Added: 4 years ago
From: teacherkoray
Views: 496,279
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (218)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hear everything these are 5.1 Surround sound headsets

  • This works great with my Creative Labs Tactic3D Sigma headset, I can heat all all sounds

  • To get Surround sound Quad or higher you need to be viewing in 480p or higher.

    1080p supports 7.1 audio

    720p supports 5.1

    480p supports 5.1

    360p and 240p are both only stereo.

  • No work, Google Chrome, MSI GX 740

  • Youtube doesn't support 5.1 period. DON'T TELL ME IT DOES.

    This test: Fail, center doesn't work, right and left surround don't work.

    Audio clip from google: Everything works.

  • @inuyasha331 Sure. New YT does support it. I tested it. Google is YT u boon ;D

  • @aelooser

    Youtube not equal to youtube.

    Someones a dumbass.

  • ye olde 240p winning :D

  • @lester2518

    YT's 240p files contain a low-bitrate 1-channel AAC audio stream. What you're hearing is 6 channels downmixed to 1 channel (assuming OP tried to upload 6 channels) then upmixed to 6 channels. I.e. you're not hearing 6 channels, you're hearing 1 channel on 6 speakers, and that's the exact same "surround" you'd hear on a single-speaker system.

  • FAIL

  • haha ha.. 360p what a fuck up

  • they could at least post a link to the original, so we could use it properly..

  • for noobs go and return her jbl sound thinking dont works :)

  • Fail

  • black men have no rights lol

  • When a surround vidoe is uploaded, youtube downmixes the audio track to 2 channels.When played on any quality on youtube, its 2 channels with various bitrates

  • im not sure of this video as a test i have had other videos work fine but on this one i only hear front R/L out of my REAR speakers and nothing else

  • LOL!  youtube works only in 2.0 XD

  • FAIL

  • ???

  • Faaail xD

    

  • epic fail...

  • this video sucks....

  • WTF HOW COME WHEN IT SAYS RIGHT I HEAR IT IN LEFT? WTF?

  • youtube is stereo only, what a stupid video...

  • I have a 7.1 surround sound headset and it dont play the surround here, fail

  • only right left for me too

  • my 5.1 speakers just say Right, Left. thats it..

  • i have 7.2 yamaha set to cinema dsp scifi, left . . . right.

  • this is a fail vid

  • it worked for me ! realy what's wrong with you guys ?

  • wheni test this on my ps3 it works for all spearks...I use my turtle beach dss and turn the surround on connected through the optical cable and all spearks sound.

  • left...right

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • doesnt work

  • yas ok and riget thes is proplem why

  • fail

  • que es lo que esta mal si no puedo escuchar todas las vocinas? ayudaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  • @manuelrada tru tarjeta de sonido

  • @6500RMP pero antes si se escuchaba, luego desconecte las vocinas o no sé que paso que ahora no se escuchan pero antes si, yo creo que algo se desconfiguró, que será

  • @SpAzMaNiK A search through youtube help makes me think only stereo's possible. It's easy to produce faux surround sound using phase shifting/delay- Dolby ProLogic does that, and maybe the vids on youtube too.

    @FR3AK250 The "p" in 720p/1080p stands for progressive. 720i/1080i are both interlaced. The number itself stands for native vertical pixel resolution. Do a google search.

  • @Norad2000x - Excellent replies dude, spot on

  • @Norad2000x we all know what the "p" stands for. Now youtube just needs to catch on.

  • if you set youtube to 240pixel and bad quality, it akually play the souround channels to,... ;)

  • @FR3AK250 "240p" aint 240 pixels. P stands for Progressive Scan.

  • @nirvanafrik nope, wrong, its like 720p hd, it means 1280x720 PIXEL, the 240p means 360x240 or sth like that ;)

  • only my rear speakers work

  • download link? 

  • isn't it only for 2 speakers? xD :D

  • lol just left and right but and no bass

  • Comment removed

  • fail

  • ok... ppl are sayin it doesn't work but it does on my ps3 LoL

  • i only heard "left" and "right" ??

  • watch?v=gBK4aDfjbRY&feature=re­lated

  • Well no 5.1 surround sound in this video, but there are a couple of athers that do have true 5.1. I think it's a Question on how to upload it, though I don't know. But it WORKS!!!!!!!!!!! just try this video out:

  • now this is pure surround only on YouTube

  • fail. youtube don't support 5.1 channel (in 240 is mono..in 360 is stereo).......do someone know if youtube HD support 5.1??

  • FAIL !

  • wtf? abusing my surround system

  • ahh, 240p doesnt give surround.... lower res, lower sound quality, probably drops to either mono or stereo.

  • FAIL! ^^

  • lol, it is working if u set it to 240p :P

  • @z1pfL that mono!

  • patut la.......mamat ni bengong

  • Too bad for you suckers, i got the Z-5500, and from using youtube, i can change the effect to " Stereo x2" so i have youtube surround sound. Suck on that.

  • now is 360p and 240p.

    Only in 360p is surround.

  • It work's because i don't hear a center, left/right surround and sub - i have 2.0 headphones. When i change to 240p it works because in mono ;)

  • lol I thought you guys were joking about the &fmt=18 in the url

  • AHHHH now it works! you have to set "&fmt=18" behind the youtube link^^

  • jajajaja that stupid

  • 360p = stereo (you hear only L/R)

    240p = mono (you hear everything, but it's NOT SURROUND)

    Fail video.

  • @Intelus now it does

  • @Intelus NO U ARE SO WRONG.. THE REASON IN 240P U HEAR EVERYTHING IS BECAUSE IN LOW QUALITY MODE... THE SOUND QUALITY IS REDUCED TO MONO as appose to HIGH QUALITY WHICH ENABLE THE SURROUND SOUND SETTINGS., THATS WHY U HEAR EVERYTHING AT ONCE.. Fail Comment

  • @shawntayys

    Let's see...

    240p flv - 64 kbps AAC, 1 ch.

    360p flv - 96 kbps AAC, 2 ch. (if you're using a typical browser with Flash, you're watching this one)

    480p flv - 128 kbps AAC, 2 ch.

    all mp4 versions (360p/720p/1080p) - 128 kbps AAC, 2 ch.

    Regarding YouTube's re-encoding - surround audio for 360p (and presumably 480p) flv versions is not downmixed (any extra channels are simply cut off), as opposed to 240p flv (mono) and mp4 (stereo) versions.

    I.e. YT = either mono or stereo, no surround.

  • @shawntayys

    *cut out (typo)

    Also, realize that posting comments in all caps saying "HAHA U FAIL LOLOLOL" without having any knowledge or understanding of the subject, or doing any research beforehand, only makes you look like an uneducated brat. Unless you're a troll, which means you've won and are having a nice laugh right now.

    Also, the game.

  • i hear all of them :)

  • you must set "&fmt=18" after the youtube link

    it works then

  • youtube does NOT support 5.1 !

    i ONLY hear left and right !

  • It was a great job with my headphones on you can actually hear the differences between the sounds and their all accurate to the sound

  • Sub fail

  • I dont hear the sub !?

  • i can hear the surround on my computer

  • if i'ts supported, it's time to update the help page youtube, you only mention aac and mp3 ? 1080p or 1080i, i i have no idea cause i am a dummy with a DSL that has the speed of Dialup, believe me! LOL !! and it's from AT&T. I don't want to share my sad story, but this surround sound seems like a great story. How nice of you to share your test video. Thanks.

     I head the left and right. STERIO.

    i gonna give LIFE... a thumbs up i think he is right.

    with respect,

    ruben from k6yar films

  • NO RIGHT SURROUND

    NO LEFT SURRROUND

  • LIFESarealally or whatever the hell your called surround does work on youtube depending on the quality HQ or not etc.. three words to you.. FACTS. RIGHT, GET YOUR, not necessarily in that order....

  • i have 5.1 and its work

  • @B0HMED because maybe u have 5.1 upscaling

  • i checked they all work and come out of the right speakers but for sum reason cant hear anythin when the sub sound comes on great work

  • i heard something from teh subwoofer in my laptop :O

  • awesoma and it works xD

  • hahshahaha...ppl are just tooo stupid to understand...MONO = 1 channel, STEREO = 2 channels, everything above 2 channels is not supported!!!!! Hence 5.1 = not supported!!!

  • OMG this is fail...

  • Sadly youtube do not support surround sound..

    Is there a way to download this?

  • @itsTheDaniel

    Yes, the software is called "Free FLV converter". I got it from download do_t com. When you install it, it will have a box to check that says, "I agree to the terms of service and want to install some gay toolbar". Just uncheck it anyways and it will install without other crap.

  • uhmBin total kuschel bedürftig aber niemand da ;(

  • FAIL -.- don't support Surround

  • you fuckin noob! even this video's audio track is not AC3, but M4A/AAC (the same as in iPods)

  • it makes a difference, listen with stereo headdphones then surround headphones trust

  • it's stereo

  • stereo!

  • I heard it perfectly in surround like it's supposed to be and not just in stereo.

  • this did used to work, ive tried it before when you could choose HD.. anyway at present, the rear speakers do work, just the front left and right also make noise when it should only be rear. :(

  • YOUTUBE DON'T SUPPORT SURROUND SOUND!!!1 lol how many people will fall for this! you will only ever get left and right (stereo) on youtube !

  • lol its works fine with my Creative soundblaster Arena surround headset..

  • YEAH...HEADSET!? lol you mean 1 speaker on your left ear and 1 speaker on your right ear (stereo)

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    lol, dillhole, a headset is a headset, i've had de G35 and now the Soundblaster arena, and i have better experience with the soundblaster so gtfo crying

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME omg you are a noob use a head set and you will see.. by the way i have steelseries siberia 7.1surround

  • @zegtasa mate, dont matter what physical device you own you ''NOOB'' YouTube only supports stereo, so you will only hear stereo (left and right) FACT! .....by the way i have steelseries siberian cock 7.1 foot long

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME No, it works for me. ragazzo is right

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME omg you are a jackass. if you are so sure about what you say why i'm listening in surround sound noob fucker ?? i know why you listen only stereo because your pc is a shit like you! buy a hd sound card fucker and dont post lies !!

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME If you choose standard quality (360p) it will be surround sound. It doesn't work with 480p.

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    IT DOES WORK!!!!!

  • @hellofyou noob

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    sure whatever YOU say

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    actually you are wrong youtube does support surrsound im usin G35 and it works

  • @dc9unknown WRONG

    what is ''surr-sound'' anyway?

  • @dc9unknown google it, or click 'about' at the bottom of Youtube then look through the handbook

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME Yes it does work surround. My G35 7.1 Headset picks up surround perfectly.

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    YES it does support it now, but a few time ago, i didn't

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    you arent right...^^ i heard in front of me and so on..^^

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    youtube supports sourround sound....

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME man there is other videos where it work man you are totally wrong man

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME that's not true add this "&fmt=18" after the youtube link and it will work with 5.1

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    Yeah, I agree, my center, back, did make any sounds.

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME not true, just watched to others that worked perfect. one with a t-rex and some halo shit.

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME Yes you can get surround sound only its called DOLBY STEREO MATRIX 4.2.4 or 4.0 MATRIX. Not DOLBY DIGITAL AC-3 5.1 LOL

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME Is that why the last one I went to did all 5.1 channels without any issues?

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME

    youtube.com/watch?v=w0eaV8r-nX­Q

    Works perfectly on 5.1 channels. So how does youtube not support this? Idiot.

  • @SpAzMaNiK No such video.

  • @LIFESaREALLYlongGAME Other tests work for me, and they work really well, but on this video i do only hear L/R speakers

  • its true tho, this test dont work properly. in every other thing i got even the sound application for my motherboard does the right and back rear surrounds on their own, on this test. it does all the speakers when it does the rear surrounds. so this test dont work properly.

  • The rear channels come on the stereo channels, so ricght rear is front right, didnt hear anything from the back speakers so sorry but FAIL

  • @123hardcoretyp

    I hear evrything

  • HQ and HD may work with AC3 but not DTS. It may work on DTS if your sound card supports it. So far my Tritton AX720 headphones with the amplified/decoder shows Dolby Digital and Dolby ProLogic II works, and I can hear it just fine, up to the subwoofer.

    HD-quality videos upload also their decoded audio formats, which has many supported formants in YouTube, but the only downside is that the audio formats support ACC encoding only, which is 2 channel stereo at 44.1 kHz.

  • FLV and AC3??? Not really or? How stupid many People are... I Cannot tell you how much...

    For every Freak on this Site: YOUTUBE AND OTHE SITE THEY BASED ON FLV DOESNT SUPPORT AC3!!!

  • HELL YEAH , IT DOES

  • Yeah...Youtube doesn't do Dolby Digital...

  • the rear speakers didnt work

  • Do you have rear speakers?

    That would explain a lot

    :P

  • it also doesn't work in normal mode :P

  • It only works out of HQ. So Don't watch in HQ.

  • but i hear it in 5.1 :D

    logitech z 5500 rlz and hp too!!!! the computer are so cool ;D

  • lol, it only works without HQ xD

  • @Psyphox

    Wow, really!! XD

  • True,Youtube fail

  • Comment removed

  • it's cuz of youtube's compression ,lol 5.1 doestn work on youtube

  • This doesn't work in HQ. Turn HQ off and it works.

  • ich hör keine subwoofer?

  • zu kurz :(

  • that sound test sucks

  • this doesnt work on my system. left and right surround are coming from left and right front.

    Wonder why the sound doesnt work right when in HQ mode though..

  • I think this video is corrupted...

    only 1 or 2 channels, but sure not 5.1

  • gay test

  • Love this test.

  • You have to turn off HQ for this to work.

  • its work haha funny

  • HQ = mono.

    NOT HQ = SURROUND.

  • THANK YOU

    I THOUGHT MY HEADSET BROKE

  • TYVM!

    Well, I thought I have a PERFECT dts desktop system (xonar + z5500). But in this test my rears aren't producing any sound at all..

    Wai? =/

    /djNio

  • Comment removed

  • @erwile ok sorry. at the time i wrote this, youtube didn't have hd 1080/780 yet. they were still using HQ.

  • @erwile 8 months ago when I wrote that comment, i put it on HQ and it WAS mono. when i took it off, it was stereo. things may have changed since then.

  • @erwile 720p not 780p

  • holy shit it worked!

  • epic fail~~ haha

  • Now that YouTube supports HD picture. The next level is YouTube videos supporting 5.1, 6.1, and 7.1 surround sound channels.

  • I agree!

  • YOU TUBE DOES NOT SUPPORT SURROUND SOUND!

    it only has 2.1ch

  • If u guys dont watch this in HD then the sound wont come just from the center.