@xBillyTheKidx no swells in the first verse, not fuzz chords in the second....seems like he just had some gear problems now that i watch it again though
@farizzal yeah now that you mention it i heard that difference. it sounded just as amazing though. however, i think that happened when i saw them live doing this in '08 or 09.
@farizzal yeah they did a lot of things differently on the basement recording. i'm guessing they did that because it's a dvd and it's professional and herp derp
Oooh I like the guitars! I wish they would've done that on their tour because when I saw them in Cuyahoga the piano part felt a bit flat. But that was the only bad part of the night. It was a mind-blowing show.
yea i like both but the guitar does sound really good on the build up...but if radiohead picked the other version to go on the album then it must have fit better
i dont have a favourite song on in rainbows, but this comes close i just think its absolutely breathtaking and isnt really talked about as one of the outstanding songs on the album, but i think it deserves to be.
The appreciation of many things is subjective, especially art. If the subject can be measured against established criteria, then it becomes ability, but art-....
So many very creative people have offered their work only to be met with unappreciative audiences. Though some may not "get it", others may feel Radiohead are unique & reveal a certain ingenuity & outstanding originality, they will probably not die as paupers.
Radiohead, along with other underappreciated artists, intrigues me.
Well Radiohead are easily the most groundbreaking band of 2000's. They should be three times as popular as they are and you know a good band when 2 of their albums are already considered in the top 500 of all time(rolling Stone mag). Bands asked if they can open for Radiohead turn it down and no wonder. Awesome songs, Radiohead will be remembered by future generations.
do you know similar noise things like this? because I really like it... also, please would you reply this msg with any of your 10x better bands than radiohead?.. give me one nameat least, please!!. thanks!
Can you see how unique they are? can you see the way they write their music is unique beyond an average song writer? as a musician and a thirsty average person seeking good music with experience of song writing for 4 years, I believe they are marked the best for their genuine talent and their excellent talent to compose such beautiful noise that is called music.
Every song they make, expresses how they feel no one will ever describe in words. Even i cant describe this beautiful band!
this is shit what you say! sure it's subjective which music-style you prefer, but there are not many bands out there which are better than radiohead. that's fact!!!
In some ways, you can say that. Some bands might be better than Radiohead in certain extend.
BUT, on the whole, music includes many things: CREATIVITY, skills , style of playing, the mood it delivered, the deeper meaning of it, the INSIGHTS it brings to people, the influences of it, and many more.
When we added up all these, Radiohead is still among the best bands.
Best band alive today hands down, most talented and original. Bands dream of being half of what Radiohead is and unfortunately in a world dominated by watered down pop it will never happen. Radiohead is all we have.
j ai d abord vu cette chanson au rock en seine en 2006, j atends maintenant de la découvrir a paris et arras en live en 2008! merci pour cette superbe chanson, version certe dépouillée mais quelle belle chanson...frissonnante
Did anybody else think the first time they heard this song, that the out-tro, was Thom saying...
"the sunn....the sunnnn...the sunnn....the sunnnnnnnnnnnn!!!"
with the night-imagery, and the "in rainbows" title, it seemed oddly to fit...especially how it sounds hopeful, after a long darkness...like the sun breaking through after the rain....in rainbows ;)
i didn't really think all of that as I have h eintelligence of a gnat, but YES. The Suuunnn, yeh :P, he says it's all right, it's all wrong apparently. I still sing The Sunnnn though :L
i wonder why always choose UK,Us,France or similar countries to prepare such kind of good and strange concerts..and wonder why they never think to visit Turkey despite they have a lot of fans here..well somethings reminds me kinda "God Loves His Children??!!??..Applauds go to Radiohead who let to please Colonist Countries children..Yeah,however They are god's children....What a great Pity!!!
Thom Yorke is one of the best vocalist to step on stage.His voice sends electrifying shocks straight to the soul. I wish I was the pen to his paper!!!
who the hell is singing inn the crowd, shutup
expectationlost 1 month ago in playlist Radiohead Live at 93 Feet East (16 January 2008)
wtf!can't believe they've already played it in 1993.but still one of my favorite songs
MrRadioheadache 3 months ago
@MrRadioheadache This was played in 2008...
SionShel 3 months ago
@SionShel then i check it again and found out it was in 2008,my mistake ,93 Feet East is a bar :)
MrRadioheadache 3 months ago
3:12 what the hell chord is that?
xBillyTheKidx 7 months ago
wow Ed really fucked up this one
farizzal 9 months ago
@farizzal how do you figure?
xBillyTheKidx 7 months ago
@xBillyTheKidx no swells in the first verse, not fuzz chords in the second....seems like he just had some gear problems now that i watch it again though
farizzal 7 months ago
@farizzal yeah now that you mention it i heard that difference. it sounded just as amazing though. however, i think that happened when i saw them live doing this in '08 or 09.
xBillyTheKidx 7 months ago
@xBillyTheKidx well i am comparing it to the basement recording so maybe they changed it
farizzal 7 months ago
@farizzal yeah they did a lot of things differently on the basement recording. i'm guessing they did that because it's a dvd and it's professional and herp derp
xBillyTheKidx 7 months ago
Radiohead has set the standard that musicians can only dream of reaching. Unfair but I'm grateful to have experienced their music.
Linknard 1 year ago
My face would melt and I'd hump the nearest leg in front of me if I heard this live. I fucking LOVE this goddamn song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ArseneWengerIsGod 1 year ago
radiohead is all i need
manuelgui15 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
how was this filmed? static webcams? I'd like to know the method. It was streamed live too. Anyone shed any light on the technique?
misterhazz 2 years ago
Oooh I like the guitars! I wish they would've done that on their tour because when I saw them in Cuyahoga the piano part felt a bit flat. But that was the only bad part of the night. It was a mind-blowing show.
tobiusfunke 2 years ago 3
Fricking awesome.
Harv3y8irdman 2 years ago
number 1 band in the WORLD
infact, in my eyes number 1 band EVER
MrCockbreath 2 years ago 12
haunting
0879186480 2 years ago
great bass here... really the drive of the song
2dtesseract 2 years ago 6
i think that's the backbone of this song
jallstars 2 years ago
one of the finest songs of all time
wrongstring 2 years ago 12
yea i like both but the guitar does sound really good on the build up...but if radiohead picked the other version to go on the album then it must have fit better
bluxx123 3 years ago
I like the camerawork for concert; very simple and intimate
shutteredmemory 3 years ago
Anybody have the chords played by Thom at the end?
I love this version because I hate the way Thom changed the vocal melody on the album. "Ly-in in the re-eeds" just sounds so bad.
Mambuto 3 years ago
I like both.
MELADORABAND 3 years ago
seeing them in montreal as well
gijzer 3 years ago
I was at Montreal :D IT WAS AWSOME
Mygalej 3 years ago
this has become one of my favourite songs ever, probably my favourite 'slow' song at least
kevin2671 3 years ago 4
Incredible song.
vimaxreview 3 years ago 2
i loved this song!!!!
peace all!!
CamiloMalakian22 3 years ago
im seeing them in montreal in august i am soo excited
briandizzav 3 years ago
best live version of the song...thom´s guitar sounds great when he sings "it´s all right..."...hope the next versions would have guitar on that part!
EdinhoU2 3 years ago
5 stars + 1 star
Zaoris 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
-FREEFOOTFETISH (DOT) NET
.
retard..
tinkerreg 3 years ago
I do fuckin' love this song....
jkpj22 3 years ago 2
As do I. It's the track that really stuck out on In Rainbows, and it's become one of my favourite Radiohead tunes.
toofargone06 3 years ago
oh no piano ending =(
darklord8603 3 years ago
it's true but it's my favorite version still
paranoidArnold 3 years ago
i dont think ill ever get sick of this song.
earman11 3 years ago 6
i dont have a favourite song on in rainbows, but this comes close i just think its absolutely breathtaking and isnt really talked about as one of the outstanding songs on the album, but i think it deserves to be.
felcho 3 years ago 5
The appreciation of many things is subjective, especially art. If the subject can be measured against established criteria, then it becomes ability, but art-....
So many very creative people have offered their work only to be met with unappreciative audiences. Though some may not "get it", others may feel Radiohead are unique & reveal a certain ingenuity & outstanding originality, they will probably not die as paupers.
Radiohead, along with other underappreciated artists, intrigues me.
treed51 3 years ago 17
i applaud thee
hilarioushippo 3 years ago
*Applause* for you.
Indiechristian 3 years ago
Geilo THOM !
meskalitoLen 3 years ago
Radiohead's music is a portal that allows the soul of my heart to burst free
11Conquest11 3 years ago 6
T H O M M O T H
katchthemouse 3 years ago 3
Well Radiohead are easily the most groundbreaking band of 2000's. They should be three times as popular as they are and you know a good band when 2 of their albums are already considered in the top 500 of all time(rolling Stone mag). Bands asked if they can open for Radiohead turn it down and no wonder. Awesome songs, Radiohead will be remembered by future generations.
SamTetro 3 years ago 3
This stripped live version sounds even better than it's counterpart.
CerebrateHyatt 3 years ago
why you all people just dont close your mouth and appreciate music...
xluisleex 4 years ago 8
i love this noise don't get me wrong!
DaftVador 4 years ago
do you know similar noise things like this? because I really like it... also, please would you reply this msg with any of your 10x better bands than radiohead?.. give me one nameat least, please!!. thanks!
paranoidArnold 3 years ago
People like me look to the future,while i see the worshipping morons(here)
And i can say there is 10x radioheads sitting in there heads
DaftVador 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
anyband can be 10x better than radiohead FACT ,
PEOPLE NEED TO RELAX
DaftVador 4 years ago
they aren't though, so what you just said is stupid.
billyhigdon 4 years ago
Can you see how unique they are? can you see the way they write their music is unique beyond an average song writer? as a musician and a thirsty average person seeking good music with experience of song writing for 4 years, I believe they are marked the best for their genuine talent and their excellent talent to compose such beautiful noise that is called music.
Every song they make, expresses how they feel no one will ever describe in words. Even i cant describe this beautiful band!
Indiechristian 3 years ago 27
settle down i can see your woody from here
friedskillet 3 years ago
if you dont get wood from this then fuck off
thejugglenaut91 3 years ago
to friedskillet btw
thejugglenaut91 3 years ago
i always have wood ;)
ThePatientLeech 3 years ago 2
this is shit what you say! sure it's subjective which music-style you prefer, but there are not many bands out there which are better than radiohead. that's fact!!!
TrickundTronic 4 years ago
In some ways, you can say that. Some bands might be better than Radiohead in certain extend.
BUT, on the whole, music includes many things: CREATIVITY, skills , style of playing, the mood it delivered, the deeper meaning of it, the INSIGHTS it brings to people, the influences of it, and many more.
When we added up all these, Radiohead is still among the best bands.
thyy 3 years ago 3
Best band alive today hands down, most talented and original. Bands dream of being half of what Radiohead is and unfortunately in a world dominated by watered down pop it will never happen. Radiohead is all we have.
stevenblades 4 years ago 37
@stevenblades Radiohead is all I need. ... Get it?
shitzkies 1 year ago
@stevenblades hey i couldnt have said it better myself.
JoshEnd44 10 months ago
@stevenblades hey i couldnt have said it better myself.
JoshEnd44 10 months ago
this song made me cry
Nyiii 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
get a life
scruffz 3 years ago
Stellar. Does anyone know where I can get an MP3 or any kind of DL for this gig?
(See you in Dublin thom!!!)
hodiaudirekt 4 years ago
(L)
juuzao 4 years ago
allucinazioni
tellipofe 4 years ago
COME TO MEXICO GUYSSSS
darklord8603 4 years ago
j ai d abord vu cette chanson au rock en seine en 2006, j atends maintenant de la découvrir a paris et arras en live en 2008! merci pour cette superbe chanson, version certe dépouillée mais quelle belle chanson...frissonnante
olivierolek 4 years ago
questa è una delle canzoni più belle che abbia sentito in sti anni...radiohaed..magnifici
zaia89 4 years ago
i first heard this in Edinburgh 2006, but this new live translation is absoutely amazing!!
TheMember06 4 years ago
What does everyone think of the B-Sides off this record? Flowers...some of their best stuff.
RogerMexicoMusic 4 years ago
Actualy Flowers was recorded just by Thom on the Eraser sessions. Great song anyway!
q1w2e3r5t8y 4 years ago
I love the B-sides of In Rainbows!!! It blew me away how good they all were. My favorites are "Down is the new up" and "Last Flowers"
ryan7908 4 years ago 4
Did anybody else think the first time they heard this song, that the out-tro, was Thom saying...
"the sunn....the sunnnn...the sunnn....the sunnnnnnnnnnnn!!!"
with the night-imagery, and the "in rainbows" title, it seemed oddly to fit...especially how it sounds hopeful, after a long darkness...like the sun breaking through after the rain....in rainbows ;)
...just a thought.
slitheringinterstate 4 years ago
i didn't really think all of that as I have h eintelligence of a gnat, but YES. The Suuunnn, yeh :P, he says it's all right, it's all wrong apparently. I still sing The Sunnnn though :L
elliotnicklin 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wonder why always choose UK,Us,France or similar countries to prepare such kind of good and strange concerts..and wonder why they never think to visit Turkey despite they have a lot of fans here..well somethings reminds me kinda "God Loves His Children??!!??..Applauds go to Radiohead who let to please Colonist Countries children..Yeah,however They are god's children....What a great Pity!!!
andrdprnd 4 years ago
you mis-informed fool.colonists children?
dMoniker 4 years ago
Lacks without the piano still good but hope they return to the piano for the live shows in the summer
mevil314 4 years ago
well i imagine it was supposed to be such a small place they couldnt really take a piano with them.
tom12345674 4 years ago
Thom Yorke is one of the best vocalist to step on stage.His voice sends electrifying shocks straight to the soul. I wish I was the pen to his paper!!!
kat197808 4 years ago 6
oh cmon.. i love radiohead as much as the next person, but he's not the greatest live vocalist.
i know its just a matter of opinion, but cmon.. stop with the hyperbole.
lickmyballsforjesus 4 years ago
OK HES NOT THE BEST
HES THE BESTEST!!
radioheadyorke 4 years ago 4
radiohead go beyond just liking a song - whole albums are like one giant awesome song...in rainbows is the same
Karmasoutar 4 years ago 7
See you in Berlin !!
ernacx 4 years ago
the best song no doubt in rainbow.
polyclix 4 years ago 3
This album is so great that could have several best songs.
TheRockandroy 4 years ago 6
Where is 93 Feet East and why wasn't I there?
plmooney 4 years ago 3
London. And it was announced ON THE DAY of the event. No-one was exactly prepared for it.
FlyBird 4 years ago
Haha Radiohead seem to like surprises, huh? First they announced out of the blue In Rainbows 10 days before it was released, now this.
IJUSTWANNACDVID 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
nah don't go to mexico.
darkgaia911 4 years ago
yeah come to mexico
radioheadyorke 4 years ago 4
Hey, here there's people who like this band enough to deserve it.
TheRockandroy 4 years ago
come to peru
mavmusick 4 years ago
come to mexico first haha... bueno cuando sea pero q vengan, no?
NNJ007 4 years ago 3
Powerful
austinguru713 4 years ago 2
thank you for your music
squeepy 4 years ago 3
Wow, I like this version much better.
Cuoin 4 years ago 4
this is one of my in rainbows-favourites
einarstraymusic 4 years ago 3
its hard to say witch one is none a in rainbows-favourites
radioheadyorke 4 years ago
it is hard to say...they are all good.. its to early to say i think
simon1975 4 years ago
hey, eeiciap, i love ya! thanks for posting this vids..amazing! i'm dreamin'...
BettyTossicaApatica 4 years ago 2
"It's all wrong
It's all right
It's all wrong"
Just like in the real life!
Please share your magic with us, come to Mexico, Radiohead boys.
bonovoxmofo 4 years ago 8
i'm agree with you!
PLEASE, COOOME TO MEXICO
and this version is totally great everytime i hear it i'm about to cry
asura13mindoff 4 years ago
Yea, I have a tough time deciding which song is better: this or Nude... They're both awesome. Wait, maybe 3:22 just decided for me.
TomMix1940 4 years ago
by far best song on album and great fun to play on my synth as well
mrcat1990 4 years ago
Live version of the song is usually with a Piano since it first debuted in 2006. No room on that stage for a baby grand.
kwizzeh 4 years ago
it changed after the webcasts.this is how they play it now....and its fucking great.
cheers.
servo1056 4 years ago
nononono why do hey do thatttt :( :( with piano sounds more powerfulll
darklord8603 4 years ago
je prefere largement le final a la gratte ici.
parceque la fin de celle-ci sur le cd me file des boutons...
guccilitlepiggy 4 years ago
Best song ever.
psychomode14 4 years ago 5
Yep.
dMoniker 4 years ago
is dat really from the 90s?
he does look like him now
thought he would look clean and younger at dat time.
doesn't matter anyway...great song!
mymode80 4 years ago
no, it was performed yesterday, 16 jan 2008 :D
the place is called 93 feet east
theantinator 4 years ago
Thanks a lot man!
I was kind of puzzled...93?
hehehe
mymode80 4 years ago
sick
jackbruce992 4 years ago
awesoem
LfunkeyA 4 years ago
Best version !
they save the song :)
Belgarath314 4 years ago
Thom should totally play a piano in that heavy bit at the end instead of his guitar, it would sound so much better.
telecasterthommy 4 years ago 2
They only brought one keyboard and Jonny's playing it... Thom plays piano in the Scotch Mist Version.
I think it's cool to hear it played this way.
patrunk 4 years ago 4
they must've sold their souls to the devil to play that good- like Tommy in "Oh Brother..."
consume33 4 years ago
Sigur Rös!!
oh, waith...
aztlanmazeton 4 years ago
Haha yeah, that keyboard at the beginning sounds like the second untitled track on Sigur Ros' ( ) album doesn't it
telecasterthommy 4 years ago 2
hahahaha I noticed it too!!!! the very beginning, just like that Sigur Rós song!
yorkism 4 years ago
thank u thank u thank u.. my fav song
willrich13 4 years ago 2
yes, the little part is so so so ...undescribeable?
it reminds me really much of This Will Destroy You's Quit, the live performance that comes up here on youtube..
how i'd fawking whish radiohead'd do something instrumental!!!!
regndrab 4 years ago
the little part at the start of the live version(and scotch mist one) is AMAZING
antithesis02 4 years ago
Best performance yet.... ;)
JonnysGroopie 4 years ago 2
I love the organplaying in this one... and the cylophone (or what you call it) at the same time... very impressive still :)Wonderman!
HeleneRT 4 years ago
glockenspiel in this case, you were thinking of a xylophone
glockenspiel is metal
xylophone is wood
:)
likespinningcreeps 4 years ago
ahhh... of course :) I know... just forgot what it was called :) thanks :) glocken glocken ;)
HeleneRT 3 years ago
Beautiful. Amazing. love it.
talkinglife 4 years ago