Kasey Butler - Beautiful Goodbye

[shinee140]

fx is better than this but all beautiful :) <3

alot of feelings :(

[OkuteZz]

even i listen to this song..Luna and Krystal's voice appears in my mind >"< ♥

[SapphirescentAngel]

Maybe the reason why I like the original version better is because I heard it first. I've been in love with this song since 2009.

[snsdislove12]

this version is good but i think it sounds better in korean. it might jus be cause i''m so used to the korean version x)

[mischun]

@hxarts DL link please

[lizjane09]

I like the song all in all. Lyrics and music are just so good. But I gotta say I like f(x)'s version cause of the variety of voices. No offense to the one singing this. Five different voices against one gives a different outcome to the song. I'm an f(x) fan, and I'm with the other fans about SM getting their own songs.

[PukiTaz4ever]

Wowwwwww! I so love the lyrics of this song! so deep U.u!

sorry, i have to say it.. I like both versions but f(x)'s ver a bit more cause of their voices ^^!

[tarany3sal]

actually i prefer this version

but the voices f(x) are better

[tarany3sal]

im here cuz f(x)

so nice

[chinleeradcliffe]

I like both versions.. But I like F(x) voices more.. 

[krush4live1]

i like both versions. thanks for uploading this :)

[bbyjlynn]

the comments on this have been quite entertaining to read. i uploaded this two years ago and for the record, i can't even find the mp3 anywhere anymore. not even iTunes! poor kasey. anyway, i like f(x)'s version too. BOTH have their strengths. the song is still generally the same, no reason to hate on either version. :)

[annabellovekpop]

Can't all of you guys just don't always talk about fx here

say something about this song by kasey alright??

u guys are disrespecting the uploader here who love this song so much and all of you only talk about fx..

[xelix666]

dunno why~ but i love this version~ she sang it sweetly :D

[xoxoassy]

I like this version more because I can understand it.

[destined2bebossy]

most of the comments are on f(x) but non of the side links are lol

[destined2bebossy]

f(x) brought me here

I like the fact that its english but vocally-wise f(x) version is better.!!!

[binkendy]

I love this version. ;)

[benniuz]

f(x) version is wayyyyy better than this honestly

[nemseicu]

I love f(x), but this is waaay better than f(x)'s version.

[AsianBabbii0209]

kpop brought me hereeee :L

[iFATEx3]

lol, imagine those people who doesnt know who f(x) is or kpop will have no idea what are we talking about ;D

[Binh60]

híc f(x) coppy , shit !

[phamlecuchuong]

@Binh60 she didn't copy f(x). This song is still beautiful as it is.

[iwansciffer]

This the last three video I watched , all the top comments are all about f(x) , SM and Netizens . These videos can reach 1K viewers if this continue ,

SUPPORTS f(x) !

[kpopftw14]

SM ENTERTAINMENT! Y U NO MAKE UR OWN SONGS?

[SapphirescentAngel]

@kpopftw14 Prolly cause their lyricists/composers aren't as good as the other companies'

[kpopftw14]

@SapphirescentAngel yeea. apparently they're not as good as YGE's or JYPE's. but the songs composed originally by SM isn't really that bad. but the songs from other companies are just much better :)

[MrChutado]

F(x) ver is more strong but this song still has the unique special of it :D So both ver is well :d

[shiningjojo1103]

awww ;~~;

[6boomberry]

OMG! poor fx :((((((

why does SM have to use old songs for fx?

they're so mean :(((

still support fx :x

[foolishyounglady]

lol i prefer f(x)'s version.. because their voices are uniqe :3 but well this verison is good too :)

[shandrew1000]

poor f(x) SMENT said if it's f(x) it have to be special but why ?? SM is over biased to SNSD !! ~

[soyabeangrrl]

@anaHajar lol So Into You sounds really familiar too. Reminds me of a kiddy song, don't ask me why.. I'm sure SM bought the rights to all the songs that are "copied" so it's not really plagiarized..

[regiusheaven]

要谢谢SM 让我知道了不少好歌lol

[a18angel]

Wow, I played both songs simultaneously, even the second voices are so identical, though both are good. Atleast it's legally bought, not exactly stolen for it to be called plagiarism.

[yanna485]

its ok if sme legally adapted the song.. but.. i so love kasey's version, not that i'am comparing their voices and whats original.. maybe because of the lyrics, the story was more understandable.

[driftgal1029]

This is good as well, since I'm not Korean, I can sing this one while listening to f(x)'s version..

[driftgal1029]

woah!!! February 2008...

this mean the song was released way back before f(x) released Pinocchio???

awww...i feel sorry for f(x)...

SMent explaination please??

[starberry1000]

@driftgal1029 Theey brought the rights to the song, but changed the lyrics. :)

[koovah]

this song is from 2008? i feel bad for f(x)

[loogiak]

it's no body's fault, just SM remakes the song into Korean, just like HK remake Japanese songs into Cantonese, Taiwan remakes HK songs into Chinese ... lol

[loveemussic241]

I love both versions! It's so good. 

[NinkaPanda]

hey they brought their songs. Miley Cyrus brought her song from Jessie J and Bruno Mars sold his Fk You song to ceelo green.

How is this anyone's fault?

[Sujunarutofan]

Wow! It's exactly da same as f(x)'s version! Juz in english... I dun blame f(x), they actually promote tis song! It's nice! I luv both version! <3

[ngokhanhtuyen]

This song has been re-directed Korean group -> f(x)

the link to test

[ngokhanhtuyen]

@ngokhanhtuyen addres : search : beautiful goodbye f(X)

[purple4dc]

i like this version more because i can actually sing-a-long to it and understand it

[anaHajar]

FUCK SMent.

Bye f(x)

Bye Amber =.= unfortunately, my goodbye's ain't a beautiful one.

[dnsueee]

no wonder they dont promote this song. instead they promote gangsta boy. i think gangsta boy is the ori one :P

[lalalosad]

i love this song!!!

and sm please stop buying all this amazing songs!! let the original artist shine!

[soyabeangrrl]

I KNEW I head this somewhere when I was listening to the f(x) version. :D

[anaHajar]

@soyabeangrrl me too O.O i felt like I've listened to it before.

I wonder if so into you's plagiarized too. CUz I know I heard it somewhere.

[44Asuka]

I like f(x)'s version but the original is better :D

[03livingthelife23]

lmao, i love how this is becoming more known because of the allkpop article (:

but i really like this song, good thing i heard of it!

[JessyJessie288]

I knew that I've seen her somewhere!!!

[MegaCandygirl29]

LOL i'm here because of allkpop. now i like more this version....

[azngirl109]

MP3 PLEASEEEEEEEEEEE~

[aniskurma]

i'm here because of f(x) and i don't care~

[sedienta94]

This is a beautiful song, i can see why SM took it.

I tend to really like the orig versions of SMEnt songs. But my gosh SM ENTERTAINMENT please get some original songs for ur artist too XD

[melloe]

hmm her voice sounds like britney spears

[lovejump48]

the song was good, prefer this version more than f(x)'s <3

[Kouchan69]

mm... I like f(x')'s version better :/ don't like this girl's voice

props for her anyway

[ainindulgent]

i like this song better than f(x) version , it just my opinion ,

[ninipops2]

shit. 3 songs out of the 4 songs that i actually like from f(x)'s album arent even original....even though i like their versions better but not gonna lie. im a little disappointed :(

[cCmuimui]

her voice is a bit lik Britney spears 

[RUiiKE]

this is so much better than f(x) version, the emotion and voice... luna still has a long way to go before she can start putting out songs like this. SM should have given the girls a different song.

[hoabinh1992]

i cant believe i am saying this but i actually prefer this over F(x) ver......

[BubbleGum11100]

You should have put Beautiful Goodbye- f(x) (English cover)by Kasey Butler seriously ! People won't know this is a cover and they're never know the original one sang by f(x) !

[jimenoir]

@BubbleGum11100 actually it's the other way around. This was published on 2008, f(x)'s version is not the original, is the cover. They must have bought the rights.

[digiworld1989]

@BubbleGum11100 Feb 8, 2008 learn to read

[arriere100]

@BubbleGum11100 this is not a cover can't u see feb 2008 fx release their album april 2011

[boobzy]

@BubbleGum11100 HUH???? Please read the description date!

[MizJuNee]

her voice is a bit too squeaky but the song is really good. :)

[lupemoon89]

f(x) brought me here, and i think i prefer this version o.0 ... So sweet ~ ♥

[caltesss]

is the korean ver. a direct translation of this.

[Ashleystitch]

English version VS Korean version~~hummm... i prefer fx ~ much more like a little girl telling her first love~~ and amber at the beginning That amazing to make this song better than this~~ and chorus with five members juz great and sound sweet and harmony

[theMilkz]

argh. another helium singer. fail.

[daboob7vanilla]

i can not understand why a lot of people prefer this version and think that is better if f(x) singing much better and is very charm and amazing to listenning 5 such a great voices in one song which singing about greet feelings.

i don't mind and i really think that this version is cool too, but not better.

[JeSsWoNn]

@daboob7vanilla everyone has different opinons- it's not that hard to understand, is it?

[VIPBJ21]

This song is better than f(x)'s remake.

[nweye]

omg i knew this song like how many years ago lol, kpop is a bit slow, at least its getting recognition now lol

[prettyadriel]

i wonder which unpopular song will be bought and re-released in korean by SM Ent. artists.....:)

[TheHoneybells]

NETIZENS BROUGHT ME HERE :P

[03livingthelife23]

@TheHoneybells i was brought here by allkpop (:

[TheHoneybells]

@03livingthelife23 but it was the netizens who brought it to akp. haha! F*ck smart netizens. :P

[oceana13579]

this sounds better than f(x)'s version, i think. it's because english suits with the melody better than korean, i guess.

anyways nice song

[sang12evol]

f(x) brought me here.. haha.. LOL

[GlennTouT]

.that is why SM bought the songs!!

.it's good but not a lot of people know her..

.

[kpopftw14]

thanks to f(x), i have found my new favorite song. xD

[amtc09]

OMG! i just listened to it and i tell you whoever you are (HAHA) that YOU'RE GREAT! the song is great so yea! i love this version and i love the Korean version too :)

nice job for SMEnt. they got this melody. but how i wish they just bought the LYRICS too and let Krystal and Amber sing the song in ENGLISH. lol

[noname2163]

this is pretty good too... im a f(x) fan :)

[sakurarockz08]

C'mon guys? Would you actually think that they would release Beautiful Goodbye if it was downright plagiarism? Think Guys! Think! SME is a big big company, I'm sure they bought this. Btw, f(x)'s voices are better. Good lyrics.

[89taylorswiftlover]

Did you know that f(x) made a cover of this song?

[oceana13579]

@89taylorswiftlover cover? hehehe lol cover cover

[89taylorswiftlover]

@oceana13579 yep a cover.

[kai200731]

LOL YEAHH ANF THIS SONG FIXXX THEIR VOICES F(X) FIGTHINGTT

[gianneism]

f(x) daebak!! I like this too..:) good cover..

[TheNameDoesntFi]

great song, f(x)'s cover was just as good. :>

[opalstar567]

i like the lyrics of this vers, but like f(x)'s voices better

[loveshatori]

does anyone have jamie's version?

[K4RAM1LIA]

Why you Korean / F(x) fans come here and talk about how they like their version better?! If you prefer their version than good but yes, it's the same song as Kasey's version so their both good T_T

[amtc09]

@K4RAM1LIA OMG. ur right! im a BIG FAN of f(X) but i love this version more. LOL. shhh! HAHA!

[Christine16292]

I KNEW I'd heard this song before when I listened to it on f(x)'s album. I like both versions

[Xis10tialist]

I like these English lyrics, and I have to say Butler is a good singer, but I prefer f(x)'s voices to hers. No hard feelings :)

[ukownyunhofan]

I like f(x) 's version better.

[MsCrazyAddiction]

Awesome.



[2010memorie1]

i have listen to this song everyday since my boyfriend broke up with me i just missed him so much and like the song say i nothing would tear us apart thats what i thougt

[trukrypto17]

Been Over 2 Years Since I Heard This Awesome Track...I Always Hoped She'd Get A Record Deal But I Heard She Gave Up On It? Sucks.....

[sweethearts82397]

just leave me with a beautiful gooodbye...*

[209hmonggirl]

:(

wtf, theres a tear in my eyes...

[xOXkat1991XOx]

goes any one know where you can get the instrumental :/ <3 

[chilaandlaly]

this song rememberz meh bout just mizz him soo much

[lonnalisius]

i love these song <3

[nweye]

this song is absolutely gorgeous.

[ana2sola]

i want this song where can i find it i want to download it ,,can some1 help me ?

[adaspolakk]

@ana2sola If you like. I can convert the song for you into mp3, i can even show you how so you could do it yourself. Message me on youtube and ill help you out : )

[ana2sola]

@adaspolakk ,,Thanks it would be great sorry i replied late ,,,yes i want that song could you help me and tell me where could i download it and how could i download it ,,,:)

[butterfly1289]

Do you think you could send this song to me?

[miki21795]

10.23.2009,Chris I freaking love you so much and i'm sorry for everything just please come back:(1.25.2010

[XXimnosupermanXX]

can you send this song to me? because i've been trying to download it everywhere but it never lets me.

[ThePavlii]

The text is very good and the music too:))

[crystalmajerski]

love the song great video 2 gurl

[lolasalsa13]

thisz song isz the best

[nbabiggestfan12]

gooood song.

well actually it doesn't even sound like cassie

so idky people mistake it for her

[lagunabeach90]

this is a beautiful song i LUV IT ALL THE WAY! = ]

[82mrkndyt]

if ur reading this and bored

i want some sexy subscribers! 6J

[sephir298]

This song was originally offered to Jamie from Sweetbox (the demo was put on the Sweetbox website) but obviously wasn't used in the end. I prefered Jamie's version, personally. Beautiful song, though and Kasey does it well.

[Daydreamersz]

Beautiful song !

x

[IIIfalling4uIII]

kasey butler has like a pretty voice but its sad cause not alot people kno about her

[nbabiggestfan12]

i know, there are so many people like that.

they just never have the chance of fame.

i wish i could bring them to fame...

[vivianwhee]

@IIIfalling4uIII now everyone knows her because of f(x) similar song =p

[RomellleXFuture]

hey can u upload this song this zshare n give me the link plz

[rafaelbh25]

Her voice is like the Britney's voice!!!!

[jimmyvibes]

... and she loves the vocoder a bit too much lol. Why not just have her natural voice???

[sadie0814]

yeah you really gotta listen to the songto understand it aha but yeah i love this song though...!!!!!

[hottidolli10]

I love this song...it brings so many feelings

[bbyjlynn]

i know kasey butler sings it.. i am not sure who the songwriter is though.. sorry

[pilfwest]

great song I give it 10+