Porcelain Black ft. Ashley Tisdale - How Do You Love Someone

[ItisCocoBitch]

Hearing porcelain black's voice under ashley's voice is like hearing gaga's voice under britney's voice in QUICKSAND.. .-.

[0oVISUALKEIo0]

this song matches with my life :O

[MsMalevolent]

I can't even hear Ashley's voice above Alaina's lol. and RealmOfChaosAndNight, I reckon the girls in tatu have way better voices than Ashley...didn't she almost not get to be in HSM cos her voice is so weak?

[TheShellycat]

awesome 

[RealmOfChaosAndNight]

the parts sung by Ashley sound like some tatu song methinks. can't wait for the full PB version to come out!

[kissmmysass123]

@AlexXChaoss it isn't. Porcelain wrote and recorded it. Ashley put her version on the album.

[mommybevelyn]

it sounds amazing ashley tisdale and porcelain black have really outdone theirselves.but it needs more work a little

[jjgjjjgjjjgjjgjjg]

honestly i wish Porcelain's verison actually featured Ashley. I think the contrast in the voices sounds good. just use less editing on Ashley's voice. it doesn't sound too natural.. otherwise it'd be amazing. :)

[ShesSoSinister]

Lyric wise, and beat, I love.. but I want to hear just Porcelain sing it :/

[7StarsFromTheMoOn]

ashley tisdale is Hoxxx

[AlexXChaoss]

FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE It's Ashley Tisdale -.-

[FamEMonsTARRR]

Ashley Tisdale? :o

[hould13]

Look de monica naranjo

[XxXBennoXxX]

Is this a real song?

[ppanic99]

@XxXBennoXxX yupp :D its going to be released on Porcelain Black's new record but only PB is going to be singing. She originally wrote this song for Tisdale.

[Hejduderkompis]

@ppanic99 You did forget Eminem !!

[TheSicotik1]

If anyone can make and instrumental for this with a good quality and keep the bridge and hook that would be awesome!!!!!

[SuperChuckylover]

story of meh life </3

[SuperFabLust]

Honestly this version isn't horrid. Ashley sung it in her way.... I'd obviously prefer Porcelain singing the song it'd have more emotion in it I'm sure.

[sweetbloodist]

wait...i'm confused a bit...i love this song; but who really sang it? i can't tell the difference now between alaina and ashley...meow

[XXAwesomenessXX237]

@sweetbloodist uhh porcelain black wrote it but ashley just sang it in another way but everyone is freaking out about it....

[KroKKaulitz]

Ashley Tisdale with Porcelain Black? :O OMG, somehow it works. I love this song!

[wirefood]

This is THE BEST!!!!!!!!!

[Handymancinema]

This song: ashley

written by: alaina

Soon: alaina and marshal

[AngelFallenXx]

@Handymancinema

When is the one with her and eminem gonna be released?

[Handymancinema]

@AngelFallenXx frankly enough, I have no idea. A lot of her work has been delayed, and with the touring she didn't have much time to record songs. The album was supposed to be released summer/fall 2011 as you might know, and currently there's no new date for the album. All we know is that she wants more songs for the album, and our opinion on what to do with the old stuff (patt) after she recorded the new ones. We have no idea when the song will be released, you can check fb and twit for updates

[AngelFallenXx]

@Handymancinema

Thanks! Im really excited for the song to come out. :)

[kiplingBlue]

What is she doing with Ashley?! I <3 both but they dont match...

[Handymancinema]

@kiplingBlue nothing, absolutely nothing.

[Aphroditte7]

The initial beat is stolen from the song ''Scream'' by Argjentina Ramosaj.

I still love Alaina though<3

[YukiiPhantomhive]

-.- Do i really have to correct you all -_- ashley didnt wrote it?!?! Its Ashley didnt WRITE it. Btw i didnt wven spot ashley -.-

[xValiumKnightsx]

Ashley's voice kinda ruins this song.

Sounds weird by her..

[MrRockapoodle72]

check out that hipster below me

FUCK ANYTHING POPULAR OR MAINSTREAM

[MrDream996]

@demone966 This is going to feature EMINEM.

[zgaga22]

never mind for me the story of song, I like her, and I like Porcelain  Black, thats beautiful song:)

[piper83061]

je la kiffe trop cette chanson

i like ashley et porcelain black !!!!!!!!!!

[MsDUBfreak]

All respect for Porcelain and the Tramps is now gone.

But hey, Alaina must be making plenty of money now.

I guess she's content with this... *sigh*

[SanIchikari]

@MsDUBfreak Why have you lost respect for her because of something she likes to do? Btw I hope you know that someone just combined Porcelain's snippet with the actual song....

[MsDUBfreak]

@SanIchikari

She sold out. Her new sound is nothing like it used to be. The vibe, the lyrics... it's all different.

It's mediocre mainstream garbage.

Not to sound like a hipster or anything.

[85TisdaleAshley]

Ashley

[demone966]

@fovsaken but she sold it to her ,....OMG -.

so if you have mobile phone and sold to someone that it's not your mobile phone anymore...

[Channy1740]

I don't get why they wanted Ashley to have this song? because Alaina's singing about her life and i very much doubt Ashley's was like Alaina's.

[audmn]

I heard this song by Ashley, and was like "This is completely Alaina Beaton-esque." Then found out she wrote it. It's great regardless, and this definitely both of them.

[Blghcr95]

@bubblegummiesxX what do you mean give the song to Ashley?

[ariellexgore]

@Dresdevious that makes 2 of us!<3

[mrj19681]

i actually love this song whoever sang it

[railgun099]

@MrFuffolino well....its disliked now...by me

[MrFuffolino]

this's the first video i've ever seen on youtube without any dislike :D porcelain <3

[IkaRocks101]

@MuzikLUVChild123 I agree with you. I really wish that the rumours were true, cause Porcelain Black & Eminem would ROCK!!!!

[DreamingMusic13]

I couldnt hear PB :o(

[SanIchikari]

@DreamingMusic13 She's the first part of verse one and then they switch every two lines.

[MuzikLUVChild123]

I feel like this should be Porcelains next single,if rumor is true that Eminem is gonna be featured on this track this song could be Epic.This could be the new "Love The Way You Lie' Or "Airplanes".Anyone Agrees? Thumbs UP

[StevenONEDAY]

@MuzikLUVChild123 Not really. Haha It will be just another normal song on the radio, you know. Well wait and see.

[Napp28]

Why is Porcelain Black not on Itunes? Or is it just in North America? I mean, her music excists - obviously!

[ShezzaaSuicide]

Ashley recorded this song like, 2 years ago, it was just edited into this one.. some comments are really stupid everyone's freaking out about it, this was recorded already ages ago, it's on her album, Porcelain is just covering the song on her own, OBVIOUSLY

[XxanaveragegirlxX]

ashley has no emotion in this.. im glad this isnt real

[Frankjosuee]

cool cool re cool excellent song *__*

porcelain beautiful

[AlyMayhem]

This could be a sick duet when Porcelain starts promoting her album more. Just saying. could be really awesome and open her up to a really diverse fanbase.

[ThePopcorn102]

I really can not tell the difference I mean you can't hate Ashley's voice if you love PBs voice

[bubblegummiesxX]

come on now people.. don't hate. Ashley may not a good singer but i think their songs mostly sounds alike but yeah I prefer Porcelain. Alaina won't give the song to Ashley if she can't sing right? (:

[jjessicawoolum]

@demone966 you can tell that theres two diff singers.

[ashleyWTF362]

Omg, it's so hard to tell Ashley & Alaina apart. They should make this song together if this was only edited. <3

[parapadme]

I can't waitto hear the full version with PB and Eminem and the rap he'll have in the bridge I'm sure will go beautifully with it!

[xSardonicPerfection]

This is a freaking amazing song! I love it!

[Dresdevious]

LOVE YOU PORCELAIN. FINALLY A REAL MUSICIAN HITS THE SCENE INSTEAD OF THE CLONE FAKE BITCH GAGA. LOVE YOU PORCELAIN

[aidynOrosco]

@Dresdevious She's been on the scene.

[Dresdevious]

she has never been on the mainstream scene. i was her fan when she was still on vampire freaks. now that she has done a song with little wayne. every little bitch loves her music. i loved her even before she hit the mtv charts. thats what i mean by on the scene.@aidynOrosco

[aidynOrosco]

@Dresdevious Okay, I get what you mean. And so many people to love Porcelain now and they don't even know that once upon a time, the Tramps existed.

[Hellwina]

I prefer Porcelain black Voice <3

[goodbyeourdarlings]

all i want is a version by porcelain no high school musical cast

[JENNYxFASHIONxVICTIM]

what?ashley tislade?

come on now....

sing alone porcelain.... u are a star

[per5on1]

@JENNYxFASHIONxVICTIM this isnt real by the way .. this is a snippet of Porcelains version , then its ashley tisdales full version ( porcelain black gave her this song but she never used it ) the real version with Porcelain Black will ft Eminem

[JENNYxFASHIONxVICTIM]

@per5on1

ooh..rlly?

thanks for the information

[BrightAmbition]

Ashley Tisdale gives no emotion to this song, she sucks and can't sing. Her version sounds like some more pop crap, but i think Porcelain Black's version will be better she already sounds better than Ashley. I'm assuming most of these comments are from 13-16 yr olds since most of them don't know good music. Porcelain Black isn't any better but at least she writes her own songs :)

[LadyGaglam]

Beautiful <3< <3 <3 <3

[watchitever]

Awsome... I love Ashley Tisdale Voice.. !! ♥♥

[TheAmine90210]

by RedOne

[DiaryIsLocked]

It's getting it on, gettin it wrong... not getting on getting on.

[XxJoinMeInDeathxX15]

this is an amazing song just saying

[wingedSkittles]

I love this! :D

[Na5hl3i]

procelain black sounds really weird...

[BeautyScarz]

@Na5hl3i because its her real version and ashley's song mashed up you idiot hence the name of the video..

[Na5hl3i]

@BeautyScarz no not just in this video, her voice sounds weird in general too.

[khapotea]

this is better than the other ones that just have ashley but when alaina and eminem do the whole song it might be better but GREAT job!

but yo kinda got the lyrics below wrong just pointing it out -.-

[OphelieMski]

J'adore ! <3

[nguyenlinhbis]

Nice