Added: 3 years ago
From: jezabeldispair
Views: 8,957
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (120)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @JRadicalll  They keep following Nightwish because they couldn't move on. It's wishful thinking. That's how much tarja has been etched into their hearts. They hope annette could make some new songs with the old taste.

    About their trolling, i can't explain that though. I sure do hope people can give constructive insights albeit negative.

  • Oce + Century Child = Best NW recordings...

    End of an Era proofs it

  • I was there with you! Right at the front on the right. I think Marco saluted me during Amaranth ^.^

  • Comment removed

  • este tema no le keda bien ella nunka va a tener el mismo registro de tarja ella es incomparable anette es un asco XD

  • ejmmmm seeehhhh lo ke digas, ed igual manera tarja no volvera a la banda

  • Y para que la escuchas?

    Mejor escucha la version de Tarja en "end of an era" y asi ya no sufres

  • si....eso todos los sabemos no necesitamos otra persona que nos diga esto. pero yo la aplaudo porque ella lo intenta. pero a mi semease tonto y inutil que alguien handa pondiendo sus opiniones en videos de anette que se trata de tarja. les voy a consejar que porfavor NO PONGAN NINGUN COMENTO DE TARJA EN LOS VIDEOS DE NIGHTWISH CON ANETTE!!! ES MUY INUTIL QUE UNO SIGUE VIVIENDO EN EL PASADO. ELLOS LO DEJARON EN EL PASADO. Y NOSOTROS COMO FANS TENEMOS QUE HACER LO MISMO. y si no, no escribes nada.

  • i dont care what the people said i love this version of ghost love score!!!!!!

  • i love both....but im not the kinda person to start shit. i love anette's voice here. she tries and i think that takes guts and bravery. she is awesome.

  • I was there!

  • it is in songs like this when you realise how great is NW

    such an amazing song!!!

    such a great band

    a little (blond) problem, but not much important...

    and great video quality =P

  • i saw them one year ago and it was the best concert of my life..sad i won't see them again until 2011 probably =(

  • aggreed :( deffo have to see them again

  • This is ok. anette is good on the new songs, since I guess they're written for her to sing. Tarja would be much better for this song.

  • this was an old song from the once album that was the last album Tarja sung... therefore it is for Tarja and it is amazing... but when you think about how difficult the vocals are... Anette did really well

  • necroforest:

    I don`t relly think the songs are written "for her", toumas wrote them before Anette was in the band.

    And it is not so wierd the songs are better whit Tarja, we are used to hear her sing it and i guess Toumas had her voice in mind when he wrote it.

    (just so you know i don`t know if i am 100% right, it is just what i have heard and what i think...)

  • Without being melodramatic. My heart tore in two when I saw this video in the sidebar. I couldn't believe it! I hoped it was fake, I hope I'd awaken from this nightmare where Tumoas would actually let Anette sing this untouchable Nightwish classic. But instead, like the jews, led it into the doomed gas chambers of Anette's lungs. I died alittle with every note, every chord relentlessly butchered with Anette's sub par karaoke vocals. I am now merely a shell. R.I.P GLS

    I'd still tap her..

  • LoL, you should be on day time tv.

  • Daedalus,

    To bring jews and gas chambers into this comparison is disgusting beyond belief.

  • I was waiting for someone to bring it up, thank you.

  • You're welcome.

    Don't come too close to Anette though, she'll melt your wings.

  • Haha, duly noted.

  • so you hate her singing this, but you want to do her? what kind of world do we live in?

  • Mmm.. Her terrible singing doesn't make her a bad person. She's not Hitler just because she failed to do this song justice. If you can't comprehend this concept, then you asked the right question. What kind of world are we living in?

  • well, at least you didn't insult her unfairly.

  • i like anette better now cuz she brings so much enthousiasm to the band. Also with her more ''normal'' vocals i feel theres more room in nightwish for the other great singer in the band: MARCO.

    anyone commenting that anette doesnt hit every friggin note should get a taperecorder and sing a random nightwish song themselves. Theyre all extremely demanding on any voice.

  • My ears Hurts!!!

    Tarja Rules

  • my head hurts so do my ears.. sorry guys this is just wrong..

  • blegh after 2 years of comments like these (tarja vs anette) im getting pretty tired of them. People should appreciate nightwish for what it is: original, epic, beautiful, touching, rocking music \(^ _^ )/

  • holy crap applecalypse....thats exactly what i tell people

    epic, beautiful and then ive said (hardcore aka rocking, and authentic aka original)

    and i agree with the point...its still 100% nightwish with or without tarja...its awesome!

  • so sad

  • I'm shitting bricks.

    They're playing this live again! I always thought this song would work fairly well with Anette's voice. Makes me ashamed that they're not coming to my state on the upcoming US tour. :( At least I saw thwem in August.

  • sounds pretty cool

  • It was brave of both Anette and Tuomas to make a new interpretation of this song. She sang it beautifully, I think:)

  • I think this mm show have more metal songs that the others, I like it !!! thanks tuomas for play old nw songs!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Fair enough - you may have your perversion :P

    Neither of them have to be the bitch, it's just I'm absolutely sick of people criticising Anette simply because they're raised Tarja onto a ridiculous pedestal. Tarja was fired for a reason and anyone who doesn't like it can just listen to old albums, rather than being hurtful to Anette when she's doing the best she can. She reads the comments on videos like this sometimes and it gets her really upset... (as shown on Made In Hong Kong.)

  • I'M GOING TO SEE THEM TOMORROW! YAY!

  • I still like tarja's version better its just more dramatic. But im very glad they gave anette a shot at this song. She did great! She is getting better and better everyday.

  • LIVE DVD !!!!

    ... NOW!!!!!

    =D lol

  • I WAS RIGHT AT THE FRONT FOR THIS!!!!!!! fucking 10 out of 10.

    Anette kicked ass with this song, she was amazing.

  • thats what I find sooooo funny....in the endless debate of Tarja vs Anette they all compare the YouTube quality to the professionally produced End of an Era. Almost anyone who has been live to these shows totally contradicts all the negative posts. To put a video on YouTube you have to shrink it and convert it to Flash

  • Anette has improved greatly, it sounds great.

    However I feel like songs like this or Romanticide were too high for Anette and some parts sound weird with the changes she did.

    (Sorry 4 the bad english)

  • PERFECT! Fucking great! They kicked a lot of asses right now :D

  • I was there, it sounded amazing.

  • I hope they wont be tired:D

  • I see them on 04 04 2009 *,* cannot wait

  • 2.4. for me.

  • I'm so happy because they decided to play this an awesome (one of my favourite) old NW song.I bet it was an awesome gig and the British crowd seems to like it too!

  • I love this song with Anette :) She is amazing....NIGHTWISH are better and better. I love them forever!

  • I was there and i was amazed when the i heard Ghost love score start i thought,,,NO WAY,,,but Anette did a fantastic job she is really finding her feet now.

  • you are soo lucky, I see they did the confetti cannons here too

  • Wow, this is great! i love nightwish <3

  • This one is so much better than Tarja's boring singing. Good job!

  • youtube y la ctm! kiero ver el videooo

  • It's not bad. I didn't like it at first, but it's just a different interpretation and great in its own way. Simply not as amazing as most of her renditions of old songs, which with a couple of exceptions have been far better than the originals.

  • ok, nw is comercial.. nw is a shit! yeah? are you sure? then go to listen the tarja solo career or something else that you like!!! and do not bother us anymore, ok? hahahaha

  • so, take some 23 valiums and go to bed. Doing this, you are helping to clean this world of sick people.

  • i wish i had went to this!

  • :o :o <3

  • OMG I love this! =)

  • JESUS THIS IS PRETTY PERFECT!

  • Why doesn't that surprise me at all when your overall attitude is already the way it is (according to your profile). And I just can't stop wathing this 8)..

  • Poor boy...then cry....don't watch this....LOL....-11...you have to make it more because there is still 5 stars....

  • This was so awesome, i have some of that confetti upstairs in my bedroom somewhere. I so glad I got to see this song live, for those who would try and put Anette down, you wheren't there, this video cannot do her voice justice, she was amazingly good.

  • Anette <3

  • Zakon.

  • well I LOVE this version!!!=)

  • Ghost Love Score!!!!!!!!!!!!!! From what I can see and hear on YouTube this concert was AMAZING

  • Yeah "Ghost Love Score"!

    As I have always said ... In this song, where the sense and what makes you feel so many emotions, it is in music, choir and orchestra! Out onto the voice!

    NIGHTWISH Forever and Ever!!!!!!!!!!!

  • well nightwish maniac, its fine u feel that way but at the end of the day its about how people interact with their music, no two people are ever the same and therefore some people will like annette and some might not, theres not need to get snappy about it, just enjoy what the band has to offer. theyre both as good, but its like saying cheese is bad coz chocolate is good. theyre two different things, just like tarja and annette are two different singers. just enjoy the music!

  • omg never in a million years thought theyd play this live

  • They play it on end of an era with tarja

  • They played it several times in 2005, both at Lowlands festival in Holland and on the famous End of An Era DVD :O

  • This whole conversation is stupid because this thing is not just about Tarja or Anette. It's NIGHTWISH, which is bigger thing than both of those singers together. It is incredibly amazing music! I am a true NIGHTWISH fan and I don't give a *peep* who is the singer. Anette owns this song in her way, as does Tarja. There is nothing to be argued about!

  • I read it exactly well, those kind of comments are something which can be excepted from a teenage girl who were 5 years old when people started digging this band. It's your little opinion and you don't need to force it. "NightwishManiac" pictures pretty well your behavior, why don't you change it to a "NightwishTerrorist"? It would be more accurate.

  • "Did you reed what i wrote?? Nightwish isnt nightwish without tarja...embrace it!"

    Who cares what you wrote. Embrace the fact that NW is still here and they rock, even without your precious Tarja =D

  • I totally agree with you!These "NightwishTerrorists" are so jealous and piss off because NW is still an awesome band and they have old and new fans.I bet this concert was great and the crowd seems to like it!

  • oh i totally agree, tarja had a certain way of singing it, i was sooo shocked they played it! i think i had my mouth open for all 10 minutes hahaha!

  • WOW! i really thought this song died with tarja leaving....i must say i am happy to hear it live again...it will take some getting used to, i don't hate it, i LOVE annette but this is one of those songs that was just pure tarja, so...but well done NW for bringing it back to the set list!

  • trust me.. she really can! its just different! but if she tried to copy tarja to the letter all the time she would never make her own impact. she cant live under tarja's shadow, she has to make the songs her own and it was fantastic to hear!!

  • she can't sing metal music

    her voice is fantastic for pop but she is not for metal

  • "she can't sing metal music

    her voice is fantastic for pop but she is not for metal"

    to kelavakoza:

    1. anette isnt a "pop" singer

    2. "Anette is her own singer--she wont truly fit into any category perfectly

    3. your accusation is ridiculous because tarja was great for the band, and she herself was not a "metal" singer, but obviously and undeniably more of an opera-based singer. nightwish is original, so ur right, it wont sound like other stuff out there--it will sound like nightwish :)

  • the girl that sang ABBA's songs before Nightwish ISNT a pop singer? so WHAT kind of singer is she?

    she might sing in a metal band, she might sing even in death metal band, and shell still always sond sweet and catchy.

    Ghost Love Score by Anette is ok, but where is the magic...

  • "the girl that sang ABBA's songs before Nightwish ISNT a pop singer? so WHAT kind of singer is she?"

    "sang" as in past tense is the key word here. Anette has been fronting a ROCK band for a number of years then one of the most successful metal bands in the world. So she is no pop singer. And speaking of a "pop" singer? Ever heard of Tarja's Turunen? The one who released her first solo POP album last year?

    "Ghost Love Score by Anette is ok, but where is the magic... "

    Define "magic"

  • "Anette is her own singer--she wont truly fit into any category perfectly"

    i think that we are in agreement that having her in a metal band doesnt make her a "metal" (by the generalization) singer. at the same time shes a singer for a metal band, so she would be a "metal" singer. It really doesnt matter what you call her, you are right in saying shes something beyond a metal singer. she's anette and she's awesome. magic is kinda opinion, both anette and tarja do it for me

  • She really made a good job on this song for the first time! I liked it very much!

  • i don't like it very much.

  • This is your nasty stupid comment and it's so pointless...Nobody is "better" singer than other because it's always opinion of own taste and your taste is not better that others!All your other comments are so naive so I don't even bother to replay....Go listen something else!

  • I really don't care what kind of band NW is because I like only music!I didn't say that Anette is better than Tarja because it's pointless and I like them both.You don't have to understand other people taste of music because it's any your business...oh jeah...and you can kiss my ass!

  • "they are just commercial thanks to anette !!!! "

    Hate to tell you but a vocalist doesn't dictate what the MUSIC genre is. The MUSIC does. And the music in NW is, and has always been symphonic metal. A different singing style doesn't change that.

    "I don't understand you people how can you say that Anette is better than Tarja!"

    What I don't understand is why people who no longer like NW /Anette continue to follow them and troll their videos/comments.

  • I agree with you

    its only not true that Nightwish has always been Symph Metal. Before Century Child you could better catogorize them as Operatic Metal...

  • "Dude, nightwish is known as a symphony metal band... and now they are just commercial thanks to anette !!!!"

    NW was commercial since Oceanborn. Got a better excuse?

    "Anette can just kiss Tarja's feet"

    Nah, there are enough of you Tarja cultists only too happy to do that.

  • yeah you are right...and yeah once was masterprice eaven if nemo and I wish i had an angel ware good for everyone's ear...And guyes do you know what is the philosophy now...Nightwish choise anette to prove to tarja that with stupid singer thay can do it right!..

  • "once was masterprice eaven if nemo and I wish i had an angel ware good for everyone's ear"

    Once was hardly a masterpiece. It was the most generic and uninspiring album they've ever made.

    "Nightwish choise anette to prove to tarja that with stupid singer thay can do it right!"

    Or they chose Anette because they wanted change. It's THEIR band and it's their choice. You don't like it? Tough shit, move on.

  • "Anette can just kiss Tarja's feet."

    Hate to admit I wouldn't mind seeing that.....:S some lickin too would to cool

  • I was there, and Anette was fantastic. She really was - she was so full of energy and life. She has an amazing voice too.

    If there's going to be and foot-kissing, it will be by Tarja. She was the bitch, not Anette.

  • Hope ya didn't misinterpret my post, I prefer Anette by a long shot , I love the EOAE concert but Anette does it for me more than Tarja, I was just being perverted

  • Why does anyone have to be the bitch? They're both amazing singers and I have yet to see either of them throw a bag of kittens into a river, how can you determine whether or not somebody is a bitch based on how they're portrayed?

  • Comment removed

  • talentwise there is no comparing who is better - aside from talent, anette is obviously better because shes the one with nightwish, shes the one that they chose and continued their elite musicmaking with

  • You'll kill yourself? Bye bye =)

  • you got that right

  • SO,SO....your mommy and daddy gonna be very angry if you write so nasty comments....

  • I honestly thought that this song would not be heard live ever again. I am very pleased that this is in set list again as this is one of the greatest ever. Obviously this sounds a bit different but still great! Thanks Nightwish!

  • i could've never believed that anette would sing this song because tarja made this so hers but anette's version is so good! sounds great! :D

  • OMG!

    That's awesome *o*

  • Excellent!!!! Anette <3

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more