Japanese are devils.. they still deny any of this ever took place. This is why Japan will never be liked by China and Korea, unlike Germany who have admitted and apologised for their atrocities and are no longer hated by the rest of Europe.
Photographs purported to be evidence of a massacre in Nanking are on display at the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Hall, at other exhibitions, and in printed publications. However, recent scientific research has revealed that there are no photographs attesting to a massacre in Nanking. At least 143 pictures are distorted, are fabricated, or are used for the Nanking Massacre pictures which were from different areas and different times by Chinese government.
(Part2)If there had been slaughter in Nanking of a magnitude so great (300,000 civilian victims) as to prompt the description “holocaust of the century,” there is not the slightest chance that he would have been silent on the matter.
(Part1)Chinese Communist Party Chairman Mao Zedong never referred to a massacre in Nanking. He made exactly one mention of the Battle of Nanking during a lecture delivered at Yan’an six months after the conflict, reproduced in On Protracted War. Chairman Mao criticized the Japanese for failing to annihilate Chinese troops after having surrounded them.
Nanking Massacre is fake.The title of the fair book on Amazon in USA and UK is "The Alleged Nanking Massacre : Japan's rebuttal to China's forged claims" .
(Part2) About 35 foreign journalists and diplomats attended there. However, Chinese didn’t explain the fact which was so-called the Nanking Massacre even once during any of these 300 conferences was a statement or announcement.
■(Part1)In Nov. 1937, during the Battle of Nanking, the Nationalist Party established The International Propaganda Section (IPS). According to the top-secret document entitled “Outline of International Propaganda Operations,” the IPS held 300 press conferences in Hankou between Dec 1, 1937 and Oct 24, 1938.
(Part2)After February 1938 when the camps were dissolved, rape was rare. Therefore, we are not able to trust the crimes of Japanese soldiers just as the Chinese representatives of the refugee camps claimed. The Chinese soldiers hiding in the Safety Zone camouflaged themselves to create the impression that looting and rapes had been committed by Japanese soldiers, to practice one of a series of Chinese strategies for the purpose of throwing Japanese soldiers into confusion."
■(Part1)Tadao Takemoto and Yasuo Ohara point out about the alleged atrocities in Nanking: "The representatives of the refugee camps of nineteen places established in the Safety Zone were all the Chinese, except Miss Minnie Vautrin. Though those Chinese took charge of the maintenance of public order in these camps, there were some Chinese officers who camouflaged themselves as if they were citizens. And many cases of rape occurred in the refugee camps.
The 228 Massacre was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947, and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government. Estimates of the number of deaths vary from ten thousand to thirty thousand or more, and Tibet and Uygure problems are the same. Why is the CCP loudly denouncing the 'Nanking Massacre' when then had insisted on it happening more than seventy years ago, but it is not even clearly defined?
1) Don’t buy Japan’s cancer causing radiation polluted products, especially food. The Japanese government lied about the safety of their exported food products.
@undertakerRach 2) Don’t marry a Japanese person; if you do, try not to have any children because they are carrying a radiation mutated gene, resulting from the two well deserved American A-bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki to force a quick surrender of Japan ending WWII, and the recent earthquake-tsunami triggered nuclear accident at Fukushima.
@undertakerRach 3) Choose another tour destination because the radiation level is still high around Japan and the Japanese government is not forthright about the severity of the nuclear accident. If you must go for business or work, don’t forget to bring your daily dose of iodine pills, good luck.
@undertakerRach 4) Furthermore, because of the intrinsic geological condition of Japan, not to let appearances fool you, another earthquake-tsunami is imminent, not a question of “if” it happens but “when”. Keep this in mind.
For you dumbfucks who think this was faked, thats like saying the holocaust was a lie (there are actually dumbasses who believe that was faked too)
China is an awesome place and is certainly one of the nicest places in the world and so is Japan. In my opinion I believe the only people who should be looked down upon are dumbass americans like most of you guys. (Well not all of them quiet a few actually make sense.)
(Part2)/////where protests broke out after anti-Chinese riots in neighbouring Tibet a week ago. People demonstrate in support for Tibet and against violence in the Chinese region, on March 21, 2008 in Paris. (Patrick Kovarik/AFP/Getty Images)
During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese soldiers were bandits, so they killed many Chinese people. Chinese government pinned their crimes on Japanese soldiers. They even now they are the same.
(Part1)Tibetans Say Chinese Troops Killed Many Demonstrators Reuters Mar 21, 2008
KANGDING, China—Tibetans in China's tense southwestern province of Sichuan said on Friday they believed police had killed several people in anti-Chinese demonstrations there this week, disputing official claims none died. China's communist-controlled Xinhua news agency reported overnight that police shot and wounded four protesters in a heavily ethnic Tibetan part of the province,/////
Please ignore undertakerRach, she is just a japanese extremist. She constantly demonizes China, and claims japan is the greatest country on earth and has never done anything bad. People do bad things. Japan is no exception. To say japan hasnt done anything bad is like saying humans dont need oxygen.
@SHUTUPNOOB654 According to the testimonies in The International Military Tribunal for the Far East (IMTFE), Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000. Therefore, the Chinese government was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE. In other words, the Chinese government had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence.
■Before the entry of the Japanese, Chinese soldiers in their mad rush to discard their military uniforms and put on civilian clothes. In a number of incidents, Chinese soldiers killed their people to obtain their clothing. During the last few days, some violations of people and property were undoubtedly committed by them. James Espy, the vice American Council at Nanking, reported to the American Embassy
@lucas1421 You keep ignoring when I tell you to watch the first in a long line of evidence. Japanese are not fucking 12 feet tall! China's "evidence states otherwise. Don't talk to me anymore. I'm tired of dealing with your chinese version of logic. Goodbye and godspeed.
@lucas1421 You ASSumed I was Japanese because I'm not swallowing your chinese shit. I know firsthand of the Chinese aggression in asia. Communism sucks, and so do you.
@Muraku666 Personal attacks do not advance your denial of historical facts in anyway. If you are an American then I have to say I am quite disappointed. Japanese people are brainwashed by their government yet the Americans have all sources of history with which they can naturally reach their conclusion. Personal attacks, along with attacks on Communism, or attacks on China will NOT nullify the historical evidence for japanese war crimes? If anything, you are a shame.
@lucas1421 actually, watch the Fake of Nanking video on youtube, where it is proven that the videos were faked. I am not Japanese. I am a white American Sailor. I know about the corpse, because the message was sent up the chain of command.
@lucas1421 The truth comes out. The problem is, I have been to China, and have seen how filthy and deceitful your people are. You can't pretend that noble shit on me. A dead baby girl's corpse was found in the filtratrion system from the river. Fuck your evil way of life. I will never condone your ways.
@Muraku666 Oh yeah? Is this the best you can do? You are such a typical japanese. When you lose, you feel embarrassed and you change the subject. I don't see you giving any evidence about the falseness of the accusations of the war crimes; instead, you are talking about some other unrelated stuff. I find your shamelessness contemptible. Using expletives in your argument isn't the sign you are such an "adult", which you accused me of not being. Do you think you are a worthy subject of debate? No.
@lukas1421 The propaganda film has been proven false. Those executioners in the film were wearing black uniforms. You can't see them in the film, but watch the fake of nanking videos to see the original. You will be shocked.
@Muraku666 I have no interest in dealing with you. You remind me of Japanese war criminals on the Far East Tribunal. Although the criminal acts had been well documented and even caputred on video, they can still shamelessly claim that they did nothing. I cannot imagine anybody more shameless than the Japanese. I cannot imagine anyone more subhuman than the japanese. As a chinese, I feel it is a disgrace that japanese have failed to learn the real ideology from China. Stilll behaving like animals
It is not Japanese nature to do such things. China made the propaganda according to the way that they treat prisoners. The Japanese are incapable of commiting such acts...
@Muraku666 It is the Japanese nature to do such things. Japanese, compared with other races, are subhuman because they are capable of such acts. Even Germans cannot do it.
(Part2)Moreover, historians found Chinese government paid money to many foreigners for writing some books or newspaper articles. In fact, these myths are believed by many people in the world. How did we call this crime? We can call the Chinese government libel and slander? Yes of course! It is natural that Japanese raising an objection.
(Part1)The Japanese want to correct wrong rumors which Chinese spread out to the world. Chinese people who are mind controlled by anti-Japanese policy after the Tiananmen Massacre in 1989, they started it, they have announced wrong myths about Japanese acts during the Sino-Japanese War ceaselessly. On the other hand, a scientific investigation with computer technology revealed that 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were edited by Chinese government.
@undertakerRach Stop lying. Lying does not help. The footage of Nanking Massacre has been caught on film and there is extensive evidence about it. It is hard to believe that the Japanese are still trying to deny the hard cold facts.
@lukas1421 The Japanese want to correct wrong rumors which Chinese spread out to the world. Chinese people who are mind controlled by anti-Japanese policy after the Tiananmen Massacre in 1989, they started it, they have announced wrong myths about Japanese acts during the Sino-Japanese War ceaselessly. On the other hand, a scientific investigation with computer technology revealed that 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were edited by Chinese government.
@undertakerRach Rumors? Your shamelessness is beyond my imagination. How dare you call these rumors? These are hard facts not only witnessed by countless people in China, but also caught on film. The american historians have conducted research and written books such as the "rape of nanking", which is based on primary historical evidence. If anyone is brainwashed, I think you are. Brainwashed by the right-wing japanese militarists. People like you are the reason why japanese are not liked at all
In fact, the Chinese government has killed many Tibetans. They invaded Tibet in 1950. Also they killed 190,000 Uyghurs by atomic bombs tests. The Chinese government hasn’t told these facts to the Chinese people. In March 2008, The Amnesty International U.S.A said serious human rights violations have been reported during and following the police and military crackdown on Tibetan protests in these areas.
Its verid, germany is world whide known about the brutal murder of 6 million jews, children learn that in school, often the first thing in history lesson.
But really noone knows about the japaneses killing 18 MILLION chineses, thats a shame how can that be? Their genonicide was 3 times bigger but who cares about that today??
Those were killed in times of a month, the naking massacre was not only in nanking city is was in the sourrounding areas, altrough in many otehr cities but the casualties in those are included in that what we today call "the naking massacre".
Are you trying to deny somethng here or what? Whats your opinion on the 9 million deads in the KZ (6 million jews and 3 million others) btw?
@JSLegoMaster (Part1) The Nanking Massacre was a false story.
According to Summary report on the Investigation of Japanese war crimes committed in Nanking, prepared by the Procurator of the District Court in Nanking, to prepare for the IMTFE, the KMT set up the Nanking Investigation Committee for Antagonists Crime on November 7, 1945, and appealed to the Chinese public to report Japanese Army's crimes.
Man I have seen holocaust deniers thats rude and shocking but this beats everything.... your even denying this I really wish the worse to you and your life, you deny the death of millions of ciwilians shame on you.
@JSLegoMaster If China wants to blame Japan which countries commited cruel atrocity, China has to show conclusive evidence about the Nanking Massacre. Even Chinese governmnet tried to collect evidence on January 20 for Tokyo Trial, they could not. Many Chinese citizens refused to testify or to deny the massacre occurred when they were asked for details.
@JSLegoMaster I deny them openly and proudly. Afterliving in both countrie, an understanding the nature of both cultures, I know that the Nanking Massare was faked. Even aide fom he eindence of edited photos, and random death toll estmates, it is foolish to beleve tat the Japanese would act a such.
(Part2)It was reported, however, that few responded to the crimes committed by Japanese Army and some refused to testify or to deny the massacre occurred when they were asked for details. Then, the KMT reluctantly submitted the tentative report to the IMTFE on January 20, 1946. Except for one testimony made by a man named Lu Su, no other evidence of massacre by the Japanese Army was available, besides burial records.
Many Nanking citizens thus came back to the city, and the population increased. Would the citizens have come back to a city in which there had been a massacre?
CCP brainwashed it's own people by teaching Anti -Japanese education
presenting it's people bunch of fabricated fake photos of massacres, to make them believe and force it's people to deal with it's low wage labor system.
That is how Japan apologized and to many countries in Asia only not to China.
WAKE UP Chinese people, are you still going to get enough being a slave of a communist group like CCP?
(Part3)China and Korea said, “We have sent many vicious criminals to Japan, but Japan decided that we don’t need to get visa anymore for entering into Japan.”
All said, “Japan must be like a frigid woman.”
Japan is a patient country because China has been demonstrating of the fake story of the Nanking Massacre since 1937. When will Japan run out of patience?
One day, a big international conference was held in somewhere in Asia. In the conference room, Japan stood up and left from the room to get to bathroom. The other countries started to talk about Japan.
China said, “I wanted Japan to get angry, so we made our submarines enter to Japanese territorial sea boundary. Also we stole nature resources in Senkaku Islands from Japan. However, Japan didn’t get angry.”
(Part2/2)Why did not Mao announce about the massacre in the international mass media conference from 1937 to 1938? Why Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000 when the IMTFE was opened? Why Chinese government edited at least 147 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum?
(Part1/2)Where were 300,000 of dead bodies? Why did many Chinese people come back to Nanking after Japanese occupied the city? Why did Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for editing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?
(Part2) 『To my mind, this should not concern us Germans, particularly since one can clearly see that the Chinese, once left to depend solely on the Japanese, immediately fraternize. And as for all these excesses, one hears only one side of it, after all.』
(Part1)John Rabe, who had never witnessed even one case of murder, sent a false report to Hitler by saying The number of victims I Nanking city were 50000 to 60000. P. Scharfienberg, the secretary general of the German Embassy to China, who returned to Nanking city on January 9, tried to investigate the fact about 'Japanese Army's atrocities Rabe reported' by himself, and wrote to the German Embassy at Hankow on February 10:
(Part4)Some Chinese mad because they have believed the mass media report which said criminal must be Japanese. Why did Chinese officials report so without definite proof? After 2 years, how Chinese officials found syringes in the river? Why have they taken for investigation for 2 years? Have Chinese officials waited people become less interesting the news? This strategy is the same as the so-called Nanking Massacre.
(Part3)Japanese investigators have insisted that the evidence indicated that the dumplings were most likely contaminated in China for two years. Finally, Chinese officials have admitted the pesticide methamidophos had been mixed into the product in that country, after repeated previous denials. The criminal is Lu Yueting, who was a temporary employee at the Tianyang Food Plant based in northern China's Hebei Province. He mixed poison to Gyoza with syringes, and he threw the syringes to river.
(Part2)At that time, Chinese officials said, no problems were detected at gyoza factory and it passed 24 quality checks since February 2007. In short, they strongly denied it causes China in 2008. Needless to say, the frozen gyozas were found to have traces of methamidophos, a pesticide banned in Japan. Chinese officials had appealed enthusiastically that the gyoza may have been contaminated deliberately in Japan before they caught criminal, so Chinese people believed the criminal must be Japan.
(Part1)In April, 2010, Chinese police have apprehended a 36-year-old man who allegedly poisoned frozen "gyoza" dumplings that were exported to Japan and sickened 10 people, the official Xinhua news agency said, quoting the Ministry of Public Security. After eating shop-bough instant frozen gyoza (dumplings), 10 people are reported to have experienced nausea, dizziness in Japan. One of the victims—a five-year-old girl went into a coma.
(Part2)However, these collections show no evidence of any vigorous critical attempt to distinguish between valid primary materials and other materials: photographs, for instance, which are known to be fabricated, or from different areas and different times, continue to be used to "prove" Japanese guilt in the winter of 1937-38 at Nanjing.
The Nanjing Incident Recent Research and Trends by David Askew
(Part1)The majority of academic research on the Nanjing Incident is conducted in Japanese, English and Chinese. Of the three language groups, Japanese has produced the most sophisticated research, with the debate in English lagging decades behind. The most objective Chinese language materials are the collections of various primary sources, including the recollections of many of the Chinese military personnel in Nanjing.
(Part3)What MATSUI said, "It was really a shameful incident" after receiving the death penalty by the IMTFE, meant that he expressed his regret at the existence of ten and several soldiers, in spite of the small number, who committed the shameful crimes like looting and rapes as soldiers of the Japanese Army. Furthermore, he kept denying it in the IMTFE to the last moment that the Japanese Army committed the systematic massacre in Nanking.
(Part2)Even though the crimes committed were small in number, it must have been unbearable for him to hear of the crimes committed by Japanese soldiers, as he always spoke of stern military discipline. The court-martial was held and more than ten soldiers were punished according to the policy of MATSUI who always said, "The looting and the rapes should be punished."
(Part1)As General Matsui said, "according to what I heard," he must have heard it from someone who had read the documents (complaints) submitted by the Safety Zone Committee. Aware of this, MATSUI emphasized the importance of thoroughly obeying military discipline during his speech made in the presence of chiefs of staffs of various divisions under his command, at the memorial service held on December 18.
(Part4)Definitely, the Chinese government is afraid of occur a democratization movement such as the Tiananmen massacre in 1989. As you know there are many human rights problem in Tibet and Uygure, etc. Thats why the government uses anti-Japanese education to kids. As a result, Chinese people firmly refuse the true facts. In other words, Chinese people are mind controlled by Chinese government. At least 143 pictures about so-called Nanking massacre are distorted by the Chinese government.
(Part2)Also, one of the photos is in Korea and in the Nanking Museum are the same. The book name is The record of the abduction of Koreans, 1st edition which was written by Park Kyung-Sik. The photo in the book says these dead bodies were Korean children slaughtered by brigands, and this picture was taken in Korea. This is exhibited without this caption in the Nanking Massacre Museum. Chinese government desires the Nanking massacre was happened by Japanese.
(Part1) More than 143 pictures are distorted by the Chinese government. In addition, one of the photos, which show many people's bones in the land, have displayed in the Nanking museum. The Chinese put an explanation. The explanation said these bones were Chinese victims. They were killed by Japanese.
However, we have seen different photos in every visit. In other words, the picture is added more and more bones. Definitely, Chinese authorities have showed pictures which was trimmed by them.
Among the records in the aforementioned Documents of the Safety Zone are detailed complaints about misconduct attributed to Japanese military personnel. They include a total of 26 murders, only one of which was witnessed (to that account is appended a note describing the murder as a lawful execution). Also, recent research has proven that there is absolutely no basis for the claim that there was a massacre in that city. How does China claim that 300,000 Chinese were killed by Japanese?
There is ample testimony,not only by witnesses such as John Magee. George A. Fitch, Lewis Smythe ,James McCallum , Dr Robert Wilson,and searle bates,but also evidence from confessions made by japanese soldiers,also the testimony of the chinese photographic developer who,at great risk to his self made copies of film given to him to develop by japanese soldiers during the period of the massacre.
(Part10)Chinese government said Japanese Military killed 300,000 persons over a period of six weeks. In short, the Japanese are accused of having murdered 7,000 people each day. It is ridiculous. One of the pictures shows that Japanese soldiers were having a pleasant chat with Chinese citizens who are wearing armbands of the flag of Japan in Nanking. This photo was taken on 20, Dec. 1937, seven days after the occupation, and published in the pictorial book, Shina-jihen Shasin Zensyu, in 1938.
(Part9) Also, he confessed what he himself witnessed was nothing. The Daily Reports of Serious Injuries to Civilians said the only killing witnessed by foreigners in Nanking was only one lawful execution. Also, the IMTFE showed Chinese could not prove the murder of 300,000. Therefore, the Chinese was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE has opened. In short, the Chinese had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence.
(Part8) The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle, and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. Moreover, according to The Documents of Magee, member of TSZC, referred the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179. He testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents'. However, this number 179 was including rumor.
(Part7)Tell the truth, people could kill 300,000 people and raped 80,000 women? They stayed in the Nanking only 6 weeks in Dec 1937. The citys population was 200,000, according to foreigners who were there at the time. TSZC(The Safety Zone Committee) documents read that in Jan 1938 the population was 250,000. Also, here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (The International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society.
(Part6) The reason for Japan staying in China was the Boxer Protocol which was signed on Sep.7, 1901 between the China and the 8-Nation Alliance which including Japan. Japan was attacked by KMT in Shanghai. KMT shelled into the Japanese camp 4 times. People called this Marco Polo Bridge Incident which was happened on July 7, 1937. This incident signified to open the war. Chiang Kai-shek escaped to Nanking. Thats why Japanese chased him to Nanking city.
(Part5) The section was propaganda section in China during the War. Timperley was paid by the propaganda section for editing the book. This Timperley fact based on the book which is called 曽虚白自伝(Page 201), which means曽虚白 Diary. 曽虚白 was also one of the members of the Propaganda section. In fact, at least 143 of pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were distorted by the propaganda section.
(Part4)During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese victims couldnt receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chiang said, You can get medical treatment for free in hospitals if you said Japanese injured you. Thats why there is much verbal evidence about the battles. One of the foundation upon which the massacre myth is based on the book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley. But he was an advisor to the Chinese Nationalist governments Ministry of Information.
(Part3)According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, one of the Americans said, Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead. 'There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.
(Part2)Thats why Chinese people called CPC, Mao soldiers, 共匪 which means communists pirates because they raped many women, plunder many towns, and murdered. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." In fact, The 228 Incident, also known as the 228 Massacre, was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government.
(Part1)During the Shino-Japanese war, Chinese military killed Chinese people as if they were a worm. One of the Chinese men whose name was梁啓超 called Chinese people戮民, which means never mind people die for victory.The Chinese military characteristics were the same not only KMT (Kuomintang, Chiang Kai-shek) but also CPC (Mao Tse-tung ). CPC acted more brutally than KMT.
all who think this is not true must explain to me the pictures of Japanese troops gutting, burying, shooting people, and cutting women's guts out. Please explain. I would like to know. All u people are saying are lies. There are even victims of the massacre! And do not underestimate these people. Humans can do very horrific and nasty things that are unimaginable
(Part4)Definitely, the Chinese government is afraid of occur a democratization movement such as the Tiananmen massacre in 1989. Thats why the government uses anti-Japanese education to kids. As a result, Chinese people firmly refuse the true facts. In other words, Chinese people are mind controlled by Chinese government. At least 147 pictures about so-called Nanking massacre are distorted by the Chinese government.
@oddballrach Guess what?! u sound just like the germans that claimed 1 they didnt know about the holocaust, 2 that hitler had nothing to do with it and 3 that it didnt even happen! get over it ur nation did some disgraceful things it wasn't the first time, and as TheArthurChow said explain some of the pictures like woman havin had bayonets shoved in their vagina or better still the countless american priests there that witnessed this and sent letters home describing all they saw!
(Part1)Do you know how much the Safety Zone Committee was aware of looting in the Nanking? According to documents of Magee, member of the Safety Zone Committee, so far referred to in this paper, those demonstrated the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179 including those in rumor.
(Part2)Although Magee, member of the Safety Zone Committee, testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents', he confessed in the cross-examination, what he himself witnessed was nothing but one case that 'a Japanese soldier deprived of some electric ice boxes.
Part3)Also, this very photo has been taken by Correspondent KUMASAKI (Japanese)in the province of Paoshan in the vicinity of Shanghai, on October 14, 1937.
In short, a scene of peaceful farming village has been secretly switched to the one that is taking villagers to somewhere prior to rape en masse. It is indeed a wicked act of secretly switching the picture. You know, this is the usual measures of China Government. Government miss led Chinese people, Chinese people are not wrong.
(part2)A set of four of pictures have appeared in the journal with the explanation, titled as "Utopia amidst the Gun-power: The 'Rising Sun' Village South of the Yangtze." The picture captioned with "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." In those days in china, the lootings are often committed by the deserted Chinese soldiers. Therefore, the farmers have needed the protection of Japanese troops to engage in farming safely.
(Part1)One of the pictures have displayed at the 'Memorial Hall of Victims in Nanking Massacre'. Chinese gave a name to the photo "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of ladies were raped and forced into military prostitution. However, this photo has appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on November 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle.
(Part10)Chinese government said Japanese Military killed 300,000 persons over a period of six weeks. In short, the Japanese are accused of having murdered 7,000 people each day. It is ridiculous. One of the pictures shows that Japanese soldiers were having a pleasant chat with Chinese citizens who are wearing armbands of the flag of Japan in Nanking. This photo was taken on 20, Dec. 1937, seven days after the occupation, and published in the pictorial book, Shina-jihen Shasin Zensyu, in 1938.
(Part9) Also, he confessed what he himself witnessed was nothing. The Daily Reports of Serious Injuries to Civilians said the only killing witnessed by foreigners in Nanking was only one lawful execution. Also, the IMTFE showed Chinese could not prove the murder of 300,000. Therefore, the Chinese was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE has opened. In short, the Chinese had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence.
(Part8) The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle, and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. Moreover, according to The Documents of Magee, member of TSZC, referred the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179. He testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents'. However, this number 179 was including rumor.
(Part7)Tell the truth, people could kill 300,000 people and raped 80,000 women? They stayed in the Nanking only 6 weeks in Dec 1937. The citys population was 200,000, according to foreigners who were there at the time. TSZC(The Safety Zone Committee) documents read that in Jan 1938 the population was 250,000. Also, here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (The International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society.
(Part6) The reason for Japan staying in China was the Boxer Protocol which was signed on Sep.7, 1901 between the China and the 8-Nation Alliance which including Japan. Japan was attacked by KMT in Shanghai. KMT shelled into the Japanese camp 4 times. People called this Marco Polo Bridge Incident which was happened on July 7, 1937. This incident signified to open the war. Chiang Kai-shek escaped to Nanking. Thats why Japanese chased him to Nanking city.
(Part5) The section was propaganda section in China during the War. Timperley was paid by the propaganda section for editing the book. This Timperley fact based on the book which is called 曽虚白自伝(Page 201), which means曽虚白 Diary. 曽虚白 was also one of the members of the Propaganda section. In fact, at least 143 of pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were distorted by the propaganda section.
Part4)During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese victims couldnt receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chiang said, You can get medical treatment for free in hospitals if you said Japanese injured you. Thats why there is much verbal evidence about the battles. One of the foundation upon which the massacre myth is based on the book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley. But he was an advisor to the Chinese Nationalist governments Ministry of Information.
(Part3)According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, one of the Americans said, Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead. 'There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.
(Part2)Thats why Chinese people called CPC, Mao soldiers, 共匪 which means communists pirates because they raped many women, plunder many towns, and murdered. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." In fact, The 228 Incident, also known as the 228 Massacre, was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government.
(Part1)During the Shino-Japanese war, Chinese military killed Chinese people as if they were a worm. One of the Chinese men whose name was梁啓超 called Chinese people戮民, which means never mind people die for victory.The Chinese military characteristics were the same not only KMT (Kuomintang, Chiang Kai-shek) but also CPC (Mao Tse-tung ). CPC acted more brutally than KMT.
(Part5)This has been conducted during the period of December 24, 1937, through January 5, 1938, in order to identify the citizens, separating them from the soldiers. We can observe that the Chinese people shown in the pictures aren't in fear of the Japanese soldiers at all. The most of the people who have been involved in the Nanking battle say that they have never witnessed such acts of massacre. There are many other testimonies recorded besides them.
(Pat4)Moreover the Asahi Newspaper shows a series of photos taken almost in the same time. Among them, one photo which was taken by Asahi correspondent KAWAMURA on the l7th, showing unarmed Japanese soldiers taking a walk on the street. Another photo shows a barber stall operating. Also, a film called Nanking, produced by TOHO Film Production, shows a crowd of inhabitants coming to get ID cards at the card issuing office opened in the Safety Zone by the Japanese Army.
(Part3)SATO Shinju, correspondent of the Tokyo NichiNichi, has taken the photos on December 15 and l6, 1937, at the Safety Zone within the walled city where Chinese inhabitants were opening the street stalls. Among these photos, there is one showing a Food stall held by a Chinese refugee where a Japanese soldier was eating as the inhabitants, including women and children watching him. Also, there are other photos showing many stall vendors selling vegetables and used clothes.
(Part2)One of the photos has been taken by SATO Shinju. It shows an aspect of the walled city of December 15, two days after the fall of Nanking. Surprisingly, at the Safety Zone located in the west side of Chungshan North Road, street stalls such as boiled Chinese dumpling sellers have still more been opening. A Japanese soldier has been the first customer. It is apparent that the Japanese occupation has recovered the public order.
(Part1)There are some clearly opposite historical documents against the existence of such large-scale murders, Chinese have claimed. For example, one is the photographic and documentary films. Also, there are some opposite data against the existence of such large-scale murders even within the documents, which they have presented as the evidence. Furthermore, some of the actions, which the then KMT has taken, are difficult to comprehend if there have been such large-scale murders.
The Chinese government is consisted of a bunch of people who do not hesitate to commit murder their people. When the atomic bombs tests succeeded in Uyghur, scientists jumped for joy. 190,000 Uyghur died by the tests. Moreover, the Yellow River flood was created by the Nationalist Government in central China in 1938. Before Chiang Kai-shek ordered the Yellow River Flood, he did not tell to the people, therefore, the flood waters took an estimated Chinese 500,000 lives. This is the China.
That justifies the Japanese war crimes in Nanking? Or do you simply avoid the issue by talking about irrelevancies in effort to both blame and smear the victim of you sick motherf*ckers?
oddballrach, I know what you mean by gov't propaganda. All governments do it and the people believe unless they go looking for the truth. Then they are called liberals. I have debated this and the US terrorist nuclear attack on Japan with a friend. People only believe what is in the mainstream books or on CNN. Thanks for trying to tell the truth though.
You mesn, of course, you have to lie against China in effort to avid the issue: the JKapanese war crimes committed against Nanking -- which is the issue of this video and thread. Were you not dishonest you wouldn't smear the victim. You wouldn't, in a word, LIE.
(Part10) To Youtube watchers thank you for reading my comments. In conclusion, the China government hardly cracks down on an anti-government movement. Definitely, they make a false charge against Japan for their countrys safe. The Japan was made a scapegoat!! One of the Chinese governors says we should use Japan at least 100 years more.
People have known at least 147 of pictures were distorted by the Chinese government.
(Part9)Finally, I want to tell you about scheming methods of the Chinese government. Chinese people are not wrong because they have no chance to get right history. In fact, school books in Beijing leave out significant historical events including the 1989 Tiananmen Square democracy demonstrations in which Chinese troops killed thousands of unarmed protestors, and the three-year famine between 1958 and 1961 when communist policies led to the starvation of an estimated 30 million Chinese.
(Part8)Even though the pictures and videos were not related to Nanking incident, they dont care. Even though the pictures were not shown any Japanese, they dont care. Even though the people put on short sleeve T-shuts in the pictures, they say these pictures were taken in the Nanking! The Japanese came to the Nanking city in November in 1937!! They just want Japanese are in troubles. The Chinese says these pictures are evidence of Japanese massacred in the Nanking! It is ridiculous!
(Part7)While the Chinese people are criticizing to Japan, the government is safe. Thats why the government has taught anti-Japanese education to the Chinese kids in school. Some Chinese are ignited or made angry to Japan by anti-Japanese education. They have found any cruel pictures even though the pixs are not related Japan, and they put caption which are written like Japanese committed atrocity. Then they uploaded the videos to the YouTube.
(part6) For example, the Chinese raped many ladies and killed their people such as the Tungchow Mutiny on 29 July 1937 and Yellow River Flood in June 1938, and so on. Even now, they have dominated Tibetans and Uyghur. Many Chinese dont know these facts because the government has concealed the facts from people for making safe their government. Exactly, the government afraid the next the Tiananmen Massacre occur. It was happened in 1989 in China.
(Part5) Secondly, why the Chinese people do such an enthusiastic propaganda in you tube. In fact, the former two of Chinese governments killed many their people than Japanese. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." Exactly, Chinese civilians and conscripts, as well as Japanese civilians, were maltreated by Chinese soldiers.
(Part4)A set of four of pictures have appeared in the journal with the explanation, titled as "Utopia amidst the Gun-power: The 'Rising Sun' Village South of the Yangtze." The picture captioned with "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." In those days in china, the lootings are often committed by the deserted Chinese soldiers. Therefore, the farmers have needed the protection of Japanese troops to engage in farming safely.
(Part3)For instance, one of the pictures have displayed at the 'Memorial Hall of Victims in Nanking Massacre'. Chinese gave a name to the photo "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of ladies were raped and forced into military prostitution. However, this photo has appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on November 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle.
(Part2)Be careful watching Chinese propaganda videos. These kinds of films about the Nanking were distorted by the Chinese as they like. Many parts of the cruel scenes in films were acted by former Chinese. For instance, the two Chinese were killed by gun; this scene was the former Chinese soldiers killed two criminals. We can find exactly the same film in another movie. Of course, people can see many fake pictures in the Memorial Hall of Victims in Nanking Massacre.
(Part1)To Youtube watchers, I want to tell you three facts of the Chinese government. Many videos about the Nanking incidents and so on were uploaded from Chinese must be faked. Second is why the Chinese people do such an enthusiastic propaganda in you tube. The last one is scheming methods of the Chinese governments.
I do often wonder if this film and the other film The Philosophy of A Knife should have been made. Are minds are a lot more vivid than what a film can produce. I do bleive there is no film about Dr Mengalere (wrong spelling) in Auswitz so why Unit 731.
This has been flagged as spam show
Japanese are devils.. they still deny any of this ever took place. This is why Japan will never be liked by China and Korea, unlike Germany who have admitted and apologised for their atrocities and are no longer hated by the rest of Europe.
WC2002Truth 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Photographs purported to be evidence of a massacre in Nanking are on display at the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Hall, at other exhibitions, and in printed publications. However, recent scientific research has revealed that there are no photographs attesting to a massacre in Nanking. At least 143 pictures are distorted, are fabricated, or are used for the Nanking Massacre pictures which were from different areas and different times by Chinese government.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
China has no right to accuse Japan of crimes such as the Nanking Massacre because the massacre was made up story using fabricated evidence.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
where can i download this movie with subtitles
uckersas 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part2)If there had been slaughter in Nanking of a magnitude so great (300,000 civilian victims) as to prompt the description “holocaust of the century,” there is not the slightest chance that he would have been silent on the matter.
undertakerRach 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part1)Chinese Communist Party Chairman Mao Zedong never referred to a massacre in Nanking. He made exactly one mention of the Battle of Nanking during a lecture delivered at Yan’an six months after the conflict, reproduced in On Protracted War. Chairman Mao criticized the Japanese for failing to annihilate Chinese troops after having surrounded them.
undertakerRach 3 months ago
Nanking Massacre is fake.The title of the fair book on Amazon in USA and UK is "The Alleged Nanking Massacre : Japan's rebuttal to China's forged claims" .
Thank you.
SOVIETasTheINVADER 3 months ago
Please search ”The Fake of Nanking Massacre”
/watch?v=VvFk2fPHHnk
/watch?v=aefFXZhOWBQ
aojiru300 5 months ago
(Part2) About 35 foreign journalists and diplomats attended there. However, Chinese didn’t explain the fact which was so-called the Nanking Massacre even once during any of these 300 conferences was a statement or announcement.
undertakerRach 5 months ago
■(Part1)In Nov. 1937, during the Battle of Nanking, the Nationalist Party established The International Propaganda Section (IPS). According to the top-secret document entitled “Outline of International Propaganda Operations,” the IPS held 300 press conferences in Hankou between Dec 1, 1937 and Oct 24, 1938.
undertakerRach 5 months ago
City of Life and Death is a lot better than this Mou's another garbage. anyway, Nanking Masaccre is one of the biggest Japanese war crimes.
gardenstatecobra 5 months ago
(Part2)After February 1938 when the camps were dissolved, rape was rare. Therefore, we are not able to trust the crimes of Japanese soldiers just as the Chinese representatives of the refugee camps claimed. The Chinese soldiers hiding in the Safety Zone camouflaged themselves to create the impression that looting and rapes had been committed by Japanese soldiers, to practice one of a series of Chinese strategies for the purpose of throwing Japanese soldiers into confusion."
undertakerRach 7 months ago
■(Part1)Tadao Takemoto and Yasuo Ohara point out about the alleged atrocities in Nanking: "The representatives of the refugee camps of nineteen places established in the Safety Zone were all the Chinese, except Miss Minnie Vautrin. Though those Chinese took charge of the maintenance of public order in these camps, there were some Chinese officers who camouflaged themselves as if they were citizens. And many cases of rape occurred in the refugee camps.
undertakerRach 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The 228 Massacre was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947, and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government. Estimates of the number of deaths vary from ten thousand to thirty thousand or more, and Tibet and Uygure problems are the same. Why is the CCP loudly denouncing the 'Nanking Massacre' when then had insisted on it happening more than seventy years ago, but it is not even clearly defined?
undertakerRach 7 months ago
@undertakerRach TRUTH ABOUT JAPAN:
1) Don’t buy Japan’s cancer causing radiation polluted products, especially food. The Japanese government lied about the safety of their exported food products.
MaxTectonicPower 7 months ago
@undertakerRach 2) Don’t marry a Japanese person; if you do, try not to have any children because they are carrying a radiation mutated gene, resulting from the two well deserved American A-bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki to force a quick surrender of Japan ending WWII, and the recent earthquake-tsunami triggered nuclear accident at Fukushima.
MaxTectonicPower 7 months ago
@undertakerRach 3) Choose another tour destination because the radiation level is still high around Japan and the Japanese government is not forthright about the severity of the nuclear accident. If you must go for business or work, don’t forget to bring your daily dose of iodine pills, good luck.
MaxTectonicPower 7 months ago
@undertakerRach 4) Furthermore, because of the intrinsic geological condition of Japan, not to let appearances fool you, another earthquake-tsunami is imminent, not a question of “if” it happens but “when”. Keep this in mind.
MaxTectonicPower 7 months ago
Comment removed
NotHomelessAnymore 7 months ago
what is the name of the song at the end?
acroussel 8 months ago
@acroussel
band: lunatica
track: the spell
album: fable and dreams
gothvampirefr 7 months ago
For you dumbfucks who think this was faked, thats like saying the holocaust was a lie (there are actually dumbasses who believe that was faked too)
China is an awesome place and is certainly one of the nicest places in the world and so is Japan. In my opinion I believe the only people who should be looked down upon are dumbass americans like most of you guys. (Well not all of them quiet a few actually make sense.)
Startnumber5 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Startnumber5 Why Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000 when the IMTFE was opened?
Why Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for writing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?
undertakerRach 8 months ago
(Part2)/////where protests broke out after anti-Chinese riots in neighbouring Tibet a week ago. People demonstrate in support for Tibet and against violence in the Chinese region, on March 21, 2008 in Paris. (Patrick Kovarik/AFP/Getty Images)
During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese soldiers were bandits, so they killed many Chinese people. Chinese government pinned their crimes on Japanese soldiers. They even now they are the same.
undertakerRach 9 months ago
(Part1)Tibetans Say Chinese Troops Killed Many Demonstrators Reuters Mar 21, 2008
KANGDING, China—Tibetans in China's tense southwestern province of Sichuan said on Friday they believed police had killed several people in anti-Chinese demonstrations there this week, disputing official claims none died. China's communist-controlled Xinhua news agency reported overnight that police shot and wounded four protesters in a heavily ethnic Tibetan part of the province,/////
undertakerRach 9 months ago
Please ignore undertakerRach, she is just a japanese extremist. She constantly demonizes China, and claims japan is the greatest country on earth and has never done anything bad. People do bad things. Japan is no exception. To say japan hasnt done anything bad is like saying humans dont need oxygen.
SHUTUPNOOB654 9 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@SHUTUPNOOB654 According to the testimonies in The International Military Tribunal for the Far East (IMTFE), Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000. Therefore, the Chinese government was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE. In other words, the Chinese government had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence.
undertakerRach 6 months ago
■Before the entry of the Japanese, Chinese soldiers in their mad rush to discard their military uniforms and put on civilian clothes. In a number of incidents, Chinese soldiers killed their people to obtain their clothing. During the last few days, some violations of people and property were undoubtedly committed by them. James Espy, the vice American Council at Nanking, reported to the American Embassy
undertakerRach 10 months ago
@lucas1421 You keep ignoring when I tell you to watch the first in a long line of evidence. Japanese are not fucking 12 feet tall! China's "evidence states otherwise. Don't talk to me anymore. I'm tired of dealing with your chinese version of logic. Goodbye and godspeed.
Muraku666 10 months ago
@lucas1421 You ASSumed I was Japanese because I'm not swallowing your chinese shit. I know firsthand of the Chinese aggression in asia. Communism sucks, and so do you.
Muraku666 10 months ago
@Muraku666 Personal attacks do not advance your denial of historical facts in anyway. If you are an American then I have to say I am quite disappointed. Japanese people are brainwashed by their government yet the Americans have all sources of history with which they can naturally reach their conclusion. Personal attacks, along with attacks on Communism, or attacks on China will NOT nullify the historical evidence for japanese war crimes? If anything, you are a shame.
lukas1421 10 months ago
@lucas1421 actually, watch the Fake of Nanking video on youtube, where it is proven that the videos were faked. I am not Japanese. I am a white American Sailor. I know about the corpse, because the message was sent up the chain of command.
Muraku666 10 months ago
@lucas1421 The truth comes out. The problem is, I have been to China, and have seen how filthy and deceitful your people are. You can't pretend that noble shit on me. A dead baby girl's corpse was found in the filtratrion system from the river. Fuck your evil way of life. I will never condone your ways.
Muraku666 10 months ago
@Muraku666 Oh yeah? Is this the best you can do? You are such a typical japanese. When you lose, you feel embarrassed and you change the subject. I don't see you giving any evidence about the falseness of the accusations of the war crimes; instead, you are talking about some other unrelated stuff. I find your shamelessness contemptible. Using expletives in your argument isn't the sign you are such an "adult", which you accused me of not being. Do you think you are a worthy subject of debate? No.
lukas1421 10 months ago
@lukas1421 The propaganda film has been proven false. Those executioners in the film were wearing black uniforms. You can't see them in the film, but watch the fake of nanking videos to see the original. You will be shocked.
Muraku666 10 months ago
@Muraku666 I have no interest in dealing with you. You remind me of Japanese war criminals on the Far East Tribunal. Although the criminal acts had been well documented and even caputred on video, they can still shamelessly claim that they did nothing. I cannot imagine anybody more shameless than the Japanese. I cannot imagine anyone more subhuman than the japanese. As a chinese, I feel it is a disgrace that japanese have failed to learn the real ideology from China. Stilll behaving like animals
lukas1421 10 months ago
@lukas1421 How many Japanese people do you know? Nihongo shaberu? If not, be quiet while the adults are talking. I don't deal with ignorant people.
Muraku666 10 months ago
All these are true and they have been caught on film.
Japanese want to lie about it, but they can't.
lukas1421 10 months ago
It is not Japanese nature to do such things. China made the propaganda according to the way that they treat prisoners. The Japanese are incapable of commiting such acts...
Muraku666 10 months ago
@Muraku666 It is the Japanese nature to do such things. Japanese, compared with other races, are subhuman because they are capable of such acts. Even Germans cannot do it.
lukas1421 10 months ago
(Part2)Moreover, historians found Chinese government paid money to many foreigners for writing some books or newspaper articles. In fact, these myths are believed by many people in the world. How did we call this crime? We can call the Chinese government libel and slander? Yes of course! It is natural that Japanese raising an objection.
undertakerRach 10 months ago
(Part1)The Japanese want to correct wrong rumors which Chinese spread out to the world. Chinese people who are mind controlled by anti-Japanese policy after the Tiananmen Massacre in 1989, they started it, they have announced wrong myths about Japanese acts during the Sino-Japanese War ceaselessly. On the other hand, a scientific investigation with computer technology revealed that 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were edited by Chinese government.
undertakerRach 10 months ago
@undertakerRach Stop lying. Lying does not help. The footage of Nanking Massacre has been caught on film and there is extensive evidence about it. It is hard to believe that the Japanese are still trying to deny the hard cold facts.
lukas1421 10 months ago
@lukas1421 The Japanese want to correct wrong rumors which Chinese spread out to the world. Chinese people who are mind controlled by anti-Japanese policy after the Tiananmen Massacre in 1989, they started it, they have announced wrong myths about Japanese acts during the Sino-Japanese War ceaselessly. On the other hand, a scientific investigation with computer technology revealed that 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were edited by Chinese government.
undertakerRach 10 months ago
@undertakerRach Rumors? Your shamelessness is beyond my imagination. How dare you call these rumors? These are hard facts not only witnessed by countless people in China, but also caught on film. The american historians have conducted research and written books such as the "rape of nanking", which is based on primary historical evidence. If anyone is brainwashed, I think you are. Brainwashed by the right-wing japanese militarists. People like you are the reason why japanese are not liked at all
lukas1421 10 months ago
@JSLegoMaster Because I am an adult, That is not what I wish for you. I hope you have a happy life, and do not have to know hardship.
Muraku666 10 months ago
In fact, the Chinese government has killed many Tibetans. They invaded Tibet in 1950. Also they killed 190,000 Uyghurs by atomic bombs tests. The Chinese government hasn’t told these facts to the Chinese people. In March 2008, The Amnesty International U.S.A said serious human rights violations have been reported during and following the police and military crackdown on Tibetan protests in these areas.
undertakerRach 11 months ago
I'm German but i love japanese people and their culture i love their language too. they were our great allies in ww2 fuck italian cowards
TR3Y4LI4E 11 months ago
thats really sad. Makes you think what a pathetic world we live in, its sick.
malika810 11 months ago
Its verid, germany is world whide known about the brutal murder of 6 million jews, children learn that in school, often the first thing in history lesson.
But really noone knows about the japaneses killing 18 MILLION chineses, thats a shame how can that be? Their genonicide was 3 times bigger but who cares about that today??
JSLegoMaster 1 year ago
@JSLegoMaster I don't think so. Chinese governmnet loves creating false stories always.
Where were the 300,000 of dead bodies in Nanking city? Even Chinese governmnet could not show any conclusive evidence to us.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
Those were killed in times of a month, the naking massacre was not only in nanking city is was in the sourrounding areas, altrough in many otehr cities but the casualties in those are included in that what we today call "the naking massacre".
Are you trying to deny somethng here or what? Whats your opinion on the 9 million deads in the KZ (6 million jews and 3 million others) btw?
JSLegoMaster 1 year ago
@JSLegoMaster (Part1) The Nanking Massacre was a false story.
According to Summary report on the Investigation of Japanese war crimes committed in Nanking, prepared by the Procurator of the District Court in Nanking, to prepare for the IMTFE, the KMT set up the Nanking Investigation Committee for Antagonists Crime on November 7, 1945, and appealed to the Chinese public to report Japanese Army's crimes.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
Man I have seen holocaust deniers thats rude and shocking but this beats everything.... your even denying this I really wish the worse to you and your life, you deny the death of millions of ciwilians shame on you.
JSLegoMaster 1 year ago
@JSLegoMaster If China wants to blame Japan which countries commited cruel atrocity, China has to show conclusive evidence about the Nanking Massacre. Even Chinese governmnet tried to collect evidence on January 20 for Tokyo Trial, they could not. Many Chinese citizens refused to testify or to deny the massacre occurred when they were asked for details.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
@JSLegoMaster I deny them openly and proudly. Afterliving in both countrie, an understanding the nature of both cultures, I know that the Nanking Massare was faked. Even aide fom he eindence of edited photos, and random death toll estmates, it is foolish to beleve tat the Japanese would act a such.
Muraku666 10 months ago
I Hope you one day will be treatend just like the chineses in Unit 731 thats my wish for your life
JSLegoMaster 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JSLegoMaster
(Part2)It was reported, however, that few responded to the crimes committed by Japanese Army and some refused to testify or to deny the massacre occurred when they were asked for details. Then, the KMT reluctantly submitted the tentative report to the IMTFE on January 20, 1946. Except for one testimony made by a man named Lu Su, no other evidence of massacre by the Japanese Army was available, besides burial records.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Many Nanking citizens thus came back to the city, and the population increased. Would the citizens have come back to a city in which there had been a massacre?
undertakerRach 1 year ago
I'm German and i respect our Japanese allies in WW2. they were far better than Italians
TR3Y4LI4E 1 year ago
@TR3Y4LI4E Germany and Japan were caught in a trap by Sir Winston Leonard Spencer-Churchill and Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
@undertakerRach
u forgot Stalin
TR3Y4LI4E 1 year ago
@TR3Y4LI4E Glad to see genociders support one-another.
GroddGuerrilla 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
CCP brainwashed it's own people by teaching Anti -Japanese education
presenting it's people bunch of fabricated fake photos of massacres, to make them believe and force it's people to deal with it's low wage labor system.
That is how Japan apologized and to many countries in Asia only not to China.
WAKE UP Chinese people, are you still going to get enough being a slave of a communist group like CCP?
watch:
watch?v=WEH3FRaK2k0&feature=gr-ec_index
watch?v=aefFXZhOWBQ
watch?v=VvFk2fPHHnk
USFullOfLies 1 year ago
死難烈士万歳 国民党政府在雨花台曽経屠殺了三十万共産党烈士
Tha Nanking Massacre was a fake story.
南京大虐殺は嘘話である。
undertakerRach 1 year ago
Comment removed
ThaBarbarian82 1 year ago
Japan-China Tensions Rise-1 What is the Senkaku Problem? (English and Japanese)
watch?v=K7rSnO6lyDw
Japan-China Tensions Rise-2 What is the Senkaku problem? (English and Japanese)
watch?v=Dz7WnURVwrw
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part3)China and Korea said, “We have sent many vicious criminals to Japan, but Japan decided that we don’t need to get visa anymore for entering into Japan.”
All said, “Japan must be like a frigid woman.”
Japan is a patient country because China has been demonstrating of the fake story of the Nanking Massacre since 1937. When will Japan run out of patience?
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part2)Korea said,” Yes, we occupied Takeshima Islands in Japan, but Japan didn’t get angry.”
Russia said,” Yes, Japan didn’t get angry even we have not returned Kuril Islands to Japan.”
North Korea said,”OK, we will attack Japan by nuclear missiles. Japan will be angry!”
The U.S, “No, we have already tried before. Japan didn’t get angry yet.”
All said, “We have no idea what we have to do.”
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part1)This is spoken in China as a funny story.
One day, a big international conference was held in somewhere in Asia. In the conference room, Japan stood up and left from the room to get to bathroom. The other countries started to talk about Japan.
China said, “I wanted Japan to get angry, so we made our submarines enter to Japanese territorial sea boundary. Also we stole nature resources in Senkaku Islands from Japan. However, Japan didn’t get angry.”
undertakerRach 1 year ago
EX-CHINESE OFFICERS AMONG U.S. REFUGEES Colonel and His Aides Admit Blaming the Japanese for Crimes in Nanking New York Times January 4, 1938
undertakerRach 1 year ago
the japanese levels of remorse stagger me
SephXIII88 1 year ago
Asians kill Asians all the time it's nothing new
TheAfghanboy15 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why Chinese government edited at least 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum?
undertakerRach 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part2/2)Why did not Mao announce about the massacre in the international mass media conference from 1937 to 1938? Why Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000 when the IMTFE was opened? Why Chinese government edited at least 147 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum?
undertakerRach 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part1/2)Where were 300,000 of dead bodies? Why did many Chinese people come back to Nanking after Japanese occupied the city? Why did Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for editing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?
undertakerRach 1 year ago
is this film available online anywhere? watch-movies has failed me....
Unit731ScottishArrow 1 year ago
(Part2) 『To my mind, this should not concern us Germans, particularly since one can clearly see that the Chinese, once left to depend solely on the Japanese, immediately fraternize. And as for all these excesses, one hears only one side of it, after all.』
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part1)John Rabe, who had never witnessed even one case of murder, sent a false report to Hitler by saying The number of victims I Nanking city were 50000 to 60000. P. Scharfienberg, the secretary general of the German Embassy to China, who returned to Nanking city on January 9, tried to investigate the fact about 'Japanese Army's atrocities Rabe reported' by himself, and wrote to the German Embassy at Hankow on February 10:
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part4)Some Chinese mad because they have believed the mass media report which said criminal must be Japanese. Why did Chinese officials report so without definite proof? After 2 years, how Chinese officials found syringes in the river? Why have they taken for investigation for 2 years? Have Chinese officials waited people become less interesting the news? This strategy is the same as the so-called Nanking Massacre.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part3)Japanese investigators have insisted that the evidence indicated that the dumplings were most likely contaminated in China for two years. Finally, Chinese officials have admitted the pesticide methamidophos had been mixed into the product in that country, after repeated previous denials. The criminal is Lu Yueting, who was a temporary employee at the Tianyang Food Plant based in northern China's Hebei Province. He mixed poison to Gyoza with syringes, and he threw the syringes to river.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part2)At that time, Chinese officials said, no problems were detected at gyoza factory and it passed 24 quality checks since February 2007. In short, they strongly denied it causes China in 2008. Needless to say, the frozen gyozas were found to have traces of methamidophos, a pesticide banned in Japan. Chinese officials had appealed enthusiastically that the gyoza may have been contaminated deliberately in Japan before they caught criminal, so Chinese people believed the criminal must be Japan.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
(Part1)In April, 2010, Chinese police have apprehended a 36-year-old man who allegedly poisoned frozen "gyoza" dumplings that were exported to Japan and sickened 10 people, the official Xinhua news agency said, quoting the Ministry of Public Security. After eating shop-bough instant frozen gyoza (dumplings), 10 people are reported to have experienced nausea, dizziness in Japan. One of the victims—a five-year-old girl went into a coma.
undertakerRach 1 year ago
Fucking japs
Sora2557 1 year ago
(Part2)However, these collections show no evidence of any vigorous critical attempt to distinguish between valid primary materials and other materials: photographs, for instance, which are known to be fabricated, or from different areas and different times, continue to be used to "prove" Japanese guilt in the winter of 1937-38 at Nanjing.
The Nanjing Incident Recent Research and Trends by David Askew
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part1)The majority of academic research on the Nanjing Incident is conducted in Japanese, English and Chinese. Of the three language groups, Japanese has produced the most sophisticated research, with the debate in English lagging decades behind. The most objective Chinese language materials are the collections of various primary sources, including the recollections of many of the Chinese military personnel in Nanjing.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part3)What MATSUI said, "It was really a shameful incident" after receiving the death penalty by the IMTFE, meant that he expressed his regret at the existence of ten and several soldiers, in spite of the small number, who committed the shameful crimes like looting and rapes as soldiers of the Japanese Army. Furthermore, he kept denying it in the IMTFE to the last moment that the Japanese Army committed the systematic massacre in Nanking.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part2)Even though the crimes committed were small in number, it must have been unbearable for him to hear of the crimes committed by Japanese soldiers, as he always spoke of stern military discipline. The court-martial was held and more than ten soldiers were punished according to the policy of MATSUI who always said, "The looting and the rapes should be punished."
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part1)As General Matsui said, "according to what I heard," he must have heard it from someone who had read the documents (complaints) submitted by the Safety Zone Committee. Aware of this, MATSUI emphasized the importance of thoroughly obeying military discipline during his speech made in the presence of chiefs of staffs of various divisions under his command, at the memorial service held on December 18.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part4)Definitely, the Chinese government is afraid of occur a democratization movement such as the Tiananmen massacre in 1989. As you know there are many human rights problem in Tibet and Uygure, etc. Thats why the government uses anti-Japanese education to kids. As a result, Chinese people firmly refuse the true facts. In other words, Chinese people are mind controlled by Chinese government. At least 143 pictures about so-called Nanking massacre are distorted by the Chinese government.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part2)Also, one of the photos is in Korea and in the Nanking Museum are the same. The book name is The record of the abduction of Koreans, 1st edition which was written by Park Kyung-Sik. The photo in the book says these dead bodies were Korean children slaughtered by brigands, and this picture was taken in Korea. This is exhibited without this caption in the Nanking Massacre Museum. Chinese government desires the Nanking massacre was happened by Japanese.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part1) More than 143 pictures are distorted by the Chinese government. In addition, one of the photos, which show many people's bones in the land, have displayed in the Nanking museum. The Chinese put an explanation. The explanation said these bones were Chinese victims. They were killed by Japanese.
However, we have seen different photos in every visit. In other words, the picture is added more and more bones. Definitely, Chinese authorities have showed pictures which was trimmed by them.
oddballrach 1 year ago
Among the records in the aforementioned Documents of the Safety Zone are detailed complaints about misconduct attributed to Japanese military personnel. They include a total of 26 murders, only one of which was witnessed (to that account is appended a note describing the murder as a lawful execution). Also, recent research has proven that there is absolutely no basis for the claim that there was a massacre in that city. How does China claim that 300,000 Chinese were killed by Japanese?
oddballrach 1 year ago
Lastly,there are hundreds of photographs
thousands of eye witness accounts,
dozens of mass graves.
The IMTFF found 155000 burials,
this does not take into account those bodies lost in the river or destroyed by burning.
Two japanese divisions and naval shore parties could easily kill 7k people per day.
Recently declassified us documents estimate a further 500000 chinese were massacred in the area approaching nanking.
Hirohito(he of unit 731 fame)and asaka
bear full responsibility,
canaerequiem 1 year ago
The nazi john rabe(siemens)testifies to the atrocities,while co-ordinating a safe zone for over 100 thousand people.
Even general matsui iwane admitted as much under interrogation.
The population of nanking had steadily risen throughout the 30s as it had replaced peking as the chinese capital,
and as the japanese drew nearer tens of thousand of civilian refugees and upward of 100 thousand chinese soldiers
swelled the city.
Revisionist history by the uneducated is useless,remember it .
canaerequiem 1 year ago
canaerequiem
(Part0)
I am afraid to say you wrong.
oddballrach 1 year ago
There is ample testimony,not only by witnesses such as John Magee. George A. Fitch, Lewis Smythe ,James McCallum , Dr Robert Wilson,and searle bates,but also evidence from confessions made by japanese soldiers,also the testimony of the chinese photographic developer who,at great risk to his self made copies of film given to him to develop by japanese soldiers during the period of the massacre.
These are testimonies produced in court
immediately after the war,you cannot deny them.
canaerequiem 1 year ago
(Part10)Chinese government said Japanese Military killed 300,000 persons over a period of six weeks. In short, the Japanese are accused of having murdered 7,000 people each day. It is ridiculous. One of the pictures shows that Japanese soldiers were having a pleasant chat with Chinese citizens who are wearing armbands of the flag of Japan in Nanking. This photo was taken on 20, Dec. 1937, seven days after the occupation, and published in the pictorial book, Shina-jihen Shasin Zensyu, in 1938.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part9) Also, he confessed what he himself witnessed was nothing. The Daily Reports of Serious Injuries to Civilians said the only killing witnessed by foreigners in Nanking was only one lawful execution. Also, the IMTFE showed Chinese could not prove the murder of 300,000. Therefore, the Chinese was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE has opened. In short, the Chinese had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part8) The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle, and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. Moreover, according to The Documents of Magee, member of TSZC, referred the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179. He testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents'. However, this number 179 was including rumor.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part7)Tell the truth, people could kill 300,000 people and raped 80,000 women? They stayed in the Nanking only 6 weeks in Dec 1937. The citys population was 200,000, according to foreigners who were there at the time. TSZC(The Safety Zone Committee) documents read that in Jan 1938 the population was 250,000. Also, here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (The International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part6) The reason for Japan staying in China was the Boxer Protocol which was signed on Sep.7, 1901 between the China and the 8-Nation Alliance which including Japan. Japan was attacked by KMT in Shanghai. KMT shelled into the Japanese camp 4 times. People called this Marco Polo Bridge Incident which was happened on July 7, 1937. This incident signified to open the war. Chiang Kai-shek escaped to Nanking. Thats why Japanese chased him to Nanking city.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part5) The section was propaganda section in China during the War. Timperley was paid by the propaganda section for editing the book. This Timperley fact based on the book which is called 曽虚白自伝(Page 201), which means曽虚白 Diary. 曽虚白 was also one of the members of the Propaganda section. In fact, at least 143 of pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were distorted by the propaganda section.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part4)During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese victims couldnt receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chiang said, You can get medical treatment for free in hospitals if you said Japanese injured you. Thats why there is much verbal evidence about the battles. One of the foundation upon which the massacre myth is based on the book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley. But he was an advisor to the Chinese Nationalist governments Ministry of Information.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part3)According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, one of the Americans said, Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead. 'There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part2)Thats why Chinese people called CPC, Mao soldiers, 共匪 which means communists pirates because they raped many women, plunder many towns, and murdered. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." In fact, The 228 Incident, also known as the 228 Massacre, was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part1)During the Shino-Japanese war, Chinese military killed Chinese people as if they were a worm. One of the Chinese men whose name was梁啓超 called Chinese people戮民, which means never mind people die for victory.The Chinese military characteristics were the same not only KMT (Kuomintang, Chiang Kai-shek) but also CPC (Mao Tse-tung ). CPC acted more brutally than KMT.
oddballrach 1 year ago
all who think this is not true must explain to me the pictures of Japanese troops gutting, burying, shooting people, and cutting women's guts out. Please explain. I would like to know. All u people are saying are lies. There are even victims of the massacre! And do not underestimate these people. Humans can do very horrific and nasty things that are unimaginable
TheArthurChow 1 year ago
(Part4)Definitely, the Chinese government is afraid of occur a democratization movement such as the Tiananmen massacre in 1989. Thats why the government uses anti-Japanese education to kids. As a result, Chinese people firmly refuse the true facts. In other words, Chinese people are mind controlled by Chinese government. At least 147 pictures about so-called Nanking massacre are distorted by the Chinese government.
oddballrach 1 year ago
@oddballrach Guess what?! u sound just like the germans that claimed 1 they didnt know about the holocaust, 2 that hitler had nothing to do with it and 3 that it didnt even happen! get over it ur nation did some disgraceful things it wasn't the first time, and as TheArthurChow said explain some of the pictures like woman havin had bayonets shoved in their vagina or better still the countless american priests there that witnessed this and sent letters home describing all they saw!
Taken31300 1 year ago
(Part1)Do you know how much the Safety Zone Committee was aware of looting in the Nanking? According to documents of Magee, member of the Safety Zone Committee, so far referred to in this paper, those demonstrated the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179 including those in rumor.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part2)Although Magee, member of the Safety Zone Committee, testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents', he confessed in the cross-examination, what he himself witnessed was nothing but one case that 'a Japanese soldier deprived of some electric ice boxes.
oddballrach 1 year ago
Part3)Also, this very photo has been taken by Correspondent KUMASAKI (Japanese)in the province of Paoshan in the vicinity of Shanghai, on October 14, 1937.
In short, a scene of peaceful farming village has been secretly switched to the one that is taking villagers to somewhere prior to rape en masse. It is indeed a wicked act of secretly switching the picture. You know, this is the usual measures of China Government. Government miss led Chinese people, Chinese people are not wrong.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(part2)A set of four of pictures have appeared in the journal with the explanation, titled as "Utopia amidst the Gun-power: The 'Rising Sun' Village South of the Yangtze." The picture captioned with "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." In those days in china, the lootings are often committed by the deserted Chinese soldiers. Therefore, the farmers have needed the protection of Japanese troops to engage in farming safely.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part1)One of the pictures have displayed at the 'Memorial Hall of Victims in Nanking Massacre'. Chinese gave a name to the photo "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of ladies were raped and forced into military prostitution. However, this photo has appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on November 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part10)Chinese government said Japanese Military killed 300,000 persons over a period of six weeks. In short, the Japanese are accused of having murdered 7,000 people each day. It is ridiculous. One of the pictures shows that Japanese soldiers were having a pleasant chat with Chinese citizens who are wearing armbands of the flag of Japan in Nanking. This photo was taken on 20, Dec. 1937, seven days after the occupation, and published in the pictorial book, Shina-jihen Shasin Zensyu, in 1938.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part9) Also, he confessed what he himself witnessed was nothing. The Daily Reports of Serious Injuries to Civilians said the only killing witnessed by foreigners in Nanking was only one lawful execution. Also, the IMTFE showed Chinese could not prove the murder of 300,000. Therefore, the Chinese was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE has opened. In short, the Chinese had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part8) The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle, and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. Moreover, according to The Documents of Magee, member of TSZC, referred the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179. He testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents'. However, this number 179 was including rumor.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part7)Tell the truth, people could kill 300,000 people and raped 80,000 women? They stayed in the Nanking only 6 weeks in Dec 1937. The citys population was 200,000, according to foreigners who were there at the time. TSZC(The Safety Zone Committee) documents read that in Jan 1938 the population was 250,000. Also, here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (The International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part6) The reason for Japan staying in China was the Boxer Protocol which was signed on Sep.7, 1901 between the China and the 8-Nation Alliance which including Japan. Japan was attacked by KMT in Shanghai. KMT shelled into the Japanese camp 4 times. People called this Marco Polo Bridge Incident which was happened on July 7, 1937. This incident signified to open the war. Chiang Kai-shek escaped to Nanking. Thats why Japanese chased him to Nanking city.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part5) The section was propaganda section in China during the War. Timperley was paid by the propaganda section for editing the book. This Timperley fact based on the book which is called 曽虚白自伝(Page 201), which means曽虚白 Diary. 曽虚白 was also one of the members of the Propaganda section. In fact, at least 143 of pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were distorted by the propaganda section.
oddballrach 1 year ago
Part4)During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese victims couldnt receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chiang said, You can get medical treatment for free in hospitals if you said Japanese injured you. Thats why there is much verbal evidence about the battles. One of the foundation upon which the massacre myth is based on the book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley. But he was an advisor to the Chinese Nationalist governments Ministry of Information.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part3)According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, one of the Americans said, Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead. 'There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.
(
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part2)Thats why Chinese people called CPC, Mao soldiers, 共匪 which means communists pirates because they raped many women, plunder many towns, and murdered. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." In fact, The 228 Incident, also known as the 228 Massacre, was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part1)During the Shino-Japanese war, Chinese military killed Chinese people as if they were a worm. One of the Chinese men whose name was梁啓超 called Chinese people戮民, which means never mind people die for victory.The Chinese military characteristics were the same not only KMT (Kuomintang, Chiang Kai-shek) but also CPC (Mao Tse-tung ). CPC acted more brutally than KMT.
oddballrach 1 year ago
(Part5)This has been conducted during the period of December 24, 1937, through January 5, 1938, in order to identify the citizens, separating them from the soldiers. We can observe that the Chinese people shown in the pictures aren't in fear of the Japanese soldiers at all. The most of the people who have been involved in the Nanking battle say that they have never witnessed such acts of massacre. There are many other testimonies recorded besides them.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Pat4)Moreover the Asahi Newspaper shows a series of photos taken almost in the same time. Among them, one photo which was taken by Asahi correspondent KAWAMURA on the l7th, showing unarmed Japanese soldiers taking a walk on the street. Another photo shows a barber stall operating. Also, a film called Nanking, produced by TOHO Film Production, shows a crowd of inhabitants coming to get ID cards at the card issuing office opened in the Safety Zone by the Japanese Army.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part3)SATO Shinju, correspondent of the Tokyo NichiNichi, has taken the photos on December 15 and l6, 1937, at the Safety Zone within the walled city where Chinese inhabitants were opening the street stalls. Among these photos, there is one showing a Food stall held by a Chinese refugee where a Japanese soldier was eating as the inhabitants, including women and children watching him. Also, there are other photos showing many stall vendors selling vegetables and used clothes.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part2)One of the photos has been taken by SATO Shinju. It shows an aspect of the walled city of December 15, two days after the fall of Nanking. Surprisingly, at the Safety Zone located in the west side of Chungshan North Road, street stalls such as boiled Chinese dumpling sellers have still more been opening. A Japanese soldier has been the first customer. It is apparent that the Japanese occupation has recovered the public order.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part1)There are some clearly opposite historical documents against the existence of such large-scale murders, Chinese have claimed. For example, one is the photographic and documentary films. Also, there are some opposite data against the existence of such large-scale murders even within the documents, which they have presented as the evidence. Furthermore, some of the actions, which the then KMT has taken, are difficult to comprehend if there have been such large-scale murders.
oddballrach 2 years ago
So what you're saying is that the Japanese didnt really do all the killing the world thought they did? Am I right or not?
AlfieWilRus 1 year ago
(part0) The Nanking Massacre was faked for these reasons.
oddballrach 1 year ago
So what are you saying please explain them more clearly
AlfieWilRus 1 year ago
The Chinese government is consisted of a bunch of people who do not hesitate to commit murder their people. When the atomic bombs tests succeeded in Uyghur, scientists jumped for joy. 190,000 Uyghur died by the tests. Moreover, the Yellow River flood was created by the Nationalist Government in central China in 1938. Before Chiang Kai-shek ordered the Yellow River Flood, he did not tell to the people, therefore, the flood waters took an estimated Chinese 500,000 lives. This is the China.
oddballrach 2 years ago
That justifies the Japanese war crimes in Nanking? Or do you simply avoid the issue by talking about irrelevancies in effort to both blame and smear the victim of you sick motherf*ckers?
JNagarya 2 years ago
戦時中、中国人民の本当の敵は日本軍ではなく、中国軍だった。そしてそれは今でも同じだ。
During the war, Chinese people's enemy was The Chinese military. Even now, peaceful Chinese are in the same situation.
戰時,中國人民真的對手並不是日軍,而是中共解放軍(或國民政府軍), 而且現在也是一樣的.
oddballrach 2 years ago
oddballrach, I know what you mean by gov't propaganda. All governments do it and the people believe unless they go looking for the truth. Then they are called liberals. I have debated this and the US terrorist nuclear attack on Japan with a friend. People only believe what is in the mainstream books or on CNN. Thanks for trying to tell the truth though.
ReligionisaCult 2 years ago
You mesn, of course, you have to lie against China in effort to avid the issue: the JKapanese war crimes committed against Nanking -- which is the issue of this video and thread. Were you not dishonest you wouldn't smear the victim. You wouldn't, in a word, LIE.
JNagarya 2 years ago
(Part10) To Youtube watchers thank you for reading my comments. In conclusion, the China government hardly cracks down on an anti-government movement. Definitely, they make a false charge against Japan for their countrys safe. The Japan was made a scapegoat!! One of the Chinese governors says we should use Japan at least 100 years more.
People have known at least 147 of pictures were distorted by the Chinese government.
oddballrach 2 years ago
You're an illiterate liar.
JNagarya 2 years ago
(Part9)Finally, I want to tell you about scheming methods of the Chinese government. Chinese people are not wrong because they have no chance to get right history. In fact, school books in Beijing leave out significant historical events including the 1989 Tiananmen Square democracy demonstrations in which Chinese troops killed thousands of unarmed protestors, and the three-year famine between 1958 and 1961 when communist policies led to the starvation of an estimated 30 million Chinese.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part8)Even though the pictures and videos were not related to Nanking incident, they dont care. Even though the pictures were not shown any Japanese, they dont care. Even though the people put on short sleeve T-shuts in the pictures, they say these pictures were taken in the Nanking! The Japanese came to the Nanking city in November in 1937!! They just want Japanese are in troubles. The Chinese says these pictures are evidence of Japanese massacred in the Nanking! It is ridiculous!
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part7)While the Chinese people are criticizing to Japan, the government is safe. Thats why the government has taught anti-Japanese education to the Chinese kids in school. Some Chinese are ignited or made angry to Japan by anti-Japanese education. They have found any cruel pictures even though the pixs are not related Japan, and they put caption which are written like Japanese committed atrocity. Then they uploaded the videos to the YouTube.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(part6) For example, the Chinese raped many ladies and killed their people such as the Tungchow Mutiny on 29 July 1937 and Yellow River Flood in June 1938, and so on. Even now, they have dominated Tibetans and Uyghur. Many Chinese dont know these facts because the government has concealed the facts from people for making safe their government. Exactly, the government afraid the next the Tiananmen Massacre occur. It was happened in 1989 in China.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part5) Secondly, why the Chinese people do such an enthusiastic propaganda in you tube. In fact, the former two of Chinese governments killed many their people than Japanese. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." Exactly, Chinese civilians and conscripts, as well as Japanese civilians, were maltreated by Chinese soldiers.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part4)A set of four of pictures have appeared in the journal with the explanation, titled as "Utopia amidst the Gun-power: The 'Rising Sun' Village South of the Yangtze." The picture captioned with "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." In those days in china, the lootings are often committed by the deserted Chinese soldiers. Therefore, the farmers have needed the protection of Japanese troops to engage in farming safely.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part3)For instance, one of the pictures have displayed at the 'Memorial Hall of Victims in Nanking Massacre'. Chinese gave a name to the photo "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of ladies were raped and forced into military prostitution. However, this photo has appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on November 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle.
oddballrach 2 years ago
(Part2)Be careful watching Chinese propaganda videos. These kinds of films about the Nanking were distorted by the Chinese as they like. Many parts of the cruel scenes in films were acted by former Chinese. For instance, the two Chinese were killed by gun; this scene was the former Chinese soldiers killed two criminals. We can find exactly the same film in another movie. Of course, people can see many fake pictures in the Memorial Hall of Victims in Nanking Massacre.
oddballrach 2 years ago
我操你妈逼!
vickiejiang 2 years ago
(Part1)To Youtube watchers, I want to tell you three facts of the Chinese government. Many videos about the Nanking incidents and so on were uploaded from Chinese must be faked. Second is why the Chinese people do such an enthusiastic propaganda in you tube. The last one is scheming methods of the Chinese governments.
oddballrach 2 years ago
Evidence! Evidence! That is what we need.
HariRina 2 years ago
As long as those slit eyed Motherfuckers make sushi with Cream Cheese and Seaweed, Im not saying shit against them
raggamuffin713t 2 years ago
fuck those pigs!!!
BobBlobOfFancyPants 2 years ago
I do often wonder if this film and the other film The Philosophy of A Knife should have been made. Are minds are a lot more vivid than what a film can produce. I do bleive there is no film about Dr Mengalere (wrong spelling) in Auswitz so why Unit 731.
jamesaellis 2 years ago
do you have more parts or is there directions at the end i couldnt read them clearly.
shoothelpmeany1 2 years ago
i weep for those lost at nanking
seegrub62 2 years ago 9
i bet japanese will never do such movie to remind us agian the pass
taiwanlong 2 years ago 11