The orchestra is not together at the big chord at 3:54 (timpani comes in early). Maybe if Karajan would make a bit more eye contact with the players, they would be more together.
Lack of rehearsal. Karajan's conducting style is somewhat vague and spiritual, so he and orchestra require more rehearsal to develop consensus. Maybe that was why he worked with only 17 orchestras in his lifetime. He spent more than 30 years training BPO into what he wanted to hear, and now we can see Rattle already ruined it. (Just kidding. You know I love you, Sir Rattle)
People are weird. When Abbado was in charge of BPO, people missed Karajan. Now Rattle is in charge of BPO, people missed Abbado (though he is still alive).
I think when new music director appointed couple years later, people will miss Rattle.
(So don't take my comment too seriously, Sir Rattle. It's human psychology)
Mozart, Schubert, Mahler, Brucnker, Strauss, Karajan !!! Tutti i grandi giganti austriaci che hanno regalato con impegno e generosità tanta sublime poesia e un altissimo "quid estetico" nella musica, nell'arte e nella cultura di tutti i tempi, per tutta l'intera Umanità ! Niente da aggiungere ! Tanti capolavori per i sogni e le gioie dell'anima di noi ascoltatori !!!!!!!!!!! ONORE E GLORIA A LORO !!!!!!!!!
Beethoven's 11th !
nevertheless123 1 day ago
Thanks For This Videos Men.
asteromax 1 month ago
01:50
gr4l9um20b7o 1 month ago 3
yes, it is too fast. my most used recording is Giulini with the Chicago symphony orchestra, made in 1976
and i deeply admire Celibidache for his Bruckner
Strefanasha 1 month ago
If i go to Vienna again, i will definitely choose to listen to Bruckner's symphoney no.9 in this wonderful concert hall :-)
Cherylyuennable 3 months ago
ΕΠΙΚΟ
VOVOUSAMAN 3 months ago
Leave it to Herb & Co. KG. to get all of these sacred sounds just right!
magister62 3 months ago
What a beautiful hall. One day I'll hear a concert there.
elainebmack 4 months ago 2
Much to fast!
Tobias15111985 4 months ago
Comment removed
yenhoho 5 months ago
5:13 is one of the most mysteriously beautiful passages in Bruckner's whole repertoire.
jonathanaconway 5 months ago
No pgk that's the way it is read dude.Bruckner is tough on a reader.see Mahler 3 and you'll get it.Just thinking.
TheTherese3 5 months ago
The orchestra is not together at the big chord at 3:54 (timpani comes in early). Maybe if Karajan would make a bit more eye contact with the players, they would be more together.
pgk7285 6 months ago
@pgk7285
Lack of rehearsal. Karajan's conducting style is somewhat vague and spiritual, so he and orchestra require more rehearsal to develop consensus. Maybe that was why he worked with only 17 orchestras in his lifetime. He spent more than 30 years training BPO into what he wanted to hear, and now we can see Rattle already ruined it. (Just kidding. You know I love you, Sir Rattle)
yenhoho 5 months ago
@yenhoho
Was't there someone in between Karajan and Rattle, with very specific ideas about orchestra sound on his own? Babbado, or Abblado, or something?
herodot2 5 months ago
@herodot2
It's Claudio Abbado.
People are weird. When Abbado was in charge of BPO, people missed Karajan. Now Rattle is in charge of BPO, people missed Abbado (though he is still alive).
I think when new music director appointed couple years later, people will miss Rattle.
(So don't take my comment too seriously, Sir Rattle. It's human psychology)
yenhoho 5 months ago 2
wow thats just fantastic ! i really love it!
BigPapa4481 7 months ago
Unbelievable, Karajan is wonderful with Bruckner, thank you very much...
jorgeuribeclar 7 months ago
@jorgeuribeclar Karajan is best in Bruckner ( not Beethoven, Brahms or Mozart) also good in Richard Strauss.
MrAlgykcho 7 months ago
Neben den Aufführungen von Wand für mich die beste "Interpretation" von Bruckners neunter.
Jetztsofortable2 8 months ago
.....eine einzigartige Welt der fantastischen Klänge....
ChrissysVideokids 8 months ago
Someone once said of Bruckner, "His symphonies are beautiful cathedrals of sound".
SymphonyBrahms 9 months ago 2
Mozart, Schubert, Mahler, Brucnker, Strauss, Karajan !!! Tutti i grandi giganti austriaci che hanno regalato con impegno e generosità tanta sublime poesia e un altissimo "quid estetico" nella musica, nell'arte e nella cultura di tutti i tempi, per tutta l'intera Umanità ! Niente da aggiungere ! Tanti capolavori per i sogni e le gioie dell'anima di noi ascoltatori !!!!!!!!!!! ONORE E GLORIA A LORO !!!!!!!!!
darkblueangel1956 9 months ago 2
Absolutely one of the best classical works ever. At the same level as Beethovens 3rd 1.movement or Mozarts 21 piano concerto 1st movement.
rkj1963 10 months ago 2
increíble!!!!!!!!!!!!!
serpucc 1 year ago 13
Oh!Epic masterpiece!!EPIC!!
THEMGOROTH75 1 year ago 8