Goodbye Carly Smithson Jesus Christ Superstar Studio version

[TheNicosMC8]

unica carly

[ingram4heisman10]

I wanna hear her voice on the radio.

[SG1lover14]

our YOuth Pastor showed us part of this movie (Jesus Christ Superstar 1973) today. it is hilarious!

[yayo1234ful]

Carly Smithson, with a vOice like that.. yOu surely gOtta` gO all the way tO the top..

[saraaax38]

i loved this.

i cannot believe she got voted off after this amazing proformance. she is amaazing.

[middlekid95]

she should have definitly stayed MUCH MUCH longer...

[COOLCAT440]

is this song sacreligious?

[patricia2big]

Carly should NOT have been taken out! I think it's because she's not American. What is wrong with the minds of Americans these days? I thought she was gona make it to the top 3.... *sigh*

[Wikoli12]

i can agree that she should have been in the top 3 but it's called "American Idol"

[underwear90s]

me too,

maybe it's because this song had to do with catholosism and all those douchbags who aren't catholic thought this was racist

[Numba1AdamLambertFan]

No, I'm Jewish, and I voted for her and David Archuleta non-stop that night! David Archuleta is my #1 and Carly Smithson and David Cook are tied at #2.

So are you calling me a douchbag because I'm not Christian? THAT'S racist.

[underwear90s]

im wasnt saying EVERYONE who isn't catholic was racist! im saying that there are a lot of people who feel offended that one religion is noted while theirs isn't. i have expiriances from this from my school were we can't express our religion, and if we did, we have to recognize everyones religion.

by the way: im not catholic either.

[Albertorey1966]

true !

[lupi0525]

She sounds so good on studio!

[cbotten106]

Carly is way, way too good for the viewing audience of American Idol. They didn't get, didn't comprehend, a talent of this magnitude. The people who see the Idol Tour might get Carly Smithson better live.

[MissJackieOlsen]

Hey! I LOVE CARLY AND I WACH AMERICAN IDOL!

[lottavideo]

if this came down to the christian vote..then it proves that crazy religious people are everything thats wrong with the world.

[0guitarplayer0]

she should have won

[JasonCastroFan797]

I love Carly but lets keep the negativity to ourselves

[JasonCastroFan797]

rock on carly!

[fjaoaoaoao]

i think it is possible that a lot of christians heard this song, and wondered about its message, so they didn't vote for her.

[JasonCastroFan797]

i'm christian, and i voted for her

[sanjayalover26]

i'm a christian and i love this song and i voted for her! i wanted her to get to the top 3! i still say that she was robbed!

[alluvah18]

i love carly

[Jenniferiffic]

Ugh. America's retarded.

And fat.

[BlingyDamon3]

well put jenniferiffic

fat and retarted indeed

at least she and michael had the last laugh at the finale

[cbotten106]

Carly is my American Idol, well technically she's Irish but still come on this is pretty freaking awesome.

[linzlinz27]

I can't believe she was voted off after such a GREAT song/performance! And to allll those people who said this was sacreligious need to understand it's just a song!

[MrProdigy555]

Carly and Syesha are the best contest of this season..but america is stupid and neither one of them will win..its a BIG shame...That would have been an AMAZING finale with Syesha and Carly

[rEtRoStArEmO]

i am Filipino,

but i think all American Female

are beautiful.

she's irish...

she's awesome!

beautiful!

[rEtRoStArEmO]

i love this version.

[rEtRoStArEmO]

i love carly smithson.

i was shocked when she was voted out!

[lilypotter66]

BOO Jason!

Go Carly!

Jason should be out, not Carly... : (

[cbotten106]

Love this "Irish girls" voice.

[lico909]

American idol really now is a popularity contest because they pick the talentless but charming Castro instead of the talented and beautiful Carly Smithson she supposed to be int he top 2 with david cook

but really they make a huge mistake eliminating her such a great talent

Carly is the next doughty

and i hope they make carly a movie just like what they did to kelly clarkson and justin

but carly's movie would be from david to carly

and i mean david cook not the archuleta

[gabz97]

i agree with you about carly, but david archleta is WAY better than david cook and all those other contestents with no talent. (syiesha , david cook, and jason castro).

[seano287]

No talent? Syesha is a very good singer. David Cook is way over rated, and Jason just plain sucks.

[lilypotter66]

Syesha's a great singer, Jason is horrible, Carly's great, David A. is getting boring, Brooke was a great singer, but she messed up a lot in live performances, and David Cook is AMAZING.

[minionoftwig]

you are SO right, its unbelievable.

[xXcyndil006Xx]

i like your idea!!!

[xXcyndil006Xx]

Carly kicked butt!!!!!!!!!11

FIRST MICHEAL NOW HER GEROFFFFFFFF

[cbotten106]

She generally held back on the Idol Studio versions and delivered the big vocals on the show. The music here on the studio is way less dynamic too. Still it is good.

[amlissa]

Gosh, she's SO MUCH better live.

When she gets ready to make her album, they need to find a way to bring aspects of her live performances in. Overly produced.

[LiLIrishChick63]

MUCH better than the live version. when she sang it live i felt like she screamed some of it. this sounded AMAZING! sad to see her go. there's others that should have left before her.

[voyager017]

c'mon lets protest.. we want carly back ang brook out!!!

[00thelemonsong]

This was really good. It's a shame that narrow-minded Christian bigots had to take offence to this wonderful song.

[vsilver839]

Its a shame that the jhudges didn't give her enough credit and that the producers just pimp David A (like how they cut away from him when he flubbed his lyrics).

[flutteringflake]

I'm a christian, and I don't know a single christian that was offended by the song.

It's a shame that narrow-minded "non-christian bigots" have to blame Carly's elimination on christians.

[00thelemonsong]

I'm a christian, for your information. I, personally, know many idiots who took offence to the lyrics in this song, and this is what I was talking about. I don't believe those people who felt it was an insult were true christians. So, I don't know why you're pointing the finger at me.

[irishsweethearttx]

I am still in shock. Carly Smithson shouldn't of even been in the bottom 2. It should have been Brook or Jason. With Brook going. I am going to miss CARLY, the only think Im happy about is that she left with pride and dignity, instead of tears. I want her back!

[mermcc]

I love Carly......she grew on me, and she was definitely one of the top 3 talents. I can't wait to see her and David Cook rock out on a duet.....hopefully when they tour!

[wcotton]

Carly has a fine voice, but for some reason I could never warm up to her.

[itsaMASQUERADE]

GREAT STUDIO VERSION! CONGRATS TO CARLY! SHE HAD THE BEST FAREWELL SONG EVER! IT WAS DEFINITELY THE JESUS THING. IT ONLY TAKES A FEW % PTS. TO CHANGE THINGS. SHE WAS STRONG & HAPPY TOO. U WOULD B SURPRISED HOW MANY PEOPLE HATE THAT. 2008 WAS A GREAT IDOL SEASON. I LOVED ALL THE SINGERS. my opinion : 1. CARLY SMITHSON 2. DAVID COOK 3. DAVID ARCHULETA 4. SYESHA MERCADO 5. BROOKE WHITE 6. MICHAEL JOHNS 7. KRISTY LEE COOK 8. JASON CASTRO 9. AMANDA 10. RAMIELE

[whuhumuch]

uh i agree al ot this is how it should of gone i think carly is one of the best singers ever on this show and i think she should of one bc she is the only one who deserves it

[xoBrittRenee]

Carly does have a great voice : ) annoying popularity for this years AI. I think Carly should have stayed.

[canadiangirl2907]

wow...this WAS amazing. I cant believe she went home...shudda been jason castro.

[paperroses101]

ya I totally agree!

[FASI0NxxFEVER]

agreed!

[lvu16]

brooke shouldve went

[FASI0NxxFEVER]

yeah her or jason

[frenzypunka]

Brooke u suck!! U should go instead of Carly! It's a definite popularity contest with no talent since Jason & Brooke r still in! They can't sing! I don't think anyone except for DC deserves to win! Carly hv always bn a winner! She's awesome as a singer, performer and definitely an entertainer. She's the gal with huge potential, talented and hv an awesome personality. I hope she do well in the music industry! Can't wait for her album to be release! Im sure it will b a blast! Love ya Carly!

[lAuthenticl]

popularity vote so unfair for carly!

[Gaiapersephone]

now I love Brooke, but she deserved to go more than Carly. Maybe Jason too, but he IS very charming:) Sorry Carly...you are a damn fine singer:)

[LittlexDrummerxGirl3]

Wow! Very nice!

[feedbackfeedback]

I miss her, I adore her! But I know this is only the start of her career!!

[KodyXSacrifice]

I will not watch American Idol again.

[07madridista07]

This season is over for me, but I might come back next season. Her exit ruins the show.

[geekoftheweek27]

This is freakin awesome. She was great on the show this week and this is even better.

[sweetsanity19]

idol is fucked up

[Ugoeze]

Still shocked beyond belief that she was eliminated... What a joke!

[irishsweetheatx]

Carly will be in my heart forever.. And in my computer :)

[iluvTylerHoechlinHSM]

Shes amazing and freaking Brooke sucks

[xxIceWiccanxx]

She didn't deserve to leave. Although I must say, I like everyone that's left. I think performance-wise, Jason should have left.

[jarodss]

BARFFFFFFFFFFFF

[amieamie12]

at least she got to leave on a good performance

[Shauzia3]

She didn't deserve to leave.

[musikero214]

i love this performance of her, its so sad shes gone now