I don't think that anyone can deny the greatness of Bach's best work. However if you examine the sum total of Bach's work, you'd have to admit that Telemann was the greater composer. Bach wrote a few amazing works but most of his work is at a much lower level. Telemann and Handel were pretty consistant in the level of their compositions. Thus I consider them better composers.
The question isn't whether Telemann is more impressive than Bach. The question is whether he is more pleasurable. I challenge anyone to name a piece of music by Bach that is as DELICIOUS as this piece by Telemann. This overture is great wine. Bach never ascends to this degree of delicious delight. He is too bogged down by theory and technique. This Telemann overture is music unleashed -- unbridled in a way Bach can never be. Bach's music is too weighty, too fettered.
This music is so pleasant, but I didn't have been moved so much to Telemann's composing. I can't be impressed by his score somehow although never dislike...
May be his fame be made on absence of other great musicians in Germany at the time(even Bach was nameless still then).
On the other hand, we can listen model of Baroque music by his legacy surely...
he wrote many operas but I generally don't like them. I fail to appreciate Telemann. His work is often mediocre. This one is no different I am afraid.
Great video, but Telemann never lost his eyesight. You have this confused with either Handel, Bach, and Graupner-- who all lost their vision.
telemannNnyc 1 year ago
At least as good as the Brandenburger!
anisuthideyakoindu 1 year ago
I don't think that anyone can deny the greatness of Bach's best work. However if you examine the sum total of Bach's work, you'd have to admit that Telemann was the greater composer. Bach wrote a few amazing works but most of his work is at a much lower level. Telemann and Handel were pretty consistant in the level of their compositions. Thus I consider them better composers.
violatione 2 years ago
Bach trembles in the wake of this overture.
FountainHouseVases 2 years ago
The question isn't whether Telemann is more impressive than Bach. The question is whether he is more pleasurable. I challenge anyone to name a piece of music by Bach that is as DELICIOUS as this piece by Telemann. This overture is great wine. Bach never ascends to this degree of delicious delight. He is too bogged down by theory and technique. This Telemann overture is music unleashed -- unbridled in a way Bach can never be. Bach's music is too weighty, too fettered.
FountainHouseVases 2 years ago
Telemann did evidently like Haendel's Water Music ......
indigoblue555 2 years ago
Funny the comments here that seem woefully ignorant of how much Bach enjoyed Telemann's music and performed it in Leipzig.
quixoteNnyc 2 years ago
This music is so pleasant, but I didn't have been moved so much to Telemann's composing. I can't be impressed by his score somehow although never dislike...
May be his fame be made on absence of other great musicians in Germany at the time(even Bach was nameless still then).
On the other hand, we can listen model of Baroque music by his legacy surely...
WatkinsAle 2 years ago
I agree with you, Telemann doesn't seem to impress me as much as Bach.
zzzzzsleepy00 2 years ago
beautiful.
ShakespeareHamlet 2 years ago
Thank you very much, Kitty..
vereiana 2 years ago
he wrote many operas but I generally don't like them. I fail to appreciate Telemann. His work is often mediocre. This one is no different I am afraid.
A good alternative composer is Zelenka!
firebreathone 2 years ago
Una overtura maravillosa y magnifica interpretacion, gracias.
¿La pintura es de Boucher??
anzdf 2 years ago
This is actually Fragonard. I love Boucher too though. :)
bubblykings 2 years ago
Pretty impressive Kitty! I'm a big fan of Telemann......do you have more? Thank you.........
MontanaBarNone 2 years ago
I probably have some more Telemann.....I'll find more of him eventually from my shelves of CDs. ;))))))
bubblykings 2 years ago
Wonderful Ouverture... and This image + this music = beautiful harmony.... thank you dear Kitty.
Alicia7777777 2 years ago
awesome video!
Aqualoshadka 2 years ago 2
lol ;) You really like to say "awesome video!" don't you?
bubblykings 2 years ago
awesome question!
Aqualoshadka 2 years ago
;)))
Alicia7777777 2 years ago