Added: 2 years ago
From: JayTMichael
Views: 29,902
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (159)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • hmm, i don't understand. can u tell me why she always put her hand in the ear? I know there is the recorder (I dnt knw what it is), but that is for what? :D

  • I don't really care if Mariah lips in her live performances..I mean what's the big deal, She had her prime when all of her performances are completely live and all would blow you away. All singers do that, who doesn't? I LOVE MARIAH TO THE MAXIMUM LEVEL!!

  • Lmao. Hello, Haters. Don't like Mariah? Get your ass out of this page. We don't need you, we DON'T need your like, okay i'll repeat it WE DON'T NEED YOUR LIKE. And your approval isn't needed. :D There's a million Lambs in the world. :D LOVE YOU MIMI! So proud of you.

  • She sounds amazing!

  • อีแม่หมี

  • Uma das melhores regravações que já ouvi,Mariah muito talentosa!!!!!

    (Rodrigo Sá -Brasil)

  • To Celine fans,Celine can't whistle,she can do high notes,but can't whistle,and remember whistle is highest note that human voice can reach.

  • IDC if she lips or whatever everyone says she does. She gave us great music and inspiration.. and if we were ALL wise, we'd enjoy her while she is still around.

  • Just perfect!

  • the whole thing was kinda bad then at the high part it sounds exactly PERFECT and then the whistle was better than the CD

  • When I watched this video, it really made me cry. even though it's hard for her to sing the highest part (the one where she used her whistle register), she sang it just for her audience and fans! I don't understand why people hate her. There's nothing wrong if she sings in that way. don't they appreciate how great she was during 90's?

  • No matter what happened, Mariah Carey is great! her performances during 90's were untouchable! people will remember her and all the wonderful and inspiring song that she dedicated to all of her fans! for me, the real DIVA is not just the way she sings or hit the high notes, but its all about how you sing through your heart making all the people around you to be inspired. that's the real DIVA! and that's Mariah Carey! So haters, shut up!

  • Comment removed

  • mariah,u mean so much to me,and even to stupid haters,cause they are still watchin u,listenin your songs and followin ur shows on you tube...they just can't ignore u,cause actually they know you re still better from any other female singer,but they don't want to accept this fact...and tryin to critise u with writin foolish sentences.go on fools,u give us and mariah extra power!!!:)

  • Man! That wasbeyond humaN...yeah there were a few flat notes but DAYUM a whole lot of chillz and a lost teardrop even...she was giving that every inch of her being! Amazing! Who goes to work like that these days?

  • her flaws just make me like her more because i know she really tries hard

  • 3:44 <3 <3

  • LINDO

  • Love MC...

  • mariah ever,!!! there's noone who can surpass you,, go girl , you rock always;

  • Mariah voce e melhor do mundo eu sou teu fa n° um a voz mais impressionante do mundo voce e tudo de bom Mariah Carey sempre!

  • Mariah tes highs notes sont IMPRESIONNANTES !!

    Merci pour tous ces LIVES européens !

    Thanks Mariah for all the europeans lives !!

  • she's is still got the vocals,despite sometimes she's having a hard time hitting the notes..but i still love her...

  • wow good all her iwtkwli performances since .. hmm .. x factor italy? on oprah and the view not so good but the new performances are good.. hope she'll sing live on wetten dass... this'd be her first live singign in germany i think..

  • Mariah is making her best her in Europe... I mean the "heys" in Italy were amazing, her whistle here is 100% live and awsome and the "boy" in X Factor UK is also amazing!!!!! plus she hasn't had to stuggle singing the rest of the son... MARIAH YOU ARE THE BEST!!!!! 5 stars!!!

  • Her whistle notes are amazing!

  • so fucking impressive.. amazing live performance... the one the only mariah carey

  • Yay, it sounds live and the vocal is good! She better not be lipping any parts. She seems like she is becoming herself again lately. For over a year she either seems stiff and medicated with no movement, lipped the song, or would give a horrible live performance. We want more of this Mariah. Sing live, work the stage, show that passion in your perfomances!

  • it is 100% live!!people listen carefully before jugging this peformance!its unfair to mariah to comment that this performance was lipped!!shes the best..

  • you know what guys...i dont know why are u telling all mariah's performance of i want to know what love is is lipped...your very wrong!!it is 110% live..pls listen cartefully...its very unfair to mariah that ur always telling that she lipped but the truth is it is not!!

  • question....am i the only that is thinking the band is just for show and their not actually playing the intruments in all the performances of these song?

  • watch regine vs mariah 2009 ..its amazing battle of diva..regine velasquez is the asia's song bird

  • Please go away. We dont care about your karaoke singers.

  • she's nothing compared to mariah...

  • i love You Mariah

  • You're so jealous. Shame on you.

  • this is origial and live.... the whistle is different... compare it from the original or her other performance!

  • this is the best performance of this song in my opinion.. after the last whistle you could tell by the look on her face that she knew she nailed it..l luv you mc...

  • you do hundred concerts tv guestings and a record breaking songs and albums .... you think you dont need to rest ? hahah lol..... just amzing performance .. and correct we all know that MC can hit high notes and super high notes accet it or just leave it! love it very much love mC

  • 2:28...lolz

  • J'taime Mariah... Excellent job.

  • She did her best.

  • Me assustei com o whistle dessa vezz!!

  • How stupid are you guys? I'm so sorry, but this is a 100% live. And I don't understand why you still say one little part of the song is lipped. Why would she do that? This singing of her is soooo different from the life singing she did before!!! You really hear that this is live!!! And I can't believe you people still don't here this!!!! Why would Mariah Carey be glad that she hit those high notes here? She hit those notes thousand times before! And not only in the studio so shut up haters

  • linda musica está linda mas esse microfone ta muito brilhoso tinha algo menos chamativo nao???

  • Mariah is the best and she always will be !! 20 years of career with the same and stronger voice of the world !! her voice is a gift !! every notes that she sings it's like an angel walking in the wind...it's so sweet like an apple pie like mango

  • you can tell she was so happy when she hit those high notes, it almost gave me butterflies and she did not lip sing any of that song as if you listen carefully you can see she struggled with hitting some of the small notes whenever she went quiet

  • no need to be smart that it was 100% live if people says that is not live so they are delusional ! or jealous ! and ya'll know it's Mariah !!HELLO !!! you know the girl from 1990 who hits every each notes in live and during 19 years almost 20 years of career !!

  • TE amuu kakau ♥

  • Mtoo lindoo esse vídeoo...

  • Bless her for (a bit late) promoting her girlfriend's hit album ''Let's Talk About Love''. Nice performance, she looked hella scared though to fail. Poor thing.

  • The end notes are not lipped! listen to all the live versions of this track and you will see the high notes are always different. Especially compared to the recorded version.

  • I did ask my teacher about mariah and she say that from time she was there and before she went on stage, she had people surrounding her.

  • What an amazing performance, she struggled with the ending a bit, but she pulled it out - I'm glad she's singing again.

  • I love her and like this performance but disappointed that she lipped the end notes :(

  • Yeah you can tell how her face changed as in ''oh now i don't need to sing live, so let's look pretty'.

  • no idiot that was a big fuck you to the hater that say she can't sing anymore.. ones like you.. she owned this performance.. this performance totally different from the rest.. this one and x-factor... amazing mc still reigns supreme

  • She did not lip it. She just used the backing tracks in the first whispery chorus and i believe the only whistle that was lipped was the autotuned one, it's always the same, but all the rest of the song sounds different to every other live performance of this song.

  • she didnt used the backing track in the first so before talking about something that you definitely know nothing !! you can see the chorists over here !! this song was without effect it was only the piano !! and someone tried to put many echos on one frase...

  • they are jealous... that's all... haters that have no respect for true honest talent. she is the best female singer ever... this is live and amazing

  • Okay err I do not hate her, I love her music. Someone can have expectations, no? I still love her, no matter what. Like on the Oprah show, she really nailed it all. So yeah.

  • of course you would say that your a celine fan... sorry but it you watch oprah, x-factor, allan carr the endings are all different.. this one is 100% live. celine could never do this even in her prime...

  • Katie, you're just an ignorant lamb. Yes, I love Celine but that doesn't mean that I don't like Mariah. And when you said that Celine could never do this even in her prime is just an ignorant statement coming from an ignorant fool.

    Anyone can see that it isn't fully live. I loved her performance but was only disappointed by the ending as it IS the same.

    Besides, I don't think I need to even bother replying to an ignorant fool like you. Just grow up and be realistic!

    PS. I love me some Mimi

  • Heya :D What notes are the same and from what performance? Thanks in adv. Just curious

  • Comment removed

  • smrimas.

    can you do better?..jealous hater..

    why was it bad...break it down genius..

    remember your criticizing the best female singer on the planet who is out promotong her album.. singing live performances night after night.. think hard before you spew hatred it very unbecoming of you/.... get a life

  • epic failure on your part.. just stop being jealous and embrace the best singer in the world.. mariah carey...lol

    your in a no win situation here.. nothing you say matters.. get a life moron

  • She Hit That Eb7 Again Lol...

  • no, she did not. look! she's a bit struggling. u know it if she's singing it live

  • Isn't 3:07-3:09 live? o.O I'm pretty sure it is...

    But 3:10-3:14 is lipped =/ She lips that on every performance sadly. But I think it's cause she needs enough time to breathe after that long high note.

    And I wish that her voice was like in the 90's...Those were some amazing years~

  • live moron...not lipped every whistle at the end is different from oprah, x factor, allan carr. you haters just can't take the fact that this women can still out sing any other female.. jealous haters.. pathetic

  • katie, compare the part at 3:10-3:14 and 3:20-3:26 from every live performance. They sound the same. But I do agree that the last whistle is live, as they sound different in different performances.

    Look I'm a fan of Mariah too, because she produces wonderful songs with high artistic details. But it's a fact that she lipped. We point it out because we listen carefully, and are her true fans, NOT because we're "jealous haters."

    Happy Holidays =]

  • I actually played two videos at the same time from three performances, and, you're right. They sound exactly the same, to a T.

    I wonder how you get away with something like that. Just make it part of the play back, I'd assume. Shame.

  • agreed...those two lines are always lipped as the "hes all up in my george forman" in obsessed...and i understand why no time to catch your breath on this song ending...

  • live. OMG. for me i think only the whistle note was lipped if it happens

  • @alvinwong15 smartest obsevation yet. you right she r, Mariah lip syncs every high except for one. I know 2 and I can see because I sing in the higest notes too.

  • well 3:07-3:10 is live,but the part after that (the F5) is lipped...but i do agree,on the View...she lipped that whole part

  • i love you mariah carey.

  • Brilliant performance and you can see she's so pleased with it. Love her

  • AHH SO AMAZING!! Cant wait till new years to see her perform at MSG and then atlantic city!!

  • so happy mariah's back!!!:)

  • me too

  • her high notes are called whistle notes btw and one member of the chior works at my school LOL

  • Thats awesome, have you asked him/her about Mariah, would did they have to say?

  • mmmmmmm interesting

  • Impressive to say the least!

    After being 19 years in the business....you cannot help but totally admire this outstanding woman.

    MIMI I love you like my sister, my mother, my girlfriend!!

    Pity I am gay, lol

  • Comment removed

  • Beyoncé can't control a F5? LMAO

    Her trademark note is a F5 and no, Xtina can't belt over E5, she struggle a lot

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • absolutely amazing! that is all there is to say really. this was live and to all the people saying it wasn't, shut up. mariah has still got that excellent voice! keep on doing what your doing mariah!

    can't wait to see you perform this song on the xfactor this sunday night!!

  • AMAZING !!! but i know the F5 and the whistle (Eb7) were prerecorded as always , i love it at 3:06 and the long C5 !!! her voice is strong and powerful this year !!!

  • Eb7 was not pre-recorded, she lost a bit of control. Although, it seems when she loses control and tries to press her ear, she goes higher haha

  • she didnt hit it and she knows it lol 3:44 nice save bit all over the place but still awsome

  • No need for her voice to go that high. I don't like.

  • Then don't listen

  • Amazing x

  • VERY HOT!

  • omgg yesss!!! this was suchhh an awesome performance of this song!! <3 NEW YEARS CONCERT @ MSG and CONCERT @ Atlantic City!! Jan 2nd :D soo there!!

  • OMG dis performance is amazinggggg Stop hateing as u can see the crowd are cheering and i dnt think any other artist has 18 #1 singles Case closed . Not even whitney can do a wistle register so there is no need for comaprison love you mariah goin to HEr New years concert in NY Cnt wait xxxxxxxxxx

  • sorry am i missing something?.... when i watched this on tv i was like :O:O:O:O:O it was fuckking AMAZING!!! mann she's still got the voicee!! i really disliked mariah before but after that interview and performance she seemed really funny and nice :)

  • perfect song to end allens first episode of the new series

  • Mariah Carey doesn't lip anymore she stopped after emancipation of mimi

  • whistle acrobatics...

  • This performance is definitely best live of IWTKWLI!!!! All haters who says this one is lipped must deafXDDDDD You are just jealous Mimi's amazing talent! The only lipped part in this live is the F5 hight note (I wanna know) But now Celine Christina Whitney Beyonce leona ...and so on are also can't control F5 only can belt to F5 for a short while and only Whitney Celine Cristina and MImi once can hold a F5 long note So Mimi is still the queen of R&B!!!
  • i agree with your post but i have to say leona has hit and holded F5's in one of her new songs, 'you dont care' check it out :) love mariah tho =D

  • just some slight corrections. Christina struggles to belt anything over E5 live, so she isn't a factor. Beyonce has belted and controlled F5 numerous times. Leona also.

  • Comment removed

  • Thank you to correct my statement

    The long note I mean is like Mimi

    1997 Butterfly in SNL

    The 10 sec hightest long note "It feels to fly~~"

    The voice is thick and powerful with

    a lot transpositions which is nearly

    impossible to sing

  • ela tá perdendo a voz, mas msm assim, tá perfeita *-*

    -

    QUE AGUDO FOI AQUELE DO FINAL ? *-*

    -

    MIMI FOREVER

  • I can't believe people are saying that this is not live. Only the whispery bits in the middle are synced. You can see it in her face after the belter and the whistles that she was well chuffed that she pulled them off. This is by far the best performance of this song I have seen, and I've seen alot. Deffo live where it counts, and she pulled it out of the bag (and then threw it around the room) GO MC :D

  • WOW I LOVE IT MORE THAN THE ORIGINAL !

  • Her belts here sounds like Charmbracelet era, and for me that´s a very good thing. Of course she sounds raspy, but actually during all her carrer her voice has been husky, except to the 95/96 period (Daydream Era) when she had a scary clarity in her belts. Anyway, I prefer when she sounds raspy (even in 1991 u can hear her husky tone), it´s more soulful and I don´t know, love her voice, so unique (sorry 4 my english :S)

  • Her whistles are never dubbed!!! There are only 2 high belting notes dubbed here, but it was an amazing performance anyway.

  • The high notes are LIVE !

  • have you listen to the original ?

  • Haters are always delusional

    we should have pity for them

    They just can't face the music XDDD

  • congratulation MIMI for the best perfomace of the era MOAIA

  • She is struggling a bit but everybody knows that her voice has deteriorated over the years. But otherwise this is pretty decent

  • its better than wat shes been giving us lately! SO BE HAPPY

  • te amo

  • love it

  • LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D:D:D:D:D:D!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!! yay mariah im going to xfactor sunday so gutted its pre-recorded and i wont see her even susan boyle is pre recorded, so i wont be seeing anyone DAMN IT!!! lol x

  • Wow, I must say, that was one of her BEST live performances of this song!!!!!!!!! Loved it!!! TY for posting!!

  • Hermosa!

    Me gusto mucho el video, linda voz y lindo escenario :D

  • Brilliant performance! Mariah is unstoppable

  • wow LIVE LIVE LIVE LIVE LIVE... Whistle was def live... and for pple who are going to say that it's similar to "The View show".. well it's SO not.. It's so different!

  • amazing perfomance, great whistles

    I love you MC

  • AMAZING, I just hope the X factor performance on sunday is this good...

  • oaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa amazin!

  • I love this performance! Amazing.

  • she was suffering to sing in tune and people still love it, thats my girl !!!! lmao

    my favorite song from MOAIA

  • she's had 2 no1 albums (Music box & Daydream) and singles in the UK...what u on about?

  • a decadência de uma diva, ainda bem q todo mundo adora ela, bate palma, grita, torce... pq ta triste a situação!

    pelo menos foi visualmente bonito

  • Mariah the best!!!

  • AMAZING LIVE AND 100% live at MJ's memorial Mariah was sad and she was really nervous !! when you cry your voice cant sing !!! but of course at MJ's she hits notes too an amazingly but people talk about 1 note only !!! OMG Mariah always has the same voice

  • love it love it love it!

  • mariah carey is amazing! her voice is awesome

  • When I saw her at MJs memorial, I thought she'd lost it, but this performance was AMAZING! Loved it.

  • WASNT THE AUDIENCE SPECTACULAR?? They really showed her love :D

  • Love, she deserves nº1 album and single next week!!!!

  • There's a first for everything!! lol in the UK at least :P

  • so she better top every chart in the UK!!!!!

  • AMAZING!

    She is so talented!

    And love the twist ending!

    WAY TO GO MARIAH!!!!!!!!

    _bRanden

  • I love Mariah Carey So Much !!!!!!! She was great in her interview with Alan, and always delivers with her performances, i really hope her new Album does well, coz she works bloody hard !! Go Mariah XOXO

    And love you Alan lol x

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more