This doesn't sound genuine at all. Perlman has a wonderful sound. This tape is some kind of dubbed over joke and I agree with MSLearningCenter, it's not funny.
@porkyfry Give the man some credit, I think alot of non-nerds (not musicians) don't know the term 'shreds' and expect the real deal. No surprise they're chocked! I laghed SO hard all the way though! =D
@devphyflutist Were my dad an accomplished musician, and someone uploaded a shred of him, he (and I) would laugh at it.
A meme is a meme. Obviously they won't be hilarious to everyone; it just didn't seem that you understood that this was a meme. Something tells me Perlman wouldn't take himself so seriously as to be offended by this, though.
I once heard Silverstein destroy a complete Guarnari Quartet performance of Beethoven quartets. My take is there is no guarantee anyone (except Heifetz) can be perfect all the time. This in no way takes away from Perlman's greatness, it just proves that he, like all of us, is human. Imagine the pressure to play thousands of concerts over a lifetime with never playing out of tune.
The funny thing is, whoever recorded the audio for this is probably a pretty good violin player in reality. You have to be pretty comfortable with a piece to play it so poorly that well...if you know what I mean.
The timing is perfect and it's obviously NEAR to the right notes. So whoever did this, I'm guessing, can actually play it properly.
I don´t know much about classical music but this sounds a bit off? Is it just me? Maybe It could be his instrument or something..? I don´t know this particular gentleman but I think he should practise some more before performing with a good orchestra like this! Maybe take some lessons at a local community college, instead of waisting our time like this! Just saying....
@Deltaprayer LMAO, Well, maybe if he practices more and is lucky he may someday become a famous violinist, although it's probably a long shot for him. I guess he can dream, can't he? :-P
LMAO, not even Jazz or Flamenco were safe from the "___ shreds" meme, and now Classical music has been conquered too. Wherever you are, StSanders (the originator of the "___ shreds" meme), you must be damn proud xD. What started out as a bunch of guitar parodies has turned into someting so epic xD.
there's a true video on youtube of Itshak playing this for real - this is NOT funny at all, trying to make it look like Mr. Perlman can't play. This video should be taken down.
it's called a shred for a reason...lol everyone on youtube and in that audience knows that this was made for fun. Perlman is playing bad on purpose. geez, lighten up. :D
People, if Itzhak Perlman actually played this bad, he would shoot himself. Even if he played one note even close to this bad, he'd be visibly pissed. Saying that these hilarious videos shouldn't be made because people think it's real is stupid. If people don't get it, it's their problem.
BLOODY HELL! COME ON PEOPLE!!! This video isn't real-the audio of the video was dubbed over by some hopelessly horrible recording. I mean I have to admit...it's kinda funny, but when I found out about this and found out what they really did...I was still mad as FUCK. Such an insult to Itzhak Perlman! I mean REALLY! People shouldn't do shit like this because it'll give people the wrong impression of the GREATEST MUSICIANS!!! BLOODY HELL IM MAD AS FUCK NOW.
Okay I love Perlman, but this is simply not good. Yes yes, 99% of the time he's the best violinist out there, but there is not much good here at all. He's out of tune, make a bazillion mistakes, and for lack of a better term is completely "shown-up" by the violinists in the orchestra, who play exponentially better than him.
He has post polio syndrome and is in his 60's - friend of mine says he did poorly at his recital this year also. Sad. :( I want to quit before I get to that point. I'm 66 so as old as he is but don't have post polio syndrome - there but by the Grace of God go I.
usually its hard to play everything clearly. its amazing if u can play everything clearly but out of tune. its easier to be in tune than to play those fast runs clearly. lol. ironic
This video is a fraud. It has the sound dubbed over and the person responsible should meet with Capone's baseball bat. It is a profound insult to Perlman, who is a great artist and superb player.
@lardman2228 Thanks for reply, but I think humour is pure creativity. When a great performer is juggling himself, it can be very funny (there is a famous parody that Heifetz made of some students who played for a hearing), but when an other person change the sound of a unconscious performer it’s pure vandalism, the same thing if someone wanted to change a Botticelli's Primavera or any other work of art with the spray, I do not laugh, to me it seems bad taste.
@stefanonio Humour comes in many forms, whether it be pure creativity or complete randomness. It is not at all vandalism, the real piece of art is still out there for you to listen to. I understand that this may not appeal to your sense of humour, but it does to mine and many other people's. This is not what is killing the art of music, people like Andre Rieu are killing the art of music. This is simply a fun little joke someone has made, no one made you listen to it.
@stefanonio Furthermore, the purpose of editing the audio was to create something that had never before been heard with that video and is never to be heard in real life, not envy. Though I myself am very envious of Perlman, who wouldn't be? He has such talent. A bit of a sense of humour wouldn't go amiss.
Yes It also made me laugh so much, but then I thought: "a joke so heavy it can also be very unpleasant. But Perlman knows that they are doing this? And he agree? Perhaps he does not like being teased "?
I mean its all about the emotion isn't it. His playing just gets me, ya know?
zcguitar1 5 days ago
Parla coi fanti...ma lascia stare i SANTI !!!! ( VIVALDI E LA CULTURA ITALIANA ) v.s.
VictorStarita 2 weeks ago
Haha is this intentional?
zeeweirdeye 2 weeks ago
wow... i really didnt expect this coming from him.
MahoRoulete 3 weeks ago
Perlman's so good, it probably was harder for him to play like this than in his real state :)
EvanWang999 1 month ago
Amazing talent!!!
fedalxis 1 month ago
More enjoyable than the real thing...
rdangelo 1 month ago
It seems that Zubin is getting angry...lol
angus24402870451 1 month ago
LMAO!
funkyseefunkydo 1 month ago
This doesn't sound genuine at all. Perlman has a wonderful sound. This tape is some kind of dubbed over joke and I agree with MSLearningCenter, it's not funny.
justwarren 1 month ago
@justwarren Very sad... anyone born without a sense of humor is a sorry soul indeed.
porkyfry 1 month ago
@porkyfry Give the man some credit, I think alot of non-nerds (not musicians) don't know the term 'shreds' and expect the real deal. No surprise they're chocked! I laghed SO hard all the way though! =D
Squadron555 1 month ago
I LOVE the trills at the beginning of the solo passage! Almost sounds like the violin is saying, "Uuuuuhhhhhhhh...?"
porkyfry 1 month ago
alright, is this actually his playing or is it audio effect? i really cant tell moslty because i cant imagine him playing like this
divyarandom99 1 month ago
damn you got me lol!
SlashTheGuitarist 1 month ago
@SlashTheGuitarist what do u mean?
divyarandom99 1 month ago
@divyarandom99 The video is a joke. This guy overdubs crappy playing as a joke. Watch his other videos. It's kinda funny.
SlashTheGuitarist 1 month ago
Perlman is so better when he plays false notes... XD !
Vinogradovsky 1 month ago
PERFECTIONN!
orionedwin 1 month ago
For your information, musicians do not "shred", they perform music.
goldie0800 2 months ago
his face...
sneaker453 2 months ago
Not Funny!!!
TheMSLearningCenter 2 months ago
can't hear how well he's playing because of my laughter T_T
theonlyjsp 2 months ago in playlist More videos from fatpjerrot
Now I can say out loud, I play like Perlman! The first solo is just Hilarious!
magec07 2 months ago
This reminds me of a nightmare I had once.
Apeigios 2 months ago
He looks so happy :D
justlooking1902 2 months ago in playlist Flere videoer fra fatpjerrot
Zubin Mehta at 0:53 "Oh shit, what did I just get myself into...."
cchamp27 2 months ago
Sounds like our school orchestra
smike53 2 months ago 3
@devphyflutist Sorry! I have been HAD. So embarassing. Oh, it is Arnold Steinhardt also in the Guarnari, not Siverstein. I am indeed an OLD cellist.
oldvlc 3 months ago
@devphyflutist Were my dad an accomplished musician, and someone uploaded a shred of him, he (and I) would laugh at it.
A meme is a meme. Obviously they won't be hilarious to everyone; it just didn't seem that you understood that this was a meme. Something tells me Perlman wouldn't take himself so seriously as to be offended by this, though.
Graxanov 3 months ago
That's the best shreds I have ever heard!
Gajdziewska 3 months ago
it's not itzhak... it's just someone else recording over the orchestra trying to play terribly.
runforrestrun13 3 months ago
@runforrestrun13 Hi, you must be new here.
tomhalpin1 3 months ago
I once heard Silverstein destroy a complete Guarnari Quartet performance of Beethoven quartets. My take is there is no guarantee anyone (except Heifetz) can be perfect all the time. This in no way takes away from Perlman's greatness, it just proves that he, like all of us, is human. Imagine the pressure to play thousands of concerts over a lifetime with never playing out of tune.
oldvlc 3 months ago
This is so embarrassing! How can that happen??
elsalaete 3 months ago
@devphyflutist Know your memes.
Graxanov 3 months ago
Is this a joke
annajeehee 3 months ago
HAHAHAHAHAH I have not laughed this HARD in a long time!!! My stomach is burning!!! AHHHHH!!!!
electricfiddle1313 3 months ago
@devphyflutist Maybe. But I think perlman would have laughed at this. Watch this: watch?v=JqCDDRAy8hQ
rawrgDX 3 months ago
Comment removed
rawrgDX 3 months ago
I'm listening to 1:07 over and over and laughing my ass off
StephaneGrappelli 3 months ago
u fuckin sick i thought for a moment OMG can he do this sounds like a fart in chorus+phaser
well done man!!
StephaneGrappelli 3 months ago
This is disturbing...haha
TheFrancescaViolin 3 months ago
Fantastic! Is there a version of it not overdubbed? (to show peopl who don't quite get it)
pietahex 3 months ago
god bless you!!!
make sure you get everybody!!
pemgolf 3 months ago
This is absolutely hilarious
SteelyPhil37 3 months ago
1:05 That sounds like me on a good day....
winrx 3 months ago 20
Ha! it works so well with his and the conductors expressions, I also love the squeaks and bangs. So good.
endofthecorridor 4 months ago
the comments are the best part of this video
branhs2002 4 months ago
Lol is this purposely done!? I mean for the man to play out of tune? Jajaja sure hope so cause it sounds ugly!
tepeke88 4 months ago
The funny thing is, whoever recorded the audio for this is probably a pretty good violin player in reality. You have to be pretty comfortable with a piece to play it so poorly that well...if you know what I mean.
The timing is perfect and it's obviously NEAR to the right notes. So whoever did this, I'm guessing, can actually play it properly.
MrStrangeSensation 4 months ago 2
I don´t know much about classical music but this sounds a bit off? Is it just me? Maybe It could be his instrument or something..? I don´t know this particular gentleman but I think he should practise some more before performing with a good orchestra like this! Maybe take some lessons at a local community college, instead of waisting our time like this! Just saying....
Deltaprayer 4 months ago
@Deltaprayer LMAO, Well, maybe if he practices more and is lucky he may someday become a famous violinist, although it's probably a long shot for him. I guess he can dream, can't he? :-P
firmingitup 4 months ago
@Deltaprayer this video is a spoof.
daniel0731ex 3 months ago
@daniel0731ex
Yes indeed:-) I know the SOB who´s behind The Pearlman "special sound":
He plays so well that some people think it´s Perlman on a "bad day"
(including me maybe if i drink enough)
MegaLoL !
Deltaprayer 1 week ago
This is an audio-dub over the other video.
TheDoughertyFamily 4 months ago
Just a tad slower and he should be fine...lol
winrx1 4 months ago 2
Hilarious! Thanks for the laugh.
formersk8ter 4 months ago
LMAO, not even Jazz or Flamenco were safe from the "___ shreds" meme, and now Classical music has been conquered too. Wherever you are, StSanders (the originator of the "___ shreds" meme), you must be damn proud xD. What started out as a bunch of guitar parodies has turned into someting so epic xD.
Incog2k6 4 months ago
COmo lo ve en le minuto 1:00 como con cara de hoy no te toca xD
Sotris24 4 months ago in playlist Más vídeos de fatpjerrot
The Guitar accomp
mateusbelloni 5 months ago
hahahahahahahahahaah
GENIUS!
mateusbelloni 5 months ago 11
which season is this?
Don789ten 5 months ago
@Don789ten Winter 1st Mvt
lonely270 5 months ago
I don't want to be mean...... but WHY THE HELL DO SO MANY PEOPLE NOT REALIZE THAT THIS IS JUST A FUNNY DUBBING TRICK, FOR F*** SAKE!
daftpunksamurai 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I spat my tea while watching this... need a new computer now!!! :D HAHAHA
Tchappz 5 months ago
Comment removed
Tchappz 5 months ago
This is very sad. I wonder what happened? I hope this is fake.
dblivezalwayz 5 months ago
there's a true video on youtube of Itshak playing this for real - this is NOT funny at all, trying to make it look like Mr. Perlman can't play. This video should be taken down.
pattyfromtoledo 5 months ago
@pattyfromtoledo
it's called a shred for a reason...lol everyone on youtube and in that audience knows that this was made for fun. Perlman is playing bad on purpose. geez, lighten up. :D
MetronomeOrchid 5 months ago
@pattyfromtoledo This is real - the video you are talking about was overdubbed to make him sound better. You should really check your sources.
ThreeFatSlags 4 months ago 3
lol whoever made this could get sewed for big money
mstrjim1 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk eu não sei como nao rir assistindo isso kkkkkkkkk
faelregilio 5 months ago
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk eu não sei como nao rir assistindo isso kkkkkkkkk
faelregilio 5 months ago
lol it was so serious until :50...its like "hi everyone SURPRISE"
Flaminggential 6 months ago
The conductor and Perlman keeping a straight face with thie shred!!!! Makes it especially hilarious!
Tilleyass 6 months ago
HILARIOUS!
Tilleyass 6 months ago
so rude........but funny
maverickstarchild 6 months ago
This is hilarious. Not one note in tune and he did it perfectly!!!
I love shreds... they're god awful. :)
MaeveAna 6 months ago in playlist HILARIOUS
Haha, the beginning sounds like in a horror movie! :D
LadyInDaHouse88 6 months ago
hilarious! great vid.
bababamoto 6 months ago
People, if Itzhak Perlman actually played this bad, he would shoot himself. Even if he played one note even close to this bad, he'd be visibly pissed. Saying that these hilarious videos shouldn't be made because people think it's real is stupid. If people don't get it, it's their problem.
Farnik01 6 months ago
2:41 hahahahaha AWESOME, fatpjerrot you are a genius...
dorpik 6 months ago
To play so bad is really hard.
Espacially if you're usually so awesome.
root1995 6 months ago
classical shreds are sooo brilliant :)
this is played very good out of tune!!
2teKnoA 6 months ago
Comment removed
2teKnoA 6 months ago
Oh yeah I get it alright, but I'm not too fond of jokes like these. >:[
hordesofkillerdomo 7 months ago
hahahahahahahahahah this is tooooooooo funny
gazzafunk 7 months ago
This is a very bad joke..
koeloekai 7 months ago
if you'd like to wash out your ears, here's the legit version hahaha
watch?v=rBq4ov5Y_84
werq34ac 7 months ago
How many people who have commented here don't understand that this is a joke? Perlman's part has been dubbed...
Sinatra70 7 months ago
BLOODY HELL! COME ON PEOPLE!!! This video isn't real-the audio of the video was dubbed over by some hopelessly horrible recording. I mean I have to admit...it's kinda funny, but when I found out about this and found out what they really did...I was still mad as FUCK. Such an insult to Itzhak Perlman! I mean REALLY! People shouldn't do shit like this because it'll give people the wrong impression of the GREATEST MUSICIANS!!! BLOODY HELL IM MAD AS FUCK NOW.
hordesofkillerdomo 7 months ago
@hordesofkillerdomo And you love us all. Now that's sweet!
mwakin27 7 months ago
That's never real! I can't believe it!
DeDeboful 7 months ago
Okay I love Perlman, but this is simply not good. Yes yes, 99% of the time he's the best violinist out there, but there is not much good here at all. He's out of tune, make a bazillion mistakes, and for lack of a better term is completely "shown-up" by the violinists in the orchestra, who play exponentially better than him.
MasterAzunai 7 months ago
@MasterAzunai MAN DON'T YOU GET IT??????????
mariusfelix 7 months ago 3
@MasterAzunai As mariusfelix said... Hahaha.
nyo267n 6 months ago
Tuneless. Horrrible...
direitocriminal 7 months ago
@direitocriminal Have you tried to google "shreds videos"?
nyo267n 6 months ago
This sound like horror movie backround music...LOL
chl91039 7 months ago
is it just me or the conductor just looks really weird....
antonettedgreat 7 months ago
He has post polio syndrome and is in his 60's - friend of mine says he did poorly at his recital this year also. Sad. :( I want to quit before I get to that point. I'm 66 so as old as he is but don't have post polio syndrome - there but by the Grace of God go I.
dbaseII 7 months ago
at :53, the conductor's like "wtf."
composer4u 8 months ago
Köstlich! Hab mich selten so amüsiert.
MartinRaetzJr 8 months ago
Vlade Divac seems pretty pleased
assclown2k6 8 months ago 2
This is such an insult it's ridiculous...
unitednerdsbeproud 8 months ago
I could not stop laughing starting at 2:41 lol....this is a well made video!
smackbannana 8 months ago 29
@smackbannana is this true?
ilovezuerich 5 months ago
@smackbannana I don't get it
Don789ten 5 months ago
@Don789ten haha, that's even funnier :p
atlings 4 months ago
flawless
nbfazel 8 months ago
The art of shredding... LoL
Scarbogn 8 months ago in playlist Erudito
its a fraud....
KosteckiAdam 8 months ago
@KosteckiAdam That's what shredding is on youtube.
wiz0floyd 8 months ago
The conductor was like wtf at 0:53
windintea 9 months ago
haha i was slightly disappointed when I saw that the video was a fraud... oh well. it was sorta funny i suppose.
1ncaravag 9 months ago
Sne of best Shred :)
Rapoutch 9 months ago
@Rapoutch One*
Rapoutch 9 months ago
NOT the real audio from Perlman's perfromance.
gkundo 9 months ago
@gkundo That's why it's called a shred...
wiz0floyd 8 months ago
@gkundo Whaaaat?
Vadraedan 8 months ago
usually its hard to play everything clearly. its amazing if u can play everything clearly but out of tune. its easier to be in tune than to play those fast runs clearly. lol. ironic
jtingyz 9 months ago
This video is a fraud. It has the sound dubbed over and the person responsible should meet with Capone's baseball bat. It is a profound insult to Perlman, who is a great artist and superb player.
yenrabaraho 9 months ago
@yenrabaraho Take it easy. It's comedy.
moltoallegro19 9 months ago
This video is a fraud. It has the sound dubbed over and the person responsible should meet with Capone's baseball bat.
yenrabaraho 9 months ago
I'd pay $2000 to see a Perlman concert like this
MrChumFm 9 months ago 3
in my opinion, this video stands as one of the funniest videos by itself..
(no need to shred it..)
my god, just the look of Perlman and the conductor is enough.. the emphasis on their role!!
it could be a silent film.. don't need the sound at all!!
plithos 9 months ago
LOL, this sounds like me playing.
agreatgeat 9 months ago 15
Horrible
meatpie29 9 months ago
ti pezei o poustis xaxaxaxaxaxa!!!!!
JAZZMANGR 9 months ago
eh...
SqueezeMyLemonBabe 10 months ago
1:03 "alright don't lose it...calm down... just go along...don't fucking lose it, not in front of all these people"
carcinogen20 10 months ago 2
Great shred!
kareshi 10 months ago
LOL... oh man. I laughed a lot at this video. I didn't understand the comments until I realized the sarcasm. ;)
rbjuliano 10 months ago
What the hell are they doing?
robertitopopy 11 months ago
Is it me or it sounds bad?
trueprophesy 11 months ago
@trueprophesy Its you :D
Smebninja 11 months ago
seriously... who dislikes this?
Riley1699 11 months ago
@Riley1699 Anyone who knows about music.
robertitopopy 11 months ago
@robertitopopy I like to think I know a fair bit about music and I think this is just hilarious.
Riley1699 11 months ago
wtf did you do to this
FaWkInGsErIoUs 11 months ago
He still sounds better than me.
JeremyImp 11 months ago 4
thats probably how i would sound if i tried to play this
Gryffindor8 11 months ago
@joannepsi
It's true, who loves the music does not appreciate this kind of humour.
stefanonio 11 months ago
@stefanonio I have a deep passion for most music, including this, and I think this is fucking hilarious!!
lardman2228 10 months ago
@lardman2228 Thanks for reply, but I think humour is pure creativity. When a great performer is juggling himself, it can be very funny (there is a famous parody that Heifetz made of some students who played for a hearing), but when an other person change the sound of a unconscious performer it’s pure vandalism, the same thing if someone wanted to change a Botticelli's Primavera or any other work of art with the spray, I do not laugh, to me it seems bad taste.
stefanonio 10 months ago
@stefanonio Humour comes in many forms, whether it be pure creativity or complete randomness. It is not at all vandalism, the real piece of art is still out there for you to listen to. I understand that this may not appeal to your sense of humour, but it does to mine and many other people's. This is not what is killing the art of music, people like Andre Rieu are killing the art of music. This is simply a fun little joke someone has made, no one made you listen to it.
lardman2228 10 months ago
@stefanonio Furthermore, the purpose of editing the audio was to create something that had never before been heard with that video and is never to be heard in real life, not envy. Though I myself am very envious of Perlman, who wouldn't be? He has such talent. A bit of a sense of humour wouldn't go amiss.
lardman2228 10 months ago 2
@stefanonio I laughed so hard at this video. That qualifies as humor to me.
crunchbite22 9 months ago
@crunchbite22
Yes It also made me laugh so much, but then I thought: "a joke so heavy it can also be very unpleasant. But Perlman knows that they are doing this? And he agree? Perhaps he does not like being teased "?
I really wish I knew this before laughing....
stefanonio 9 months ago
22 people have never laughed in their life
newFranzFerencLiszt 11 months ago 4
oh this is hilarious!!!!
musicalfunctions 11 months ago
Why edit audio, to what purpose, perhaps envy ?
stefanonio 11 months ago
@stefanonio HUMOUR - something you're clearly not very well acquainted with.
joannepsi 11 months ago
You guys need to learn what shredding is.
crunchbite22 11 months ago
Haha Nice one. Made me laugh. This is a good bit of work. The syncing is perfect. Well done :-)
tal1sker 11 months ago
of course this is a joke!
angemoguz 11 months ago
You have nothing else better to do with your life, I see.
Garturner 11 months ago
Fantastic hack job :D
pbaron23 1 year ago
LOL ! :D (it's not Perlman ? no shit sherclok !)
TushTushTush 1 year ago
People! I think this video is a joke! Obviously!
DianaandherGuitar 1 year ago 3
its not Perlamn playing the violin, fake sound fake video!
JulianMCalderon 1 year ago
@JulianMCalderon Really?
mariusfelix 1 year ago
@mariusfelix ¬¬
JulianMCalderon 10 months ago
omg i was so worried that this was real. thank god for the comments lol.
tembeckchigan 1 year ago
wait, is this the real recording?
LightningSpeedRacer 1 year ago
Mehta is stoic as fuck the whole time. What a pro.
jsivanataru 1 year ago
:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D
Drippl3 1 year ago
These all sound like me =(
Love the looks on everyone's faces
overlordKrunK 1 year ago
How did you guys did this! Its so funny hahahaha. It reminds me of my own playing now and again!
hamadah4 1 year ago 2
hilarious heh heh!!! well done whoever made it!!
gm255 1 year ago 2
Best shred ever fatpjerrot, thank you for this hilarious moment...
Maxecom02 1 year ago
OMG........HUH?
Karlcarl 1 year ago
I teach middle school orchestra. What's the problem?
It sounds really good to me.
mhjasinski 1 year ago 47