Added: 5 years ago
From: Musicppl09
Views: 494,561
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,325)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Asia has a powerful voice,she is my favorit

  • wtf did asia win? shes just yelling.

  • @CLIilmama33830 that did an acess hollywood story bout it and robin said she was a great singing but she dances like a drag queen

  • @fudgegirl911 Sure, she'd say that after the fact.

    Robin loved her dancing... She chose Asia to win that first dance challenge and called her the best at the Beep dance.

  • WHO EVER SAID ASIA QUIT LIED CUZ THEY DIDNT LIKE THE WAY SHE DANCE AND SO THEY KICKED HER OUT

  • @fudgegirl911 The PCD chose her based on her dancing. Technically, they were only there for the last performances, so they probably chose her based on her dancing and/or Lady Marmalade, some of her only true shining moments on the show.

  • WHO EVER SAID ASIA QUIT LIED CUZ THEY DIDNT LIKE THE WAY SHE DANCE AND SO THEY KICKED HER OUT

  • @clilmama33830

    dude she was cryin -.-"

  • @babycupid722 She was not crying until later in the song.

  • Hmm. Melissa took no risks and still was off pitch a lot at the end of her solo part.

  • Actually Melissa is better than Nicole that is why she didin't win.

  • I just dont understand how would Melissa have outshined Nicole? Nicole is a really GREAT singer.. Her voice is amazing, she sound a hell of a lot better as a solo singer doing serious songs.. Melissa is good but how would she have outshined someone with a lot of talent??

  • the reason i love this song is because you could tell Melissa put a lot into, not just the performance but her heart and soul, i like all kinds of music, especially when they are sung by a singer who puts everything into it

  • Someone being flat can't really be a measure, since Melissa is flat on so many notes on every song. She can't control her higher register, whereas Asia is better at it...

  • She's no Nicole- but Melissa R or Chelsea should have won. Asia was a dumb bitch who quit!

  • me too

    i agree w/ itsSteffyBee

  • I love Asia`s voice.

  • ew. she didn't win because she looked too much like nicole schregerson ( idk how to spell her last name)

    but i love melissa and chelsea!

  • Melissa will always be my favorite. I still <3 listening to her even though it's already 2011. She's really awesome and talented and i wish she would've won! =]

  • @xXElleN816Xx Same with me, Melissa has the voice of an angel <3

  • she probably left becuz they were already sort of a sinking ship

  • this was my favorite performance! they both sound great

  • what happened to this girl?!?! (asia)

  • what happened to this girl?!?!

  • it's 2011 and i still listen to this girl sing

  • wow

  • Melissa is stunning o.o

  • how did the judges respond to her crying?

  • @fjoliva20 From what I remember, they were pretty bitchy about her crying /:

  • I like Asia alot, she has a unique voice

    thats why she got chose

    not cus mel was better then nicole

    mel was good, but the way asia made it her own was better,

    in my opinion anyways.

  • i thik it is a good thing melissa didnt join PCD cuz i dun her to be a slut! and be mixed into 9 other girls. She might even have a chance to go solo/be in a new group, perharps leader too!

  • this was 1 of my fave performances!

    i still think the judges were to hard on Melissa though but thats me

    I still get teary eyed when she starts to cry

  • I know u don't like Asia. But she's better in this song....

  • @MusicSweetDoll she got much better better part choices for this song.

    Melissa reyes would have done an equally if not better of a job.

  • @mojo0737 I think that's sh** ...if is Melissa so good... well, she would sang it good, too... it is a poor excuse that Asia got better part choices for this song ;D ... but I'm not saying that Melissa can't sing... I just think that this song sang Asia better than her...

  • @MusicSweetDoll there a version were mellisa sings the whole song search for it and she is way better than aisa! she walked away who does that!

  • @MusicSweetDoll That's your personal preference.

  • lmao, the guy judge just hates Asia. Every time it cuts to him when Asia sings, he looks so disgusted.

  • @eeermnot ino what you mean im glad that melissa didnt get it cause she better than a bak up dancer but chelsie got put in pg and robyn could of stuck mel im girlicious :O or the new pusycat olls is bascally nicole and 4 dancers :(

  • i hate Asia's prsonality so thats why i thought that shes dosn't deserve to win

  • they would kill if both of them were in a group with them two ^

  • they both were good, but couldnt stand for a song like this

  • asia doesn't necessarily look stiff, but she just makes these weird movements, and bends her knees as if she's getting ready to hit a tennis ball with a racket or something =_= loosen up woman lol. and her hand too, it bugs me 0-0

  • @SamzBabesz yeah.. but those gestures actually help her hit the notes lol.

  • Asia has a very powerful voice compared to Mel. Both are amazing singers except one has a better attitude then the other. I think you guys know what I mean XD

  • wOaHH!!

  • umm asia shud never sing again. shes has a stupid voice. it just sounds like shes gurgling

  • I commented like 3monthes ago.. saying that PCD was slowly loosing there members.. well guess what? They did.. :( So you know im actually glad none of these very talanted girls won. PCD broke up anyways.. Members tryna go solo.. i do wish them the best of luck! This performance is so beautiful.. there both so good! =) Love them. Rumor has it PCD well be back with a new line up for 2010* See some new faces.. The group will not b the same.. like Girlicious issnt the same without Tiff! :(

  • Robyn probably blacklisted Asia, Thats why she hasn't made any music.

  • seriously Malissa R should of won even though her voice sounded similar to Nicoles !

    i'm still a huge fan of Malissa R!

  • I know! She dropped out later on and in my head I'm like, All of Robin's hard work was for nothing! She didn't train you and waste her time for you just so she could drop out. Don't get me wrong I love her but I'm just dissapointed in her for dropping out.

  • Agreed. :\ Melissa R totally should have won.

  • I love this..I always remembered this one performance for some reason..

  • this was a beautiful performance for a beautiful song. they both sung it well. love em both. y'all should stop hating they both talent in their own ways jeeez lol. and wtf was robin thinkin puttin them in those clothes for a song like thiss??? those dresses are so freakin short, summit a bunch of hookers would wear on a night out. IM NOT CALLIN ASIA AND MELISSA HOOKERS BTW! i love them two alot! i jus think the wadrobe is soooo wrong for this song.

  • i loooovee malissaaa :) imma fan of herr.

  • I LOVE BOTH OF THEM

  • melissa is so much better and prettier. she's gorgeous!!

  • that song gets a solid A+ wonderful

  • Aisa has a mint voice

  • #2 won..

  • I really loved there performance! You can really tell Melissa was sinqinnq from the heart & she sounded oh so qood!! But i have to say Asia was better, she nailed it! She was the winner on the reality show, but choose not to be apart of the pcd. I actually am a biq fan of the pcd, but i have to say i'm actually happy Asia didnt choose to be apart of there qroup. Look at pcd now, there slowly loosinnq there members & not really makinnq much sonqs! I do hope they come out on top soon! LOVE THEMall

  • Melissa is better

  • i don't give a shit what anyone says, i love Asia.

  • they are so good together!

  • there both really good but asia didnt evan become a doll!

  • Asia won, But then she quit not even a week later! So that was all on her.

  • this was my favorite song from the whole season. asia ruined it though.. her voice keeps shaking and at many points she screams instead of sings

  • They Both Sounn Good;

    Nd My Girl Asia

    Be Kill'n It.!

  • asiiiaa 1:40 to 1:52

  • Asia is really good, but her vibrato kinda ruins it sometimes. She should learn how to space it out more.

  • i LOVE asia's voice 1:11 to 1:15(:

  • asia wasn't that bad, but the vibaration in her voice, make's it sound terrible

  • no matter how much u say she sux... she's the one that won... so she basiically proved that she doesnt have to b the best siinger she stiill kiicked ass

  • LOL where she at now?

    ;p

  • omg asia is terrible, wow

  • y do u hate asia so much half of u voted for her

  • Asia sounds like a sheep lol

  • asia is a wkd singer xx

  • 1:16/1:17...what the fuck is up with Asia's voice?

  • I think it's an Audio Slipup.

    Other uploads of this episode was normal.

    -LADYGAGAFANS

  • loveee melissa R <3

  • shuup she didnt even say asia looks Good

    she said asia sounds Good

    go and learn the diffrence You idiot

    i dont really like asia my self but who are we 2 judge ? asia can sing....

  • Melissa R. totally should've won!

  • melissa is so so so much better than aisa, aisa sounds flat on some notes. and who gets the chance to be a pussycat doll and walks away i mean comon aisa why be like that why even enter the competition !!!!

  • they got asia cause Melissa would outshine Nicole

  • @itsSteffyBee lol thats so ignorant from you

  • @darksterboy no its actually probably why they picked asia melissa and chelsea were too strong as singer better than nicole they wantes a background singer

  • @90Rhapsody mmm i don't think so

  • @itsSteffyBee so true

  • @itsSteffyBee hahah pleaase! she wouldnt even get the chance to sing cuz Nicoles big head is always takin the spotlight. Asia won because she was better.! point blank period. besides this show (even tho she messed up) Melissa can barely sing in the right key.!

  • @itsSteffyBee i agree 100%.

    asia was a mistake

  • @bradleyy2kaii8 The Pussycat dolls were going down. what kind of group has 5 or 6 singers/dancers && one chick that sings EVERY song. she probably didnt wanna go down with that ship. if i was her i wouldve entered the comp. got my tv time && after i won, i wouldve looked for something better. PCD was not all that anyway. she could of done better.

  • @SheFollowsDreamz and that worked out for her how? what has she done since pcd presents! both mellisas and chelsie have had more fame! and the girlicious girls haha and pcd were quite big look at nicole now and even kimberley and ashley her magisty and the wolfs :)

  • @bradleyy2kaii8 is that why iv never seen her with PCD?

  • @tissetatten have you seen aisa in it either naah dont think so?

  • Daammm Asia Is Good !!!

    she even betta than nicole from the pcd !!

    Goo Asia !

    y Did you have 2 leave :(

    she shud make her own Song Now (: x

  • you must be some quire ass homo bitch to think asia looks good have you seen her teeth she looks like a beaver the 2 best looking people on that show were melissa s. and melissa r.

  • aweeeeeeeh melissa is crying : (

    shess soo cuuutee < 3

  • hi cindy this rihanna why are you cry?

  • Comment removed

  • asia sounds like shes trying to hard and pushig her vocals to hit the notes and it doesnt sound good

  • Melisa reyers in very this song qu it made c the meuileur ecoter its voice in 0:08 just qau 0:59 is it (But melisa she has as cry in the 1:00

  • they were both again

  • mellissa reyes should have won the next pussy cat dolls....

  • i know !

    it's so... GRR XD

  • FYI , cheLsea is not in PCD, she is in Paradiso Girls!!l.. peace c(=

  • What is the last name of Asia?

    Asia [...]

  • Asia's last name is Nitollano.

  • asia went solo?

  • Yes.

  • No She dIDNT sHE qUIT cUZ oF hER dAUGHTER

  • no she never she quite because she thought she could go solo

  • They were both really good, but Asia's voice reminds me of elise estrada's

  • I was actually rooting for Asia. She was much more original and unique than Mellisa R. Mellisa is really good looking, but that isn't enough to get through. I admit, she has a lot of talent, but we don't want a bunch of the same people in the Pussycat Dolls, and she looks very similar to Nicole. I'm glad Asia went solo though, it matches her more.

  • jelouse people -.-

  • i said she's a way BETTER singer too idiot :s read before u start talk

  • they didn't want a singer who overshined pcd's leadsinger so they let asia win, even though melissa is better.

  • good song ! :)

  • i agree, haha. people need to grow up. asia won, drop it.

    it's over... what the fuck.

  • well to me Melissa deserved to win her last performance was amazing and fantastic and than

    Asia quit and than Melissa became a superstar !!! heard 1 of Melissa's songs yet ??

  • Nope. When did they come out?

  • episode sorry

  • what ep was this?

  • ep?

  • mel should have solo'd this song..

  • this was def 1 of the better performances on the show :)

  • and so did melissa r. she even has a music video. and same with melissa s

  • the hugg on the end is cute

  • she already went solo

  • their both talented bout Melissa has more class !!

  • Melissa should have won she's so talented and way hotter than Asia! I love Melissa <3

  • hahahahaha no it just sounds kinda muffled

  • madd song!!!

  • I thought she left because she missed her kid to much.

  • thesse 2 giirlz should of been girlicious

  • i think that isnt true... Melissa would have said yes.. and she really didnt have a reason to say no.. when asia did.

  • They are the two best in the competition and Asia won that was good :)<3

  • I LOVE ASIA,CHELSEA,MELISSA R. <333

  • How old was melissa in this?? x

  • this was like 2 years ago O_O

  • 19 years old

  • 18 yearold

  • yep 18

  • Bessssttt song ever !

  • that show was a waste of money because when asia she quit and it was over it was all robins fault she shouldve listened to lil kim and that other judge

  • Did lil' Kim & Ron Fair choose Melissa instead?

  • Ron Fair said Melissa,

    Lil' Kim didn't mind either

    Robin said Asia.

    Melissa shoulda won .. Asia wasn't even good -.-

  • this is deffinatly my fav sonnngg ♥

  • why didnt asia cry so we could hear more of melissa?? Would have been perfect if it was all melissa but she had to cry and asia was happy to sing the entire thing to TRY to impress the judges which didnt work

  • Melissa R should win.. Asia is a bitch because she abused from the fame, she shouldn't win

  • guess what? i think all those girls have talent. i just like melissa r more in my opinion. just becuz u dont wanna worry ur parents doesnt mean ur not confident, and wearing boob pads? cmon! noone likes those things. i know she shouldnt say that to melissa s, but dont u get annoyed with UR friends sometimes? Asia and the other girls DO have talent. I dont want to be mean, but i like melissa r more.

  • Give Asia A Break!!! <3

  • SOO TRUE!!!

  • asia is so bad i cant believe she won melissa r should have won!melissas great!!!!!!!!!