Destruction of historical sites to build Mc Donalds,Starbucks,KFC,etc. How low will our capitalistic,materialistic,greed go??? May Allah swa guide our leaders to true Islam and protect our history and heritage. Amen
Muslims love the Prophet's family and love means to follow their great examples. Muslims thus worship Allaah, alone (including supplication/ DUA/ invocation/ prayer) to Allaah, alone.
Sufis and Shias exaggerate the status of the Prophet's family and other pious people and worship them by supplicating to them, seeking their help and intercession - THAT IS SHIRK (polytheism/ associating partners with Allaah).
Shirk is the worst sin in Islaam and expels a person from Islaam.
Building places of worship over graves is FORBIDDEN in Islaam and is in fact the ways of the Pagans of our time (Sufis, Shias, Catholics and more) and the Pagans of old.
Muslims love the pious slaves of Allaah; they were great humans and are great examples for us to follow.
BUT - We CANNOT build shrines above their graves - No!
IN ISLAAM - Mosques are for the worship of our Creator only and NOT for the worship (including excessive veneration) of humans or any other created being.
The Prophet of Allaah has indeed said: “Allaah cursed the Jews and the Christians for taking the graves of their prophets as Masjids (mosques).” -- Refer to the English Translation of Saheeh Bukhari, Book of Prayer, volume 1, Book 8, Hadeeth no: 427 & 428.
From Abu Al-Hayaaj Al-Asadiy who said Ali ibn Abi Taalib said to me “I am dispatching you upon what the Messenger dispatched me upon, that, “you do not leave statues except you deface it nor a grave raised except you level it”
This narration is in Kitaab ul-Janaaiz 2/666 in Muslim
Exaggerations of the righteous slaves of Allaah, have led to people (Shias, Sufis, Catholics and more) to build shrines above the graves of the righteous - THIS IS ILLEGAL IN ISLAAM
Building shrines or places of worship above graves is FORBIDDEN in Islaam because it leads to the worship of the dead
This is apparent in many Sufi and Shia shrines, where people pray to/ DUA/ supplicate to the dead, seeking help and intercession- THIS AMOUNTS TO SHIRK (polytheism/ associating partners with Allaah)
Muslims love the Prophets of Allaah (such as Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, Muhammad and more), but the Prophets were only human, therefore they do NOT deserve to be worshipped.
This means (despite their high status with Allaah), it is NOT permitted to invoke/ call upon the Prophets when we supplicate/ dua.
Muslims also love the pious friends of Allaah and the Prophet's family, but ALL of the aforementioned were human, therefore they do NOT deserve to be supplicate/ prayed to.
Shias sometimes supplicate to Allaah - This is good and is an example of Tawheed (monotheism) - eg. when one raises his hands and invokes Allaah: "O Allaah, help me, cure me...".
BUT - Sometimes Shias supplicate to their Imams (who died many centuries ago and have thus left this world) - This is AGAINST Islaam because it involves directing an act of worship (DUA/ supplication) to created beings/ humans.
If a person worships others besides Allaah, then that person is a Mushrik (polytheist).
HADEETH- The Prophet Muhammad said: "If you ask, ask of Allaah, and if you seek help, then seek the help of Allaah." [Tirmidthee, good and authentic]
HADEETH- The Prophet said: "Dua is worship". [SAHEEH (authentic) - Reported by Ahmad and the compilers of the Sunans]
HADEETH- The Prophet said: "Whosoever dies whilst making dua (invocation, supplication) to others besides Allaah, will enter the HellFire." [Related by al-Bukhaaree (no. 4297)]
Shias worship their Imams by invoking them in supplication/ dua.
For example, Shias supplicate to the 4th Khaliph - Alee and also supplicate to Al-Husain (one of the Prophet's grandchildren)
Shias supplicate in this manner: "O Alee help me" or "O Husain intercede for me" - THESE DUAS (supplications) ARE DUAS OF SHIRK and expel a person from Islaam
Muslims love Alee and Al-Husain, but it is NOT permitted to supplicate to anyone besides Allaah.
Shias supplicate/dua to others besides Allaah. This is an example of why Shias (not all Shias by the way) are Mushrikeen (polytheists/ pagans/ those who associate partners with Allaah)
The act of DUA/ invocation/ supplication is an act of worship
In Islaam ALL acts of worship can only be directed to Allaah
If a person directs ANY act of worship to others besides Allaah, then this person has given a share of worship to others besides Allaah & worshipped others besides Allaah - That is Shirk
I am not a wahabi but wahabi's shouldn't be blamed for these thing because the wahabi only say the Ameen Loud thats all and the have more understanding of Quraan as well ahadees then few of us. Brothers don't use swear words because you are watching the holly places just respect them. I don't believe if the ruling saudi family have any respect for these holly place or for Islam because they love the wealth. They are the cause of the problems in the middle east but don't blame every one. thanx
Majority of the shias in the west are ignorant and the majority of the Shias in the east are mushriks if not all. PRESS TV which run by the Child molestor Khomenei and his evil empire are the biggest deceivers. The Shias are behind alot of the killings muslims in pakistan, afghanistan, iraq, iran lebanon etc etc. Dont worry people are waking up to the truth inshaAllah.
shiia. grave worshippers. I somehow agree with keeping Islam pure and remove anything that can be worshipped apart from Allah(SWT) 95% of Muslims are sunni and they say yes take it down if it's going to lead to shirk.
i hate how they call them sacred sites. They are no such thing. Only the kaba is sacred not the actual structure around it. It's not like they are destroying the sites to make way for just housing. It;s to make way for makign hajj easier and faster and to expand the masjid itself which requires other things to be put int he place of things that were once torn down. Think with your brain people not your heart.
@SalafeeSpot no offence...but what your saying is not convincing..trust me it wont hurt them just to write theeir names on their graves....Theses people would love their to be bigger holy cites,,,hwever they would definetly be satisfied if they were just visible and seen and had their names on them(ahlul bayt) name...havce you went there and seen aryh albaqee3 im guessing not...i mean subhan allah ahlul bayt are bettre than us all , are you with me on that....
....so usually when we die we have this nice grave not so fancy...but it at least has our name..so if anyone anted to visit us....and these ahul bayt.....dont....instead..their graves are ruined...all yiu see is and..no name no nothing...now do you think that is fare? please answer..
@zynab1234 Well muslims do not put large name stones on graves so yes I think it is fair. Sure you can put a marker and the saudis do do that. How else do people know which grave to visit if they want ti visit a specific one.
I have witnessed the grave worshippers in person. As for those scholars who do not speak about the evil deeds of Al Saud family, they are known as ``Scholars of the Rulers. But among those who speak against the grave worship of the ignorant Muslims, there are many who speak against the Al Saud family and go to prison for speaking out. That was the case during the American stationing of its military during the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. Usama Bin Laden also cites presence of Americans in Arabian P
@myyou1 sorry..who are you referring as grave worshiper? shia? hhhh get your facts straight....dont bebrainwashed....shia WORSHIP ALLA,,,,SO IF You went to visit your mother's grabve and..cried...would that mean your a grave worshipper?
? please answer that but no foul language.....be polite...if you consider yourself a muslim...
First a disclaimer: I don't believe All Shia's worship at the graves of the alleged grave of hussein (radiallahu 'anhu). There are also many "Sunni" Muslims who practice worship at Graves of long deceased Muslims.
The context of my comment for example is the prostrations of some shia at the alleged grave of Hussein (radiallahu 'anhu) - see the youtube video titledShia worship of the grave of Al Hussain, is this Islam? Monotheism, or Tawheed
I am disillusioned with the two sides of the issue. I don't need any explanation to understand the corrupt and hypocritical nature of the Al Saud family. But those who protest the demolitions, most of them [though, Not all] practice grave worship (Shia, extreme Sufis like Ahbash, Haqqani, ...) which the prophet forbade in the strongest terms.
@myyou1 its not grave worship. Its asking for intersession. Later in his life The Prophet(pbuh) encouraged people to visit graves so that they would be reminded of their final destination. "Whoever visits my grave, it is incumbent upon me to intercede for him." Narrated by al-Daraqutni. The propaganda spread about "grave worship" is mostly coming from wahhabism. So why does the Wahhabi ideology flourish under the house of Saud? Why do these wahhabi's not say anything against the house of saud?
many ppl disagree wid saudis building hotels in haram area nd madinah but wt can dey do so many ppl doin hajj nd umrah mashallah if dey dont build dese hotels wher will ppl stay. but its wrong to take to take out some of the islamic sights.
we dont need the prophets birth place or the sahabis birthplace etc. What we need is to remember what the prophet taught us in hadith. I know so many indian , pakistani and irani muslim who start kissing the area were the prophet is buried and crying. So in a way i agree with the saudis. But i hate this building huge vegas style hotels.
You are not a Muslim with ur Shaitanic anti-Islamic views. Allah swt & Rasool Allah said whoever believe on Allah swt & Hz Mohammed saw as Rasool Allah, he is a Muslim. U r denying Aayat of Quran & sayings of Rasool Allah so u became Kafir by rejecting Aayat of Quran & sayings of Rasool Allah.
Don't make urself Sharik in decisions of Allah swt which he has to announce on Qiamet. A person is kafir who disbelieves Allah swt & non-Muslim who disbelieve Mohammed As Rasool Allah
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL Murderer! Jesus Healed/Blessed/ Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY/FREE OF ABUSE/MISERY! Your leaders are killing you! All Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! PLEASE REBEL/ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of ISLAM LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
No thanks... Even if you give me gold as big as an earth I will stick to Islam. We all love Jesus, but he is just a human being. A rare human being. Peace be upon him. He has so many miracles. Awesome. But Muhammad (PBUH) also has the living miracle. The Qur'an. You learn arabic then you can taste God's biggest gift to human being. The One (1) Qur'an. Even if they burn all Qur'an in this world. The same Qur'an will appear again without change. Thank you!!
well let us hope they do not destroy the dwelling place of the israelites where Moses received his commandments in Jabal Al Lawz. his is all the sign of the end when there will be no muslims left. One sect of the Sunnis who destroy to the maximum lw=eaving to trace or evedence, anothe the Shai who like the Christians and the influence of Babylonians tend to worship anything that crosses them, so who do you trust....
Yes everything needs to be modernised. It's Arab style Olympic and what has it got to do with Pakistanis? What the hell? I mean I am Afghan and I don't give a toss about it.
The site has been the best source of income for many centuries for Sauds and now more and more people are realising that Macca is now boring and perhaps they should spend their money in Dubai or Egypt. Mate it's competition wake up!!! Build a home for Allah in Karachi to support locals forget about Saudi Arabia they have oil
therefore eventually after all the extensions the grave became next door to the masjid. the sahaba had nothing to do with that neither did the taabieen neither did the taba taabieen or the muhadeetheen, or great caliphs the last extension was just a few years ago and the major extension was in 1925!!!!!! lol u need to read up bigtime. and dont call my hadeeth fake again please especially if you are a sunni forget me ask your own maulana which books after quraan are most authentic
You said: "prophet muhammad was buried in the same place he passed away, which was in bibi ayeshas house". That house then became a structure on his grave, isn't it? Therefore, it is permissible to build house on grave, isn't it? Use your brain brother!
repent from calling these hadeeth fake please. as for the prophets grave being in the mosque that just completely shows your lack of knowledge . read up on the history of masjid nabawee.the prophet muhammad was buried in the same place he passed away, which was in bibi ayeshas house, which was nowehere near the mosue at the time the mosque has been extended countless times , nu uthman e ghanee, the ummayads, the abbasids, and the green dome was put on by the ottomans a few hundred years ago
give me some islamic evidence to substantiate your claims. i have given you loads from saheh bukhare, saheh muslim and sahih tirmidhe the 3 most authentic books after quran paak. i have evidence for my views rasool allah himself ordered to destroy the tops of these graves no one has gone inside the graves to ruin them. long live the true islam.
the instructions in this hadeeth are from rasool allah himself and yes he used to visit his mothers grave because she was his mother and the only other reason allahs prophet used to visit the graves was to remind people of death and to pray FOR the person not to them. give me one ayat from the uran or a saheeh hadeeth where it says you are allowed to build on graves.sheikh muhammad ibn abdul wahaab was a reviver and he has acted on the orders of prophet muhammad
o you sunni muslim who lectured me , read all these saheeh reference from saheeh hadeeth narrated by Sahaba who knew rasool allahs deen better then us, salaam aleikum everyone if ive offended you im sorry . we dont make the deen, quraan , sunnah and hadeeth does.fee amaan allah.
I agree with you that Muslims should not worship or pray to holy men, dead or alive. However, destroying their graves is not really the way to prevent it. Instead we should preach to these Muslims about the true teachings of Islam. Otherwise, even if we destroy the graves of holy men, these ignorant people would still worship and pray to these holy men in their heart. The Prophet of Islam himself used to visit his mother's grave; it can remind us of the hereafter and soften heart.
On the authority of Abu al-Heeyaaj al-Asdee who said: 'Alee bin Abu Taalib said to me: "Shall I not send you with what the Messenger of Allaah sent me with; not to leave a statue except to efface it, nor to leave a grave elevated except that you level it."
Narrated by Muslim (v.7 p.36), at-Tirmidhee (v.2 p.154) and he authenticated it, and Abu Dawood (v.3 p.207), and an-Nisaee (v.4 p.73) and Ahmad (v.1 p.89).
On the authority of Thamamah bin Shafee: We were with Fadaalat bin Ubaid in the land of the Romans in a place called Baroodus, and one of our companions died, so Fadaalat bin Ubaid ordered for him to be buried in a grave. The grave was leveled off, and then he said: I heard the Messenger of Allaah order with the leveling off of graves.'Narrated by Muslim (v.7 p.39), Abu Dawood(v.3 p.208), an-Nisaee (v.4 p.72), Ahmad (v.6 p.18) and in it is mentioned: 'level off your graves with the ground
On the authority of Umm Salamah -radiAllaah anhu- who said: the Messenger of Allaah - sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam – prohibited building on graves or plastering them.
Narrated by Ahmad (v.6 p.299), Haythamee said in 'al-Mujma az-Zaw'aid'(v.3 p.61): with extra wording in a mursal narration: 'or sitting on it' and in both these narrations is Ibn Laheeyah, and there is some talk about him, but he is trustworthy.
On the authority of Abu Sa'eed al-Khudree : that the Prophet - sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam – prohibited building on graves.Narrated by Ibn Majah (v.1 p.498) and the authenticator said: in 'az-Zawa'id': Its Isnaad is saheeh and its narrators are trustworthy. Abu Ya'ala brought extra wording: 'or praying on top of it.' Haythamee said in 'al-Mujma'(v.3 p.61): Its narrators are trustworthy.
On the authority of Jaabir who said: that the Messenger of Allaah sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam prohibited plastering a grave, sitting on it, and to build upon it.Narrated by Muslim in his Saheeh (v.7 p.37), at-Tirmidhee (v.2 p.155) and he said that the hadeeth was hasan saheeh, Abu Dawood (v.3 p.209) and in one of his narrations: or had an extra wording, and in another narration: 'that you write upon the grave[1]'. An-Nisaaee (v.4 p.71, 72) and Ibn Majah (v.1 p.498), Ahmad (v.3 p.339).
Aisha said, "The Prophet in his fatal illness said, 'Allah cursed the Jews and the Christians because they took the graves of their Prophets as places for praying."' Aisha added, "Had it not been for that the grave of the Prophet (p.b.u.h) would have been made prominent but I am afraid it might be taken (as a) place for praying.sahih bukhari
@ForJannah read the saheeh hadeeth. rasool allah and his companions broke the buildings and structures on graves. we have been told to follow rasool allah and his sahaba.
@ForJannah read the saheeh hadeeth. rasool allah and his companions broke the buildings and structures on graves. we have been told to follow rasool allah and his sahaba.
@ForJannah brother...trust me no one worships a grave..we jsut love ahlul bayt..however Allah is the One we woship....so brother..you love your mom ...right....till death,,.....does that mean you worship your mom?
Here is the basis for the objections against Shia practice at graves: The Messenger of Allah (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam). said:
"O Allah, do not make my grave an idol to be worshipped after me. Allah was very angry with people who took the graves of their Prophets as places of worship".
Reported by Imam Malik, 593, Al Bukhari, 3765, and others
Please try to follow preceding sincere advise of our beloved leader and imam, Messenger of Allah (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam).
Aisha said, "The Prophet in his fatal illness said, 'Allah cursed the Jews and the Christians because they took the graves of their Prophets as places for praying."' Aisha added, "Had it not been for that the grave of the Prophet (p.b.u.h) would have been made prominent but I am afraid it might be taken (as a) place for praying.
“Beware of those who preceded you and used to take the graves of their prophets and righteous men as places of worship, but you must not take graves as mosques; I forbid you to do that.” (Sahih Muslim)
PEOPLE STARTED WORSHIPPING THE PEOPLE WHO WERE BURIED UNDER THEM TOMBS WHEREAS ONLY ALLAH IS TO BE WORSHIPPED PEOPLE STARTED DOING TAWAAF AROUND THESE MONUMENTS AND GRAVES AND ASKING THE INMATES OF THE GRAVE FOR HELP, THAT IS DEVIATING FROM THE SUNNAH AND IF YOU ARE A SUNNI MUSLIM READ THESE SUNNI REFERENCES
I am a sunni muslim, not a shia. If historic religious sites are haram, why the Prophet of Islam himself did not destroy those sites or instruct his companions to do so? Isn't deviating from the practices of the Prophet Bidaah? By destroying these sites, the Saudis are destroying the past of the Ummah, and without that past there can be no present or future.
@syedhasan1964 “Beware of those who preceded you and used to take the graves of their prophets and righteous men as places of worship, but you must not take graves as mosques; I forbid you to do that.” (Sahih Muslim)
@syedhasan1964 exactly...becayse saudis main intention is to wipe out ahlul bayt.not the graves..they dont want us to remember ahlul bayt..RASool says ;(SAAS) AHYOO THIKRENA RAHAMA ALLAH MEN AHYA THIKRANA......
The arguments the Saudis use to destroy religious sites can be used to some of the practices of the Hajj as well, becasue these can lead to idolatry of Abraham, Ishmael or his mother. Should these practices therefore be abolished do you think? Please brother use your brain because not using our brains has resulted in the current state of miseries of this Ummah.
@syedhasan1964 “If any religious man dies amongst those people they would build a place of worship at his grave and make these pictures in it. They will be the worst creature in the sight of Allah on the Day of Resurrection.” (Sahih Bukhari)
“Do not sit on the graves and do not pray facing towards them.” (Sahih Bukhari)
The grave of the Prophet of Islam is within his Mosque in Madinah. If these hadiths are sahih, how the companions of the Prophet of Islam could let this happen? I therefore have reasonable grounds to believe that these hadiths are fake.
@syedhasan1964 tut tut tut, wash your mouth out, ahle sunnah wal jamaah meaning sunnis have done an ijma on the fact that all the hadeeth in saheeh bukharee and sahee tirmidhee and shaheee muslim are authentic. read the isnaad meaning chain of narrators they are sahabiye rasool.your reasonable grounds mean jack shit to me the references are there from the most saheeh books in islam after the quraan paak. first sahih bukhari then sahih muslim then sahih tirmidhi after the quran are most authentic
Good Work Saudi Muslims Destroy All the Islamic,Holiest sites!!!!
m00se321 6 days ago
wahabi pigs don't worship Allah they worship dollar. May Allah destroy wahabis and save Islam. Ameen.
subsrebel 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@subsrebel
Allah has selected the Saudis as the custodians of Makkah and Madina.
Who are you challenge Allah's decision??
alfulani5 2 weeks ago
Destruction of historical sites to build Mc Donalds,Starbucks,KFC,etc. How low will our capitalistic,materialistic,greed go??? May Allah swa guide our leaders to true Islam and protect our history and heritage. Amen
mirasprofile 1 month ago
@mirasprofile If we go by your suggestion Makkah and Madina will be 2 large museums, as every squire inch is filled with history.
alfulani5 2 weeks ago
haha, shiite propaganda, try again...beware of this press'shit'tv
yat81 1 month ago
Saudi Arabia is NOT perfect, but there is a lot of good Islaam there.
Their Islaamic scholars promote pure Tawheed (monotheism) - the worship of Allaah, alone, without the association of any partners with Him.
It is a land where people are NOT permitted to worship the dead at graves - because Islaam FORBIDS worshipping anyone or anything besides Allaah.
Saudi Arabia contributes considerable wealth to the cause of Islaam, including the printing and donation of huge amounts of Qur'aans.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Muslims love the Prophet's family and love means to follow their great examples. Muslims thus worship Allaah, alone (including supplication/ DUA/ invocation/ prayer) to Allaah, alone.
Sufis and Shias exaggerate the status of the Prophet's family and other pious people and worship them by supplicating to them, seeking their help and intercession - THAT IS SHIRK (polytheism/ associating partners with Allaah).
Shirk is the worst sin in Islaam and expels a person from Islaam.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Building places of worship over graves is FORBIDDEN in Islaam and is in fact the ways of the Pagans of our time (Sufis, Shias, Catholics and more) and the Pagans of old.
Muslims love the pious slaves of Allaah; they were great humans and are great examples for us to follow.
BUT - We CANNOT build shrines above their graves - No!
IN ISLAAM - Mosques are for the worship of our Creator only and NOT for the worship (including excessive veneration) of humans or any other created being.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
The Prophet of Allaah has indeed said: “Allaah cursed the Jews and the Christians for taking the graves of their prophets as Masjids (mosques).” -- Refer to the English Translation of Saheeh Bukhari, Book of Prayer, volume 1, Book 8, Hadeeth no: 427 & 428.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
From Jaabir bin Abdullaah who said that the Messenger of Allaah prohibited plastering of the graves and sitting upon it and building upon it.
This narration is in Kitaab ul-Janaaiz 2/667 in Muslim
trenchraiding 1 month ago
From Abu Al-Hayaaj Al-Asadiy who said Ali ibn Abi Taalib said to me “I am dispatching you upon what the Messenger dispatched me upon, that, “you do not leave statues except you deface it nor a grave raised except you level it”
This narration is in Kitaab ul-Janaaiz 2/666 in Muslim
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Exaggerations of the righteous slaves of Allaah, have led to people (Shias, Sufis, Catholics and more) to build shrines above the graves of the righteous - THIS IS ILLEGAL IN ISLAAM
Building shrines or places of worship above graves is FORBIDDEN in Islaam because it leads to the worship of the dead
This is apparent in many Sufi and Shia shrines, where people pray to/ DUA/ supplicate to the dead, seeking help and intercession- THIS AMOUNTS TO SHIRK (polytheism/ associating partners with Allaah)
trenchraiding 1 month ago
We should be careful NOT to exaggerate the status of the pious/ righteous. All of the pious were slaves of Allaah and humans.
IN ISLAAM - Only Allaah - Who is the sole Lord, Creator and Provider - deserves to be worshipped.
Created beings do NOT deserve to be worshipped.
In fact the pious friends of Allaah worshipped Allaah, alone, including the fact that they supplicated/ invoked Allaah, ALONE.
Let us follow the Prophets and their pious followers - Let us also supplicate to Allaah, alone.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Muslims love the Prophets of Allaah (such as Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, Muhammad and more), but the Prophets were only human, therefore they do NOT deserve to be worshipped.
This means (despite their high status with Allaah), it is NOT permitted to invoke/ call upon the Prophets when we supplicate/ dua.
Muslims also love the pious friends of Allaah and the Prophet's family, but ALL of the aforementioned were human, therefore they do NOT deserve to be supplicate/ prayed to.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
QUR'AAN - ...so invoke not anyone along with Allâh. (Al-Jinn 72:18)
Therefore when Muslim perform the act of DUA/ supplication, they only invoke Allaah - Who is the sole Lord, Creator and Provider of all things.
But Shias disobey Allaah, by invoking their Imams (who were only human and left this world many centuries ago!) in supplication/ dua.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Shias sometimes supplicate to Allaah - This is good and is an example of Tawheed (monotheism) - eg. when one raises his hands and invokes Allaah: "O Allaah, help me, cure me...".
BUT - Sometimes Shias supplicate to their Imams (who died many centuries ago and have thus left this world) - This is AGAINST Islaam because it involves directing an act of worship (DUA/ supplication) to created beings/ humans.
If a person worships others besides Allaah, then that person is a Mushrik (polytheist).
trenchraiding 1 month ago
AUTHENTIC proof from the Messenger of Allaah:
HADEETH- The Prophet Muhammad said: "If you ask, ask of Allaah, and if you seek help, then seek the help of Allaah." [Tirmidthee, good and authentic]
HADEETH- The Prophet said: "Dua is worship". [SAHEEH (authentic) - Reported by Ahmad and the compilers of the Sunans]
HADEETH- The Prophet said: "Whosoever dies whilst making dua (invocation, supplication) to others besides Allaah, will enter the HellFire." [Related by al-Bukhaaree (no. 4297)]
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Shias worship their Imams by invoking them in supplication/ dua.
For example, Shias supplicate to the 4th Khaliph - Alee and also supplicate to Al-Husain (one of the Prophet's grandchildren)
Shias supplicate in this manner: "O Alee help me" or "O Husain intercede for me" - THESE DUAS (supplications) ARE DUAS OF SHIRK and expel a person from Islaam
Muslims love Alee and Al-Husain, but it is NOT permitted to supplicate to anyone besides Allaah.
Therefore, Muslims supplicate to Allaah, alone.
trenchraiding 1 month ago
Shias supplicate/dua to others besides Allaah. This is an example of why Shias (not all Shias by the way) are Mushrikeen (polytheists/ pagans/ those who associate partners with Allaah)
The act of DUA/ invocation/ supplication is an act of worship
In Islaam ALL acts of worship can only be directed to Allaah
If a person directs ANY act of worship to others besides Allaah, then this person has given a share of worship to others besides Allaah & worshipped others besides Allaah - That is Shirk
trenchraiding 1 month ago
I am not a wahabi but wahabi's shouldn't be blamed for these thing because the wahabi only say the Ameen Loud thats all and the have more understanding of Quraan as well ahadees then few of us. Brothers don't use swear words because you are watching the holly places just respect them. I don't believe if the ruling saudi family have any respect for these holly place or for Islam because they love the wealth. They are the cause of the problems in the middle east but don't blame every one. thanx
123shyda 1 month ago
Wahabbis r cursed! Pure n simple!
privatezib 1 month ago
Majority of the shias in the west are ignorant and the majority of the Shias in the east are mushriks if not all. PRESS TV which run by the Child molestor Khomenei and his evil empire are the biggest deceivers. The Shias are behind alot of the killings muslims in pakistan, afghanistan, iraq, iran lebanon etc etc. Dont worry people are waking up to the truth inshaAllah.
ManhajOfTheSalaf 2 months ago
Shia majority are not muslims.
ManhajOfTheSalaf 2 months ago
and what about them removing the Holy name Muhammad from the wall in the grqve of Prophet Muhammad (sAaws) ?
Oh, yes, their excuse is that Muhammad next to ALLAH being shirk. Soon they will pay and run and hide, just wait...
Qassimax 2 months ago
FUCK THE DIRTY HOUSE OF SAUD WAHABI MUTHAFUKASS
ruthless6661 2 months ago
IF IT WAS UP TO THE WAHABIS THE KABBA WOULD BE TURNED INTO A TOILET SIK FUKERS
ruthless6661 2 months ago
Comment removed
ruthless6661 2 months ago
WAHABI BASTARD SONS OF YAZID
ruthless6661 2 months ago
shiia. grave worshippers. I somehow agree with keeping Islam pure and remove anything that can be worshipped apart from Allah(SWT) 95% of Muslims are sunni and they say yes take it down if it's going to lead to shirk.
glower125 2 months ago
@glower125 u prik if my shia brothers are protesting against turning the prophets birth place into a public toilet is that a bad thing wtf
ruthless6661 2 months ago
@glower125 NO LETS TURN IT INTO A TOILET THE FUKIN JEWS COULDNT HAVE THOUGHT OF A BETTER IDEA WAHABBI BASTARDS
ruthless6661 2 months ago
they are persian , and everyone know persian hate the hale word . disgusting people . now go and take shower .
MsLumos85 3 months ago
wahabis are the worst
TheSmartboy77 3 months ago
لعن الله آبوكم كلكم ياليهود يالملاعين ياقحاب .. تحاولون تشوهون صورة السعوديه منتوب عارفين ياخنازير ياقحاب
flaregunsx26x 3 months ago
King of Saudi is a fraud, he should go.
badiaism 3 months ago
i hate how they call them sacred sites. They are no such thing. Only the kaba is sacred not the actual structure around it. It's not like they are destroying the sites to make way for just housing. It;s to make way for makign hajj easier and faster and to expand the masjid itself which requires other things to be put int he place of things that were once torn down. Think with your brain people not your heart.
SalafeeSpot 3 months ago
@SalafeeSpot no offence...but what your saying is not convincing..trust me it wont hurt them just to write theeir names on their graves....Theses people would love their to be bigger holy cites,,,hwever they would definetly be satisfied if they were just visible and seen and had their names on them(ahlul bayt) name...havce you went there and seen aryh albaqee3 im guessing not...i mean subhan allah ahlul bayt are bettre than us all , are you with me on that....
zynab1234 3 months ago
....so usually when we die we have this nice grave not so fancy...but it at least has our name..so if anyone anted to visit us....and these ahul bayt.....dont....instead..their graves are ruined...all yiu see is and..no name no nothing...now do you think that is fare? please answer..
zynab1234 3 months ago
@zynab1234 Well muslims do not put large name stones on graves so yes I think it is fair. Sure you can put a marker and the saudis do do that. How else do people know which grave to visit if they want ti visit a specific one.
SalafeeSpot 3 months ago
Stupid shias and there protesting this.
SalafeeSpot 3 months ago
I have witnessed the grave worshippers in person. As for those scholars who do not speak about the evil deeds of Al Saud family, they are known as ``Scholars of the Rulers. But among those who speak against the grave worship of the ignorant Muslims, there are many who speak against the Al Saud family and go to prison for speaking out. That was the case during the American stationing of its military during the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. Usama Bin Laden also cites presence of Americans in Arabian P
myyou1 3 months ago
@myyou1 sorry..who are you referring as grave worshiper? shia? hhhh get your facts straight....dont bebrainwashed....shia WORSHIP ALLA,,,,SO IF You went to visit your mother's grabve and..cried...would that mean your a grave worshipper?
? please answer that but no foul language.....be polite...if you consider yourself a muslim...
zynab1234 3 months ago
@zynab1234
First a disclaimer: I don't believe All Shia's worship at the graves of the alleged grave of hussein (radiallahu 'anhu). There are also many "Sunni" Muslims who practice worship at Graves of long deceased Muslims.
The context of my comment for example is the prostrations of some shia at the alleged grave of Hussein (radiallahu 'anhu) - see the youtube video titledShia worship of the grave of Al Hussain, is this Islam? Monotheism, or Tawheed
or: /watch?v=P-jsrfCjkzg
myyou1 3 months ago
saud family is puppet of united states and they are back stabbers against islamic world.i am sunni not shia.shia are better muslim then wahabies.
GhalibSarmad1724 3 months ago
@GhalibSarmad1724 ya that is so true...finally...someone reveals the truth...
zynab1234 3 months ago
typical shia propaganda
iffi0014 3 months ago
اصلا الكذاب الثاني باين انو مسلم ما تشوفوالسلسةمعلقة
JEDDAHization 4 months ago
ابناء متعة.. ماذا تتوقعون منهم غير الكذب والخيانة
2gohan002 5 months ago
I am disillusioned with the two sides of the issue. I don't need any explanation to understand the corrupt and hypocritical nature of the Al Saud family. But those who protest the demolitions, most of them [though, Not all] practice grave worship (Shia, extreme Sufis like Ahbash, Haqqani, ...) which the prophet forbade in the strongest terms.
myyou1 5 months ago
@myyou1 its not grave worship. Its asking for intersession. Later in his life The Prophet(pbuh) encouraged people to visit graves so that they would be reminded of their final destination. "Whoever visits my grave, it is incumbent upon me to intercede for him." Narrated by al-Daraqutni. The propaganda spread about "grave worship" is mostly coming from wahhabism. So why does the Wahhabi ideology flourish under the house of Saud? Why do these wahhabi's not say anything against the house of saud?
badassmonkeykilla 3 months ago
Destroying the evidence in the name of idolatry :)
TheRationalizer 5 months ago
many ppl disagree wid saudis building hotels in haram area nd madinah but wt can dey do so many ppl doin hajj nd umrah mashallah if dey dont build dese hotels wher will ppl stay. but its wrong to take to take out some of the islamic sights.
allah wualam.
elterible2k10 6 months ago
Sonna muslim are filthy pigs. they are moon god worshippers, not even Muslims
perrik7 7 months ago
The hypocrites called "Wahabis" will soon be thrown out Hijaz.
Hussain5572 7 months ago
we dont need the prophets birth place or the sahabis birthplace etc. What we need is to remember what the prophet taught us in hadith. I know so many indian , pakistani and irani muslim who start kissing the area were the prophet is buried and crying. So in a way i agree with the saudis. But i hate this building huge vegas style hotels.
babynadoo 9 months ago
my dear they r not muslims they r non muslims be care full
kafir kafir shia kafir jo na many wo b kafir
tahirkhan93 9 months ago
tahirkhan93
You are not a Muslim with ur Shaitanic anti-Islamic views. Allah swt & Rasool Allah said whoever believe on Allah swt & Hz Mohammed saw as Rasool Allah, he is a Muslim. U r denying Aayat of Quran & sayings of Rasool Allah so u became Kafir by rejecting Aayat of Quran & sayings of Rasool Allah.
Don't make urself Sharik in decisions of Allah swt which he has to announce on Qiamet. A person is kafir who disbelieves Allah swt & non-Muslim who disbelieve Mohammed As Rasool Allah
Rakhasabd 6 months ago
@tahirkhan93 estaghferallah...men keferee moslim fe huwa kafir......
zynab1234 3 months ago
kafir kafir shia kafir
shia is the black kafir on earth
tahirkhan93 9 months ago
@tahirkhan93 Bhenchod! get you fact right you Wahhabi Kafir and the follower of corrupt saudi, house of Saud! worship them you stupid !!!!
alialiker 2 months ago
oil money is used to a have a go at each other sect.....nothing more.....Iran and Saudi Arabia go head to head and leave the rest of muslims..
jawadtlg 9 months ago
@wasiim69 and what Hadith/s are you referring to? Any refs
saj3002 10 months ago
shia funny
basoom1000 10 months ago
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL Murderer! Jesus Healed/Blessed/ Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY/FREE OF ABUSE/MISERY! Your leaders are killing you! All Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! PLEASE REBEL/ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of ISLAM LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
tigersforchrist 10 months ago
@tigersforchrist
No thanks... Even if you give me gold as big as an earth I will stick to Islam. We all love Jesus, but he is just a human being. A rare human being. Peace be upon him. He has so many miracles. Awesome. But Muhammad (PBUH) also has the living miracle. The Qur'an. You learn arabic then you can taste God's biggest gift to human being. The One (1) Qur'an. Even if they burn all Qur'an in this world. The same Qur'an will appear again without change. Thank you!!
joniindo78 10 months ago
Black flags Black souls black minds everything about U is black
ReneeDeRiyadh 11 months ago
@ReneeDeRiyadh wowww....brainwashed...
zynab1234 3 months ago
TO hell the saudi KING and HIS family too.
1976jasse 11 months ago
well let us hope they do not destroy the dwelling place of the israelites where Moses received his commandments in Jabal Al Lawz. his is all the sign of the end when there will be no muslims left. One sect of the Sunnis who destroy to the maximum lw=eaving to trace or evedence, anothe the Shai who like the Christians and the influence of Babylonians tend to worship anything that crosses them, so who do you trust....
vixi92 11 months ago
Yes everything needs to be modernised. It's Arab style Olympic and what has it got to do with Pakistanis? What the hell? I mean I am Afghan and I don't give a toss about it.
The site has been the best source of income for many centuries for Sauds and now more and more people are realising that Macca is now boring and perhaps they should spend their money in Dubai or Egypt. Mate it's competition wake up!!! Build a home for Allah in Karachi to support locals forget about Saudi Arabia they have oil
kataSang 11 months ago
Comment removed
syedhasan1964 1 year ago
therefore eventually after all the extensions the grave became next door to the masjid. the sahaba had nothing to do with that neither did the taabieen neither did the taba taabieen or the muhadeetheen, or great caliphs the last extension was just a few years ago and the major extension was in 1925!!!!!! lol u need to read up bigtime. and dont call my hadeeth fake again please especially if you are a sunni forget me ask your own maulana which books after quraan are most authentic
wasiiim69 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@wasiiim69
You said: "prophet muhammad was buried in the same place he passed away, which was in bibi ayeshas house". That house then became a structure on his grave, isn't it? Therefore, it is permissible to build house on grave, isn't it? Use your brain brother!
syedhasan1964 1 year ago
repent from calling these hadeeth fake please. as for the prophets grave being in the mosque that just completely shows your lack of knowledge . read up on the history of masjid nabawee.the prophet muhammad was buried in the same place he passed away, which was in bibi ayeshas house, which was nowehere near the mosue at the time the mosque has been extended countless times , nu uthman e ghanee, the ummayads, the abbasids, and the green dome was put on by the ottomans a few hundred years ago
wasiiim69 1 year ago
give me some islamic evidence to substantiate your claims. i have given you loads from saheh bukhare, saheh muslim and sahih tirmidhe the 3 most authentic books after quran paak. i have evidence for my views rasool allah himself ordered to destroy the tops of these graves no one has gone inside the graves to ruin them. long live the true islam.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
the instructions in this hadeeth are from rasool allah himself and yes he used to visit his mothers grave because she was his mother and the only other reason allahs prophet used to visit the graves was to remind people of death and to pray FOR the person not to them. give me one ayat from the uran or a saheeh hadeeth where it says you are allowed to build on graves.sheikh muhammad ibn abdul wahaab was a reviver and he has acted on the orders of prophet muhammad
wasiiim69 1 year ago
o you sunni muslim who lectured me , read all these saheeh reference from saheeh hadeeth narrated by Sahaba who knew rasool allahs deen better then us, salaam aleikum everyone if ive offended you im sorry . we dont make the deen, quraan , sunnah and hadeeth does.fee amaan allah.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
@wasiiim69
I agree with you that Muslims should not worship or pray to holy men, dead or alive. However, destroying their graves is not really the way to prevent it. Instead we should preach to these Muslims about the true teachings of Islam. Otherwise, even if we destroy the graves of holy men, these ignorant people would still worship and pray to these holy men in their heart. The Prophet of Islam himself used to visit his mother's grave; it can remind us of the hereafter and soften heart.
syedhasan1964 1 year ago
On the authority of Abu al-Heeyaaj al-Asdee who said: 'Alee bin Abu Taalib said to me: "Shall I not send you with what the Messenger of Allaah sent me with; not to leave a statue except to efface it, nor to leave a grave elevated except that you level it."
Narrated by Muslim (v.7 p.36), at-Tirmidhee (v.2 p.154) and he authenticated it, and Abu Dawood (v.3 p.207), and an-Nisaee (v.4 p.73) and Ahmad (v.1 p.89).
wasiiim69 1 year ago
On the authority of Thamamah bin Shafee: We were with Fadaalat bin Ubaid in the land of the Romans in a place called Baroodus, and one of our companions died, so Fadaalat bin Ubaid ordered for him to be buried in a grave. The grave was leveled off, and then he said: I heard the Messenger of Allaah order with the leveling off of graves.'Narrated by Muslim (v.7 p.39), Abu Dawood(v.3 p.208), an-Nisaee (v.4 p.72), Ahmad (v.6 p.18) and in it is mentioned: 'level off your graves with the ground
wasiiim69 1 year ago
On the authority of Umm Salamah -radiAllaah anhu- who said: the Messenger of Allaah - sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam – prohibited building on graves or plastering them.
Narrated by Ahmad (v.6 p.299), Haythamee said in 'al-Mujma az-Zaw'aid'(v.3 p.61): with extra wording in a mursal narration: 'or sitting on it' and in both these narrations is Ibn Laheeyah, and there is some talk about him, but he is trustworthy.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
On the authority of Abu Sa'eed al-Khudree : that the Prophet - sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam – prohibited building on graves.Narrated by Ibn Majah (v.1 p.498) and the authenticator said: in 'az-Zawa'id': Its Isnaad is saheeh and its narrators are trustworthy. Abu Ya'ala brought extra wording: 'or praying on top of it.' Haythamee said in 'al-Mujma'(v.3 p.61): Its narrators are trustworthy.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
On the authority of Jaabir who said: that the Messenger of Allaah sallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam prohibited plastering a grave, sitting on it, and to build upon it.Narrated by Muslim in his Saheeh (v.7 p.37), at-Tirmidhee (v.2 p.155) and he said that the hadeeth was hasan saheeh, Abu Dawood (v.3 p.209) and in one of his narrations: or had an extra wording, and in another narration: 'that you write upon the grave[1]'. An-Nisaaee (v.4 p.71, 72) and Ibn Majah (v.1 p.498), Ahmad (v.3 p.339).
wasiiim69 1 year ago
Aisha said, "The Prophet in his fatal illness said, 'Allah cursed the Jews and the Christians because they took the graves of their Prophets as places for praying."' Aisha added, "Had it not been for that the grave of the Prophet (p.b.u.h) would have been made prominent but I am afraid it might be taken (as a) place for praying.sahih bukhari
wasiiim69 1 year ago
@wasiiim69 Grave worship is obviously not allowed but destroying a grave isn't the right way to prevent idolatry
ForJannah 1 year ago
@ForJannah read the saheeh hadeeth. rasool allah and his companions broke the buildings and structures on graves. we have been told to follow rasool allah and his sahaba.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ForJannah read the saheeh hadeeth. rasool allah and his companions broke the buildings and structures on graves. we have been told to follow rasool allah and his sahaba.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
@ForJannah brother...trust me no one worships a grave..we jsut love ahlul bayt..however Allah is the One we woship....so brother..you love your mom ...right....till death,,.....does that mean you worship your mom?
zynab1234 3 months ago
@zynab1234
Here is the basis for the objections against Shia practice at graves: The Messenger of Allah (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam). said:
"O Allah, do not make my grave an idol to be worshipped after me. Allah was very angry with people who took the graves of their Prophets as places of worship".
Reported by Imam Malik, 593, Al Bukhari, 3765, and others
Please try to follow preceding sincere advise of our beloved leader and imam, Messenger of Allah (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam).
myyou1 3 months ago
Comment removed
ruthless6661 2 months ago
Aisha said, "The Prophet in his fatal illness said, 'Allah cursed the Jews and the Christians because they took the graves of their Prophets as places for praying."' Aisha added, "Had it not been for that the grave of the Prophet (p.b.u.h) would have been made prominent but I am afraid it might be taken (as a) place for praying.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
that shia slag on 51 seconds comes on ahlebayt tv saying things about the great men of islam such as Abu Bakr RA, Umar RA and Uthman RA
wasiiim69 1 year ago
“Beware of those who preceded you and used to take the graves of their prophets and righteous men as places of worship, but you must not take graves as mosques; I forbid you to do that.” (Sahih Muslim)
wasiiim69 1 year ago
PEOPLE STARTED WORSHIPPING THE PEOPLE WHO WERE BURIED UNDER THEM TOMBS WHEREAS ONLY ALLAH IS TO BE WORSHIPPED PEOPLE STARTED DOING TAWAAF AROUND THESE MONUMENTS AND GRAVES AND ASKING THE INMATES OF THE GRAVE FOR HELP, THAT IS DEVIATING FROM THE SUNNAH AND IF YOU ARE A SUNNI MUSLIM READ THESE SUNNI REFERENCES
wasiiim69 1 year ago
Assalammualaika ya Rasullulah....
Allahumma shalli 'ala Muhammad wa aali Muhammad wa ajjil farajahum
aryzalamany 1 year ago
shia bastards.
wasiiim69 1 year ago
@wasiiim69
I am a sunni muslim, not a shia. If historic religious sites are haram, why the Prophet of Islam himself did not destroy those sites or instruct his companions to do so? Isn't deviating from the practices of the Prophet Bidaah? By destroying these sites, the Saudis are destroying the past of the Ummah, and without that past there can be no present or future.
syedhasan1964 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@syedhasan1964 “Beware of those who preceded you and used to take the graves of their prophets and righteous men as places of worship, but you must not take graves as mosques; I forbid you to do that.” (Sahih Muslim)
wasiiim69 1 year ago
@syedhasan1964 exactly...becayse saudis main intention is to wipe out ahlul bayt.not the graves..they dont want us to remember ahlul bayt..RASool says ;(SAAS) AHYOO THIKRENA RAHAMA ALLAH MEN AHYA THIKRANA......
zynab1234 3 months ago
@wasiiim69
The arguments the Saudis use to destroy religious sites can be used to some of the practices of the Hajj as well, becasue these can lead to idolatry of Abraham, Ishmael or his mother. Should these practices therefore be abolished do you think? Please brother use your brain because not using our brains has resulted in the current state of miseries of this Ummah.
syedhasan1964 1 year ago
@syedhasan1964 “If any religious man dies amongst those people they would build a place of worship at his grave and make these pictures in it. They will be the worst creature in the sight of Allah on the Day of Resurrection.” (Sahih Bukhari)
“Do not sit on the graves and do not pray facing towards them.” (Sahih Bukhari)
wasiiim69 1 year ago
@wasiiim69
The grave of the Prophet of Islam is within his Mosque in Madinah. If these hadiths are sahih, how the companions of the Prophet of Islam could let this happen? I therefore have reasonable grounds to believe that these hadiths are fake.
syedhasan1964 1 year ago
@syedhasan1964 tut tut tut, wash your mouth out, ahle sunnah wal jamaah meaning sunnis have done an ijma on the fact that all the hadeeth in saheeh bukharee and sahee tirmidhee and shaheee muslim are authentic. read the isnaad meaning chain of narrators they are sahabiye rasool.your reasonable grounds mean jack shit to me the references are there from the most saheeh books in islam after the quraan paak. first sahih bukhari then sahih muslim then sahih tirmidhi after the quran are most authentic
wasiiim69 1 year ago