Added: 4 years ago
From: Sillylily101
Views: 177,761
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (283)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I loved this movie, and so did the author. All you crap-faced freaks that hate it should just shut the heck up and get on with your already-wasted lives. And they are only wasted because you say that you hate this movie! Saphira was beautiful for the movie and her scales, in my opinion, were the right color, and all the character designs were good! All the mistakes in this movie could be easily fixed and the casting was great. The best part of the movie, though, were the special effects!!!!!!!!!

  • even if this movie wasn't based off a book, it STILL would have sucked.

  • THE URGALS ATTACKED FROM BELOW GROUND IN THE BOOK!!!! I WILL KILL YOU HOLLYWOOD (oh but paolini is epic)

    please don't take this toooooo personally

  • @IsaacD39 Actually, Ajihad WAS black, but other than that, you are correct

  • @MisterMortarious yea that or really tan, like an arabien.

  • @miskers12 he had orange ish tan skin but not blak

  • @j48000 yea.. like an arabian.

  • JOKES ON U I LIKE THIS SONG

  • if i remember corectly does the dragon shouts with the rider? or smth like that? FUS RO DAH !!

  • Brom is Eragons dad

  • jeremy irons by far was the best actor in the film.

  • i thought Irons did ok as brom

  • *facepalm* Feathers? Really?

  • barzul, safe to say that this explosion of... well, comments, occurred due to Inheritence?

  • 1:11 lol

  • Release it in parts. Sry about it cutting off last time.

  • When I first saw this movie I thought it was good, I saw it again after I had read the books and was tempted to throw the disk on a fire, they miss out literally months of the storyline like when he is bringing saphira up and all the time he spends in fathen dur before the attack, I know it would have been a ridiculously long film if they had but why not do it in 2 parts. I am going to be remaking the whole storyline of eragon in minecraft and not miss out anything it will take time but I will

  • @TheCrafters1997 the spine and Beors will be hard and what if Elsmerria caches fire?

  • I really hate that Arya in the movie is blonde. It clearly states in the book that she has long black hair.

  • Personally Brom ( jeremy irons ) is one of my favorite actors, he always has very good roles

  • Nope Draco off dragonheart if u havent seen it watch it its beter than this movie

  • The only thing I liked about this film is Brom. He is just like I imagined.. 

  • brom looks young i imagined him looking like a very old person with white hair and a bigger beard

  • The movie sucks! They skipped a lot of events! Seriously! Eragon found Arya when he was captured! He didn't go looking for Arya! And Arya was unconcious! Murtagh, Nasuada, Orik... All the characters that made the book good were taken out! Saphira's form sucked! HEr scales are supposed to glimmer, and gleam! They completely changed Farthen Dur! What happened to the wins! And the star Sapphire!

  • i think saphira looks fine... and she didnt have those whisker things on her head. she could have looked a little more saphirre blue though, her scales are a bit dim

  • What the crap was that????? I could make a better movie!!! I don't even know how to work a video camera!!! I mean sieriously, there was no conversation in the movie! It was just major event after major event!! And not to mention they totally skipped Teirm which was one of the best parts!!!! Saphira and Eragon had barely a relationship! Brom was portrade wrong, but Murtagh was HOT!!!!

  • they didnt give enough info about brom or magic in the movie as much as they did in the book

  • the black horse at 0:12 should be white!

  • @MegaDuckyduck there were so many things they got wrong in the film it really doesnt matter haha

  • Arya didnt have pointed ears.... and she's an elf....hmm...

    anything wrong with this picture?

  • I own thus movie and the second book. Murtagh and eragon are super freaking HOT!!!!!

  • i was the 130th person to unlike this video XD

  • Hmm. . . Eragon Filk . . . Ahhh. . . beautiful.

  • movie sucked..

    books = best discovery since air

  • Am I the only person who wants to know the name of the song??

  • @Stukii81 no, you're not :D i love this song

  • i was shouting at the tv when i saw this film, i could not fathom how it was possible to make such a brilliant story into such a bad film! :-(

  • @18joe2 I know how you feel, okay. Check out my channel.

  • I just reread the entire series and am really disappointed that it hasn't been turned into an epic movie series. They messed it up bigtime but it could be given a second chance after a few more years. Maybe they could get Peter Jackson or someone who wouldn't be dumb enough to make a majestic blue dragon with bright scales look like a giant bird to direct it, because it could really be as good as Lord of the Rings

  • @georgebaggy dude i sooooooo agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!! i mean it should be turned into a epic movie series like hp or narnia right?!

  • 0:38 NO WAY! the book describes her as a blue dragon with bright glittering scales! not a bird with gray scales!

  • Dosn't matter wot Saphira looks like. The matter is does she act like a dragon? Breaths fire? Yep. Flies?Yep. Then she acts like a dragon so is a dragon

  • loooooooooser

  • Brom Died so sad

  • why the fuck does saphira have scaley bird wings. one of the thousands of fuck ups they did in this movie, its like they didnt even read the book.

  • 1. Terrible Actors.

    2. Terrible AcTING.

    3. Book rushed through.

    4. lack of descriptive gore that the book had.

    5. cheaply created.

    6. norealistic/ almost a childrens movie.

    7. why was i reminded of disney wen i watched this?

  • @HollowWithin001 Cheap? I'm very sure it looked nice, even better than most fantasy movies do.

    Maybe Eragon was bad, but was Eragon all of the actors in the movie? What about Brom and Saphira?

    Nonrealistic.. that just says it all, a movie about Dragons controlled by some chosen humans is nonrealistic..

    As for Disney.. I can't associate the 2 together, Disney had a lot of amazing films with brilliant art, story and mood changes.

    All in all the final conclussion to this coment, a failure.

  • @toxicitzi how the FUCK is saphira an actress? none of the actors i recognize because of the low budget bootleg ass feel! maybe brom...ajihad and galbatorrix. thats it?!?! cheap for sure! if compared next to the LOTR series, this looks like even more of a pile of shit than it already is! as for disney? this movie lacked the realistic world feel- no one swears, or bleeds. magically, the characters seem to understand they are in a pg movie and should tone down their personalities.

  • @HollowWithin001 You have no idea how to talk about movies, please shut up.. You're just another prick that doesn't even know the First step on how to produce a movie..

    btw, I don't remember LotR movies saying Fuck or Shit, maybe because they didn't need to?... like I said, you have No idea how to talk about movies.. your insane expectations get in your way of Analyzing a movie Properly

  • @toxicitzi just shut the fuck up you fucking twat. who gives a shit if i dont know how to produce movies? i give my opinion as the VIEWER of the movie. just like everyone else that thought this movie was shit. you can gripe all you want about it, but fact remains the same, since the producers were so good at their jobs, no one fucking enjoyed the movie, so have fun being the only one wishing for a sequel while everyone else just wants a remake. go fuck yourself you self absorbed piece of shit.

  • @HollowWithin001 and you are supposed to be the next generation that will follow after our fathers?

    if you're promising me you know how to do a movie better than these assholes that failed at Eragon, when you can't even get what's wrong with this movie out, I'm telling you right now.. It will take a few centuries before we will be able to cleanse the taint of this next generation that's about to come, and only then will we be able to make something close to the level of Citizen Kane.

  • @HollowWithin001 Here's why you have no idea what you're talking about.

    1. The scenes aren't fucking connected, they just jump out of nowhere and start anew.. if you read the book, you'd still be confused because of the terrible transitions in this movie..

    2. The main actor isn't a main character, he's one of the most wooden actors I have ever seen at delivering actual emotions..

    3. As far as the book goes, I don't fucking care. This movie failed the basics, that's all I need to know.

  • @HollowWithin001 You are talking only from 1 angle, and that's the fucking book..

    Fuck the books, OK? fuck them..

    Lord of the rings didn't have gore, swears, realism as well, and it was still praised!

    and I know why you said that... I know why you said no realism, and why your comparison to Disney fucking failed.

    It's because you saw no emotional investment with the characters, that's what you mistook with Realism..

  • @toxicitzi dude shut the fuck up no one cares what you have to say your just a dumbass kid who thinks he has this grand view of movie criticism, but you dont. there was nothing special about what you just said it was all garbage. the only reason i can say differently about my opinion is that its shared. and enough with the fucking ranting god just shut the fuck up already! and dont tell me "i know why you saw no realism" bullshit just shut the fuck up. YOU DONT KNOW ME, fucking cunt.

  • @HollowWithin001 And your 7th reason, "Why was I reminded of Disney wen I watched this?" was brilliant, right?

    or a better one, Cheaply created..

    And who the fuck are you to talk like tihs about movies?? just a VIEWER?

    fucking die in a fire you piece of shit, if you didn't like the movie GOOD! but shut the fuck up about it, you fucking whinny cunt!!

  • @toxicitzi oh and fuck books fuck the book? compared to the movie the book was great. the producer failed to reproduce what was already written, properly. never forget, producers and directors are not even close to the level of the author in literary ability. that why everyone always says "the book was better" because producer is shit and so are you. now ill just click th block button on your page so i dont recieve any more of your rant-a-thon messages

  • @HollowWithin001 I don't fucking care, books are different from movies you piece of shit!

    see where you fucking fail again??

    In movies, you have a limit to how much you can add, if you go over 2 hours it's TOO FUCKING LONG and NOBODY WILL FUCKING WATCH IT ALL!!

    In books, you can have how many fucking pages you need.. you are free to do WHATEVER...

    How can you even compare these 2 completely different things?!

  • @toxicitzi ahem LoTR was long

  • @IsaacD39 True that, but come on.. LoTR is something else :p

    That would be like Christians no longer appreciating the Bible, anything related to that in movies is watched by them.

  • @toxicitzi Movies normaly do good at following the book and still taking it short but Eragon seemed cheap. A good exmple is Murtagh being held in a wooden cage just out side the front. Or the lack of blood and gore described CLEARLY in the book witch clearly was not ment to be PG. They failed at making the Beors left out entire races (Dwarves) and added blonds and 1 black guy so the movie did not seem racist. They should have went in parts and not 1 gun it movie.

  • @IsaacD39 Ok, that's a good point right there. simply saying they didn't follow the book is an overstatement, you gotta clarify some things that would work better and for this matter, I agree with you here..

    There weren't sufficient characters and substance to the story and I had a problem with that as well while watching this movie.

    Still, let's just say, all movies are based off stories so, just because a story is in a book doesn't mean it's necessarily good. just look at Twilight -.-

  • @HollowWithin001 not to mention the countless non-canon events

    Saphira telling Eragon her name

    The ra'zac being killed

    Galbatorix knowing the locations of all the cities

    Lack of Roran and the Twins

    To name a few

  • @QuickScopersUnknown so many reasons for them to wipe the plate and go back to formula. especially remove that piece of shit director or producer that failed so miserably.

  • @HollowWithin001 exactly

  • @HollowWithin001 i know right didnt follow book at all

  • @HollowWithin001 jeremy irons, john malkovich, robert carlyle are three great actors. but yes overall the movie was pretty bad.

  • when i read the book i thought Brom was fat.

  • I liked this movie but if you compare it to the book, Eragon, Arya, and who knows all the other people they didn't get right...Eragon has brown hair and eyes, not bland hair and blue eyes...Arya is taller than Eragon and has green eyes and black hair... those are two things I remember them getting majorly wrong on the movie. but if you didn't compare the movie to the book it was a good movie.

  • @Batsareawesome55 Actually im pretty sure Eragon had blonde hair but not blue eyes

  • @Inheritance41Park I haven't read Eragon in a while and I just looked in the first chapter all I found was dark eyebrows over brown eyes. I always pictured him with brown hair, but he could be blonde.

  • @Batsareawesome55 Oh well maybe it is brown. idk.

  • @Inheritance41Park me neither

  • @Batsareawesome55 just Jike HollowWithin001 up there, some people have these Insane exepctations from movies..

    It's a movie, it's bound to be shorter than the book.. I just like how people instantly think that because they watch a lot of movies, they know how to classify/criticize/analyze them without error. Those poor deluded idiots..

  • Murtafh is hot v.v

  • what the f**** is this ???

  • The movies are never as good as the book, and this was no exception. It was a horrible representative of the book. All the characters seemed.....off in some way.

  • The movie suckad ass.

  • nice song dude!

  • I love the picture at 0:38. *o* Saphira is great.^^

  • When's Eldest coming out!? :) Right after the next His Dark Materials, I bet.

  • @wilburtrex There is no next movie coming out. Eragon was the first and only movie. It would be impossible to make a second movie

    of the books there are currently 3.

    1 - Eragon

    2 - Eldest

    3 - Brisingr

    there is a 4th book coming (maybe this year) but no name for it hasn't been released yet

  • what the heck is this??! this isn't from the soundtrack!! :(

  • how did they get the idea that saphiras' wings were feathered??????!?!?!? the book doesnt say they are feathered at all. >< the details and the movie were screwd up. i luv the books and paolini but i do not like how they put the movie together tho...ugh....

  • @Ramzue They said in the book that Saphira had a thin leathery membrane on her wings. Feathers on a dragon is ridiculous

  • @loonygoldfish You got that right, dude.

  • @loonygoldfish i wasnt saying that she diddnt have leathery wings, i was talkin bout the movie and her havin feathered wings in it . i was wondering where the heck they got the idea for saphira having feathered wings. ^^ i agree she does have leather wings.

  • @Ramzue Perhaps it would be better to give her leather wings instead of feathered. Such an insult. But hell. Leave it up to Americans to totally fuck this book series out of porportion with a movie. Let the Brits make Eragon a movie. They'll make it right..

  • @lushlust ...dude...im an american...=.=' and i think if they do any movies over a book or game...they better get ALL THE DETAILS RIGHT! not put in their own ideas on what THEY think would be good for the movie....

  • @Ramzue very damn true

  • @DionneCorcoran thank you. ^^

  • Awesome video! CONTINUE DOING YOUR WONDERFUL WORK!

  • this movie waz the biggest fail since they made barbie movies....

  • the books where realy good but the movie totaly sucks

  • hmmm i smell remake....

  • The special effects and the dragon were awesome, but the history was bad written =/ it's sad that they aren't going to do a the "Eldest" 'cause I'm a great fan of the books, but at least they could try to do a better movie next time.

  • anyone know the lyrics?

    eragon 4 ever

    ♥ murtagh

    GO VARDEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • rofls........................ 0:43

  • is it just me or does the guy who plays Brom look like the guy who plays House in the seiries House? or is he same guy?

  • it isn't the same person, Jeremy Irons plays Brom and Hugh Laurie plays House. (I think that is how you spell Laurie, but it could be spelt differently).

  • No it's not House, but I guess he does look a little similar to House... -shrug-

  • wtf is this lol !!

  • Even so i believe that Arya is much better(i mean in appearance)in the movie than the book.I believe the same for Brom,but that's my opinion...

  • eragon looks stupid and the movie is the biggest bullshit but the book is very good

  • The books better then the movie the movie lost alought of detail like eragon has brown hair in the book and he looks to young in the movie then the book diskribs

  • I read the book.

  • Ugh Eragon looks so gay in movie... hes described soo hot in book lol! Arya looks like as freak too....

  • @4mnm OHH MY GOD THEY LOOK LIKE NOTHING LIKE HOW THEY SHOULD! Not even saparia, she shoul look like a friken BLUE SAPPHIRE

  • omg this movie sucks, 0:29 it looks like he is shooting sperm from his hand

  • I always find myself comparing Eragon to Rocky. It's just more entertaining that way.

    "YO SAPHIRA!"

    "ARRRRRRRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYAAAAAAA­A!!!!"

  • lmao wtf?

  • Wair the towns name is FARTHen?

  • read the book

  • I want to read it,I recently found a book in spanish and I want to read it even with all the supossed star wars coincidences and the silly names

  • wie heisst die musik?

  • The only thing good about the movie was the dragon...srsly...

  • Not even that lol, saphira has feathers(and hair) and no spikes on her back.

  • no acctually that would just be stooped

  • @gujazzord You people need to quit being so damb critical over a fucking movie. I bet if this was just a random movie and not based on a book you people would probably love it. So who cares if it doesn't match every single part of the book,who fucking cares, only a nerd would get that upset over something so stupid. It's still a good movie.

  • @gujazzord Even that wasn't good enough to save it...sorry....XP

  • @gujazzord not really cuz her wings were FEATHERED.......

  • @TheJamescantrell They may look feathered, BUT THEY'RE NOT! Did you EVER get the feeling that they were long pointy SCALES? I mean, srsly!

  • @gujazzord lol ? 0:39 Wings like a bird

    a ridiculously long neck

    and she isn't even really blue

    Worst dragon ever

  • @gujazzord Jeremy Irons actually did a solid job, everybody else was shit

  • @SuperHeroMania couldnt have said it better

  • @gujazzord Exactly what I thought.

  • @gujazzord seriously, they failed with the dragon as well. Dragons with feathers? Really?

  • hey at 3:57 does her neck look a little skinny to anyone else

  • i think the move was horrible i think they should remake it and make it rated R

  • yeah, if they ever do try making the movie exactly the same as the book, it will be rated R

  • yea R for umm... Realy epicly awsome

  • i agree peter jackson please redo this fucking movie. this movie is a disgrace

  • Why Peter Jackson? Why not someone else?

  • because is doesnt well with fantasy movies like king kong and Lord of the rings. there are other people who could do it but i feel that he is the best person for the job. many people seem to agree lol watch my movie review part one if you want

  • Just saying: PETER JACKSON!!!!! PLZ REDO THIS MOVIE!!! FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS GOOD AND RIGHT SAVE US!!!!!

    -end rant-

  • @sowheresthefire heehee. yeah. peter jackson should totally do eragon. it would be great. =D

    eragon 4 ever

    ♥ murtagh

    GO VARDEN!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • @secretelf7

    xD tottally agreed

    Trianna <3

    lol

  • @sowheresthefire Yes I totally agree. I really wanted to like this movie. The whole movie was more like a trailer for the book.

    I thought it was well cast but man... I'd love if they made it over again.

  • @sowheresthefire I AGREE! They ruined one of my favorite dragon stories. D:

  • @sowheresthefire Yes. Peter Jackson doing Eragon? i wonder if he has read the books? He would make the best movie ever.

  • @bookercreator Well, he bought the rights to Naomi Noviks Temeraire. . .

  • I really love this guy's music.

  • this isn't even farthen dur, its not 10 miles high for a start, there aren't any dwarves either. the movie SUCKED! christopher paolini is a genious, they are the best books i have ever read, but this!? this is just a big giant steaming pile of $#!T

  • i dont even think the director read the book

    so so so many flaws in the movie

    first off eragon is supposed to be awseome not a fag

  • i agree it was COMPLETELY different

  • the director probably read the back of the book, then asked someone what happened at the battle of farthen dur, then BARELY based it off of that info. and yes, eragon (in the movie) looked gay

  • Every one who worked on the movie should have read the damn book.

  • agreed man you rock

  • LMFAO

  • Why the FUCK?WHy should have they done the movie so badly?

  • The movie blew, ill leave it at that

  • 16. Eragon is supposed to be in jail himself when he rescues arya.

    17. Murtagh shoots Durza in between the eyes, not eragon in the forehead.

    18. Durza doesn't hurl weapons with magic

    As you can see, there's an endless list. And this is time-consuming, so i'm going to stop there.

  • These are all sadly true.. and the dragons don't die when the rider does... both of them would live if the other was killed, but it wouldn't be very fun.

    Eragon NAMES Saphira, she doesn't come pre-named, they skipped out on the festival and his uncle's death was bullshit.

    also where was the werecat?

  • the werecat plays a gerat role in the book. also, very important: i think it´s brom who says (in the film): "galbatorix wont rest until your dragon is killed." completely wrong. galbatorix doesn´t want to kill her, of reasons i wont mention here in case there´s someone reading this who haven´t read the book (;

  • 7. Galbatorix isn't supposed to sound like a redneck.

    8. Brom is supposed to be and old man with silver hair.

    9. Eragon isn't supposed to look like a fag

    10. Saphira is supposed to have spikes on her back.

    11: Saphira doesn't shoot fire balls, she blows fire.

    12: Durza is supposed to slash eragon in the back.

    13. There's nothing about saphira getting owned and eragon healing her in the end.

    14. There's only supposed to be 2 ra'zac

    15. Eragon doesn't meet murtagh while he's rescuing arya.

  • Major Flaws in the movie

    1.Saphira without scales? but feathers? I call hax

    2.What kind of piece of crap is the fortune telling part? all that happens is this weird hippy covered in jewels says "Would you like angela to read your fortuyune?"

    3.Arya=Supposed to be in a personal coma type thing+pointy ears cuz she's an elf

    4.Where the hell are the dwarves?

    5.Eragon vs. Durza is supposed to be when eragon stabs him in the heart ON GROUND. Durza has no dragon

    6.Galbatorix's dragon is black not red.

  • *calm voice*

    it's not our fault if if the movie is done like that so what's the point of putting those comments ?

  • but in th movie galbatorixs dragon WAS black, like in the books

  • -.-

  • WHY DO DRAGONS HAVE FEATHERS

  • haha right, i asked that too...

  • BECAUSE THEY WANT TO FLY O.o

  • all the details of the movie are fake!

    i really liked the movie but it could be so much better if it looked like the book

    the books of Cristopher Paolini are the best i've ever reed, but the movie is bulshit when compared to the book...

    you are all right!

  • Some reasons to remake:

    1.) they took the urgals waaaay to far, they are just supposed to be beasts with horns...

    2.) Brom is supposed to be old T.T

    3.) The gedwey ignasia isnt even silver... wtf? It means shining palm... in the movie it just looks like a deep cut... plus they name him like silver hand or something in the book...

    4.) He doesn't battle Durza on a dragon he battles Durza on the ground while Saphira is in the dragonhold with arya

    5.) I didn't think murtagh would have black hair

  • Gedway Insignia is a silver spirilt off the thumb into the palm, just as the movie shows and it's Argetlam - Silver Hand

  • and Arya has black hair, and shes hot.. not some irish person lol

  • gedwey ignasia

  • and U FORGOT THE NIGGAS WTTF ARE THEY DOING IN ERAGON MOVIE!!!!!!! O.O!!!!!! ITS LIKE U SEE A NIGGA INSIDE LOTR !MOVIE!!!!!!! I DONT WANA SEE A NIGGA SAYS  CHAAAAAAAAAAARGE! WTF!

  • Because a "Nigga" is a main character in the plotline, and the leader of the rebellion.

  • And Arya should have pointy ears and they replaced Solembum and Angela with a fortune teller

  • Yea... guys go to pronunciations in the book... thank you :3

  • you can pronounce anything how you want to.