This version is by far my favourite, I just like the lyrics more. All the different versions of this song can really make you realize how a couple of tweaks to a song can really change what it means to you.
People can' explain this song, because they were once or still are from Indiana, and they remember what Broadripple used to be, and god damnit it was sad, but it was so beautiful, it was a place to smile, it was a place to cry, it was a place to escape, but it was never a place to fight, it was never a place to riot, it was once Broadripple, and it was once where people in Indiana could go to feel HUMAN for a while. Broadripple R.I.P.
@davidmalone94 I live in Indiana, and I'm not sure that it ever literally "burned." It's difficult to describe if you haven't lived in a Midwestern town -- we're small. We're insignificant. We're a homogeneous, simple minded state. Broadripple was once a haven of culture and beauty in the center of a state most well-known for its corn fields. It turned into less of a beautiful, spontaneous place than a badge of honor for hipsters and we lament that. It's the Garden of Eden, post-expulsion.
this version is vastly superior to any of the others. it's just a better arrangement; slightly more upbeat and yet still very raw - one man with a guitar (coughs not omitted). I do however miss the sporatic use of the cello and the female backing vox in the chorus... other than that this song was just what i needed when i stumbled upon it
I love this version! The only noticeable lyric difference is 'snortin coke' instead of 'huffin glue' .. . I feel like this is a more upbeat version if possible haha
@youatemyzombie that, and the fact that he repeats "I'll be hanging from a rope" twice in the chorus instead of switching to "I will haunt you like a ghost"; I also noticed he says "then somebody moves" instead of "IF somebody moves", but that's not very noticeable. I agree it's more upbeat, if possible, than the album version. I think both are fantastic.
Um.... This is not the right song, so i'm wondering what this is from or who this really is because this isn't the orginal song from Margot & Nuclear so so's... so yess(:
great song! i wanna try and cover it would be fun i think. its wierd i have a lot of songs ive written on my own but never rly covered but this fits my style. if you like this you might like some of mine :p
dang, you guys all need to cheer up. i was going to post this on facebook, but now everybody is going to think i'm emo or something relating to all these comments. bahah.
I cant even explain what this song means to me. It kills me to listen to it but I still do, over and over and over again... Makes me want to kill myself.. but in a good way.. in the kind of way where u know ur alive
@misssunflower420 People shouldn't be giving this comment a thumbs up. Don't kill yourself. You have a good taste in music. That would be such a waste!
I was so excited to see they were coming to Boise, but they're playing a bar so I can't get in! I'll be in the alley listening though; I can't explain how it feels hearing this song (let alone all of their others).
I'll be there as well. Cant miss the Broadripple anthem at the best place in town. Anyone who doesnt know how it feels to walk those streets needs to.
i cant find this version anywhere! (except here) this isnt the daytrotter version
sriversk8r 2 days ago
my liver hurts from drinking, but i don't even fucking care because i love this song.
JJthaJuiceman 5 days ago
Whenever he says, "Don't fucking move," it gives me chills. Every single time.
ah0yangela 5 days ago
someone please tell me what the story is behind this song?
DeanSundheim 1 week ago
dooont fuckin move.
Colaa0326 1 week ago
Is this the original version? I own Not Animal, and the version on that is a lot different than this, just how it sounds and what the lyrics are.
davidmalone94 2 weeks ago
@davidmalone94 This is the Daytrotter Sessions version
Jcop42 1 week ago
I always feel depressed each time i listen to this song
bradyboi102 3 weeks ago
deeper than any thing ive ever heard.... my heart hurts good
jeremybiggs 3 weeks ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
i have constant panic attacks of the overwhelming feeling that we will no longer exist. this song helps ease that shit.
misanthr0pyx 4 weeks ago
Replay. Replay. Replay. Replay. Replay. Replay. <3
hannamarie981 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
where can i find this version???its amazing
tallydevuono 1 month ago
i miss you home sweet home ripple </3
mojitoXOXO 1 month ago
Gawd. So amazing <3
MasterPoobrain 1 month ago
I love this version. Sounds so much more emotional.
3oh3bby 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
The way he sings darling makes my heart break a little.
ManjotKaur97 1 month ago
It's so...beautiful. [;
BlackDaisee 1 month ago
i'm going to kill myself. just kidding because i wouldn't be able to hear this song.
lawlacost1 1 month ago
If youtube take this off for copyright, I WILL kill myself :L
HAMISHMCC300 1 month ago in playlist Music
This version is by far my favourite, I just like the lyrics more. All the different versions of this song can really make you realize how a couple of tweaks to a song can really change what it means to you.
andrearpelletier 2 months ago 3
Comment removed
LoveMusicRum 2 months ago
A song that makes you appreciate life as well as wanting to end your own. Beautiful.
HAMISHMCC300 3 months ago 6
Where is this version from?
FrequenciesMusic 3 months ago
@FrequenciesMusic its the demo
xShockArtistx 3 months ago
@FrequenciesMusic It's the demo version. :)
PanicAtTheDisco0011 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
This has been flagged as spam show
Herd this tune 2 years ago and loved it ever since. Still finds a way to give me goosebumps.
MiniDumpster 3 months ago
Comment removed
MiniDumpster 3 months ago
Comment removed
stephwren12 3 months ago
Nice cough!
Shakey719 3 months ago
People can' explain this song, because they were once or still are from Indiana, and they remember what Broadripple used to be, and god damnit it was sad, but it was so beautiful, it was a place to smile, it was a place to cry, it was a place to escape, but it was never a place to fight, it was never a place to riot, it was once Broadripple, and it was once where people in Indiana could go to feel HUMAN for a while. Broadripple R.I.P.
xXxRedXIIIxXx1 3 months ago 12
@xXxRedXIIIxXx1 That was actually really pretty...I take it this is about a real town that burned?
davidmalone94 2 weeks ago
@davidmalone94 I live in Indiana, and I'm not sure that it ever literally "burned." It's difficult to describe if you haven't lived in a Midwestern town -- we're small. We're insignificant. We're a homogeneous, simple minded state. Broadripple was once a haven of culture and beauty in the center of a state most well-known for its corn fields. It turned into less of a beautiful, spontaneous place than a badge of honor for hipsters and we lament that. It's the Garden of Eden, post-expulsion.
3ljsk38 1 week ago
the guitar makes me shiver. <3
teaandthesea 4 months ago
I really just want to hear the live version with the keyboard and female vocals. Still... such a fantastic song.
420sidious 4 months ago
I melt every time he sings "darling i'm lost"<3
melinaa20 4 months ago 9
This song is gorgeous, I can't stop listening to it! And I love his voice -3
Brianna7104 5 months ago
Gorgeous beyond words.
T0tal0wnagex3 5 months ago
Hands-down, one of my favorite songs ever.
Fluer111789 5 months ago
i love this song it has so much raw emotion, love it <3
i dont think ill ever get tired of it
haditabonita666 5 months ago in playlist stuffffff~
this version is vastly superior to any of the others. it's just a better arrangement; slightly more upbeat and yet still very raw - one man with a guitar (coughs not omitted). I do however miss the sporatic use of the cello and the female backing vox in the chorus... other than that this song was just what i needed when i stumbled upon it
BWilliamsAA7237 7 months ago 5
So pretty..Makes me wanna cry, but still so pretty
sharkapillar 7 months ago 5
I listen to this song 5 times a day. it never gets old, just better.
robair9911 8 months ago
@robair9911 They are going to send you to the counseler
CashREAMe 8 months ago
@CashREAMe because you think this song promotes suicidal ideation? I no understand your comment
robair9911 8 months ago
Oh gawd, I'm learning this song for my choir tryout
dumbassazn 9 months ago
I love this version! The only noticeable lyric difference is 'snortin coke' instead of 'huffin glue' .. . I feel like this is a more upbeat version if possible haha
youatemyzombie 9 months ago
@youatemyzombie that, and the fact that he repeats "I'll be hanging from a rope" twice in the chorus instead of switching to "I will haunt you like a ghost"; I also noticed he says "then somebody moves" instead of "IF somebody moves", but that's not very noticeable. I agree it's more upbeat, if possible, than the album version. I think both are fantastic.
AfterMath4lyfe 9 months ago
i bought this album off itunes but mine sounds different like it starts with harmonica but i bought it off itunes!! i'm so confused!!
ThePostitUp 9 months ago
@ThePostitUp this is a demo version.
AfterMath4lyfe 9 months ago
@ThePostitUp theres 3 versions my friend :)
BeNeath0 8 months ago
Greeat
maxpunk01 10 months ago
Going to see them next week woo!
greenstarmeg 10 months ago
check winning724 singing this song
garlicrosey 10 months ago
check winning724 singing this song
garlicrosey 10 months ago
<3
davos1326 11 months ago
Ok thanks!(:
KGootkin 11 months ago
Um.... This is not the right song, so i'm wondering what this is from or who this really is because this isn't the orginal song from Margot & Nuclear so so's... so yess(:
KGootkin 1 year ago
@KGootkin its just a different recorded version, cus its the same singer.
TheTylerSboyd 11 months ago
@KGootkin You're thinking of their Daytrotter version. This is their album version.
Murrowcat 11 months ago
great song! i wanna try and cover it would be fun i think. its wierd i have a lot of songs ive written on my own but never rly covered but this fits my style. if you like this you might like some of mine :p
InArmour 1 year ago
i really like this song.
meizlovely 1 year ago
You guys are a bunch of self loathing attention starved pussies, its a good song however.
TheRoseLandRemedy 1 year ago
how can a song be so depressing but change your outlook on life completely at the same time?
bradleythebear17 1 year ago 2
this version had so much more emotion... it made me cry. I love it. thanks for posting.
MelinGrata 1 year ago
Elliott Smith, is that you?
Ypres 1 year ago
First time discovering this artist.. glad i did. But the lyrics hit a little too close to home.
Brookenesss 1 year ago 4
feb 2 2011 @ 7:42pm i died. i woke up 4 mins later. its not like u think it would be. just listen- we've got alot dont you dare forget that!!
jakequintal 1 year ago
this is the only video ive seen that has 0 dislikes! definatly deserves it
snpclothesdotcom 1 year ago
Yeah, where can you buy this? I like this better than the huffing glue version. Haha
doinjustfine369 1 year ago 6
HOW DO I GET THIS SONG ON MY IPOD!!!!!! (legally)
amandaisalongo 1 year ago
@amandaisalongo i want it on mine!
amandaamanda320 1 year ago
dang, you guys all need to cheer up. i was going to post this on facebook, but now everybody is going to think i'm emo or something relating to all these comments. bahah.
shaungates 1 year ago 5
It's a feeling like I want to take death into a warm embrace
SNAILCAKES 1 year ago
ahh this version is so much better then the one on the album.
Beautiful beautiful beautiful
roflGabbyx 1 year ago
Please don't kill yourselves, thankss
danieldoap 1 year ago 186
@danieldoap 584 people are going to kill themselves
bradyboi102 3 weeks ago
It's such a sad song, but it's so beautiful that I can't stop listening to it.
musicfreak11324 1 year ago
this song is beautiful, it makes me feel suicidal but not in a bad way...
XxBlowYouKissesxX 1 year ago 4
@XxBlowYouKissesxX Hahaha I was thinking more like depressing in a beautiful way. Hahaha, but that works! :DD
RaInAnDhIm 1 year ago
and darlin im drunk...
saldali420 1 year ago
I cant even explain what this song means to me. It kills me to listen to it but I still do, over and over and over again... Makes me want to kill myself.. but in a good way.. in the kind of way where u know ur alive
misssunflower420 1 year ago 101
@misssunflower420
"There's a big difference, I discovered, between wanting to die and wanting to kill yourself. -Marilyn Manson"
B1adezUp 1 year ago 4
@B1adezUp so B1adezUp... subtle cutting reference. nice.
indigorokkers 1 year ago
@misssunflower420 People shouldn't be giving this comment a thumbs up. Don't kill yourself. You have a good taste in music. That would be such a waste!
Iwilljudgeyourvideos 1 month ago 2
@Iwilljudgeyourvideos hahaha, good taste in music.. sounds like something my friend would say.
vikiwozeya 1 month ago
this version is more depressing....I LIKE!
VivaLaWill03 1 year ago 8
seriously no song like it
i love this version
cheeriosryum 1 year ago
@cheeriosryum maybe you like danny malone as well, for example 'danny malone- song for the year' ;) his voice is very nice. listen ;)
therunningfree95 1 year ago
@therunningfree95 hey thanks for that i listened to some of his songs
and he's got some really good ones thankyou so much :)
cheeriosryum 1 year ago
Comment removed
ARTANDBIOLOGY 1 year ago
wow
Seagerash 1 year ago
Amazing version of this song. Love this band!
Attackofdrew 1 year ago
i saw him yesterday at luna music in broad ripple indiana :D:D:D:D
i got to meet him and got the buzzard CD signed plus 6 days early.
does anybody know why there are two versions of this song?
i can't find this song on any of their CD's so i wasn't sure.
the other starts with children broad ripple is burning...etc.
SMILEitscool 1 year ago
@SMILEitscool I think this is the Daytrotter version.
dappleddaydream 1 year ago
@SMILEitscool its the demo version, not on any CDs but you can find it out there
bobbyliiite 1 year ago
@SMILEitscool yeah i know i was confused too, i like this version better tho.
auroy4 1 year ago
@SMILEitscool this version is off Animal! the version that the label didn't like. the other version is on Not Animal.
deafaids 1 year ago
I was in Fountain Square yesterday. lol
disturbedjosh 1 year ago
SO EXCITED TO SEE THEM SUNDAY
silvermoontakkun 1 year ago
I was so excited to see they were coming to Boise, but they're playing a bar so I can't get in! I'll be in the alley listening though; I can't explain how it feels hearing this song (let alone all of their others).
born2drum421 1 year ago
oh my goodness. i cannot even explain the raw power of the emotion in this song. it's overwhelming. so beautiful.
gingerdoll9876 1 year ago
I'll be there as well. Cant miss the Broadripple anthem at the best place in town. Anyone who doesnt know how it feels to walk those streets needs to.
jamieclark420 1 year ago
Looking forward to hearing this at The Vogue on October 15th. Already have my tickets!
ctshermanii 1 year ago
Ah. Yes. I like this.
PreciousRobot 1 year ago
Comment removed
screamgorgeousbby 1 year ago
wish he sang the hook like this on the album version
oombop11 1 year ago
and darling i'm drunk.
everything that i have loved, has turned to stone.
so pack your bags..
and come back home.
heartbreaklullabies 1 year ago 2
i like this version better :]
xmelyloveshimx 1 year ago
@xmelyloveshimx this is demo version
kikitozor 1 year ago
Hmmmm..... I know you do. Fuck!!!!!
beyondrationalthough 2 years ago
i love this song to absolute pieces. i love the emotion in this version. <3
alysev 2 years ago
yes it is a demo. i like it better too :]
melaniexrose 2 years ago
is this a demo or something? i like it a lot better than the album track (though it's good too)
deathbydeath32 2 years ago