Doctor Who 'Important' Mistake

[keiracounsell]

'rule 1 the doctor lies' a clever way for the new writer to re-write everything we already know in the show

[torchdexto]

that awkward moment when two top comments are the same comments.

[calindor23]

actually, simply put, he was WRONG, she turned out to be very important. So his argument still stands.

[CharleeeeEmm]

He said he didn't like cats in 'fear her' then in 'gridlock' he was cuddling kittens..

[Darrren042]

The whovian answer is that they are different doctors with different perspectives, but in any case just because the Doctor thought that Donna wasn't important it doesn't mean that she didn't become important and indeed she did!

[vinnycentful]

i love doctor who

[TheSman515]

Nah, that's just the 10th Doctor and he's habit of being rude

[TheAfroThunder1]

Dam it! The two top comments are the same! I hate it when that happens!

[VBGoPro]

what season was the first clip from???

was it a preview or something, I've watched all six seasons, except part 2 season 6, and i do not remember that one. Someone answer

[Puffycheeks288]

@VBGoPro It is the Christmas special for 2010 (A Christmas Carol) so I guess you could say it is the sixth season.

[Forthelemon]

Explanation: At this point, while still the tenth doctor, he thought that everybody was important except her. Then, it later turned out that she was important after all. So the doctor realized that yeah, everybody is important. Some time after that, he regenerated.

Case closed.

[Tomlilz]

Well Donna was important so technically the 11th Doctor at his period in time still hasnt met someone that isnt Important.

[SilverPatronus17]

Lawls

[myturningtables]

D-d-dumbledore? I never knew Kazran was played by the actor who played Dumbledore.

[littletalifox]

Hahaha oops :)

[Plottoberry]

Hahahaha I love you.

[Puffycheeks288]

30,000 VIEWS! Thank you all for watching.

I have uploaded new Doctor Who videos so do not forget to watch them.

You are all brilliant!!

[TheMlleSam]

It's DUMBELDORE !!! ^^

[HarrypotterHP7]

Well actually the Doctor didn't know she was important at that time

[harrypotterfantng]

"Sorry! It's Christmas, I was up on the roof, saw a chimeny and was like, "What the hell?"

[BilliePiperLuv]

Ahahahahahaha :D

[nichill86]

But donna was important. Just not at that point in her life.

[PolexiaAphrodisia]

In the end she was important

[SongokuCY]

Dude I get what you're saying :) but maybe he told her that she is not important on purpose because she slapped him in the face... TWICE!!!

[emunahberurah]

The Doctor just learned his lesson with Donna you see. It was because of her that he now has the corrected thinking that everyone is important. He was just niave and she changed that with her "unimportantness". lol

[harpdevil]

Well and lets not forget they might be the same man but they're totally different personalities, with different views on things. One might think there are unimportant people, and while the other doesn't.

[AtarahDerek]

So the Doctor admitted he was wrong. That's a hard thing for any Time Lord to do. He should be applauded for it.

[Gorgangler14]

@smallvillenerd - You mean Steven Moffatt. Russell T Davies was a Doctor Who writing LEGEND. It was the Moff who cocked up all of his brilliant work when he took over.

[saerilee]

Yeah, but then she turned out to be, I believe the quote was the "most important person in the universe"... So just because he thought she was unimportant before it doesn't mean that stood true.

[martang66]

Haha poor Donna! "Nobody is the whole universe isn't important...well, except you!"

[RenardeBlanche]

@martang66 Yes, and Jack Harkness will flirt with literally anything that talks... except Donna.

[jhibbitt1]

@RenardeBlanche and jackie lol

[graham1984]

If we are forgiving it could be assumed that the Doctor was joking when he said that to Donna, maybe trying to provoke a reaction from her.

[1andrewman1]

she's not important, shes ginger, no soul

[shawn70715]

of course shes important, shes doctor donna, he just didnt realize how important she actually was

[LuluLilypad]

He found out how important she was later on when the earth was again invaded by daleks

[OneWingedRose]

Well David Tennant's doctor was pretty damn arrogant, maybe now that the Doctor's older he's had time to look back on that time in his life and learn from it.

He's a bit more of a show off as Matt Smith but at the same time he's a bit more humble.

[lazyd3vil]

yeah, it's pretty tricky, the english language. He probably meant that Donna wasn't "odd" enough for her to seem NECESSARY to the aliens in question. Easier said, she wasn't important, but not in the belittling sense.

[mbranford9]

different regenerations different personalities

[TimoSverige]

10 ans 11 are different...... have kinda different opinions of people.....and 10 didn§t mean it same way like 11, I think

[thedoctorlovescats]

It's not a mistake because donna ended up saving the whole of reality. I think that's pretty important.

[vincent314ljm]

it's true!

[ISawItAndIMissedIt]

I loved the episode The Runaway Bride

[whotuber61]

It was a busy day and the doctor was trying to save the ponds

[whotuber61]

It was a busy day and the doctor was trying to save the ponds

[operageek65]

Rule 1: The Doctor lies.

[TheAfroThunder1]

"Iv'e never met anyone who wasen't important.... Except Donna Noble, even though she kind-a saved the universe... She's stealing my style!"

[eleriel]

Weird how she turned out to be the most important person in all of creation...

basically, anytime he says that someone isn't important, it makes the universe snap to attention and MAKE the person he's talking about very important indeed.

[AuslandCharlie]

saw these two specails in a mini marathon together and when I saw the Smith clip I thought of that clip exactly :)

[Nikklas57]

When he said " ive never met anyone who wasnt important" and the way he said it, inmidiatelty assumed he meant about this.

[DeltaMetroid1]

Yes it's a real mistake because the doctor can't learn can he? MADNESS!

[OhWiseSam]

Or its a change in writer...

[captaingrim1]

Quick easy answer: Rule #1: The Doctor lies.

That's Steven Moffat's inspired solution to Doctor Who continuity gaffes, threaded throughout the 11th Doctor's run.

[killbotvii]

Did anyone else catch the doctor losing the British accent a bit?

[johnFP1966]

@killbotvii never heard of a british accent, it's either english/scots/welsh or irish, but never british

[johnFP1966]

@killbotvii scots/english/welsh/irish but never a British accent

[missjessiebarry]

@killbotvii It must have been hard for david though.

[rmilrta]

Don't think there's any real contradiction. Two slightly different sense of important, one relative, the second ultimate (the first in the video actually).

The way the character dismisses the girl, who is in quite a distressing situation, as "not important is cold and flippant and the Eleventh Doctor rightly calls it out, by pointing out the fact that ultimately no one is "unimportant", and he does it brilliantly.

[Smallvillenerd]

Another RTD mess up

Typical

[StickMarsChannel]

Lol

[Izlandzadi14]

She was, he just didn't know it yet

[toffeechaton]

It's because when he regenerates, he also change personality so he may have different opinions about the importance of people. If you watch seriously, you would know that Tenth hates guns although Eleven doesn't have any problem with it.

[tardismole]

Brilliant. Utterly brilliant. Some came back to bite him in the butt :D

[TerminatorGary]

RULE 1 THE DOCTOR LIES

[ChewyTheEpicWookie]

lol



[CyberTimelord]

he has just brainwashed.

[Redbrodie16]

haha :d lol!

[ThisMakayla]

Turns out Donna was important, though.

[ArisonaThemare]

oh boy i NEVER noticed that

[GetterRay]

He says the same thing about the crew in Waters of Mars. Its probably more the Time Lord Victorious stuff that changed him than Donna.

[pointyobject]

10 was the rude and not ginger one

[superherom03]

Donna changed him. and 11 is much more positive than 10. 10 was slightly emo

[darkironyoshi]

@superherom03 I would disagree. I found the 10th to be more subdued then the 11th is.

[TheStalkerNinja]

Thers also another mistake int eh same spisode, when 11 goes over to the control and Kazran say there "icomorphic" 11 says that cant happen, that its not real but the MAsters laer screwdriver was icomorphic, becaseu 10 tried to use it and failed

[GoldenTalesGeek]

@TheStalkerNinja That's not really a mistake either, cos the Doctor talks a lot of smack to confuse his opponents. Obfuscating stupidity is one of his tricks of the trade.

[doctorofthe12thkind]

I think its because 10 learns from Adelade Brook (waters of mars) how dangerous it can be to think of people being more important than others, after he claims hes saved a few 'little people' and she shows him hes going down a dark path with his way of thinking. so 11 is actually making a point, more to himself than anything, that he believes that everyone is equally important in time and space.

[GoldenTalesGeek]

To be fair, I think Eleven was being a bit snarky to Kazran Sardick, so it's not really a "mistake" per se. :P

[ThatMovieGuy77]

Hahahaha!

[Brownbirdfeather]

He changed his mind after all that Donna did

[TristanFear]

Not politically important, not a famous or well known (influential to many) type of person. I think this video shouldn't be taken too seriously, just two scenes, put out of context, together for a laugh.

[fleuve0styx]

lol. XD Apparently Donna punched him in the face before she left. XD lol.

[Puffycheeks288]

WOW! 10,000! Views! Thanks everyone when I made this I did not think it was even that good.....

[Destro7000]

he did find out that she was important later on

[bobfromthenorth]

STUPID STEVEN MOFFAT!!!!!

HE CAN'T EVEN REMEMBER WHAT HE HAS WROTE IN HIS PRESENT TIMES!!!!

[project2501b]

@bobfromthenorth

Given that Moffat's name isn't RTD, I don't see how he would remember what he didn't write. It was RTD's mistake to write a line like 'not important' to begin with.

[MollyLaughForLife]

@bobfromthenorth Never ever EVER call Steven Moffat stupid. EVER.

[mlgnerd13]

@bobfromthenorth did he write that ep? i thought it was RTD

[mlgnerd13]

@bobfromthenorth did he write that i thought it was rtd

[phnompenhandy]

No contradiction - context is all. He's playing mind games with Donna.



[farshnuke]

And 10 was an arrogant randy vengeful god.

[triroa]

he he ha ha

[TheHPExperiment]

But he does find out later that she is EXTREMELY clever and important

[Coldheart322]

Rule 1, The Doctor lies.

[forthecause]

@Coldheart322 Agreed. Plus that could have been his way of being cheeky or inspiring her. I wouldn't call it a movie mistake

[227060]

Plus lets not forget he first met Donna, when she just shwoed up in the TARDIS right after the big goodbye in Doomsday so its fair to say he wasn't in the best of moods

[shimkoan]

I'm sure it's been said, but just in case... Rule number one: the Doctor lies.

[Serelenntidude]

he meant earth-wise

[ModestlyAwesomer]

yeah, i love DW more than almost any other show, and i know they have different personalities in this situation, but the truth is that this show has a ton plot inconsistencies. but they make up for it in amazing characters and dialogue.

[johnthebull]

@ModestlyAwesomer And the fact that Time Travel doesn't need to make sense.

[227060]

@ModestlyAwesomer any given episode has inconsistencies so i dunno why we fans get so hung up on inconsistencies within seasons, eras, or the whole 50 years even

[MewKimmy]

You realize he just doesn't realize how important Donna is yet right? :I;; it was just what he thought at first and learned from that first judgment, because he does say that Donna is important later on, so he has in fact never met an unimportant person.

[Puffycheeks288]

@MewKimmy Of course I know that I only uploaded this because it is just the thing people will watch on Youtube and comment on, just as you did. :P

[bluelizard81]

@Puffycheeks288 trollololol :)

[TheFamilySlitheen]

@MewKimmy But he doesn't know who Abigail was.

[Akela002]

Take a look on the episode "Stolen Earth" and tell after it that Donnan Nobel was unimportent XD

[BrokenTourniquet]

This is the difference between Moffat writing the Doctor and Davies writing about the Doctor--Moffat's Doctor seems to care more about individuals and Davies' Doctor was stuck in a flip-flopping state of condemning humanity as a whole one minute and then adulating it the same way the next. Moffat's has more consistency.

[flyingtardis]

contradiction much

[theguylambert]

Different Doctors, different personalities :-)

[DoctorWhoRocks10000]

11 FTW

[Puffycheeks288]

If you like Doctor Who, don't forget to subscribe!

[Philoishness]

that's the difference between Ten and Eleven. Also he meant more a kind of 'not especially important to society' kind of thing, like, not the prime minister, etc.

[SaveDWC]

Rule number 1, the Doctor Lies!

[Decimaster321]

@SaveDWC And the important question: which one was the lie? Were they both lies?

[terriblethomas101]

LOL

[OwlCityFan26]

pfffff....hypocrite! :P

[EverChangingShadow]

I see your point. But I think the meaning of what eleven said, is that every single living person in the world in important. Whereas ten probably just meant that Donna didn't seem specifically important. If you get what I mean.

[TDOTSE1]

Lol mind rape

[KendrixTermina]

He was just thinking out loud/being blunt/annoyed at her at the time, he didn't *really* think anyone's not important. and even if he had. he'd surely learned from that after she saved the universe....

[FrazzlledCuRt117]

lol.

[CaptainAndyman]

Doctor learns from his past - hence why, after the Time War, he was a lot more violent towards Daleks. And after having met Rose, he became a very anti-violence person. And after spending so long around humans, he's actually come to quite like us! :)

[KendrixTermina]

@CaptainAndyman ...And after "Journey's end" and everything he lost there, he's once again quite tired of everyone's favourite pepperpots - by "Victory of the Daleks", he wanted them wiped out of the sky for good... Can't blame him after being forced to basically mindrape one of his closest friends...

[ahaetulla]

He thought she wasn't important. He was wrong.

/solved

[Eliserose95]

He obviously learnt from that mistake. Good thing too. The way I see it, that's the main theme of the series; even the mist insignificant seeming individual can be the mist important man woman or other in the universe, they just need a moment to shine.

[p0nkub0x]

Different Doctor, Different Attitude

[kupkakeluvr1727]

"For one shining moment, she was the most important woman in the whole, wide universe." *tear*

[kupkakeluvr1727]

But for one shining moment, she was the most important person in all of creation. *tear*

[34BestBuds43]

but she tuned out to be important, Doctor's Mistake

[KarstenOkk]

@34BestBuds43 *looks at amount of likes* *doesnt like comment even tho he wants to*

[Domianisti90]

thats the whole point no one is "not Important"

its not a mistake it's a lesson

[TheGallianthe]

Everyone knows the Doctor contradicts himself ALL THE TIME!

[emilyweimarxx]

Ha ha lool

[Scarperguy]

I think it's out of context, by 'important' the Tenth Doctor meant on a huge scale - it might be expected that the Racnoss would only manipulate and interfere with somebody important or with authority over other people, if you understand me :) The Doctor himself, though, would view Donna as important to him.

[stijnhommes]

Even RTD made a mistake with this one. First calling her NOT important only to later say he met her twice (the only one in the whole wide world) and the whole parallel earth thing in Turn Left.

[Laudeverd]

@stijnhommes turn left, what a paronia

[BuffyFan81886]

Sounds like he's learned his lesson since that temp from Chiswick became the most important woman in the universe. :D