Hehe.... I have to say, her voice is good, but needs to practice more to hit the right higher notes. And the tempo of this song definitely needs to be faster.
Tempo is WAY too slow. Her voice is terrific, but this is a song about exacting blood in revenge from a rival. This aria in a slowed tempo takes away from that big time. So anyone who doesn't know this piece or the German language might think, "Oh wow! This is really pretty."
I respect your opinion. I have mine as well and I think very highly of this singer. Be sure you are distinguishing VOICE from PERFORMANCE. I don't like this PERFORMANCE because of the incredibly slowed tempo. I think had this been performed at a more appropriate tempo, it would sound very good!
I personally know how difficult it is to sing this. It's a workout. Kudos for trying it out, takes guts. Yes, for some reason it's under tempo...really odd.
Okay, so maybe this isn't her song. But at least she could hit the hight notes, so we can rest assured she isn't a reincarnation of Florence Foster Jenkins. At all.
"Oh... my... GOD!" is all I can say of Florence Jenkins. I cannot believe that they even dignified her on Wikipedia with a recording her performing this very song.
she's here and a very lot of people can see AND hear her. she's not perfect. she's miles away from it. the kind of interpretation is not the best. she tryed, but not succesfully.
i think, if you are not the best and you are in front of such an audiance you cannot expect good critics(?). plaese take this video off from youtube. its better for you and for us.
if it's slow and she's not perfect, then she can't be fine!
we're not haters, we offer a healthy review of someone's poor singers. and our inability to sing this bad does not excuse her from taking this awful performance out in public. you do it and you get the beating.
Don't use the "you can't do it" excuse. If someone here knows that can't sing this, probably won't even try, especially in public. But she didn't care and kept hurting everybody's hears.
You all are just mean, and I think I can judge her... is her voice so off key that cats are running in opposite directions? No, unless you have heard Florence Foster Jenkins, you cannot be hating on this woman...she's fine...is she sumi jo, no, but for someone who is not a professional she's doing ok...
That's boloney and you know it. You just want to be mean and cruel...Why is it that opera "critics" are so nasty? It's like having a bunch of Simon Cowell's that get off by spewing venom...
Well, I *can* do it, but that doesn't make much difference to what we are talking about here. Every soprano who has a few high notes think they can sing this aria, and I wish they wouldn't! How does the teacher allow this, is what I want to know. Teacher must be as delusional as the student.
Judging by the background, the acoustics and the cuts it sounds like a class recital, if she's a learner then it's not going to be perfect. She didn't sound like she was struggling much except a couple of the very highest notes. She just needs to keep up the training and practise.
Her voice is very high but where is her talent? She only stands there and thinks she is gorgeous and great. I wonder if she know what she is singing or if she knows that most of her notes is false?
I never understood why would anyone sing and aria that they are totally struggling with. She could sing anything else, I suggest romantic opera. Why this hell of an aria that if one doesn't make perfect it's terrible? If you can't do it perfect stay away from Mozart for in his music the slightest mistake SHOWS!!!!!BADLY!!!
My God, this is slower than Bessie Abott! And why those odd little edits? Did someone spare us the really BAD notes? Of course, the Benchmark of Bad in this aria is Florence Foster Jenkins, but this, bad as it is, isn't bad enough to be funny.
she has no pitch control in the upper register, at all. whoever americanidol006 is doesnt know what theyre talking, this has nothing to do with anyones opinion of opera, it just sucks. judging by the americanidol name, youre probably some high school girl in choir who sings pop and doesnt know anythign about opera, im in music school and i listen to a lot of opera, and i can definitively say that that was aweful.
This lady has a good voice but has been mislead into singing in the wrong range & clearly doesnt benefit from the guidance of a good vocal coach. If she did I think she would do very well. Her lowest notes were the strongest & in the best tone. Because of this, I'm sorry, not trying to be unkind but this particular performance was awful, pianist hang your head in shame.
who told her she could sing this? i've never seen someone who misses so many tones. it's like a cat falling into a bathtub!
plus she clearly doesn't understand a word of what she's singing.
the pianist must have some musical education. and for destroying this piece by polaying it so slowly he should be punished. by listening to that recording over and over again.
Also, I think if she performed something like Voi Che Sapete, it would suit her voice much better, as it's a slightly simpler aria, and it would also show off her vocal abilities much better as well.
She has a very nice tone to her voice, but lacks in vocal technique. I can't hear her diaphragm working at all on the high notes. I don't think she was really ready to perform it. The tempo of the aria is also way too slow, and because of a lack of emotion it comes across as a tad bit boring. I feel that she was only trying to show off her voice. The pianist also faltered on many occasions.
A nice voice, but she is seriously mislead. The aria itself is about a woman who is enraged, this tempo is waaaaaay too slow. She didn't sing that 'F' in tune ONCE! Moreover, I don't think she knows the meaning of what she is singing. She is completely emotionless.
She isn't that bad. It all has to do with your opinion of Opera and music. If you don't like it then why are you even listening to it? She actually has some talent!!! I sing opera. It can be very pretty and she isn't doing that bad!!!!!! Stop hating on opera singers!!!
ZZzzzzzzz is it over yet? She probably has a fairly good voice, but she shold keep her vocal chords away from this piece, otherwise she won't be singing for long. That might be a positive note!!
Well, anyone who will take this aria on in front of any audience is braver than I will ever be. The effect of this one, slowed down like this, with all its glittery edges softened, is really different. It's just too high/too hard for her, as it is for almost everyone.
i'd say, anyone who's willing to butcher the aria so much has no shame. if she considers herself an opera singer, she needs to make sure that she can sing the piece before standing in front of any audience. it's like one of those bad american idol auditions.
Seems like something a really young, really high-aspiring person might do, though.Reminds me of myself in my teens, singing "Che Faro" from Gluck's Orfeo in an audition because (as I was pathetically pleased with myself for being able to do) I could hit all the notes. I'd gotten enchanted with the aria after hearing it sung by someone whom I know now was not all that good. I hadn't heard Janet Baker or Marilyn Horne sing it at that point, and if I had, I'd have known not to try.
Why has thou forsaken me?....LOL The pianist is a mess too... and whoever is saying bravo at the end must be a blood relative. Now that I'm done be ugly, let me say it took a lot of work to get to that point, good job, don't give up! Nice voice let it work more and not you...just think about it and you'll get it...
Oh my poor ears...this is the WORST Der Holle I have EVER heard. That does include the 12 year old boy that sings it!!! FAR too slow, horribly unclean coloratura, bad piano playing, bad video. Do I need to continue??? Please remove it!!! Unless you want something to laugh at non-stop. I hope you didn't charge for the recital!
Ok I'm the last person to judge one's singing but this really isn't that good. The tempo is too slow, the phrasing is pretty dire, the pitching of higher notes is pretty poor, and tbh, I think this has been recorded more than once and pieced together.
well... not great. flat on the high F and and ugly slurred runs, not great control of your upper register. more practice and it might work. also, another song might be better. I feel you are just a soprano, not a coloratura soprano. the pianist was amazing either.
Your voice is rather rough for this aria and you fall flat on the high Fs. You need more training to polish your coloratura. But I like the natural quality of your voice.
I'm sorry but she actually makes my skin crawl! Far too slow, pitching is absolutely horrendous *particularly in the upper registers* and the pianist isn't that brilliant either. In fact just as bad!
Canta bien y SparafucileVengador te ensalsará. Hazlo mal y SparafucileVengador te lo dirá. Esta mujer, con ese peso, cómo carambas podría cantar rápido? No tendrá un buen amigo que le diga que se ve horrible con los brazos descubiertos? Tiene potencial, pero está más que verde. Por Dios, que no la dejen cantar mientras no esté lista!! Esos "sobreagudos" son insoportables. Cómo la gente se atreve a subir esto a Internet? El objetico es que la gente salga huyendo de la ópera?
she needs help...tempo is extrememly slow...she needs to understand the text better..I dont thinks she has a clue what shes saying...the F's were nasty
This is beyond awful. Why and how in God's name does this woman think that she can sing? It's like amateur hour at the local school, come to think of it I reckon that it is amateur hour at the local school.
there are some parts that are off key.... was she singing sharp when she is trying to reach the high F???? I don't she has trained her voice.... at least, it does not sound like she has...
Not a very good rendition, but she definitely can sing well. This is one, if not the most, dificult aria to sing, & she did deliver most of the tough notes quite alright. The tempo is way too slow though. If Mozart was alive, he'd sue her.
Firstly, as everyone has already mentioned that this aria is under tempo. But maybe the singer purposely did this to make her diction more clear and also do something that isnt easy. Because what she did wasnt easy and she was brave to take it on.
Awwwww! Okay, she is not the hottest Queen but did anyone hear the accompanist? My good God in heaven! Oh, by the way, did I say it is waaaaaaaaaaaaay too slow? Yaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwwn!
This aria was meant to be FAST not turle express slow! Go back to an opera school, practice that car alarm voice and try not to squeak when ya sing OR talk!!!!
thats right lady, take your time..dont mind the piece's tempo markings..just soldier on..pretend the notes are all whole notes, dont mind the composer's intentions, you are far above that.
but to give her credit, she can hit high notes i cant.
Es demasiaaaado leeento, para cantar eso se necesitan años de trabajo vocal, tecnica operistica. ademas canta con microfono, y no llega a las notas sobreagudas y los tresillos ligados los hace aaasqueroso.
In her defense, the first round of C's were better than I expected...but oh dear GOD!!! The worst Queen I've ever heard. This tempo is AWFUL!!! All her rhythms are wrong, and the pianist is almost worse than she is.
My opinion is I wouldn't even attempt it if I couldn't sing it well. I mean, she is not only weak with her support (is there even any there?) she can't keep the beat--she's off a couple places, and futhermore, she sings it as though everything is all wonderful--and that is not what the song is about. Also, why the hell is she keeping the beat so slow? It's much faster.
Now I may still be new to opera, and my ears may not yet be conditioned to tell horrible from good, but in my opinion, she's attempting to sing of the most difficult aria there is, and I say kudos to her for at least attempting it.
Well, what can one say? It's almost like she can't reach it! She's struggling to get up there 'so to speak' besides, she's singing it to decent, too nice, this should be sung malicious, evil.
Please... isn't this just an amateur singer performing for some people at a church? Taken as that, it's not so awful. It's far better than that woman who just sang the notes to a beat as if there were no lyrics.
If that's the case, and she's at a church, then why didn't someone throw some holy water on her and command that screeching demon out? The power of Christ compels her:o)!
Hehe.... I have to say, her voice is good, but needs to practice more to hit the right higher notes. And the tempo of this song definitely needs to be faster.
biokemiker 9 months ago
why god why
dkoraytuncel 11 months ago 2
FLORENCE FOSTER-JENKINS REVIVAL!!!
SergioRenzulli 1 year ago
Lo peor fue el tiempo, definitivamente.
Me gusta la voz... hasta que llega a la cololatura...
No se si es que aún el aria no le queda bien, o que sinceramente es culpa del que le arreglo la pieza.
Ademas... su dicción tiene problemas.
DriAner13 1 year ago
demasiado vibrato, desafinada, cantas con la garganta, falta de presencia escenica. a destiempo, mal pianista haha y bla bla bla ...
Zimmmermmmannn 1 year ago 2
技巧要多練練！唱的這樣爛還自我感覺很良好會不會太誇張了..................
ymot3201 1 year ago
No es para ella
citybell1990 2 years ago
Yeah... the tempo is slow...
The voice is... goob... but dosen't have the... that special thing.
Jaa na !!
omegazo 2 years ago
Goshhh!!! Retire!
mariokalogeropoulos 3 years ago
MA RITIRATI VACCA!!!!!!!
emilytransex 3 years ago
despues de ver a marisol cantar, esta mujer es una diosa
reptila98 3 years ago 6
hahahahahahaah y que lo digas xD
DeadMovieStar0 2 years ago
Tempo is WAY too slow. Her voice is terrific, but this is a song about exacting blood in revenge from a rival. This aria in a slowed tempo takes away from that big time. So anyone who doesn't know this piece or the German language might think, "Oh wow! This is really pretty."
oneworldguy 3 years ago
her voice is NOT terrific
sirinferno 3 years ago
I respect your opinion. I have mine as well and I think very highly of this singer. Be sure you are distinguishing VOICE from PERFORMANCE. I don't like this PERFORMANCE because of the incredibly slowed tempo. I think had this been performed at a more appropriate tempo, it would sound very good!
oneworldguy 3 years ago
NO.. NO.. NO GUSTAR
carlaisabelc 3 years ago
lol this was hilarious..
Satirike 3 years ago
I couldn't take my eyes off of her strange chicken impession. She just kept lifting her elbows up rather than breathing.
Learn some basic technique and do a simpler piece some credit before you murder something that's way out of your vocal and technical league.
I think she was just showing off(and failed!)
Toriabockle 3 years ago 6
@Toriabockle Nice Tits though.
HConstantine 1 year ago
I could sing this version without care, and you see, I am a tenor. This is awful!
Guilherme7530 3 years ago
the tempo it´s horribly wrong
sounds like a ballad and not like a rage aria
pakovozronka 3 years ago 2
Horrible :(
carlosdevivo 3 years ago
she need breath!!!!
vincetcran 3 years ago
of chlorine
sirinferno 3 years ago
I think this aria is not for her.
She is out of tempo cuz she cannot breath correctly, lack of technique maybe, she should try with smth easier.
dft82 3 years ago
hehe.. ye.. sounds a bit like florence foster jenkins. check her up :)
manwithemeraldeyes 3 years ago
yeah it's pretty slow
ComaLies225 3 years ago
I personally know how difficult it is to sing this. It's a workout. Kudos for trying it out, takes guts. Yes, for some reason it's under tempo...really odd.
FlyBean8 3 years ago
Florence Foster Jenkins
ll40808 4 years ago 2
Waaaaaay too slow jesus are you enjoying the sound of your own voice too much or something??
Armedcor 4 years ago
if u think this bad, search for "Marisol cantando la flauta magica" and compare.
lintopa 4 years ago
bwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahahahaha, thanks, i needed a laugh...although kudos to that pianist. he was really helping her as much as is possible.
sirinferno 4 years ago
Okay, so maybe this isn't her song. But at least she could hit the hight notes, so we can rest assured she isn't a reincarnation of Florence Foster Jenkins. At all.
PluckyRagdoll 4 years ago
"Oh... my... GOD!" is all I can say of Florence Jenkins. I cannot believe that they even dignified her on Wikipedia with a recording her performing this very song.
But this performance is FAR too slow.
oneworldguy 4 years ago
Yes, she "hit" the high notes, and this video proves that this is not the only qualification for singing this aria!
RossiniSoprano 3 years ago
tooooooooooo sloooooooooooooooooow
mariokalogeropoulos 4 years ago
she's here and a very lot of people can see AND hear her. she's not perfect. she's miles away from it. the kind of interpretation is not the best. she tryed, but not succesfully.
i think, if you are not the best and you are in front of such an audiance you cannot expect good critics(?). plaese take this video off from youtube. its better for you and for us.
greetings from germany
Perkel84 4 years ago
You guys are haters, she's fine...yes, it's slow, no it's not perfect, but can you do that? I sure can't
meowmeowkitty3 4 years ago
no we're not. we're realists. she's beyond awful. it's slow, it's not perfect, it's not even in tune! a dying frog could do better than that
sirinferno 4 years ago
if it's slow and she's not perfect, then she can't be fine!
we're not haters, we offer a healthy review of someone's poor singers. and our inability to sing this bad does not excuse her from taking this awful performance out in public. you do it and you get the beating.
10catz 4 years ago
Opera critics are the worst! You all are not nice to that poor woman, at least she's trying...mean, mean, mean, mean...
meowmeowkitty3 4 years ago
Don't use the "you can't do it" excuse. If someone here knows that can't sing this, probably won't even try, especially in public. But she didn't care and kept hurting everybody's hears.
AnonimuzZ 4 years ago
You all are just mean, and I think I can judge her... is her voice so off key that cats are running in opposite directions? No, unless you have heard Florence Foster Jenkins, you cannot be hating on this woman...she's fine...is she sumi jo, no, but for someone who is not a professional she's doing ok...
meowmeowkitty3 4 years ago
I have heard Florence Foster Jenkins and this woman is not far from her =P
AnonimuzZ 4 years ago
That's boloney and you know it. You just want to be mean and cruel...Why is it that opera "critics" are so nasty? It's like having a bunch of Simon Cowell's that get off by spewing venom...
meowmeowkitty3 4 years ago
Lol, I'm just kidding, don't take it so serious. But you have to admit that she's definitely NOT an opera singer.
AnonimuzZ 4 years ago
well the last part isn't the greatest, but I've heard worse.
meowmeowkitty3 4 years ago
Well, I *can* do it, but that doesn't make much difference to what we are talking about here. Every soprano who has a few high notes think they can sing this aria, and I wish they wouldn't! How does the teacher allow this, is what I want to know. Teacher must be as delusional as the student.
RossiniSoprano 3 years ago
this is not good but shes way better that florence foster jenkins.
nicevidbro 4 years ago
This is far too slow, and the flaws in the voice show out because of it, plus the mistakes made. eeeek! Try for lower roles.
Joeleole 4 years ago
Judging by the background, the acoustics and the cuts it sounds like a class recital, if she's a learner then it's not going to be perfect. She didn't sound like she was struggling much except a couple of the very highest notes. She just needs to keep up the training and practise.
tricky778 4 years ago
it says performed at a church. hence she's an amateur singer.
she was struggling to stay vaguely in tune ALL the time. and it was ridiculously slow.
sirinferno 4 years ago
it waz sloppy. but way better dne i cud evr do so i appreciate
Eyo0o 4 years ago
Florence Foster Jenkins, anyone?
KatherineXIX 4 years ago
I was thinking the same thing
hillevifan 4 years ago
ew.
gamenick923 4 years ago
she has lots of mistakes...and it´s too slow
imeaus 4 years ago
Her voice is very high but where is her talent? She only stands there and thinks she is gorgeous and great. I wonder if she know what she is singing or if she knows that most of her notes is false?
dannymaestro 4 years ago
way too slow
mmg565s 4 years ago
I never understood why would anyone sing and aria that they are totally struggling with. She could sing anything else, I suggest romantic opera. Why this hell of an aria that if one doesn't make perfect it's terrible? If you can't do it perfect stay away from Mozart for in his music the slightest mistake SHOWS!!!!!BADLY!!!
FloriaTosca85 4 years ago
¿What kind of bad joke is this?
tradi2007 4 years ago
So many things she could do with all those easy high-C's... but this piece with all that vibrato is not one of them!
Nathan1097 4 years ago
My God, this is slower than Bessie Abott! And why those odd little edits? Did someone spare us the really BAD notes? Of course, the Benchmark of Bad in this aria is Florence Foster Jenkins, but this, bad as it is, isn't bad enough to be funny.
pno4tay 4 years ago
ROFLMAO. I agree! I want to see FFJ's recording on here. Hang on... I have the CD... somewhere. lol
Nathan1097 4 years ago
she has no pitch control in the upper register, at all. whoever americanidol006 is doesnt know what theyre talking, this has nothing to do with anyones opinion of opera, it just sucks. judging by the americanidol name, youre probably some high school girl in choir who sings pop and doesnt know anythign about opera, im in music school and i listen to a lot of opera, and i can definitively say that that was aweful.
skitzo429 4 years ago
Aaaaarg. She's out of her vocal range. And the triplets were mildly horrendous... Also, I think they need a change in pianist, or at least a tuning.
henrythorogood 4 years ago
Dear, sweet Jesus! Please make it disappear from YouTube.
urgrad03 4 years ago
This lady has a good voice but has been mislead into singing in the wrong range & clearly doesnt benefit from the guidance of a good vocal coach. If she did I think she would do very well. Her lowest notes were the strongest & in the best tone. Because of this, I'm sorry, not trying to be unkind but this particular performance was awful, pianist hang your head in shame.
staudrey 4 years ago
btw i could kill her for that egocentric laughing at the end... and the person who says "bravo" must be deaf. at least after listening to this.
JenneEssen 4 years ago
oh...my...god...
who told her she could sing this? i've never seen someone who misses so many tones. it's like a cat falling into a bathtub!
plus she clearly doesn't understand a word of what she's singing.
the pianist must have some musical education. and for destroying this piece by polaying it so slowly he should be punished. by listening to that recording over and over again.
JenneEssen 4 years ago
Also, I think if she performed something like Voi Che Sapete, it would suit her voice much better, as it's a slightly simpler aria, and it would also show off her vocal abilities much better as well.
Apollo2077 4 years ago
She has a very nice tone to her voice, but lacks in vocal technique. I can't hear her diaphragm working at all on the high notes. I don't think she was really ready to perform it. The tempo of the aria is also way too slow, and because of a lack of emotion it comes across as a tad bit boring. I feel that she was only trying to show off her voice. The pianist also faltered on many occasions.
Apollo2077 4 years ago
A nice voice, but she is seriously mislead. The aria itself is about a woman who is enraged, this tempo is waaaaaay too slow. She didn't sing that 'F' in tune ONCE! Moreover, I don't think she knows the meaning of what she is singing. She is completely emotionless.
dejatucoro 4 years ago
This is the worst one I have heard on youtube. She had trouble all the way through.
theRubyRunner 4 years ago
She isn't that bad. It all has to do with your opinion of Opera and music. If you don't like it then why are you even listening to it? She actually has some talent!!! I sing opera. It can be very pretty and she isn't doing that bad!!!!!! Stop hating on opera singers!!!
americanidol006 4 years ago
what is she doing?
mdancer01 4 years ago
What the f*$#!!!
MezzosRule 4 years ago
I hope nobody paid to hear this horrific performance. This is very embarrassing for both the singer and the pianist.
Laeliapurpurata 4 years ago
a good effort. Good for her.
testomatic12345 4 years ago
ZZzzzzzzz is it over yet? She probably has a fairly good voice, but she shold keep her vocal chords away from this piece, otherwise she won't be singing for long. That might be a positive note!!
Dortmunderstrasse 4 years ago
So she clearly has the Florence Foster Jenkins recording and learned to 'sing' it from that, right?
RossiniSoprano 4 years ago
FFJ was a genius, either way. She sang at Carnegie, damn it! She was "off" just enough- and keeps us guessing. This woman is just plain painful.
Nathan1097 4 years ago
Just two words: extremely painful!!!!
igottafindpeace 4 years ago
OUCH...painfully slow, and crappy tuning on her way up, and squeaky tops...just...wrong...stop tormenting mozart :(
sirinferno 4 years ago
Well, anyone who will take this aria on in front of any audience is braver than I will ever be. The effect of this one, slowed down like this, with all its glittery edges softened, is really different. It's just too high/too hard for her, as it is for almost everyone.
periodictable47 4 years ago
i'd say, anyone who's willing to butcher the aria so much has no shame. if she considers herself an opera singer, she needs to make sure that she can sing the piece before standing in front of any audience. it's like one of those bad american idol auditions.
10catz 4 years ago
Seems like something a really young, really high-aspiring person might do, though.Reminds me of myself in my teens, singing "Che Faro" from Gluck's Orfeo in an audition because (as I was pathetically pleased with myself for being able to do) I could hit all the notes. I'd gotten enchanted with the aria after hearing it sung by someone whom I know now was not all that good. I hadn't heard Janet Baker or Marilyn Horne sing it at that point, and if I had, I'd have known not to try.
periodictable47 4 years ago
Really bad...i agree this is not the right pieces for her, probably she's not ready yet.And the pianist is so bad too.
Awful...
Violinfrau 4 years ago
Der Hölle Rache is beyond the singer's talent.
this is another reason why i avoid churches - it is a breeding spot for singing mediocrity.
10catz 4 years ago
actually, im not sure why i decided that this was performed in a church.
terrible nevertheless. both the singer and the pianist.
10catz 4 years ago
it doesn't mean there's a complete lack of talent in them though...
sirinferno 4 years ago
i know. i was just being an ass
10catz 4 years ago
gdgd
sirinferno 4 years ago
She is reminding me of Florence Foster-Jenkins...
dannymaestro 4 years ago
Why has thou forsaken me?....LOL The pianist is a mess too... and whoever is saying bravo at the end must be a blood relative. Now that I'm done be ugly, let me say it took a lot of work to get to that point, good job, don't give up! Nice voice let it work more and not you...just think about it and you'll get it...
diamler 4 years ago
Oh my poor ears...this is the WORST Der Holle I have EVER heard. That does include the 12 year old boy that sings it!!! FAR too slow, horribly unclean coloratura, bad piano playing, bad video. Do I need to continue??? Please remove it!!! Unless you want something to laugh at non-stop. I hope you didn't charge for the recital!
pianophil84 4 years ago
good voice, wrong song...her voice is not as far in the development as she thinks it is...could be better if she had waited a bit...
xx8XPunkRockX8xx 4 years ago
too slow
minjica 4 years ago
Really beautiful tone, wrong choice of song though.
prettyxxpoison 4 years ago
She's good. This must be crazy hard to sing
ProphetessMarcia 4 years ago
Ok I'm the last person to judge one's singing but this really isn't that good. The tempo is too slow, the phrasing is pretty dire, the pitching of higher notes is pretty poor, and tbh, I think this has been recorded more than once and pieced together.
Oh, and the pianist? Not that good tbh.
LesAdieux 4 years ago
well... not great. flat on the high F and and ugly slurred runs, not great control of your upper register. more practice and it might work. also, another song might be better. I feel you are just a soprano, not a coloratura soprano. the pianist was amazing either.
CurrentBroadwayActor 4 years ago
sing in your fach lady!
cbrown6660 4 years ago
I think this is a prime example of why it is so important to pick the right song for your voice. Nice voice, bad song decision.
fromanda 4 years ago
this video is great. she is the best of the worst. i'm adding this to me favorites.
zacharybr 5 years ago
Your voice is rather rough for this aria and you fall flat on the high Fs. You need more training to polish your coloratura. But I like the natural quality of your voice.
tanynzh 5 years ago
your voice is amazing but you need to sing more ligth , this aria is for coloratura soprano
llum82 5 years ago
i do not mean to be mean but this is my favorite aria. the woman needs a lot more practice before she can sing it.
derhollerache 5 years ago
she obviously totally misunderstood the song...she's trying to sing the colouratura sweetly which is just wrong!
dtinkler257 5 years ago
Eeeek! Run away! Run away!
sarahflute 5 years ago
She has a very nice voice, but she needs a kick in the ass.
Alexandrinchen85 5 years ago
I'm sorry but she actually makes my skin crawl! Far too slow, pitching is absolutely horrendous *particularly in the upper registers* and the pianist isn't that brilliant either. In fact just as bad!
Though the sound does seem to be rather alright
LesAdieux 5 years ago
This really bad. The tempo is really slow. The pianist is really bad and her voice was not made for this song at all.
dcleo1515 5 years ago
AH, my god. Awful... The pianist is really bad, and the woman in the picture, the screamer... Delete, delete...
dannymaestro 5 years ago
Canta bien y SparafucileVengador te ensalsará. Hazlo mal y SparafucileVengador te lo dirá. Esta mujer, con ese peso, cómo carambas podría cantar rápido? No tendrá un buen amigo que le diga que se ve horrible con los brazos descubiertos? Tiene potencial, pero está más que verde. Por Dios, que no la dejen cantar mientras no esté lista!! Esos "sobreagudos" son insoportables. Cómo la gente se atreve a subir esto a Internet? El objetico es que la gente salga huyendo de la ópera?
SparafucileVengador 5 years ago
she needs help...tempo is extrememly slow...she needs to understand the text better..I dont thinks she has a clue what shes saying...the F's were nasty
jokerab112 5 years ago
This is beyond awful. Why and how in God's name does this woman think that she can sing? It's like amateur hour at the local school, come to think of it I reckon that it is amateur hour at the local school.
saab900se 5 years ago
jajajajaaaajajajajajjajajajajjajaja ajajajajajaj ajajajaja ajajjajaja aajjajajajajaja ajajajajajaj ajjajajajaja ajajjajajajaa
edgutgar 5 years ago
you need to have more concentration...a lot of the pitches are off
its alright
0flauta0 5 years ago
This is terrible. Did someone try to edit some of her squeaking because the video because skips.
zacharybr 5 years ago
You raped a piece of art.
apnAEA 5 years ago
this really sux, some potential in her voice but really BAD technique and no emotion at all. oh... she killed this
gilmourex 5 years ago
the pianist is out of tune also
paminaase 5 years ago
HORRIBLE
nicenicedude 5 years ago
Very very bad.... this is like the graduation of the kinder garden on the singing art. Very bad, it's a joke!!
macielnegrete 5 years ago
this is a joke :P
crowjr 5 years ago
The pianist doesn't help either ...
mcbud 5 years ago
its okay but idk..
can be better
endairagoth 5 years ago
i think a dying frog would give out a better rendition of that aria...would probably be in tune too...
sirinferno 4 years ago
hahahahahaha......
Nathan1097 4 years ago
This is awful. It is not endured to listen honestly.
I think that she is not a skill as this song can still be sung.
delphine15 5 years ago
I agree this is a little slow, lost the magic...
cicipio 5 years ago
there are some parts that are off key.... was she singing sharp when she is trying to reach the high F???? I don't she has trained her voice.... at least, it does not sound like she has...
margotlorena 5 years ago
see, it could be good if it was faster...if it was faster then she'd have more energy to sing and it'd probably sound pretty good
glasskimono 5 years ago
I enjoyed it. Why should everyone stick to the original? Come on, it wasn't like remaking of the opera or anything. ;]
theprimadonna 5 years ago
she was trying to stick to the origina o_O that's what's so disturbing
sirinferno 4 years ago
sirinferno, the original from 1791? o_O did she hear it her nightmares.
gosh, every time i log on to read comments, i have to hear this performance all over again.
i wonder if FoxyGrandpa is somehow related to the singer.
10catz 4 years ago
Come on honey, it is Queen of the Night not a Sleeping Beauty...
Angelicangelic 5 years ago
Not a very good rendition, but she definitely can sing well. This is one, if not the most, dificult aria to sing, & she did deliver most of the tough notes quite alright. The tempo is way too slow though. If Mozart was alive, he'd sue her.
gemininer 5 years ago
Firstly, as everyone has already mentioned that this aria is under tempo. But maybe the singer purposely did this to make her diction more clear and also do something that isnt easy. Because what she did wasnt easy and she was brave to take it on.
krnsassyboi 5 years ago
"How about this song?...It has lots of high notes and I love singing high notes... What's a zauberflote?... That's too fast, can we do it slower?"
Love the smile at the end...yes sweetie, you done good. But do you know WTF you're singing about?
txtumbler 5 years ago
choose another song..please.. you will ruin your voice..
zrngrkm 5 years ago
Awwwww! Okay, she is not the hottest Queen but did anyone hear the accompanist? My good God in heaven! Oh, by the way, did I say it is waaaaaaaaaaaaay too slow? Yaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwwn!
civileso 5 years ago
AWFUL!
LazEstrada 5 years ago
Mozart would kill her...
Bloodeuwedd 5 years ago
huh?
rekkha 5 years ago
so it's slow - it's not that bad. people say i'm too nice when it comes to reviewing and stuff, but i thought it was pretty good.
shiryu22 5 years ago
sssssssssllllllllllloooooooooowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
glasskimono 5 years ago
This aria was meant to be FAST not turle express slow! Go back to an opera school, practice that car alarm voice and try not to squeak when ya sing OR talk!!!!
zambardecae 5 years ago
Wow...go hide under a table or something. This is terrible. have some self-respect for crying out loud!
fernandoclassic 5 years ago
boah, ist das schlecht...
felixvonseeburg 5 years ago
thats right lady, take your time..dont mind the piece's tempo markings..just soldier on..pretend the notes are all whole notes, dont mind the composer's intentions, you are far above that.
but to give her credit, she can hit high notes i cant.
abadab 5 years ago
was the speed supporsed to be largo? please hit the high notes properly.
potatoeu 5 years ago
what a pity!
paminaase 5 years ago
Okay... THIS IS TOO SLOW! It stares you in the face. I'm sure she would sound a lot better is you sped up the tempo.
Drinners 5 years ago
Oh, please close the gates of hell (that would be her mouth).
sentheru 5 years ago
Ummm...one of the worst (probably THE worst) I've heard this aria sung. She totally murdered it.
migglemunker 5 years ago
so baaaaddd
joconde 5 years ago
A TOTAL DESTIEMPO
canapinas 5 years ago
The accompanist pianist can't get the right fingers on the right keys... no comments...
nilsuthor 5 years ago
>< argh how awful
Obernik 5 years ago
she looks like she's singing about the milk in the pot that boiled over
camillelopezmolina 5 years ago
Esta del nabete su tecnica no es buena, es una verguenza para los que estudiamos opera
saritalove 5 years ago
PLOP! tu siempre has dicho que no estudias opera, que lo tuyo, lo tuyo, lo tuyo, es cantar para el populo!
Lyosha87 5 years ago
Es demasiaaaado leeento, para cantar eso se necesitan años de trabajo vocal, tecnica operistica. ademas canta con microfono, y no llega a las notas sobreagudas y los tresillos ligados los hace aaasqueroso.
Lyosha87 5 years ago
jjaajjaa LOL
baobanshee 5 years ago
In her defense, the first round of C's were better than I expected...but oh dear GOD!!! The worst Queen I've ever heard. This tempo is AWFUL!!! All her rhythms are wrong, and the pianist is almost worse than she is.
JonGStahl 5 years ago
My opinion is I wouldn't even attempt it if I couldn't sing it well. I mean, she is not only weak with her support (is there even any there?) she can't keep the beat--she's off a couple places, and futhermore, she sings it as though everything is all wonderful--and that is not what the song is about. Also, why the hell is she keeping the beat so slow? It's much faster.
Mindi31 5 years ago
Now I may still be new to opera, and my ears may not yet be conditioned to tell horrible from good, but in my opinion, she's attempting to sing of the most difficult aria there is, and I say kudos to her for at least attempting it.
ScathingResplendence 5 years ago
Well, what can one say? It's almost like she can't reach it! She's struggling to get up there 'so to speak' besides, she's singing it to decent, too nice, this should be sung malicious, evil.
swanlakegirl 5 years ago
Someone needs to throw her a big tomatoe.
boipussi 5 years ago
FOSTER JENKINS IS BACK!
alexmacias 5 years ago
Please... isn't this just an amateur singer performing for some people at a church? Taken as that, it's not so awful. It's far better than that woman who just sang the notes to a beat as if there were no lyrics.
PocketRebel 5 years ago
If that's the case, and she's at a church, then why didn't someone throw some holy water on her and command that screeching demon out? The power of Christ compels her:o)!
urgrad03 5 years ago