Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (456)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I listen to music like this and wonder why people would listen to shit like Sexy and I know it.

  • Grazie di esistere.....nn saprei vivere senza le emozioni che mi date sempre.....Dream Theater 4ever!!!!!

  • I would cry saying goodbye to my lover hearing this emotional song which comes from sensitive lungs of James Labrie. He is so emotional singer.

  • wowowowow!!!!!!!!!!

  • I've say goodbye to my lover with this song...:(

  • That moment when you need to pee in a middle of a DT show and Rudess decides to play water drops samples.

  • @DarkieBC happened to me 2 days ago :D

  • @22bibia93 Lisbon ?

  • @DarkieBC that's the one!

  • @22bibia93 Join the club, bom saber que não fui a unica com esse problema, ainda por cima mesmo que quisesse não podia ir á casa de banho porque estava mesmo na primeirissima fila, escusado será dizer que não me importei nada de aguentar até porque ficar na primeira fila me valeu a palheta do Petrucci :D

  • @DarkieBC tás a gozar? que sortuda! eu estava um bocado mais atrás, para aí na 5ª ou 6ª fila.

  • @22bibia93 Está à espera de ser emoldurada xD, foi um grande concerto, a ver se os vejo a próxima vez que vierem

  • Fucking amazing first song I here by dream theater and I wanna but every album they have..

  • I can listen to this song all day long....

  • Spirit Carries On is an awful song completed by some of the cheesiest lyrics ever

  • @michael88863 I love that song so much I can't even describe it...

  • I just broke down halfway through the song, that's never happened to me before. Thank you Dream Theater for this beautiful, amazing song <3

  • I have every DT CD - I have to say that is it for me. Doesn't anyone else hear how cheesy and cringe making this is???????? Good god. The lyrics are a joke. Goodbye DT. Hello Symphony X :)

  • @michael88863 Agreed, solid album..really bad song lol! Not sure if portnoy would of went along with this faggy song.

  • why you dislike this video if you are not bitch !

  • I'm still waiting for my pain to be buried beneath the surface..

  • every day i come here to hear this song ... but i hear this song 10 times or more in a single day / Damn Dream Theater its like a drug you cant stop

  • 0:00-0:12 public toilet

    Nah, all jokes aside, this is probably the best ballad song that DT has ever created. Petrucci's lyrics are so touching and easily relateable that it's unbelieveable. This song tells so well why and how the balance between love and desire for love and getting hurt so easily tips to the latter side quite heavily.

  • @MannnisEi Really?? how bout the Spirit Carries On by far, and it's not even close!

  • this one leaves me crying every time, and i'm not ashamed to admit it

  • I think that 6 guys have problem with their ears..

  • @TheGreave Labrie's voice has been amazing live recently.

  • I cant wait until they come to Switzerland...i live in czech republic and im travling 700km cause of them :D they totally deserve it!!!

  • People says that LaBrie is horrible live.. saw them live yesterday.. LaBrie was flawless.. Dream Theater <3

  • I cry every single time I listen to this... but it's worth it ^-^ can't wait to see them!!

  • Saw them at Vallhall arena in Oslo, last night......sorry for swearing....they were fuckin awesome and tears poured down my face, as this song was played......may you have many more years, of fantastic musical art...ahead of you. Mike, was just awesome on his drum solo what more can I say.......'The Spirit Carries On'........:)

  • Can't wait to see these guys at wembley on the 10th. VIP too! :D

  • @siggerz100 I hope you have a fantastic time.......they were awesome last night in Oslo...and I was lucky enough to squeeze to the front row!!! Have fun :)

  • So,there are 6 people till now who don't like this song?? OMG..

    Guys.. This is the BALLAD of the decade..!

  • Can somebody tell me what kind of effect is using Jordan here??

    By the way... EXCELLENT SONG, great way to finish a GREAT ALBUM!!!

  • dream theater can still stay epic, even with an acoustic song!!!!!!! \m/ BEAUTIFUL

  • I think this is one of the best songs in the world

  • Beatiful song !!!!!

  • Actually watched the Titanic movie yesterday. It got me again at the end like it did in the theater. This song strikes a bone...

  • The Titanic makes women cry. Dream Theater makes men cry.

  • @dmdollinar08 i guess i'm a man then.. thanks for the heads up!

  • @dmdollinar08

    It can make women cry too, just saying.

  • look to my cover of Beneath the surface on my profile. Anghellos1

  • Comment removed

  • @dmdollinar08 3/10. Intentional or not, your trolling skills are bad. You may want to work on that.

  • nice song DT incredible¡¡¡

  • Muy buen Tema!! Amazing song!!!!

  • better than rebecca black's friday

  • @Diego1973Art Let's not bring up that wretch's name when we're talking about musical gods here.

  • why dislikin' this? :O

  • me and my boyfriend now (of about 2 and a half weeks, best friends for 4 and a half years)...story of our lives EXACTLY word for word <3 <3 <3

  • this was the song my ex let me hearsome time after we broke up it hurts this song

  • Comment removed

  • is it just me or when La Brie sing the last "And began to forget" at about 4.38 is slightly out of tune????? i can't bear listening to these part.

    But the song is a masterpiece! :)

  • posted lyrics are way off.

  • @skimam your statement is only your opinion. I think most listeners would argue that this is the moment where the song really soars... I would... and i personally think that LaBrie sounds great on this album.

  • I'm going to go down the aisle at my wedding to this song.

  • A beautiful song. I literally cried the first time I listened to this. Just... so full of emotion... especially the ending. Tears at 4:27. :) Dream Theater is just amazing.

  • Amazing insight..amazing emotions...amazing lyrics..incredible..music....a­hh....

  • I was listening to the whole album for the first time today, but I was kinda sleepy, and I slept through the whole thing... and then came along this one piece of amazingly wonderful piece of art, and actually made me cry while I was having a kinda lucid dream.. thanks Dream Theater for this one, and from the first note of Majesty Demo to the last bit of it up till now.. DT forever

  • such a coincidence...

  • So many emotions... thank you Dream Theater... for allowing me to cry, for helping me to get through these difficult times. Thank you all for writing amazings songs, that kept me dreaming all the time, waiting for every album. Thank you for your support, and thank you for your eternal and powerful love.

  • beautiful

    

  • Those lyrics are just all wrong...

  • there is no right time for dream theater , thats why they always change time signatures a million times in each song !

  • And the song turned to orgasm, never went away...

  • That first line is amazing.

  • I cried when I heard this in concert at Houston in October. Greatest band ever, no argument..

  • what do you hear when you listen to this song?

    i hear peace at last. finally home, but perhaps alone after a long journey. where have all your companions gone?

  • i come so close to crying when i listen to Dream Theater. every time... hm hm <3

  • ...and I just now realized the water drops in the intro are actually in the same rhythm as the main riff. chills.

  • It's almost like JP wrote this song about my life. It really hits close to home.

  • I'm gonna be honest. I was 2nd guessing this new Dream Theater album. It seemed to be lacking that one song their albums have that totally blow me away (count of tuscany, octavarium etc.). That was, until I heard this song. This album is awesome.

  • 5 people live above the surface.

  • This song is just amazing :') i can't help but press the repeat button when it finishes

  • ok guys we need a time machine and 5 condoms

  • Awesome song. It's like Ana Lee.

  • yea go boy

  • I flee towards the beauty of music when the generic noises emanating from the radio gets too loud. As a fan of music, listening can sometimes be a lonely thing to do since a lot of people ceased doing so..

    Dream Theater is a triumph to music.; making music that tells, music that means something.

  • Deep beneath the surfaaaaaaace...

    beautiful song,beautiful lyric,and beautiful harmonies.

    Bridges In The Sky too..

  • song that never gets old

    no matter how many timez i listen to it

  • So great!

  • I love this number indescribably much, it gives extreme peace of mind

  • hart touching 

  • Wonderful song :)

  • That first line is fucking amazing. Great delivery with the lyrics. LaBrie has lost his higher register but he can still deliver a line!

  • Amazing.

  • it cant be a more fitting circumstances for me to adore this song !! music and lyrics! wonderfall !!! :D

  • that wold justin b bar

  • only a person without feelings can dislike this...

  • The first song I heard I had cried to...

  • Great album, awesome song... everything is incredible... but still something is missing - Mike Portnoy!

  • the solo like the final fantasy music ! @@

  • sung with soul. like it

  • yes man

    Great ending to a Great album

  • This is truly the perfect song to close the best DT album.

  • i just love this song more then anything elalse in the world

  • @URAssassiN1

    ur mum's gonna be proud to hear. :S :D

  • Friend zone fiona: The song

  • have to love that keyboard, thank you Rudess!

  • Justin Bieber created 5 accounts on YouTube and disliked this

  • listen to the strings from 4:07 it´s the ministry of lost souls^^

  • yes i just loose my self in this song

  • the most beautiful song..............

  • jak tego slucham to czuje się jak te gosciu na tym rowerku :D when I listening this song i feel like this man on this bike :)

  • Even the Devil Love this 666 Thumbs Up and i wont be the 667 =P

  • 5 ppl are buried deep beneath the surface.

  • can i vote .... more and more....and more ?

  • Comment removed

  • I have to skip past the second  chorus if I'm not alone, or I bawl.

  • The beginning of this song shows there sadness that portnoy left. The keyboard solo shows there happiness that Mangini joined.

  • After hearing this song, I've made my decision. Dream Theater can play any type of music.

  • @fild77 You didn't know that already? :D They are the most talented band there has ever been, and the most talented there ever will be

  • @fild77

    You should have know that already ;)

  • To all the people talking about love, this song is about how brutally pointless and painful the pursuit of "love" truly is. The woman always causes the pain, and only has herself to blame.

  • Such a great song!!! It's simply beautiful! <3

  • I always Cry!! :'(

  • Drums by Mike Portnoy

  • Never thought I would say this but Portnoy made 5 youtube accounts and disliked this song. Dream Theater the Dream carries on.

  • i just love it 

  • anyone else think this is about portnoy?

  • @DemiseOfSanityJSY

    It's about what's beneath the surface of Labrie's foreskin.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY HAHAHA

  • This reminds me to a very special person..that i almost lose.. =3 Beatiful and great song !

  • Cheesier than Labrie's foreskin.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY you spelled his name wrong. troll.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY dude... really?! you need help...

  • i notice that the comments are mostly refering to memories of loved ones and feelings. this is why this is an amazing song. because it goes beyng the music and into what you feel.

  • Sucks without Portnoy.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY man shutup dude I know you've been writing this on all the album's songs. i can agree that dream theater is different without portnoy but this allowed them to bring about a new and old side of themselves that we have never seen and have missed for a long time.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY you're an idiot

  • @MlKEPORNTOY you wrote Mike porn toy... you are a pervert !

  • @MlKEPORNTOY

    lol it's time to carry on, sir

  • Comment removed

  • I love this song soo ♥♥

    I can listen to it every our ! Then there is a speciel wonderfull fealing in my body

  • Love his touching voice

  • That keyboard solo at 3:27. Wow. That is The most powerful solo ever. Turn up the volume!

  • this is my favorite song in this album. :(

  • @uccisato why sadface? it's a masterpiece

  • but on a musical level, I have to say I love Mangini's touch on this song. He added JUST the right stuff in the right places. Some timpani, a soft gong, and the tambourine. You know a drummer's good when he can add real orchestrated percussion music like that without even using a drum-beat.

  • I first heard this when driving... I had to pull over just to be able to listen and feel the emotion...

    Definitely singing this for voice lessons. It just hit me at a very personal level.

  • I think i would never forget why i'm trying to be so close..

    But i can't find the words..I can't find the words to express my self to her..

    This song is my favourite from the new album..

    If i won't disappear into the darkness i would thank d.t forever..

  • ..and btw @MASZ8: in case that john petrucci wrote this thinking of Mike Portnoy - I think the only reaction of MP can be the one I have permanently listening to this: crying tears in love of Music and his true friend from college.. hm?

  • Wow.. Thanks URAssassiN for posting this wonderful piece - and thank you DT for the gift of your newest and BEST ALBUM EVER (i can now say that without any doubts) :-)))

  • i need to wash my headphones now because my ears just had the most intense orgasms in the world.

  • best DT ballad since lifting shadows of a dream

    with the best dream theater´s chorus ever

  • It just goes to show you, just because a bands main focus is metal/speed metal, they can still be deep. <3

  • i just came together with somebody while I listened to this song :)

  • OMG, this song is just like Hollow yearsss !!! SAme time and style

  • 1 person don´t like this song?.. i think he/she doesn't have tears...

  • Beautiful song. Saw them live a week or so ago, it changed my life forever. \m/

  • lol its funny how most of dream theaters heart felt songs were written by John Petrucci ,he must be the sweetes man ever 

  • @yngwierulez1 A Nightmare To Remember.

  • this is in my opinion the best DT ballad, and is a phenomenal ending to an amazing album.

  • 3:17 makes me think of being in a awesome journey or something lol

  • Easily their best album since coming to Roadrunner. Excellent job. MM did an excellent job, but I really wish MP was back.

  • First time i listen to this song,

    i just want to cry,

    It's about Untold Love...

    Oh My God... ;((

  • great song to end an amazing album!

  • Dream theatre is just not about music. The lyrics are so touching and it has soul in it. I just lost my girl and i regret it because i was silent.

    The song says "Sad to think I never knew you were searching for the words For the moment to emerge Yet the moment never came"

    So go out there and tell her you love her if you really do!!

  • @technicalnote4t Sometimes even you're advice just doesn't work. It's Sad but True.

  • @impenetrable2 yeah man!! I hope they dont just read and say 'oh". I hope they read my comment and say,"Damn, this shouldnt happen to me" and express their love without waiting for the so called 'right time'. Coz right time itself is the time when you love her.

  • @technicalnote4t You're making it too easy...

  • @technicalnote4t Thank you for that comment. I think ill go for it!

  • @MrGnoopy All the best.

  • @technicalnote4t I just lost my girl too dude :(

  • @technicalnote4t

    Why does every.single.video for Dream Theater have some emo sob story BS in the top rated comments?

    This isn't an emo band. Go cry elsewhere.

  • @Brewzkier Dont look at the comment section then. Problem solved. Dont be such a negative person.

  • Ouch, 4:27 shows just how far LaBrie's voice has deteriorated. That sounded rough. 

  • @Brewzkier Nah, I think that's intentional.

  • @Brewzkier what the fuck are you talking about? that sounded amazing. and i just saw them live and the did this song acoustically and he fucking nailed it.