i just went to check the original singer's version of this performed live and there are more glitches made than AP's version it makes me wonder why there is a demand for perfection when the original is worse in many,many instances.
Kmusta na paiburong? Dto lng pla kta mkkita. Im really bothered w/this FITH perfromance coz im used to seeing Arnel always near perfect even when tired. I dont check any of Augerie's clips anymore. Not worth it. Tlagang wla syang binatbat kay AP. PANIS!! Pero kumbaga sa basketball game, if they want to keep their winning streak, they have to drop this song from their set list. Unless they can do better next time.
i think that arnel is just really very tired at this point in the tour. he is just human and like us he has his good and bad days. they've been touring since july (here in the states)and performing almost every night through rain and storm. just please give them a break. they're still the #1 band for me! cheers!!!!
No question he sounded great in WYLAW. He can't reach the notes and catching his breath in the middle of phrases on this song. Same YouTube clip. Stop using the it's just a crappy video excuse. Arnel is a good singer. But he is tired and maybe still not fully recovered. THAT is the (real and legitimate) reason.
Yes, me too! I was looking forward for Journey to play this song live. BUT, im kinda disappointed. Ive checked ALL vid clips of "Faith In The Heartland" & they're all the same. The band & Arnel OBVIOUSLY have a hard time playing this live. He STRUGGLED. If they still want to include this in their set, they have to give more justice to this wonderful song. Otherwise, just remove it from the setlist. Dont get me wrong. Im saying this with an OPEN MIND (& ears of course!).
This is LIVE music, Appreciate JOURNEY because they don't compromise or cut corners...this is what makes them great. Many fans have asked this song for a long time along with TDTWT,but when they sang it, still many complains (though every one is entitled to their own opinion). THIS IS LIVE MUSIC AND NOT A STUDIO MIX, critique of tone or the like imho, should be rungs down in reviewing how a group performed.
check out the first singer of this song Steve Augeri and you'll see that Arnel pretty much nailed it even in this vid. SA even has to change the inflection and tone of some parts. Just because of one night's performance you will ask the group to discard a song, check the version of this one in Sacramento 25sept08. Again some of us are basing it from a choppy video which doesn't do any justice whatsoever...
I was in the concert at shoreline, section 102 E17 12 rows from the front, dead center!. The sounds was way way better that this video! Arnel was in the zone on this song and the rest of the setlist.
This was recorded from a videocam probably from 800 feet away from the stage guys. I've been to one of their concerts and he was perfect. Then I saw the UT recording a couple of days later, it was worse than this one you're watching. Actually this one is not that bad. Try viewing those recorded from cell phones.
I agree! If u think otherwise, there must be something wrong with your ears. I maybe a staunch supporter/defender of Arnel & Journey but this song is simply difficult to perform live. The recording was great with the very haunting vocals of Arnel but with the wear & tear he suffers doing the tour, it becomes evident that he struggles on this one. As much as i like this song, it has to be removed from the setlist if they cant perform it at par.
Ang sa akin lang, to avoid hearing bad comments, medyo hinay na lang sana pagperform si Arnel. Avoid Fith dahil tenor killer ang song na yan. I know how hard it is to perform Fith esp when you are at the end stage of touring. We fans are the one hurting kung my negative comments like this. Peace for Pinoy fans. I didnt mean anything to sabotage journey. I still love them no matter what. In fact I viewed this video almost 10 times now and read comments how they feel about this one.
If you only in the concert,you will realize the difference.I was there.He have a golden voice.He is running ,dancing,jumping while singing,what you expect.He is just a human,this is live.We the crowd enjoy.
I felt this song was totally off. I am a fan of AP/Journey but this song (sorry) was not their best. I didnt really like it. Neal Schon's guitar was flat at 3:13 (It was very noticeable). They should have not include this in their setlist if they think its too strenous to perform because of their almost everynight tour. Fans will totally understand like me (my opinion.. to avoid embarassment).
unforgetable HI-5 from arnel
bisaya 2 years ago
Journey at shoreline 9-27-08 #4
watch my video's i took at shoreline
zakkrick 3 years ago
i was here. The first 3 songs were a little strained. Arnel sound tired and burned out in some of the songs. Still, i had a great time.
xtna2530 3 years ago
I was at this concert and AP sounded much better than this clip. He was great in this song.
beehive03 3 years ago
thanx for sharing Faith in the heartland love this song
ranbar193 3 years ago
i just went to check the original singer's version of this performed live and there are more glitches made than AP's version it makes me wonder why there is a demand for perfection when the original is worse in many,many instances.
paiburong 3 years ago
Kmusta na paiburong? Dto lng pla kta mkkita. Im really bothered w/this FITH perfromance coz im used to seeing Arnel always near perfect even when tired. I dont check any of Augerie's clips anymore. Not worth it. Tlagang wla syang binatbat kay AP. PANIS!! Pero kumbaga sa basketball game, if they want to keep their winning streak, they have to drop this song from their set list. Unless they can do better next time.
theBukolKing 3 years ago
i was der last nyt,.. i had fun watchng dis concert a lot people watched.. more power arnel!,..
artsikominder 3 years ago
i think that arnel is just really very tired at this point in the tour. he is just human and like us he has his good and bad days. they've been touring since july (here in the states)and performing almost every night through rain and storm. just please give them a break. they're still the #1 band for me! cheers!!!!
aypusaka 3 years ago
No question he sounded great in WYLAW. He can't reach the notes and catching his breath in the middle of phrases on this song. Same YouTube clip. Stop using the it's just a crappy video excuse. Arnel is a good singer. But he is tired and maybe still not fully recovered. THAT is the (real and legitimate) reason.
skyechas 3 years ago
Im just being objective. Im just giving a CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. No amount of bashing. Its for the good of the band... and for Arnel of course!!!
theBukolKing 3 years ago
Yes, me too! I was looking forward for Journey to play this song live. BUT, im kinda disappointed. Ive checked ALL vid clips of "Faith In The Heartland" & they're all the same. The band & Arnel OBVIOUSLY have a hard time playing this live. He STRUGGLED. If they still want to include this in their set, they have to give more justice to this wonderful song. Otherwise, just remove it from the setlist. Dont get me wrong. Im saying this with an OPEN MIND (& ears of course!).
theBukolKing 3 years ago
This is LIVE music, Appreciate JOURNEY because they don't compromise or cut corners...this is what makes them great. Many fans have asked this song for a long time along with TDTWT,but when they sang it, still many complains (though every one is entitled to their own opinion). THIS IS LIVE MUSIC AND NOT A STUDIO MIX, critique of tone or the like imho, should be rungs down in reviewing how a group performed.
jummon55 3 years ago
check out the first singer of this song Steve Augeri and you'll see that Arnel pretty much nailed it even in this vid. SA even has to change the inflection and tone of some parts. Just because of one night's performance you will ask the group to discard a song, check the version of this one in Sacramento 25sept08. Again some of us are basing it from a choppy video which doesn't do any justice whatsoever...
jummon55 3 years ago
I was in the concert at shoreline, section 102 E17 12 rows from the front, dead center!. The sounds was way way better that this video! Arnel was in the zone on this song and the rest of the setlist.
larcal75 3 years ago
This was recorded from a videocam probably from 800 feet away from the stage guys. I've been to one of their concerts and he was perfect. Then I saw the UT recording a couple of days later, it was worse than this one you're watching. Actually this one is not that bad. Try viewing those recorded from cell phones.
international159 3 years ago
I agree! If u think otherwise, there must be something wrong with your ears. I maybe a staunch supporter/defender of Arnel & Journey but this song is simply difficult to perform live. The recording was great with the very haunting vocals of Arnel but with the wear & tear he suffers doing the tour, it becomes evident that he struggles on this one. As much as i like this song, it has to be removed from the setlist if they cant perform it at par.
theBukolKing 3 years ago
Ang sa akin lang, to avoid hearing bad comments, medyo hinay na lang sana pagperform si Arnel. Avoid Fith dahil tenor killer ang song na yan. I know how hard it is to perform Fith esp when you are at the end stage of touring. We fans are the one hurting kung my negative comments like this. Peace for Pinoy fans. I didnt mean anything to sabotage journey. I still love them no matter what. In fact I viewed this video almost 10 times now and read comments how they feel about this one.
smalltownworld 3 years ago
That was painful to listen to.
skyechas 3 years ago
If you only in the concert,you will realize the difference.I was there.He have a golden voice.He is running ,dancing,jumping while singing,what you expect.He is just a human,this is live.We the crowd enjoy.
bhelen55 3 years ago
they did not embarass themselves in this song, again this is LIVE MUSIC, not a studio mix, these guys are just human
jummon55 3 years ago 2
I felt this song was totally off. I am a fan of AP/Journey but this song (sorry) was not their best. I didnt really like it. Neal Schon's guitar was flat at 3:13 (It was very noticeable). They should have not include this in their setlist if they think its too strenous to perform because of their almost everynight tour. Fans will totally understand like me (my opinion.. to avoid embarassment).
smalltownworld 3 years ago
great,,thanks for this...
unpluggme 3 years ago