Added: 4 years ago
From: jmtin016
Views: 55,186
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (362)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Drew is better! <3 <3 <3

  • they said that he sang on the second movie.

  • Zac Efron's voice is much better!

  • I Love drew but everytime i here Zac sing i get butterflies<3

  • omg Zac's picture when singing "breaking free"! <3.<3

    But anyways zac doesn't sing bad.! wither lip sing! lmao

  • im sorry but it all sounds like zac lmao

  • See, no one made fun of Zac when his voice was a little high, but we now find the need to torturer Bieber about it. smh.

  • this has break the ice.. thank you.

  • i love zac's authentic voice.. its for a real star voice. 

  • I love zac's voice <3<3

  • They mix the voices together, neither of them sing alone in the whole movie, even listening to this you can tell that the voices dont completely match the movies. They both are good, but the mix makes it better and fits the character of troy

  • I should of known my bro told me but I didnt beleive him, but They are both great:}

  • omg 2:24 is a hot pic of zac :D

  • i think Zac is a wonderful actor (and Hot) nut Drew have a very special and wonderful voice.

    So i like the two

  • Zac is so hot

  • The reason why zac didn't sing was becouse his voice changed and he was in "Hairspray"...Then they found Drew and like blendid their voices.....But Zac did sing in High school musical 2 and 3 :D

  • OH! That's why! Thanks for this! Now I'm not confused. :))

  • years ago,  my brother told me about this. but i was young and it made me sad that he didnt sing everything. so my brother pretended like he was kidding. but now i know the truth. [that they both sang].

  • Omd nver noticed this before awesome:}

  • Zac can sing and he has a good voice but Drews singing was more balanced and powerful. Like he had more control when he sang. So I understand why they'd blend it in. If you listen to HSM 1 and The other two, you can hear the difference between zacs voices. And I think cuz in number one, he wasn't as experienced in singing and his voice wasn't like fully developed right and stuff. But he got training and grew up a bit more and now he sounds amazing.

  • It's because drew could sing the higher parts but they wanted to give zac parts he could sing so it'd still be "his" part. Zac can sing, yes. But singing is Drew's career while acting is Zac's. So stop arguing. They are both good but meshing the two was the best for the movie.

  • I heard it was beacause it didn't sound good at the high notes, but I have no ide! :)

  • zac is singing drew is nothing like zac...

  • During HSM1 Zac's voice was not that good that's why he only sang a few lines on the soundtrack..

    But in HSM2 & 3, He was the one who sang all his parts.. I think because, while filming HSM1, disney had a voice lesson for Zac Efron for a preparation in both sequel.

  • @eumari13 is that true? where did you get that info?

  • @farfave14 Yes i think t's true.. hmmm. As you heard in the Start of something new and Everyday songs. His (Zac) voice change a lot.. it's not that great in the first song but in the last his voice really developed and it's amazing.:)

  • Zac voice is quite good.. But Drew's voice is really great..

    When I first heard HSM1 songs.. I was like "oh, there was something different on Breaking Free.. a few lines has a good sound while some parts was better especially those parts that has a higher range.. "

  • drew is a better singer, however zac's appearance is more appealing to girls, a key factor in a teen movie

  • wooow

    

  • ok zac admited that he didnt sing in hsm 1 he only did a few of them maybe just couple of lines soo drew seeley did sing for him and zac admitted it that someone was singing for him and isnt it enough that drew didnt get enough credit for what he did and all the credit goes to zac who didnt do anything ...drew seeley should have played the part of zac efron drew is oo much better that zac...zac efron is just white trash with good abs drew is better dont be stupid!

  • actually, zac efron's singing voice in all HSM series is actually th mixture of drew seeley's voice PLUS zac efron's.

  • HE'S JUST AS BAD AS BRITNEY SPEARS TOMMOROW HE'S GONNA HAVE A SHAVED HEAD

  • @yayamchic haha that was 2 days ago and does he?

  • drew forever!!!!!

  • COME ON PPL! zac can still sing! it's not his or Disney fault that his voice wasn't cooperating. so don't be all like " Omg! that was drew! why? this is dead! disney lied! blahblahblah!" no.

  • yeaah, they said in the first movie zacs voice wasn't strong enough for some parts of the songs.

  • At Breaking free zac sounded like he needed help

    thumbs up if u agree

  • someone pleasse tell me the story with this! im soo confused!!

  • @heyitsnotfriday14 look on hsm1 zac didnt have experience and his voice wasnt deep enough for some kind of notes so disney hired drew as the backup singer or complement singer so drew recoreded the difficult onotes and zac the easier ones,,,, but in hsm2 zac's voice was DEEPER and he had more experience... so disney rrealizaed that they dont need drew anymore... so in HSM2 AND HSM3 is ZAC SINGING! the only movie drew helped zac's voice was in hsm1

  • @jimeniuxxobo ohhhhh okay..that makes sense!! thank you(:

  • @heyitsnotfriday14 u welcomee bby!! love ur nickname seriously loving it

  • @heyitsnotfriday14 u welcome bbyy,,,, love ur user name

  • @heyitsnotfriday14 ZAC EFRON LIPSANG FOR HSM 1 BUT THREATENED TO QUIT IF THEY DIDN'T LET HIM SING

  • the previous two songs sung by drew r much better than by zac

  • Drew is better, but everyone sung by ZAC  is also good. but i think drew's range varies indeed

  • this killed high school musical for me as a kid

  • Drew singing as Troy, Zac acting as Troy.. Two Troys? Why don't they just let Drew play the whole part of Troy and not only the singing voice? He has the looks after all.. But, on the other hand, I also like Zac as Troy..and that's the reason I watched HSM..and also the voice..Oh, nevermind!! XD

  • zac sings cute but drew sings great. hahaha if that makes sense? xD

  • even when this came out (i was little) i could telll there were two voices, i mean the sounds are so diffrent but the same.

  • the only reason drew sang was because zacs voice started to change during recording so they used drew

  • It's easy to tell that Drew's voice was blended with Zac's (duh, why do you think they sent Drew in Zac's place when he wasn't available for the HSM tour?) .....but Zac is so gorgeous it doesn't matter if he can sing :P

  • Zac is really a bad singer b4 HSM happened and after HSM 1 he had his voice lesson...

  • I just found this out today... OMFG, Holy shit... Disney kinda lied to me, now I feel like I got raped and betrayed (I know I'm so exaggerating the matter), either way it kinda ruined the "Troy Bolton's singing career" for me. Yeah, in my mind Troy had a career in singing...

  • if anything i think they both have there own sections on different songs, if anything drew probably was brought in to hit the higher notes being more of a tenor, and having better quality.

  • I knew it that there was a lot of difference between a scene and another.. type of voice? hmm.. but I forgot about that... that beutiful voice came from Drew and I didn't even know him!! I feel horrible right now :(

  • (In 2005, Seeley began working with established producer Ray Cham and together they wrote “Getcha Head in the Game” for Disney’s quadruple platinum High School Musical soundtrack. His voice had been blended Zac Efron's voice for the character of Troy Bolton in High School Musical) There you have it folks....

  • Nobody ever said that it was just Drew Seeley. They combined both voices together.

  • drew is the best !!!

  • Lol..i really come to wonder what you guys are trying to prove here?? Proving here doesn't really make any changes...some would still come to believe that drew seeley sang all the songs...The fact is that Drew has a more smoother voice than Zac..Both of them are great singers~~

  • hmm i guess drew sings better but my heart is for zac! :D

  • they used drew for the parts that zac couldnt sing well, he is not a expirenced singing so he couldnt hit the notes correctly...i know, i sing

  • drew just sang for part in high school musical ONE! but ZAC EFRON sang in the rest of the movies

  • they took the voices together and blended them.

    drew made it sound better.

  • drew seeley is HOT AND HE CAN SING. i bet that no.. zac efron CANT SING

  • Now.. Zac Has a good voice, he improved :)

  • They both sound good. Just wish Zac actually did his part on singing the whole dang song!

  • This Drew person is way better.

  • ZAAAAAAAAAAC is better

  • Drew

  • drew is way..... better than zac , zac cant sing

  • yeah drew is better than zac

  • TOTALLY DREW SEELEY! ZAC EFRON IS A RETARDED PERVERT! HAHA DREW SEELEY IS HOT AND A GOOD SINGER

  • Drew is wayyy better!!

  • zac efron is a better singer sorry 2 anyone who like drew its true

  • drew is so much better. i saw him in concert and hes amazing live too

  • drew has a way betta voice than zac. when zac sings he sounds nasal

  • zac better :)

  • Drew is a way better singer than Zac

  • Drew is a better singer than zac but it is hard because they almost have the same voice.from colleen

  • drew>zac :P

  • Hmm...

    Drew is better.

    His voice is better.

    And I love him! :D

  • drew's voice is better -_-

  • I think Everyday is in High School Musical 2!! Drew sings just Troy in HSM1!

  • Zac CANT SING HIGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AHHHHHHH I NEVER KNEW THIS!

  • yeah but zac is so much hotttter!

    he isnt as popular now, but still sexxy (:

  • drew all da way!

  • Drew is sooo much better!!!

  • i luv drew seeley hes soo hot i jus luvv himm i luv him i want to marry him omg i luv himmmmm

  • this is pretty legit i think ;)

  • Lol i like zac's voice a lil better, He sang in hsm 2. lol

  • Zac's voice sounds all miffed and muffed up! Drew foreva!!!!!!!!!!!!! P.S Selena gomez and Drew seeley r so made for each other! to bad he is like 10 years older!

  • drew is so much better

  • I LOVE ZACS VOICE!!! it makes me melt everytime i hear it!!! AHH! :D zanessa 4 ever

  • Drew is so much better!

  • Eh? I always thought that they cast Zac first, then realized his voice range didn't go high enough for most of the HSM1 songs, so used Drew for the high parts.

    It's not that Zac couldn't sing. His voice range just didn't fit.

  • ahhh youurr sooo right!!!!! oh my goshh i never would of known!!!! i love dres voice (=

  • Zac rules... In HSM2 and HSM3 Zac sings...

  • Now that I hear the voices it does sound like drew is singing in the movie

  • well he did im hsm 1. i don't know why though... zac efron probably had he's voice break i'm guessing. cause some boys only get it at like 17

  • Drew, eres el mejor, inigualable, saludosss..

  • Ther is no HSM2 concert but if it will be, Zac will be ther!

  • The productor of High School Musical said that zac has voice but his voice should be performed....In High School Musical 1, zac sing just the bigining and the final on "Start Of Something New"and "Breaking Free". In the free time between High School Musical 1 and High School Musical 2 Zac took sing lessons...In High School Musical 2, the productor knew that zac is ready to sing alon.....So, in High School Musical 2 and High School Musical 3 zac sing alon without Drew..In HSM2 concert zac sing

  • i adore drew's voice!

  • thx 4 the info because i heard lots of people saying zac never sang in hsm 1 and i love drew's voice!

  • lol

  • La voz de Drew Seeleyes mas dulce!!!!!!!!

  • hey i understand why zack uses drew seely voice if u listen carefully zac's voice zac's voice is a little lower tone then drew n drew voice is slidely higher a bit

  • They chose Drew because he can sing well, better than Zac. If you notice, Zac sings pretty simple parts, on the other hand, Drew's range is larger and can sing higher and lower notes.

  • i adore drew's voice . and he is hot .

  • oh dang, now that i know it was drew seeley, i realize his voice is wwaaayyy better than zac's.

  • they put almost all of drews in hsm1 as zac couldnt reach the high notes bless him =] but he sang the bits it says in this video and when he's at gabriellas house he sounds completely different to drew so its kinda weird but zac sang all of hsm2 & 3 and hairspray & he has a great voice!!!

  • OMG..!!!!

  • drew seeley all the wayy!!!

  • both

  • why couldnt just let drew be in hsm instead of zack? obviously drew can sing and act and his great looking, so why not put him in the movie instead of zack is they didnt want him to sing ?

    GOD BLESS

  • Seriously, give up. Zac Efron made an official statement saying that he didn't sing in the first one, it even says in the credits of the soundtrack (newer publications of it, not when it first came out). Everyone involved has confirmed he did not sing in HSM.

  • drew seeley is hot!!ü

  • i think that in the movie they mixed the voice so there wasnt much difference to his talking and singing voice, but oh well still a hsm fan, both sing very good!

  • é muito parecida a voz dos dois .

  • i think i like Drews voice better & obviously they didnt think that zacs voice was strong enough so they hired drew for some spots

  • its both of them!

  • um actually zacs and drews voices where blended together for the songs so its actually both of them in the movie

  • their voices sound the same in the movie, it sounds like its only zac, but i love drew seeley!

  • thats why drew took zacs place on the hsm tour

  • Drew Seeley, only sang because, Vannessa Hudgen's voice is too high, and Zac Efron's doesn't reach Vannessa's Pitch.

  • i love drew seeley !

  • drew seeleys voice is a bit better then zac s but zack is still good but thats only my opinon

  • yah your right

  • Comment removed

  • I like Drew Seeleys voice better because its stronger. That's just my opinion!

  • what would be nice if they said the same lyrics and than we could hear it better but yes there is a difference

  • drew a bitch

  • Me gusta Drew Seeley! xD... Zac iwal!! pero mas DREW!

  • Drew's voice and zac are blend....

  • y did drew sing..!!!

    and btw drew is sooooooo much better than zack..! i ♥ drew..!!!!! xx

  • zac sounds more honest then drew!

  • no zac's voice is better :)

  • Drew's voice s better!!!!

  • Zac's voice sounds nicer.

  • drew's singing is more mature and more theatrical.

    Zac's is more juvenile. and that probably why they picked zac. (they needed a younger guy)

  • for me there the same lol

  • i hear yah! [:

  • Your talking about HSM1, why is "Everyday" in there then?

  • i love drew's voice...but all the credit went to high mainteneced zac efron.

    drew sounds sexy....zac will never be a good singer to me.

  • If you "listen closely" to the breaking free part Drew sounds EXACTLY like the scene in the movie.

  • Zac is actor and he sing perfect!

  • the reason why it's drew and zac singing is because zac had been cast in HSM1 after the songs were written and the songs (that were written for a tenor) were somewhat out of his baritone vocal range!!!! do you understand now!!!!!!!!!!!!! he had a diferent voice type, ok, thats why drew had to sing, and i like them both!!!!!

  • oh now i get it

  • ok drew totally sung in hms 1 but zac sung in 2 and 3

  • This totally proves to me that Drew sang for High School Musical 1. If you remember, HSM1 all the songs the voice is more like soar one(Drew's), not like those child-like voice(Zac's). Anyway, Drew's singing skills is much more better and experienced than Zac's. I support Drew all the way. Tha fact (that drew sang in HSM1) cant be changed(:

  • Drew is better. I mean, he's playing Prince Erik in Broadway's The Little Mermaid. Broadway requires and amazing voice. So, in my opinion Drew wins. And yes, Zac did sing. I heard it.

  • all that they have done is joint drew and zacs so its part zacs voice and part drews

  • drew is kinda better

  • so drew sang all the hard stuff

  • YAH IT SUCKS ALL THE CREDIT GOS TO ZAC

  • all the higher notes, yeah, that's what Drew sang since Zac's voice still wasn't completely done changing.

  • exactly...which makes drew a way better singer than zac. all zac had to do was act......BADLY.

  • well thats your opinion..im not gonna argue over it

  • @crazychel and higher notes. Drew's voice is higher than Zac's voice.

  • SAME

  • Drew is a better singer

  • Drew is better.

  • drew does sing better

  • Both zac and drew have good voices. Different but good. I like Drew's more, but I know perfectly well that Zac can sing too. And that's what they do!

    Good on Zac Efron to want to sing for himself in HSM2 and 3.

  • Zac did sing in hsm1 but drew did the overlay to get zacs voice up but in hsm he told them if couldnt sing his self that he wouldnt do hsm2 or 3

  • But everyday is from HSM 2 and zac sings there all the songs self, right ??

  • oh gosh~~!!!

    its almost the same

  • Zac's voice is okay. He's just more of an actor. I feel Drew's voice is the best. And there are more reasons why I like Drew (Really cares about fans, writes own stuff, ...)

  • OK I LOE ZAC EFRON! But u guys are acting like selfish Brats because that is DREWS VOICE........... NO! U LKISTEN CAREFULLY. You played different parts of the song!!!!! ZAC CANT SING ALL HE CAN DO IS ACT AND LOOK AMAZINGLY HOT!!!!!! so GET A LIFE THIS IS ALL DREW

  • Zac can sing! His voice was mixed with Zacs! Both them sang the in the movies but they mixed it together! Zac can sing! He proved it in HSM2 && HSM3............... SO SHUT UP! xD

    -SawBaby

  • HAVE YOU HEARD ZAC SING ON ROBOT CHICKEN HE IS SOOO GOOD  lmao, im being serious the video is called 'zaccy say wat??' lmao watch it ;]

  • seriously stop underestimating famous people we are all the same people in this world.!

  • drew has a warmer and calmer voice... zac has a nice voice too,... but his vocal range is higher than drew...

  • their voices was mixed and it's official version!! Zack was 19 it was 3 years ago!

  • zac wasnt 15 when he filmed hsm u idiot

  • Sure Drew is better than Zac, the voice of, zac is very nasal, has a beautiful voice but not close enough or the voice of Drew ... Besides being a great actor and dancer ... is better than many that are good ...

  • there is no diference

    zac uses his nose

    drew uses all voice

  • you guys are so mean. never underestimate drew.