甄妮 - 楓葉情 [045]

[l6632]

說句良心話，鳳飛飛唱得比較好聽，這首歌當初若由甄妮唱，應該就­沒這麼紅

[tsaorientalam]

Both of them are powerful~!

[tsaorientalam]

Both of them are the best singers in Asia. They are different, we can not comapare them with each other, Different style, different voice, But, They all have the best on their own.

[sky09242005]

她與鳳飛飛皆是一時愉亮~~不能以偏概全! 我只感覺各有千秋..論意境鳳飛飛有特別簡單的親切.論歌聲甄妮­也絕非無法抗衡

[izangke]

i listen so many times. Jenny sings very good in this song. i like her version.

[kkll02]

i prefer feng fei fei version although i admit both singer sung well in their way. But this song suit feng fei fei voice better as she portray it well.

[a01818792]

聽了2種版本以後只有一個感想

甄妮沒放感情 鳳飛飛有放感情

[Tkhs1010]

如果鳳飛飛先錄製，甄妮再唱，當然選用了不同的風格，

如果甄妮先唱，或者最終發行的版本選擇甄妮才是明智之舉‧

[izangke]

jenny's voice better than fei fei.... fei fei's voice is too old

[MrOliverStanley]

@izangke

Pls don't insult veteran singers! Fong Fei Fei is also a very good singer. Both are good, and each of us hv our own opinions.

[izangke]

i give my vote to Jenny

[bernardeng]

Give this to Feng fei Fei. Jenny's voice is too sharp and highly pitched for this. The former's husky and medium-low voice is just superb.

[dalesongtsu]

妮聲音如金石冰淇淋,SWEET ,SWEET,SWEET,,,,,,,,,,,,

[lorky2004]

作曲者,也是電影的音樂總監駱明道已有提到~

楓葉情當初是按照鳳飛飛的聲線替她量身打照的歌曲

後來片商方面又接洽甄妮 於是歌曲鬧雙包

為何片商當初又去接洽甄妮 而最後決定是由鳳飛飛主唱的2個關鍵

我看只有出的主事者最清楚~

我雖然是甄妮的忠實歌迷,但是就事論事,我覺得甄妮一再提這件事­很無聊

而且我也覺得鳳飛飛唱真的更適合!!

[wuzlaohu]

@lorky2004 這首歌還是甄妮唱得好! 各有優點!

[yadnussyl]

甄妮有天份，飛飛好技巧。

[tan00002]

Thanks so much. I heard this song when I arrived from Hong Kong to Paris in 1977.

[tan00002]

She is one of the best singer at the 70s

[Ferio3399]

@tan00002

I think Jenny stil IS one of the best singer today!

[CCCPPY]

她唱得明亮高亢　同時也略顯嬌嫩　而鳳飛飛則唱得情感酣暢　意境表達得淋漓盡致

最終發行的版本選擇鳳飛飛是明智之舉　

[lotusalanwang]

凤飞飞唱的比她好得多了！

[wongyion2001]

最愛甄妮!!