Heather MacDonald - The Costs of Illegal Immigration

[jupiter919]

Immigration has to be controlled. If you call that racist and I don't care how many languages you speak and of you education, if you refute this fact, it's purely ideological and nothing to do with rationality. The US citizen has allowed and paid for millions of illegal immigrants and have not complained until know due to economic reasons. I think a "thank you is in order" for allowing people escaping there own country that refuses to take care of them.

[erik4727]

This lady has absolutely no experience, completely unfounded, disturbed, and from the sound of it hasn't been laid in ...too long. You don't like our shitty immigration laws? Get out! Fucking idiot.

[thebobbyblock]

The immigration in humans is a natural thing. And is this natural desire is what has made possible the men in the origins spray throw to the whole planet. Everybody has been an immigrant. . In contemporaneous time injustice is ones of major cause of immigration  still the men is for nature an immigrant.

. God does not made differences between persons. This declaration it knocks down frontiers, and others.

[jupiter919]

@thebobbyblock Yes that was true thousand of years ago, but today governments exist to take care of its people. Today corrupt governments squander there money on themselves rather than their people. The individual illegal immigrant should not be blamed, instead blame the governments that allow the exploitation if its people. US citizens and illegal immigrants are put at risk. The day when the money runs out to support illegal immigrants is soon approaching.

[thebobbyblock]

The immigration in humans is a natural thing. And is this natural desire is what has made possible the men in the origins spray throw to the whole planet. Everybody has been an immigrant. . In contemporaneous time injustice is ones of major cause of immigration still the men is for nature an immigrant.

Now remember fellows. God does not made differences between persons. This declaration it knocks down frontiers, and others.

[thebobbyblock]

The immigration in humans is a natural thing. And is this natural desire is what has made possible the men in the origins spray throw to the whole planet. Everybody has been an immigrant. . In contemporaneous time injustice is ones of major cause of immigration but still the men is for nature an immigrant.

Now remember fellows. God does not made differences between persons. This declaration it knocks down frontiers, and others.

[greenjeansmjr]

We are watching nation building happen in our southern states.

[javi75tube]

It seems that racist like you so ignorant and arrogant forgot that your parents or grandparents are immigrant. if the Hispanics look like irish it will be ok for you. Right? I can't believe Forbes allows ignorant writers like you!! Racista!!

[BoxGuy1951]

@javi75tube - YOU are the RACIST . La Raza loving little criminal cowardly cocksucker that you are , you failed to determine your own countries demise and have crept into MY countyr to STEAL all that you can before WE kick your CRIMINAL TAN asses out forever. FUCK YOU Pedro !

[javi75tube]

@BoxGuy1951 you are so ignorant. No arguments, no facts. California, Arizona, Texas were stolen last century. So you piece of sh..wants to argue go to school get educated and then learn how to get good arguments. Ignorant!!

[BoxGuy1951]

@javi75tube - The Gadsden Purchase , The Treaty of Guadalupe - Hidalgo , US Federal Troops defeating Santa Anna with much blood being spilt on both sides - all of that never happened right ? Start with " See Spot Run " and then within just a few years mommy will take you by the hand all the way to the Library and help you to find the " big books ". YOU are simply IGNORANT.

[javi75tube]

@BoxGuy1951 My mommy is not so fuck up like yours telling you stories about hidalgo, the treaty of Guadalupe. you dick. your library probably needs more donation, and get less movies and more books. You triple ignorant!!

[BoxGuy1951]

@javi75tube - Your mommy should avoid inbreeding and will not end up with something with an 87 IQ such as yourself.

Those documents are available in Washington DC for anyone ( even you Pedro ) to see for themselves.

How does it feel to have EVERYTHING that you comment on dismissed as pure ranting by a racist little cocksucker such as yourself ?

[javi75tube]

@BoxGuy1951 ok willie, wang, dick, gaylord, whatever is your name. You are probably in a small town in New Mexico, and you are angry because Maria didn't like you and you are telling me that is in Washington D.C. so tell me something pedazo de marica que tu papa te lo chupa y tu madre se coge a tus amigos por gratis. you coudl search this information in the library de tu culo en D.C. take your time looking your dictionary in the library of your mommy

[BoxGuy1951]

@javi75tube - Your lack of IQ is showing again pedro !

I will leave it to the YouTube community at large to determine your overwhelming ignorance and RACIST cocksucker behavior.

[javi75tube]

@BoxGuy1951 Still looking the dictionary. IQ? do you want me to translate it for you wang, dick, willie, winnie? so couldn't translate it .Go and ask to a Hispanic and show what you wrote. I think you are stupid.. so good luck with your IQ and you can put it right u.... malacas!! you won't find that word in Spanish. Catalavene?? of course not

[javi75tube]

@BoxGuy1951 don't forget to drink your milk idiot!!

[javi75tube]

@javi75tube hello cocksucker.. did u improve your Spanish? I haven't drank milk yet because I am not gay like u who likes men milk. Is ur stupid high IQ helped u to figure out what I wrote in Spanish? It doesn't seem like. I will write u in one year to know if there is an improvement...

[jupiter919]

@javi75tube ....and the Spanish Conquistadors stole South, Central America, and Mexico from the native Indians, who are now treated as third class citizens by the Spanish descendants. California, Arizona and Texas were not stolen, those areas were saved!

[javi75tube]

@jupiter919 oh I didn't know the 40,000 mexican troops killed by Americans during wars in the 1800's because of gold in California, slavery to indians to work in mines, and exploitation by whites, I didn't know they felt saved,you probably think the same with the atomic bombs. Spanish conquistadors were as horrible as the Americans who stole the lands and killed people, and many of them are illegal in this country. You have to excuse me my English,it is my fifth language, and I am an immigrant.

[NorthEastliberaldem]

Most illegals work in the food and housekeeping industry that's why Americans are so fat fast food places on every corner

[andypazin]

The cost of you wiping your ass is 400 billion a year haha. Italians rule

[ferrarriguy]

Unpaid costs for treating illegals has directly caused the closings of nearly 100 hospitals in California alone.

Illegals consume nearly $69 BILLION in social services annually.

Children of illegal immigrants cost public schools $28.6 Billion annually.

Illegal immigrant labor depresses wages for American citizens by 200 BILLION a year.

The cost of illegal immigration to the American taxpayer is $55,000 PER illegal.

The total cost annually is over is a whopping $ 338 BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR

[kekler101]

each illegal murders 100 white cute little babies!!! each illegal costs us fourty one trillion dollars!!!

Shuuuuut the fuuuuck up.

[four4vizslas]

We all must acknowledge that U.S. land originally belonged to Native Americans. We also know that according to various TREATIES, "Indians" (I like N.A. better) recieve TREATY LAW (health care, fast-track to financial assistance, & other CONCESSIONS). This issue is still under debate. I am sympathetic to Native Americans over law-breakers. Emergency Rooms ARE GETTING PACKED. Federal dollars reimburse the ER's under "Fed Law" providing medical stabilization. REWARD FOLLOWERS OF IMIGRATION LAW!

[historyscoper]

What if poof, all Mexicans and Americans become one? Google "Megamerge Dissolution Solution" to read how, within 5 years.

[conwict7]

...no.

[shnikez]

your such a crazy lady!!! Illegal Aliens in hospitals???? Like they would EVEN go to a fucking hospital!!! Plus you keep on complaining that this is "your land" boo hoo, your the fucking illegal immigrant!!! your the alien stealing INDIAN LAND!!!! give it back and THEN you can complain you fucking KUNT ASS BITCH!!!

[ferrarriguy]

indians get MILLIONS of taxpayers dollars ever year. what are they comlining about? Stop indian welfare, make them sober up and get jobs.

[Metalownz09]

it was there land they deserve it

[Metalownz09]

fuck u whore. they can go to the hospital bitch. didnt u hear her. there is little enforcement of illegal immigration in this country. we took over this land.

[agentc73]

If the neighbor showed up at your house, because he lost his job, or yours is better, is it YOUR responsibility to house him, feed him, and pay for his health care and education? Because that's basically what you are saying.

So, can I assume there is NO homeless in your city, because they all live with you?

[crpdm1965]

SUE MEXICO !

[stealthgerm]

what of the people that hire them?sue them ,fine them,boycot them .ice need not raid they need to jail the ones that hire them be they the military or fastfood restraunts.

[LaRazaRacism]

Many Latinos within our community suffer from the idea that we are victims. As a result, we love to cry racism, our most popular attack toward anyone non-Hispanic. However, we then become highly sensitive and defensive when our very own racist, ethno-centric ideology is publicized. Education and freeing ourselves from victimhood will strengthen our community. Be sure to watch these educational videos!

[fastinbulvis]

Yep. Many Jews look at Anti-Immigration as Anti-Semitism.

They try to align the two to make a Pro-Immigration position unthinkable.

Unless it comes in the harmless for that Heather MacDonald presents it.

That's why she backed down from that one guy, what's his name? Medved? Anyway, he was Jewish and he tried to intimidate Heather MacDonald into backing away from saying what she should have said - that Latino Culture is INFERIOR. But she can't. That's how Jews operate.

[pitbullexpress]

however indirectly, though often enough, directly, the elimination of the White population.

What's the solution?

No More Mr. Niceguy

It's that simple.

[pitbullexpress]

EVERYTHING they have into the gradual and permanent displacement of Whites, with the exception of Obedient Shabass Goy.

You can not fight them being timid and kind and you will never get a word in if you don't since they control the Media.

So they KNOW they are provoking a reaction that will justify wholesale slaughter on Whites. No one is calling for Shooting Immigrants on the Border? Yes. But the Immigrants and their cheerleaders (enablers in the Media, Politics, Education) ARE calling -

[pitbullexpress]

Heather, you just don't get it (actually, she does, but that's why she can't DO anything about it).

The people who are in Power who are Pro-Immigration - I'm not talking about the Public Faces, I'm talking about the Button Pushers - are almost entirely Jewish.

Through Political Correctness, Multi-Culturalism (whose critique says the West and All Whites are a Pathology) through Affirmative Action, September 11th, Mass Immigration, and BOTH Obama/McCain (who they control) are putting ---------

[adama0731]

Heather MacDonald and Michelle Malkin are the kind of women that America needs.

[mrluke13]

...TO GET RID OF .

[BoomerNavy70]

By the way, this woman is is the type of woman every American guy should date, she is quite attractive.

[BoomerNavy70]

This situation is getting ready to reach critical mass and the American people are suffering for it.

Consider this; This is a double edged sword. First we have the Mexican government full of corruption and graft and not caring about their own people, and then we have the companies in America that entice them to come here by offering them jobs.

It is not the fault of the illegals it is the fault of our own citizens for giving them jobs. If you cut off the head of the snake the snake dies.

[jessi14ef]

But if we go way back in time the illegal immigration has been going on forever and there was a time that the ones that are now native americans came to this country to look for help because the situation in their country was bad but the people that lived here before didnt have a chance to protect what was theirs, Immigrants dont want to take over, they dont want a war against americans. The only want to be something.

[jessi14ef]

Plus this is a country were being successful is easier than other places. As long as you study and decide to make something out of yourself you. Americans shuldnt need jobs like working in the farms or mcdonalds. The reason illegal immigrants do is cause in their country doctors and teachers get paid about the same thing or alot of them just lack education so they come here to try to succeed and help their families. Im proud of americans for making the country the way it is.

[mic112244]

Of those executed on death row, whites have the second highest population represented, 34%. This pattern is also consistent with the current death row population, which stands at 45.5% white, the highest population on death row.

[adama0731]

Whites account, according to a 2006 demographic study,for 73.9% of the population; therefore, they are actually underrepresented on DEath Row.

[freakazoidodo]

Actually, the percentage is more around 60% because your figure includes mestizos and other mixed people and Middle Easterners.

Anyway, MacDonald is seen as an outsider by the Religious Right faction of the GOP because she's an atheist. While the membership of irreligious people is less controversial in other conservative parties in other rich nations, the GOP will make a big mistake by permitting the RR to have as much influence as it does today, since that would deter non-Christians.

[GustavusAdolphus1]

She didn't really provide any statistics, but her argument for solving the problem was excellent. All reasonable people agree, America needs to do something about Mexico's passive war, but few can actually define what they mean. That is, "America" is very nebulous term. Further, most assume it's just something politicians will take care of if they hear enough clamour. Actually, it starts with the individual. We need to be more conscious consumers/voters, and be more direct with out politicians.

[DelinquentFaith]

Send every illegal immigrant back home and nothing will improve for the average American. Jobs will continue to go abroad, tax money for the rich to feast on, and our HUGE military budget will continue to swallow up our resources. I am latino and I hope they send the illegals all back to see who the next scape goat will be. Who are you gonna blame next America? wake the F up!

[jessi14ef]

i dont agree the way you state your opinion at all but in a way something is true right now the country is going under a big economy problem but not to blame on the illegal immigrants. There are alot that come to this country to help and then leave. The reason alot of them decide to live here is cause they know once they leave coming back is hard.

[jessi14ef]

this comment was for delinquent faith

[reg4321]

I am Hispanic too Delinquent and I hope illegals are deported. Of course they are not the only reason why problems exist in America. However, some problems will be resolved if the illegal immigration problem is dealt with.

[utube9000]

reg4321 - yes, I agree. If the illegals are deported, Anglo Americans will not resent the legal Hispanics (who are currently being all lumped together)

[junkm452]

BUILD THE FENCE!

Even with immigration laws enforced, many illegal aliens would stay to do construction / custodial / restaurant / yard work, or day labor for cash. Don't forget the underground economy, prostitution, selling drugs, aiding and harboring illegal aliens, gang "protection" and other rackets.

Big meat packing plants and retail stores are only the tip of the iceberg of "undocumented workers." What's below the water line, where you can't see it, is what will sink the ship of state.

[BobLarrabee]

You don't need a fence. Simply target greedy businesses, and the rest will follow. In Arizona, they're cracking down. First offense = suspension of business license. Second offense = revocation of license.

[befranklintoo]

The First Nations think everybody is a invader otherwise known as immigrate with dangerous motives to the earth.

[neotoy]

"Illegal" Immigration is only possible because of illegal employment opportunities. If policy makers just focused on requiring citizenship for employment the immigration problem would not exist. Greed/cheap labor is the real source of this problem, not immigration laws.

[subversive]

neotoy, you head the nail on the head

[jackferwerda]

couldn't have been said better!! gee gosh why are policy makers not sticking it to big business criminals instead of going after the mexicans? the choice between sending a rich criminal to jail or a poor criminal to jail is not a choice it all for politicians.

[BobLarrabee]

Of course. They only come here at all because greedy businesses want a source of cheap near-slave labor.  If they couldn't get jobs here, they wouldn't come at all.

The businesses benefit by paying far less than they could pay a citizen. The immigrants benefit because even the bum deal they get here is better than at home. The whole thing is an alliance of the Rich and Poor against the Middle Class. Free labor simply can't compete against Slave Labor.

[americanliberal09]

@BobLarrabee no it's not buisnesses that's causing this. welfare is creating the problems.

welfare destroys productivity it make naitive americans more lazy and the illegals can take the jobs for less.

america have always welcome foreigners except the illegals ones.

[erik4727]

@neotoy mistaken you could not be. Greed is the primary reason, but immigration laws contribute greatly. we NEED comprehensive immigration reform.

[americanliberal09]

@neotoy cheap labor laws are not the problem. the federal goverment did not do anything to stop illegals from coming. they say they will secure the borders but they failed. that's it bring the troops home and secure the borders. and get rid of welfare too so that americans can start working instead of relying on illegal to do all the dirty work. replubicans and democrates failed to see this.