I actually prefer the Lp version by Phil Harris with Camarata. (Disneyland DQ-1333). Camarata's arrangements are so much livelier and better than what was used in the film.
I think I prefer the version they used. This sounds like something you'd hear on one of those stupid "Hit Crew" records where they ruin classic Disney songs and cartoon themes (look for them on iTunes).
It definitely wasn't Al singing. It was probably a black trumpet player, as Floyd wouldn't have trusted a white one to attempt to be hip, unless it was Wingy Manone or Jack Sheldon...
Al Rinker was Bing Crosby's original singing partner. Paul Whiteman added Harry Barris to the group to form The Rhythm Boys.
I doubt that the second singer is the same person playing the trumpet, as the timing between them is too close. I'm not familiar with Al Rinker's voice after the late 1920s, but as he was a singer professionally, it is possible that the second singer is him.
Where do you find this junk;that's so cool!
starlaasmith 4 months ago
I actually prefer the Lp version by Phil Harris with Camarata. (Disneyland DQ-1333). Camarata's arrangements are so much livelier and better than what was used in the film.
gerryu21220 6 months ago
@gerryu21220 I agree, that was a dynamite version, as was the album arrangement of O'MALLEY THE ALLEY CAT, which made that song a MUCH better song.
hustonhuddleston 6 months ago
I think I prefer the version they used. This sounds like something you'd hear on one of those stupid "Hit Crew" records where they ruin classic Disney songs and cartoon themes (look for them on iTunes).
MichaelSar12IsBack 6 months ago
Interesting bit of trivia: The line about catnip and milk was put into the Disney roadshow musical "On The Record" during it's short-lived run.
DisneyFan16672 6 months ago
I love the Aristocrats and this lost demo of the awesome song just makes my night. :)
JojoMonReturns91 6 months ago
It definitely wasn't Al singing. It was probably a black trumpet player, as Floyd wouldn't have trusted a white one to attempt to be hip, unless it was Wingy Manone or Jack Sheldon...
hustonhuddleston 6 months ago
Al Rinker was Bing Crosby's original singing partner. Paul Whiteman added Harry Barris to the group to form The Rhythm Boys.
I doubt that the second singer is the same person playing the trumpet, as the timing between them is too close. I'm not familiar with Al Rinker's voice after the late 1920s, but as he was a singer professionally, it is possible that the second singer is him.
mayerson 6 months ago