I've been listening to t.A.T.u. for years (since I was in elementary school) and it's weird how no one knows about them. I'm in college now and when ppl ask me what's my fav band I tell them t.A.T.u. Then they get this weird look on their face and it pisses me off how this band is underrated! seriously?! more ppl know about dumbass lady gaga (which is not worth the gum under my shoes). I've been trying to promote this group on my own and it's hard. We ALL need to unit to help promote! TATU ROCKS
I like so much to listen again and again at their songs...I'd like to get them back together because I want to hear new music...good music...the best music...the music of t.a.T.u !
treat people with respect!! they will treat ya with respect too !! treat every person so! doesn't matter if they are black withe gay lesbian bie or somethin else!!!! treat with RESPECT!
They are THE MOST UNFORGETTABLE band. They were very controversial. And I'm DAMN sure that they have helped a lot of GAY people around the world. That includes me. If it wasn't for them, I wouldn't have had the courage to to tell everyone about my sexuality. LOVE OURSELVES!!!!
My boyfriend and I can relate to t.A.T.u. so much. Everyone thinks that it's wrong of us to be together, but we keep our heads held high. Every song by them makes me think him. <3 =) t.A.T.u. Forever
who gives shit about their sexuallty, they were not lesbians god dam it now get over it. however they both were cute together but sigh, they dont sing together anymore
@TRchotbal I know, unfortunately they have said Waste Management is their last album together and the WM remix album will be it, then they're going solo. Sad really, but maybe it's time. I say, go for it and thanks for giving us such great albums and music. Go Tatu!!!
@The4logos EXACTLY! But I found them a few years ago and I loved their cd but i then realized that they never really had much besides it. and barely anyone know them
@RuckalltheFules hahaha all im saying is they were an amazing band who had shitty promo and the fact they had to act like lesbians...i dont get it and if it was to appeal to men...eh seems to not work to well. I just think they need a kick ass comeback AS THEMSELVES with better promotion and marketing
They are still friends but they knew that t.A.T.u had it's ending because it wasn't anything new and exciting anymore. So now they're working on there solo projects :P
@iTrollThis: YES!!!!!!!!!! Almost everyone in my town either hates them for being lesbians (when they're not), think they stink at singing (just from hearing Yulia yell "NOT GONNA GET US" or Lena yell "THIS IS NOT ENOUGH"!). Or they don't know them.
I'm pretty much the ONLY t.A.T.u. fan in my one square mile town.
@iTrollThis Well....it's just the anti-gays that dislike t.A.T.u. But even the pro-gays in my town have no idea who they are or don't remember them from 02-03.
ok so in their first album their manager made them pretend to be lez so that they would get more attion and thats why they kissed on stage and stuff, but after awhile they relized that it was wrong so they made an agreement with their manger so that they didnt have to kiss in their videos and but they would still hold hands because they felt more comfortable like that... they really do love each other just not in the way that every had thought =) either way tatu is the best band in the world!!!!
@TheForgottenJellicle Very small curlier. or you can put your hair into very small tight braids while it's wet and in the morning just take out the rubberband holding them.
To me it's an enormous sign for our society going under that everyone assumes they could only get famous by pretending to be lesbians. of course it speeding things up , but I think their story tell us more about our homophobic and mainstream society than most would like. don't get me wrong, i love their music and to me it's very sad that everyone seemed to care about their private life! Lesbians or not, they are singers, not having a job which would obligate them to talk about who they love!!!
sie kommen zurück, das weiß ich.. darum können wir nur hoffen (leider), dass die Solo-Alben schlecht werden, sonst kommen sie nachher gar nicht mehr zusammen. es is einfach alles zum heulen
I will forget my dreams Nothing is what it seems I will effect you I will protect you From all the crazy schemes... See More You traded in your wings For everything freedom brings You never left me You never let me See what this feeling means Everything that you feel Is everything that I feel So when we dream We shout...
Meanwhile, people like you slaughter the English language. How the fuck can you spell Beautiful correctly yet you feel the need to shorten They to Day/dey.
@dvsk45 no one should care if they are gay or bi, which they arent. The real issue is your lack of grammar. please do not show your lack of education to the rest of the world.
I think they are amazing and gorgeous! If you look on Wikipedia it says "Early on [Lena] Katina and [Yulia] Volkova put forth an image of a lesbian couple but their 2003 documentary Anatomy of t.A.T.u. they have stated that they like both females and males." I don't think it really matters though, they are amazing singers and that's what I care about. So, for all the homophobes, get over it. It's not like you have to listen to their music if you don't want to.
@JStar3927 I don't see the point in being homophobic I mean I can understand not accepting it but they make it seem like they're the ones who are gonna get hurt if the come into contact with somebody who isn't exactly heterosexual...
I LOVE this song. They are both beautiful (but Yulia's hotter, no offence Lena) with amazing voices. They are very good, and no one should still be fighting over if they are lesbians, bisexuals or straight. And does it really matter? They have good songs are are just amazing. I think all the homophobic people watching these videos should just quit commenting. Its just annoying to those of us who don't want to go through hundreds of bad comments to get to some good ones.
Actually, Yulia has claimed to have been in love with a gril during one of their tours, and she's the one with two children, but isn't married to their father
I'm Probably The Only One In My School And Town And The Town Besides Mine That Have Even Heard Of t.A.T.u. Their SO Underrated!
MissShadowDragon97 4 months ago
Yes, Tatu need the comeback, so does Abba
IzayoiArwena 4 months ago
ive been listing them for while now too. love there music..
82roses 4 months ago 2
I've been listening to t.A.T.u. for years (since I was in elementary school) and it's weird how no one knows about them. I'm in college now and when ppl ask me what's my fav band I tell them t.A.T.u. Then they get this weird look on their face and it pisses me off how this band is underrated! seriously?! more ppl know about dumbass lady gaga (which is not worth the gum under my shoes). I've been trying to promote this group on my own and it's hard. We ALL need to unit to help promote! TATU ROCKS
ReinaDelAcordeonMimi 4 months ago 5
@ReinaDelAcordeonMimi AMEN!!!!
dinobublz 4 months ago
@dinobublz =)
ReinaDelAcordeonMimi 4 months ago
@yuiina'thanks for this song'i really like it it's 1 of my favorite!:-)
soniagt4 4 months ago
I like so much to listen again and again at their songs...I'd like to get them back together because I want to hear new music...good music...the best music...the music of t.a.T.u !
1995karola 4 months ago
The fans of tatu need to do something big, to get them back together + Hitting the Charts in Music.. :(
darkelf743 4 months ago 2
This is now my favorite song of their's, there is no doubt about that.
Wragziez 5 months ago
What also proves that TaTu is the most popular band is that the comments have the most thumbs up of any video I've ever seen.
Wragziez 5 months ago
me encanta
TheTATU220 5 months ago
Thumbs Ups If...... Well Just Thumbs Up!!!
jacktowngrl15 5 months ago
I love this song. I love Tatu.
I miss them so much, these girls changed my life.
BloodyFantasyXIII 5 months ago 16
gawd i absolutly love these girls their voices are beautiful!
roxstr2013 5 months ago 4
25 people don't like shouting then.
ClaireSpooky 6 months ago
@ClaireSpooky it's probably polaks
HomoCallidus 5 months ago
@HomoCallidus ....LMAO )))
TheAeroflotbitch 4 months ago
Miss them too. I get real sad just listening back to them
bleacHfreakAur 6 months ago 17
i miss them:(
dx5tune 6 months ago 12
25 people must die....
BloodWolf752 6 months ago 8
i remember when my comment was the most thumb up in this video hahaha... anyways badass song!!
dvsk45 6 months ago
śliczne laski na tej fotce ld czarnulka jest po prostu MNIAM :D moja przyszła żonaa :D
ktomawiedziecwie2 7 months ago
treat people with respect!! they will treat ya with respect too !! treat every person so! doesn't matter if they are black withe gay lesbian bie or somethin else!!!! treat with RESPECT!
-snoop Dogg
Craftoful 7 months ago 3
They are THE MOST UNFORGETTABLE band. They were very controversial. And I'm DAMN sure that they have helped a lot of GAY people around the world. That includes me. If it wasn't for them, I wouldn't have had the courage to to tell everyone about my sexuality. LOVE OURSELVES!!!!
suomynonys 7 months ago 12
@suomynonys More power to you! I'm gay as well. I'm glad Tatu helped you move on!
twister1002 7 months ago 6
left 4 t.A.T.u.
epicmax99 7 months ago
AYE!! Who were the ones who disliked mah video?!? I shall bust a cap in yo face. ._.
Yuiina 7 months ago 108
@Yuiina Ass, bust a cap in yo Ass
LoveTrance19 7 months ago
@Yuiina Lmao I love your comment
InvaderJixaera 5 months ago
their music is beautiful
blazingirl4 7 months ago 10
Can i get a thumbs up just for no reason?
sampb92 7 months ago 10
@sampb92 Evidently so XD
FinalFallenFantasy 7 months ago
Can i get a thumbs up just for no reason?
sampb92 7 months ago 7
22 losers without a life
VioletMortis 7 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪♫♪
I will forget my dreams
nothing is what it seems
i will affect you
i will protect you
from all the crazy schemes
♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♫♪♫♪
LiizKriptOn 8 months ago
This is my favorite t.A.T.u. song. =)
ericwarnercline 8 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
watch the orchestral version on my channel
MusicRakan 8 months ago
20 people don't shout when they dream.
I love this song, a bit more than Nichya
3cheers4Ger 9 months ago 4
My boyfriend and I can relate to t.A.T.u. so much. Everyone thinks that it's wrong of us to be together, but we keep our heads held high. Every song by them makes me think him. <3 =) t.A.T.u. Forever
xXchelsearoxXx 9 months ago
I think this is the MOST beautiful song EVER! Love t.A.T.u. forever!
xXxHellButterflyxXx 10 months ago 13
who gives shit about their sexuallty, they were not lesbians god dam it now get over it. however they both were cute together but sigh, they dont sing together anymore
TRchotbal 10 months ago
@TRchotbal I know, unfortunately they have said Waste Management is their last album together and the WM remix album will be it, then they're going solo. Sad really, but maybe it's time. I say, go for it and thanks for giving us such great albums and music. Go Tatu!!!
terrycharnley 10 months ago
@terrycharnley agree!!! Go t.A.T.u
TRchotbal 10 months ago
Thumbs up if you think they are one of the most forgotten bands that need to make a serious ass kicking comeback!
kiradunlop14 10 months ago 276
@kiradunlop14
i'm agree . their songs are great but marketing are suck!
i just found them few months ago >>
just make one more album together and then distribute it worldwidely,
The4logos 10 months ago
@The4logos EXACTLY! But I found them a few years ago and I loved their cd but i then realized that they never really had much besides it. and barely anyone know them
kiradunlop14 4 months ago
@kiradunlop14 a-fucking-men! YEs! right there! yeah! woo!
RuckalltheFules 4 months ago
@RuckalltheFules hahaha all im saying is they were an amazing band who had shitty promo and the fact they had to act like lesbians...i dont get it and if it was to appeal to men...eh seems to not work to well. I just think they need a kick ass comeback AS THEMSELVES with better promotion and marketing
kiradunlop14 4 months ago
t.A.T.u ! FOR EVER <3
Tsukiya57 10 months ago 8
left 4 t.A.T.u.
epicmax99 11 months ago 3
there hot
forthepeeps345 11 months ago
They are still friends but they knew that t.A.T.u had it's ending because it wasn't anything new and exciting anymore. So now they're working on there solo projects :P
t.A.T.u 4-ever! <3
idishk 11 months ago
'everything that you feel is everything that I feel...' <3
quana999 11 months ago
gay
SuperSmeggs 1 year ago
@SuperSmeggs your gay
blossom123ppg 1 year ago
@blossom123ppg
you're*
SuperSmeggs 1 year ago
@SuperSmeggs how fat ass?You are the one who called it gay...Take a come back ass
blossom123ppg 1 year ago
Schön.
thomyketchup 1 year ago
Are they still together or what?
Reneealltheway48 1 year ago
@Reneealltheway48 Broke up in april of 2010. Doing their own solo projects.
xSylviaMoonx 1 year ago
@xSylviaMoonx they didnt break up there just not doing the band full time and are gonna do solo projects
misszoelikesyou 11 months ago
thumbs up if you pushed the "replay"-button <3
lichtsturmjunge 1 year ago 2
I Absolutely love this song.
diana00jonas 1 year ago
It's so sad that the band broke up :(
shadowlink220 1 year ago
lol in the pic they kinda look like alice and victoria from twilight XD
michiru95 1 year ago
@michiru95 FUCK TWILIGHT.
Rave1ing 1 year ago 6
17 people missed the like button.... tsk tsk! You ought to be more careful! (:
yaoiblnshounenai 1 year ago 4
i cant believe i used to not like this song
MegJ326 1 year ago 3
what's going on? they are straight!
animeprincess417 1 year ago 2
they are levis?
mitzmayo 1 year ago
@mitzmayo whats a levis
ROKONandRELY 1 year ago
@ROKONandRELY Oh, here we call Levis (like the brand) to girls that like girls: lesbiana sustantivo femenino
lesbian
mitzmayo 1 year ago
Thumbs up if u think Tatu is One of the MOST Underrated bands.
iTrollThis 1 year ago 574
@iTrollThis I was going to say, "They're the most successful Russian band to date", then I saw your username.
potatoelolidk 1 year ago 2
@iTrollThis I agree with you.......
Dmxcro 1 year ago 3
@iTrollThis: YES!!!!!!!!!! Almost everyone in my town either hates them for being lesbians (when they're not), think they stink at singing (just from hearing Yulia yell "NOT GONNA GET US" or Lena yell "THIS IS NOT ENOUGH"!). Or they don't know them.
I'm pretty much the ONLY t.A.T.u. fan in my one square mile town.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
@3cheers4Ger And then when there is a big news or you ask them about homosexuality somehow they are all "pro" gays.. Hypocrites much?.
iTrollThis 4 months ago
@iTrollThis Well....it's just the anti-gays that dislike t.A.T.u. But even the pro-gays in my town have no idea who they are or don't remember them from 02-03.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
the image is GREAT i just cant stop lookin at it
omoshiroidayo 1 year ago
love this song to death but on the "we shout" I wish they'd sing higher
Jsilvers10 1 year ago
t.A.T.u amazing songs
andrekatina 1 year ago
The 17 people need to suck it easy :3
Phuckurful 1 year ago
first there not lesbians yulia has children from men and lena had boyfriends second this sounds exactly like reach out by lena from her solo album
SunLeaf192 1 year ago
@SunLeaf192 "Reach Out" isn't going to be on Lena's album? "Reach Out" was a demo for "We Shout".
BubaBoi 1 year ago
@BubaBoi i know that now
SunLeaf192 1 year ago
es una cancion realmente bonita y emotiva, asta me izo llorar ='( TATU OS AMO SOIS LAS MEJORES!!!
chibolitarica 1 year ago
lena has more purtity to her voice
danLOVESgirlsaloud 1 year ago 4
i love lina <3
summerland121 1 year ago
Ez is tetszik.
80kazy 1 year ago
I am not 16 anymore, but i still LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!!!!
mixarz 1 year ago 3
Tatu r amazing. Im from Sweden i i've liked in almost 3 years now. They so good :]
habboclub1324 1 year ago
fuckin hot.i idolise the bruinette!!!!
ILYBUB8 1 year ago
such a buitful song
carblecca 1 year ago 6
WE SHOUT
choccybiccycake 1 year ago 7
Oh my god! Are people still talking about them being lesbians? It's been like 5 years since they annonced that it was only for publicity!
soniqueblast 1 year ago
no offence but enough about there sexuality lets bother about the music !!!
choccybiccycake 1 year ago
Love the lyrics.
I could care less if they were lesbian or bi, they make good music :)
DrzDamien 1 year ago
there freaking great
ggs0077 1 year ago
ok so in their first album their manager made them pretend to be lez so that they would get more attion and thats why they kissed on stage and stuff, but after awhile they relized that it was wrong so they made an agreement with their manger so that they didnt have to kiss in their videos and but they would still hold hands because they felt more comfortable like that... they really do love each other just not in the way that every had thought =) either way tatu is the best band in the world!!!!
kittykat1ib 1 year ago
cute song!
and seriously enough about the lesbian or bi thing, there both straight! get over it ppl! they kissed for publicity not because there lesbian!
UNEXPlAiNABlEGURl 1 year ago 2
i love it!
pucko087 1 year ago
@daveythepoet it doesn't matter who they're doing. They aren't gay tho it was a publicity stunt
Spacibo100 1 year ago
does it really fucking matter if they are gay or not? how is it any of your business who they sleep with?
daveythepoet 1 year ago
such a beautiful song
TheLostLolli 1 year ago 4
Elena love Yulia but Yulia is heterosexual !
mykruk 1 year ago
Mindkettő hetero.:)
80kazy 1 year ago
Comment removed
mykruk 1 year ago
i kind of like reach out better
bunny201428 1 year ago
@bunny201428 I don't think I've ever heard that song...
vexion15 1 year ago
Their voices r just perfect.
"you traded in your wings, for everything freedom brings.. "
I love that line
therealmusa 1 year ago
@therealmusa I like the we shout [echoes]...
vexion15 1 year ago
I agree I love lena's hair 2!
"_" sooo beautiful!!
(Hair and song! lol)
therealmusa 1 year ago
Ahhh someone tell me how to get my hair like lena's in this pictureee <3
TheForgottenJellicle 1 year ago
@TheForgottenJellicle Very small curlier. or you can put your hair into very small tight braids while it's wet and in the morning just take out the rubberband holding them.
Angelwings1995 1 year ago
@Angelwings1995 Thankyou! I'll try it out :)
TheForgottenJellicle 1 year ago
Lena and Yuila are not lesbians but even if they were it wouldn't really matter. All who hate them shouldn't be listening to them then.
SoulfulMiMi 1 year ago 2
amazing song~
XxKinkyXCareBearxX 1 year ago
amazing song~ <3 <3
XxKinkyXCareBearxX 1 year ago
i love this song! could you by any chance send me the song? please and thanks : ]
crazycc135 1 year ago
@crazycc135 google - free youtube to mp3 converter
LillyIsBored 1 year ago
Tatu is the best! i love this song :x
nyzandhlg 1 year ago
To me it's an enormous sign for our society going under that everyone assumes they could only get famous by pretending to be lesbians. of course it speeding things up , but I think their story tell us more about our homophobic and mainstream society than most would like. don't get me wrong, i love their music and to me it's very sad that everyone seemed to care about their private life! Lesbians or not, they are singers, not having a job which would obligate them to talk about who they love!!!
alphacyclodextrin 1 year ago
I like how everyone is telling the truth about them not being lesbians, but , who's saying that they are?
corgiegirl 1 year ago
who cares if they were actually lesbos or not the music is what it is its fucking awesome!
RuteliaMari 1 year ago 4
Cmon guys. -_- Stop arguing about their sexuality and enjoy the song. =)
ShyenneTheRabbit 1 year ago 58
lol so true. but yeah, they're nor lesb. or anything. to tell you the truth i like their songs in their language is better in my opinion...
khmaidancer 1 year ago
Brunnete is so beatyfull ..
Uldbard99 1 year ago
i love them for who they are
horrorrulez 1 year ago 5
i love this song. <3
TommyTMonster 1 year ago 3
this song is pretty good!
marsuylama 1 year ago 3
This is one of the greatest songs ever made in existence6 out of 5 stars
LionheartRevolver 1 year ago 4
the best.
linelea 1 year ago 5
ich muss immer bei diesem lied weinen haben sie sich wirklich getrennt also tatu
66animegirl 1 year ago
@66animegirl
sie kommen zurück, das weiß ich.. darum können wir nur hoffen (leider), dass die Solo-Alben schlecht werden, sonst kommen sie nachher gar nicht mehr zusammen. es is einfach alles zum heulen
lichtsturmjunge 1 year ago
JackLondonGirl 1 year ago 61
I Love Them <3
They Are Perfect (:
I Love Very Much Their Songs
MzellxMaary 1 year ago 6
one of their best songs <3
nikachyy 1 year ago 2
love them forever xo
BellaXTC 1 year ago 5
there both great singers
redskull28 1 year ago 5
tatu makes the best songs, shes a great singer.
OokamiShiranui1 1 year ago 4
fantastic song
samy3310 1 year ago 2
T.A.T.U. are amazing. *-*
fanaticforanime 2 years ago 14
love TATU so much!!!!
1404yen 2 years ago 6
Hell yes.
Beholdthecoma 2 years ago
yes!yes!yes!
1404yen 1 year ago 3
......beautiful.....
alcapoj 2 years ago
Love it,
any one know where I can buy their albums?
aralolocares 2 years ago
how about amazon?^^
SpashleyInLove 2 years ago
itunes
kaitlynx103 2 years ago
I'd say itunes or google shop for the best price.
much love, lyves
XMuchLoveLyves 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
try a garage sell since the album is pretty old
djkalja 1 year ago
the song orginally was dedicated 2 the families that lost their kids in bislan's massacre,,,2004....
TheDee95 2 years ago 4
wow good
alexblueeyes214 2 years ago
la music est trop belle j'l'adore
97delphine 2 years ago
I love the pic u used it fits nicely with the song!
forgottenbutterfly7 2 years ago 7
Ja, that it does!
jeramie1983 2 years ago
i kile this song but i like the russian version better
julie7733 2 years ago 8
I love Lena and Yulia. They're perfect!
Love their songs, love their lyrics, love their videos!
EdwardCullen185 2 years ago 29
@EdwardCullen185
Yeaah xD This is truue :-)
And forever :D
emogirldahlie 1 year ago
who gives a fuk if day are bi or not point is dey sing good and dey are beautiful damn haters
dvsk45 2 years ago 108
This has been flagged as spam show
Meanwhile, people like you slaughter the English language. How the fuck can you spell Beautiful correctly yet you feel the need to shorten They to Day/dey.
Damn moron.
BlaneXero 2 years ago
oh I'm sorry asshole what the hell does my english language has to do with this?
guess you didn't have anythin else to talk about so you just got to say shit.
I think Beautiful is a big word for you since you are talkin about excuse me for my laziness
Fuck you and have a nice day i didnt ask for your correction
dvsk45 2 years ago 11
@dvsk45 haters guna hate , but fans guna kill
MrSilentMotive 1 year ago
@dvsk45 no one should care if they are gay or bi, which they arent. The real issue is your lack of grammar. please do not show your lack of education to the rest of the world.
anklepickcrick 1 year ago
@anklepickcrick who cares about my grammar, i made a good point so stop been de grammar police and go get a life.
dvsk45 1 year ago
@dvsk45 your an idiot,Who cares if someone is Bi?Or gay.They shouldnt be juged for it,they are great singers,and are a good couple.
crowfeatherofmoon 1 year ago
@crowfeatherofmoon I think you mis-read his post.
You just called him an idiot for making the same point that you did.
KarlxMxN 1 year ago 5
I love their lyrics
MadMadamMarlin 2 years ago 9
I think they are amazing and gorgeous! If you look on Wikipedia it says "Early on [Lena] Katina and [Yulia] Volkova put forth an image of a lesbian couple but their 2003 documentary Anatomy of t.A.T.u. they have stated that they like both females and males." I don't think it really matters though, they are amazing singers and that's what I care about. So, for all the homophobes, get over it. It's not like you have to listen to their music if you don't want to.
JStar3927 2 years ago 112
@JStar3927 I don't see the point in being homophobic I mean I can understand not accepting it but they make it seem like they're the ones who are gonna get hurt if the come into contact with somebody who isn't exactly heterosexual...
vexion15 1 year ago
I like this song!
stanislav182000 2 years ago 10
ıyı sarkı
emre0187 2 years ago 4
i love these girls and mary both of them
pmoverlord1972 2 years ago 9
I LOVE this song. They are both beautiful (but Yulia's hotter, no offence Lena) with amazing voices. They are very good, and no one should still be fighting over if they are lesbians, bisexuals or straight. And does it really matter? They have good songs are are just amazing. I think all the homophobic people watching these videos should just quit commenting. Its just annoying to those of us who don't want to go through hundreds of bad comments to get to some good ones.
blueflames1123 2 years ago 9
This Song Very Beautiful
MinakoBitch 2 years ago 10
Lena i love u! <3
SPgirlyBrazil 2 years ago 8
Actually, Yulia has claimed to have been in love with a gril during one of their tours, and she's the one with two children, but isn't married to their father
vffv 2 years ago 3