@undertakeredgar Nah, I reckon he forgot to sing it. Don't give me that rubbish about "the laugh is to create a deranged effect" that was more of a legit laughing at himself if you ask me.
@alexmartin51 If he had really forget to sing the 2nd verse than why was there no 3rd verse in the song. Im telling you they shortned it. They did the same thing to the song in other concerts in 1999
Im sitting here in my classroom writing an essay, and at the same time im listening to this song. Suddenly i feel an extreme lust to write somthing dark and horryfiing
3:17 And THATS how you play off a slip up while performing. He LAUGHS it off and moves on to the next verse so smoothly you could almost say it's part of the song. Handled it like a PRO. James you continue to impress me.
@Ibarrai You need the dislikes to keep things balanced. I'm actually growing tired of metallica myself, but one things for sure. They're always be a part of musical history. That being said even though I was a long time fan I'm going to say dislike because of how over hyped metallica has become.
The nost indescribably haunting and heavy song ever.a work of pure genius the way the orchestra plays along with the savage and heav sound of metallica, i love it
Now we know this man is possessed!!!! If you can pause it fast enough or look closely at 1:34 you can see that James jumped nearly 6 feet into the air!!!! If you pause it it looks like he's *bleep*ING FLOATING!!!
Now we know this man is possessed!!!! If you can pause it fast enough or look closely you can see that James jumped nearly 6 feet into the air!!!! If you pause it it looks like he's *bleep*ING FLOATING!!!
With the orchestral part, this is my favorite Metallica song. The way the strings, brass, percussion, and woodwind comment on the lines of the song and add harmonic creepiness is so genius. This song is indescribably haunting. Metallica is the greatest band of all time - end of story.
First things first, cant i watch a Metallica video without seeing Justin B***** in the comments? right now i rarely go down to look at the comments and im gonna stop today since it ruins my videos, its sad
maldita sea esta cancion me posee, y empiezo a hacer cosas tan enfermizas que me asusto yo mismo empiezo a convulsionar y ese tipo de cosas y hablar como satanas jajajaajajajajajaajajaja
99% of teenagers would cry if they saw Justin Bieber standing on top of a skyscraper about to jump. If you are the 1% sitting there with popcorn and 3D glasses, screaming "DO A BACKFLIP!" Like this
@atsuktuvas2 ''99% of teenagers would cry if they saw Justin Bieber standing on top of a skyscraper about to jump''. WRONG!! 99% of all teenagers want himdead. under what rock have you been living?
99% of teenagers would cry if they saw Justin Bieber standing on top of a skyscraper about to jump. If you are the 1% sitting there with popcorn and 3D glasses, screaming "DO A BACKFLIP!" Like this
i love metallica
Wadmaz 4 days ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Metallica
thumbs up for people who know what this song is about.
"....and with stranger aeons even death may die"
LocKe20007 2 weeks ago 2
i think he's possessed when singing. no human can sing this good. but then again..James is a god amongst men
LocKe20007 2 weeks ago
My little brother asked me what "EPIC" means. I showed him this video.
Bianca97LP 2 weeks ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Metallica
James cracking up because he forgot to sing the second verse = best ever.
alexmartin51 2 weeks ago
@alexmartin51 He didn't forget they shortned it.
undertakeredgar 2 weeks ago
@undertakeredgar Nah, I reckon he forgot to sing it. Don't give me that rubbish about "the laugh is to create a deranged effect" that was more of a legit laughing at himself if you ask me.
alexmartin51 2 weeks ago
@alexmartin51 If he had really forget to sing the 2nd verse than why was there no 3rd verse in the song. Im telling you they shortned it. They did the same thing to the song in other concerts in 1999
I'm not tryn to be a dick or anything.
undertakeredgar 1 week ago
Here is some proof
/watch?v=tJqMEVF_RuA
undertakeredgar 1 week ago
i loved the whole S & M thing but i found this one to be one of the best songs from it. imo of coarse.
ksjunkie1 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up if you are watching this in 2012!
Joshuab75000 2 weeks ago
03:19 James Scream ?
mhrl10 3 weeks ago
why did he laugh at 3:14?
koolclient 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Metallica
@koolclient
Cause he was putting irony to the word "sanity".
And in case you were thinking he was really laughing because of something that happened during the show, he wasn't, it was artistic expression.
Get into the music man... :P
DamageIncM 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
koolclient 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Metallica
This is the best song they did off of S/M, I love playing this in my daily commute to work diving through traffic that should not be.
punkrockloser7 1 month ago
at 0:36 Shit is about to get real >:)
KingREDEADED 1 month ago
this is the heviest muther fuker out there. next to sad but true
savageblue25 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why are you people listening if you don't like it?
ilijamaslovar 2 months ago
this is a kickass song but i wish the volume was louder
FanHawk2010 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Metallica
@FanHawk2010
Be careful what you wish for.
The volume is just about right here according to my equalizer.
If you make sources louder, you get clipping and that's what we call the "loudness war".
Which is a bad thing, trust me... that's how we got "Deaf Magnetic"...
Otherwise, get the DVD or CD...
DamageIncM 3 weeks ago
37 people listen to Justin Bieber.
tripplebypass103 2 months ago in playlist stuff
Dear Mr. Bell; Where were you during For Whom the Bell Tolls??
k4den66 2 months ago
God, this song (especially the intro) was MADE for a full string section. :)
stopthemadness99 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lady gaga, lil wayne, justin beaver, katy perry. THE THINGS THAT SHOULD NOT BE
sexybeast507 2 months ago
Cliff's Death - The Thing That Should Not Be
vovchik2000 2 months ago 6
@vovchik2000 Cliff dead? Didn't you learn anything from this song? "Not dead which eternal lie, stranger eons, death may die."
Cliff lives. \m/
Prottoy959 1 month ago 7
it's fucking awesome!
kakuzu134 2 months ago
Justin Bieber is for pussys gimme some metal :)
kakuzu134 2 months ago
5:28
James' little part right there, I poop every time.
lookslikeharry2 3 months ago 4
Love the way he does the demented laugh at 3:16, what a beast. Wish that was in album version!
SweeetDrums 3 months ago 2
When you clic on "the thing that should be s & m", the first vid is "Jizz in my pants". Hazard? I dont think
RoxxorForEver 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
36 people should not be...
AweswomeSauce 3 months ago
1999, is the correct year that this concert happens in San Francisco with The San Francisco Symphony Orchestra,
Katchenko1 3 months ago
Imagine the violonists headbanging! :)
hepilica 3 months ago 34
@hepilica Hehe Look at the guys from Apocalyptica;)
DziobekPl 2 weeks ago
@hepilica That's called apocalyptica. Check! -b
CoupeAudi1990 1 week ago
@CoupeAudi1990 But Apocalyptica plays with cellos.
julioangel93 1 week ago
Im sitting here in my classroom writing an essay, and at the same time im listening to this song. Suddenly i feel an extreme lust to write somthing dark and horryfiing
dragonfurp 3 months ago 5
This live is amazing!
Orchestra + Metal = EPICNESS
TheDarkSideOfMusic 3 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Does anybody know in wich year was this video made?
Valerio2381 3 months ago
Does anybody know in wich year was this video made?
Valerio2381 3 months ago
@Valerio2381
1999
killemall1983 3 months ago
@Valerio2381 The concert from which this song was taken is in 1999. This video was uploaded on Oct. 25, 2006.
ThEG933 2 weeks ago
Ph´nglui mglw´nafh Cthulhu R´lyeh wgah´nagl fhtagn
MichaelmyersTX 3 months ago 7
This is a great song to drown out all that is going on, take your ipod plug in your headphones and crank up the voulume :)
TheLordOfPies 4 months ago
Comment removed
mghillsburg 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Symphony should not be! :)
yunustencere 4 months ago
Comment removed
yunustencere 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3:17 And THATS how you play off a slip up while performing. He LAUGHS it off and moves on to the next verse so smoothly you could almost say it's part of the song. Handled it like a PRO. James you continue to impress me.
jdpazmino2010 4 months ago
que excelente arreglo, muy bien elaborada,para mi la mejor cancion de este disco...
Giova2774 4 months ago
S&M Its a Master Job *-*
ISMAROCKful 4 months ago
THIS IS SO AWESO- *BRLGBLGRBGLR* (mind exploded)
CrazyGirl12123 4 months ago
35 votes that not should be...
Ibarrai 4 months ago 41
@Ibarrai You need the dislikes to keep things balanced. I'm actually growing tired of metallica myself, but one things for sure. They're always be a part of musical history. That being said even though I was a long time fan I'm going to say dislike because of how over hyped metallica has become.
parsleysprigs 3 days ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Metallica
I find that Kirks solo captures the whole "horror story evil monster" thing. love it
james' voice, love it even more
tonzjsl 4 months ago 3
>.> <.< i always thought this was based off the kraken
crackincrackers 5 months ago
All shall bow down and wordship....CTHULHU.....and His Father....Who art H.P. LOVECRAFT.....IA...IA...fthagn!
TheJameslehr 5 months ago
This song gives me goosebumps...I listen to it every day. And it always gets better and better
JGr525 5 months ago
IA IA Cthulhu fthagn = Cthulhu is Metal.
TaimaDjinn 5 months ago
at 3:15.....his laugh makes me lose it
Saiwi21 5 months ago 6
whose dont likes this is gay
onlyRicardo 5 months ago
WOOOOOOOOOOHOOOOOOO!!!
BorysTheTormentor 5 months ago
35 people should not be
TheTrueShadows 5 months ago 5
C'thulu is the best creature in the world, for inspiring Metallica so greatest songs as this one or The Call of Ktulu.
DaMetalAvanger 5 months ago in playlist Metallica S&M
1:03 - 1:08 I think I found Cthulhu!
AlexLazor 6 months ago
Not Dead Which Eternal Lies Stranger Eons Death May Die
LandoMan09 6 months ago
@LandoMan09 Drain you of your Sanity...Face The Thing That Should Not Be!
EoinByrneMusic 6 months ago
H. P. Lovecraft would have loved Metallica... no question about that...
9420617 6 months ago 6
3:29 is freakin' amazing!!!
xangelxofxpeacex 6 months ago
I would give my fucking testicles to have been at this concert.
bentkkkk 6 months ago 5
is it me or does it rather sound like spy music at the begining :)
Kibby95 6 months ago
@3:15 - @3:22
MrHammerofdeath 6 months ago 4
Ph'nglui Mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn. Ia, ia, Cthulhu fhtagn.
asnaes 6 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
HYBRID CHILDREN WATCH THE SEA... PRAY FOR FARTHER ROAMING FREE.
NEPHILIM AND THE MASTER OF THE FALLEN ONES?
zootblunt 6 months ago
Comment removed
zootblunt 6 months ago
This song proves that it doesn't need to be fast to be heavy as hell...
TheOrionification 6 months ago 4
@TheOrionification Right on. Actually slow-paced songs tends to sound heavier. Have you ever listened to Crowbar?
dcs2690 6 months ago
@dcs2690 I have not listened to them, I'm going to search for them... :D
TheOrionification 6 months ago
3:23
YOYO1991ism 6 months ago
can i seriously enjoy one damn song without having to see justin bieber's name?
fuck
datfunkyfresh 6 months ago 3
Legendary !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! M E T A L L I CA
MrTrancemongolia 6 months ago 2
whenever i watch a video of good music, everyone has to bash justin bieber hahah xD and those comments are usually top rated.
LAJHS 6 months ago
FACEE THE THIIIIIINNG THAAT SHOULD NOOOT BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEthankyou
cheseecake 7 months ago
35 people are things that should not be!!
HaydenMetallica 7 months ago
Epic song is legendary ...
r34p3r1992 7 months ago
I used to not like this song very much. Then I heard the S&M version, and that opinion changed incredibly quick lol XD \m/
DMAN4219 7 months ago
The nost indescribably haunting and heavy song ever.a work of pure genius the way the orchestra plays along with the savage and heav sound of metallica, i love it
gamemstr98765431 7 months ago
Now we know this man is possessed!!!! If you can pause it fast enough or look closely at 1:34 you can see that James jumped nearly 6 feet into the air!!!! If you pause it it looks like he's *bleep*ING FLOATING!!!
*Reposted because of spelling placement issues.)
MsMetallicaFan1996 7 months ago
Now we know this man is possessed!!!! If you can pause it fast enough or look closely you can see that James jumped nearly 6 feet into the air!!!! If you pause it it looks like he's *bleep*ING FLOATING!!!
MsMetallicaFan1996 7 months ago
With the orchestral part, this is my favorite Metallica song. The way the strings, brass, percussion, and woodwind comment on the lines of the song and add harmonic creepiness is so genius. This song is indescribably haunting. Metallica is the greatest band of all time - end of story.
ninpo4life 7 months ago
This is so heavy its like a earthquake, IN YOUR MIND!!!
SuperWhofarted 7 months ago
@SuperWhofarted and depending on your sound system your home as well ^_^
BlackThunder885 6 months ago
FUCK ING HEAVY \m/ this is why Metallica is the best
RandyVanHalen1 7 months ago
This song is so much better with the orchestra.
I thought that this song was probably the worst in the Master of Puppets Album but with the orchestra... This is almost a new song. Very dark
franklouuu 7 months ago
This is why I liked Jason WAY more than Rob, Jason has such enthusiasm and is so alive, all Rob does is his little monkey dance..
Tytokman 7 months ago
First things first, cant i watch a Metallica video without seeing Justin B***** in the comments? right now i rarely go down to look at the comments and im gonna stop today since it ruins my videos, its sad
colddeath47 7 months ago
2:22 demon face Jason!
SwissWolv 7 months ago
I can just picture Cthulhu head banging to this. That's probably whats been causing all these earthquakes actually.
Caboose1117 8 months ago
Amazing solo!
LoadMagnetic 8 months ago
3:17 Pick Of Destiny
MrColonela 8 months ago 2
Somewhere deep down the waves, in the darkest, deepest corner of the ocean, Cthulu is digging this.
Rudolfusftw 8 months ago 101
@Rudolfusftw
And all the while giving Hastur shit because no one's written a song about Hastur. XD
msaoichan 6 months ago
@Rudolfusftw and cartman is coonin it out
xLDKxClan 6 months ago
@Rudolfusftw the irony about that is that Cthulu actually is an air god :P
suushii90 5 months ago
I dont remember james laughing in this song
dirtbikepro64 8 months ago 2
@dirtbikepro64 ni o my god pero eso es lo bueno de el que improbisa
diososcuro123 8 months ago
daaamn.. he was feeling this song...
mido305 8 months ago
the begining when the orchestra sounds kinda like "black sabbath" by black sabbath
johnnyhorton2 8 months ago
3.22 he's not human
GAMMUTRON26DET 8 months ago
this is well shit watch my videos i terror metallica!
biggestj10 8 months ago
fuck you!!!!
mathi123ify 8 months ago
0:41 , its the end of the world theme tune :O
theukgod1 8 months ago
God-send demons
robepm11 8 months ago
why does the orchestra have glass round them?
arsenal2477 9 months ago
@arsenal2477 Acoustics much?
whannes 8 months ago
@arsenal2477 to protect them from james awesome demonic voice ;) HA HA!
NUNPUNCHER714 8 months ago
this is the greatest vocals on the show
arsenal2477 9 months ago
and that my friends is how awesomeness came to be
FlamingPineapples1 9 months ago 3
Symphonic Black Metal < Symphonic Thrash Metal \mm/ and when james laughed at 3:16 he sounded like he did in the 80s if u ever heard him laugh
metaldrummer2397 9 months ago 2
Symphonic Black Metal < Symphonic Thrash Metal \mm/
metaldrummer2397 9 months ago
3:06 James is probably thinkin to himself, "wow, we wrote a damn good song!"
PotatomanIV 9 months ago
Great Symphony, JAMES HETFIELD's VOICE \mm/ :D
His laugh @3:15 . \m/
tabluvsrock 9 months ago
Great Symphony, JAMES HETFIELD's VOICE \mm/ :D
tabluvsrock 9 months ago
Wasn't really feeling this one.
ZaneHitsurugi 9 months ago
the little thing at the beginning sounds just like the intro to black sabbath
Rock4life93 9 months ago
YO TENGO ESTE ALBUM Y ES DE LAS CANCIONES QE MAS ME GUSTAN
TheHellbrothers666 9 months ago
All hail the mighty Cthulhu!
kutlessrocker23 9 months ago
@kutlessrocker23
lol what
ZaneHitsurugi 9 months ago
@ZaneHitsurugi Cthulhu is the fictional monster this song is about. Look up "The Call of Cthulhu" by H.P. Lovecraft.
kutlessrocker23 9 months ago
:O YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH JAMES IS THE BEST
Jucermy33 9 months ago 3
@chansey13795 You have been another victim to Metallica's mind fuck. It's awesome
longhorns27 10 months ago
Good nights, lil' Cthulhu
Chochiman 10 months ago
Brilliant! The orchestra background really adds to it. Clever idea, Metallica
thewag777 10 months ago 4
hey, I'm trying to find something that is better than epic. Oh wait, it's S&M. Fucking awesome!!! \m/
teenmetalfreak3 10 months ago
Haha the woman at 5:12 is like "MUST PLAY THIS INFERNAL RACKET!!!! JAMES HAS SUMMONED US"
DMoots 10 months ago 2
maldita sea esta cancion me posee, y empiezo a hacer cosas tan enfermizas que me asusto yo mismo empiezo a convulsionar y ese tipo de cosas y hablar como satanas jajajaajajajajajaajajaja
musikrammstein 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Metallica was so good in their performance that night Cthulu called them to say congratulations!
SuperWhofarted 10 months ago
Este video es creo que el numero 3 o 4 de mis favoritos en este concierto! lml
IT¨S SO FUCKING AMAZING!!!!
throll2008 10 months ago
Kirk was amazing at this concert.... nice!
19Jda05 10 months ago
@19Jda05 Kirk is always amazing
horror4ever1997 10 months ago
james's voice is absolutely amazing here. so much power...
XxZero97531xX 11 months ago 2
@nicolasTaBjA96
mostly accetable possesion ;)
roxterat 11 months ago
I was play Quake 1 many years ago and listenieng this song when I'd played. EPIC :D
polokowski 11 months ago 2
This song makes me sooo fucking scared O.O Cthulhu is coming for me, i can feel it :'(
LegoGenfilms 11 months ago 2
Thumbs up if you fucking sick of the people that fucking say's fucking thumbs up SHUT THE FUCK UP!!
needkolas 11 months ago
Dagon swallowed 34 people whole.
KigekiHakuchi 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love metallica but this concert was very boring
JElias1996 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love metallica but this concert was very boring
JElias1996 11 months ago
Comment removed
JElias1996 11 months ago
god damnit. im tired of this "thumbs up if you..." bullshit.
caboose39134 11 months ago
god damnit. im tired of this "thumbs up if you..." bullshit.
and @zealotelite044 this is a live concert...think about it.
caboose39134 11 months ago
god damnit. im tired of this "thumbs up if you..." bullshit.
caboose39134 11 months ago
@zealotelite044 Studio editing, that's why
MitchellBleesTube 11 months ago
99% of teenagers would cry if they saw Justin Bieber standing on top of a skyscraper about to jump. If you are the 1% sitting there with popcorn and 3D glasses, screaming "DO A BACKFLIP!" Like this
atsuktuvas2 11 months ago 29
@atsuktuvas2 ''99% of teenagers would cry if they saw Justin Bieber standing on top of a skyscraper about to jump''. WRONG!! 99% of all teenagers want himdead. under what rock have you been living?
michellangelo22 11 months ago
@atsuktuvas2 I don't understand how this is pertanent but it is funny.
0ZAZU 11 months ago
@atsuktuvas2 99% already? Well, people started overreacting that pretty fast. There's actually about 25% that like Rock or Metal the most.
FredAndXaveloy 6 months ago
@atsuktuvas2 Who the fu** is Justin Bieber?
4zr489 6 months ago
@4zr489 you dont want to know...
xangelxofxpeacex 6 months ago
@atsuktuvas2 you mean "DO A BARREL ROLL!!"
thericecrispy2 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
99% of teenagers would cry if they saw Justin Bieber standing on top of a skyscraper about to jump. If you are the 1% sitting there with popcorn and 3D glasses, screaming "DO A BACKFLIP!" Like this
atsuktuvas2 11 months ago
best song with the orchestra...period.
FFBpictures 11 months ago
3.15 onward...The laugh aww fuck..JIZZ
gamerinsideu16 11 months ago
@Putian98 Axl must die.
NickChim 1 year ago
james' voice <3
greendayholidayrules 1 year ago 2
@greendayholidayrules yea he sounded great in this.
904austin 11 months ago
Justin bieber is the thing that should not be!!!
Govenator1 1 year ago 52
@Govenator1
Justin Bieber is not worthy to be Cthulhu
Dimitrando 7 months ago 38
@Dimitrando
Justin who ?
Speak of music or gtfo, thanks.
4shr4m 3 months ago in playlist Metallica S&M
@Dimitrando my comment on him: as Metallica would say: The Thing That Should Not Be, or at least The Thing That Should Not Sing
1994djNemo 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
S&M is the sexiest album
metalgod044 1 year ago
Fuck I love this song. Fits the Lovecraftian theme perfectly. It sounds so wrong is such a good way!
Cxaxakluth 1 year ago
Cliff Burton´s death is the Thing That Should Not Be...
yklamix 1 year ago 4
2:23. For a split second look at Jason xD
NickChim 1 year ago 3
@NickChim epic sadface :D
nowheremancameron 1 year ago
lol look at 4:11
the bald man dancing
LightStevOo 1 year ago
34 people are Yog-Sothoth bitches
kriechentod 1 year ago
METALLCIA FOREVER MOTHERFUCKERS BITCHES!
stealer111 1 year ago