Added: 5 years ago
From: blockaderunner
Views: 2,996,351
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (4,204)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 103 people doesn't known Pink Floyd neither Pompeii...

  • so find ich toll hihi

  • Divine, Magic or a High ??? Only Floyds can answer...

  • pure joy .. i wish everybody could hear what im hearing .. alas .. at least i got it ..

  • The first four minutes transfer me to another world altogether! OH MY FLOYD! \m/

  • Es muy probable que Pink Floyd sea el único grupo que nunca ha tenido "sucedáneos" porque efectivamente son inimitables, y por supuesto no me refiero a los buenos cover que circulan en la red (algunos de muy buena calidad), pero ellos serán siempre únicos.

  • wish I was here

  • 102 people didn't go to Pompeii

  • Holy cow, David Gilmour used to be cute? What the hell happened man? :)

  • @jasmine2501 Gravity. Gravity happened.

    

  • I was in Pompeii about 4 years ago but I didn't know about this back then :-(

    Definitely need to go visit again...

  • I... NEED.. TO... GO ... TO ..... POMPEII

  • A concert with no one in the audience...alive. No one in attendance but thousands of dead people on pompeii...pretty cool when u think about it like that.

  • 102 people were waiting for the rap verse.....

  • those 102 people can suck it :P

  • Maravilhoso...

  • The Perfect place... For a perfect band!!!

  • This is one of my favorite songs. I just wish that Pink Floyd was a big enough band to draw even one person to their concert! ;-)

  • great great song...words cant explain the feelings hearing it..

  • 4:20 reminds me of that portrait of Doug Heffernan that he didn't like.

  • there is no chance no way to dislike this......

  • God was trying to give us a message...and Pink Floyd could give us that message

  • Comment removed

  • naja is ja lustig

  • Pink

    Floyd.

    London  |

  • paradise is off the  planet.....

  • 5:45 he throw his drumstick x)

  • 100 dislikes ... party :))

    

  • Roger Waters - David Gilmour - Nick Mason - Rick Wright

  • I can't wait to get my own dorm in college and get stoned and listen to all my Pink Floyd cd's.

  • @MarcooPF Cliche!!!

  • @MarcooPF only a few more years to go right man!

  • ...Excellent!!...

  • magic.....!

  • cuando estoy pedo escucho a los grandes si señor jaja !

  • this is more than a paradise. this is the creation of paradise.

  • The music that can change you.....

  • Since a few weeks, i realize that Floyd is the king of symphonic rock! Live at Pompei is more than heaven, it consumes me.

  • 5:28 - 5:40 looks so fucking much like that riff from Phantom of the Opera.

  • @marisarm1 I knew I wasn't the only one!

  • @dowhatyouregoodat It sounds blatantly the same, don't know how anyone couldn't notice xD

  • MAybe floyd wouldn't have upheld everyone's expectations if they had stayed together......Gilmore's on an Island was good and WAters' work since has also been good.....It just happened...I do wish they would toured together more.....Like I have seen Waters, but not Gilmore, and the whole time I saw waters I thought....I wish it was the whole band together again....

  • I think David Gilmour has become fatter over the years.

  • I have been to Pompeii and you can still hear this music....being played..

  • Ez egy túltorzított fos!!!44!!

  • Ez egy túltorzított fos!!!44!!

  • This song sounds great, but the audio quality makes it painful to listen to. Maybe if I wasn't using headphones it wouldn't feel like those cymbals were scraping out the insides of my ears.

  • @EtherealSiren225 I wonder if there is ever a better recording... I have Senn HD595s so I think I'd notice more than right now on this iMac.

  • man. life without pink floyd is life unlived ..

  • I'm italian. This year I chose to join the school trip to Napoli, Capri and Pompei only for walk in that arena.

    ...Awesome, I'm speechless.

  • First time hearing this. WOW!!!

  • 94 people have been violently attacked with a hammond organ.

  • I personally think this is the long, lost performance AND song of Pink Floyd. Long Live

  • Greatest keyboard work in the history of rock and roll.

  • New progressive rock coming out soon band type ''innerspaceband''

  • 94 people don´t listen the echos

  • The best, of the best, of the best, of the world.

  • i love the introvert sound of the singing in this version, that's a point i miss in most of their live performances of Echoes

  • the feelin comes naturality. exciting!

  • I'm no fan, I'm addicted..! <3 Pink▲Floyd

  • Comment removed

  • Cloudless everyday you fall upon my waking eyes

    Inviting and inciting me to rise

    And through the window in the wall

    Come streaming in on sunlight wings

    A million bright ambassadors of morning

    And no one sings me lullabies

    And no one makes me close my eyes

    And so I throw the windows wide

    And call to you across the sky.

  • @DominicJozwik So, is it continuity, tribute, homage, recognition, rejection, or is it that they all grew up reading the same english poets (e.g. t.s.eliot) in grade school? Check out the imagery and figurative language here in Echoes and in Across the Universe and on Abbey Road: inciting and inviting me, here comes the sun, limitless undying love like a million suns, sleep little darling do not cry, and I will sing a lullaby. More remarkable: the shared musical lyrical genius.

  • I'd`ve paid to go go to that gig...loads of empty seats too!!

  • Epicness

  • Helping to control the human anxiety since 1965!

  • God, seeing this makes me miss Rick's voice so much.

  • @anomalousclouds yes Rick's voice is so underrated! I'm so bummed I never got to see him live

  • @notoriouslizw Same here, although I've always had an odd feeling that I was never going to, that the band and their music would remain ethereal to me. An artifact from the not so distant past that I discovered as a child rummaging through my parent's record stash, that would become the soundtrack to many reclusive stoned nights, magic mushroom days and a couple wild LSD experiences during my first couple years of college. I don't know what to call the Floyd sometimes. Sonic magic? RIP Rick. <3

  • @anomalousclouds With ya brotha, Rick's voice was amazing - and we seem to forget about the incredible keys he played!!!

  • @anomalousclouds how can u miss it when is w us here forever

  • too much for fucking youtube.... fuck that 480pt... that needs looseless...

  • Bliss

  • The director Adrian Maben is a criminal,he could something astonishing with this music but he badly failed wasting this chance.His view is outdated (even for that years),poor and flat,while the music is the opposite.Everytime I watch this movie I wonder why Pink Floyd gave their approval once seen the result.Or better, why they considered to be directed by an unknown scottish-french director at his first work.He will do next just 2 films, 2 documentaries, and 1TV serie in his career. A looser.

  • @geovkiller WTF are you talking about?

    It was EPIC the Whole thing... The Pompeii Scenery speaks for itself...What do you want? Some Crappy CGI effects??? Mabe starships or Aliens??

    Come on man...leave it...

  • @Ekphrasys Are YOU mad man? What CGI fx are you talking about?Did I ever mentioned it? Did you see the scenes in which David Gilmour's guitar replicates in all the screen?That is SHIT, and looks like a CGI effect. Keep the aliens and the starships for your movie and quit commenting things you don't understand or things you don't know anything about.The CONCERT was epic,the MUSIC was epic,Pompeii is GREAT,the film was SHIT. Believe me and try to compare it to The Wall.Maybe you'll see my point

  • @geovkiller STOP TELLING BULLSHITS! Accroding to you is SHIT!!! Not according to other ten million people! The "effects" were TYPICAL of the SEVENTIES, you Dumbass!! You can see similar thing in De Palmas "Phantom of the Paradise" that was shoot 2 years after...

    It's NOT a movie, moron...It's half way between a long "video clip" and a "live sequence"....

    For Christ sake stop telling crap....Learn what a movie, commercial, Video Clip are....

    OMG...

  • @Ekphrasys you don't even deserve any further reply, as you are not able to keep an interesting conversation alive without showing your bad manners. Thank you

  • @geovkiller "Are you MAD man"...Did it come from me? No, dear, you wrote it....

    Talking about "bad manners"....

    Regards...

  • shit.. it breaks my heart to see them together in that era.. the legendary Line-up...!!! too bad Roger Waters had to became such a fucking douchebag..!! he ruined the brighter future that Pink Floyd Could Had....!

  • @EMIL1020 true, but you have to remember that without waters in control, they wouldnt have had such epic concepts

  • @EMIL1020 If you understood the situation properly, you would be wise enough to know that it wasn't Roger's fault.

  • @EMIL1020 How much brighter could it have been?

  • @EMIL1020 How much brighter could it have been?

    I was at pompeii, too. Years after this "concert". I can't begin to describe how accidental and spiritual that trip was. This means nothing to anyone reading this (except one) but that tour guide was useless, and the stray dog deserved a tip.

  • I sure wish that we could see an upgraded version of the director's cut.... I think a lot of the older, die-hard Echoes fans were upset by the newer clips and dated graphics.

    I bet that nowadays, someone with vision and some artistic or graphic connections could make a masterpiece of Live from Pompeii that even the original director and the Floyd crew would appreciate.

    Echoes is my very favorite Pink Floyd work!

  • takes me back to my youth wish i could be there again this is how music

    should be happy days or should that be hippy days

  • There will never...EVER be something like this again. And even if something comes close, they were so far ahead of their time.

  • I love this song!!!!!!

  • @TheAuburnSaints maudlin of the Well's most recent (and free) album is powerful. Also look into Kayo Dot. Unrelated to Floyd but modern and very different.

  • The drums sound really fucking bad in this video.

  • @marcusklaas they had bad microphones for that recording... too bad. plus this vid's sound is particularly bad I agree

  • ONE OF THE GREAT EPIC SONGS. AN AMALGAMATION OF MUSIC VIRTUOSITY AND ART. ITS IS UP THERE WITH EPIC SONGS LIKE KING CRIMSONS-IN THE WAKE OF POSEIDEON, FAMILY'S SCENE FROM THE EYES OF A LENS, CREAMS-DESERTED CITIES OF THE HEART, MOUNTAIN'S-NANTUCKET SLEIGHRIDE, JUST A FEW I AM MENTIONING, ALTHOUGH I DO THINK FLOYD COULD HAVE DISPENSED WITH THE GAGGLING CROWS BIT THOUGH, IT ADDS NOTHING TO ECHOES.

  • one of the best live performance EVER !

  • Best Rock Song ever.. Deal with it!

  • I honestly have "Echoes" tattooed on my forearm in Blue, white and black. :) Its almost as beautiful as this song!!!

  • This is amazing!

    Pink Floyd is my favourite rock band!

  • would it be wrong to tattoo "PINK FLOYD LONDON" on myself (by a pro, of course)?\

    and David's palm mute groove thru the 2 minute mark is awesome!

  • would it be wrong to tattoo "PINK FLOYD LONDON" on myself (by a pro, of course)?

  • This is precisely the highest point that Rock has ever gotten.

    Echoes 1 and 2 are together the most intense and creative moment in Rock history!

  • ever meet anyone who says, "Bah, Pink Floyd couldn't jam" - just be happy knowing you're correct - Richard would be proud...

  • watch?v=VRPZIhEcfcM

    This vid has better quality :D

  • It's genius. But...

    And I understand 93 people. May be they don't know much about Pink Floyd. Shitty quality of sound ruins this song for them. So much unpleasant noise -_-

  • @WiNCR4SH2

    the remastered Pompeii is so much better. actually, only a couple of songs were recorded there. they couldn't get electricity to the island in time for most of the shot. most of it was recorded in France i believe

  • @yourOpinionNotMine Yep, I know it :)

  • And we where not there wonder if they meant that !!!!!!!!!!! ?

  • Comment removed

  • LSD-25 BLOTTER ACID, HERE I COME!!

  • i now dislike 93 people

  • i feel the lump in my throat everytime i listen to this song..i could never give up on life just because this song. i feel defeated but ill put forth my best effort to continue on and have some bit of hope.

  • This is paradise, THIS IS PARADISE. This town is like a great big pussy... just waiting to get fucked. (tony montana)

  • i cried. this.. is amazing.

  • 93 dislikes. Fuck Ya'll!

  • @Nachojman indeed...

  • 93 dislikes. Fuck Ya'll.

  • It's been 30 years I 1st saw this in a matinee. It changed me musically 4ever . Still goosebumps .

  • anyone know where i can find tabs to the part that starts at 3:18 ?

  • @bigfelix223 pritty sure the music is still echoing around the pompeii arena, well it was a year back when i went to pompeii,,, so if that doesnt help........get urself to either Italy or a good music store :p

  • 93 peoples have any Life !!!!! lol

  • ahhhh, this is relaxation at its best

  • This is absolutely amazing , oh to have been there,

  • music of the Gods.!!!!

  • i bet a lot of people jumped at the beginning

  • Click 4:12 if you want to live!

  • I want this at my funeral.

  • 93 people lost it at 3:18 i dont blame them

  • i feel just overwhelmed

  • glorious!

  • This is not simply music. I don't know what it is, but not music. David Gilmours playing is magnificent. One of the best peaces of music from Pink Floyd, the best group ever. No doupth

  • this is a piece of art

  • what the fuck with this music? It sounds like the end of all, eternity awaits

  • what a drastic change this guys made in the 70's

  • complain, complain all you want - this is Mother Earth speaking to us...

  • HORRIBLE SOUND QUALITY! WTF

    turning the volume tab up doesn't help it sound good

    it just maxes the amplitude out... holy shit

  • angels were the audience

  • @dxbfreemind angels were the performers as well

  • Never get a show like this again,history,give my right testicle to have been there

  • this was a concert presented to the death

  • 3:18 Oh my god!

  • this is my all-time favorite song, yes its better than stairway to heaven .It is by far the most epic rock song ever

  • @whiteandshadesofblak stairway to heaven is such an overrated song, this blows it to pieces.

  • @jimmyshitbags stairway overrated??? you talk some amount of shite pal!!

  • @mrcjwolfe lol yeah well, I also think the beatles were average at best... stick that in your pipe and smoke it!!

  • @jimmyshitbags i dont give a fuck what you think.....so stick that in your pipe and smoke it!! ya dick!!

  • @mrcjwolfe yeah well, I like when people don't give a fuck what I think and call me a dick, so stick that in your pipe and smoke it!!!

  • @whiteandshadesofblak of course :p

  • this is my all-time favorite song, yes its better than stairway to heaven-i think.It is by far the most epic rock song ever

  • make one complaint about this - I keel you

  • yaaawwwwn...oh, wait my hears hurt from the cymbal intro.

  • Awesome

  • seeing this video gives me the chills cause no one else is there except the film crew....This song is just genius!!!!! first pink floyd song i ever listened to and still love it.