Australian Pink Floyd-Sorrow

[iccolours]

not bad, these guy should hook -up with roger waters band (the bleeding hearts band) i'm thinking

[kidda74]

Going to see these tonight in Liverpool, hope it's as good as I'm expecting! :)

[fmfadz]

i watched these guys last night at blackpool they were fucking awesome close your eyes its like listening to the real pink floyd absolutely brilliant

[AnimalPlanet000]

a good copy is still a copy... yeah, they can play, that doesn't mean they will ever be true artists, such as the real Pink Floyd

[PinknessOfFloyd]

There's a tribute that only plays here in St. Louis, Missouri, called El Monstero. They're not national, but honestly, they're a thousand times better on the musical aspect of the Floyd. Their videos are all fan-recorded, so you'll never find one that does their live shows any justice. But compared to the light show, they've got nothing on the Aussie Floyd. Which shouldn't matter if you're a true Floyd fan. The music should be your main focus if you love Pink Floyd. :]

[tritonxtr]

Dave Gilmour es only best guitar of pink floyd

[bbrown6057]

SirijusS....you're an idiot

[alcas78dp5]

These Aussie's are great!

[Aliasaxxe73]

Above all I don't see why to clone Pink Floyd that way...

[oldgeezer68]

I have seen both 3 times. I agree with Dave Gilmour, these guys are good enough to play at his 50th birthday party. And to jam with. This is not one of their better renditions of this song or more accurately, they're better in person. But you can go to their shows and not know much difference between them and the album. At least the 3 I've been to. And they are certainly better than the next PF concert you're never going to see.

[oldgeezer68]

I have seen both 3 times. I agree with Dave Gilmour, these guys are good enough to play at his 50th birthday party. And to jam with. This is not one of their better renditions of this song. But you can go to their shows and not know much difference between them and the album. At least the 3 I've been to. And they are certainly better than the next PF concert you're never going to see.

[oldgeezer68]

I have seen both 3 times. I agree with Dave Gilmour, these guys are good enough to play at his 50th birthday party. And to jam with. This is not one of their better renditions of this song. But you can go to their shows and not know much difference between them and the album. At least the 3 I've been to.

[oldgeezer68]

I have seen both 3 times. I agree with Dave Gilmour, these guys are good enough to play at his 50th birthday party. And to jam with. This is not one of their better renditions of this song. But you can go to their shows and not know much difference between them and the album.

[bluesfashion]

horrible guitar sound....

[FloydGilmour]

@bluesfashion agree!

i dont really like this sound

[PLEEUZ]

All you nay sayers strike me kind of funny. It's like are you hearing the same song I am. I've seen these guys 3 times when they have came to Dallas. They are absolutely magnificent. Of course some things are different in their songs because they are not the real deal but you can't get any closer to the real deal than this.

[mikedo6]

SirijusS.... having seen both,myself and a few million fans around the world respectfuly disagree with you.

[lene2free]

This was terrible!!! ruined the song!

[hologramh]

Good job. Good band, but needs more practice in singing.

[miniwick93]

@hologramh

Agreed, Singing timing is a bit off but other than that its absolutely perfect!

[SirijusS]

It's OK, compared to other amateur tribute bands, however compared to Pink Floyd - this is absolutely rubbish

[NateyG1]

@SirijusS

You have no idea what you're talking about. I've seen Pink Floyd live in L.A. back in their hay-day. The Australians are virtually indistinguishable. Don't let ignorance influence things you say on YouTube boards. You won't appear as such a tool.

[soph921000]

@SirijusS , you are talking out of your arse mate, these guys are the nearest thing to Floyd, these guys pack out stadiums all over the world, come back when you know what your talking about!!!!

[PRIMAX1967]

@SirijusS: This is a "Tribuite Band". Not Pink Floyd. There will only be ONE Pink Floyd. And no other band comes close musician wise. Rubbish? On the contrary, these guys are simply amazing! Can you do better? No? Then don't critisize what other CAN do and what you yourself can not.

[wispa1a]

@PRIMAX1967 Sounds awsome live with their quadro subs

[iccolours]

@PRIMAX1967 now get on with your work,..now repeat after me,, the area of a rectangle...........

[roberthodd]

Wersja utworu dobra, ale to utwór niewątpliwie również na aranżację dla orkiestry symfonicznej.

[CtrlRm]

Guitar sounds nothing like Dave's tone

[jonondoey3]

garbage vocals

[DamiSzmyd]

Terrible!!!!



[bladeboy2041]

Got tickets for this Sunday May2nd!

[djhopps]

going to see these guys 2nite in belfast...cant wait!!floyd forever!

[lippygitthegit]

I have been lucky enough to see Floyd at Earls Court in 94 . Roger has gone his own way , Rick is dead , so no chance of a reunion eh , . Look forward to seeing these Ozzie boys next time they hit Manchester . Good work lads .. long live Floyd

[Caucasianaasian]

Of course the real Pink Floyd shows were multi-million dollar amazing spectacles, but for someone who didn't get to see them live, these guys are a damn good substitute. I saw them in Oz many, many years ago and they were great then, but have really come along. They capture the Floyd feel pretty well and for all the negative comments on youtube about them, the people in the crowd here seem pretty bloody impressed. I walked out amazed and listened to nothing but Floyd for the next 3 weeks.

[irena7777777]

Just booked a ticket for their show at the SECC in glasgow. Can't wait. never seen them before and heard so much good about them.

[RichLesPaull]

cant wait to see thes guys in april at brighton

[iluvem]

Pink Floyd are the greatest live band in the world.But these guys have come on a bit since i saw them at 'The Flower Pot' in Derby! Don't rate the lead singer's voice much though,but brilliant otherwise.

[TheFaxlico]

fue una gran belleza haber escuchado a este grupo tan maravilloso,lo maximo qu me pudo pasar en mi vida,poder haberlos visto en vivo.FOREVER PINK FLOYD.

[runtifish]

Bloody Awesome

[luismty76]

this guys are great , despite the bitter coments

[weathered79]

best cover band imo

[walkdenandy]

saw these guys at bolton town hall back in 1999. thats when they weren't as well known. still awesome though.

[Decapitatorul]

Love this song!!! I think it's one of the best songs by Pink Floyd

[Saruuuman]

no one can really do it better than gilmour ,.. because hes best .

[Amvet69]

That girl on the far right was really getting into it.

Luved the followup instrumental, their own touch to the song.

[floydianPL]

Many guys on YouTube play this solo much better than APF... vocals are poor as well... and the attempt to imitate the 94' tour stage is not a good idea...a great tribute band anyway!

[jbeck180]

i agree..94s PF show is the best light show ever put on to this day

[sethmanjette12]

im gonna see these guys next month to play the wall album in its entirety.

[marco52jk]

nice tone..

[wineistheanswer]

These guys are good.One of them actually comes from Crewe in Cheshire,England.....I know because he was a customer of mine at an electrical store I used to own.I saw them in Crewe at The Limelight Club and in Stoke at the Victoria Hall. Do yourselves a a favour and see them if they visit your town.

[BeyondOurGain]

That guy can't sing... ruined whole feeling. Bad.

[Verdugothewatcher]

Jesus, these guys cover Pink Floyd like they ARE Pink Floyd.

Fantastic.

[Zigaldiam]

so much so,even Pink Floyd themselves,quite often,go to 'there',gigs.un-canny likeness.superb 'tribute',band.

[FloydGilmour]

@Verdugothewatcher don t say that, is stupid!

only ONE pink floyd

[captainlucy]

Fantastic! I first saw them in a small club with about 200 people present, in 1995, about 3 months after seeing the real thing in Earl's Court, and I was blown away then. I've seen them every time they've come round here since, and watched thm developing into a tribute band able to sell out an 8,000-seater stadium. They'll never match the Floyd, but they come about as close as anyone ever will.

[Tetragrammaton22]

oh man i hope they come to Canada soon, i missed when roger waters came and i never forgive myself, i need to see/hear pink floyds music being played live whether by them or these guys, i dont care they both sound reallllly good.

[Adie1304]

I'm waiting too for 1st March...;]

[joalcoany]

Those guys are playin' in my country on March 1st.... JUST CAN'T WAIT!!!!!!!!!!!!

[iluvem]

I saw these guys at a club in Derby years ago-they seem to have improved a bit!The vocals need a bit of work but i can't fault the playing or presentation-brilliant!

[ink0kevin]

I saw these guys last night and I was in shock at how amazing they are. I figured it would be good at best. During the intermission the guy next to me asked what I thought. I didnt speak because I didnt want him to hear my voice breaking due to nearly being moved to tears. That was after they had played Dark Side of the Moon straight thru. They came out after that and played two more hours of Floyd to perfection if not better then the originals.

[losChou]

"I didnt speak because I didnt want him to hear my voice breaking due to nearly being moved to tears" incredible sentence...i will be in that state in one month when they come to madrid...i was able to c pink floyd when i waz 13 in madrid...at least we have this now

[BCDCdrummergirl]

This is one show you must not miss. I was so impressed with the drum sound and was blown away when I found out they were made by a company in PA. They blow DW and Yamaha away.

[gilmour480]

I have seen them I watched the concert on Tv. Watch PULSE and its obvious that Gilmour has 10 times more bass.

[brobostigan]

You have no effing idea how good these guys are until you seen them live. I could feel my clothes moving from the bass and the overhead choppers, the massive surround sound - unbelievable. They also had their own multimedia show going on in the background complete with a huge inflatable pink kangaroo - get it? Aussie Pink Floyd - Kangaroo. I was on another planet most of the time.

[gilmour480]

Guy needs way more bass on the opening solo

[wey1010]

yep, because you can really tell what the live mix is like through a truckload of compression and your 2 buck pc speakers.

arsehat

[gilmour480]

pc speakers? Learn to read dumbass. Dolby sound system  on my Tv.

[benchmarek2007]

c'est une excelente chanson. domage que ds nos jours on ne peut avoir pareille. la musique s'est degrade.sorrox c'est une chanson qui retsera gravé ds l'histoire de la musique

[leobd]

very goooood.....

igualzinho pink...sem noçao

[ag2res2or]

grandes¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

io estuve el 25 en el caupolican

viendolos son espectaculares

[alex69gilmour]

exelente banda son bastante buenos,ademas si saben a quien rendirle tributo, los amos del rock pink floyd...atte chano

[FinalCut1190]

Increible! suenan IGUAL a Pink floyd!

[ProjectExodus]

They are mimicking Pink Floyd a bit too much in my opinion (just look at the dancers), but I guess thats what tribute bands do.

These guys are really talented, I must say... If these guys made their own music they could do big.

[gilbertgodlyddd]

They have a new singer now, he's excellent.

[turkishdagger]

sales are good?

[imsoglad1]

these guys r brill even dave gilmore thinks so off to see them in a couple of weeks

[hockeyman566]

i watched these guys on T.V i really liked them

[SamBennallick]

the voice is different, not bad. but the sound quality is kind of crap

[chriswikkid]

i miss Gary wallis!:P

[djtrixen]

Ian Cattell's voice is MUCH MUCH more like David Gilmour's than Steve Mac's is.

[rashbabu]

his voice isn't asgood as david gilmour

of course no one can b

[hliva1802]

You are so right about that...the creator of a song always performs best

[djtrixen]

This is taken straight from the DVD... Great performance, I'll have to say! I just wish they would do a DVD of thei recent North American tour--with Ian Cattell. The setlists were amazing and the light show has improved considerably since they did this one.

[Remy56]

Keep a look out, I was at The Royal Albert Hall on 4th May 2007 and they were filming the show for their new DVD which has Ian Cattell, Jamie Humphries and Amy Smith included along with the rest of the the usual team.