'Closer/The Only Time' live from 'Beside You In Time'

[TheMcarignan]

kewlcactus is a jackass

[kewlcactus]

Alright. Enough with the ass kissing and worship and admit that the first half of his performance sucked ass and didn't deserve praise.

[NELLA1680]

I mean ORGASM!!!!

[NELLA1680]

This is the proof of why I have an instant oegasm every time that I listen or watch NIN and Trent!!!!

[00Flamerz]

The only artist that personifies sex ..mind, body, soul and music.

[thekosseli]

i havent listen NIN in few month , now i got orgasm

[kanervd2005]

Mother of fuckkkkkkkkk

[jackstylck]

He's crazy!!! but really awesome!!!!

And these scenary and the lasers... @_@! O_o!

[starsparklefox]

christ..cant breathe..

[EmpressBlackisJen]

This has always been one of my fav songs. I can remember the days of a certain club that used to be open and my and my friends would always dance to this song at the club. There was like a hip hop/rap bar that was a couple doors down and every once in awhile there were a few of the people that went to that bar take a peek of what was going on at the club. Of course they were like, "DAMN!" jaws dropped, etc...

[pfmartyn1]

Incredible, Amazing, Intoxicating, Sexy, Reznor & NIN are just simply AWESOME!! Thanks guys!! :)

[2hot2tell]

I'm waiting for the time when he's actually banging a chick while singing this Live.

[brpeters01]

...so, uh, what do you think they DO with all the blood??? Fertilizer? Feed {shudder}?

Also: Who else wants to hear an EXTENDED version of "Closer"?

[Cardien18]

oh wow love that riff 1:17 HAWT ;)

[nirewolf0]

that touch sensitive light curtain is seriously one of the coolest concert props ever, and this whole video gives me the tingles. 3:28 oh. my. god. so sexy I think I almost fainted D:

I would very gladly fuck him like an animal thanks very much. Sooo jealous of his wife!!

[mattman337]

who the hell is bottlefly?

[tepehood]

I want to fuck you like an animal!!! I want to feel you from the inside!!!

[shredsledman]

I like this song much better live.

[libbern]

Ahh, no one fits better than trent when it comes to honouring our mating act... right?:D If I had to do a man, it would be Reznor. I'm just saying...

[mangosnake]

@libbern Even if there weren't no obligation, I'd do Trent Reznor anytime !

[libbern]

@mangosnake

Agree. Not that he gives me the turn on, but it would be damn cool to be able to say "hey, I did Trent Reznor" to people. I would even make a t-shirt with that on it:D

[jowoasis97]

Damn Trent's all sweaty and uhhh and then Jeordie opens his mouth and sings and its just AHHHH!!!

[MikeyRGuitar]

saw this live from five feet away and Trent was screaming in my face. I got kicked in the head and I was bleeding everywhere and he kept telling me to leave, so I flipped him the bird and held on to the rail for dear life. That was fun.

[AGENT24]

That is so epic, what a true fan.

[EnigmaCaptain23]

such a great song after all these years

Im honestly jealous of his fiance

[MrBuckwilliam]

wow

[overdoseoncandy]

reznor, my god. you sexy sexy beast!!

D:

[meshell1066]

@overdoseoncandy More like sexy motherfucker.....Meeeooowwww!!­!!!!

[AudiBabay4180]

i loooove this song... his voice is so sexy and beautiful!!!

[twochicksONEcamera]

I don't know how many times I am going to say it...but Trent Reznor is down right SEXY

[nirewolf0]

@twochicksONEcamera hell yeah!! words can't even begin to describe how sexy he is!! and talented too!! <3

[Davkiller69]

man live sounds better :D

[fearrising10]

i was watching this on paladia, and all you could hear was drums, keyboards, and vocals. you could see them playing guitar and bass, but you couldn't hear it at all

[BlitzkreigYYZ]

really? i watched it on paladia and i heard it fine.

[fearrising10]

i couldn't hear anything at all, it must have been my tv.

[sickboyduke]

i had that problem with the dvd. that happens when you have the wrong sound settings

on 5.1 sound setting it was the same with me

[abinmex]

3:25 to 3;30 makes me fall in complete lust for him......

[Rachael5922]

i love this song :)

[lor83130]

he didnt play it at jones beach the other night... ugh.......

[EternalComedy]

I think he said he won't be playing it at all on this tour. Something about him being tired of it.

[MLGKarma]

Well, when you play a song at every show for 15 years.....

[07mantle07]

haha, it was a great concert. otherwise. i was working at gate g.

[Ryno4269a]

don't get your hopes up for Closer, He hasn't been playing it this tour.

[xxfulatoxx]

why?

[3zyPL]

3:13 to 3:16. The best part.

[DivisionbyZer0]

Ain't there a bit of "The only time" in the end?

[carawaySUCKS]

@divisionbyZer0

that's why it says "Closer/The Only Time'" in the headline above your comment... ;)

[marcegutifuentes]

fucking cool !!!!

[adamchabbi6]

why does it say closer/the only time, but in this video they only played closer?

[3zyPL]

Those songs got a similar type of lyrics, about fucking, at all, and Trent've decided to get a little of "The Only Time" on their "Closer" performances - look from 2:50 to 3:30.

Those are drums right from "The Only Time", with lyrics from Closer.

[ajaxrulzz]

Love them but to bad that Robin Isn't in here

[zorac91]

did anybody else got the creeps when hearing this amazing kick ass performance?

[NINtrigued420]

The entire set gave me goosebumps throughout the entire show when they were here last year in So. Cal. Trent seems to have that affect on me... LOL

[ajpatter210]

that outro gets me every time

[zbbrown8]

when was this

[empty216]

The band of my life.

[azrial4421]

god they put on some great shows

awsome artist

[gregsuperstar]

Amazing.

[knightraider3176]

oh by the way THEY WERE FLOOR SETS ! I was so close to trent I could smell him!

[knightraider3176]

I went to see NIN a dozen times and use to skip class in Cleveland to see Trent when he was with Exotic birds, I love the old Trent too, but he still fricking rocks my lastest concert was in Oct of 08 at the AT&T center in San Antonio where I now live

[HarryUpHarry]

Haha

[usedtohatecellphones]

Okay, I don't want to sound like a creeper or anything, but...

This song makes me horny. Haha.

Can anyone relate?

[HarryUpHarry]

Nope, just you - you are a massive creep

[djh3mp]

This song is amazing, well everyone knows that.

But one thing people haven't discussed so much about, is the downward spiral motif in the ending. it's cool. out of sudden the distorted guitars and stuff end and a depressing, offtune synth melody pops in.

[samg789]

how is aaron north the guitar player wearing a black shirt while playing then few moments later wearing a white shirt then back to black then white then back to black?  is it two different dates?

[PeelOutTheWatchword]

Don't you know that Aaron North is a sex goblin who can change in and out of his clothes in the blink of an eye?

[a8ingemini]

ROFLMAO!!!!

[samg789]

haha everyone knows that

[AustFisch]

Not only that, it's two days recorded.

[hatfisc]

Trents definitely improved on his onstage prowess. @ 3:31 it looks as though he dissappears. Best closer performance by far. Jordie White sounds great but he prances around the stage like a fairy.

[Spectreman]

The lighting effect was so freaking cool live. He just stands in front of it and he looks theres only 8 bits of him. This tour was awesome. I was so pissed that the last tours skipped Milwaukee. NIN Rules!

[rigila]

2.04:(L)

[tCsGRIM]

I have the DVD... And this isn't on it... There's a similar performance, but this isn't the Beside You In Time DVD version of the video... Am I missing something?

[twiggywhite]

special features->winter tour i think....atleast on euro disks

[niko88888888]

where the hell in the dvd is this?

[tannienn]

Awesome!!!

[BurnDuri]

Great new lyrics to an immortal calssic,

perfect fusion of decadence and beastly rafinement.

[ThrowThatJunkIn]

There are no new lyrics except an additional f-bomb.

The "Through every forest, above the trees..." verse is much more subtle in the original mix. Easy to not hear it -- though he did change "I drink the honey" to "I am the honey."

Who cares anyway, right? This mix gives me an eargasm. Why don't any new bands even flirt with having that kind of talent and originality? No more nasally douche-bags whining over infantile indie-rock -- no more Nickleback clones making the same song 150,000 times

[BurnDuri]

You Sir/Madam, are absolutely right.

Thumbs up.

[allbranwheaties]

fucking amen

[Ketobbey]

Hell!!! Yes!!!!!!!

[wizofoz0124]

This song is like an instant orgasm...heard it live more than once and there wasnt a dry panty in the house....oh Trent, fuck me like an animal

[djh3mp]

Everyone speaks about Closer's lyrics, but ever listened to the bassline in the chorus? Hot.

[AustFisch]

YES!!!!!!!!

[Jewman4000]

mmm YES! That's more or less the sole reason my band covered it :P and the chance to shout out at the audience 'fuck you like an animal!'

:D God...i love NIN!

[mantunapig]

help me get away from myself :)

[mysticalwind72]

This makes me want to grab Henry and demand he ravish me....

[djh3mp]

Lmao. My name is Henry

NIN Rocks, BTW

[shutupswine]

he needa come 2 jersey and play this im dyin 2 see nin

[belochka07]

KICKASS!

[TheEdibleShoe]

I have this dvd on Blu-ray :D. I saw NIN live it was fucking awesome. Its a must see concert no matter what.

[fashionista16]

AHHHHHH YES!

This reminds me of how AWESOME IT WAS to finally have seen them in Ottawa and for the first time in life!! You don't know an awesome live performance until you've seen NIN live...AHHHHHHHH IT WAS AMAZING AND A HALF!

[kyjb70]

amazing and a half?

[zara958]

i want trent from 10 years ago. he's still sexy, but not as much as he used to be (sorry everyone, but his body has just change soo much! he's that bulked up he's no longer got a neck). 'im afraid of americans, closer and perfect drug videos. mmmmm GORGEOUS!

[mitcky]

You prefer the addict Trent instead if the healthy and ALIVE trent?

[zara958]

i'm afraid so

[empty216]

Nothing fun and interesting about alive and well now is there?

[Clairage]

WOW

that's love

so pumped for the show on fridaaaaay :D

[lovelylady36]

30 or 40, I'd still let him violate, desecrate, penetrate and complicate me. FUCK IT, ALL AT THE SAME TIME!

[Lube512]

i wana meet him make musik and smoke a joint ^^

[puretoon]

COORRRRRR!!!  Seexxyyyyy :) Trent rocks big time.....what a sexy version-what a track! you wanna meet his mum? I wanna meet HIM :))

[Rowan1186]

Nope, the synth line toward the end is from "The Only Time".

[mubrenda]

that´s not "the only time", that´s "down in it", still i love it!!

[warmambereyes]

this is my favorite version

[spyplane3]

i wanna meet trents mom

[Radar180]

i love this version, my jaw dropped when i first watched this at home on dvd

[bradbsh]

Twiggy!!!

[rmunoz44]

never realized that the songs are a perfect thematic match for each other

[jessSHIKA]

dear lord.... that gave me chills.

[chriis9180]

this is the only time I feel alive.

[happyphantom32]

i fucking loved the show in Dallas the best hell yeah

[Vindicut]

Why have I never heard of 'The Only Time' ?

[sampledsoulless]

Because apparently you are not familiar with PHM.

[omgwtfwhoami]

lol!!

[mrjaz666]

Good question...

:P

[Vindicut]

holy shit that light show kicks ass, cant believe I missed them in Dallas:(

[Salvador33HPR]

PLEASE READ IF YOU LOVE THIS AMAZING BAND CALLED NIИ(1MAN BAND)

I have a video vote on Nine Inch Nails that I want all REAL NIИ FANS to see and partake in. I am doing this video because I want to hear the opinions of my fellow NIN fans.

[maserati1990]

i love twiggy, or whatever his name is the sick guitarist, he's just so fucking sick.

...so is trent, but i fuckin do love twiggy..or whatev's his name.

good job

[jmo32082]

jeordie white

[Whore4Horror]

I'm drunk and right now I'm so in love with you

[musketwarrior]

they performed this in dallas earlier tonight!

[LauraWish]

really? what a surprise...;D ;D ;D

[musketwarrior]

they don't perform the remixed version with the only time often. i haven't heard of them doing it anywhere other than dallas on this tour.

[scarred2112]

They did it at the two shows I went to (Cleveland - always a good show because of the "hometown vibe" - and Lexington) and with the complexity of the show's lighting I doubt they switch between the two. I simply think Trent like this shorter, more concise version these days.

[musketwarrior]

yeah i realized that afterwards. I watched some clips from other places. I just hadn't heard anyone mention the mixed version. oops.

[AggieMaryann]

This IS the only time I really feel alive :D

[RiflemanIzzie]

True, teh sound lame, but it's less industrial then The Downward Spiral Version. Makes him easier to understand, but at the same time, makes it lose the storybook effect it had as part of the album.

[electrifizzle]

LOL alessandro has 3 mac tattoos xD hilarious

[angelflyn2low]

They sound great, to me, it's THE CROWD who sounds lame.

[Steve141986]

This particular performance of Closer seemed a bit lame but I can't blame the man. IMAGINE how many times he has had to sing that song.

[valereznor]

trent, ma quando sei sexy?? quanto?? èèèè????

[Trezire]

I'm a die hard NIN fan and all, but the BYIT tour just doesn't do anything for me. Video's I mean. Pretty much any NIN show post fragility tour, You HAVE to be there. Once that element of utter chaos goes away (From being in the crowd) it's just not as good.

[teardwnyuridolz]

Just because he's in his 40s doesn't mean he doesn't still love sex. Ya know? I don't see the coralation there. Especially since he's aged HELLA fuckin' good. :]

[LauraWish]

he actually has more 'reasons' to sing it now than 13 years ago ]:> I mean...he has gained a lot of experience in f****** ]:>

[BluesMaddy]

He must feel weird singing this in his 40s

[TheInhumanGlitch]

Ugh..

You know that it would've been sooo.. oh.. soo.. orgasmic to be in that mess live..

I would let him do anything to me.. ;D

[Steve141986]

Which is why you'd bore him & anyone else like him for that matter. =)

[meislink]

Did he just say "The only thing that burps for me"?

[e6e2e3e1]

he say "Works for me"

[meislink]

I dunno man XD

[meislink]

I know it is supposed to say that but it says "the only thing that burps for me"

[Knutorius]

it's like "i've got no soul to tell" on the album.

[ladycardinal25]

Hell, He can just Fuck me like an animal. Mmmmmmm, Damn. LOL he's so sexy.

[Lilito27]

completly agree... his voice ..mmmm... everything about him..

[fakoff1]

fuck you to everyone who says hes on steroids... you guys just never went to a fucking gym of your life, hes bigger but you can already see that in big day out he began to train and that "the hand that feeds" he began to be buffed. He just train like everyone else. In a gym you wouldnt even look at him if he wasnt trent...

love the effect on that vid.

[RagePrime]

Can agree...was a out of shape guy, joined the army and I have pretty much the same build now.

[gorny540]

I think he may have done steroids around this time because his head looks fuckin huge, but whatever NIN is amazing can't wait to see them live over the summer

[fakoff1]

Nothing can make your head huge, not even a tumor... He just shaved his head thats all...

[JustusDestruction]

WOW.

That's all I can say.

Fantastic mix/Performance.

[atwiggofpearl]

"you can my everything!" yes and you give it to us fro free!

god bless Trent Reznor.

[empte77]

HOLY SHIT THAT WAS AMAZING!!!!!!

[waynedrake]

man, look at his arms! Trent the Tank!!

[RiflemanIzzie]

I just noticed this as well.

[bensteed123]

yeah man this aint the one from the original dvd, cus i remember at the time when 'the only time' kicks in, the keyboardist like slams his hands down onto the keyboard so it goes all blah

and that aint on this one...

[epispecial666]

thats cuz it's from one of the other tours that are on the dvd as well

[locomexican125]

does the dvd have different angles cuz i saw another one from the dvd and it starts off in a different angle

[MrMagicMushroom]

This is from the bonus features on the Beside You In Time dvds, the list will be like Summer 06

Somewhat Damaged

Closer

Help Me Im In Hell

Non-Entity

Only

I think anyway!

[wysteria640]

Holy crap he's beefed up... looks damn good though :P

[divick630]

There was no greater feeling being there that night. Still can't believe it's already been more then two years (march 30). You should have been tehre.. the crowd went INSANE once the heart beat began...

[Jobana]

I love this video soooooo much, I could never be tired of watching this again and again! besides it has reznor has the main ingredient^^

I am a Reznorian!

[nin56665]

=D you're not alone!!!!Reznorian.LOL

[fekborbsbaby]

Reznorian? Really? I'm from a different denomination of Reznorism, I'm a Reznorite.

NIN!

[WhiteStripe333]

This is the BEST HD/Blue Ray DVD availiable, it looks soo kick ass. It's like your there at the concert....It's fucking awesome.

[snylekkie]

Bureau of Morality's lounge in Poland recognises this show as valid. Drink the water.

[Jobana]

Taken from the dressden dolls diary...is it possible?

"Alessandro, the italian keyboard player, had three (THREE) mac tattoos. one of the mac logo on his wrist, one of the "sad computer" error icon on his forearm and another one i never saw. "

[atwiggofpearl]

what the fuck that mans a saint!

[getanerection]

LOL omg thats so lame xD

[nin56665]

THE PURE SEX!

Is there something better than NIN???The answer is : NO,there is NOTHING!!

And live!OMG,awesome!!!COuld watch this the whole day!NIN is the perfect drug,you can NOT get enough of them!!

[reznorzyca]

love, love, love this song (and the orginal video)- best greetings for fans from Poland

[amylovesnate2007]

trent you are sex humanly hottness and a damn good musican :)

i love you

[pigd1666]

Watching jeordie headbang is magical!

[groboto]

reznor got fat?

[cbackus09]

Nah, just ripped.

[PeterSteele9423562]

great, perfect 10 ;-) Trent I Love You for making this music !!!

[fohawkNIN]

amazing, it blows my mind. i dont get how its humanly possible to make music this amazing. i dont understand? NIN IS AMAZING!!!