I can't believe the negative comments this is getting! I'm so pumped this is on YouTube! I saw this particular production in person and remember vividly how moving this number was. You're awesome, Amy :) I hope you're still performing somewhere!
It is theatrical, but I love it!!!! You're not just copying, you're making it relevant to your style. This is one of my favorite songs, and you sang it well :-)
You have much talent, and many songs have been sung by different people and they may not sound the same each time. I like it, your very pretty too. Thank you.
Everyone's entitled to their opinion and some like and some don't- I have to say that I do and have returned here a number of times to listen to your interpetation. Good on you and better you act out the song with feeling and drama.
love the song, Janis Ian, Spooky Tooth and your versions all different and wrong to compare!!!
Nice to see that a perfect song can be interpreted in many ways. I bet the diehard Ian-fans here don't like the Spooky Tooth version either. Aecollier, you deserve a compliment for turning this wonderful golden oldie into a modern musical song.
This sucks. Really sorry, but it is full of bloated self importance by the performer. When the messenger appears to be more important than the message then we have a right to be critical.
Plus she had to make this theatrical. She couldn't deliver this as was it's intent. Taking a classic and running it over with the lawn mower
I can't believe the negative comments this is getting! I'm so pumped this is on YouTube! I saw this particular production in person and remember vividly how moving this number was. You're awesome, Amy :) I hope you're still performing somewhere!
melissaisfun 5 months ago
It is theatrical, but I love it!!!! You're not just copying, you're making it relevant to your style. This is one of my favorite songs, and you sang it well :-)
Succour 1 year ago
It is OK, by me.
Must be hard to sing this classic in Public, like this.
No way can do it...
Thumbs up....
Ken69a 1 year ago
ok she is not FEELING this song. just empty words. i hate it..
WonderWomanFan4life 1 year ago
great!
LiaPamina 1 year ago
With all due respect this is the best version , hands down !!
pubsterguy 2 years ago
@pubsterguy ..You are entiled to your opinion as I am of mine. Happy Holidays!!
36midnight 2 years ago
Nice voice..but I'm not sure I really like this version. No offence..that's just me. Not that I can do any better!..mind you.
36midnight 2 years ago
a good cover also a great song one of the best ever written
jackwbb 3 years ago
You have much talent, and many songs have been sung by different people and they may not sound the same each time. I like it, your very pretty too. Thank you.
teendude16 3 years ago
How awful; it was like watching a drag queen honking and wailing because she couldn't go to Palm Springs.
Eschatus2 3 years ago
Everyone's entitled to their opinion and some like and some don't- I have to say that I do and have returned here a number of times to listen to your interpetation. Good on you and better you act out the song with feeling and drama.
love the song, Janis Ian, Spooky Tooth and your versions all different and wrong to compare!!!
I'll be back again soon...
jules1957 3 years ago
Not a very good interpetation of this song.
Steve915 3 years ago
Nice to see that a perfect song can be interpreted in many ways. I bet the diehard Ian-fans here don't like the Spooky Tooth version either. Aecollier, you deserve a compliment for turning this wonderful golden oldie into a modern musical song.
wieohwie 3 years ago
Great job. Very different from the original in a good way. Sorry a couple people have been dicks to you about it.
pomafiwo 3 years ago
This singer made this song far more dramatic than it should have been. It was a simplistic protect and this was turned into a semi-theatrical piece.
MsWizard 4 years ago
um... this is from a musical. i was playing a character and acting out the song.
so.. thanks?
aecollier 4 years ago 4
are you kidding?
fanfestdhl 3 years ago
no?
aecollier 3 years ago
no shame here. ugh.
fanfestdhl 2 years ago
@aecollier ....yeah...Still No!!
36midnight 1 year ago
This sucks. Really sorry, but it is full of bloated self importance by the performer. When the messenger appears to be more important than the message then we have a right to be critical.
Plus she had to make this theatrical. She couldn't deliver this as was it's intent. Taking a classic and running it over with the lawn mower
fanfestdhl 3 years ago
The melody has been changed and the key...doubt she could hit the notes.
...but nice enough try.
...but no Janis.
Asuigeneris1 4 years ago
Definitely NOT better than Janis. Can't even hit the high notes. More like a high school play performance.
Pantherboy2 4 years ago
What a voice and an impressive song arrangement.
wymstr 4 years ago
I think this is really good. ^^ Better than Janis Ian. But the sound quality sucks.
KillerNeko 4 years ago
I was impressed.
Very well done.
cryingflower 4 years ago
GREAT job!
Deedee5858 4 years ago