Added: 2 years ago
From: SFSimonWhite
Views: 185,252
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (291)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Edge should play some Beatles on that guitar ((°J°))

  • What a racket!..self-satisfied bollox!

  • ARE YOU ALL DEAF? This documentary could have easily been made with Jimmy Page and Jack White alone. The Edge is really not that great.

  • @p6y6r6o no but u might be tone deaf

  • @imedi not really. the edge sucks. go cry moar.

  • jhonny depp

  • The Edge is not one of the most skilled guitarists, but he's tasteful and he knows what he's doing. That was great

  • Page >> White >>>> Edge

    pretty obvious.

  • i like Edge's notes here..

  • i am speechl.....

  • 2 blues rip off's and the Edge. His parts are the best here.

  • @samliffe yuh cuz your one of those bitter little cunts who cant accept reality,..

  • c'mon The Edge shut up and let the masters play

  • Jimmy owns!

  • i like how jimmy page has p-90's yet his tone is the thickest and most pronounced in this vid :L

  • roarsome!!

  • les accords de yalta su rock!!

    

  • page looks j.s bach and a white dead james brown xDD ahahahahahhahaha:D:D

  • zeitlose zauberer

  • This is the soundtrack for a scene like this.

    "Riding on a horse, coming to the nearest town. Old folks are fleeing the streets. I see a man standing in the middle of main-street looking up at me. I'm getting of the horse. Me and the stranger is looking at each other while the sand is blowing across the street and a tumbleweed is passing by in the back. The stranger say "Draw, you no good manure eating yellow belly coward.". I shoot him dead and get on my horse and ride away.

  • Page looks like J.S Bach in this.

  • @IanBarton1994 D A D Gb A D

  • They really play like a MAN)

  • homme shoulda been in there

  • 2:08 jack smile

  • In everyone video of Jimmy teaching them Jack can do it. He just gets it. He understand Jimmy. Meanwhile The Edge is always playing catch up and fucking up the beautiful sound they have going.

  • @vedderfan94 lol i guess we all hear what we want to hear going by your name u might be a pj fan if u are it might intreast u to know that u2 are 1 of vedders fave bands so i dont think he would agree

  • @imedi dude i created this account when i was getting into pj and i dont even care much for them anymore, so i dont care for anyone referring to me username. the fact is, the edge sucks and has to hide this by smothering his guitar sound in u2 using a bunch of effects and pedals. also im just curious but do you have a source on that info?

  • @vedderfan94 there are references to pjs love for u2 all over the net from opening for u2 to covering their songs as for the edge smothering his guitar with pedals i think if that was the case after 160 mill albums playing to world record crowds and 22 grammys over 30+ years i think the edge would have been found out by now as for u thinking he sucks well sorry to inform u but in the grand scale of things thats an irrelevance

  • @imedi your opinion became completely invalid once you mentioned sales you idiot. sales =/= quality. just look at justin bieber ffs. as for grammys, everyone knows they are a joke.

  • @vedderfan94 my point seems to have gone straight over your head i will put it another way for u. looking at u2s history its plain stupid to say they suck not likeing them is fine i dont like the who or the stones but im not dumb enough to think because i dont like them they suck. both bands have too much history behind them for that statement to stand up and thats where bieber differs he has great sales and good luck to him but unlike u2 no real history behind him. 30+ years

  • @imedi grammys award on popularity. eddie vedder is the only guy who had the balls to go up there when pj won and say that it doesnt mean anything.

  • The Edge is a master....of special effects.

  • Jack White looks like Edward Sissorhands...

  • does anyone know what tuning this is in?

  • If I were to sit on the floor,with these three men surrounding me,I would've came at least 16 times without even moving.

  • I love the way The Edge looks at White at 2:42 . . . A bit like "Okay, you're talented, BUT I don't like it" and then Jack White's with his Edward Scissorhands face : "Sorry".

  • Comment removed

  • The edge would be a great sound man at a gig but a solo guitarist.. i just dont know he doenst fit and he just aint the innovater to play around them strings and thats just an opinion and no i cant play any better i think?? But Page and White just made music so damn new and interesting they are like the gods Page the early days White the latter days hehe

  • Comment removed

  • I love how many people think being a good guitarist requires you to play technically perfect. I have seen a lot of guitar players who aren't able to play a fast speed metal solo. But they are still better guitarists than most people who can.

  • tre fessi

  • Super freak

    get a life men

  • normally jack white can do this alone :)

  • i love how jimmy is dancing and rocking out and there just kinda standing there

  • And then it continues with Jack saying "You're supposed to join the family" :)

  • this is really shitty

  • the edge sound great

    fuck haters

  • @raw2is2jose i agree!

  • @raw2is2jose sry bro but edge hasn't shown really anything that he can keep up with these two, i suggest you watch a south park episode called "more crap" ok that's about bono, but i actually feel bad for edge 'cos he knows he's outclassed here that's why i wont go any further besides this--> 100 best guitarists ranking: edge #24, jack white #17, jimi page #9

  • @bakikatana sorry but south park in this episode SUCKS and EDGE is original.

    In my opinion.

  • @raw2is2jose Lol, that was the most correct portrayal of bono ever, and i've been playing the guitar for about a year and a half and i've never seen anything that would put edge (what a laugh) in the spotlight, noone ever gave him any credit nor did he do anything outstanding, he's just a backup with his guitar, in this video he played something and jack did it how it's suppose to sound, what a fan boy you are

  • @raw2is2jose yeah, i like them all! its about having fun!

  • beethoven can play guitar?

  • omg i wasnt enthusiastic about the Edge in that movie but In my time of dying his parts were the best! Im really surprised that everones dissing him on that video! People, this is great what he is doing. Jack and Page are just playing allover again what is on the studio version of that song and The Edge is improvising something new and fresh!

  • What the hell doing the Edge over there?!?!

    Jimmy and Jack rules!

  • Comment removed

  • @DantonDK f**k you Edge

  • Page has the best tone

  • lol the edge

    

  • I'm not a fan of U2 or the Edge but I have to say his solo was the best in this. Jack had the best Rhythm.

  • @SnipinxClan Ahaahahhahha you have officially made my day!!!!!!

  • lol I love how jimmy page and jack white's like talking to each other with their guitars........it's amazing!

  • So this is what three guitar wizards sound like.... I'm in heaven.

  • the edge is cool fuck haters

  • Why the hell there are some people that dislikes Edge ?? Edge admits by himself he´s not a bluesman.. so from that point of view he is working different. If you think that playing guitar is only playing blues... and moving the left hand as fast as possible around the fretboard you probably don´t know nothing about guitar

  • the Edge - pls out !

    

  • Why people dissing The Edge? I am no big U2 fan but his parts are the best in this clip. Unique and cool.

  • I don't like the sound of The Edge..

  • the edges sound is entirely different between that of jack white and jimmy page, the edge did well including that this has taken him out of his comfort zone compleltely. No offence to page or white but how would they like it if the edge chose one of his songs to play

  • i would have preferred to see someone like john frusciante or matt bellamy in this movie instead of jack white or the edge

  • on this jam the edge didnt suck so much. it was ok i think.

  • master Jimmy ^^

  • I personally thought the Edge's section was incredible, and made me appreciate U2 more. His sound is exceptionally recognizable!

  • is it me of is mozart looking a lot like Jimmy Page....

  • Even I as Page and White fanatic have to admit, the only original thing in this jam was Edges solo.

    White copies blues licks thats it. While Edge here maintained fairly unique tone and playing.

  • Jimmy Page ! the Mozart of Guitar !

  • The Edge was the improvisation leader in this exchange, wet-behind-the-ears White was out of his league and twice tried and failed spectacularly to upstage the Edge's innovation with hilarious mouse-like squeaks, prompting a knowing nod-and-a-wink hug Page gives the Edge after the exchange ;)

  • hey in this performance,the edge showed some real style...but you can see in his eyes,that he thinks he is no match for the other guys...for that i respect hin,he is trying to be humble and decent and does something own in this.

    great is wehn jack shows "lets take this to another height"(at the end you know)

  • i think jimmy page is a shit guitarist, Noel Gallagher is so much better

  • @MrJamesPaylor GTFO

  • @MrJamesPaylor LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!­!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jack White - the teenage boy who is amazed by this old mans tricks.

    Jimmy Page - the guitar tutor thats so awesome.

    The Edge - the father of the teenage boy who doesnt understand rock n roll music.

  • The Edge lost, give him a dick to suck on.

  • jesus that was good

  • @shw500 I wanted to write the same thing, but you were faster.;)

    But... Who cares, I have to say it: That music is fucking awesome!

  • The Edge is no bluesman, but he enhances the mix with his unique sound. I thought all three were brilliant!

  • god the edge is so shit, two amazing blues/rock guitarists page and white, then the edge, really? he is nothing with out all his effects. jack and jimmy are so raw and pure in there playing, the edge is.... well.... bad.

  • edge is so lame

  • Wait I didn't get to 2:24. That's the only original bit in the whole thing and I thought it was Hendrix coming down to join them! The Edge is an innovator. So what if he doesn't copy blues riffs.

  • Yes the blues isn't Edge's style of music. He has celtic roots. It's different but not worse. Edge sounds like a fiddle or a bagpipe sometimes.

  • Jack is AWESOME

  • Comment removed

  • We have The Edge of a White Page here...

  • Well lads and lassies, great comments, and some shite comments....if any of you can play better than these three bucks, then you deserve to post a bad comment, but I dont think you can. To say that the edge 'fails so much as a guitarist' is a very brave comment, unless of course you are Jimmy, so, keep practicing and keep listening to three of the best masters......

  • @philmordey

    you hit the nail at the core dude! 

  • @philmordey To Many Haters on youtube man, to many people trying to think of something negative, or smart ass to say!!! Shame, but then again... Fuck those people ;-) Rock n Roll...........

  • One is not the same as the others.

  • The edge fails so much as a guitarist and during this whole movie just puts a smile on my face.

  • Jimmy's good, others are pupils.

  • f+ck all these edge haters

  • Comment removed

  • jimmy is god

  • Its like a gun fight at the OK Corral!!

    Which one dares to blink first

  • jacks little solo jus cuts in so much its sound epic

  • Jack and the Edge look kinda stressed and too serious...Jimmy is cool and chilled lol.

  • it might get loud 2.0  Angus Young,Richie Sambora,Lenny Kravitz

    or Iommi,Lifeson,Hetfield,

  • fuck off edge

  • If you appreciate truly great guitar music, this is heaven...

    Hitting the dislike button for this video should carry a mandatory sentence of 20 years, in a cell being forced to listen to Westlife, N-Dubz, and Atomic Kitten !... I know that sounds cruel, but I have no mercy for non-believers

  • i love how their different styles of playing come together

  • jack white almost out plays jimmy page awsome.i think jack white plays the best slide on this vid but jimmy gets the top spot only because its his tune

  • they should make a sequel to it

  • They both have their unique style. Your statement "using effects = lack of skills" is some kind of twisted logic to me.

  • jack just destroys the 'edge' when it comes to slide guitar, and most other aspects of guitar playing, except compensating for lack of skill by using effects, jack doesn't need that

  • einfach nur genial!!!

  • I love jack and his sister.  and I have done for many years. But I never in my wildest imagination ,thought or hoped to see him in in this good company. and by the look of his face during this show.''so didn't he''

    zeppelin, ++U2++ and stripes fan

  • @arveaakra jack's sister?

  • @arveaakra they are not brother and sister. They just told people that so it would be more focused on their music than their relation ship. they are divorced now x

  • thumps up if the next video you search is the rain song

  • 2 dislikes are 2 tooo much...

  • there all eyeballing eachother im better than you no im better than you ok lets have a wanking competition and whoever comes first wins ha hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah hah ahhhhh

  • Jimmy is simply the great and the best of all

  • You can really tell that Jimmy and Jack both have the blues in their veins. The Edge doesn't.

  • @thestranger4812 My thought exactly, Edge is just standing there going what am I supposed to do now.. while Jack and Jimmy are just really into it.. and se at 2.39 I think it is when Jack plays something really cool and the Edge just stares at smiles thinking this dude rocks XD

  • @thestranger4812 He has green in his veins

  • @thestranger4812 theyere al rock legends they all have al kind of music in them the edge no diverend thats why thay aske him!! im sorry but youre comment faills!

  • @thestranger4812

    2:25 check out this solo of The Edge!

  • @wiktor99321 its very average. Jack White and Jimmy Page are miles ahead of The Edge

  • @wiktor99321 It's boring

  • @thestranger4812 Yes, Jack White has "blue veins"

  • @thestranger4812 no cuase edge is what you call a rock guitarist.

  • @thestranger4812 I disagree, the respect Page has for the Edge is palpable, as opposed to his almost dismissive attitude to White, so make what you will of that.

  • @thestranger4812 I think that its good The Edge doesnt , it brings a different level to the peice.....but yeah Page and White are blues..

  • The thing that just gets me about this one is that they all play together and you can without ever watching the video pick out any one of them based on their style :)

  • edge seems lost

  • Minchia!

  • much better than innitial version...

  • Ha ha, Edge looks lost on this effort.

  • great great performance, ...makes my heart melt.. thx so so much for this post

    !!!!

  • Old Dinasour Farts :)

  • well, of course Jimmy is the man here but i kinda think that White stole this song :D he rocked and well im not a big fan of him,and the boy in the cap?? i mean if there were no delays n effects Edge would have propably be in some wedding band...well but he is kinda talented too:) i say put Slash in there. That would be amazing

  • @LovedHatedLoved why put slash in there he's just a poor mans jimmy !

  • @martinsmals The blues, kid.

  • Anyone knows how to get the whole movie?

  • @MusicianMendel Torrents my friend.

  • Jimmy is the man ...Cant take your eyes off him...But The Edge does rather not to well to keep up as does Jakie boy as well.....What a clip .... ;) xx

  • and since when that fat white is a legend sorry?

  • this awesomeness could have destroyed the world thank god it just brought god to earth

  • Page influenced guitar player looking for a band: watch?v=k4H_Qq41Sfk&NR=1

  • all good all have effect on music world now shut up

  • pagey is a guitar pimp that's what he is

  • jimmy is obviously the king here

  • LOL The Edge really sounds best here. Guess why? He's a musician first, and only then a guitarist. Jimmy and Jack are the other way around.

  • The edge rocks this song. with his subtile play he's giving it a nice "edge". unlike others say I think he knows excactly what he's doing.

  • the Edge obviously can't play the slide as well as the two others. He doesn't know what the fuck he's doing. His solos sound exactly like what he always does with U2 and it's weird on that song.

  • Thank Blues Funk

    3 cool !

  • Seems to me that alot of the time, you can only here 2 guitars. Who is the odd one out?? I wonder?!?

  • @taylorjackify Jack White?

  • this is fucking great .

  • What guitar is Jack white playing?

  • @MinusTheDinosaur Jack White play with a Getsh guitar ;)

  • @TotoSoloRock *Gretsh sorry

  • The Edge shouldnt be there he sucks

  • really great clip, starts out kinda of slow but then it gets really good. Thanks for posting

  • Was not a good idea.

  • I always think Jack's solos to resemble a robot short-circuiting and shooting off sparks.

    In a good way.

  • whats up with jimmy's trap???

  • Does the edge en Jimmy have a solid or semi-hollow guitar??

  • @tremedemp hollow

  • you actually have the life to post songs after a 12 hr night .... damn you're good !!

  • At the start, Jack is like:

    'dare i make all my childhood dreams come true and solo over the top