Added: 4 years ago
From: foxnewsSuxx
Views: 136,923
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (265)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why does a video playback speed has been too fast ?

  • OMG i remember this Video of it it fits so well its been a big part of my life

  • I like both this version and the Selena Gomez one, although I think the latter is more in rhythm with the lyrics. :)

  • is not a cover is a living legend

  • esta cancion la escuchaba en 1973 en primero de secundaria en disco de 45 rpm

  • i hate when people comment on videos with this song "OMG why is the old guy singing Selena's song?" Learn before you post

  • What ever happened to Helen Slater??? One of the hottest women on the face of the Earth!!!

  • what is this movie called?

  • A truly aamzing song! One of the world's greatest!

  • Decided to watch your upload coz I like your name!

  • ????? I DONT GET IT

  • Wat...is this i don't even....

  • ....what is happening. it works though

  • @socool101100 IN the words of cartman, "SCREW YOU HIPPIE!"

  • Everything was better back then, im only 15 dont know what its like but when you listen to music you know it was fun times...or the "goldden years" as the old people say but i'd much rather have the old movies tv serries....deffinatly the music :)!!!! those times did have some sort of Magic???

  • @tp4ever1950s i completley agree with you. everything back then was fresh ideas better music. Now a days songs consist on older songs and are usually remade by a newer singer and everyone thinks it is better but they never heard the original and inspiration of the song. When im in the car or on a bus or anything with a radio and i hear today's songs i think what happened to the past?

  • no1 talk about selena. just let her be the whore she is and just listen to the music.

  • u guys love this song my dad has a vidieo type in harold fancher

  • wtf does the video have to do with the song???

  • LOVE THISSONG!!

  • Great Lord! Marvellous original song!!! Poor little child Selena! Which movie is that about Supergirl?

  • no wevees xD..

    es mucho mejor la original..ademas la cancion es antigua que mas quieres que suene como puto regaeton o las canciones de disney y los cariñositos? xD...

    disney te atrofio el oido ;D.

  • it's true that this version is slow, but i think both are good. Selena's reaches out to the youth and also lets people remember classic oldies while this one seems genuine and brings good memories out of a person.

  • Disney have screwed this up good and proper.They got some dolly bird doing the Oh OH OH sex version.Thank God they cant scrap the original.Mind you 10 out of 10 for her looks!!!!!!!

  • they make this song fit so well in the movie happy gilmore

  • yeah they do.lol

  • Comment removed

  • But isn't selena's cover non-natural? I mean, there is a lot of editing that went into the song. Not to her voice though, it's completely her voice. All I am saying is that Pilot made a recording with less effects that selena.

  • I agree with you! Nearly all the songs that are "new" now are useually old songs

    the only differance is that the younger generation sing it instead

  • selena's cover is SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • No.

  • This is much better than Disney's "QUICK! LETS MAKE A MOVIE OUT OF EVERYTHING WE SEE (INCLUDING GINUEA PIGS!! YAY!) AND LETS DO REMAKES OF SONGS THAT ARE MADE OF AWESOME SO PEOPLE LIKE US MORE!" version.

  • i hate when disney characters ruin songs with their fake voices. this original is amazing. Pilot is awsome

  • @halobombs104 Yees! I knoww! ¬¬

  • omg selena stole their song!

  • @danceaholicgurl That is a very Crap don't you?

  • @danceaholicgurl It's called a cover... But she sucks so idc

  • @danceaholicgurl Yeah. Pilot is waaay better than Selena Gomez and other pop artists of today. XD

  • @missmagicaladventure Eminem is better than pilot

  • @TrentonsGap lol I'm not a huge Eminem fan, so i have to disagree...no offense of course. :)

  • @danceaholicgurl thats called cover... but the true thing is that the original is best :D

  • With a name like "JBFan" I don't think you can make calls on what's good music.

  • i love this song its awesome, this and selena gomez version are both amazing.

  • Bollocks from me, I grew up in 70s Edinburgh and this is my cousin David Paton on lead vocals.

    I think that it is very ignorant to suggest that if it was'nt for Selena then people wouldnt have heard of this song, who is this girl anyway? But I really dont care as its Pilot that I want to hear.

  • 9 minutes and somone spammed this message idk why

  • Holy cow it Helen Slater lol

  • love this SONG!!!

    (im a TWILIGHTER!!!!!!)

  • dude selena sucks so much this original version is so much better because it actually tells you a real message

  • yup

  • this song is better when selena sings it

  • Yeah? Music today is always Digitized in some way. In the 70's (the time this was made), you had to have one hell of a good voice to sound like this.

    I'm sure with proper training, your next door neighbor could sound like this through Digital Alteration. :P

  • Why must disney stars have to go around terrorizing great songs, and ruining them?

  • well, not all. :)

  • I like Selena's version better because, even though this one is lovely, her version is more upbeat. But this version rocks too.

    Don't hate on Selena for covering this song. It was a smart career move. Besides, you're giving her more press for hating on her.

  • @rbdfan1718 cant beat the classics man.

  • i love this. NEVER gets old.

  • You can't forget the classics! Jeez, I wish we had something like a National 80's Day or something. LOL.

  • i like this version better than selena's, but hers is ok. you guys dont have to be mean about it. i only knew she had made a cover of this because of all your comments, and when i searched it it definitely wasnt that terrible. how much you wanna bet most of you bein meanto her listened to hers and THEN found this version?

  • No not me mate.

    Ah, Edinburgh in the 70s, great summers and a great band who played great tunes.

    I dont know who Selena is, Im 42 years old and this is my cousin David Paton on lead vocals and bass guitar. I have'nt seen anything from Disney since The Junglebook lol, but opinions are like buttholes, we all have one.

    Love from Bonnie Scotland.

  • OH, And another thing that I forgot to mention, This song was sung by Scottish football fans on the terraces of most grounds in Scotland before Selena who ever she is............. Mother was born. lol

  • music is......... a fail now a days. Classic Rock and Motown, oldies............. tthat's the good music

  • Selena sucks. THIS IS WAY BETTER!

  • OMG shut up about stupid wannabe disney stars they're only disney stars because they couldn't make it any bigger. This original is soooooo better than selena's I like hers but it's not that good. And myfriendisdobby, I agree but I'm a teen and I love this version and am not a fan of selena's.

  • Comment removed

  • oh and i agree with myfriendisdobby

  • demi lavato is better then selena. haa!

  • Yay the original is way better! I hate the disney crap!

  • omg can people stop saying selena's is better? no it isn't! hers is a remake so it's def. not better and it doesn't help that she's from disney remaking it and music these days suck so little teenagers be quiet about what music and versions are good or not when you haven't heard real good music

  • The cover is never better than the original, especially when its covered by some wannabe, disney star. god. Real music was made in the era of rock and roll!

  • one thing that REALLY pisses me off is that every time i search pilot - magic half of the list is selena gomez...

  • uhh its O.K. but i preffer selena's version!

  • I like them both.

  • GUYS!! It just really depends on your own taste and, in alot of cases, which one you listened to first. I like Selena's better, but I also listened to it first. Do we really need to argue over it? Neither party will give in to the other so it's pointless. Plus, everybody has their own personal opinion. Jeez.

  • the orginal is always better than the cover.

  • That's not always true. The Beatles cover of Please Mr Postman is better than the original by The Carpenters, in my opinion. Though in this case, I think that's true. It depends on what kind of music you like.

  • i thought i added the original is usually always better than the cover.... sorry. ):

    but it's very rare when the cover is better than the orginal.

  • agreed

  • I hate how now every time I listen to this song on youtube someone always comments on how Selena's version is way better. Not here to listen to Selena's version folks.

  • selenas version sucked so bad this song is way better than shell ever be:)

  • ugh i cant stand this selenas version is wayyyyyyyyyy better

  • selena "gonads" is a bitch

  • If it's bad, don't listen to it.

  • selena gomez didnt steal the song!! she did a cover for it! how is that so wrong!!!!!

  • she didnt steal it..she sang it for Disney..blame Disney not Selena..shes under a contract wit dem so dey prob made her sing it

  • she did a cover! its not her fault

    bsides her version is better :)

  • i luv this version i used to hear it when my mom got the old disco CD!

  • this song is awesomely amazing:D

    i love it wayy more than selenas version lol....i ♥♥♥♥♥ this sond:D

  • I AM SO OVER SELENA GOMEZ. the truth is half of how ignorant listeners would never have even heard this song if it wasnt for her and its disgusting.

  • its true selena stole this song and i can prove my self right

  • yup she did did song is the classic

  • How come ts "Stole" Now, She did a COVER! not stole

  • Did she give credit to Pilot?

  • I Dunno, I Guess so

  • she didnt steal the song she did a cover for it!!!

  • i like the original better! but selena's is good tooziess. (;

  • can't beat the original.

  • what is this movie called?

  • super girl lol not joking

  • lol really? i want to watch it haha

  • Comment removed

  • Selena Gomez rocks =)

  • u people should hear selena gomez's cover of ''magic''. she sounds great too!

  • hell no she doesn't. It's called computer "magic" XD

  • thats funny

  • selena's verison is better :)

  • happy gilmore!!!!!

  • ???? ok random

  • u never saw that movie, this song was in it

  • i saw happy gilmore but it cant say i remeber te song i might watch the movie again

  • The singers voice has a cool accent to it, love this song.

  • Thats because David Paton is from Edinburgh and most folk from Edinburgh have a cool accent.

    His family were very close with my parents as our fathers were both singers, infact........ Now this is where it gets complicated. My grannys brother was Davids Dad, so I suppose he is a 2nd cousin.................. I think, lol.

    I

  • the blond girl is like really pretty!

  • lol. super HOT Woman

  • good song but wired video

  • lol flo rider and selena gomez took this song

  • DUH

  • Everyone should stop talking about Selena's version. This is by Pilot, not Selena. Go comment on her vid if you wanna talk about her.

  • GUYS STOP TALKING ABOUT SELENA! THIS ISNT SONG ISNT ABOUT HER! And i know she sang it and all but seriously its not about her! Who really gives a crap about her! this is Pilot's song so talk about THEM!!!!!

  • ya but ppl can say what ever they want && ppl are just giving thier opinions so SHhhhhhhhhh

  • Ok I will, I was at the Usher Hall in Edinburgh to see them in 1978 and I was 12 years old, His family (David Paton) were very close to ours, infact its my grannys brothers son. Me mum and my twin brother and Davids parents were backstage after the gig, but at 12 years old it never quite gave me as big a kick then as this song does now at 42.

    This is a classic as were a good few others of Pilots music...............I loved January.

    Honestly mate I dont know who this Selena girl is.

  • thats coz you´re old ;)

    young folks don´t know Pilot or David Paton

  • I'm 19 and I know them. My baby sister is 7 and knows them. Your argument is invalid.

  • Great song. The original is the best version, period. HOWEVER, it should be know that Paton's brother Tam was a perverted child molester who raped two members of the Bay City Rollers, the band he managed.

  • Yeah they know Jonas brothers, Miley, selena, all that crap im only 15 (young for you) and i love Pilot so shut up, and old music Owns todays music (today is ust techno gyam robot make over and kids crap) i wish i was born back than.

  • Selena's is good, but it's like...

    edited.

  • super woman/girl? ne ways i kinda like selena's version better cuz well.....she's awsome

  • i'm not hating on selena, but in the music video 'magic' the voice is EXTREMELY editted. listen to her sing live in her video "my new family" and she sings a little part of she's a lady by herself and it's obvious she's not very good.

  • go listen to her sing in the video "the reason i miss home" she sings a thousnad miles by vanessa carlton! she sings better in that one compared to "shes a lady"!

  • I like selena's well i like her in general! but i think she sings it very good so that is my opinion they are both good but i like selena's a little better but then again this is a classic! idk.... selena's i think ( in my opinion) was better =) peace!

  • Are you kidding me! Selena Gomez version ruins the song!

  • There must be something wrong with your ears.

  • i think selena gomez did an okay job but this version is way better. her version was WAY WAY WAY too edited.

  • selena sings it a little different, but i like this better cuz on her video u can hear that they helped with her vid

  • look, sel gomez, version is good, but without this song she woudnt even have a song to sing

  • ok fuck you they made the song it was made for a male to sing so if u r tring to say selena is a dude ur gay he made give hem props fag

  • this version is wayyy better than the Selena Gomez version...

    she just KILLED the song =(

  • lol i no rite!

  • shut up

  • it better with Selena Gomez

  • ok fuck you they made the song it was made for a male to sing so if u r tring to say selena is a dude ur gay he made give hem props fag

  • Her version is fine, but if you came to watch this just to comment and act like a Selena fangirl/boy then, thats a bit sad, this is the original and best form of the song.

  • i think how selena sang this song wz nice and ok... and it wz how i got to like this song

  • omggg this song is 23948029480324803284 x's better in its original format!

  • selena gomez absolutely killed this song!

    i love the original, and im only 13!!!

  • ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff­ffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuureal

  • hahaha I agree.

  • you so right she should write her own songs..

    or better she stick to acting..she can't really sing..sorry selena but it't true

  • selena gomez fucked this song up.

    the original is better

  • lmao, I agree :)

  • Yeahh! I thought the same thing

  • Comment removed

  • never believe its not so