speak 5/10
9:14
Added: 3 years ago
From: mcrlover666lover
Views: 56,440
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (229)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I don't understand why the mother didn't notice how much different she was behaving than she was before. The father noticed. She seems especially unobservant.

  • I've never seen a movie that was so spot on to how I feel. The secrets, and then the breakdown. People thinking you're "weird" I'm finally dealing with situation and its been years in the making. Its hard to describe to somebody how alone you feel when nobody gets why you cant just "get over it" "move on" I still feel like it happened yesterday, slowly but surely I am putting my life back together. This movie is what sparked my own self-discovery. It broke down the walls that I built up.

  • @ecull515 I feel for you! but one thing is...let go of the pain..see the present..and then you'll be able to move on.

  • first tym & she kiss her .. aesa to hota hi he aese kamoooooooon mn.. stupid

  • 2:04 What a bitch....

  • This is a hard movie to watch when you know how Melinda feels </3

  • @Plovdivsko Sorry I guess I was being bitchy, it's actually good to see that some people wouldn't just let that kind of shit happen

  • @Plovdivsko do you seriously think it's that easy? Not only it can be so traumatic you can be paralysed but beat the shit out of someone almost twice as tall as you won't have much effect!

  • at 8:42 it looks like kristen has one green eye and one blue eye

  • To everyone saying how horrible and inattentive her mom is, you should note that she does see something wrong when she wakes Melinda, she just doesnt pry about it. She even tries to comfort Melinda, so she should at least get props for that, I think.

  • THIS IS A SAD MOVIE=( the mom thinks everything is gonna be okay when its not!

  • THIS IS A SAD MOVIE=(

  • that Andy Evens is an asshole. RAPER!!!!

  • evan is a bastard if she doesnt want to do SHE DOESNT WANT TO DO IT

    FOR FUCK SAKE

  • holy crap i can't bare to look at that scene

  • That's stupid, there's such a thing as getting in trouble for teachers who give away too many A's? What are they supposed to do if their students all do excellent work? I don't get that at all.

  • oh my god! those cries in the car tore me apart inside. And i know the mum didn't mean it, but when she said Melinda would forget it in 5 years i wanted to slap her.

  • @aidygiz1 I don't think her mum knows exactly what happened. Although I can't believe that she didn't realize that her daughter was going through something serious, where's that mother's instinct?

  • the mom is really clueless.. i cant believe it..>_<.. i hate the rape seen..!!!!

  • I just hate the rape scene! Really.. I'm almost crying everytime iøm watching it. It makes me feel soooo sad!

  • this is probably one of the scariest things i've ever watched despite all of the horror movies:(

  • @sexywrestledevil You want to see something even more sadder and terrifying? Watch: The Girl Next Door by Jack Ketchum. Its even more brutal than this, like 10X more. A girl gets locked in her aunts basement and gets tortured by a group of kids, including her Aunt.And yea, more than one rape scene, and yea its based on a true story.

  • @BewareOfJay wow i dont want to see anything too sad but is i a lifetime movie?

  • @sexywrestledevil Nope! But still its a good movie even though its really twisted. Im a guy and it even made me cry. Its that bad.

  • @BewareOfJay I saw the trailer...and it looks a cruel. If it makes a guy cry...then im sure it would make me cry too...i realized that people called it a horror movie.

  • !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I cried the first time I watched the rape scene... We watched this movie in class too ._.

  • WOW....

    the mom is clueless...

  • the boogie man , seriously ?lol her her mom is weird .

  • I really hate when schools crack down on the GOOD teachers. The ones that care about their students and what they're teaching. It's real bullshit.

  • OMG, I was wondering what caused the girl her silence from the start of the movie. When I first saw her with the guy, I thought she was heart broken because he cheated on her or something. But after seeing the horrible incident, I was stopped dead for a few seconds because of shock. I didn't cry for that scene and the rest of the movie but felt utterly helpless and empty just like the girl did. I was literally shaking when trying to finish the rest of the movie.

  • est-ce que ses yeux sont les couleurs diferentes à huit minutes quarante-cinq?

  • est-ce que ses yeux sont les couleurs differents a huit minutes dix-neuf?

  • eww nasty rapist! that is sooooo disturbing. she shulda cut his nasty butt, send him to jail!

  • Poooooor kristen.(Middle Finger) 2 the rapist

  • WCA's peperrallys are just like that

  • Um. Probably both....

  • that bond girl is a trick and i wannt kill that guy so bad

  • she was saying NO and he covered her mouth, so the muffled screams are the sounds. he planned it out, drew her to his car, pinned her down and when she couldnt move or get help, he undid his pants, got under her skirt. he was too heavy to fight off. i dont know how a rape scene can be criticized. so sad

  • @kerrishasinger

    Personally, I think everyone should see the scene because it might teach people to be more compassionate towards each other, that their behavior might hurt someone else. I think the actors and director did a good job, portraying it accurately.

  • @kerrishasinger

    I think Melinda made noises because it physically hurt her to be raped: You can't help but make animal noises when someone is hurting you like that. I think she screamed, afterwards, in shock.

  • I wouldn't go out with him alone like that. Kinda creepy.

  • not what i meant.

  • lol i thought dat to!!!!

  • this movie gives me chills

  • I actully like Hairy Woman. I don't know why though. She just seems like a good hearted person.

  • We're still watching the movie in English II class

    We have to write an essay after the movie =(

  • this is a good movie but i just think that is so sad that she got raped!!! :(

  • on 8:42, one of Melinda's eyes are purple and the other is green. did they give her color contacts?

  • Kirsten Stewart looks too much like Jodie Foster for her own good.

  • No I'm too old for it...its cool that others like it...I havent slagged it off...I didn't even know what it was till I asked people here and they told me.

  • God, I hate this part cuz everytime i'm alone with this guy (senior) I worry and freak out about what could happen and have to go somewhere else,

    As good as this movie is, it just puts paranoia in me. :) / :(

  • hey guys! a would love to read the book, but a just cant find it, does anyone knows were I can buy it, or find it on line?

  • it's usually in the young adults section at any book store

  • i got mine from a book store

  • @jimencv

    You can find the book online, on Amazon.

  • wth is wrong with the mom how did she not notice anything...

  • hahaz good point

  • i lov this movie and the book was awesome

  • I agree with what you're saying

    however, I'd like to point out that kristen stewart is in twilight, therefore, she is related to twilight

  • I still cant understand how her mother coldnt note that something was wrong with her dauther??

  • sad deal, can't believe that happened to her and now she's totally neglected and hated. pobrecita!

  • Oh wow people. "Teenyboppers" like Twilight? My mom likes Twilight. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean you always have to tell people about how stupid you think they sound because they like it. The book was better than the movie. The people who don't like it, probably have only seen the movie. Pick up a book and put down the remote the next time you want to comment on it.

    This was Kristen's best movie. I can't wait to get the book.

  • @0kbaby0 well even if people did read the books, it wouldn't make much of a difference. I read the books and watched the movies, and I still think the Twilight series is dull. I admit it had a potential to go somewhere greater, and the author whom I met when I was a fan was really nice and I liked her, but no, I don't recommend the series to anyone. If anything, people should pick up old classics

  • yesss

  • 4:16

    nice

  • just because kristen stewart comes out in this movie doesnt mean you have to compare it to twilight damn all you teeny boppers suck the life out of everything. NOT EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE IS ABOUT TWILIGHT AND YOUR MUSICALS!

  • iloveyou

  • Oh god... How can no one see what's wrong? If anyone I knew were acting like that, I wouldn't abandon her. God... What the hell... Kristen Stewart is an amazing actress who conveyed that scene with such realistic emotion...

  • Its times like these I thank god for bieng born a man. I couldn't even picture going through something like that.

  • i have a teacherr who ttalks exactly like her

  • Ohmygod I love the art teacher.

  • when that girl says about how do you know thats what he ment i said that excat same sentance to my english teacher lol

  • It is. Like the book cover.

  • "S for straightforward" made me laugh a lot.

    And the scene where it happened made me cry. It was scary how it honestly showed how a situation like that can go from perfect, fun, fantasy to dangerous and threatening and irreversable and a nightmare our of nowhere and there's nothing you can do about it.

  • OMG I feel really bad for her but I really find it funny where her mom says "It's ok the boogie mans gone he went right out that way" I dunno why but I laugh every time and It makes me feel bad :(

  • i don't understand. her acting is amazing here. but it's shit in twilight

  • I second that.

  • what is Twilight?

  • are you being serious ? lol

    twilight?

    it's a book about vampires (there are four books altogether). they made a movie - kristen played the main character - last year. it came out in nov 08. the next one is coming out in nov 09, called new moon.

    i can't believe u haven't heard of it! i use to love it. but i'm bored with it now. i prefer the tv show "true blood".

  • I'm 25 not 14...so I don't follow up on the Jonas people,Mily Cyrus and HSM happenings.That type of thing is of no interest to me.I like my vampire movies on an adult level like The Thirst,Interview with a Vampire and The Hunger 18+

  • its not even romotely close to anything disney--it has a bit more substance then a Disney feature with the oh so out played story lines. Its like a romeo and juliet kind of thing. Not really much of a watch unless you are like a die hard romantic. Books had more power then the movie did.

  • okay no thats wrong twilight was released november 21 last year and new moon will be released november 20 this year

  • Yeah thanks...people are so obsessive about this Twilight flick.Thank God I'm not a teenybopper.

  • Everyone was laughing when she started spazzing out on the floor.

  • my hands were shaking and i don't think that i am EVER going 2 forget that . in some ways i wish i hadn't seen it but in others i do - does enyone understand wat im saying?

    This has really made me think.

    great actress !

    Yeah! one green one blue - weird ! :L:L xx

  • i think im D a dreamer

  • wow.

    thats all I can say.

    Kristen is really an amazing actress

  • one eye is blue and the other is green just like the cover of the book

  • if i were raped and would have seen my rapist again i'd kick his ass spit at him and send him to jail

  • no the hell it ain't alright

  • HE MOVED THE STILL LIFE!!!!

    ugh... get some reference before u make a scene u dont know shit about....

  • gosh her eyes are weird. no offense but this quality is crap dont ya think? its really annoying.

  • yeah!

  • it does.that's weard

  • wow. i'm glad they don't make the band do that at our pep rallies. i would probably shoot myself.

  • Omg that rape scene brought tears to my eyes ='[ i felt soo bad. kristen acted really well in this movie.

  • omg at 7.18 is that hallee hirsh??

  • That scene brought tears to my eyes. ;m; Oh god, that was horrible

  • This movie has one of the most brutal rape scenes (psychologically). I say this because Melinda is still a little girl while this guy is practically a fucking adult, she is just so helpless and defenseless it make me want to vomit when he rapes her.

  • I definitely agree. In some ways, this movie reminds me of the movie The Color Purple. Just sad and sick.

  • ya i know i loooove twilight

  • if only edward was around.. LMAO!!! does any one else notice in this movie, how close related some scenes r to twilight?? lol like the apple, her walking into her class, etc. ?? maybe its just me.. lol

  • andy was probably thinking melida score-deno! what a perv andy is!

  • im the same as u i didnt stop moving my feet and was sad 4 her

  • omg... in the rape scene I got really anxious and couldn't stop moving my feet

    made me wanna scream

    hahaha

    her mother's conforting tip "you know people sometimes just suck"

  • i love how she wears a hood.

  • this is a really good movie lol kittaycated89!

  • I agree with Rachel; symbolism is a crock of bull.

  • it was so sad i cried

  • how come I already am crying? this movie is just amazing.

  • i agree with maddison31797 i havent either.

    the blond is kinda like jessica on twilight because jessicas like a talkative girl like the blond

  • * If you've read Midnight Sun Edwars Perspective the you would know that jessica is a real bitch. XD LOOOOL. But yeah i agree

  • oh my.

    I love this movie<3

    But i feel bad for Language teacher.

  • wht happenend wht did he do

  • ...Did you even watch the scene. He raped her!

  • It happens to guys too. It's sad, but it happens.

  • ya but it happens 2 girls more

    and when it happenes 2 guys,almost all the time itz by an adult and 4 girsls...well...that usually get raped by n e body

  • Actually, sorry to seem rude, but it happens to guys /just as much/ as girls.

    And yeah, girls rape people. Teenage girls do.

  • tht rape scene was so horrible

    ppl dont give her enough credit for how good an actor she is

  • Yes. I'm glad that someone, perhaps the director, understood the helplessness, where you can't stop yourself from making noises, even though you're embarrassed and wish you could. Usually, I see poor caricatures on films or t.v shows, where it's obvious that the actor, director and/or screenwriter haven't experienced an attack. I'm glad someone on the film crew understood.

  • You are never more helpless than when someone attacks you and won't stop.

  • this iz jus 2 sad

  • ye it is

  • does her mum know she was raped?

  • as far as i know no

  • nope. the mom said "the boogeyman went that way" she probably doesnt know.

  • maybe she thinks that andy is really the boogie man trying to shove his in girls

  • Twilight was a horrible movie because of the low budget

  • that rape scene was crazy...Kirsten was amazing...I thought i was about to scream...

  • if there's one thing i hate more than pep rallies, it's those god damn cheerleaders

  • Hahaha I agree.

  • Oh God, the rape scene made me want to take a scalding hot bath :P

  • also, if twilight sucked so bad, millions of viewers would not be in love with the story, or the movie. and a movie does not win awards for a book. i can guarantee that most people didnt even hear of the book before the movie.

    don't talk trash about an actress un less you can do better. they do what they are told to do by the directors and other people making the movie. every expression, body movement, or even sound is either in the script or they are told to do it. thats how acting works.

  • well said!!!!

  • Millions of preteen girls like a horrible movie because 1) marketing 2) a hot lead actor. It happened with the backstreet boys... is still happening with the jonas brothers. It'll happen again.

  • Fuck Twilight....I read Hawthorne.

  • many of you don't know what you are talking about. I think Kristen Stewart is a great actress. If she weren't she wouldn't be famous.

    And with Twilight, that is a different story. People hate it because it isn't exactly like the book. If you're one of those, read the partial draft of Midnight Sun on Stephanie Meyer, the author of twilight's website. It is twilight in edward cullen's point of view, and the movie is pretty exact to it.

  • People (aka those above 12) hate the Twilight because it's a bad movie. I actually liked the books alot.... the movie was just... plain a horrible movie. If there was no book people would hate it.

    That said, Kristen Stewart is a brilliant actress. Don't believe me check out her other work like Into the Wild and especially Adventureland. THIS is an actress.

  • whoa...on 8:42...one of her eyes is green and the other one is blue...

  • omg your right. thats so scary

    but it looks cool aswelll

  • i heard that they couldnt really express their eyes and the stuff the way they wanted too...that could be something...but i also think its that they didnt know what they were getting into so they went by the script not the book and all the emotions it talks about in it that would have made it a better movie...

  • 5:41 is a perfect time to tell her mother what really happened. she seemed to really care for her daughter and if i was her i would told the truth.

  • You should read the book...

  • she looks like avril lavigne at 6:50

  • i dont get why she isnt as good of an actress in twilight then in here.

  • ew the rap part is gross shes over

    there screaming and hes enjoying it (having sex and stuff) ugh just sick and twisted

    that poor thing!

  • omg i was just crying this is so sad i mean i can really relate to her in so many ways!!

  • Me too. I hated feeling different from everyone else, seeing them laughing and smiling...

  • yeah... it's sad. wait, how did he..take off her pants and his?? that's weird.. she should've pulled his hair. poor melinda

  • i think that when he raped her he only when on her blouse. that's why she didn't get pregnant that would be a much diffrent story ha

  • i totaly no how u feel. i went threw the same thing as melinda and going to skewl each day noing that u r gonna get picked on and embarrased, it's hard and tireing.

  • la violo, o solo fue un sueño?

  • la violo :S

  • I've neva cried at a film b4, but this is pretty sad.. :( poor M

  • that art teacher is so right though...

  • why dont any of the girls that play in these types of movies ever stand up for themselves time being

  • Hey what's up with you people giving cherrybomb thumbs downs about their opinion? They're kind of right. They DID act terrible towards Melinda, nobody bothered to even ask what had happened to her that she called the police. And cherrybomb is right, nobody ever knows the full story and what immature high schoolers REALLY care if a party got broken up and carry a grudge for THAT LONG? Kind of pathetic.

  • ur right no one even asked waht happened!!if they at least knew they wouldnt bother her that much!! and right who cares about a stupid party!!!

  • "if i ever started a clan we'd be the Anti Cheerleaders...we'd walk underneath the bleachers and commit mild acts of mayhem" i miss the part when she talks about cheerleaders XD that part made me rofl

  • actually i'm surprised they didn't do alot WORSE to her

  • This hight school looks bit smaller than most. Its not ridiculous.

  • The people at the party would have remembered. It's the downfall of high school. The people involved remember and tell their friends.

  • that is soooo sad. i get so tense when i watch this scene.