@mark33033: Yes, it's me playing, but it was just off the cuff noodling to try to sell the guitar. I've since lowered the action so it plays a lot easier. ( 'cause it didn't sell ). I really need to post some proper vids of my music..... You guys really are GOOD! I just subscribed to you. Hurray for talent, and music with feeling and melodies ;)
harpsichord? Maybe one of the guitarists could play that part on a keyboard rather than the guitar. Also... The backround harmony doesn't move around like that. It's mostly one note... less vibrato too please.
Great cover guys! Spot on! You guys sound great. The singer sounds a bit like Eric Carmen, which is nothing to be ashamed of, he had some great pipes. Wish I coulda seen this live!
Allright Aftermath! Loved the Left Banke original in '66. The 4 Tops cover in '67 was pretty good, but I didn't hear Southside Johnnys 1986 recording until today. Really love the vocals in that.
The two lead singers are so smooth together, they make it seem so easy:) The female lead singer brings an amazing quality to the sound. She's really great. Both singers are great. The whole band is fabulous. I was so enthusiastic about this performance I shared it with my partner, who was equally impressed.
It was a true pleasure and surprise to learn this was a cover and not the LEFT BANK performing in some small venue. Your whole style and sound indicates that you obviously have taken very seriously the reproduction of such an old classic rainy day ballad. Please if you are so inclined do share any others you may have and I hope you stay together as a musical combo deserving of much success!!
I always thought the four tops were the original author's of this song and the left banke was covering them. It was only a few days ago that it was vice versa.
The Left Banke was the original band that recorded this song in '66, not the Four Tops. This band is absolutely blow this song out of the ballpark. Even better than the original. Fantastic, man! The best cover of this song by a mile!!!
i can't find the original video in youtube of Left Banke performing in a park. i saw it about 2 years ago, but i can't find it now. not sure if Youtube has removed it due to some infringement rights.
Congratulations on a fantastic performance which so captures the feel of the original Left Banke version. So many covers after The Four Tops just fail to get the sadness of the song. This is great. Come to the UK some time :o)
it would be nice to see more of the leftbanks this was a big part of my youth that would love to get a chance to revisit my old life renee was one of my nicknames i loved this song raine
@goldenglovegreek59 , This song was written by a member of the Left Banke about the girlfriend of another member. The 4 Tops covered it a couple of years later. I like both versions equally.
@goldenglovegreek59 It was actually written by Michael Brown, keyboard player and founder of the Left Banke in 1966. It was then covered in 1967 by the Four Tops but didn't chart until 1968, where it hit #14 on the Billboard Chart.
Very good cover of a song that brings back so many memories of my young teen years, first loves, long summer days & evenings and how time flown by seemingly overnight. Have you thought about adding "Love Grows" to your repertoire? Seems like it would fit right in.
I remember it well.. Dayton Ohio. Cavern's.. You use the equiptment of a band called the Trojan's.. I wondered what happened to you, think of you often!
I have to watch this at least once every day now, I'm addicted to it! I really like your voice in this song, Mark. It's perfect for it! You would be great doing a Guess Who song like "These Eyes". Maybe you guys could try doing that one sometime.
Wow! You have a great voice, Mark! :) Keep it up! Would love to hear you another of the Left Banke's hits, "Pretty Ballerina". Your voice and style would be perfect for it!
Amazing performance! This is as good as the original.
audiotrax2000 3 weeks ago
@audiotrax2000 Thanks
We really appreciate that.
Is that you playing the Gibson acoustic?. Sounds really good
mark33033 3 weeks ago
@mark33033: Yes, it's me playing, but it was just off the cuff noodling to try to sell the guitar. I've since lowered the action so it plays a lot easier. ( 'cause it didn't sell ). I really need to post some proper vids of my music..... You guys really are GOOD! I just subscribed to you. Hurray for talent, and music with feeling and melodies ;)
audiotrax2000 3 weeks ago
Nice version of a great classic song. You guys sound great.
cforssi 1 month ago
Well done!
PorkyPants 2 months ago
I've just seen a face, actually, it was Macca looking at an After-Math Album cover....Any connection to this group???
billy38010 3 months ago in playlist left bank
wow! Very nice cover!
Sueski2 6 months ago
Sounds like the drummer never read the lyrics. This is a very sad song of love lost. The drummer would rather go to war.
JaiUneGuruDeja 6 months ago
I was at that show. Jeff Stoll
BlueKatBoneYard 7 months ago
I was at that show. Jeff stoll
BlueKatBoneYard 7 months ago
You guys nailed it on too many levels to even list. An amazing performance.
lancetop 7 months ago
Thank You. Means alot
mark33033 8 months ago
BEST VERSION I EVER HEARD. YOU GUYS NAILED IT.
Peteo67 8 months ago
Excellent cover! Well done Mark
A lot of memories!
ronnelson82 9 months ago
their up-beat version is really good...............great tune
pkappel006 1 year ago
Know what you get when the Left Banke meets the Four Tops? AFTERMATH ! Excellent in every respect guys!
craigs1001 1 year ago
Wow! Great job.
TheFloridaPappy 1 year ago
harpsichord? Maybe one of the guitarists could play that part on a keyboard rather than the guitar. Also... The backround harmony doesn't move around like that. It's mostly one note... less vibrato too please.
Over all very good... sorry about the nitpicking.
b3organ 1 year ago
Great job. Needs to be a bit slower though.
stadalberts 1 year ago
great !!!!!!!!!!!
mthrnatrsson1 1 year ago
I like the little staccato thing and the chord shifts at the middle eight -- a unique play-off on the original.
pdorn777 1 year ago
Great cover guys! Spot on! You guys sound great. The singer sounds a bit like Eric Carmen, which is nothing to be ashamed of, he had some great pipes. Wish I coulda seen this live!
drumbeato 1 year ago
Wow, what a terrific cover!!! Thanks for posting so I could hear it.
BruDiggity 1 year ago
Thanks Lulu
mark33033 1 year ago
~ This was beautiful...thank you so much.~ lulu
victorianlulu 1 year ago
Allright Aftermath! Loved the Left Banke original in '66. The 4 Tops cover in '67 was pretty good, but I didn't hear Southside Johnnys 1986 recording until today. Really love the vocals in that.
RobMackenzie 1 year ago
Wow.. Very good cover of this groovy song. it sounds like the original...
galcivare 1 year ago
Woah!!! You guys are amazing, i watched the Incense And Peppermints cover and it was amazing too
bigfootisreal100 1 year ago
The two lead singers are so smooth together, they make it seem so easy:) The female lead singer brings an amazing quality to the sound. She's really great. Both singers are great. The whole band is fabulous. I was so enthusiastic about this performance I shared it with my partner, who was equally impressed.
lancetop 2 years ago
thoroughly enjoyed it.
lancetop 2 years ago
Excellent job!!! I thought it blended elements of both the original by the Left Banke and the cover recorded by The Four Tops.
aargoldtakesflight 2 years ago 8
@aargoldtakesflight Exactly what I was thinking!
JohnnyCxviii 2 weeks ago
Nice job!
Shimmeringsmiley 2 years ago 3
Very good cover of a great song. Thanks
70schild63 2 years ago 3
Sounding like the original. Love it!
Byrds1967 2 years ago
Very nice cover. Well done.
gmtruitt9 2 years ago 2
This is an absolutely wonderful version. I was very much taken aback when I heard it. Thank you! Pam Renee
PamelaTGNC 2 years ago 3
Wow, what a fantastic version!! Thank you :)
circles69 2 years ago 3
I have no idea who this band are.....but that is a bloody good cover!
oilinmyblood 2 years ago
It was a true pleasure and surprise to learn this was a cover and not the LEFT BANK performing in some small venue. Your whole style and sound indicates that you obviously have taken very seriously the reproduction of such an old classic rainy day ballad. Please if you are so inclined do share any others you may have and I hope you stay together as a musical combo deserving of much success!!
-Hank Frealy Ottawa,Ont. CANADA
stankerino 2 years ago 5
Thank you for the kind comments.
We have some more videos under mark33033
mark33033 2 years ago
I like that you sped it up, you put your own spin on it. You folks did a great job, you sound great.
HankLandMan 2 years ago
Good thing for Pro-Tools
Floorbird 2 years ago
groovy tune ;)
Zippertheslipper 2 years ago
great rendition, absolutely (to quote a 60's line) fab..,.
revwjh 2 years ago
hey guys...is there any documentary on Left Banke? i like to know more about the band.
mikelee8873 2 years ago
I don't know of any.
mark33033 2 years ago
@mark33033
There's also an official Facebook fan page by founding member and bass player Tom Finn (Renée's actual boyfriend at the time)
Evertje1962 1 year ago
@mark33033
There's an official fan site, but somehow I can't mention that here, lol. It's the band's name, dot nu.
Evertje1962 1 year ago
Steve Tyler (Aerosmith)on background vocal
bobbysinatra 2 years ago
I always thought the four tops were the original author's of this song and the left banke was covering them. It was only a few days ago that it was vice versa.
tempo1889 2 years ago
Too fast....slow it down....enjoy the ride....
KOOLDAVE1953 2 years ago 3
very nice cover of a LEFT BANKE hit! 5 *
cebfolk 2 years ago
Good Job!! Very nice.
ravevden 2 years ago
Wow..good work!..fantastic cover :))
oilinmyblood 2 years ago 2
The Left Banke was the original band that recorded this song in '66, not the Four Tops. This band is absolutely blow this song out of the ballpark. Even better than the original. Fantastic, man! The best cover of this song by a mile!!!
acall2rise 2 years ago
Nice job, they even look like the Left Banke.
spiritbearNY 2 years ago
This is my favorite song...am collecting all the versions...I am looking for that original video in the park...will post when I find it..
trixielaroux 2 years ago 2
The original keeps being removed in all it's forms. It's really a shame, as the song is such a hauntingly beautiful ballad. Good luck.
scubawrestler 2 years ago
i can't find the original video in youtube of Left Banke performing in a park. i saw it about 2 years ago, but i can't find it now. not sure if Youtube has removed it due to some infringement rights.
mikelee8873 3 years ago 2
awesome and classy!
leebarbie 3 years ago
Congratulations on a fantastic performance which so captures the feel of the original Left Banke version. So many covers after The Four Tops just fail to get the sadness of the song. This is great. Come to the UK some time :o)
VFDGFact 3 years ago
That guy {girl?} on the organ did a great job. Sounds just like the original version.
stadalberts 3 years ago
Really good cover, as I remember the song.
ConditionalID 3 years ago
it would be nice to see more of the leftbanks this was a big part of my youth that would love to get a chance to revisit my old life renee was one of my nicknames i loved this song raine
raine6178 3 years ago
Comment removed
goldenglovegreek59 3 years ago
Thanks goldengrovegfreek
Went to your page.
Is that really your dog getting your newspaper?
that was really cool.
mark33033 3 years ago
Actually, Left Banke were first in 66. One of the few times a black band (4 tops) ever covered a white one.
maxweisenfeld 3 years ago
Actually, Michael Brown of the Left Banke wrote the song while with the group. He wrote it for his babysitter, whom he had an early crush on.
The Four Tops performed the cover among countless other groups thereafter.
munchkiecocoa 3 years ago
no he wrote it about a girl named Renee Fladen who was going with LB bassist Tom Finn and was part of their circle
brilliantcolors7 3 years ago
She then broke up with Finn left the scene and they never saw or heard of her again!
021jonnyone 3 years ago
021jonnyone, I guess she really did walk away.
HS22181 2 years ago
OMG. Tom Finn!! Did you know them? We did and my gf had such a crush on that guy. LOL
spiritbearNY 2 years ago
@goldenglovegreek59 , This song was written by a member of the Left Banke about the girlfriend of another member. The 4 Tops covered it a couple of years later. I like both versions equally.
akcoins 1 year ago
@goldenglovegreek59 It was actually written by Michael Brown, keyboard player and founder of the Left Banke in 1966. It was then covered in 1967 by the Four Tops but didn't chart until 1968, where it hit #14 on the Billboard Chart.
grahamdawson09 11 months ago
@goldenglovegreek59 Walk away Renee was an Original tune by Left Banke 1966 and was later covered by the Four Tops 1968
Check out Wikipedia.
ravennaslim 10 months ago
@ravennaslim
Your absolutely right, thanks for the correction
goldenglovegreek59 10 months ago
Excellent.One of my favorite songs ever.really tight band.Excellent harmonies.
RickTDK 3 years ago
Very good cover of a song that brings back so many memories of my young teen years, first loves, long summer days & evenings and how time flown by seemingly overnight. Have you thought about adding "Love Grows" to your repertoire? Seems like it would fit right in.
meNmyMonky 3 years ago
I remember it well.. Dayton Ohio. Cavern's.. You use the equiptment of a band called the Trojan's.. I wondered what happened to you, think of you often!
Karol
Niksgrammie 3 years ago
Was not expecting much....I was wrong, nice.
hollies65 3 years ago
Perfect. You nailed it from the first measure. Nice Rickenbacher, too.
david85251 3 years ago
Good band.
tb1519 3 years ago
I have to watch this at least once every day now, I'm addicted to it! I really like your voice in this song, Mark. It's perfect for it! You would be great doing a Guess Who song like "These Eyes". Maybe you guys could try doing that one sometime.
56Mercgal 3 years ago
You guys have a killer drummer! Just thought I'd add that! He is really good! And I've seen alot of drummers!
56Mercgal 3 years ago
Takes guts to try to sing a song and group with such a distinctive sound.
wcsu1975 3 years ago
Best cover I've heard of this song.
at90percent 3 years ago
hey mark my daughters name is Renee and I like the way you sing it
rodriguezdiane53 3 years ago
Wow! You have a great voice, Mark! :) Keep it up! Would love to hear you another of the Left Banke's hits, "Pretty Ballerina". Your voice and style would be perfect for it!
56Mercgal 3 years ago
that drummer is slammin it!
francisbucketeer 3 years ago
Excellent rendition!
JoHomza1 3 years ago
Wow, great job guys. Love this period of music, something magical was in the air then. Love the Left Banke, also really like Desiree.
WIGSCOTT 3 years ago
Great Sound...Talented group
timjregan 3 years ago
i hate covers! this is great..!
koolizm1000 3 years ago 2
Excellent attention to the vocals.
FritzOmnibus 3 years ago
I was 19 when the original came out, this is a good cover. I like it.
f4tweet 3 years ago
Nice job. Let me know if you pass through Nashville.
SharonCobb 3 years ago
Thanks Sharon, We sure will
mark33033 3 years ago
good stuff! but you don't see many bands wearing the matching outfits. not a big requirement these days . love the rendition
stymye 3 years ago
Haha That's true. Since we are a 60's band
We are going for the whole look and feel.
I'm just glad we aren't a 70' band with the platform shoes!
mark33033 3 years ago
Yes Mark I could just see you as Ziggy Stardust,haha!
56Mercgal 3 years ago
Great job recreating a really hard song to replicate.
Rickysound 3 years ago
two thumbs up.
ukkfayooyay 3 years ago
Well done! Nice presentation, and attention to details. Best of luck to your group.
itsmypartygirlgroup 3 years ago
Thanks I went to your videos. You are great!
Loved the whole look and sound
mark33033 3 years ago
Mark,
please post what year this was recorded- EVERYTHING looks 70ish but it can't be, it's just too perfect to be "staged".
Excellent.
OjaiRoy 4 years ago
Thanks OjaRoy;
We recorded that last summer. We are a 60's tribute band.we do it for fun
mark33033 4 years ago
Thanks for the reply Mark. I stand corrected- 60s. Excellent wardrobe.
OjaiRoy 3 years ago
Wow, its nice to actually understand the words. Like the previous response said, nice version!
keith98point6 4 years ago
Nice version. Thanks!
Nefarioso 4 years ago