I thought the amv was awesome but I truly feel 2nd place was better. I can understand why this one though, it was an amazing video and had more of an understandable theme.
great amv but i don't like this manga but this amv it's cool for other man 5/5 because the effect are cool this amv it's cool but i prefer amv with song most noisy
WOW the editing in this AMV was so in detail, it would have been hard to tell which parts were edited if I didn't already see the movie. Although Nostromo is my all time favorite, I can't help but think that this amv deserved its place.
I am angry but let me clear the air. The video is good, but Nostromo's was better 100 times over. The beatles won this for the creator. But let me clarify, this was a great AMV. I just dont agree with the decision which made it take 1st place.
that´s what I had thought too as I saw nostromo´s amv... but you know... after watching the anime nostromo used... his amv is pretty boring campared to the second and first placed... if you know their anime materials as well ^^
You could tell from Nostromos silly title mixing up his old amvs that he wasn't taking the competition as seriously as he was last year when he released Auriga there. Still though, since Qwaqa's Time has come out I've yet to see a better new AMV come out. Redona by Oroshi was close, but the storytelling punch Qwaqa packs is just amazing.
watching it again i came up with a few questions who was the guy she was following at the start of the amv? Also when is the next expo i want to see what they do for 2010
well...no surprise he got 1st place...2nd's and 3rd's vids are great too but this one is my fav out of the 3...
just one question, i love this anime *.* i know it wasnt you who made the amv but as an amv maker you know where to get good quality vids, no? you know where can i find this movie in a quality as good as the one from the amv? :P
You probably wouldn't know if you never seen the movie but there were ALOT of subtle effects in this amv which all contributed to its greatness. There was more than one scene that was completely aboriginal (i.e not in the anime and created through masking). Just for an example, the bubble that forms around the girl while she travels is the editors creation, not the movie's. Please fully experience amv before making an incorrect analysis.
@CrimsonYuya so the fx are what make a video based on story?
i think someone who hasnt seen the anime is oftentimes the perfect judge for an amv, especially one like this that is so heavily intent on portraying a story, because they have no idea what the source is about so they don't have a preconceived set of emotions associated with the anime.
@gotegenks Ummm...ok lol I agree with your perspective to a certain extent, but that isn't what my comment was about in the least. I was replying to a comment that stated that the video was "nothing but raw edit" which it most definitely isn't. The effects added in this video wasn't superfluous like many seen today in amvs. It was perfect and subtle to fit the atmosphere of the amv, and add to it's recreation of a new story. Through it you can tell that the meticulous work of creator.
omg beatle fan like forever!! great work love it. loved the girl who leaped through time!!! thanks for you hard work hugs
LAYLA5855 7 months ago
I thought the amv was awesome but I truly feel 2nd place was better. I can understand why this one though, it was an amazing video and had more of an understandable theme.
beautifulybrainsick 10 months ago
i keep telling my self to watch it but now i got no excuse
monks311 1 year ago
This AMV gives me the chills everythime I see it.
AuroraBorealis00 1 year ago
the amv was pretty good. I wish there was a happy ending though :P. The ending was kidna creepy...But anyways. The Amv was.....good..
SignUpForFreeToday 1 year ago
aye looked and flowed epicly
nice amv! ;D
(on a side note did anyone else here the voice in the last couple of seconds?
sounds like if you rewinded it and maybe turned down some of the toning it would say something in japanese?)
uredoom 1 year ago
wow, the emotion that it captures is undeniable. beautiful.
layZactivist 2 years ago
great amv but i don't like this manga but this amv it's cool for other man 5/5 because the effect are cool this amv it's cool but i prefer amv with song most noisy
grimjowiner 2 years ago
WOW the editing in this AMV was so in detail, it would have been hard to tell which parts were edited if I didn't already see the movie. Although Nostromo is my all time favorite, I can't help but think that this amv deserved its place.
AmvManiaX 2 years ago 7
DAMN!
NOW THIS IS WHAT YOU CALL AN AMV!
dominicanmami92 2 years ago
oh yeah a great idear of combining animes and songs =D
FreakFranky 2 years ago
I am angry but let me clear the air. The video is good, but Nostromo's was better 100 times over. The beatles won this for the creator. But let me clarify, this was a great AMV. I just dont agree with the decision which made it take 1st place.
Grapplercj 2 years ago
that´s what I had thought too as I saw nostromo´s amv... but you know... after watching the anime nostromo used... his amv is pretty boring campared to the second and first placed... if you know their anime materials as well ^^
FreakFranky 2 years ago
I 100% agree. Not even second.
AznTakumi 2 years ago
thank you! :)
FreakFranky 2 years ago
You could tell from Nostromos silly title mixing up his old amvs that he wasn't taking the competition as seriously as he was last year when he released Auriga there. Still though, since Qwaqa's Time has come out I've yet to see a better new AMV come out. Redona by Oroshi was close, but the storytelling punch Qwaqa packs is just amazing.
AnimeIntroStyles4 2 years ago
Impressive.
justin7560 2 years ago
k one more question do you have to live in japan to make a video for the contest?
animafrea 2 years ago
3rd place nostromo is france :)
so no you don´t have to
FreakFranky 2 years ago
watching it again i came up with a few questions who was the guy she was following at the start of the amv? Also when is the next expo i want to see what they do for 2010
animafrea 2 years ago
just watch the anime ;)... you´ll have to wait cuz 2009 just finished
FreakFranky 2 years ago
i loved it i see why it came in first place
animafrea 2 years ago
Amazing !!! Great idea and fantastic editing !
Azertynin 2 years ago
true ;)
FreakFranky 2 years ago
well...no surprise he got 1st place...2nd's and 3rd's vids are great too but this one is my fav out of the 3...
just one question, i love this anime *.* i know it wasnt you who made the amv but as an amv maker you know where to get good quality vids, no? you know where can i find this movie in a quality as good as the one from the amv? :P
puzin 2 years ago
yepp just buy it and RIP it :P
FreakFranky 2 years ago
i wish...the only store i know here that sells anime doesn't have this movie xP -i dont liek to buy stuff online xD
puzin 2 years ago
awsome timing and editing ^_^
hairapidu 2 years ago
I pretty much love the idea :P
FreakFranky 2 years ago
Thank you for uploading this bro
GaaraSandz 2 years ago
no problem pro
FreakFranky 2 years ago
Really epic AMV, right-pace and cut lengths to match the music so well.... /speechless
d3nv1 2 years ago
That is cool :D xD
marcelsz2 2 years ago
It's super nice!
suckafish80 2 years ago
subscribe me pls for more amazing amvs :)
FreakFranky 2 years ago
holy shit, I can see why this came in first.
Assassinluffy2 2 years ago
hehe yeah :D
FreakFranky 2 years ago
so fking ...wow O_O
sinshenlong 2 years ago
I think just by the concept of this vid it won
the story and such didnt need any complicated effects
:D
it was nice!
EwolfY7 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
damn this vid won!!???
its pure raw edit!!!
=) lol im using this style too
GetsugaTenhou 2 years ago
this is what AMV making really means not that crappy editing stuff :)
FreakFranky 2 years ago
the editing stuff is fun to look at though...like for commercials..ya know..but this was ass raping nice!!!
KakarotPhoenix 2 years ago
What are you talking about?!
You probably wouldn't know if you never seen the movie but there were ALOT of subtle effects in this amv which all contributed to its greatness. There was more than one scene that was completely aboriginal (i.e not in the anime and created through masking). Just for an example, the bubble that forms around the girl while she travels is the editors creation, not the movie's. Please fully experience amv before making an incorrect analysis.
CrimsonYuya 2 years ago 22
lol i just love the amv!!, criticize my comment all you want, i make mistakes u make mistakes, life goes on, thx for the clarification ^_^
end.
GetsugaTenhou 2 years ago
@CrimsonYuya so the fx are what make a video based on story?
i think someone who hasnt seen the anime is oftentimes the perfect judge for an amv, especially one like this that is so heavily intent on portraying a story, because they have no idea what the source is about so they don't have a preconceived set of emotions associated with the anime.
gotegenks 1 year ago
@gotegenks Ummm...ok lol I agree with your perspective to a certain extent, but that isn't what my comment was about in the least. I was replying to a comment that stated that the video was "nothing but raw edit" which it most definitely isn't. The effects added in this video wasn't superfluous like many seen today in amvs. It was perfect and subtle to fit the atmosphere of the amv, and add to it's recreation of a new story. Through it you can tell that the meticulous work of creator.
CrimsonYuya 1 year ago 2
omg, o_O this is a awesome amv
Ruffy41 2 years ago
wow - after watching this video i know the reason, why this video got the 1 st place 5*
stitsch007 2 years ago
Nice nice ^-^ It look very good! 5 strars :'D
Rikax33 2 years ago
boah O.O that is sooooo great, excellent so so...indescribable
Ly616 2 years ago
snap
shub125 2 years ago