DT vs Astley - Never Gonna Wither You Up

[RetroLektro]

Rick Roll goes with any music, from Nirvana to Metallica to DT.... amazing LOL

[felipefritschf]

Dear Lord, these were the best five minutes of my entire live!

[Stormith]

Best rick roll ever

[ArneVonWeise]

Holy fuck.

[Bakazuraz]

Gah, this goes WAY too well together. I SHOULD NOT be enjoying this that much. I'm so confused, I hate you D:

[MCAmaZ]

....This is actually good. No, this is actually great! Every time I listen to this, I like it more and more. Weird how these songs combine this greatly.... :o

[666slipmaiden1]

DT Rolled

[jerkakame]

dream rolled

[deJanglez]

better then both originals combined...oh wait

[anthrmthrfckr]

I don't like Rickthat Astley that much, but this made me laugh... so what the fuck. xD

[MachoMartin]

THIS IS AWESOME

[stalmeseto]

Best rick-roll ever.

[NakedSnakeIta]

che coraggio

[Raaaaaaaaaafls]

OMG

[goblin2055]

Lmao this is amazing!!

[MaximumPayne12]

Masterpiece! o.O

[gnryeah]

Never thought this would work. But oh wow. I actually fucken love this. :D

[LPgurl97]

This is the only way that I can take Never Gonna Give You Up seriously anymore. XD.

[urguelfa]

I just heard the "Astley music with DT vocals" version on Neil's blog...weird but somehow nice! :D

[XiaoCooper]

DICK ROLL'D

[comosapian007]

3:26 thumbs up if you heard the windows error XD

[Talibson]

oh God ;D great :>

[anthrmthrfckr]

I headbanged while listening to this.

[konz0]

I was like ... OMG WTF :| again rick rolled ? And then i stand up, and started to dance the rest of my life

[Craf7y]

That's brilliant!

[gonzalobelatti]

this is bizarre... but what a heck!!! I LIKE IT! :P

[PhilM3t4l]

Very clever. Well done.

[Laaurenator]

How even..

[laskipaa2]

17 guys have been given upon.....

[jimmyEADG]

this is soooo awsome!!!!

[valinhorn42]

That's what you get for using generic chord progressions! :P

(It does sound nice though)

[Asche13500]

16 guys are RickRolled.

[Katastrofyk2512]

Blasphemy!

[DarkSouls010]

This is funny, sad, heartwarmingly beautiful, a win, a fail, so wrong, yet so right!

[fredfaa]

hahaha, so fucking lol!!! XDDD

[OrioProductions]

They should actually add him to the band...

[TheLlamaPie]

LOL PORTNOY LEFT DREAM THEATER TO JOIN AVENGED SEVENFOLD.

How does that feel, DTfags? Hmm?

[beastlyninja1]

@TheLlamaPie IT SOUNDS LIKE:

a) YOU'RE A GIANT ASS

b) YOU'RE LIKE 9 MONTHS LATE

what I want to know; why the hell are there so many fucking haters for this. I LOVE *BOTH* A7X and DT. Why do so many people act like you have to hate on one to like the other.

BTW: DUMBASS, Portnoy got kicked out of A7X so there is ABSOLUTELY NO point in you poutting that as a comment.

[TheLlamaPie]

@beastlyninja1 1. I'm a giant ass for telling the truth?

2. Yet you're here to reply.

And I never said I hated DT, I just stated fact. Besides, the word 'fag' shouldn't taken too personally anymore.

And never the less, Portnoy left DT to join A7X, then went back to DT, where they said no. So... yeah. :P

[beastlyninja1]

@TheLlamaPie

1. no, you're an ass for referring to dream theater fans as "DTfags"

2. because even though you're late, you still only posted this like 2 days ago

3. if you don't hate DT why would you call DT fans FTfags? Even if gay shouldnt be considered an insult, it still is! So if you don't mean for it to be an insult why the hell are you even commenting in the first place?

4. "And never the less, Portnoy left DT to join A7X..." You're just proving my point.

[gguilford72]

@TheLlamaPie

A7X is a good band, and the work they produced while he was there was quite good. I rather look forward to Mike's collaboration with Symphony X. And I think DT made a wise decision in hiring Mike Mangini, given the quality of their new track.

[cookiesformee]

HAHAHAHAHA I can't

[nouhta]

Awesome! :DDD

[freetrader0000]

NEVER GONNA BUILD ME UP!!! NEVER GONNA BREAK ME DOWN!!!!

[joeyklerkx]

It's scary how well this works...

[Yakushii]

I've never laughed so hard at being rickrolled before.

[MrAlcatrazDick]

this songs about Portnoy....

[faustolg]

This video is SOOOOO PERFECT!!!

[above90decibels]

Now that is talent. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!



[AWillsMusic]

This needs so many more views than it has.. Its soo perfect I about cried laughing

[501stSpitfire]

Never gonna give, Never gonna give!

[Sokojou]

Perfect =)

[SamHerrington14]

This is so wrong.. yet so right..

[Sarah1199]

HAHAHHAHAHA

[Pikkuzelikki]

This is awesome :D

[Muksmiduulit]

Very well done! :D Haha!

[zonic26]

I guess Never Gonna Give You Up and Wither work together

[elbeasto4]

omfg lol its perfect

[Patrock17]

15 people are rick astley fans

[manjenson]

@Patrock17 Actually they would like this too, cause ... well, this is just amazing.

These are Brian Griffin fans.

[lewa3910]

@Patrock17 umm...no

[Patrock17]

@lewa3910 lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollollollollollollollollol­lollollol

[lewa3910]

@Patrock17 nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­nonononononononononononononono­

[DrummingEvil]

THIS!!!

IS!!

FUCKING!!

AWESOME~!

[tcsbangbang]

chorus= eargasam

[Pmahoney1337]

omg... this is amazing.

[KubrickFTW]

DT should go on tour with Rick Astley xD

[StatusMaciza]

You mean Rick Astley should go on tour with DT

[cunha545]

@StatusMaciza Hell yeah

[BlazingWildfire]

I do believe that this is my favorite.

[lugzman91]

How did you split astley's voice?

[TheAthesis]

Absolutely magnificent.

[LlamaTheory]

This is fucking amazing.

[nekezajebancije]

Hahaha, man, the alternative mix to this (the other way around) on your blog is also awesome! I almost like it better.

[bobbob53629]

gayest song ever

[JakenJragin]

@bobbob53629 Trollest comment ever

[bobbob53629]

@JakenJragin seriously this is so gay what are their music kind? faulk pop metal its seriously pointless to listen to this crap its just retarded i prefer bieber by far

[Firedblood]

@bobbob53629 The fact u said that this is ''gay'' and that you are a bieber lover just tells us your age and mentality and that your not even worthy to listen to DT.

[JakenJragin]

@Firedblood Dude, he's a troll, just grab a pitch fork and lets have a lovely day forking him (lol)

[bobbob53629]

@Firedblood your just mad cause your music sucks

[JakenJragin]

@bobbob53629 SUCCESFUL TROLL FOUND! SUCCESSFUL TROLL FOUND! QUICK EVERYBODY, GRAB YOUR PITCH FORKS!!!!!!!!!!!

[MaximumPayne12]

@bobbob53629 Sigh... you piece of worthless shit doesn't even deserve to waste my time in bashing you and tell you how pathetic you are. Please burn in fire and die slowly. I hope you get cancer and die in pain ;)

[bobbob53629]

@MaximumPayne12 you just took your time to bash me, btw you don't even defend your music cause you know its bs

[Critdizzle]

"If you hadn't told me, I never would've known it was two songs." My older sister. :)

[Farfaramir]

3:12 :')...

[mjloaner]

Wither was acually my favorite song, Like from dream theater at least. Hearing this makes the song better by OVER 9000!!!

[mrblahboogi]

YESS!!!!! My life is complete... lol but that is scarily cool.

[johnnystrawberryseed]

Beautiful.

[jemercury]

3:28 - 3:46 - The Sound of the winner

[AllyOfTractorMan]

Eargasm.

[400SA]

We got DT Rolled!!!

Brilliant!!

[JakenJragin]

*sniffing* The internet......is sooooooo beautiful!!!! *starts crying*

[ThazuaBlackarrow]

@JakenJragin I know!

It could take one meme and combine it with a shitty song by a shitty band and make it go-

No they still suck

[alienhell663]

This made my insides hurt laughing.

[lewa3910]

Thumbs up if you Demand anMP3 of this!!!

[tacotisco904]

@lewa3910 idk if u alredy did this but if you download Youtube Downloader, you can download this and convert it to and mp3 and there you go. hope this helped. :p

[lewa3910]

How the hell can Rick Astley be this Bad ass!?!?! You sir. Have just divided by Zero!!!!1

[Tr1sK3Li0n]

I'm 12......And this is pure win :')

[TheShnitzel]

Lmao! this is ridiculously awesome!

[Mvisilla]

These two were made for eachothers. Best song on the tubes.

[JOfTheWind]

I laughed, I cried, I changed my pants.

[MikeAsHimself]

This is one of the best fucking things ever 5/5!

[FriendlyFantom]

Yay, Mike Portnoy is wearing a King Crimson shirt.

[dragnarok1134]

we all win the game.

[ub3r2008]

The craziest thing is that it FITS!

[Xynl]

HAHAHAHAHAHA.

[PlaguedMan]

Oh shit, I cannot remove this version from my head.

[ucg102]

So this is how they sound without portnoy º-º fkin interesting

[jpsdoit]

14 guys don't apprecciate opera...and got badly rolled of course...

[shreddingjoris]

RRRRRRRRRRRRROOOOOOOOOOOOOFFFF­FFFFFFFLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL­LLLLL AWESOMEEEEEEEEEeee

[jman40194]

Myung: I want to pop this guy in the mouth so bad... Petrucci (in a trance): woah, his voice is like a combination of fergie and jesus... Labrie: Boy, you better get the fuck outa here.. Rudess: Whaaaat the ffffuuuu....hey guys, who is this guy, and where did he come from?? Portnoy: Oh my god, not again... Ill just wait back here until its over.

[pryan37bb]

DAMN IT, I'll never listen to this song the same way again.

[galoportnoy]

NOW THIS SONG MAKE SENSE!!!! FINALLY!!!

[a66448579]

this is actuallly amazing. i hope dream theater see this!

[MERTx123]

HA!!! I haven't lolled that hard in a long time

[antidood1]

Dude, effing AMAZING!!! :D

[RyuMN]

Insane.

[Z4nk0]

jajajjaaa LOOOOOOOOl good good job

[Jerosifoam]

:DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD­DDDDD=My face.

[IkuralHakiir]

My life is now improved.

[CMostarda]

I love DT a lot!!!! And i like Rick Astley... this video is amazing!!!! Congratulations to the mand who made it.... Very nice!!!!

[locustofchiron]

I cannot unhear it

[MERTx123]

@locustofchiron Yeah lol, so much for being able to listen to Wither without cracking up

[connordrum]

For the first time I enjoyed being roll'd

[runevaldivia]

rofl this actually sounds good

[phantomdroid]

It's an enjoyable nightmare. A melodic obscenity. Do I sing along or kill myself? Lol. xD

[AlienWeaver08]

Deck Thastler ^^

[wcr4]

excellent

[sfgvrich]

This is the most amazing thing I've ever heard.

[FOMFAH2]

haha

[sally65356]

wow!

[tiki2188]

I like DT but I thought Systematic Chaos and BC&SL were meh (best)

This makes Astley AND DT better!

Nicely done

[Mvisilla]

This is how the song SHOULD be.

[EddyMorino]

Dream Theater really never will give you up. Well, except for Portnoy.

[Uchihafan05]

@EddyMorino Damn, i'm so pissed that he split... but you sill made me lol

[MegashadX]

This might actually be beautiful if Rick Rolling wasn't fucking hilarious.

[Jerosifoam]

Ah!!! This!!!!!

[wookster77]

I think I laughed throughout the whole length of this song. This is so brilliantly done.

[imacarfreak]

Well, with Portnoy leaving, i hope that he will reunite with the band in the coming years. i dont think he could ever really give them up, or let them down, let alone run around and desert them. And i dont think he would make the fans cry by saying goodbye, or telling a lie to hurt us.

[mushroomzagain]

life affirming........

[fiervahl]

Really awesome! Everything fits really nicely. :)

[BlossomGrace]

i think we've all just been ROCK Rolled!!! :'D

[DamienThornes]

Wow, I knew Portnoy leaving would bring changes to DT, but I didn't expect this! :p

[fonarte]

Ah the awesomeness of being in similar keys with similar tempos.

So good XP

[totallyfingbrutal]

Mother of God.

[maddearth]

this is actually quite awsome =D

[UnforgivingCritic]

it might be a good idea for Dream Theater to tour with Astley now.

[cdiSPAGHETTI]

I think the universe just ended.

I just enjoyed getting Rickrolled.

[kylethehedgehog101]

For once, I don't mind a rick 'roll!

[locobotics]

pretty funny but also really good!

[HadrianBlindEye]

Wow, original Wither just blows now after hearing this.

[GGusG]

Dreamroll'd!



[GGusG]

Fits perfectly, ROFL.

[EnviZiado]

Dream Theater Has Been Rickrolled

[unholynightmare2]

this is great XD

[MxC1337MxCsh43d]

Dude. That's fucking awesome.

[10dthompson60]

Im a DT fan and I still think this is epic

[CallumPK]

I actually laughed out loud.

[ttunna]

Man - top effort!!! You did a great job but at the end of the day it's just proof that you just can't wreck a DT song! They can make anything sound awesome!!!!

I hope they do a live version soon.

[UnforgivingCritic]

i like how rick astley is just pasted there. lol

[indistruttibile]

This is definitive

[Critdizzle]

My mom said I should try to get them to do this, so who else agrees with me: Astley and DT should get together and record a studio version of this song.

[KyleJPie10]

LMAO

[LerxstTheAnalogKid]

MIKE PORTNOY HAS A KING CRIMSON SHIRT ON! Sorry, I this just made me intensely happy :)

Also, HOW is this possible? It is incredible!

[MegaMrDT]

LOL

[eaglepridev2]

lol. the chorus fits perfectly.

[LOLLOROCKET]

Awesome! O_O

[GuyWhoCantGetAName]

We've all been prog-rolled...hey can I use this in my vids?

[JulianBaynez]

I actually like this more than the origional wither.