The Review Show - Ep. 1: Battle of Naboo 2 & 181st Legion 3

[legocommanderfox55]

I agree with you on davids he seems far more concerned with making it flashy then concentrating on the voice acting for instance I don't think clones use the word " crap " I would see them saying Kark or firefector. I also think that its sets lacked detail like the computers that the clones sat at. aso I couldn't stand the Tin can droids line he hesitated it while recording

[buffalo827]

review mine " THE INFINITY SQUAD'

[DeeJayYZ013]

legoboy12345678 is more concerned on his collection than animations which is ok I guess???

[lmarts09]

i agree with you

[wakomike29]

nailed it



[ARCblooper]

I think the same of pizzamovies videos as you do of 181st legion. I hate both.

[LegoJonJon]

legoboy12345678"s 181st legion could have 2 and 1/2 stars...maybe..MAYBE! have 3 stars. well that's my opinion.

[Seamonster3712]

You have a British Accent?

[lisaisanut]

legoboy12345678 needs to put more time into the voice acting

[whatintheworldwastht]

very cool my friend, have you considered doing this on a regular basis? XD i seriously would lol

[legohaloman1997]

i agree to make a war film you have to put feeling into it

[charge881]

i think most people subscribe to legoboy is 1 because of hes huge army and 2 because when he started people expected him to amount to much more.

[legohaloman1997]

@charge881 agreed

[legodarknight101]

Do you choose what films you review?

[SmilieisBeast]

Great point, sorry for spamming it ;P

[SmilieisBeast]

If I may, I would like to suggest reviewing Keshen8's new Lego Black Ops video.

[SmilieisBeast]

Got to love these reviews. If I can support the comment section on presuading you to make more, I will so..... keep up the good work.

[jweimer111]

i agree!!!

[warboys6789]

nice you took the piss out of legoboy123456789

[MrLegoCloneCommander]

Which other films are you going to review??

Maybe my one??^^

Just a joke... I´m really interested in your opinion of Stop-Motion films, but for all it helps the guys to improve their technics... so THX ;-)

see you subbed... THX again^^

[spugesdu]

@MrLegoCloneCommander Well, now that you come to mention it... ; )

[MrLegoCloneCommander]

@spugesdu ^^

[MrLegoCloneCommander]

@spugesdu sry for asking but.... so you gonna make a review on my film?

[customlegoboy1234567]

Your opioun was perfect can't wait for the next one

[ghartsho]

I think You were going Easy on David a bit to much. lol.

[michael12345690]

i like your stopmotion better

[PickleProductionsLtd]

You should definitely make more of these. I really enjoyed this one.

[drsamtam74]

I have subscribed to both you and Legoboy1-8, so where does that put me?

[MasterKnight24]

@spugesdu hey I have a very important question to ask you Garth and if you could reply that would be superb. Why do hate or not like lego12345678 videos? He's ok his acting is ok and filming is.......ok but I really don't see any reason to hate or really dislike him? I get if u don't like him but if u could just tell me why that would be suprerb thanks!

Masterknight24

[spugesdu]

@MasterKnight24 ...Is that a very important question?

[MasterKnight24]

@spugesdu ugh yes..........kinda.......somwh­at.......no i just really wanted to know it is ok if u dont want to answer it its ok but thanks for responding!

[djproductioning]

@spugesdu well actually i agree with masterknight . why does everyone take the mick out of legoboy????? im not one of his fans, but to tell the truth, if he is bad (which he is) then forestfire must be like the worst film maker eva!

[spugesdu]

@djproductioning His videos are entirely substance yet completely without substance. Understand what I mean? And actually FF101's videos are generally pretty damn funny.

[djproductioning]

@spugesdu meh, suit urself noob....oh no no no no no no no no, i just called prctically the best film-maker on utube a noob!!!!!! this is bad!!!!!!!!! Spugesdu please i beg of you not to send ur fans on me!!!!!! or else..................goodbye cruel world!!!!!!!!!!!!! but still i have to say that i think forestfire is rubbish, even though i wont say it to his face.

[spugesdu]

@djproductioning ...That was a bit immature, you are kidding, right? You think it bothers me that you have a different opinion to me? 

[djproductioning]

@spugesdu yea, well um.......maybe i shud keep my mouth shut.................

besides i probably shouldn't make enemies with the current "leader" of the lego youtube franchise. sorry for the trubble

[spugesdu]

@djproductioning Maybe you should... No problem!

[CommanderPreston]

@spugesdu that true FF101's films r very funnny

but the animating is that great its the script that makes it awesome

:)

keep making good videos

[LegoForever89]

@MasterKnight24 i see almost no reason to LIKE him or his vids and in overall i think that is a dumb question!!!!

[bluerex112]

GREAT REVIEW!! DO MORE! I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING! :D

[HarryMonsterMovies]

I enjoyed this review! You have a nice voice to listen to, and you seem to be quite fair. I wouldn't have done it differently! Keep them coming!

[aatvideos]

Great review. I would honestly lower legoboys rating.

[clonecody45]

Hmm, these reviews really put a turn on how I view both videos. I didn't get the complete cinematic feel from ABC123Toasts' but I didn't even bother to watch the entire 181st Legion video. Great reviews, I look forward to more! :D

[legofoxanimations]

2 truthful reviews.

[dublinjake]

I would give legoboy12345678's vid 1stars as he took some of the idea from squad 42 five like he stole the idea of data in some clone's helmet and an elite unit saving the guy with important data

[biggerbeyondbigger]

i like the review show it gives me an idea of what i should watch and what i shouldn't

[bossk2000]

nice show i cant wait in till the new squad 42 it looks like it will blow my socks of

[jangofett4566]

hey man i liked it but definetly 5 stars and its awesome that you play with the characters from ST republic commando

[ben98771]

Not to be rude, but your editing system costs 400 dollars and legoboy12345678's only costs fifty. (High production costs)

P.S Your vids are awesome!!!!!!! :) :) :)

[pocdb1997]

i didnt like 181st legion 3 i knew its was gonna be bad becuz it took him two weeks to complete the film no offence to david but i give it a three becuz of animation right now im gonna watch battle of naboo

[Kaipyro67]

181st Legion 3 sucked. You were right.

[clonekiller38745]

i a nice idea

[idioticdirector101]

id like to see a couple more reviews. You might not sound very enthusiastic but it helps me know what to check out and what not to.

[topratereviews]

The theme at the beginning is the beginning of the Close Encounters of the Third Kind Theme!

[mrvendetor]

Th review show, every morning at 7 Pm with your host, Gareth Pugh.

[ScypaxPictures]

Nice review show, was really impressive.

[tacomoviesproduction]

i thought it was good and fair judging

[hongadongaha]

i liked the bit about the dead squirrel. keep making em, but with more enthusiasm

[pizzamovies]

I really think that this is a good idea, Gareth. I'm dead serious. Taken my advice, I see? :P

The only thing I can say is that you need to be a bit more enthusiastic. Ya nowuttai mean? ;)

[YoohGotNoobed]

idea about battle of naboo, and i quite enjoyed it. I think you should do this more spugesdu.

[YoohGotNoobed]

@legobryne

4 stars is very good. It doesn't matter if it's a great animation, thats only a partial amount. The rest is the effects and voice acting, plot. There's a lot to consider. As for legoboy's videos, to be honest it wasn't good. The plot, dialogue, and the voice acting were horrible. They were ineffective, and unrealistic. The plot was O.K., but my problem with it was that it was overused, and poorly presented. I have my own review on my channel.

I enjoyed this video, because i had no

[millenniumfalsehood]

Good, honest review! Thanks for taking the time to do this and I look forward to further reviews.

[redbullgivesuwind]

I liked it Gareth! (:-P)

[anibooms]

i would give it 2/5 too

[legomoviemaker1]

You should do what you did in this episode in every one - one video you liked and disliked

[GamingCentral1]

Good video I agree completely with the ratings that you gave both of these videos I would give them about the same as you but I'm not a fan of legoboy12345678 he braggs to much

[o0streak0o]

though the video is helpful it shows whats good, it would be nice to see other videos like ones that don't have effects or shorter stop-motions maybe include 4 videos in an episode, some where out there is a decent video that hasn't got many views that should be recognised, maybe look around a bit more, but all in all the video you've made is decent enough

[99JediDrew]

You are probably one of the best reviewers on YouTube. "Some lines, such as a clone shouting "Hey, look!" towards their rescuers/saviors from a brutal death, are uttered with the exuberance of an old man sitting on a park bench pointing towards a dead squirrel." I just love it! ; ) Bring on Review Show 3!

[iamcaboose300]

both wer goodish 

[naterboy1]

MORE!!!



[tsage2007]

great reviews, very very formal it makes the vid really enjoable. ;)

[SpongeyFilmer]

The review show! awesome

[QuickEvidz]

Can you tell me what i need to improve in my movie HALO ODST Cold Storage? and can you give me advice?

[customlegoboy1234567]

You hate to make more and your reviews are spot on with your opunin great would watch it all day if I could

[legosareus]

keep doing this

[Starwarsfreak231]

I agree completely with what you said about the individual videos

[supermariobrosx1]

Wow thnx for telling that the battel of Naboo 2 is to loud my parnets would've grounded me I hate that.

[melonhead82]

These Review are actualy quite handy, and it should allow the animator of the shows being reviewed know where to adapt in their films.

[LegomationStudio]

close encounters of the third kind at the begining!

[JSPNFilms]

I know this is supposed to be a show about reviews for popular movies in the Lego community, but perhaps for certain episodes you could look for relatively unknown flicks by unknown animators. By "unknown", I mean brickfilms that are decent, but made by newcomers to the genre. Just a thought. Excellent reviews by the way, though I do think that you sound a bit unenthusiastic. Just providing some constructive criticism :)

[legobryne]

no offence but you should actually give battle of naboo 5 out of 5 stars cuz its a awsome animation, i just don't get why you are giving 2stars... even putting legoboy12345678's video on it( no offence)

[spugesdu]

@legobryne 5/5 would imply that it's near-perfect, which it definetely isn't, but 4/5 is a really good score. I put legoboy12345678's new video here because it's a popular new release and many people want to know about it.

[legobryne]

@spugesdu okay, thanx! I even like your vids not legoboy's! also, you can put up fancypants' force unleashed vid!

[MultiGeekProductions]

@legobryne I think you've misunderstood the point of the video, this is Spugesdu's View, not yours, If you strongly believe it should be 5/5 then for Spugesdu's sake post a video response. No film is perfect, nothing is perfect, but this comes close.

[LegoHavoc]

What I have to say pretty much has already been said by "Nuclearbugman" so all I really have to say is brilliant job.

[cagee14]

You should do this every week or so with different movies! It would help animators highlight certain flaws and perhaps correct them in future projects.

[MrImaginator]

@cagee14 I agree but remember he needs to work on Squad 42 so I say he should do this once or twice each month depending on his schedule.

[cagee14]

@MrImaginator Totally. Whatever suits him! Anything helps really. =)

[MrImaginator]

I also have to say that it's good to know that u have decided to become a reviewer.I always dislike watching films like the 181st legion 3 so I'm happy that u are telling us the ups and downs on videos before we watch them :)

[MrImaginator]

How do u choose which videos to be on your review? Do u just pick out currently released videos or videos u like or dislike.

[lhproductions00]

Continu with this, its great :D

[nuclearbugman]

No offence, but I don't really think you're cut out for reviewing. You don't sound very enthusiastic about what you have to say, like there's no conviction behind it. Also all the observations you've made sound like you read a review in a magazine and then copy and pasted some of the technical terms into this review. You sound frankly bored and are obviously reading mechanically from a script. I actually enjoyed the negative review you did more than the positive one. Still, you're only starting.

[spugesdu]

@nuclearbugman Noted, sound less scripted and more enthusiastic. ; )

[theninja222]

@nuclearbugman It hard to do all that with a sexy accent!

[lobot888]

Don't stop the reviews

[hnewberry99]

MORE!!!!!!!!! This is a review show that has that special thing about it that makes it truely great. it tells straight facts while keeping the viewer entertained. 5 stars out of 5

[jba8472]

Excellent idea, very entertaining. A good way to let fans of Lego Cinema know what is out there. Question: will you be limiting your reviews to just Clone Wars films (which I guess would be your genre of expertise) or will films of other genres be reviewed as well?

[camodeo10]

I agree with you

[darkrie7]

you are soo fun to listen too! I love the way you just through in those old classic english terms! This is really good by the way, and one of the few who dares insults legoboy12345678.

I would love to see more!

[nr12444]

It is a cool ideia so i sugest you move on!

[StarCorpsProductions]

@BattleDoctor Agreed! It would be awesome to have a lego studio audience! I mean this is great but a lego TV show would be amazing!

[billymaysfan101]

I meant doesn't

[spugesdu]

@billymaysfan101 I've still no idea, you tell me.

[billymaysfan101]

@spugesdu You know what, this was pointless to begin with.

[legoboy1215]

i agree with everything you said, but i think legoboy1-8 should have been a 1.6, and ABCD123toast should have been 4.5

[billymaysfan101]

Um, I liked this and all ,but does Topratereviews do this?

[spugesdu]

@billymaysfan101 I've no idea, you tell me. 

[frontloaderman]

good job keep doing it!!!

p.s. will you check out my vids

[NickBrick1]

i like it! Nice idea...you'd make a career out of being a critic i think... :)

[legoFANqmb]

the truth is always welcome

[XxSeargentDuppersxX]

quite a good script on your part acatually, some very witty david mitchell style comments love to see more.

[spugesdu]

@XxSeargentDuppersxX Thank you, that's quite a compliment!

[BKwonder816]

good job! keep the reviews comin

[brickcinema101]

looking forward to more

[Thekidmakesmovies]

I think you should definitely keep doing these reviews! I have a few questions though.... how do you choose what videos to review? And are they only gonna be Lego Star Wars ones?

[drsamtam74]

Brilliant idea. I hope you decide to continue with them.

[calum327]

i felt that the films were very fairly rated as expected i personally felt you summed both films up as some viewers would have them selfs i have seen both animations and as you can well gather from the above i undoubtedly agree

p.s. i dropped you a comment the other day i was wondering if you had read it and if you have i would really appreciate it if you could reply

[BrickAction101]

awesome! do more!

[minifigman2009]

Yes. Keep making more episodes of The Review Show.

[Inglis93]

Nicely done sir! Looking forward to more reviews! :)

[OmegaLegoMan]

Great video love the review show

[thefourmonkeys]

Wonderful reviews! Very well said and very professional. I enjoyed watching and listening to the whole thing. Great job Gareth!  @(^_^)@

[legomasters911]

At 2:18 you said Battle of Naboo 3 >.>

(Just informing you)

[ABCD123toast]

@legomasters911 ?

[JRPictureProductions]

I think you are overly critical of legoboy's film, though I agree the voice acting and dialog could be better. I thought the other aspects of the film were quite good, as far as lego films go.

[ziggy12000]

Great! You must make another episode!!! :)

[jak12329]

ye but this is just a little video and he said that hes working on squad 42 vi alot atm so animation in this will take to much time time for him. its fine as it is

[DylianTimoLego]

really cool show really good idea i hope you do more

[crazylegoguys]

thanks for reviewing!

[WWIflyingace62]

the usual insults i would expect for legoboy12345678. heh twilight saga. i'm still laughing my brains out.

[spugesdu]

@WWIflyingace62 Not insults, criticisms.

[Sithbrick1]

amazing, keep doing what you do!

[smproductions101]

thanks for reviewing this

[11legofan]

I really hope you'll do more of this, love it!

[Jedifilmer101]

I was pretending to do the same thing it was supposed to be released on friday! I had almost the same catgories. But well, looks like you released it first. But ill still post mine. Okay?

[skyawalker]

i like the review show but u need to look at the films from diffrent angles not dependig on if u like the guy who makes them or not but yeah keep on making the review show!!!

[ARCstudios1]

Keep doing the review's, they're great!!

[metru18]

Just my personal opinion, I think 2 stars for 181st legion is a little underrated, because I liked the movie. I think most of the animation was pretty good, although the voice acting wasn't the best. I would give it 3 and a half stars.

[souventboy]

Haha .... that's silly , a review show , well ok .-... But yeah pretty cool if i make a movie with legos again ... you could give a review too . This is a good idea , i think you should do the reviews on your second channel . that would be much better ... you see on this channel you could make your  [ s42] and on your other channels you could make reviews and ratings of lego movies .

willem (15) <--- souventboy

[wraithlord31]

DO MORE! Love the vids man

[blackrosesquad]

yeah that was good

[bxkvenom65]

ive seen lego boys vid but not other one looks good though

[limanardo]

Wow good reviews job i agree with you on both reveiws. I watched the first like 30 seconds of the 181st legion and it was crap.... But i watch Naboo 2 and it was pretty darn epic. Great reviews keep it up!

[SadelmanFliks]

It says "S42 VI ep. 1 2.12.10" at the top. Is that an error?

[bumblebee11111]

@SadelmanFliks In some countries they put the day before the month eg. 1.4.10

which is the 1st of april 2010 but in America it would be 4.1.10.

[SadelmanFliks]

@bumblebee11111 Oh, yeah, I usualy put the month first so I didn't know.

[LegoAppleCo]

I agree completely! LegoBoy12345678 is over rated. He's just good at doing reviews IMO. BRING BACK THIS SHOW AGAIN!!! I love it!

[LegoBoy300]

want animation software do they use

[TheBrickFlicks]

how do you pick the vids you review? i would be homored if you would review one of my vids.

[Legofan961]

I have to kind of agree with what he said.

defiantly about the 181st legion 3, but not so sure about the comment to the battle of naboo vid.

[americanidiotm4]

i agree with you. i like this review you do keep it up

[Meteshadow101]

You should put these videos on the News Lego Channel.

[bpgower98]

make more!

[BKMPictures]

I agree with the review with 181st legion, like I said before. However, it did seem that Invest had a better plot with a bit more originality and effort than any of his previous films, and I also believe that he was rushed while making 181st legion 3, because he said he'd start filming after Invest, and it was... what... 2 weeks later that 181st came out? I honestly don't know why he thought he was rushed to clomplete it, but, anyways, nice reviews! Can't wait to see more!

[cloneguy1235]

to me i think 181st legion 3 is 3 out of 5 but thats just me

[jj481012]

I agree David did a realy bad job on the 181 legoin.

[TheSuperLegoClone]

great comparison to the 181 legion

[CptRexFilms987654321]

Lol 0:22 thats a mouthfull!!

[NeverEnoughLego]

I liked this idea please do it again!

[bluerex112]

Awesome do more!!! ur very accurate!!!

[peairlandogriffin]

i say its a 4

[mrlegocollector2]

I Agree.

[clustertoo]

I am a legoboy12345678 fan, however, I did find that 181st was a bit of a disapointment. But thats just my opinion. I like a movie with a little more tactical discution. So I am going to have to agree with you on 181st.

[Seo241]

i so agree

[atn212]

noice/honest/funny metaphors... i would enjoy a couple more reviews like this one :)

[databoy77lego]

so true 181 st is deffinetely not that good i think he just has alot of subscribers is becaus of the amount of money he has and the sheer and complete volume of his collection

[hiddenhalo1]

i know what you're gonna say, but the lutinant from the begining, i bought that! ask ABCD123toast!

[dartheric6]

Very nice, this is really great!

[12345678legostarwars]

nice review

[Gresh542]

Battle Of Naboo 2 was the best of the two. And Republic Commando was on Xbox as well.