Seven Potters - The Remus Lupins

[aridancer14]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho THANK YOU! I feel the same way. I often get shot down by other Christians for liking Harry Potter because it has magic in it; meanwhile, many of the ones who criticize me are busy obsessing over Twilight, which is about VAMPIRES. I think, as long as you don't idolize or worship an idea or series, and as long as it doesn't inspire you to do sinful things, it's not un-Christian to like it. But sorcery is real; and that's what Christians have to be careful not to meddle in.

[noorgansjustawesome]

Fantastic. (:

[flyingpuppy13]

I started listening to them about a month ago... I'm sad cause I fell I've missed everything

[lunathewarrior]

@flyingpuppy13 I know how you feel. I saw Alex Carpenter perform about a year ago, and now the Remus Lupins don't even exist. But the best we can do is be glad that wrock exists and we had a chance to listen in the first place.

[Ravenclaw2313]

I've always loved this video. Watching it now makes me miss everyone. Still a really great video three years later. Also still a fantastic song, but that surprises no one. =)

[MidnightThief15]

This video was executed beautifully.

[PowerOfPie]

This has to be one of my favorite songs EVER.

[firefly2552025]

Who are in The Remus Lupins? Besides Alex?

[456puff]

@videochannel101

Completely agreed!!!

[TheGoddessPayne]

Meh...

[Artdoggy123]

AMAZING MUSIC VIDEO

[smelialee]

So amazing!!

[bookwizard7]

i love this video, it is so unique. and i absolutely love the music in this song!

[ZynethPhoenix]

Oh COME ON guys, how can anyone be so naive to still believe those stupid rumors about JKR and real witches? It's humiliating!

[ZynethPhoenix]

Totally amazing! Seeing you in concert when this first came out was even better though. I mean, who else can literally leap off the amp while playing the most intense rift in the song and screaming all so perfectly?

Alex Carpenter holds the title of being the only man to ever make Chuck Norris blush.

[marauderverity]

Alex Carpenter, you make me so happy in this video<3.

[feasible]

Still in contention for one of the single most fun songs to experience live, even if the recorded version wasn't already amazing enough. And I love Brad's vision for the video.

[TheTaekwandodo]

Really skillfully made Alex - I am truly blown away!

[DiscoSux87]

that girl is damn fine

[crash5444]

Coming from an ultimate Harry Potter fan this was tight, good job man

[greenpawify]

@MonayIsMe Uh, I see your point, but I am a Wiccan, and there are no demons what-so-ever involved... But besides that, they are just REALLY good books.

Anyway, This is awesome!

[CoroziEtaRumni]

@quarters42: I know TONS of Christians who LOVE the "Harry Potter" series. I'm one of them, and I've read all seven books and watched all eight movies... Just because some of the haters are Christians, doesn't mean that we all are. Co ro zi e ta rum ni.

[quarters42]

Amazing don't let the haters/Christians who take things to seriously get u down

[promoguy59]

You can tell that the audio was dub in.

[waffles032]

@promoguy59 That's the point of a MUSIC VIDEO, bro. This isn't a live performance.

[EmmaLestrange]

Love it! XD

[JSMemoir]

@AlexanderCarpenter You look kind of like Sherlock here.

[sarahsoliloquy]

Awww, I remember this video! Those were the days.... I like it more now than I did then actually. At first, back then, I don't think I had heard you sing enough, yet. So like, there are people in these comments saying that you need to sing softer? That's crazy talk, because what I like about this song is that you do sing harsher and louder than what I've come to expect from you lately. And it sounds really really good. <3

[Retard12346]

Wait...this was serious? I thought they were just dicking around...whatever. In that case, not very good lyrics or vocals, but the music kicked ass. One of the best bass lines ive heard in a while

[crapzel]

cool ^^~

[jujubeans360]

I hadn't seen this before, but I think it's one of the best music videos you've ever done, Alex. And honestly, Ron's mustache makes my life.

[crayonlightning]

Amaaaazing

[bubblegumforever15]

alex is awesomeee~~~~~~

[videochannel101]

Alex your an amazing singer/songwriter dont let these rude people get you down

[kerijp]

mad haters yo lol!!

[soccercheese013]

@MonayIsMe are you in contact with demons?

[danad1rox1ur1sox]

@MonayIsMe

Oh my gosh.. I'm the typical obsessive Harry Potter fan..

Read the books more than twice, seen all the movies, own posters, video games, clothing, administrate HP pages on fb, roleplay as a HP character..

I am also a Christian, and J.K. Rowling actually had her spells approved by legit witches from Wisconsin.

My youth leader hates it that I read Harry Potter, and if she knew how obsessed I was, she would be pissed.

I also believe it would be demons. Just letting you know I agree.

[VickiLovesDoctorWho]

@MonayIsMe I'm a massive Harry Potter fan. My brain is full of facts and trivia that would probably win me first place in an HP pub quiz, but would be completely useless in my day-to-day life. However, I do not worship sorcery. Because SORCERY ISN'T REAL. Anyway, magic is only 10% of the HP books. I can't speak for everyone here, but to me HP is about love, hope, death, friendship and compassion. It teaches you to be brave and to stand up for what you believe in. What isn't Christian about that?

[ayubisobhan]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho Everything. Religion is about division, hate, war, and greed.

[DobbysSockss]

@ayubisobhan religion is about GOD!

[DobbysSockss]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho almost everything you said was 100% true except the part about winning first place in an HP Quiz.... *hint hint*

well... can never know for sure who is the best. (until there is one :] )

[ExactlyElla]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho right you are my friend :), I feel the exact same way :)))

[ShakespeareIsMyMuse]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho

Woah, "Sorcery isn't real" and you call yourself a Harry Potter fan? I scoff at thee. Sorcery is as real as breathing.

[MarilyHearts]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho Well said, my friend. ^_^

[ThGirlNextDoor98]

@VickiLovesDoctorWho I knew it wasn't real, but still waited for my letter when I was 11. Then again, I was 10. 10 year olds are supposed to think wacky things like that. 

[MidnightThief15]

@MonayIsMe He's making music inspired by Harry Potter because he finds enjoyment and fun in it. He's paying homage to a great series. Where are you getting him trying to become a sorcerer from?

And besides, you contradicted yourself. By claiming that the plot of Harry Potter is "awesome," that means you have a bit of enthusiasm about it. So this sorcery that you are ranting about is something that you yourself enjoyed when reading or watching Harry Potter. And are you trying to recreate it? No.

[percyinthestyx]

OH. MY. GOD. You have just earned a like, favorite, subscribe, and another person buying the song.

[xxxElegatorxxx]

Fantastic!

[iloveunclet1]

I have never watched a video of yours before but I heard people were trashing you? Yeah, youtubers are supposed to support each other so you go bro! Keep up the great job :) I'm so glad you made front page and I hope you continue to make awesome videos. You have definitely won over a new subscriber.

[Thesofiale1]

great job :)

[zakman70]

fricking awesome . 

[222jesusfreak]

Awesome Love you Alex :)

[Eamarellano]

yall fucken full of shit

[pencilpushable]

I love it :)

[661Brandy]

Lol o.O creepy but so funny

[SammieSparxx13]

Wizard rock. <33

[cookiesgorawr1099]

Do dementors even have wands? (if those were dementors xD) lol

[eMoXEcStaCy]

EPIC -3 work done appreciated -3

[byroninscoe3303]

I made my first video this morning, I heard on tv that herman Cain told his people : don't speak until spoken to. Check it out.

[HMAHN57]

I like the musical score, simple and basic but clean. I agree with some of the other posters that the vocals could be improved.

[reverendbug]

great lyrics. great vid...you need to work on your vocals a bit. it sounds like you need to train your voice for soft singing rather than loud singing. nothing wrong with that, just turn up the mic a bit. XD

[invinciblemode]

Nice song.. But the vocals didn't do it justice.. :/

[Tomsm481966]

Simon and Randy would say you cant sing your awful get a real job terrible video to your really tone deaf and the people who like you have to also be tone deaf good luck

[IxAmxAsian]

Song - Good

Singer - Bad

Video - Really bad

[ghimchuan]

suggest raising the key just a little so u can sing higher.. this is a little too low for you I think.

[instereovideos]

Christ this is bad. It sounds like a little kid tried to write his first song, and then formed a band with random people without asking those people if they had ever played instruments before. Jesus, it's just so bad.

[poporin12123]

ดี

[mrreman]

Stupify

[Zouhaiter]

You're awesome Alex! Great song and video!

Dftba.

[clarence520]

Music - good

Singer- ....sucks!

[carolinaladivina]

this was awesome!! and alex you're amazing!

[samuelh063]

You are great! Your sound is a lot like another of my favorites, Jethro Tull. Keep up the good work.,

[LaurenYMAS]

Absolutely loved it! Great song :D

[JBXFACTOR89101]

Alex, you are awesome! If anybody has a problem with you, they're gonna have to get past me and my army of nerdfighters.

[taaeeh]

bad

[wisemint]

i like it but the vocals are lacking a bit

[sunchip72]

Good

[StarWhale15]

I love this!

[bcbeauc]

I don't know if it's the mustache or what. But is that Cary Elwes?

[VampireDemonQueen]

lol that amuses me...very good!

[iBmaori]

clever way to get famous!

[ImaTechGeek]

You need a better mixdown of this, levels were atrocious !

[daemadosa2]

Good

[csmejia71]

this is terrible.

[candecornluver]

Congrats! I love you, Alex. You are absolutely amazing, totally awoosome, unbelieveably talented, & supermeafoxyawesomehot. There will always be haters, but you should do what you love, with the people you love. Hopefully we will meet soon. You have my everlasting support. -3 hugs and butterfly kisses, Krystle

[alcoholicferrets]

I love love love the 20s silent film style video. It's all spot on, the movements, they eyeliner, etc. =]

[Sailortrance]

I will say that there was a lot of effort that went into this, and so I will say I respect you for that. I didn't really like the music or your voice, but I'll still thumbs up- for the amount of work you put into it.

[Awgez24]

Mr. Potter from Its a Wonderful Life.

[tjhall1000]

is this twilight?

[dannerzme]

Alex, you are one of the greatest minds on YouTube, thank you for sharing your greatness with us!!

[captiandrek]

I love how many people are treating this like The Remus Lupins are new. . .

Seeing this was great, I've been aching or some wizard rock since Harry and the Potter's 'Ride the Lightning' tour hit my city in June!

[phayjimbo2z]

im sorry for this band manager, lonely nights and broom sticks

[kj67879]

this is crap...sry vocals suck good try on the kickpack to the old silence...maybe it would be better if it had been sry just being honest

[will987s]

Great job ... I enjoyed it... Please make more like this.

[xKayleeWasHerex]

NEED ONE ABOUT TONKS PLEASE

[marissakay03]

AWESOME VIDEO! So I'm definitely subscribing. :)

[TheSTLOVER]

So awesome!!! I loved it!!!!!

[kingkal3]

This song captured one of the saddest parts of the Harry Potter universe.

[iamjoshng]

WE LOVE YOU ALEX! Don't let those haters hate!

[KatielouCurtis]

YES!!! this video is so amazing!  which music video have you done that you would consider your favorite?

[amberlikesapples]

YOUR AMAZING. [:

[Dustwitch]

I love it! Please do one about Snape.

[Sarawkweird]

What is wrong with these people? Everything about this video is majestic.

[nrhodes09]

test

[dansie714]

I don't get why some people bother writing rude comments on here. If you don't like it, DON'T WATCH IT! Alex, you're AWESOME and your friends are awesome for supporting you! Keep making music! :)

[starkidlover100]

I love and meany others do too don't let the haters get to u I have been a fan from the beginning and i will b a fan till the end love u soon much don't stop bing u

[Allfound12]

I clicked this because I thought it would be a good song about harry potter. Wrong.

[expertpianoman]

Thumbs up if you read the first page of music (0:11) and knew that it was actually beethoven's "moonlight" sonata. HA

[Taylorwest626]

"You guys are fucking lame! Com'on Cage your coming with me"



[FashionistaOnline]

my mom saw this on her igoogle and said "wait, does this have something to do with Harry Potter?" smh -_-

[fersiita00]

yay for alex being luke's friend! loved it btw

[KenshinSensei]

This is the only Alex Carpenter song that I like and I'm a potter head.

[vticher77]

WOW.... this so freak!! LOL

Sound reminds me The Clash....

But about Potter

Crazy, crazy

[jonathon6448]

I hope they have a day job. I am not paying for there health care. They suck ball sacs. Wow. Blow crap

[emcskills]

@jonathon6448 You shall stifle in your own report,

and smell of calumny.

[jessmejessmee]

u guys are awesommm:)

[destinydoodles]

No matter what haters come along, you'll always have your original fans. Don't let them get you down. <3

[JessicaLeader]

Sounds great!

[mjpartypants]

I'm sure these people are very nice, but this just painful to listen to

[emcskills]

@mjpartypants Thou jarring unwash'd knave!

[SlauterHouZe101]

everything is good but the vocals...they're...ehhhh

[JediMasterBrian]

136 people can't read books.

[13thVulture]

reminds me a bit of the veils. the vocals arent great, but... the style is similar. 

[wanasiapa]

Such a good effort.. thumbs up..

[BigCityDreams02]

i love you alex!!!

[M3LF4C3]

Yay, Alex!

[pizzutim926]

huge harry potter fan...........this was just disappointing

[museblock]

Not bad but vocals need a lot of work.

[posionousrose13]

Cool video! Something new and fresh! I like it!

[werewolfwithwings]

That was simply aw00some

[GinervaWeasleyPotter]

ignore them alex! you're so SUPERMEGAFOXYAWESOMEHOT!

You won on the rise for a reason - ur an awesome nerdfighter!

so boo you haters!

[CrazedAuthor]

Ya'll rock!

[wildtangerinelove]

lolololol genius sir!

[13ERex]

You know whats a good idea? You should make a music video about bears!!!

[poddesetnikG]

Nice

[saragill123456789]

It's just like when Alex did the Friday cover but i don't know what the trolls are saying this is awesome. (make more videos)

[9wj9jw9]

Ok.... I absolutely love Harry Potter. Favorite book series ever. This video is pretty cool. It's alright for a low-budget music video. But this song is just awful. Chord structure and chord development, and especially vocals. It's just not good The Ministry of Magic is the only way you can go with Harry Potter music.

[JoshGDaigle]

I don't know why, but this makes me want warm orios and ice cold milk.

[shenlong568]

102 Edward's don't like this

[Ruacach]

Great music video... :) Shame the song is so awful.... :(

[sappy441]

Let me sum up what you may have missed:

The following comments are simply Harry Potter fans enjoying a musical tribute to their favorite series and people who don't want them to enjoy it so instead of simply clicking dislike or forgetting about a video that does not apply to their interests, they vocally want them to be as miserable and hate-filled as them.

Maturity has been pushed aside by people who think their opinions matter because they can see their thoughts on a computer screen.

[TheLostCause76]

Check out TheLostCause76 for new original rock music from a Florida band and also watch a hilarious video of a crazy women lighting a fart on a birthday cake....

[TheElectricFirebolt]

stop sippin on tha hateraid

[goofygoober981]

I love Harry Potter but this is just a little bit weird..

[spiffy427]

This was the first Remus Lupins song I heard and I feel in love instantly -3

[speed0spank]

I guess Luke's army came crashing in since he posted his vlog because I am seeing so much positivity ;) lucky to have good friends like that! You're awesome!

[Yariitzaable]

loverrrss you (:

[woodfromthehood100]

Congratz On the front page!!:) you deserve it!!

[30072743]

oh my god the vocalist is just awful.

[FrankHarrisonFord]

@TheRainbowSupreme, you may want to read John 8: 1-11. Here Jesus makes it clear that we are to not judge or condemn people. To everyone who may have read this person's comment, that is not what being a Christian is about. We are not to judge nor condemn. We are to Love as Jesus Loves. I think Alex Carpenter is a gifted musician and singer. I think he is very clever. I wish him the best along with everyone reading this comment. This person has severely misrepresented Jesus and the Gospel.

[raytwin11]

I dont like this song because it tell you not to read the books

[PeetaPettigrew]

Awesome video! Probably one of my all time fav Wrock vids!

[Goleghar]

Hhj

[impuseuser]

Finally a song that I can really connect too! -_-

[blueeyedbraniac]

so people people are hating on Alex if you don't like it just leave because the people who do enjoy don't want you here anyway

[Jamesdo33]

plz go to his channel and beat the crap out of it everyone can have their own opinion and this guy is an idiot for talking about not reading real book. Harry Potter is an amazing series so i guess he can go fuck himself!!

[Jamesdo33]

Not my opinion i found out what TheRainbowSupreme said "JOANNA NEWSOM, MF DOOM, NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL, YEAH YEAH YEAHS, MODEST MOUSE, THESE ARE GOOD BANDS. GET YOUR HEAD OUT OF THE FUCKING TOILET KIDS. YOU MAY BE YOUNG BUT YOU DONT HAVE TO BE STUPID. READ A FUCKING BOOK A REAL BOOK FUCKTARD AND STOP EATING GARBAGE. JESUS CHRIST WATCH A WERNER HERZOG MOVIE FOR FUCKS SAKE. DOES ANYONE HAVE GOOD TASTE? PEOPLE LIKE THIS ARE MURDERING YOUR BRAIN! THUMBS UP IF YOU WANT TO REPENT YOUR WICKED WICKED WAYS

[Nickdonaldsbfast]

shitty singer, unoriginal lyrics, essentially failing at what could have been a great idea. catchy beat though...