Added: 3 years ago
From: NikUnderhill
Views: 178,204
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm sorry,but this is awful,It is a pop ballad and not even a genuine one,it comes off as forced.I am an open-minded person,but I don't get what they were aiming for with this album...

  • Ah, Isnt this the song the drummer commited suicide because of? Now I'm hearing it i can feel his and Kai Hansens frustration and dissapointment!

  • A great Helloween song (one of the best soothing metal ballads). Though not in Kai Hansen style but just wonderful.

  • Beautiful.........

  • I'm too young to think about it, but ... this will be the official lullaby for my son

  • kk guys, if you don't like a song, simply don't search for it on youtube. this song is LYRICALLY much more helloween than many of their "heavy" things. actually, they have been changing songwriters so often that is almost impossible to classify anything as "true helloween"... if we're going by that line, everything after Hansen has left the band can be classified as not-helloween. but hey, the song's got meanings, if you don't like listening to lyrics, then keep listening to mindless riffing!

  • it is Helloween and it's pure CRAP!!!

  • @danmenez not liking something is a pathetic and miserable excuse for calling it SHIT. the song's got meaning... and yeah, I guess you're one of those metalheads who don't care about lyrics or meanings, just listening to great riffs - anything without great riffs is pure shit, I guess, for you.. well, pal, this song is melodically pretty good, and it's lyrically much more Helloween than some of their "heavy" works...

  • If it wasnt Helloween I would call it shit

  • yep, ingo was right, R.I.P

  • This song is probably the reason why kiske left haha

  • Comment removed

  • Ingo Schwichtenberg was right..

    

  • Helloween's original drummer called this song 'shitmill'. Have to say i'm not a big fan of this song either.

  • @joshie92 i understand you dont like the song i happen to like it i think its what is known as a power ballad shows the singing voice talent.A much more mature aproach then some garbage rock n roll or shit metal song that is mindless garbage with childish lyrics

  • las mejores rolas junto con la de A Tale That Wasnt Right

    DE: herlloween jeje no ma se la rifaron...

  • Comment removed

  • I swear to god. I sing this song to myself at least once a week. I don't even realize that I am doing it. It's such a beautiful song.

  • This seens Elvis Presley...

  • Hermoso video... hermosa canción... ehmmm felicidades!!!

  • I don't understand why people watch and comment hate. If you don't like it, DONT WATCH IT. You're morons for proving to everyone that you're stupid. It's like saying "HEY! I'M A TROLL. AND AT THAT, A BAD ONE!" god.

  • Beautiful video for a beautiful song. Really brings back a lot memories. Very good job!

  • @daviddek27 Couldn't agree with you more! This song brings back beautiful memories...

  • ela re xristoforidiiii...ellada reee

  • sent me to sleep

  • This song should be renamed to Shitmill.

  • @TRUEkiller6666 you should be renamed to "bad taste for music".

  • @TRUEkiller6666 Real original

  • This album their weakest album, but it's not worse in my optinion.

    But what's wrong with Pink Bubbles Go Ape? That's a perfect album, with great songs like "The chance" "Mankind" and "Someone's crying". And all song is good in Pink Bubbles... But certainly it's my optinion.

    Ohh, and Helloween forever!

  • gay ballad, can be this called metal???

  • Like it :)

  • WOODSTOCK KURWA

  • i love this song

  • " everlasting ballads........i like "

  • good music balad

  • Kick ass song

  • Reminds me of Milli Vanilli, hahahaha.

  • I have th original CD. Some stupid gifted to me because he did n´t like it . I know that this is not the heavier Helloween´s album , but it´s excellent..

  • Dont get me wrong peeps, i love helloween. And tbh i hate it when people make negative comments on songs: if u dont lke the link dont go there... but as i said i listen to helloween for more than 15 years, but this will have to be the worst album they made for me likes. PBGA was a good album, but chameleon im not so sure.. lots of shit happening around the band at that time and i think the album came up as an attempt to commercialise. But yea metallica today are def worse than this :D

  • @beaffteki

    You hate when people make negative comments on songs? How the fuck are we supposed to know whether the song is good or bad if we don't listen to it. And everyone is entitled to an opinion dude. Is an opinion only valid if it agrees with yours?

  • @beaffteki thats the way a 12 year old thinks, clear and open your mind dude everybody can comment freely and say their opinion either its good or bad

  • No matter what they say, I've been going on listening to this song since they released the album I'd rather prefer it to today's Metallica...

  • Great song. Always makes me happy ;)

  • Muito Bom *-*

  • chours: maiden ,maiden ,iron maiden haha :D ;)

  • @zdraloviocnjaci Hahahaha. xD \m/

  • @zdraloviocnjaci comparing the worst helloweens album with iron maiden - epic

  • @Lundvalnaden you probably didn't listen "Shit bubbles go ape"! that's their worst album, dude! this one is pretty good, but this song is gay!

  • Ingo was right. This song should be called SHITMILL

  • @siamois71 Yeah, he was so right. And then Wei-fag-kath fires him! He might as well had pushed him on the railroad track himself...

  • muy bonita sin duda...pero echo de menos al impresionante cantante de los "keeper",sabeis donde se quedo? aqui su voz parece de lo mas corriente,sin hacer gala de sus impresionantes agudos y falsetes :(

    PD :aun asi me gusto xD

  • Uma das melhores do Helloween, muito bonita :)

  • This song has always creeped me out since the first time i heard it. I can't tell why, but it creeps me out. Especially the beginning with this rusted swing sound. That's prob. the only helloween song that i don't really like listening to.

  • Such a beautiful song. The bunny at the end... xD

  • very good song !!!!Michael Kiske is a great singer !

  • Ingo calls it "Shitmill"

    spot on description. 

  • einfach spitze!!!!!!!!

  • it's funny how ingo hated this song

  • one of the best rock ballad in the history!!!!

  • ANG DATING DAAN BACKGROUND,THE OLD PATH

  • FLY HIGH! TOUCH THE SKY! :/

  • 6 ppl need to stop listening to crap... or clean theyr ears... just a verry little message for those 6 idiots: _|_

  • @Houstof Now they are 10. And since i am one of them I have a simple message for you as well...SUCK MY DICK FAGGOT!!

  • @evermetal2 is your faggot a dick? =D

  • @Houstof I knew it from the start that you are really stupid...

  • @evermetal2 youre fighting over a music and im stupid? just stfu troll

  • @Houstof Suck my dick fag and then shove your head in your ass so that we won't hear from you ever again.

  • @evermetal2 lol... youre fag is still a dick =)

  • @Houstof And you are still stupid...

  • @evermetal2 yes i am =D and you love me dontya? "evermetal" you look like a kid that dont know the roots of metal.... you just like garbage dont you? i feel sorry for your kind.... please..... accept my apologies... i didnt know you were special.... is there any thing i can do to help you? i like helping people in need

  • @Houstof And I suppose YOU know about metal, huh? I've been listening to Metal for 20 fuckin' years and I can tell you that THIS is pure shit. Nothing more than a sell-out.

  • @evermetal2 A SELL OUT???? =D omg you suck so much =( now i really know how "special" you are... really...

  • @Houstof Ooooh, fuck you. Your case is hopeless...

  • @evermetal2 dont worry about yours... i hope you grow up

  • @Houstof Blah blah blah.......

  • @evermetal2 why comment back when you have nothing to say? "blah blah blah" wtf? youre stil in the kidengarden?

  • @Houstof Just keep mumbling dumbass. You MIGHT convince yourself you're right...

  • @evermetal2 i dont care whos right or wrong... i just wanna help you out because im worried about you... you seen confused.... youre fag that whose fag is also a dick.. thats worrying.......

  • @Houstof Apparently, BOTH your reading and writing abilities haven't improved since you were 6. No wonder...

  • @evermetal2 lol... english is not my native language and I really don't care about writing it the right or wrong way..... what I really care about is to help people thats just in need.... seriously.... no joke.... if you need me i'll be happy... no... honored to help you.... such a awesome guy.... just some disabilities but well... no ones perfect... not your fault you are hearing impaired.... you could use those devices.... or adjust yours if you use one... dont believe is the case but well....

  • @Houstof You keep mumbling the same shit all the time. Clearly a retard...You must be Brazilian, no you are Braz-alien....that's why you like this piece of shit.

  • @evermetal2 lol... after seeing my profile you guess im brazilian =D~~ yeah.. you just continue to show how "special"..like been brazilian is a reason to like helloween old times music..thats not my favorite from helloween..still is better then a lot of music out there.... well..youre greek? well i guess youre gay then? dick gay fag =) lots of gayness in greek history isnt there =) now i know why youre like that.... its good to talk to you... now i can understand a little more about your species

  • @Houstof Like you said...in ancient history but now...go ask your girlfriend...if you have one 'cause you look more like a fag to me. Judging by the shit you like.

  • @evermetal2 LoL =D the shit i like? you dont like helloween do you? no... so what... helloween is not justin bieber for me to be a fag for liking it..... if i like queen then im a fag? twisted sisters??... you seen too much worried about others sexual choice.... people like that are most fags... gays... you say people are fag too much... probaly deep inside you you wanna be a fag =D

  • @evermetal2 and yeah... im a braz-alien =D im in the wrong place.... since ive born i feel like this is not my place... thats why im moving to japan....... you know what alien means right? or you tried to tell me i was a green brazilian?

  • @Houstof Fag? Me? HA! Like I said, ask your girlfriend. Also, Helloween are one of my fav bands but not when they compose shit like this. But you're probably from another planet and you like listening to crap there. Save it kiddo, you are not up to it. When you start listening to some REAL Metal, come back...

  • @evermetal2 youre freaking 32 yo and still talk like a kindergarden little kid..... ask my girlfriend... you dont even know me... never been to brazil i guess.... and you talk shit about other people girlfriend like you fucked her or something.... you make me laugh greek boy.... dont your brain grow up with your old balls? real metal? what is it? black sabbath? iron maiden? pantera? mega death? blind guardians? pick one... live em all.... metal is not just heavy sound.... theres more to it..

  • @evermetal2 you listen to metal since youre 12..... you should had known it.... or youre a closed mind person with cant see trough a open window and just spot a city? theres more to every thing.... tell me... is forever and one also a "sell out"?? people that makes music dont need to stick to "cool" lyrics... they also want to show more emotion in theyr songs.... but i guess youre a tough guy thats never sad or in love aint ya greek boy? playing all macho man when theres no reason to

  • @Houstof Okay, let's forget the girlfriend part, my bad, and let's talk serious here. Alright? Noone said, ballads are not cool, Forever And One, A Tale That Wasn't Right and so on. But, come on, this is not even close! This sounds more like pop music. Even the bands you mentioned have shitty songs, noone's perfect. And I am not playing it tough or bad, Death Metal, Black Metal etc.

  • @evermetal2 idk man.. for me that's not even close to pop music... just a unique helloween music.

  • @Houstof For someone who really woships everythind they did, until the Keeper...albums, no matter how I try, I cannot find anything good in this. It surprises me that many people like this album. I am not prejudiced, I just cannot dig this stuff.

  • @evermetal2 idk.... just whatever..... tired of this subject =) but this album is not just bad... watch?v=3-SC4TjmnEg&feature=re­lated that one kind of reminds of some ozzy stuff

  • @Houstof

    well, i consider my self a die-hard helloween fun, however i really dont like this song plus i consider Chameleon as a mediocre-towards bad- album. This is not because its pop mate, its just a BAD album for me taste. Tbh i listen to pop sometimes, i like good pop music. This song could be best described as cheesy ballad for 8 year olds who all smile by the camp fire, while the album has a play-more-of-us-on-the-radio-w­e-aint-metal attitude, instead of being genuine creative work

  • @beaffteki This song is simplistic and kind of bad, but whoever doesn't find songs like "Giants", "I Believe" and "Longing" (all from the Chameleon album) creative has some major issues!

  • @evermetal2 man, i love metal songs, my fav bands are helloween,gamma ray, iron maiden, megadeth etc.. but tbh ,i think windmill is a good song,and it does bring me good memories,...that's what i call a good song..i'm not gonna say ur fag or smthing coz it doesnt make sense.but the true fact is that ur an idiot if u call this song a GAY BALLAD.and then what??if i do listen to the beatles, to pink floyd or to the rolling stones, it means i'm a fag?? you piece of shit, just grow up..

  • @dafronasmia Your mother's corpse is a piece of shit, got it asshole?? And especially YOU, you don't have to listen to the beatles to be a fag. You're a fag no matter what. Go fuck yourself and then die. OH, AND STOP PRETENDING TO BE A METALHEAD.

  • @evermetal2 i think i should decide if am a metalhead or not, not waiting for you to tell me, you street rat.plus, i know iron maiden, scorpions, judas priest, megadeth, avantasia, edguy, much more than you do. n even if i listen to the stones , jimi hendrix ,eric clapton or chuck berry.they're GODS and doesn't mean i'm listening to justin bieber, eminem or lil wayne.besides,you seem to see fags everywhere.so i guess ur the only fag here.end of discussion.now shut up you, you tax dodgin student

  • @dafronasmia Yeah, right. I'm sure you know much more than I do...if that makes you happy...now, listen to this piece of shit, go hug your mother and cry. FAAAAAAAG!!!!

  • @evermetal2 yep. listen to black metal songs, drink blood , you're gonna be THE only man .. and i am the fag

  • @dafronasmia man, you just made yourself an admirer. good point, this song ain't a "gay ballad" or something, it's got meanings, and if someone doesn't like it, just don't search for it on youtube, everything's fine, nobody here has been FORCED to listen to it or to like it... right?

  • This song really shows what Helloween is capable of produce.

    It's not within the metal genre, no. I'd rather recall it as "magic". This is pure art.

  • Schönes Lied, schönes vid. Danke!

  • ομορφο κομματι ¨)

  • I most definitely think this was a low point in Helloween's career. Shame, because the piano at the beginning is incredible. This doesn't sound like it came from a band that had ever been metal.

  • So sad!

  • I Genualy Cried

  • dla najcudowniejszej dziewczyny na świecie

    

  • ela re patrioti...xairomai polu pou eisai ellinas k akous helloween...to tragoudi einai apisteuto..

  • Windmill+girls=<3

  • ingo didn't like this song - but he is legend .. i love helloween

  • @bartenderjoe899 You're fucking retarded.

  • Funny as how it can be. Schwichtenberg referred this song to as "Shitmill" according Michael Weikath.

  • Comment removed

  • This should be Holland's National Anthem! LOL!

  • Hearing Michael Kiske's voice again is like holy water on the soul.

  • Ingo jumped infront of a train because he was ashamed of making this song. I much prefer the power metal side of Helloween, but i'm not gonna lie and say i don't listen to this stuff as well.

  • @bartenderjoe899 ingo did not like this song, he jumped in front of a subway train due to a long battle with drugs and not taking medication for a mental condition. a long battle with depression ended his life. very sad!!!! R.I.P. INGO

  • After all its a matter of taste...For me Windmill is one of Helloween best songs. n to me Forever n One or In The Middle of a Heartbeat more "pinky" than this song. Look at the lyrics. Look at the tone...Guitar Distortion aint always means rock.... Windmill has something unique in music, but Forever n One n In the middle of a heartbeat is just similiar with other slow rock songs....Windmill, keep on turning

  • nice song...

  • Who is this if it`s not Helloween. It`s Helloween.It`s joy.

  • Well,i don't care anymore if Ingo hated this song, or if everyone else hate, or if everyone says Chameleon sucks, or Whatever, I love this song and fuck everything else...

  • @killerfireworks101 a lot of bands do that nowadays, and I think they're all right in doing that, if I had a band for more than 6 years, I would die if I didn't release at least one ballad or if I didn't experimented a little because it's terrible for a band, specially these old ones like 15+ to sound exactly the same through the years, or at least I would hate that.

  • Ingo hated this song....because this really isn't power metal like the band is famous for. Many power bands tend to do this. First heavy then something quit different. i'm not ripping on the song; I just want people to know how Ingo really felt about this "soft touch stuff"

  • komatara !!!

  • beautiful i love kiske

  • "Bolhas cor de rosa viram chipanzés!"

  • aww q linda canciòn. <3

  • Jeden z lepszych kawałków Kiske słucham od młodych lat zespołu Helloween i takiego wokalu moje ucho się nie boi...;-) Pozdrawiam

  • I'd refuse to play this shitmill of a song too.

    Schizophrenic drug addict drummers will live on in our memories

    PS: this entire album needs to die in a fire. Atleast Pink Bubbles had a few good songs

  • @dethdakiller0 well too bad cause ur mom loves to listen at this song when im screwing her from her asshole

  • @CallebAntichrist

    Cool story bro

  • This is absolutely sicking!! This band sux.

  • @7WordsET suck my balls retard, you heard one song and make a statement like this? By that logic i see you being retarded now, so i conclude you are retarded in general :]

  • Ingo hated this song....he called it "Shitmill"

  • Love this song <3

  • beautiful song! reminds me one girl :)

  • I really love this song, and yet I think it is the worst Helloween album

  • A very, very slow number from the Power Metal Band to cool things down for the sake of mankind. Happy, Happy Helloween !!

  • The best....

    (google translate-latvian) -:baigi labais gabals!!! Latvijā arī ir tādas dzirnavas!!! :):):)

  • ich weiss ganz genau warum ich diesen song immer weitergedrückt habe ;-) katastrophe ...

  • ich weiss ganz genau warum ich diesen song immer weitergedrückt habe ;-) katastrophe ...

  • I never thought that the Windows sample pictures could be usefulls!! Good song.

  • This song may heal you.

  • Ingo hated this song

  • know that I think about it, I never really listened chamelleon, since everybody said it sucks. This song might not be metal, but it sure is good!

  • Cahaya yg terang

  • I love Helloween mine goods!!!!!

  • Man I hate this song. It is one of the worst helloween songs. I dont mean to make you guys who likes this song mad but this is not helloween.

  • @scatman813

    It sure as hell isn't helloween's style...But it's a beautiful song. :)

  • a mi me gustaba helloween con kiske, pero esta canción parece una nana!!

  • Ingo did not like this song.

  • Very nice tune! My hope is that in time this album will be revaluated because in itself it's very good.

  • That was when we knew that the 80s were gone and would never come back again.

  • This song is awsome and chameleon is not a bad album just because it isn't 'helloween". It is simply them trying something new and expanding their horizons which only makes them better musicians.

    p.s. Helloween is DAMN AMAZING!

  • egrapases nick......

  • lol, i tell ya, listening to this song years later, i really have to admit... it's not a bad song. It's just extremely un-helloween, and they can get away with a LOT and still be helloween. Its kinda like a well done tune that should be in the opening credits to a show on the "education channel" or something like that, not on any rock band's record, lol. And this is not Michael Kiske's best singing, he's a little flat and lazy here and there, like his heart wasn't in it.

  • Great song!!

  • Hm....

    I don't have a problem with ballads in metal. Surely, there is a lot of great songs which can beat all of FM and pop songs up. But this one....

    Hm...Hm...

  • fucking shitmill!

  • I agree 100% with ya Daniella :) And thank u for the nice words :) Nik

  • I honestly can´t understand people who think "metal" band is absolutely forbidden to record anything even close to "pop". There are no borders in music, no good or bad songs- because something so awesome as music can´t be bad... there are just compositions you like and dislike. This one is from the first cathegory for me. it´s very touching, moody and I think it nicely captures the emotion behind Weiki´s behaviour. Awesome song, perfect video, 5 stars.

  • this song reminds me of my late father.. the last time i heard this was when my father was still alive 15 years ago..

  • so nice!! song is awesome!

  • c'est un unique....

  • I agree with Ingo...this song is forever in my mind, Shitmill. However I respect the work Nik put into making the video.

  • this song came from heaven

  • @pitbull1981gr Yes indeed!