I cherish this scene, it says so very very much! 37Dionysos post below says it all it makes you crazy then it makes you sane! A whole lot of truth in these moments. I think every kid in America should see it( when they're old enough)
...Britain was destroyed, France was destroyed, Germany was destroyed, Japan was destroyed, Mongolia was destroyed, Russia (Soviets) was destroyed, Sumer was destroyed, Babylonia was destroyed, Egypt was destroyed.
America will be destroyed, China will follow, and India soon after. No great imperial (militaristic or economic) nation will ever stand the test time. So why not yours? How much longer do you think your country will last?
I would say about two more years give or take a month.
@Remington61189 ti spacco il culo bastardo..propaganda inglese e americana:gli italiani sono codardi.........fatte schiffo inglesi e americani di merda..suchiatecci il cazzo
I love this scene and am glad you posted it. I have sent it to many friends and watch it once a week or so. The book Catch - 22 was much better than the movie but this scene and THE B-25's especially are a great thing to watch. The B-25 takeoff scene is an over looked movie screen gem and if you listen to the sound on headphones while watching it is as close as you can get to flying in one. I was lucky enough to catch a ride in one in S. Fla> early '80's and consider it a thrill of a lifetime!
I cant even express the happiness I felt when Rise Against incorporated this in Survivor Guilt; my favorite dialogue of my favorite book being featured in my favorite band's song :)
@pork2k how? after I heard the song i reread the book listening to the album. AWESOME experience. besides, it gets people to want to read the book more.
My favourite scene,grandpa destroyed his little american world.
The whole book was black humour flavored and I laughed my ass off but when Snowden died that was terrible.This book really made me think life is funny in it's nonsense but dying isn't at all.
Marcel Dalio, who plays the old man, is the same actor who plays Emil the croupier in Casablanca. In one of that movie's memorable scenes, Claude Rains as Captain Renault closes down Rick's (Humphrey Bogart) saloon using the pretext, "I am shocked, shocked to find that gambling is going on in here!". Emil - Dalio/old man - approaches Rains and hands him his usual bribe money with the line "Your winnings sir." Same actor! Marcel, who died in '83 at 83, lives on forever in 2 legendary movies.
thanks for posting this part of the movie...i just watched the movie again recently and it has much more meaning for me now than it did when I was in my teens. Now an anti-war activist and much more aware of the military industrial complex...I wanted to use this piece and post it to fb
Casting Art Garfunkel as Nately was absolutely perfect. Except maybe the chaplain, Nately was the sweetest, most heartbreaking character in the book. And Art Garfunkel is almost ridiculously angelic.
I have just finished reading this amazing book and it's so strange to see the characters in the film, I imagined them totally differently, but this is the magic in reading.
The old world philosopher has the new world idealist by the short and curlies, yet is gracious and urbane, of course they are discussing all this in a bordello .. . wonderful clip. It's not so much an anti-war as a 'pro-life' movie!!
It was cold in Chicago. A brass band played outside of the movie theater at the premier of Catch 22. I don't remember the name of the theater. Many of the actors were there. Yosarian sat behind me. The movie is better today than yesterday.
One of my early childhood memories -- i was wondering if I had just imagined it or not (not too many Chicago premiers) -- I was a kid with my mom -- we didn't see the movie, but just happened to walk by, and then lingered around for a while as the stars walked by. My most distinct memory of the event was the sight of an older man with newly implanted hair-plugs -- which formed an odd grid patterm, and were not quite healed.
The film has one of the longest, most complex uninterrupted scenes ever made. In the scene, where two actors talking against a background, 16 of the 17 planes, four groups of four aircraft, took off at the same time. The problem was, for every take, the production manager has to call the planes back and made to take off again for every take of the particular scene. This was done four times.
Marcel Dailo, the old guy, was a much sought-after French character actor who worked a lot with von Stroheim. In "Casablanca" when Claude Rains delivers the signature line, 'I'm shocked! Shocked! To find that there's gambling going on in here!' the croupier, Emil, played by Dalio, approaches from the roulette table and says simply, 'Your winnings, sir.'
As the filming of Catch-22 took longer than planned in 1970, Art Garfunkel wasn't able to make it back to New York from Europe in time to start writing and recording the album "Bridge Over Troubled Water". Angered by the delay, Paul Simon wrote the track "The Only Living Boy in New York" about the incident.
Artie!
ohhicaroline 20 hours ago
Why are people saying Rise Against?
I love Rise Against too (think Revolutions Per Minute is the best album ever)
But everyone is forgetting Tim's band in the 90s, BAXTER, who used the same audio clip in the song Burden.
AlmostaFlipinSkater 5 days ago
Im Just here for Art Garfunkel..
somegreens 1 week ago 3
Rise against yea!!!
awesomeness1367 1 week ago
fuck rise against, BOMB20 is what got me here!!
jabrove 3 weeks ago
PS didja know the Italian citizens per capita income is now more than Great Britain's??? And the Germans now own Rolls Royce and JEEP??!!??!!!
chasyes1 2 months ago
@chasyes1 Italy's also in the middle of a massive debt crisis.
TKZ100 1 month ago
I cherish this scene, it says so very very much! 37Dionysos post below says it all it makes you crazy then it makes you sane! A whole lot of truth in these moments. I think every kid in America should see it( when they're old enough)
chasyes1 2 months ago
...Britain was destroyed, France was destroyed, Germany was destroyed, Japan was destroyed, Mongolia was destroyed, Russia (Soviets) was destroyed, Sumer was destroyed, Babylonia was destroyed, Egypt was destroyed.
America will be destroyed, China will follow, and India soon after. No great imperial (militaristic or economic) nation will ever stand the test time. So why not yours? How much longer do you think your country will last?
I would say about two more years give or take a month.
MERC3NARYPRODUCTIONS 2 months ago
Fuck Rise Against, Mr. Garfunkel is why you're watching.
JesusFishAndFriends 2 months ago
"Its better to live on your feet than to die on your knees."
Truely a quote to live by.
gp16593 2 months ago 3
the book version of this film was on my GCSE english paper last year. oh my god. what a coincidence that its in one of my favourite bands songs!
revels95 3 months ago
Comment removed
kcg5000 2 months ago
All this time I've been wondering where the lines from Rise Against's song came from....I found it. XD
neuroticsquirreljack 3 months ago
This scene is tremendous but the book's version is even better! Makes you crazy and then it makes you sane....
37Dionysos 4 months ago
best social commentary ever!
Nunto1 4 months ago
this sums up what italians were during ww2
Remington61189 4 months ago
@Remington61189 ti spacco il culo bastardo..propaganda inglese e americana:gli italiani sono codardi.........fatte schiffo inglesi e americani di merda..suchiatecci il cazzo
TonyCagnoni 3 months ago
3:15 Truer words have never been spoken.
Nightrbinger24 4 months ago
That old bugger had a point. How could he be wrong. Hed lived longer than that kid after all.
grimblebrumble17889 4 months ago
I love this scene and am glad you posted it. I have sent it to many friends and watch it once a week or so. The book Catch - 22 was much better than the movie but this scene and THE B-25's especially are a great thing to watch. The B-25 takeoff scene is an over looked movie screen gem and if you listen to the sound on headphones while watching it is as close as you can get to flying in one. I was lucky enough to catch a ride in one in S. Fla> early '80's and consider it a thrill of a lifetime!
chasyes1 4 months ago
Thumbs up if you came to this based on "Survivor Guilt" by Rise Against.
fightclub1537 4 months ago 30
SURVIVORS GUILTTTTT its so powerful with the music
iamtheSASS 4 months ago 3
Rise Against. Is awesome it's cool that they used some of this dialogue.
InsecurePsychotic 5 months ago 3
I looked up rise against lyrics to see where that line came from. I find it so cool it came from a movie.
BlackNikNakFlak 5 months ago 3
"You have it a-backward-za...." Ain't that the truth?
37Dionysos 5 months ago
WHOAH. lol That is probably one of the best/funniest scenes I've ever seen.
varekai918 5 months ago
Comment removed
Nunto1 4 months ago
I cant even express the happiness I felt when Rise Against incorporated this in Survivor Guilt; my favorite dialogue of my favorite book being featured in my favorite band's song :)
EntertainTheDeranged 5 months ago 3
unh hah, you're all crazy. an italian with a french accent? coulda cast this better, nichols. art is good, tho (for a singer)
ultrakool 6 months ago
great quotes
dabul3169 6 months ago
don't know anything about any song. but this novel was one of the greatest of the 20th century.
mrspivvy 6 months ago
Thumbs up if you liked this before the Rise Against song
stargazer93 6 months ago
They portrayed this scene from the book very well.
ChannelCatch22 7 months ago
5 people thought the dislike button was "Backwards" Shameful Opportunists..
RadiationBeats 8 months ago
The real Rise against fans who do researches and are into rise against for a long time know that this was already used in a song by tim in the 90's
RDSPunk933 8 months ago
@RDSPunk933 Which song is that?
JohnMac1011 6 months ago
Thank you for uploading this ^^ one of the most meaningful scenes in a movie. Though I cant seem to find a copy of it anywhere
Sigefreadthebulmunk 9 months ago
Block the entrances, close the doors.
Seal the exits because this is war.
I really should watch this movie again...
ZombieFryCook 9 months ago 3
@ZombieFryCook you should read the book instead.
hollymoon21 6 months ago
@hollymoon21 I have? I'm re-reading it now
ZombieFryCook 6 months ago
great, rise against ruined this great book for me
pork2k 9 months ago
@pork2k how? after I heard the song i reread the book listening to the album. AWESOME experience. besides, it gets people to want to read the book more.
EntertainTheDeranged 5 months ago
i was typing in my iphone so ya not as easy as you think
maxnak4 9 months ago
Only because of Rise Against I've watched this movie.
LvRezery 9 months ago 7
3.51 facial expression pwned!!
SupraCRF 9 months ago
And other guy its not u hav ut backwards live on ur feet 4 crists sake u just watched the fing clip u think u would b able 2 remember its
U shameful opertunist
What u dont understand is that its better 2 die on ur feet than 2 live on ur knees
Ah, u have it backwards
Its better 2 live on ur feet than 2 die on ur knee
maxnak4 10 months ago
@maxnak4 Your abuse of grammar makes my soul hurt...
WhereBeDragons 9 months ago 3
@WhereBeDragons For typing all of that bullshit he needs to be shot in the head, revived and then shot again.
EmperorHeresy 9 months ago
Omg actualy u mite of been rite i ment 2 correct other guy i mean rly its
I fought with courage
To preserve
Not my way of life
But yours
maxnak4 10 months ago
And hell ya rise against all the way
maxnak4 10 months ago
Dude its what purpose did this serve, what purpose did i serve
maxnak4 10 months ago
What purpose does this serve? What purpose did I serve?
trolltacular1 10 months ago 2
He fought with courage to preserve... Not his way of life but yours.
BTR0C 10 months ago
It’s “Survivor Guilt”.
FuelledByHamish 10 months ago
1:08 for beginning of Survivor's Guilt
3:15 for end of the song
RISE AGAINST
xZOOM99999x 10 months ago 121
@xZOOM99999x hell yeah, thats what brought me here. Rise Against. :D
strawberriesandgravy 10 months ago
@xZOOM99999x Awesome. ENDGAME is why I checked this video out. lol
corruptgunslinger 7 months ago 2
@xZOOM99999x hey, i just randomly looked up catch 22, didn't know this was used in one of rise against's songs, that band fuckin rocks :)
TasteForDisaster 5 months ago
@xZOOM99999x Emiliano Zapata Google it. :-)
dreamshooter90 2 weeks ago
Yessss marcadamia Nut
SuperAidan5 10 months ago
Rise Against - Survivor's Guilt
MarcadamiaNut 10 months ago 4
Absolutely great scene---Quintissential Catch 22!
37Dionysos 11 months ago
Favourite scene
Rockapebates 1 year ago
My favourite scene,grandpa destroyed his little american world.
The whole book was black humour flavored and I laughed my ass off but when Snowden died that was terrible.This book really made me think life is funny in it's nonsense but dying isn't at all.
Szczotkov 1 year ago
- "Don't you have ANY principles?"
- "Of course not (hissing sound)!!"
LOL
rem2267 1 year ago
Apply to the current situation in Asia.
Lather, rinse and repeat until clean.
rdecredico 1 year ago
Perfect! It shows the futility and absurdity of patriotism. I love the old man.
dfdjw 1 year ago
don't ever, ever get sucked into facsism. then you won't ever, ever have to worry about dying on your knees. listen up, america
ultrakool 1 year ago 3
Good question.
lad500 1 year ago
Living 5 years in Italy, I can confirm "Italy is a very moral country";-)Joseph Heller's rules!
requinromantique 1 year ago 2
Marcel Dalio, who plays the old man, is the same actor who plays Emil the croupier in Casablanca. In one of that movie's memorable scenes, Claude Rains as Captain Renault closes down Rick's (Humphrey Bogart) saloon using the pretext, "I am shocked, shocked to find that gambling is going on in here!". Emil - Dalio/old man - approaches Rains and hands him his usual bribe money with the line "Your winnings sir." Same actor! Marcel, who died in '83 at 83, lives on forever in 2 legendary movies.
Lonette 1 year ago 3
HAHAHAHA Thanks for that fact! RIP!
That was probably the funnies scene in Casablanca!
rcdESPANYOL4ever 1 year ago
u have it backwards
live on your feet
tippycolfax 2 years ago
art!
Nickdude6 2 years ago 4
thanks for posting this part of the movie...i just watched the movie again recently and it has much more meaning for me now than it did when I was in my teens. Now an anti-war activist and much more aware of the military industrial complex...I wanted to use this piece and post it to fb
thanks again
wemissamerica 2 years ago
just great...
Ralexand1988 2 years ago
Arty didn't need to act his "New Yawk" accent.
Chrisdrumz 2 years ago
great movie/book
oooBOOSHooo 2 years ago
The strangest thing ever in any film i have seen happend and still freaks me out when i see it.If you have not seen it is in a scene at the lake.
TheTmny876able 2 years ago
did the ska band get there name from this?
manchillout 2 years ago
Not sure what band you mean, but if they're called Catch 22 then yes, indirectly or directly, because this is where it origionated (first a book).
MyOwnRejects 2 years ago
whoa. he reminds me of emperor palpatine.
beowgrendel 2 years ago
this is nothing how I imagined this scene when i read the book!! hehe which is to be expected of course...
brownca 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
catch 23
jlbengry23 3 years ago
Great book
omghxrSpRiNgEr 3 years ago
I love this book. It's fantastic
simonpaul3 3 years ago
America is deliberately being destroyed right now.
tapper36 3 years ago
"would you go put some clothes on? You're practically naked."
hilarious.
jonfromcanada 3 years ago
Casting Art Garfunkel as Nately was absolutely perfect. Except maybe the chaplain, Nately was the sweetest, most heartbreaking character in the book. And Art Garfunkel is almost ridiculously angelic.
TressaJT 3 years ago 4
One of the best dialogues in movie history
ffh8666 3 years ago 41
@ffh8666 Dude, screw the movie, this is one of the most memorable scenes in the book Catch-22 by Joseph Heller.
TheUnwrittenWriter 1 year ago 3
@ffh8666 Yes, indeed.
infonomics 1 year ago
You cannot defeat us, for we have already defeated ourselves.
regimesoftruth 3 years ago
I like Art Garfunkel :)
MakiHad 3 years ago 16
This is my favorite scene in the movie. So true- and quite contemporary in its scope and meaning.
rayjr62 3 years ago
This be my favorite book. ( Catch 22)
next is "All quiet by the Western Front"
Then, "slaughter house 5"
airsoftcrazed 3 years ago
Catch 22 is very good book :)But film is also very good.
MakiHad 3 years ago 2
this movie is great! if you want to listen more stuff on it, there is a website which has a nice podcasting on catch 22: beyondtheexposition. com
check it out!
nicomar78 3 years ago
This book is my favorite...
its up there with "The Brothers Karamazov" and "Under Western Eyes"
GREENgummydrop 3 years ago
I have just finished reading this amazing book and it's so strange to see the characters in the film, I imagined them totally differently, but this is the magic in reading.
drebeka 3 years ago
Poor character is a survivalist more or less. A country is effectively held hostage by whatever ideology is in charge at the time.
Ultrasecond 4 years ago
It's "A shameful, unscrupulous opportunist!"
Shameful, not shameless.
BeeReM 4 years ago
pedant, no pedantic !
smellycar14 3 years ago
oh god not this....
laurak90 4 years ago
The old world philosopher has the new world idealist by the short and curlies, yet is gracious and urbane, of course they are discussing all this in a bordello .. . wonderful clip. It's not so much an anti-war as a 'pro-life' movie!!
Ve4Vendetta 4 years ago 3
Oh please shut up.
thomas196x2000 3 years ago
Love it!
MySerpentine 4 years ago
Lol. That little salute he does cracks me up.
themuffinman9 4 years ago
Ditto.
MySerpentine 4 years ago
"Would you put some clothes on? You're practically naked..." haha! I like Art Garfunkel.
TSRule 4 years ago 5
It was cold in Chicago. A brass band played outside of the movie theater at the premier of Catch 22. I don't remember the name of the theater. Many of the actors were there. Yosarian sat behind me. The movie is better today than yesterday.
twentyfourFPS 5 years ago
One of my early childhood memories -- i was wondering if I had just imagined it or not (not too many Chicago premiers) -- I was a kid with my mom -- we didn't see the movie, but just happened to walk by, and then lingered around for a while as the stars walked by. My most distinct memory of the event was the sight of an older man with newly implanted hair-plugs -- which formed an odd grid patterm, and were not quite healed.
garvic7 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this movie is great! if you want to listen more stuff on it, there is a website which has a nice podcasting on catch 22: beyondtheexposition. com
check it out!
nicomar78 3 years ago
The film has one of the longest, most complex uninterrupted scenes ever made. In the scene, where two actors talking against a background, 16 of the 17 planes, four groups of four aircraft, took off at the same time. The problem was, for every take, the production manager has to call the planes back and made to take off again for every take of the particular scene. This was done four times.
tysonmofka 5 years ago
Marcel Dailo, the old guy, was a much sought-after French character actor who worked a lot with von Stroheim. In "Casablanca" when Claude Rains delivers the signature line, 'I'm shocked! Shocked! To find that there's gambling going on in here!' the croupier, Emil, played by Dalio, approaches from the roulette table and says simply, 'Your winnings, sir.'
Lonette 5 years ago
As the filming of Catch-22 took longer than planned in 1970, Art Garfunkel wasn't able to make it back to New York from Europe in time to start writing and recording the album "Bridge Over Troubled Water". Angered by the delay, Paul Simon wrote the track "The Only Living Boy in New York" about the incident.
Lonette 5 years ago
and Tom ("Tom get your plane ride on time") was Arties nickname when they were known as Tom and Jerry.
thenoseymethod 4 years ago