I'd have to go with... Blake Richardson from BTBAM. IMO, DT would have been musically better with Blake Richardson behind the drum kit. I could imagine him making old songs sound new every live performance (shame DT is a more of "play what is written" band but still) and ADTOE sounding better by adding his own stuff in the written drum tracks of Petrucci. I really hope come 2015, DT parts ways with Mangini and make Blake their new drummer.
at minute 17 or so, john petrucci made a mistake, showing how even virtuosos like him also makes mistakes, so to fellow guitarists out there, dont be afraid to make a mistake while playing, its just natural, no one's perfect
I think you meant to write that he improvised a single note, making the entire song even more perfect! Dude, you made a mistake by saying he made a mistake. This is John Petrucci you're talking about!!!
17:32 was the perfect yeah but james labrie. i also feel that mangini is lacking the skills portnoy had. of course he isnt as familiar with these songs it seems that hes been playing the drums slower than the usual rate of this song
@chaoshexer96 I read in an interview that he uses click tracks in his monitors so that each song is played at it's original tempo, while Mike Portnoy didn't do that. That's why it seems slower.
Three fools missed the hand "like". They were probably in another universe flying with this masterpiece. I can't find another reason to do that. Long life DT!
There are 3 haters they want to hate this video but then they want to download it but seriusly i don't care about these haters cause this song is so beauteful that these guys are forget in 1 second so don't care about them please ;-D
Felisov45 - You're camera gets GREAT audio! Not bad on the footage either bro. Thanks a lot! Especially since they DID NOT play this when I saw them at the Warfield on 9/24/11. I'm still a little bitter about it....
@NightmareGuitarist I believe the guy who filmed this died, they just recovered the camera afterwards... RIP filming guy that died for the sake of showing this marvel to the rest of the world. Your sacrifice was not in vain.
Gotta admit, Portnoy leaving was a blow to me...he was as much DT as any of them, if not more...he brought so much to their table so to speak...that being said, I can hardly wait to finally get a chance to see Mangini play live (Oct 25 Austin Texas...15th row in a small venue on the UT campus) AND with my favorite band! Rock on DT and MP!
Mike had to make the hard decision. You have to understand what goes through a musicians mind. sometimes when you go this long, it's like beating your head against the wall. I only followed this band because I went to school with Jordan for a few years. I think if Jordan and John would walk away and go another direction something big would happen for them. Those 2 have great talent and saddens me they have to be an opening act at times
i'm sure im not the only one that feels disapointed about portnoy
it's ok if he wants to leave the band,thats sad but ok
but leaving it because he was sure that Sevenfold would take him as new drummer is pathetic, he was not part of Avenged Sevenfols and he was no longer from DT, he was left without any band
and leaving saying that DT needed to rest is more pathetic because the band carried on without him
and making a new band as mediocre as Adrenaline Mob is is just nameless
@SebaChannel I feel the exact same, its not like I was expecting Dream Theater 2.0 but I was hoping Portnoy would do something a little bit more challenging.
@SebaChannel ...........Thats when ego gets in the way.......he tried to use the 25+ year friendship to call the shots.......Mike was a HUGE part of the band.......but he was 1/3 of the band that started it..........but DT was his bread and butter........I believe he thought he was irreplaceable...I think he wanted to go on "hiatus".......but wanted DT to come back to if things didnt pan out...I was never a MM fan, but think he's a humble, friendly guy that is MORE then capable of replacing MP!
anyone watching this if you cannot see the joy in these guys faces..the satisfaction...they know their craft...they are so critiqued yet so damn amazing....
off course; if you had to invent the parts yourself its alot harder then playing along.... i don't like MM in DT because there's no soul, MP has always put some spirit in the songs.. Remember? MP's adiction of the alcohol his deadenemy, al of that things he's put in the songs over all that years.
So, you kan keep your MM i will have MP over him any day man. Old DT rules.
The fact of the matter is; if you closed your eyes, listened to this video and was told that this was recorded before Portnoy left - you wouldn't know any difference.
Mangini covers Portnoy exceptionally well and I for one am extremely happy that he's part of Dream Theater now. A fantastic addition to the band.
@EnterSamland Maybe i've only listened to their recordings a million times but i didn't think he sounded terrible just not as great but thats what playing live does to you. LaBrie is like 40 some years old too.
Not sure what everyone is complaining about with Mangini. I'll miss Portnoy's craziness and energy, but Mangini seems to be doing great. Every YT video I listen to of the European tour he's right on it. Can't wait for the US tour dates!
Those criticising Mangini - remember he has taken a few months to learn a set that Portnoy has been able to work at and build up over years. Decades with some songs...
I saw them in Wolverhampton and the version of 'Count' they did there sounded much more polished than this. I guess they get better every night, but not sure how much is due to recording quality.
I think Mangini did a superb job - he's an absolutely incredible player :-)
Sorry, I have to disagree with you. Having seen both shows live, the one in Zurich and Wolverhampton I can say that the Zurich version of this song had much more depth and athmosphere. This is the beauty of live concerts, they are never the same... ;-)
"Sorry, I have to disagree with you. Having seen both shows live, the one in Zurich and Wolverhampton I can say that the Zurich version of this song had much more depth and athmosphere. "
Yes - but you only get depth and atmosphere hearing the live gig - this is one of the better recordings - but everything sounds crap on youtube!
@SAHBfan Really miss Portnoy, it's ok the change, but I think Mangini should respect what was done before and play as the record, I don't like what he made in this song... sorry, maybe in the new songs, but not this one. I'm really sorry because this is one of my favorites and I don't like how it sounds with him.
i want to see dream theater live again so bad. on one of their headlining shows and not just opening for maiden (although i would gladly do that again too)
I've listen to that video again and again. And even if I like Mr.Mangini very much. You can hear it's missing something. There's is a slight change in the bpm. Listen very carefully around 3:58. They donsound as tight as they previously where. I remember feeling that when Derrick Sherenian, was playing live with DT. I guess I'll need to give them some time!!!!!! One positive thing, Mike drumset is awesome!!!!!!!
:))))) \m/
JJda40 5 days ago
Freewill Rush?
LJLiveLV 1 week ago
18:27 HEIL!!!!
88Heimdal 2 weeks ago
I so much wish they would play this song at offenbach on monday but it´s not on any setlist of this tour :(
Frankness9 3 weeks ago
tears of happiness in my eyes...
FRSyRexT 4 weeks ago
this song should be painted, as its a work of art
bobaderpants 4 weeks ago 5
wonderful song!!!!
kevlebmxeur 1 month ago
17:44 Shut up, LaBrie, I'm trying to masturbate.
Yossome 1 month ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
I'd have to go with... Blake Richardson from BTBAM. IMO, DT would have been musically better with Blake Richardson behind the drum kit. I could imagine him making old songs sound new every live performance (shame DT is a more of "play what is written" band but still) and ADTOE sounding better by adding his own stuff in the written drum tracks of Petrucci. I really hope come 2015, DT parts ways with Mangini and make Blake their new drummer.
DT with Blake> DT with Mangini> DT with Portnoy
Peace
irwin3036able 1 month ago
I've always dislike LaBrie's singing, but then I just got to thinking, what singer IS worthy of this band?
Jpbritt123 1 month ago
dude what camera do you have!? most films i watch of people recording with a camera the sound is awful but yours is perfect!!!! BEST BAND EVER!
bobaderpants 1 month ago 3
at minute 17 or so, john petrucci made a mistake, showing how even virtuosos like him also makes mistakes, so to fellow guitarists out there, dont be afraid to make a mistake while playing, its just natural, no one's perfect
MrJeffkob 1 month ago
@MrJeffkob Mistake???
I think you meant to write that he improvised a single note, making the entire song even more perfect! Dude, you made a mistake by saying he made a mistake. This is John Petrucci you're talking about!!!
FranLesPaul 1 month ago 2
11:22 Thats some serious Blade Runner shit. Nexus 6?
Guitarsthatkill 1 month ago
portnoy portnoy me suena ese apellido ..quien es????
betobareto 1 month ago
17:33 = Petrucci trying to prove to everyone that he is human.
bradkroll90 1 month ago
Comment removed
fortesp33 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bradkroll90 xcept he is a human... just a godly one :o You know like Jason Voorhees or Freddy Krueger
fortesp33 1 month ago
Stop complaining about Portnoy!! He was the one who decided to leave. And if he had stayed, Dream Theater would be now in a break like five years.
Ultimatecamouflage 1 month ago
could you imagine if one of them had to take a shit like 5 min into the song. Theyd have to wait like another 15 min. id crap my pants. 0_0
blubbersack5 1 month ago
What a great live mix
WitherRecords 1 month ago
no Portnoy? Just Sad
bushmenofkumquat 1 month ago
without Portnoy, this song is a little piece of shit! #total #fail
bruinfo 2 months ago
Now that is what I call EPIC!
One m0:00re time?
akosiCoco 2 months ago
its really sad that portnoy couldnt have been the one playing the drums at this success of a concert
chaoshexer96 2 months ago
17:32 was the perfect yeah but james labrie. i also feel that mangini is lacking the skills portnoy had. of course he isnt as familiar with these songs it seems that hes been playing the drums slower than the usual rate of this song
chaoshexer96 2 months ago
@chaoshexer96 I read in an interview that he uses click tracks in his monitors so that each song is played at it's original tempo, while Mike Portnoy didn't do that. That's why it seems slower.
thericecrispy2 2 months ago
@thericecrispy2 they seem slower than the audio tracks too though
chaoshexer96 2 months ago
When the part around 1:43 starts, doesnt he (MM) close the hi-hat on those hits? It kinda sounds less "sharp" than in the original?
CenkutU 2 months ago
Three fools missed the hand "like". They were probably in another universe flying with this masterpiece. I can't find another reason to do that. Long life DT!
axelus22 2 months ago
This song... this song... crying...
TulioFluMetal 2 months ago
mike mangini tah tocanu muito mais ainda continuo fã do mike portnoy ele destroi muito mais q mangini !
pedraodosteclados 2 months ago
Never been a big fan DT, but this song is probably the best metal song I ve heard in the last decade, it's fucking awesome!
stergenakis 2 months ago
There are 3 haters they want to hate this video but then they want to download it but seriusly i don't care about these haters cause this song is so beauteful that these guys are forget in 1 second so don't care about them please ;-D
LastWish90 2 months ago
great live-sound!
mcscheijgrond79 3 months ago
I love it how he does the intro excactly the same as on the cd <3
oomwillem10 3 months ago
Incredibly good quality for a crowdvid. well done.
Brok3nC4rrot 3 months ago
the pink floyd-like section is just beautiful
lokifea05 3 months ago
man, the harmonies in the intro guitar solo sounds so much better than on record!¬
lokifea05 3 months ago
listen to that bass at 3:18 to 3:42. incredable.. Love this song to. one of my favorite DT ones!
MrEvilBacon 3 months ago
sangar tenan cuk!!!!!
masbegoal 3 months ago
Labrie is so fat! =O
MM10Matheus 3 months ago
insane, would die to see them,
alextagachi 3 months ago
I love this band
Embrioman 4 months ago
I'm gonna cry when I see this song live in December, that final guitar solo drives me to tears and Petrucci never misses a single note... DAMN.
MidnightSundowns 4 months ago
awesome, but a little slow for my taste towards the end..
xxDead2xx 4 months ago
@xxDead2xx thats the best part. it's beautiful
MrEvilBacon 3 months ago
James Labrie says at 8:38 this could be the "erst" time... Why ??!!
vivekingdomhearts 4 months ago
@vivekingdomhearts Supposed to be first, but you know, live, he was disturbed by the awesomeness of the rest of the band
SilentXStarcraft 4 months ago
@SilentXStarcraft I think it's because it's in swiss and he said "erst" because in german it means "first"
vivekingdomhearts 4 months ago
@Kafixis OMG i rofl'd soooo hard when i read your comment xd
iArianTV 4 months ago
Haha, a little Pink Floyd in there. I love it!
Darkspyyy 4 months ago
14:52 *He remembered my name!*
blakfloyd 4 months ago 4
Haha, a little Pink Floyd in there. I love it!
Metalmarsh89 4 months ago
Haha, a little Pink Floyd in there. I love it!
chris734c 4 months ago
Felisov45 - You're camera gets GREAT audio! Not bad on the footage either bro. Thanks a lot! Especially since they DID NOT play this when I saw them at the Warfield on 9/24/11. I'm still a little bitter about it....
SterlingBoyd 4 months ago
@ justaspectator01,
yeah right... weirdo...
gsxracer1977 4 months ago
Great !They're the "five elements"! Yeah! Really the white metal in the name of Jesus Lord because I see so many brighting angels !!!!
fabrycyoptc 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@fabrycyoptc this isn't about god you ignoramus
Hotdog40404040404 4 months ago
Awesome! But mike's missing growls in the chorus are a little disappointing... :/
xJMAN07x 4 months ago
@xJMAN07x I just doesn't sound the same :\
sk84uhlivin1 4 months ago
@sk84uhlivin1 I don't know why Petrucci doesn't do it, he had a mic, and now there's just an awkward pause in the song without them.
xJMAN07x 4 months ago
@xJMAN07x The only time I've seem JP do vocals likes that is during "The Glass Prison" where him and Mike go back and forth, so I don't know.
sk84uhlivin1 4 months ago
@xJMAN07x who care?!?!?!
OlhuscOmuns 4 months ago
I'm going to see them on October 27 in Grand Prairie, Texas. I pray to Jesus Christ that they play this song!!!
cliffordodelljones2 5 months ago 18
@cliffordodelljones2 So, dude, did they play it? I'm going to see them on December 10! :D
Zcfsr90 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@cliffordodelljones2 oh they will, no doubt about that ;)
oomwillem10 3 months ago
@cliffordodelljones2 did they? :D
KrixPrix 2 months ago
woow excellent sound! what camera do you have? or did you use an external microphone?
GuidoPerdomo 5 months ago
Great, DT!!
stukutra75 5 months ago
@Kafixis haha god just wrote your name down. he's coming for you!
Rhamsody 5 months ago
I cant believe you got to film so close!
Usually everyone in the first couple rows die when Petrucci plays
NightmareGuitarist 5 months ago 77
@NightmareGuitarist literally lmfao
Mongo966 3 months ago
@NightmareGuitarist I believe the guy who filmed this died, they just recovered the camera afterwards... RIP filming guy that died for the sake of showing this marvel to the rest of the world. Your sacrifice was not in vain.
LPArmyMen 2 months ago 2
[PT] Queria ter metade do talento de qualquer um desses caras aí.
[EN] I wish I had half the talent of any one of these guys.
DaviAlvesMagal 5 months ago
Queria ter metade do talento de qualquer um desses caras aí.
DaviAlvesMagal 5 months ago
music is not a compatition...its an Art...
55Sungkono 5 months ago
epic
mateszabolcs 5 months ago
did mangini steal priester's gloves?
fxxxprofanity 5 months ago
@oddishtheguitardude He told a joke himself? :)
gragi11 5 months ago 2
Jesuschrist is playing now the guitar with Dream Theater! O-o
Ranametalera 5 months ago
Gotta admit, Portnoy leaving was a blow to me...he was as much DT as any of them, if not more...he brought so much to their table so to speak...that being said, I can hardly wait to finally get a chance to see Mangini play live (Oct 25 Austin Texas...15th row in a small venue on the UT campus) AND with my favorite band! Rock on DT and MP!
ripowell65 5 months ago
Mike had to make the hard decision. You have to understand what goes through a musicians mind. sometimes when you go this long, it's like beating your head against the wall. I only followed this band because I went to school with Jordan for a few years. I think if Jordan and John would walk away and go another direction something big would happen for them. Those 2 have great talent and saddens me they have to be an opening act at times
poorwilly00 5 months ago
i'm sure im not the only one that feels disapointed about portnoy
it's ok if he wants to leave the band,thats sad but ok
but leaving it because he was sure that Sevenfold would take him as new drummer is pathetic, he was not part of Avenged Sevenfols and he was no longer from DT, he was left without any band
and leaving saying that DT needed to rest is more pathetic because the band carried on without him
and making a new band as mediocre as Adrenaline Mob is is just nameless
sorry but its true
SebaChannel 6 months ago
@SebaChannel
agreed
johnmoncrot 5 months ago
@SebaChannel I feel the exact same, its not like I was expecting Dream Theater 2.0 but I was hoping Portnoy would do something a little bit more challenging.
ABFan010 5 months ago
@SebaChannel ...........Thats when ego gets in the way.......he tried to use the 25+ year friendship to call the shots.......Mike was a HUGE part of the band.......but he was 1/3 of the band that started it..........but DT was his bread and butter........I believe he thought he was irreplaceable...I think he wanted to go on "hiatus".......but wanted DT to come back to if things didnt pan out...I was never a MM fan, but think he's a humble, friendly guy that is MORE then capable of replacing MP!
mikeybbdrummin 5 months ago
@SebaChannel Agreed, but Adrenaline is waaaaay better than Avenged Sevenfold. So I'm glad he ended up there rather than with A7X.
Echapify 5 months ago
i'm gonna kick whoever is whistling at the end in the face.
TessiturA1995 6 months ago in playlist Metal
DT is not "one man show". DT looks a very happy band in 2011, i'm sure you'll get this feeling from the new record, can't wait.
nvmitkov 6 months ago
Great video of a great song!! Thanks
4everMetal123 6 months ago
@SebaChannel DT replaces a god with another god!!
4everMetal123 6 months ago 2
DT replaced the best drummer with the second best
lol
SebaChannel 6 months ago
That day was my 18th birthday and I was there at that show in the first row... it was just amazing! =)
Thanks DT for that f*ckin incredible present!!!
PoetaOdoris 6 months ago
Great quality
Thanks for the upload
OctavariumXP 6 months ago
i'd be embarrassed to sing those lyrics live
jonsburyhill 6 months ago
@jonsburyhill Distinguished accent!
undershock94 5 months ago
Petrucci is able to bench God to the bench
freminick123 6 months ago
Petrucci looks like a porn actress!
lukemaster123456 6 months ago
Son increíbles... Esperando el disco como un loco. Mangini es un virtuoso... no hay más.
djmorfina 6 months ago
I like Portnoy, but What a great job done Mangini !
mulotwo 6 months ago
anyone watching this if you cannot see the joy in these guys faces..the satisfaction...they know their craft...they are so critiqued yet so damn amazing....
DAVEALANIMAGES99 6 months ago
this is with mangini the new drummer? it doesnt sound exactly the same as the original version, its got a different taste. good though
pirrungon 6 months ago
this is probably my fav song
NightFalcon190 6 months ago
petrucci ist fuckin fat, as fat as his skill
eyiineriin 6 months ago
@eyiineriin Thats muscle!!
Tedericoe 6 months ago
Mangini is the master!!!!....he can plays perfectly all songs of DT, so portnoy is a simple mortal....YEAH!
OlhuscOmuns 6 months ago in playlist Dream Theater 2011 Mike Mangini
Who the hell would say that Petrucci has no soul? This is the most soul filled thing he's ever done.
RushTheater100 6 months ago
2 people dislike DT =(
Lisjuuh 6 months ago
Just wait one more year and we will see dt in their big time withMangini! He is very very great drummer! So give him a little more time
frtanmartin 6 months ago
how can i download this video to mp3? i use one program here , but does not works, if you could help me, i will greatfull.
Nelinho123456 6 months ago
@Nelinho123456
Just use the Video2mp3 extension for Firefox, Chrome or Safari ;)
Hope it helped!
:)
andreao1990 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tulsa's HOTTEST New Theatre!
youtube.com/watch?v=cLo9VTeS8Y4
SabarStudios 6 months ago
Petrucci makes a little mistake at first solo. But not problem.
graphficker 6 months ago
I'm going to see DT in DC in October, I can't wait!
LedSatriani 6 months ago
@LedSatriani Me too! 7th row and center! \m/
sp3ci4lkpo 6 months ago
Woooo DT live in Toronto Oct 6th row N yeeeeeeeee cant waitttttt!!!
hockeyismygame888 6 months ago
14:37 oops lol
maldrifterxxx 6 months ago
Is it me or does Petrucci get bigger the longer his hair grows?
leragequit 6 months ago
this insn't spam guys, just an honest opinion :-)
gsxracer1977 6 months ago
@ SAHBfan
off course; if you had to invent the parts yourself its alot harder then playing along.... i don't like MM in DT because there's no soul, MP has always put some spirit in the songs.. Remember? MP's adiction of the alcohol his deadenemy, al of that things he's put in the songs over all that years.
So, you kan keep your MM i will have MP over him any day man. Old DT rules.
gsxracer1977 6 months ago
@gsxracer1977 that's no opinion. That's a statement. Don't abuse your freedom of speech. It might kill you someday.
justaspectator01 4 months ago
11:34 = God told Petrucci a joke :P
oddishtheguitardude 6 months ago 99
@oddishtheguitardude lol thats hilarious
maldrifterxxx 6 months ago
@oddishtheguitardude
hahahahahaha
JonnyCruzz 6 months ago
@oddishtheguitardude Who said that gods are all serious business was totally lying: one god tells another right there some humor.
IPstixrawesume 6 months ago
@oddishtheguitardude That's beautiful. :)
rafaeldeor 6 months ago
you tube just dosent do these guys justice
SuperFluffyface 6 months ago
his drum-kit is epic
SuperFluffyface 6 months ago
This is probably the best live version of this song available on Youtube, amazing!
jonestowneinsor 6 months ago 2
There's no keyboard solo in the set list? It's heartbreaking...
666Extremist 6 months ago
Anyone else think this version is really slow?
KornSOAD 6 months ago
The way the light is shining on Petrucci makes it look like hes literally on fire sometimes lol
tatfr0guy 6 months ago
omg, petrucci is getting fatter and fatter every time i see a new video of him
InsaneDrumer18 6 months ago
@InsaneDrumer18 So?
cocolukia21 6 months ago
@cocolukia21 so? so what, i'm just sayin' hahhahaha
InsaneDrumer18 6 months ago
Fucking Great Labrie
batusai2412 6 months ago
Fuck Crying portnoy im still crying kevin moore
batusai2412 6 months ago
@batusai2412 me too ;( hahaha
ahs19291 6 months ago
The fact of the matter is; if you closed your eyes, listened to this video and was told that this was recorded before Portnoy left - you wouldn't know any difference.
Mangini covers Portnoy exceptionally well and I for one am extremely happy that he's part of Dream Theater now. A fantastic addition to the band.
SamHerrington14 6 months ago 5
finally a full length version of the Count. Thank you. Mangini sounds good
edjo68 6 months ago
what a track!! OMG!
132sazthemaz465 6 months ago
No other band can do this live. Just amazing.
Koroar 6 months ago
@EnterSamland Maybe i've only listened to their recordings a million times but i didn't think he sounded terrible just not as great but thats what playing live does to you. LaBrie is like 40 some years old too.
ISesseriI 7 months ago
Not sure what everyone is complaining about with Mangini. I'll miss Portnoy's craziness and energy, but Mangini seems to be doing great. Every YT video I listen to of the European tour he's right on it. Can't wait for the US tour dates!
kimjalh99 7 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Great quality, thank you for uploading it, man! :)
xxxxx6778 7 months ago
Comment removed
xxxxx6778 7 months ago
This is the last REAL Dream Theater song...I miss Portnoy, Its clear to me how much he influenced the band.
Scoootter87 7 months ago
No MP, no one who tells LaBrie that he sucks ;(
Dareonz 7 months ago
Only reason why I miss Portnoy right now is that he had Dream Theater logos on the bass drum heads. However, Mangini is incredible.
DrummerOtto 7 months ago
@EnterSamland I guess i'll need a good spankin'!
mxjanon 7 months ago
amazing quality so happy gonna see em at the beacon theater when they come here idc theyres no not goin
xxJimster94xx 7 months ago
jesus Mike is amazing, the pieces to this masterpiece of music is so well played by such talents. I cannot wait to see them in the states..
DAVEALANIMAGES99 7 months ago
i always have tears in my eyes when i listen this interloude...this is so perfect...
JohnPetrucci1991 7 months ago
I wish james would lose some weight.
RussMaxable 7 months ago
Those criticising Mangini - remember he has taken a few months to learn a set that Portnoy has been able to work at and build up over years. Decades with some songs...
I saw them in Wolverhampton and the version of 'Count' they did there sounded much more polished than this. I guess they get better every night, but not sure how much is due to recording quality.
I think Mangini did a superb job - he's an absolutely incredible player :-)
SAHBfan 7 months ago 40
@SAHBfan
Sorry, I have to disagree with you. Having seen both shows live, the one in Zurich and Wolverhampton I can say that the Zurich version of this song had much more depth and athmosphere. This is the beauty of live concerts, they are never the same... ;-)
Fetisov45 7 months ago 6
@Fetisov45
"Sorry, I have to disagree with you. Having seen both shows live, the one in Zurich and Wolverhampton I can say that the Zurich version of this song had much more depth and athmosphere. "
Yes - but you only get depth and atmosphere hearing the live gig - this is one of the better recordings - but everything sounds crap on youtube!
SAHBfan 7 months ago
Comment removed
Roger17drummer 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SAHBfan Mangini also did spend years developing his skills ;)
Roger17drummer 6 months ago
@SAHBfan Really miss Portnoy, it's ok the change, but I think Mangini should respect what was done before and play as the record, I don't like what he made in this song... sorry, maybe in the new songs, but not this one. I'm really sorry because this is one of my favorites and I don't like how it sounds with him.
ingluishector 6 months ago
@SAHBfan plus mangini has broken several world records in drums so
meryuin 6 months ago
@meryuin on*
meryuin 6 months ago
there is nothing to say :D
great Video great song Great Band :D
but the only question : what's the name of your camera ???
MrMetalbarD 7 months ago
does it make me bad the fact that i am not missing MP ?
mxjanon 7 months ago
awesome
frian7 7 months ago
i want to see dream theater live again so bad. on one of their headlining shows and not just opening for maiden (although i would gladly do that again too)
Kraryx 7 months ago
Which planet is this from? I mean, this is just out of this earth lol O.o
XJeans83X 7 months ago
I've listen to that video again and again. And even if I like Mr.Mangini very much. You can hear it's missing something. There's is a slight change in the bpm. Listen very carefully around 3:58. They donsound as tight as they previously where. I remember feeling that when Derrick Sherenian, was playing live with DT. I guess I'll need to give them some time!!!!!! One positive thing, Mike drumset is awesome!!!!!!!
wabalou31 7 months ago
Its sound and feel that Mangini is running after the other band member!!!! It's missing the DT essence. Hope MP is going to come back someday!!!!
wabalou31 7 months ago
Seeing them this week :D
TheRealMechanix 7 months ago
lol who is the 1 person who disliked this??
Devonhubertmusician 7 months ago
@Devonhubertmusician probably Mike Portnoy
GenesisTheater 7 months ago 5