Added: 5 years ago
From: heartbreakdi
Views: 392,932
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (670)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Awesome song

  • One of the unsung greats.

  • this song should see the light of day and appear in the next album.

  • this song is one of my favs from them,,,i jjust feel sorry that it weren't recorded in a studio

  • such a song such a waste it weren't recorded in the studio

  • The pic at 0:08 looks like Brandon's take on a deodorant commercial. "Smell like Flowers." lol

  • isnt this called Soft Surrender,,,,?

  • @SernaFuckerz4 Its

    "Where is she (Soft Surrender)"

  • If I could grow a mustache I would grow one like that guy's.

  • Hey,

    Cool stuff. Peace

    -MW

  • Omg ((: <3

  • <3333

    

  • I love this song and the killers

    He can do his eyeliner better than me !!!!

  • The great thing of the killers is the diversity of styles and music they create. They cannot get it wrong. They are are just amazing! Very few groups can do this...

  • GO BACK TO HOT FUSS STYLE! PLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEASE!

  • The reason they went on hiatus is because they were touring for 6 straight years and brandon's mom died of brain cancer.

  • This song is so freaking banging. Brilliance. 

  • Bugs me when people say they split,,,they had time out and were always getting back together they said may 2011 which they did they didn't finish the tours downunder cause Brandons mum died of brain cancer.in the time out Brandon did a solo tour in the Uk which I saw and did his album and even Robbia did a solo album which is due out July 2011...

  • @ewooddave71 You mean Ronnie? :P Should be pretty good. And totally agree with you there :)

  • Actually the song is called "Soft Surrender"

  • Soft surrender

  • WHERE THE FUCK IS SHE???!?!?!?!?!?

  • Comment removed

  • anyone know how to get this song? or why the parents of the poor little girl didn't want it realeased?

  • @13PanicLover Well, in my opinion the song is written from the perspective of the boyfriend and his anger towards the person who has taken his "whole wide world", thus you could argue the band believes the boyfriend was innocent, and that would piss me off as a parent

  • @psychohippygoth No? As far as I know, it's written from the mother's point of view... which makes sense if you look at the lyrics :P

  • @BR3DDK How is that so? The protagonist describes the police coming to the house and watching the mother, so it would make more sense for the song to be written from the perspective of Luke, the boy accused of murdering her, but its all subjective I guess

  • @13PanicLover Simply because of the lyrics in the song and they also did not ask permission x

  • This song is about a Scottish girl, Jodi Jones, who was killed by her boyfriend. Obviously it's from one of her parent's perspective. Apparently the guys in the band saw her story on the news when they were touring in Scotland, and decided to write a song about her.

  • itsblitzday she was 14

  • Brandon has really nice hands.

  • Brandon has really nice hands, among other things of course.

  • @kkw0archer Well, you know what they say about guys with nice hands ;)

    They look damn good in gloves!

  • is this just a single, because i cant find it on any of their albums. or maybe im a bit blind/ deaf

  • @rockprid3e723

    it is a song that they only play live. but you can get it from limewire/frostwire/4shared etc.

  • @carminewvu97 oh ok. yeah i just heard about the kidnapping and murder. i havent heard them live yet, because all the damn tours they do in australia aren't underage. oh well, i got an year.

  • @rockprid3e723 You know they broke up right? Hence Brandon's solo album?

  • @psychohippygoth Actually, they didn't. They were just on a hiatus and needed a break but Brandon wanted to continue with his music. They're supposed release a new album this year sometime or 2012. :) GabriellaEve

  • @psychohippygoth what? apparently they're getting back next month to start their fourth studio album, which will be released end of the year/ start of 2012, as rumoured on the wikipedia page. i swear, if they broke up, ill be forever sad. best band out there, my favourite to be honest

  • @rockprid3e723 actually I didn't explain that right at all. They broke up, yes, about a year ago? Feb last year? He released his solo album and then decided to go back and write music with the old group so never fear they shall be back :) Hiatus or broke up either ither they shall return

  • @psychohippygoth THANKGOD. you kept me worried my friend. yes, lets forget about that and we shall enjoy their awesome music =D

  • @psychohippygoth they didn't break up, they took a hiatus. Hell, they are in the studio right now making an album.

  • @dylanator999 dude if i was murdered and brandon wrote a song about me i would be fucking pissed if people wouldnt let them release it!!!!!!

  • @ixlovexjohnnyxdepp if you were murdered your loved ones might not want to be reminded every time a popular song comes on

  • @ixlovexjohnnyxdepp Hey Look that message was to me :O

  • @ixlovexjohnnyxdepp Its called RESPECT and if you listen to the lyrics then you would understand!!

  • Despite the content, this song ROCKS!

  • @Dylanator999 okay thanks :)

  • hey I'm a big big killers fan, but I don't know this song! what album is this from? somethin I never thought happened!! :O

  • @cookiecarooi It isnt from a album as it is about real events the family of the girl didnt want the song published and what not,

    so now they only preform it live

  • Has anyone got the MP3 for this, please message me on here and I can give you my email.....thanks!!!

  • What album is this from

  • @Atexbigs05 it isn't on any of thier albums, it was to "controversial" because brandon wrote it about some girl who got killed. people were mad about it. i think they should of released it anyway.

  • i fell in love with Brandon, damn.

  • @iADOREmessi

    me toooo!!

    he's just wayyyy toooo *adorable*

  • @iADOREmessi Yet you adore Messi,very interesting.

  • im a guy and i do brandon flowers...no homo

  • so where was this song from

  • @JamieBugajski This song will never be relased

  • @Tiffolo o cool.

    wheres it from?

  • @JamieBugajski Was writed douring they tour in Scotland. Talk about a girl of 14 years old that was murdered. Her family get mad and so Brandons in sign of respect don't sing this anymore.

  • y does everybody talk about human on this song y not the real song ???

  • what vid is that from at 2:07-2:08 ????

  • human has the most well thought through lyrics with the most meaning but i don't love the style of it. I prefer their old style like in "Jenny was a friend of mine" real indie rock n roll. the killers <3

  • hey this song was never recorded but its so awesooooome

    i know there's a reason it was banned, can someone tell me plz coz im real confused with all this about the murder of some jodi person

  • @fishy8081 A girl was murdered by her boyfreind and they wrote the song for her mum. However she didnt want it to be recorded :'( (its realy sad) xxx

  • @scarletmoonfall ah thanks

    that is sad :(

  • @fishy8081 thats ok, yh i know. :( xxx

  • @scarletmoonfall It was due to some of the lyrics in the song x

  • the song is about a girl who was murdered by her boyfriend in Scotland her name was Jodi Jones. If you look up the Murder of Jodi Jones it will tell you everything.

  • this is new song?

  • @jake7147 No. Surely it is another "Sawdust"

  • @jake7147 they aren't recording new songs anymore, they'll have a new album out in 2012 probably. Brandon is now going solo for a while, his album 'flamingo' just got out. Go buy it.

  • from which album this song came? i never heard of this!

  • @LaVieEstUneFarce It's not on an album, I don't think it ever will be - there's a whole story behind this song which I'm not an expert on, but suffice to say I doubt it'll be recorded properly.

  • @LaVieEstUneFarce I do believe this song was written for a girl that was murdered or something along them lines.

  • Lol Yeah This Isn't "Human"

    I Love This Songs By The Way :D Where Is She, Where Is She, Where Is My Baby Girl?

  • howd dis song get a conversation about human n not dis song

  • Comment removed

  • wtff i hav all of the killers albums and this songs not on any of them :((((((

  • @fobxoxo123 it has never been recorded in the studio,, early Killers song.

  • they all look so different at 2:52

    great pics BTW

  • how can i get a copy of this song i had it a few years ago but lost it :(

  • @Jossy99 If you haven't gotten it already, I can email it to you, unless you know some other efficient way for me to get it to you.

  • Love this track!And yes,Human is a very good song as well and defiantly means more than most people would think.If you'd just listen you can feel it.

  • is it just me or does Brandon's voice sound more "live"?

  • @0Megaman0 brandons voice does sound "live" but his voice always sounds almost the same live as on cds and sometimes better but he always sounds amazing!

  • @0Megaman0 Its because it is live bud

  • 1:29

    he's BEAUTIFUL!! oh brandon...

  • 1:42 is such a gorgeous pic of brandon he looks so beautiful in pink and vests! also love how in this vid at 1:51 you put a pic of brandon with his left hand up when it says "on one hand ive got myself to blame" it is like he is saying it in the pic... Great vid! thanks for it:) love it:)

  • jellocase... they all have great personal style... definitly brandon has gps lol:)

  • where are all this songs from????? what cd or what some1 plz. answer

  • Mmm, actually what Brandon said about Human was, that he had received the quote, "Are we Human, or are we Dancers" from a fellow artist. The artist had said; "We are raising a generation of dancers." & that's where the line, was "conceived"

  • @mutebydesign he got the quote from the journalist hunter thompson

  • @sabitanclip I agree the CDs got worse as they went on cuz I love evry song on hot fuss but day and age I like spaceman and losing touch and tht it but all these hidden songs are so amazing

  • when did they last sing this? it's really catchy, i hope they get back to making these kinds of songs. their new songs don't grow on me, no matter how many times i listen to them. i don't know, maybe i'm just too shallow to appreciate great songs when i hear em ahehe.

  • aw, I haven't heard this song for so long. The Killers give me such a great feeling that I don't think is possible to get from any other band. :)

  • Brand has great personal style!

  • I Love you too Thomas! <3

  • is this a bonus track? what album is it a bonus for?

    gee, i thought i was a die-hard fan, but i've never heard this song... :-(

  • @MyCousinVinny13 Nope, it's just an unreleased LIVE track, i read somewhere they wrote this song for a girl who attended a Killers show in Scotland and she was killed by her boyfriend :/

  • Comment removed

  • I don't want you for dead, but I want you to die - brilliant!

  • This song rocks... All of The Killer rock... Hott Fuss, Sam's Town, Sawdust, Day and Age, thier covers, & secret songs... I like em' all I can't get enough of The Killers...

    Dedicate this song to my Babygirl Stephanie1 <3

  • The picture at 1:03 is ADORIBLE!

    Great song too.

  • I can't believe how much i like this song its like their hot fuss style i need to download it but its no were

  • It's a shame, I actually really like this song, but if it'd only upset people then it's best that it's not available I suppose. It's not actually that specific, so they could've just not said who it was about.

  • cool ^^

  • to the twelve people who gave this a thumbs down, what kind of crappy music do you listen to?!?

  • Comment removed

  • ive never heard of this song and i know all their songs

  • @TheBrowneyedgirl01 me to??

  • @TheBrowneyedgirl01 same here

  • @TheBrowneyedgirl01 this song is based off of a real life kidnapping and murder of a 13 year old girl from Scotland. They wrote this because she was a huge fan of them, but here parents didn't want them to release it on an album. So that is why u never heard it or will hear it on an album

  • @Itsblitzday She wasnt kidnapped x

  • I thaught I knew all the songs of the Killers, like I'm a big fan, but here there are some that I didn't know... but they are less good, they don't sing them in concert anyway...

  • in the first bit you can hear the synth from read my mind in the background :D

  • its probly comin from another dudes perspective, a guy who was probably another of her very good admirers, best friend that liked her?

    @tictacjoe134 thats probly the best interpretation I've seen'

  • No guys, it is from the pov of her mother.

  • Hi Im not starting an dispute here but Jodie was my little cousin .... that murdering sob deserves everything he gets... My aunt Judy got the song banned because of the lyrics that are in the song not the actual song!!! yes it is a great song and I avtually like it but at the end of the day it is her choice what is said about her... Josie/Toad was the best girl you could ever meet and didn't deserve to go the way she did!!

  • @xoxCarrieWalkerxox im sorry for your loss but the band was just being nice

  • @xoxCarrieWalkerxox im not argeein with theses ppl but srry 4 ur lost and dont get up set they dont understand wat ur feelin i go wat ur aunt siad about not reaslein the stuff b/c nobody want 2 be reaminbed about the killin of ur cousin i feel sad 4 u and im very depress b/c my uncle died but i wouldnt go 4 wat im gettin ready 2 say but pick ur self up and move on i cant go with it but u can (i know im late with the comment

  • this is one of my fav killers song

  • Holy crap I have been looking for this song since 2005... They played it live in Vancouver when i saw them and I couldnt find it anywhere after that!!!

  • without a good friend on a sunshine...

  • scrumptious 0:35

    the songs is amazing, also!

  • beautiful song...

  • great song havent heard it before can i get it anywhere?

  • is this on an album? cos it's not on any of mine

  • no, they didn't release it cause the family of the girl didn't want them to.

  • @amycarysc can you explain what is the story of the family? of whom? did some girl really die related to this song? thanks!

  • it's not directly related. here's the story:

    a girl who was a fan and had attended a Killers concert, was killed a few months later by her psycho boyfriend. The band happened to hear about it on the news and Brandon got the inspiration to write these lyrics from the girl's mom's point of view. they asked her if they could put it on the sawdust album (i think, not positive) but she refused.

  • Thanks for sharing, interesting story. So this song had no relation to the trilology stories. S the girlfriend was killed after Midnight show was released and they probably preformed it at the concert that poor girl had went to, trippy huh?

  • @amycarysc thats so sad i feel so sorry fr her mom x

  • @amycarysc thats so sad i feel realy sorry for her mum x

  • This came out prior to Sam's Town & Sawdust, during their Hot Fuss tour. I believe the mom contacted the Killers first and requested them not to profit from it. I recall Brandon feeling so overcome by guilty that he agreed and has felt sorry ever since.

  • i feel like it's from the boyfriend's point of view, the murderer's. Cuz, like, he's convinced himself that it wasn't him who killed her and the trauma erased the memory. Cuz it says "your mother looked scared" unless she's talking in 3rd person, that means it can't be from the mother's perspective.

  • I can see how it would seem like that a first glance, but it means the mother was watching the boyfriends mother. when the police came to his house to talk to his parents, because he had run away to hide.

  • please send me the pics!!!

    by the way, good job! =D

  • @megan7001 STFU this song was 4 a girl that got murdered by her bf i like the song but u r mean at lest give some happiness 2 towered the song

  • this song makes me cry

  • same. the line "where is my baby girl?.... what have you done with my whole wide world?"

    so heart wrenching.

  • i like this song.

  • this song is amazing!!i love it!!and the pictures were also amazing!!i love them all!!

  • @MusicAddict650 hi patty

  • where did u get the images???? there brilliant. love this song so much it is one of my favorites. one of the killers best!!!!

    i <3 the killers

  • they should make another b-side album

    and put all of these songs

    it would be great

  • the mother didn't want them releasing it on an album

  • this wasn't on any album. it's a damn shame too, it's a great song.

  • KILLERS <3

    Watch my channel for around 20 HQ/HD Live vids.

    If you want toooo..

    <3Brandon, Mark, Dave & Ronnie<3

    Hugs.

  • this song is about a murder of a teenage girl in europe, the song is from the mothers view and it was meant to get more people to see what happened

  • haha dave's face at 1:51

  • ..♥ .. Sam's Town is just perfect....Magnificent like all the music of them....The Killers are absolutely incredible ..♥ ..

  • when was made this song?

  • It was before Hot Fuss, I really wish they put it on an album.

  • it was on sams town, which was released in 2006 :) so i'd guess around that time

  • @pinballwizard8394.....was that the US version? its definitely wasn't on the UK album of Sam's town

  • well, i have the whole sam's town album on my ipod, and this song was all the other songs on the album... but i'm not really sure though, because when i looked at the actual album, it didn't list this song, so i'm not sure

  • it wasnt on the US version, i have all of their albums and it isnt on one of them...

  • this song is great but is sooo sad

  • In my eyes the lyrics from Sam's Town have much more meaning and depth than those of Hot Fuss. And Day & Age....well its just weird, but still has great lyrics. Dustland Fairytale? or what about Goodnight, Travel Well which is about the death of a band member's mother. Neon Tiger about being who you are and not letting people change you and use you?

  • everyone forgets the album "sawdust"!!!

  • also great music and lyrics on there. but its a b-side/compilation album really so....well you know. its different.

  • In an interview, Brandon talks about how in this song they sing in the perspective of Jodi's mom

  • It sounds like it is from a parental view, since most of the language isn't the intimate kissy-goo-goo type of love, it's the mutual you're my world type.

    I feel like such a little kid saying that.

  • It's supposed to be the victim's mother point of view while she's talking to the killer. When she says ''your mother looked scared'' she's talking abt the killer's mother.

  • i think it is, i think its from the girls mother's or father's point of view.

  • THE KILLERS ARE THE BEST OF THE BEST

  • HIGH FIVE

    Finally someone agrees with me that they will never be the same as they were in Hot Fuss

    Hot Fuss was AMAZING. Not anymore :(

  • How are they dumb?

    I mean, I can understand if you think 'Human' is dumb, but it's not bad. It's mostly the chorus.

    I thought Day & Age was great.

  • People think Human is dumb because they don't know that Dancer is meaning puppet. Like are we human or are we a puppet that is just being controlled. It says in there, "cut the cord." it is about how we are just turning into robots.

  • Human is the most clever song lyrically I have ever heard, its calling people fake without basically everyone not realising.

    Dancer also meaning being a follower, not in control of their decisions, brilliant.