@juiceforjoe This statement means nothing. R. was a reputable pianist, so at least you must say WHY it is not good. Or, if you know nothing about music you can say "I don´t like it". No one can argue about that. Actualy, I am not particularly fan of R., however, this is a great performance! I can´t believe this is Richter. One thing I don´t like about him (among others) is his strange feeling for tempos. But here is everything just perfect+.
I think the recording of Richter playing all 4 Scherzi in one his recitals in Hungary (I believe in the mid 60's) is one of the best sets ever recorded. The more I listen to Richter, the more I am impressed. When I hear new things upon each listening, I know I am in the presence of true greatness.
Have you thought about different plausible scenario? For example, performance is great but critic has no idea about what's "good" and what's not... You know, just a possibility...
Is this from the Richter Rediscovered recital from 1960, issued by BMG? I think Richter captures the Scherzando quality of this marvelous piece better than any other pianist I've ever heard! A rainbow of tonal colors and shifts! He, Michelangeli, Moisiewitsch, and Kapell are my all-time favorite pianists.
@juiceforjoe This statement means nothing. R. was a reputable pianist, so at least you must say WHY it is not good. Or, if you know nothing about music you can say "I don´t like it". No one can argue about that. Actualy, I am not particularly fan of R., however, this is a great performance! I can´t believe this is Richter. One thing I don´t like about him (among others) is his strange feeling for tempos. But here is everything just perfect+.
TheHanslick 4 months ago
I think the recording of Richter playing all 4 Scherzi in one his recitals in Hungary (I believe in the mid 60's) is one of the best sets ever recorded. The more I listen to Richter, the more I am impressed. When I hear new things upon each listening, I know I am in the presence of true greatness.
Pogouldiwitz 5 months ago
@Pogouldiwitz
>When I hear new things upon each listening, I know I am in the presence of true greatness.
Great notion! Speaks highly about your own abilities!
truecrypt 5 months ago
@juiceforjoe
Have you thought about different plausible scenario? For example, performance is great but critic has no idea about what's "good" and what's not... You know, just a possibility...
truecrypt 5 months ago 2
This is the best interpretation of this scherzo I've hear thus far :) So lovely
143twins 6 months ago
Ah ! I'm so much relieved by this velvety interpretation ! Gracious yet powerful. Delicate tone, mellow and rich colours !
Shame on the others ! Shame on you Blechacz, shame on you Yundi Li and all the other youngsters for playing machine gun and not piano !
Your marvellous interpretation, Mr. Richter, regenerates my ears and fulfills my heart with rapture. Thanks.
KapustinIsGOd 9 months ago
genius : ))
shopindani 1 year ago
This is the best...
Yundi Li? Pshh!!!
Richter is the best...
beryllium2 3 years ago 14
just don't try listening to yundi li after listening to richter. :))
deandusk 3 years ago 18
Is this from the Richter Rediscovered recital from 1960, issued by BMG? I think Richter captures the Scherzando quality of this marvelous piece better than any other pianist I've ever heard! A rainbow of tonal colors and shifts! He, Michelangeli, Moisiewitsch, and Kapell are my all-time favorite pianists.
billyguns2 3 years ago 2
I thing this is the studio recording of 1977. (I have the LP). I am listen to the 1960 recital on "France Musique". Sublime pure music with mistakes.
GiovanniEMB 3 years ago
I agree with you about favorite pianists and I would add, for this scherzo Tomas Vasary. He is such a subtle colorist.
aardvaark069 3 years ago