Taeyeon + Joo - If + Because of A Man (sub)

[laozharbo]

taeyeon gave such a lovely harmony for joo.... while joo did such a poor job with her harmony with taeyeon;s song

[suikalabsICHII]

Besides, Taeyeon's voice fits both songs better. Joo's voice gives off a little-lady kind of charm while Taeyeon's gives off a fully mature woman's.

[proudsone]

Does anyone else feel like taeyeon has a mysterious aura? She's so talented and pretty

[proudsone]

Taeyeon owned Joo's song, how sad

[grandmasteryip]

I'm only liking this for Taeyeon.

[Invincibleme9]

Taeyeon voice is just smooth and soft. Love her. Really love her. No comment about Joo. :)

[fattyalex]

Taeyeon, just perfect!

[DivineGekkata]

It's really hard to sing when you hear fans only screaming Kim Taeyeon. I think she was just really nervous, but anyway I really liked Joo and her singing. She has such a great voice and is so underrated. Joo-unnie hwaiting!<3

[Hikazumi]

I love both, but people should recognize Joo too! She's amazing ^^

[chupachiups14]

Taeyeon.. I so want to see her on Immortal song!

[awesomeeddy1]

taeyeon is way better then joo.....

[ramzaawaji666]

Why these shorty girls always have angel's voice?? I'm in love with both of them..... <3 <3

[Coniathree]

well of course Taeyeon is better JOO was a rookie, she's better now... wish JYP promoted JOO better.

[macheretaengoo]

@Coniathree

When did Joo debut? I thought there's no much different between them, since Taeyeon debuted in late 2007, and Joo early 2008?

[Coniathree]

@macheretaengoo SNSD debuted August 5th 2007 and Joo debuted January 10th 2008 its only 6 months but an artist can grow a lot during a period of 6 months. Taeyeon is more comfortable on the stage and Joo seemed nervous here. They both still did a wonderful job.

[KPopFanForever]

Ahhh i really love Tae yeon! :D Her voice is just PERFECT <3 She has depth and emotions when singing these kind of songs, and it really pierces your soul, letting us understand the emotions of the song even though its in a foreign language (:

[macheretaengoo]

Taeyeon's singing has soul in it, with the right amount of emotions. I love her!!

[yoyoluve139]

tae has ability control her voice to harmony with other's voice. she can down or up her tone easily

[boatjae]

i love joo ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

[WMoksg]

Woww .... Joo is excellent! Nice singing girls.

[KingofKpop]

SM vs JYP

[djmadafakaxxx]

ME QUEDO CON TAEYEON TIENE MEJORES PIERNAS BUAJAJA

[ScuttleBuggist]

2:37 - Joo did the harmony for Taeyeon's song but it didn't sounds a good as Taeyeon's harmony for Joo's song at 5:47 ...

[messala84]

If I go to a concert like this I will bring a sniper rifle with me and shoot everyone who attempt to scream and ruin the song.

[flubberdubu]

They have different singing styles. Stop comparing. JOO at 5:34 <3

[y08189]

TaeYeon has a nice voice! She can express every song in a good way~ She knows how to sing! TaeYeon jjang^^

[basarabest]

Joo voice is really good, she sang her song really well. Just Taeng sang joo's song too well, tae has perfect control in her voice, she sound flawless, even her facial expression was good.

I love this part 4:55 so beautiful

[lauradu123]

Of course taeyeon is strong in her song and joo in her song too

[lauradu123]

Here Joo was just a rookie now she is just amazing

[fullscholl]

joo's voice is surprisingly sweet in the second song...it's like honey on my ears...taeyeon's voice is incredibly undescribable and soothing...like a nice memory on my brain...it echoes...LOL

[Nasiiiima]

who is joo?

[sujugirl468]

@Nasiiiima she's a solo artist under... jyp entertainment i think. ^^ she's very talented, but sadly she's underrated. :(

[taenysi]

Taeyeon sings both songs with lots of emotions

[AbcdefghiJ0306]

they both have a beautiful voice :) but i prefer JOO than taeyeon ^^v

[Heart2Heartization]

I love how Taeyeon can make any and every song her own, and it sounds absolutely amazing <3 My first time hearing JOO but she's pretty good too. Her voice is sweet ;)

But tbh i think Taeyeon's voice is much stronger and very soothing.

And the harmonization at the end of both songs were awesome =P

[Jenniiushuilong]

how old is Joo here and how old is she now?? she looks like a kid!

[Coniathree]

@Jenniiushuilong JOO in this video would be 18 years old ~ right now she'll be 21

[EmiVickyFan]

Taeyeon Killed Joo :/

[KurumiJ3]

Joo was like a baby here! She's grown so much in the last few years. Still as beautiful, even more amazing. And I must compliment Taeyeon on her amazing voice. :)

[daughterSSA]

Taeyeon looks younger than Joo

[daughterSSA]

when they sing the first song Taeyeon sings much better and that song suits her, her voice is stronger than Joo`s vice, but the second song suits Joo better than Taeyeon thats what i think

[macheretaengoo]

@daughterSSA

Well, the first one is Taeyeon's song and the second one is Joo's song. So of course they are more comfortable with their own songs.. ^^

[crystalsoooooo]

Joo sounds nice here ^^

[haveHEARTT]

Taeyeon's voice is absolutely amazing <3 and she only seems to get better with time. LOVE her 

[lytsebaas]

Wow Joo looked really young back then!

[sshortii4life]

i love how joo put so much emotion into the song...but its taeyeon song so of course she owns it! lol just saying!

[TheConkyubine]

Joo's voice is very sweet. So nice in the ears. :D

[amylalaz123]

I think both sang "Because of a Man" very well, but for "If", I think TaeYeon did better because the song was designed for her strong and lower pitched voice. It's more difficult for Joo to sing as that key isn't really compatible with her voice.

[ronasol]

for me joo es better but .. here ... well... she could do ti better!!..

[xxrawr22xx]

Lol you can't tell as much during If, but during Because of A Man you can clearly see the two are completely different singing personalities. Joo's feeling has a more delicate singing personality, while Tae Yeon's passion causes her to have a stronger personality. I'm not saying what they look like or what their personal personalities are, just what story their voices tell.

[Darlagayle]

the title is like taeyeon plus joo minus if plus because of a man lol.

nonetheless, their voices are beautiful ^^

[CODEVOIX]

Taeyeon *o*

[AegyoTaeng]

I don't know about Joo's voice quality now that she's actively singing again, but back then she really needed better breathing technique. Despite that, both girls sang with such good emotion!

[sweetnagisa]

Joo almost became the "IU" on that time if it wasn't 4 the netizens who tried to destroy her 'cuz of her mistakes of her past.

u have such a nice, beautiful and Perfect Voice!

Joo, Hwating!!

JYP Hwating!

[hinakochch]

Who is joo.......?I am not anti of joo......i really dont know who is joo...taeyeon is the best!!!love you!!!

[Megapei90]

taeyeon expression saying "from now on,i can stand with my own feet"

like this! ^^

[pumpkinhotdogcheese]

hehe!! i love taeyeon!! she sang really well =P

[samtrinh22]

wow! taeyeon..<3

[nihonkk1208]

いつ聞いてもテヨンちゃんのボーカルは、「お見事！」＆「凄い！­」です。

どの音階においても「下音」が安定しているから、「安心」して聞­いていられます。

[SuperWgFan]

WHY IS JOO's VOICE LIKE AN ANGEL!!!! dreamy

[SuperWgFan]

I really like tae's singing, strong powerful and everything. but i cant help but feel that something is missing. and JOO complemented it with her feelings. JOO's feelings and emotions in her singing are daebak!

[aryka0KaT]

Haha, I actually felt like Taeyeon had more expression in her voice! I feel like there's just more power in it to convey her emotion. They're both great singers though :)

[BenDannDevil]

To me, Joo seemed much comfortable singing Because of a man than If. Well, anyone would, seeing how it's not her song and the singer is right beside her, she will obviously feel stressed.

Both did a wonderful job anyway, :D.

[halfofminute]

technique wise, taeyeon wins. but feelings wise, joo wins hands down.

[soshilism]

I think Joo sing not too bad but have no feeling on the song that what i feel

[soshilism]

I love Taeyeon. Her voice, facial expression. She really awesome.

[OHSmurfyGee]

JOO+Taeyeon (:

Taeyeon's voice is amazing, her voice is like an angel's voice, but I need to confess I love JOO's voice too, her songs are amazing, and her voice is really pretty.

Both are amazing singers, and both were looking gorgeous <3

[SUPERAHBEE]

how old iis joo?

[liavictoriadenisse]

@SUPERAHBEE  born in 1990...

[SUPERAHBEE]

@liavictoriadenisse so she is 20 sumthing... umm she doesnt look tat old..

[YuneTube]

Taeyeon singing Joo's song makes JOO sound like a good karaoke version. Taeyeon OWNS!

[yanmoney2004]

love both, but tae's voice is amazing, kid leader jjang <3

[Effectforeveryone]

I think both of them quite good singers. But Joo's voice sounds soo sweert, soft and high. Taeyeon's strong.

[yoonyul11]

who's joo? from where?

[xiongts]

Who's Joo?

[myriem6]

@xiongts

Joo is a JYP's singer (solo) :)

[pauline87645]

saranghe taeyeon! your so pretty!

go snsd leader taeyeoN!

[CookieFridays]

Wow, Taeyeon's powerful voice contrasted with Joo's soft and high voice, interesting collaboration! They were both amazing, I really, really love Taeyeon's voice, she's such a pro. And Joo's voice is really pretty~

[gauri1990]

why is everyone saying tht she joo doesn't sound good??? i thought she sounded great..and this is the first time im listening to her...and she's a high singer....she did brilliantly i think....

taeyeon is good there is no doubt....

[videoarl1404]

i think Joo''s voice is higher and more beautiful than Tae. Even though i'm snsd fan. Tae more powerful but JOO was perfectly high, when its go to the high notes

[i1master]

and juu's voice sounds better in her recordings..not live. @.@

[caldevera]

@i1master i hate to agree..but yeah. even her song Bad Guy is a lot better live. she can't hit the same notes live.

[i1master]

i dun like most of jyp artists at all....especially after listenting to this. joo kinda destroyed the songs >.<

[phanthuyquynh]

I think Taeyeon's voice is better than Joo's

Taeyeon can control her voice and feeling

Taeyeon also sang better than Joo when they sang Joo's song

[phanthuyquynh]

I think Taeyeon's voice is better than Joo's

Taeyeon can control her voice and feeling

[forever4luvf4]

joo's voice is not good at all :|

[HentaiZero]

Taeyeon looks so lovely....

[eugenegenegene]

I guess this video just goes to show:

SM Ent. 1 - 0 JYP Ent.

[itsmetin127]

i love TAEYEON ! her voice is Nice !

[tvc14ri]

joo's voice was really good.

but personally, i think tae's voice was better. tae's sweet voice is stronger and her controlling her voice is also better. i love her facial expressions. she's really talented. love taengoo :x :x :x

[BoAlove2007]

i feel bad for joo, the crowd keeps on shouting "kim taeyeon"

[lifelikedrama]

@BoAlove2007 they also shouted Jung Min Joo, which is Joo's full name.

[dbskshinee12]

Personally I think Taeyeon has better voice control while that Joo girl has a gentler voice. Haha, but I'm still biased towards Taeyeon! xD She's so sweet, pretty and sings so well! :D

[Gryzek5mv]

@dbskshinee12 Taeyeon! version is way better to "if" (: in the end when they two sang last sentence of "if" it was horrible... yeah Joo got nice voice, but its too much shaky kind;/

[erasers9876]

taeyeon is so pretty.

[Enoa7]

good voice both of them! btw whos joo? ==a

[GomChingu]

@Enoa7 jyp solo artist shes been out of the scene for a while tho.

[haylabit]

Love Taeyeon's voice (;

[likefoshox3]

TAEYEON<3

[97060041]

Joo looks like taiwanese actress and singiner Rainie Yang

[jamee7]

@kashisuke2010 i think joo is a singer from JYP... im not sure when she debuted but this was from 2008 when she was promoting her song, Because of a Man... she does possess a very nice voice... and about her looking crying, she's like taht when she sings this song...:D:D.. but im prettty sure that she's very glad that she got to sing with taeyeon..

[superlowrider]

Hey..this Joo is pretty good. Hope she'll do well by herself.

[jamee7]

@MultiMath123 no..she didnt destroyed it.. in fact she really does possess a cute and great voice.. her song, Because of a Man is so wonderful

[MultiMath123]

@jamee7 who is joo?

[jamee7]

@MultiMath123 Joo is a singer who debuted last Jan. 11, 2008 under JYP. She was even referred as the "Jewel of JYP". Joo participated in SBS's talent show ``Super Star Survival'' (2006) in collaboration with JYP. Though not the winner of the show, she got into the training program at JYP. Because of a Man is her debut song who was written and composed by JYP. He only gave this song to Joo although many are wanting to get it.

[jamee7]

@MultiMath123 After the success of Because of a Man, she told JYP to become a trainee again. I think she wants to enhance her vocal and dancing abilities. Now, this year, 2010, she returns with a new OST for Cinderella's Sister [starring 2PM's Taecyeon and Korea's Little Sister, Moon Geun Young]. The song is entitled, Turn Around. ...She's underrated but I really love her voice.

[MultiMath123]

@jamee7 THANKS:)

[Chekas1292]

@jamee7 She's so good.. They both are.. But how old is she? o.o