Added: 4 years ago
From: rosiepep
Views: 507,302
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (464)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • for those wondering what the song she sing is its called Caro mio ben artist: Cecilia Bartoli

  • :)

  • jay's accent = hot

  • favorite part is 3:26 wish she stayed in the key instead of changing....but all good :))

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I THINK IS IS LIKE A GREAT VIDEO. I WATCH IT EVERYDAY AND I FEEL LIKE MY DREAMS COME TRUE EVERY TUME. ONE DAY I WILL SING LIKE THE BEAUTIFUL ANGEL HILARY DUFF AND BE IN A MUSIC SCHOOL WITH COOL TEACHERS AND MUSIC AND LOVE.

  • whats the song called at 4.51

  • okay but that was clearly not her singing at 3:10

  • I love Hilary Duff's acting, but she can't actually sing...so this really wasn't the movie for her.

  • @SierraLorraineBowers same as all disney stars, really

  • i love this movie i love how terrie sings in the class at almost of the end of her singin i wish i could sing lyk tht hehe one word to describe her singin "amazing" hehe lol

  • love this movie!♥&& ollie james♥♥

  • ...i just love how they have her voice mixed in with some other girls voice cuz she cant actually sing it XD

  • Jay is hot!!:)

  • ah its been so long since iv'e seen this movie!

    missed it <3

  • i know what you mean oliver. hahaha ;p

  • Comment removed

  • I like ollie james in this movie instead of ''what a girl wants.''

  • JAY <3

  • where the hell is the guy standing in MY doorway when i'm crying....lol

  • God I love Oliver.

  • it is her voice

  • hahaha i love hilary but that most definitely was not her singing.

  • I actually don't think her 'wrong' note is that wrong :S

  • Comment removed

  • omg oliver james is HOOOTTT!!!!... <3

  • Girl at 2:45

    How did she get in?!

  • @narly0carly It is not only for singers.. ;P So maybe she is a trumpist or something? :P

  • @MelletjeDuhh Yeah, but wouldn't she be in a different class then? lol

  • @narly0carly No, because you gotta learn more things than just your own special thing, right?

  • @narly0carly I think she plays an instrument

  • @narly0carly she got into the school cause of her brother TheOceanoffire

    

  • No offence Jay but youre not too good of a singer :) Still love you though <3

  • terry=beatifull

    jay=hot

    terry+jay =perect couple

  • fucking looovveee jay's accent!!!! <3 <3 <3

  • @TheAllie4ever and i looove it

  • hilary is  pretty short compared to oliver ...

  • why d hell are the having a voiceover for when she sings ??

  • U do ur Own thing at ur own time Lmaoo! i love oliver james

  • that ain't Hillary duff singing like tht!!! infact i wud like to see her try to sing like tht!!!

  • @ssameeze no its actually her but they had to record it in a studio first

  • @charicebiggestfan  yh and thn add some1 else's voice to go on top of hers and get it totaly auto tuned!!!

  • @ssameeze no its her voice maybe there is auto tune but its hers am sure

  • iwill gonna be an actresse so i cry really fast but this me movie just kill me!!!:(

  • did she wear that one long sleeve shirt with the heart on it in lizzie miguire? haha

  • what song by giodonni is she singing? i think thts how u spell the name ..?

  • @Fallinupintolove caro mio ben.

  • "The bag isn't walking away!"

    LOL i love that line!

  • Am I the only one who can tell that it's not Hillary Duff singing in the beautiful falsetto at 3:27? You can obviously tell where it's her and where it's not. lol

  • @cooolness3 same!!! lol i think its her sister's voice x)

  • How is name the song? 4:20

  • 4:40 XD

  • i love raise ur voice!!! x

  • @ 3:25 gave me chills

  • the show is over alright................ the is not walking away cute but funny

  • love the way she saves herself :P so beautiful :P

  • the words to this scene reminds me of sam and austin in A Cinderella Story haha

  • love his tatoo, at 6:12...hott!

  • The french teacher is hilarious

  • no offense to other ppl in this film, but it doesn't seem like they are very good. i kno so many ppl in my school who can sing WAY better and hit MORE notes. i thought this was suppose to be a hard camp?

  • guys who are there for girls wen they're crying<3

  • i despise this movie, and every time my sister ties my hands to my back and makes me watch it. fml

  • @cheeseman2122 then what are you doing youtubing it?

  • i despise this movie, and every time my sster ties my hands to my back and makes me watch it. fml

  • rofl it takes one guy to help a girl in distress or whatever you would call what terry was feeling

  • 3:12-3:15, 3:20-3:22, and 3:30-3:35 all Hilary.

  • @starchix01 definitely not lmao.

  • that was so fake

  • 3:08 to 3:10 Not Hilary

    3:12 to 3:15 That's Hilary

    3:16 to 3:19 Not Hilary

    3:20 to 3:21 Hilary

    3:22 to 3:29 Not Hilary

    3:30 to 3:35 Hilary

    :) That should solve it for everyone. But I still love her

  • Play something for me biatch! XD

  • Would a guy now days just die being caught singing a love song.

  • Can anybody be able to tell if Hilary really sang from 4:38 to 5:00? And is the way she sang different from the way she sings the songs on her albums? Because it sounds different.

    Does it have to do with where the voice come from? Such as throat, diaphragm, etc. Sorry, I'm interested in music, but I don't know much about the terms and singing skills.

  • @shainalovesmusic  It's an Italian song called Caro mio ben

  • @shainalovesmusic it has a lot to do with where she is singing from. it changes the timbre. she sang through her throat in this song and in her album she sings through her nose.  She actually sang this song incorrectly. I'm singing this for my workshop in college and her tone is not the way it should be.

  • @GypsyBuggy Wow, you know A LOT! I thought she was singing from her diaphragm in this video... But how do you sing from nose? I've heard this kind of singing skill from a friend before.

    And I didn't know colleges have singing courses. What's your major, and what classes are you taking for that? Because I'm interested in singing, but I don't know what the requirements are. Did you take any singing class in high school? I mean, do you need to take the prerequisites in high school beforehand?

  • you have to do your own things on ur own terms

  • luv this video a lil boring:)!!!!!!

  • pause at 3:50 priceless

  • 1:31 - 2:39 Oliver is to taller than Hilary :p.

  • i really love hilary's hair in this movie.. she looks preety.. X)

  • I'm sorry, I love the movie but he's like two foot and ten years older than she is!

  • Oliver James is so HOT!!!!

  • "You're takin the top of the Four!"

    "Thank you!"

    "I was talking to Terri" xD lmao

  • i hate when she starts rocking out, its just awkward.

  • OMG why the bad editing? could it be anymore obvious that's not her singing?

  • hi rosiepep kannst mal denn ganzen film rein stellen wer voll geil

  • oh my gosh I love this movie so much :D :D :D

  • Whats the song at 3:57 called and whos it by? and at 4:52?

  • @schpazzumz The song at 3:57 is called Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen and the other song at 4:52 is called Caro Mio Ben by Giuseppe Giordani :) I sang that once in choir. Its a beautiful song, so is Hallelujah.

  • @PassionofGuitarMusic  3:57's not lenoard cohen? =s

  • @schpazzumz yes thats the composer of Hallelujah

  • @PassionofGuitarMusic not that one though, his is the "i heard there was a secret chord that david played and it pleased the lord. it goes like this a forth than fith the minnor fall and the major lift, the baffild king composing hallelujah. hallelujah hallelujah hallelujah hallelujah."

  • @schpazzumz so cool that you know the song good on you everybody knows the song!!

  • Whats the song at 3:57 called and whos it by?

  • what's the name of the song played at 4:40??

  • oh my god she is so gooooooooddddddd!

  • I never heard that it was digitally enhanced or not, and if it was, it could have been enhanced with her own voice, like some singers do so they can have their own voice as background vocals. I love Hilary Duff and I think she did an excellent job in "Raise Your Voice" and "Cinderella Story." I am a college music student, an allthough some of her shaping may have been off, with or without a lil enhanced help, she is an amazing singer and actress.

  • @letusbethemusic her voice is not digitally enhanced but it's most definatley NOT her voice. Hilary Duff has different voices for her singing in the Lizzie Mcguire movie and in this one. I heard that it was her sister who sing a couple verses and the rest were a uncredited teenage singer who had a similar voice to Hilarys - but a better vocal range. The problem with Hilary is that she's an alto when it comes to singing and in her movies her character is always singing soprano parts.

  • You know, her voice is:

    1. digitally enhanced

    2. chorally disgusting.

    You can't sing like that in a choir and expect to survive. Her mouth is so closed it's a wonder she can breathe. Not a single choir teacher would applaud her-- they'd kick her out of the classroom.

  • Poor Terry. Her brother is such a sweet guy!

  • lol I love how she pays absolutely NO atttention to the metronome and the dude is supposed to look impressed

  • they are so nice couple <3

  • she starred in the film Raise Your Voice, While some critics praised Duff for appearing in a more mature and serious role than her previous films, the film itself was heavily panned. Several reviews were indifferent towards her acting performance and were critical of Duff's vocals, with critics pointing out what appeared to be her digitally enhanced voice. The same year, Duff received her first Razzie nomination for worst actress for her roles in Raise Your Voice and A Cinderella Story

  • by wikipedia

  • Well no wonder, she can't sing like that in real life and both of the movies in that year she played the poor perfect me role. It made you want to barf.

  • ok this is how you can tell if shes not or is singing at 4:40 she is but earlier at the practice class she starts to sing but after the mess up when she goes all freestyles that wasn't her until she goes oooh then its her again but she did have a singer that sang parts of the movie for her because hilary was and is not that skilled. and im not trying to offend anyone im just pointing out the obvious

  • @justen25 And she may sound good but they also mixed her voice with auto-tune i think its called

  • no affence but Jay sings really bad! urgh...

  • @jade77choc Hilary Duffs wasnt even really singing??!!!

  • wow that was the fastest most successful confession i've ever seen in a movie

  • thats not really her singing she doesnt have the skill

  • @EscapeTheFateCRAIG oh dear..yes it is

  • how do you know?

  • @EscapeTheFateCRAIG Your right you can so tell its not her!!!

  • Lmao "i was talking 2 terri"

  • úžasný film

  • hilary duff is so lucky/

    ooft that english guys is fit.

    ahm lucky he lives in my country!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • hahahaha

  • 3:09 - 3:35 rocks!! Love youu Hillaryy!!<3

  • I Totally agree i went through all the parts on youtube just to find this bit XD

  • I love oliver james... hes so cute XD

  • @woodyjojo

    Nah he is hot!!!

  • umm your tato is wrong spelling it should be tatoo>>>

  • Actually it's 'tattoo'.

  • This movie is inspiring

  • why do chick flicks always find hot cute guys, who we can never have a chance in seeing?

  • @michellel9595 ikr!

  • @michellel9595

    so true

    the guys we get were there pant half way down so that we can see their undies and they ones who only want sex

  • @michellel9595 I asks the same question

  • @michellel9595 hey u culd say the same about the girl

  • @lostsoulz1337 i could but im not a lesbian lol

  • @michellel9595 OMG I KNOW RIGHT!

  • what song is she singing in her voice class with the russian?! it has been driving me crazy for a while now...and goggle isn't really helping either.

  • I think it's called Jericho

  • Caro Mio ben... the first song any classical vocalist sings.... badly...

  • @collegesis911 lol you mean google?

  • @collegesis911 Caro Mio Ben.

  • gawd i cry way to much on this movie

  • OH SHE MAKES ME CRY

  • 5:00

  • haha 3:30

  • 3:28 I wish I could sing like that

  • it's so weird, at 4:40 it's definitely her singing (albeit, recorded). and she sounds great.

    But, instead of just having her sing at 3:23, they dub most of it.

  • 3;23 hilarious

  • i love oliver james <3

    and hilary duff is a very good actrees

  • you'd think they'd try harder to make the voice that they dub in for her sound more like her....i thought she was supposed to be a singer? she cant even sing her own notes. psh hahaha

  • yeah like in part 6(a), in the video her bro makes her vocal dubbing was really obvious when she is playing the piano and singing after jericho. lol. you figure she'd be able to sing those notes.

  • it was soo the idoit who ran the red light guys fault i hate when ppl blame on themselfs when they did not do it!

  • OMIGOD! I HATE IT WHEN SHE STARTS AT 3:25 becuase it is sooo stupid. But i still like the movie. so sad

  • oh my god! His voice is awesome♥

  • yeah it's dubbed a couple times in the movie. i don't know why the movie producers would do that when she can already sing.

  • @kbvip cuz she cant

  • figured.

  • great voice !! she's sooo awesome! love her !

  • i cry when ever i see this movie

  • i love her! but even though this is an awesome movie, its making me cry! i wanna be a singer too...but....i ....cant sing as well as her...but i still wanna sing

  • Most singers sing from their head. Imitating popstars. Professional singers hate that. You're not suppose to sing like that at all.

  • she has a sweet voice but very weak.

  • wait, when he sings, isn't his accent supposed to be there? It's probably dubbed but....

  • I LOVE HER VOICE!!

  • I LOOOVE THIS MOVIEE

  • WTF?!?! she was singing out of time but the guy perked up like she was improoving.....i'll give her points for her singing voice though...

  • I totally agree. If you actually had ears, you could hear that the whole sound is electronically changed so that she can sing in tune, when she can't. Plus her breath support is so opposite from classical singing that it's quite hilarious. I agree with the Italian Diction. If you want to hear real classical singing, go see an Opera.

  • luv this movie but it is veryy sad!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • dubbed!!!!her real voice sucks as

  • You know... I never realized how short she is!!! She's pocket sized. And all the cuter for it. LOL ;-)