Added: 3 years ago
From: NoelGallagherIsGod
Views: 64,272
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (156)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this song is born for voices like Liam's

  • liam version is muuuuuuuch better

  • noel o liam, sea quien sea el que cante, esta canción es brillante!

  • i can only say lennon & mcartney,,,briliant together not as briliant without each other,,noel and liam init,,,,just the chemistry comes across in their music

  • Noel one said in an interview that He's the better singer, Liam's just got the better voice. I would tend to agree. Except back in the early days, at that time Liam was both the better singer with the better voice as well. Over time Liam's voice got worse and Noel's improved.

  • From time to time I actually feel like Noel sounds bad on some songs when he's just singing too hard and starts shouting his voice starts to sound weak and not powerful enough like it needs Liam's voice. And on most harder tunes I prefer Liam's voice but for some reason on this one I just feel like Noel nailed it, love the way he sounds on it going hard, strangely I prefer the original with Noel on this one.

  • Wow this is so weird to hear Liam singing this, I've always heard this from Noel and thought it was always his... it really does sound like Liam is trying very hard to keep in this key...

  • Comment removed

  • @MadFerlt : Please???

  • This was perfect for Liam.

  • too high for liam

  • I love the fuck out of Noel's voice, and in general I might prefer it to Liam's, but I really feel like Liam's voice just fits this song so much better.

  • watch?v=2QjEhz43wXo  - to see Liam singing DLBIA lol

  • Liam adds more, more fuckin Rock 'n' Roll!

    D'you know what I mean? But Noel is the fuckin Man!

    Both Gallagher in this song is godlike... Someone's agree? :D

  • Much better version. Nails it.

  • The Lord did slow down Liam, lol

  • I think liam version is much better

  • I always thought Liam should've taken this song, but now that I've heard it, I'm not sure. I don't have too much time for this song anyway.

  • Love -em -both, -this -ones -better -by -Noel, -cant -wait -for -hopefully -twice -as -much -Oasis?? -Noel -going -solo -and -the -rest -of -the -band -creating -new -tunes -with -their -own -direction. -BEST -BAND -EVER< -FACT.

  • I usually prefer songs with Liam as the lead singer, but this one is just made to be sing by Noel and Noel alone.

  • Great... Liams singing is more earthy so it suits this song better

  • I'd like to see someone mix both versions. One chorus Liam, one Noel or something like that.

    Think it would be great.

  • both versions are fuckin class !

  • Genial!

  • Love Liam, but Noel is better on this song.

  • Generally I prefer Noel's voice to Liam's......... but I actually think I like this version better.... and that surprises me.

  • why the fuck wernt this the singleee

  • Not a patch on the original

  • why was this not the single

    like or not liam was the lead senger and since it was a stand alone single it makes it more important to have liam on lead. Does anyone else agree? Don't get me wrong noels vocals are great too but i just liams should be on the mastered version

  • this version shoulda been the real version and it soulda been on dig out ur soul

  • They are unique right!

  • why do people feel that they have to force their point of view on people? i mean, if someone thinks that liam can't sing or noel can't write then thats fine! i ain't changing my opinion because of it! i think oasis had the voice and noel writing the songs! this is another gem that may never be released! but then again i'd love to hear some of the stuff noel has written and not even recorded...

  • i like more than the original version

    but liam now cant sing this

  • Both are good but i'd say Liam's version just shades it for me.

  • oasis = LIAM

  • CHATTIN POO,SHUT THE MOUTH IT STINKS

  • LIAM RULES!!!!!!!

  • i dont knoo why alot people think noels better than liam i mean liam was the one who made the band noel just came along and wrote alot of songs.

  • yea and its not hard to get a band together... writing songs as good as some of noels is alot harder...

  • neither is better. But seriously, Noel just came along and wrote alot of songs, are you fucking kidding me? If he hadn't came along and wrote all those genius songs, the band would still exist yeah, only no one would give a fuck to hear them and we would never have heard of them.

  • calm down.

  • eh???

  • just came along and wrote the songs? WTF? you try writing songs like this and you'll soon realise why noel's a legend. i agree that liam's voice is the oasis sound, however without the songs that noel wrote oasis wouldn't have even been signed. Sure liam's got the voice, look and attitude but noel has the gift of music.....and he also has a fantastic voice

  • beetlebum1997 : you really stupid, noel write this song and the most songs that liam sing, and both sing really well, so fuck you :)

  • gawd, i'd love to knock you out. Liam Gallagher is OASIS!!

  • better than noel version! hey liaaamm!!!

  • beetlebum stfu you clueless faggot, ur making a fool of yourself

  • why are you comparing them?..

    they are both f*ckin brilliant.

    Oasis would not have been if either was not in it.

  • As Much as I admire Noel I do think that liam is possibly THE hottest man ever (taking Johnny Depp and Jonathan Rhys Meryes out of the equation)

    He is a fucking babe!

  • he wrote them dick head, so in a sense, so many great songs were GIVEN to Liam.

    That said Noel did say that this was left off the album because he was singing on too many songs, so dont see why he didnt give it to Liam, would have bulked the album up a bit, great song

  • love this its fkn class

  • i think this verson should of replaced lyla on dbtt i like lyla but i like this more

  • Garethfeb16 has got it spot on, Liam rips this tune up!! Class as always!

  • wow i like it iv only heard noel singing it!! this 1 is better!

  • Defo should have released this version. Sorry Noel but this is just better,

  • loving it

  • there both awesome versions

  • listen digsy dinner live 94.....and shut up

  • eh your grammer is a bit mixed up there, which tells me you where not very educated as a teenager....and you ask me to shut up, come again??

  • I'm crying........ :-)

  • its not that bad

  • dont get me wrong i like lyla i just think this has the edge (slightly)

  • lylas fuckin awesome its even better live!!! wtf u on bwt

  • so is lord dont slow me down. like i said i like lyla. i just think that this is better.

  • as far as vocals go, I prefer Noel to Liam almost every time, including here. Champagne Supernova is an exception.

  • better than noel

  • This is the bollocks!!!

  • i think noel and liam doing a duo (sing different lines) in the fame would be awesome! i don't know why but some of the low parts in the fame could be for liam and high pars for noel and the chorus for both of them. i know i'm weird but i bet it would sound awesome!

  • i like noels version better, liam struggles a couple of times in this one.

  • Oh I donno, its a close comparison, Noel has more soul when he sings, but liam can show the hostility. if I had to pick, I guess on this track Id pick......Noel. Yes. He has a better range!

  • this version better, oh yes!

  • Better than Noel version

  • IMO Noel's better here

  • much better liam, on this... :)

  • I really can't decide which one is best, Liam or Noel for this track, they're both pretty good.

  • The Noel's version is better

  • I prefer Liam on this tune for sure.

  • noel made it cos of liam, liam made it cos of noel! without each outher they couldn't have hoped to be anything more than a pub and club group! im nt saying they are not tallented but they come as a pair! this is a great song and shows that noel has an ego! this has taken on awhole new life! i loved this song when i heard noel singing it but liam blows it outta the water!!!!

  • I 'll die to hear Liam sing Don't look back in anger...

  • Same here mate, how awesome'd that be. Maybe one day. Oasis is always full of surprise, like bringing I Am the Walrus back for this tour, as well as kicking off w/Rock n Roll Star... I think Noel loves doing DLBIA live, but you never know. :)

  • Well, Noel wanted to sing wonderwall, but liam wanted to sing that. So Noel sung Don't look back in anger.

  • Noel actually wanted to sing Don't look back in anger, he used Wonderwall as bargaining measure.

  • I'm just going by what he said in an interview. It's from the horses mouth.

  • Yeah, same here with me, I saw it in a TV interview.

  • I also heard Noel wanted to sing Fade In/Out, but Liam said ok, then I'm singing Magic Pie, but Noel didn't want to give that song up so gave Fade In/Out to Liam - good job too!

  • and i would like to hear Liam sing Sad Song

  • @applefieldd and if noel sing rock n' roll star? .... champagne supernova?

  • @applefieldd did You know that there's "Don't Look Back In Anger" Liam 's Version .. =)

  • @bonklers1527 no there isn't.

  • @Robertrafn he played it in a manchester pub a while ago..

  • @EvelinevandeWinckel thats not liam singing dont look back in anger. Its an impersonator. Fool face.

  • @LukaRaPtoR Since when it's been a Liam impersonator that sings "Don't look back in anger"???? Until the last time I checked, it was NOEL who sang this song!!!

  • @dreamer13266 there is one bloke in an Oasis tribute band and he did a version of it. the video of it on here has had the comments disabled so that all the thick fucks who think its liam cant be told otherwise. but yeah, theres a video knocking about

  • @dreamer13266 watch?v=2QjEhz43wXo thats the video mate, see for yourself 

  • @bonklers1527 no there isnt

  • This sounds great but does anyone else think he wouldn't have managed it live? That could be why Noel took the lead on it. but then... they never do it live with Noel on lead either, do they.. Really uninspired setlists for the most part... hardly any surprises anywhere whatsoever, except for Half the World Away the other week, which was nice.

  • What would be an inspired setlist? A band like Oasis has to keep everyone happy, and its hard; they have to play all the old hits, and with as many as they have, that takes time, and then they have to play new material. I'd love to hear Some Might Say, is all I can say.

  • I'd like to hear more obscurer though no less great stuff, e.g. 'Going Nowhere'.  Would also like to hear them do 'Roll It Over' just once. Something more unexpected. They could still keep fans happy but throw in surprises is all I'm saying.

  • i think he would to ok becasue it's sounds very simillar to his live voise especially at the begining let us know what you think

  • There are some songs that just have to be sung by Noel and some by Liam but this one seems to work just as well for both of them. Check out the version where they both sing if you can't decide!!

  • i prefer this one, were dd u get this btw? xD

  • OMG THIS IS AMAZING!

    how do I get this??

  • FUCKING TUNE MAN!!

  • i think liams better is alot better

    i think we should hear liam do noels songs more often, because we always here noel doing lims songs, i think liam singing dont look back in anger would be very interesting

  • when has Noel ever song lead on a Liam song?

    Liam struggles to hold some of the notes on this one anyway

  • hate to break the trend but i actually like noel's version better

  • I concur

  • I really prefer Liam on this song. His voice suits it much more.

  • both versions are out of this world!

  • Did Liam really write this song ?

  • No Noel wrote it. I cant imagine Liam writing a song and letting Noel sing it...

    (I know this is Liam singing in this version before you say anything)

  • i imagine his music is a lot better than yours(should you have any) and anyway its his song so its fair he decides how and when it comes out -_-

  • thank you noel

  • no problem robbie williams :P

  • Who the fuck you think you are ?

  • What?

  • CLAP CLAP CLAP!

  • Liam has never sung DLBIA live.

  • i think id have liked this version as the single a hell of a lot more than the original

  • Liam never sings Noel songs even when he walks away. In 2000 without Noel they skipped those songs and in Acquiesce he asked the fans to sing the chorus.

  • better then a noel's version..meglio liam sentite

     che rock n roll!!!!

  • rather have liam singing this, anywhere i can get it?

  • liams voice fits this song much better!!!!!!

  • way better than that awful performance at the brits last year.

    forget him singing anything off of dm or morning glory. be here now he can manage

  • fucking awesome

  • Very good song. Liams voice sounds good if he lays off of the cigarettes and alcohol a few days before he sings.

  • yeah its a class track, i downloaded it there. found out liam wrote the lyrics for it as well which i never knew

  • awesome, song was meant for liam

  • how do u get these

  • This is fuckin'great!! And Liam's voice is the one we were waitin'for!

  • Didnt Liam Do A Song With The Prodigy

  • yeah its called guns. great vocal! noels on bass in that track as well

  • its called shoot down

  • is the original prodigy song not called shoot down but the remix with noel and liam called guns? aww well doesnt matter

  • liam really rocks on this song but noel's versione is massive too

  • Noel is much better

  • Liams voice on this just makes me wanna drink and sing all nite pure summer time rock n roll

  • noel, you should have let Liam sing this one.

  • Liam has much more bigger voice and it sounds better on rocker like this. Comparing to noel's version he got a bit too thin voice

  • Being honest Liam should have sung the official relased version.

  • when was death in vegas recorded?

  • in 2004. They were the original session for Don't Believe the Truth, but were eventually scrapped

  • great sessions with death in vegas!!!!

  • its a demo which was leaked anywhere...same with 2 other NEWsongs

  • its from the death in vegas recordings!!!!!!

  • liam does a great job on this one i actually prefer his vocal

  • ohmygod!

    Top song!

    Noel does a bit better, but Liam still does a good job!

  • where is this from? it's not the download single. from a show or something? (first post! :D)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more