Added: 3 years ago
From: Tarnovsky
Views: 37,154
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (93)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ¡¡¡ Bravo, Martyna !!! 

  • bravissima!

  • Genial!! Cuando yo empecé a tocar la guitarra, esta chica todavía no había nacido. Sin embargo, ella toca mejor que yo. Bravo!!

  • bien pero algo aburrida, se supone que es una danza española y deberia llevar un ritmo un poco mas bailando con los graves, jugar con la pieza, asi como tocarla de forma danzante, aunque estuvo bien pero solo ese detalle, a mi me falla mucho ello, asi que se de lo que hablo, mi maestro me pide esta pieza de forma mas danzante pero bueno

  • Great , well done :)

  • Beautifull and for Martyna's listed age - 11years - amazing!!!

    This video was shot almost exactly 3 years ago - I would love to hear an updated version

  • Really nice job...you have a bright future ahead. Keep up the good work. Many would try, but there are few who can perform this piece as well as you have. Brava!

  • This is amazing am playin this at the minuit in my grades of classical guitar and still cant play it as good as you have Good Performance

  • Not always technically perfect, but lovely and musical playing by a serious kid who obviously listens to what she does. I'm not a naive listener...I was a conservatory student years ago...but I prefer her playing of this piece to the playing of some professionals, who view it as an amusing showpiece and not as music. I find myself coming back and listening to it again and again.

  • Simply awesome. This would be an excellent rendition from a 31 year old.

  • ¿Quieres ser mi novia?

  • Bravo, wish I could play this tune also.... Carry on.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Well done!

  • Nice performance. I posted my video response just to interact. Greetings :D

  • yawn.

  • where can you get this version sheet music

  • what a wonderful job. beautiful tone, bold colors, clear intentions behind the performance. i'm a big fan!

  • That looks like a really difficult piece to play! wow

  • jak na taką smarkulę to prześwietnie wręcz;)

  • pero que bonito

  • Beautiful performance, dear namesake!

    Martin

  • very good,,,nice playing guitar

  • Excellent player but the tempo has to be kept in check. It's not good to speed up too much in places. You lose some of the rhythmic feel if it's too fast.

    Nice arrangement here. Tone changes in some places are good too.

  • @Rexicano this piece is supposed to be at a fast tempo. All music from this era was lively and was mainly used for dancing,

  • She is 11 years old!

    Why not just say 'Bravo!'

  • Since you know so much about music, why don't you contribute something yourself, rather than writing spiteful comments about talented people like this young woman.

  • @key2kingdom

    And I'd say;

    why don't YOU get some music lessons?

    Your Dowland is so flat and boring. Robotic.

    I can understand you being bad at French music because you Brits are so tone deaf to French culture...but you're English and can't play Dowland worth a damn.

    Less time on YT and more time getting help is what you need, crybaby.

  • @Rexicano i dont mean to give you more flame then your already getting, but, to put it crudely, stop being an ass and get your arrogance under control. the fact that you have nothing better to do then to argue with others on youtube (of all the sites and forums) doesnt say much about yourself. Also, before you want to criticize someone about something, you should probably prove that you yourself know or can do better. you claim to be so much, yet have nothing to show for it...

  • @haxxoromg

    Thanks for presenting me with your credentials in Music.

    Oh, that's right, you don't have a video of the piece yourself...gee, what shall I assume?

    I guess you're too busy as you need to run now to write to Roger Ebert that he has non right to comment on films as he hasn't made any. "Cept maybe one.

    And here you are pointlessly arguing with me on YouTube. Hypocrite.

  • @Rexicano im not criticizing your music, im criticizing your personality. and yes, im arguing with you on youtube, but its hardly a waste of time on my part if theres even a slight chance that i can leave an impression on you to make you grow up a bit and maybe start acting your age. ce sont les gens comme toi qui donnent aux francais une mauvaise image, tu sais? i appreciate that you started off giving constructive criticism, but you should keep your temper and patience in check.

  • @Rexicano It is truly sad that you've not managed to control your ego at your age. Clearly from your comment addressed to viciousmagdiel you're getting on a bit, as you tell him / her (quote) 'I was playing this piece well before you were born'.

    You clearly have something to prove. Is youtube really the place to do it? I notice you've contributed NOTHING to youtube, excepting your attempts to grind talented musicians into the dust with your 'wit'.

    Ever thought of getting a life?

  • @WinjaWarrior

    Yeah, let's kill the messenger...not discuss the art I critique. Just stop the fake drama. It's just too bad that I know what I'm discussing and you don't.

    And this is coming from an idiot who claims his interests are "Winging and moaning." Hypocrite?

    Maybe you're unclear on the concept here on YouTube but it's a public forum and others (besides just you) have a right to express opinions..even negative ones...so grow up. Winja Warrior? What are you...7 years old?

  • @Rexicano er, no, I'm 9 years old. Seems strange that I have more constructive things to say than someone like, for example, yourself, who from your comments I estimate is in his 80's.

  • @WinjaWarrior Yay for the WinjaWarrior!

  • @WinjaWarrior - to be fair my ego has taken a bashing here too

  • @key2kingdom You have to say: "Brava!" She's a girl. ;)

  • @ilRibe ,

    Sorry but "Bravo", when used as an expression instead of as an adjetive, has no gender variability at all. A girl can be "brava" (brave, valiant, strong-hearted, aggresive), but you can NOT shout "¡Brava!"(sic) to celebrate her success, unless you want to speak like some unliterated Spanish women ministers decorating recent (socialist) governments.

    Believe me, I am Spanish :)

  • @lentorpe I was talking about Italian, but thank you for the spanish lesson! xD

  • Wow! That made my day. I am not kidding you. Dynamics were great. Bravo, 5 stars!!!

  • ok sigue asi muy buena interpretacion.luis.madrid.

  • Impresioante!!!

    Qué dominio de la técnica!!!

  • Beautiful.

    Could you please tell me where can I find the sheet music to this version ?

    I would be very glad to play it as well as you do.

    !

  • Congratulations

  • Just Wonderfull...

    Thank you so much for sucha a nice performance.

  • WooW!! very nice playing.....love you!!!!

  • She did great!!!

    Great left hand,(Tarrega would be proud.)

    the staccato was nice clear the slurs we clear and very strong. A fine approach to Rasgueado and good jig form.

    I always find it interesting to hear comments from people who are not professionals.

    as I have played hundreds of concerts and taught for 27 years, I feel secure in saying she is a real talent.

    Keep the love in your music and don't worry about the rest.

    James Hunley

  • I like this one very much, I played it also but yours much more expressive, congratulations!

  • you made me cry darlin... what a talent you have for makin people cry

  • BRAVA!!! Martyna. Your playing is lovely. :-)

  • smile martyna, smyle

    SONRIE MARTYNA.. SONRIE

  • i practise this song at the moment, really fun to play ^^

    11 years... i hadn't even started playin guitar at that age xD

  • very good but the sound quality sucks (the video i mean)

  • not bad but you must practice

  • Personally, I liked her performance better than your video...

    She has much more colour, and really delicate playing. Beautiful technique...And she is only 11!!!

    Don't be so negative, this was great!

    A solid performance :)

    A young Bream??? I would like to hear her play again in 10 years time :)

    - Michael -

  • good song

  • Outstanding ! !

  • I love that song. Nice performance and good tone color.

  • really good =)

    is that a hanika gutiar?

  • Beautiul! it seems Martyna is playing even before she was born!! :)

  • your interpretation is very good! BRAVO

  • Fantastic!!

  • Martyna, this is excellent! Expression like adult, experienced guitarist! Your Canarios are really part of Fantasia para un geltrihombre...

  • marvelous!!!!...very well played...

  • excelente!!!! felicitaciones

  • really nice!

    but it's not the original one. I don't like this version!

    But i'm amazed the way you play! 5 stars!!!

  • an 11 year old? amazing just when you think you've seen everything you watch one video on youtube and boom! blown away

  • brawo :)

  • Bravo

  • Wooooow!!! amazing for an age! im only 15 and i know i couldnt pla that at her age

    Ya Jestem Polakem, but id rather write in English ;]

  • Widząc takich gitarzystów zaczynam poważnie wątpić czy kiedykolwiek będę dobrym gitarzystą.

  • Widzę że Polacy nie gęsi swoje gitary mają:D Brawo Martynko, popracuj jeszcze nad prędkością a dorównasz w niej np Angelowi Romero:) poszukaj jego wersji wykonania tego utworu na YT:). Masz 11 lat więc nie można mieć do Ciebie żadnych pretensji co do szybkości gry, to tylko rada:) z czasem zagrasz ten kawałek znakomicie:) Mam oko na Twoje wykonania i będę zaglądał często. Zrobiłaś na mnie wrażenie. Daleko zajdziesz...:)

    Pozdrawiam

    Daniel 21 lat

    P.S. Też gitarzysta ;) xD

  • Bravo Martyna!!!

    BRAVO!

    Interpretación para elogiar!

    Bravísimo!!!!!!

  • Unfortunately (or fortunately) the guitar music level is getting higher every year. Martyna, though she's quite good, she's not an evenement. There lots of kids playing better than her. Some of 13yo guys play even better than the Musical Academies graduates. For example "mr" Przedbora and Kozlowski (as far as I remember from Tomaszow Mazowiecki in Poland). They are 14 year old and they win international contests with 30-40yo guys. Hope some day we'll see them on yt.

  • No, niestety (a może stety?), poziom muzyki gitarowej idzie bardzo szybko w górę i trzeba przyznać, że Martyna, choć dobra, nie jest wcale ewenementem czy też niesamowitym talentem. Już zdarzają się 12-13 latkowie grający lepiej niż studenci Akademii Muzycznej. Masa ćwiczeń, dobrzy pedagodzy. Wystarczy wspomnieć "panów" Przedborę i Kozłowskiego bodajże z Tomaszowa Maz. To są mistrzowie (13, 14 lat?) Może kiedyś zagoszczą tu ich nagrania

  • Increible la ejecución de esta niña para su corta edad. Felicidades!

  • WOW! Very nice young talent!! Thank you.

    Pere.

  • Very impressive guitar playing, regardless of age, well done!

  • great playing, i love the chords at 1.80

    beautiful performance

  • Excellent! Martyna is a seldom talent! 5*

  • Excellent in every regard!

  • So let me see... At her age I still wouldn't pick up the guitar for another 3 years. And yet she plays better at 11 than I do at 48. And in front of an audience no less. And not just technically does she play well, but with real verve and style. That makes my head hurt.

    See you at Carnegie Hall.

    My hat's off, WAY off to you.

    subscribed.

  • rayos tocas muy bien felicidades

  • OH..... MY.... FUCKING... GOD!!!

  • cudooo!!! ;*

  • Muy bueno!

  • ma cm cazzo fai a suonare così bene a 11 anni??

  • How beautiful!

  • O:) Lublin 2008:)

    Perfekcyjnie.

  • Wonderful! 5*

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more