I love this, but I'm so confused... I'm reading Hamlet as I watch this, and this version seems to have skipped Hamlet's "To be or not to be" soliloquy, but I know it's in here, I watched a clip of it earlier. Have they moved it, changed the placement? Or did YouTube remove the clip? I LOVE that speech, the play doesn't feel quite right without it.
So glad to know that I'm not the only one who thought that the knife was a sonic for a second. :D I'm not the only crazy whovian out there watching this video.
I think it's great that Hamlet's speech as he's about to kill Claudius is all done in his head. One of the great things about technology---we don't have to rely on unrealistic conceits like asides as much in film.
jackyp1893, the point is he is so deep in prayer that he doesn't notice that, or the rest of Hamlet's monologue. This scene really shows the religious expectations of Shakespeare's day and the irony in that expectation, like TomatoDoom pointed out. People didn't really "talk" to God, they just muttered devout words and hoped for the best.
I love that ironic line- "Words without thoughts never to heaven go." His soul was no safer than before. Had Hamlet gone through with it then and there, he'd have had everything he wanted.
@Kill4Karamel That's actually the climax of the play. I know in my copy of Hamlet I have that page starred and all over it, I have written in full uppercase; "YOU JACKASS!! YOU COULD'VE STOPPED EVERYTHING!!! YOU DAMN DAMN FOOL!!" That being said, it delights me to see the progression of death from one single decision. Sort of sad.
@idontlikesand right. i was thinking the same thing but i was like. wait how does that make sense but then there was the blade and i was like oh. disappointment.
@idontlikesand Honestly I did...I was hoping...-_- too much of a who fan...wait...no...that's not possible...checks tenant style coat...hmm...sonic screwdriver pen in pocket...oh...uh...Dr. Who iphone case...oh my...oh well Doctor Who kicks ass...and so does David tenant ^_^
@SamDeRe81 I recommend the Folger Shakespeare Library copies of the books. It has the text of the play written on every right-side page with translation for the archaic terms on the facing page. Trust me, it helps a lot.
I actually found it impressive how much it DIDNT look like the sonic. For someone so used to pulling out the same shaped something for years, its pretty awesome how different he can do it when he chooses.
@semperreg It's important, though, to note that given the different time setting, it allows room for a different interpretation of the stage actions. That's part of why modernized "translations" (they are using the same words, after all) are so interesting to watch.
there are references to characters guilt through their hands all throughout Shakespeare's work. Macbeth comes to mind... something about turning the seas red. and then Lady Macbeth and the smell of her hands.
It's true that the knife is definitely opposite of the sonic screwdriver, but I think what people are thinking of most when comparing them is that they are both consealed items that extend with the flick of a button. I thought the same thing when I saw the knife in the trailer, even though their purposes are completely different.
the final part is just fantastic, Patrick Steward is an amazing AMAZING actor. and I just love Tennant's Hamlet... oooh, how much do I love that verion of the play~
I had never recognized the connection between the scene with the Player performing the monologue about Pyyrus and Priam and this scene with Hamlet and Claudius. The difference was the any pause Pyyrus had he allowed his vengence to break though, whereas Hamlet again, allowed indecision to stay his hand... Beautifully done by both actors!! :D
Once again, the combination of David Tennant and Patrick Stewart is amazing. They are two of my favorite actors and seeing them together, doing Hamlet is......... I can't even summon the proper adjective to describe their performance. Words such as wonderful, terrific, great, fantastic all fall flat.
best lines "what if this cursed hand were thinker than itself with brother's blood, is there not rain enough in this sweet heaven to wash it white as snow"
we have a competition every year (since 9th grade) and I've done hamlet each time because its my favorite play. (I pick different monologues of course)
@AyumiLovesYaoi I was really glad this was made when i was doing my exam on Hamlet. Not too far on and i still look back on this and it has massively changed my perspective on the story and characters. Wouldve made for an awesome essay
1:25 .. can anyone say, "an excess of Phlegm?" ;)
katheraincloud 2 weeks ago in playlist Hamlet 2009 BBC
Comment removed
thatwhichisgiven 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
thatwhichisgiven 4 weeks ago
I love this, but I'm so confused... I'm reading Hamlet as I watch this, and this version seems to have skipped Hamlet's "To be or not to be" soliloquy, but I know it's in here, I watched a clip of it earlier. Have they moved it, changed the placement? Or did YouTube remove the clip? I LOVE that speech, the play doesn't feel quite right without it.
thatwhichisgiven 4 weeks ago
@thatwhichisgiven This might be a while after the fact, but that bit is found in one of the scenes in Act 2.
APileOfDeadBears 2 weeks ago
5:23 - OMG Sonic Screwdriver!!
5:24 - Oh... Knife...
LaresGothic 1 month ago 11
So glad to know that I'm not the only one who thought that the knife was a sonic for a second. :D I'm not the only crazy whovian out there watching this video.
idontlikesand 2 months ago 2
as a visual learner, you saved me so many headaches. thank you so much :D
roxe08 2 months ago
I was sick when this got shown in my lesson, thank gpd its on YT, im ready for m mock xam now!
randomonium5 2 months ago
this play is like a hallucinatory lesson
happybuddyperson 3 months ago
this gust might be the best scene
6noobsaibot 4 months ago
ooh. CHILLS! I have the Brannagh version, its great but I will have to invest in the bluray of this production as well!
tristanchord85 4 months ago
Claudius is like, "Me. Your queen. Hot."
koenan1 4 months ago in playlist Hamlet
urgh....Claudius is so evil!! At the end he's like "hehehe....I am evil"
shredlessmarmalade 4 months ago
PS is so great. When he's talking about how he can never be forgiven the murder I'm like "Oh, I'll forgive you Captain!"
And does DT remind anyone else of Colbert at times? It's been bugging me.
ChristinasMinx 4 months ago
at 5:23 i thought for a minute he would press the button and it would be a sonic screwdriver :D
ionlylikeoldmusic 4 months ago
5:23 Sonic Screwdriver!
Rhimione7x 5 months ago
Sir Patrick Stewart is brilliant
RyogaXvX 5 months ago
I think it's great that Hamlet's speech as he's about to kill Claudius is all done in his head. One of the great things about technology---we don't have to rely on unrealistic conceits like asides as much in film.
antuck1 6 months ago 2
I memorized Claudius' Monologue last year. I know it by heart--guess what I got? 95 ;)
aznblackblade3 7 months ago 3
jackyp1893, the point is he is so deep in prayer that he doesn't notice that, or the rest of Hamlet's monologue. This scene really shows the religious expectations of Shakespeare's day and the irony in that expectation, like TomatoDoom pointed out. People didn't really "talk" to God, they just muttered devout words and hoped for the best.
NewspaperCat 7 months ago
I like Hamlet's reason to not go and kill Claudius there and then. Great play.
sonicspeedx13 8 months ago in playlist Hamlet 5
Comment removed
sonicspeedx13 8 months ago in playlist Hamlet
7:10 for great musical timing :D
MelloPhunkV3 8 months ago
lol i thought he was gonna pull out a sonic screw driver :)
sokmonkeys 8 months ago 5
Personally, if I were in Claudius' place, I would like to think I would have heard the switch blade and then, y'know, ran the fuck away?!?
jackyp1893 9 months ago
Patrick Stewart is the man.
BaldGrace 10 months ago 18
I love that ironic line- "Words without thoughts never to heaven go." His soul was no safer than before. Had Hamlet gone through with it then and there, he'd have had everything he wanted.
TomatoDoom 10 months ago 6
@TomatoDoom And without every single main character in the play being murdered.
umcoolio 10 months ago
@umcoolio except Horatio
slightlyinsaneFTW 5 months ago
@slightlyinsaneFTW which is why he's my favorite. That, and he is the world's most longsuffering best friend.
Perinlyn 5 months ago
do it you pussy!!!
PrincessBootilicious 11 months ago
This scene always kills me. If he had just killed Claudius the, there wouldn't be as many deaths, and Hamlet would be alive and ugh.
Kills me.
Kill4Karamel 11 months ago
@Kill4Karamel That's actually the climax of the play. I know in my copy of Hamlet I have that page starred and all over it, I have written in full uppercase; "YOU JACKASS!! YOU COULD'VE STOPPED EVERYTHING!!! YOU DAMN DAMN FOOL!!" That being said, it delights me to see the progression of death from one single decision. Sort of sad.
MoonInShadows 11 months ago
@Kill4Karamel Hamlet diess?? wtf!! man!
PrincessBootilicious 11 months ago
@PrincessBootilicious It's a Shakespeare tragedy. That tends to mean everyone dies
slightlyinsaneFTW 5 months ago
5:24
OMG i thought it was Doctor screwdriver:)
OH he's sooo amazing as Hamlet
he could "sonic" Claudius:D:D
martitta1 1 year ago 4
@martitta1 I thought the same thing! xD
onlyaraya 11 months ago
when he pulled out the knife, did anyone else think sonic screw driver before he switched out the blade?
idontlikesand 1 year ago 50
@idontlikesand it DID look like that, didn't it?
pinkjaguar12 3 months ago
@idontlikesand right. i was thinking the same thing but i was like. wait how does that make sense but then there was the blade and i was like oh. disappointment.
finalhidingplace 3 months ago
@idontlikesand YEAH!!!
DoctorWhoAwsomness 3 months ago
@idontlikesand Honestly I did...I was hoping...-_- too much of a who fan...wait...no...that's not possible...checks tenant style coat...hmm...sonic screwdriver pen in pocket...oh...uh...Dr. Who iphone case...oh my...oh well Doctor Who kicks ass...and so does David tenant ^_^
Arella17 2 months ago 2
@idontlikesand
i was just thinking that lol
Limecapp 1 month ago
@INV100 Partick Stewart is AWSOME! I'm not saying anything bad about him or David Tennant, I was a joke.
EthalaRide 1 year ago 2
Good monologue help...
Josephdorf03 1 year ago
That was a REALLY loud clicking sound the switch-blade made, and yet Claudius never heard it! Jeez!
EthalaRide 1 year ago
@MajCinematic He played Claudius back in 1980 for BBC, I do not know if he played hamlet, but if he did i would like to see that.
Warlock2019 1 year ago
@SamDeRe81 I recommend the Folger Shakespeare Library copies of the books. It has the text of the play written on every right-side page with translation for the archaic terms on the facing page. Trust me, it helps a lot.
tygortora 1 year ago
I actually found it impressive how much it DIDNT look like the sonic. For someone so used to pulling out the same shaped something for years, its pretty awesome how different he can do it when he chooses.
PiggyofGuinea 1 year ago
Claudius is almost perfectly played :
- just one time, his look is too much turn inward
- his left shoulder is higher than the right one (which is not possible for a king)
- the 2 youngers are much too close to the king (also impossible) and screaming in his ears (bad manners and against the etiquette)
But an excellent actor !
The other 3 are bad :
Hamlet is discribed by his mother as someone whose goodness is in his face. never would he have rise his arm this way with a dagger,etc..
semperreg 1 year ago
@semperreg It's important, though, to note that given the different time setting, it allows room for a different interpretation of the stage actions. That's part of why modernized "translations" (they are using the same words, after all) are so interesting to watch.
tygortora 1 year ago
5:10 !
piratelover20 1 year ago
Patrick Stewart should do a Doctor Who epsiode and play a evil Time lord seeking revenge on the Doctor for blowing up the Home world.
WarshipAngelus 1 year ago 4
there are references to characters guilt through their hands all throughout Shakespeare's work. Macbeth comes to mind... something about turning the seas red. and then Lady Macbeth and the smell of her hands.
Just for the fact fans.
elimacca 1 year ago
gonna do hamlets monlogue on thursday i'm shitting bricks but if I pull it off right i'm guarenteed a place in college =)
Fallenkitten1000 1 year ago
Why are people making sonic screwdriver references when he takes out the knife?
"Doesn't wound. Doesn't kill. Doesn't maim. But I'll tell you one thing, it's very good at opening doors"
Opposite of a knife.
I love how David Tennant knows where his light is. His creepy monologue is awesome with his face mostly shadowed.
HoshiHikari 1 year ago 2
@HoshiHikari
It's true that the knife is definitely opposite of the sonic screwdriver, but I think what people are thinking of most when comparing them is that they are both consealed items that extend with the flick of a button. I thought the same thing when I saw the knife in the trailer, even though their purposes are completely different.
ThatGirlWithTheFangs 1 year ago
@ThatGirlWithTheFangs I like comparing Hamlet's gestures and voice intonations to the Doctor's more than comparing their tools. ^_^
HoshiHikari 1 year ago
Dang. Everything David gets the chance for revenge....ugh. Oh wells. Gotta wait to the end. ^_^ I <3 David!
yanokogarra555 1 year ago
Look out your highness he's got a Sonic Screwdriver...er I mean knife..Sorry.
PHOENIXGUNDAM 1 year ago 7
Patrick Stewart's voice is entrancing. @__@
CaptainToddPerson 1 year ago 8
are parts of this missing?
nintendonut100 1 year ago
doing the hamlet speech for university on thursday...shitting it
AimEh1407 1 year ago
the final part is just fantastic, Patrick Steward is an amazing AMAZING actor. and I just love Tennant's Hamlet... oooh, how much do I love that verion of the play~
LadyNorthstar 1 year ago
the best scene in the whole thing
sondano 1 year ago
@sondano
Yes. Yes it is.
AspiringPotato 1 year ago
whoa Rosencrantz and Guildenstern! These guys can make a profession out brownosing, what would they charge?
markosantos79 1 year ago
Okay I love this interpretation of this scene. I'm studying Hamlet in school now. Which version is this from? :)
harrypotternerdkoko 1 year ago
omg at like 5:25 before the blade comes out, it looks like he pulled out the sonic screwdriver:P
redchick12345 1 year ago 2
i swear david tennat was going to pull out a sonic screwdriver
dannyboy1177 1 year ago 4
I had never recognized the connection between the scene with the Player performing the monologue about Pyyrus and Priam and this scene with Hamlet and Claudius. The difference was the any pause Pyyrus had he allowed his vengence to break though, whereas Hamlet again, allowed indecision to stay his hand... Beautifully done by both actors!! :D
WannabeWanderer 1 year ago 3
Isn't that that evil guy from Harry Potter?
mcilwrai 1 year ago
@mcilwrai yes he played Barty Crouch Jr. the death eater who escaped from azkaban, and took the polyjuice potion to become mad eye moody
Ellonzo 1 year ago
Once again, the combination of David Tennant and Patrick Stewart is amazing. They are two of my favorite actors and seeing them together, doing Hamlet is......... I can't even summon the proper adjective to describe their performance. Words such as wonderful, terrific, great, fantastic all fall flat.
Elspethe 1 year ago 5
best lines "what if this cursed hand were thinker than itself with brother's blood, is there not rain enough in this sweet heaven to wash it white as snow"
and
"Words without thoughts never to heaven go"
brilliant :-)
Keeltrice 1 year ago 7
Wow, Cladius is truly a villain. In my interpretation. : )
Metroid02099 1 year ago
1:10 reminded me DT's visit at the Cathrine Tate show :)
toontoosh 2 years ago
OMG it scared me when Hamlet got his knife out
millie33433 2 years ago 42
@millie33433 Definitely an epic shot there from 5:19-5:25, though, when it comes out.
tygortora 1 year ago
@millie33433
spoiler alert!
MeTsRoCkMySoCk13 1 year ago
I'm doing Claudius' monologue for school and this is really fantastic and helpful. I love Patrick Stewart <3
AyumiLovesYaoi 2 years ago 47
I envy you, being able to perform /any/ bit of Hamlet in front of an audience.
Elanel 2 years ago 6
we have a competition every year (since 9th grade) and I've done hamlet each time because its my favorite play. (I pick different monologues of course)
AyumiLovesYaoi 2 years ago 4
@AyumiLovesYaoi me too!
ninjajimzandnick 1 year ago
@AyumiLovesYaoi I was really glad this was made when i was doing my exam on Hamlet. Not too far on and i still look back on this and it has massively changed my perspective on the story and characters. Wouldve made for an awesome essay
ChezJamesy 3 months ago