As much as I know this would help a lot of people understand the basic concepts of Plato's ideas, you say that the 'creator' made only one of everything and that everything else that exists are just copies of the idea.
Didn't Plato say that they are not copies, but rather mere representations of the objective idea? Correct me if I'm wrong though, I have not been studying Plato for a long time.
Thank you bunches! I am currently trying to do a project for Aquinas and I have to understand Plato & Aristotle first before I can answer about Aquinas. This helped me understand it better than my book, thank you again! :) <3
Thankyou SO much for that. :) Maybe i should have tried Youtue first instead of spending all that time searching around on the net for a SIMPLE answer!
this is good and i love the music but there is a reason why everyone else explains it in such a long and drawn out way. In some ways to simplify it takes away its essence. Plato never made his ideas this clear. this is a great gcse guide but id avoid basing your disertations on this sorry
Thankyou Ashlay and everyone for nice comments. As the video is getting a few views, I got a philosophy professor to check it . Here are his comments:
- `i think Plato uses either '`Form' (eidos) or 'Idea' (idea) to refer to the forms.
- The relationship between the creator and the forms is very unclear in Plato, but the main view today seems to be that the forms pre-exist the creator and he uses them as templates in creating the world.
So hold on, are the "copies" in the shadow world that our senses believe is real? And does our soul, as Plato believes go to the other better world after we die? Surely he cannot sustain an argument as he is professing we come from a mere thought of a creator, is this creator a person? Wouldn't they be imperfect? I've just started A level Philosophy and this is my first piece of work, and basically, I'm very confused...any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.
Very interesting, so how was Plato not a copy? I guess in developing his own ideas or forms you become a type of creator and the immortal soul is a common belief amongst ancient greek philosophers.
nice, but remember, this is just one interpretation, and Plato had more than a single theory of ideas throughout his life - this theory was not necessarily the epicenter of his philosophy anyway, but more like a kind of assumption ("the one and the many" could might be seen as the actual center of his thought.)
a form is more a concept they aren't the same, i loved your video nonetheless
Indigotten 2 weeks ago
:"""") thank you!
yatusabdr 4 weeks ago
i have never thought philosophy could be this simple :D thx a lot!!
MsHotVampire 1 month ago
YOU ARE MY HERO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you for this oh so simple explanation
aSmurray26 2 months ago
I have my own ideas. They are not copies.
rodneyhatch56 2 months ago
Then this means Humans are the latest Idea of Creator !
imranbug81 3 months ago
i doun't think plato was alluding to a creator. i think that was aristotle who camwe up with the concept of the 'prime mover'
jingthethief 4 months ago
this is bullshit, u got it wrong matey
Jozzef458 4 months ago
Plato was on some strong marijuana...
tenseman08 5 months ago 6
Used this for my Year 12 ancient history oral presentation. The teacher thought it was surprisingly cool! =)
reapa69 5 months ago in playlist reapa69's Favorited Videos
Once again, someone who got it totally wrong. The Good is not a creator. It's a form-an abstract.
BlueFireWitch 6 months ago
i've got my philosophy exam tomorrow & i studied all i need to know from this vid - cheers :)
KirFarrugia 8 months ago
Sounds like the Matrix. Did the Wacoski bros. borrow this concept?
CosmoShidan 9 months ago
As much as I know this would help a lot of people understand the basic concepts of Plato's ideas, you say that the 'creator' made only one of everything and that everything else that exists are just copies of the idea.
Didn't Plato say that they are not copies, but rather mere representations of the objective idea? Correct me if I'm wrong though, I have not been studying Plato for a long time.
WhisperWhat 10 months ago
you have to do more revision videos
girlilious 10 months ago
Thank you bunches! I am currently trying to do a project for Aquinas and I have to understand Plato & Aristotle first before I can answer about Aquinas. This helped me understand it better than my book, thank you again! :) <3
Jacquelynex3 11 months ago
You have saved my SANITY!!! Thank you SO much... I was having such a hard time wrapping my mind around the concept.
tooqtcute 1 year ago 2
Wow. This actually helped me a LOT!!
Thankyou SO much for that. :) Maybe i should have tried Youtue first instead of spending all that time searching around on the net for a SIMPLE answer!
DarkMisery113 1 year ago
this is good and i love the music but there is a reason why everyone else explains it in such a long and drawn out way. In some ways to simplify it takes away its essence. Plato never made his ideas this clear. this is a great gcse guide but id avoid basing your disertations on this sorry
justme821000 1 year ago
I wish I could hug you right now.
You made me understand this in a short 3 minute video when my professor couldn't help me understand it in 2 hour long lectures. Thank you so much
ashlay0106 1 year ago 19
@ashlay0106
Thankyou Ashlay and everyone for nice comments. As the video is getting a few views, I got a philosophy professor to check it . Here are his comments:
- `i think Plato uses either '`Form' (eidos) or 'Idea' (idea) to refer to the forms.
- The relationship between the creator and the forms is very unclear in Plato, but the main view today seems to be that the forms pre-exist the creator and he uses them as templates in creating the world.
hillhottinger 1 year ago
@ashlay0106 (cont.)
Your video seems to identify the creator with the forms, which looks more like neo-Platonism (e.g. Philo, Plotinus, Porphyry.
hillhottinger 1 year ago
THANK YOU!!! I'm researching this for a project, and everywhere else tries to explain this in the most indirect ways possible.
gamefan06 1 year ago
This is sooo good! I've spent 5 hours worth of lessons on this and i finally get it! Dude your amazing! xxxx
JobloMaloco 1 year ago
Comment removed
jakesthesex 1 year ago 2
Nice vid!
Which song is this actually? :$
realmen93 1 year ago
This was really great! Thanks for creating and sharing!
egoterminators2012 1 year ago
So hold on, are the "copies" in the shadow world that our senses believe is real? And does our soul, as Plato believes go to the other better world after we die? Surely he cannot sustain an argument as he is professing we come from a mere thought of a creator, is this creator a person? Wouldn't they be imperfect? I've just started A level Philosophy and this is my first piece of work, and basically, I'm very confused...any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.
orangepuffafish 1 year ago
Very interesting, so how was Plato not a copy? I guess in developing his own ideas or forms you become a type of creator and the immortal soul is a common belief amongst ancient greek philosophers.
infamos 1 year ago
nice, but remember, this is just one interpretation, and Plato had more than a single theory of ideas throughout his life - this theory was not necessarily the epicenter of his philosophy anyway, but more like a kind of assumption ("the one and the many" could might be seen as the actual center of his thought.)
emblemOFbeing 2 years ago
me too! please complete the series.
esperanzaspriz 2 years ago
Love it!
Are you going to do a whole series about philosophers?
(I bought some 'Great Philosopher' finger puppers yesterday ... maybe I should make a video response with them?)
Alison
CamperGrrrl 2 years ago
if i get a philosopher finger puppet video back, i'll make 20..I wait in anticipation..... xL
hillhottinger 2 years ago
Game on!
Looking forward to the remaining 19 ...
CamperGrrrl 2 years ago