Perfect Sense

[cloglighter]

I was lucky enough to be @ Glastonbury 2002, and enjoyed every nanosecond of it, but especially this performance

[MegaEvan67]

Just mind blowing, fantastic

[burgersoft777]

First time I heard this I cried like a child. What a brilliant song. Rodger has matured into a very great song writer.

[sanch064]

история это ошибка!

[einrib4truth]

IT'S TIME Not just for America to "Wake-UP!" But "The WORLD!" Please; watch the 5hr video: "Ring of Power: Empire of the City-Full Length Documentary." Although it's 5hrs, this should be watched by every single Human Being because it not only Exposes Our "Purposely" Hidden Hi(S)tory, it Exposes WHO the Lying Deceiving Parasites that are Stealthily Orchestrating the Whole World-Wide Demise! Did you know that the US/Canada are in fact; Registered "CORPORATIONS?" Created by the Rothschild's? UNITE

[SuperKinevil]

pp arnold makes me greet like a baby

[SuperKinevil]

its rare to find a live performance out-doing the original recording........pp arnold has always been my reason for luvvving this,but i got to hand to waters-he knows how to put a band together-fuck me this is fuckin awesome

[EinahTeb]

Those are great lyrics, except that the Arabs kill the Jews at a much greater rate than vice versa. That Israel is a tiny Indian reservation surrounded by 21 Arab cowboy states tends to escape most Brits. But again, great lyrics.

[finner3]

@EinahTeb

Exactly wrong! Over the last 20 years, approximately three times more Arabs have been killed (by the Israelis) than Israelis killed by Arabs. I think the issue is lack of opportunity, not that some Arabs wouldn't kill more if they could. And trust me, Roger Waters is more aware of world politics than you or I are.

[EuTuboSim2010]

hairs standing!!!!

[rodrigodvm1]

And the germans killed jews

And the jews killed the arabs

And the arabs killed the hostages

And that is the news....

[hamdanz1]

This song makes the hairs stand up on the back my neck every time!

[trey18ym]

all of the singers were awesome

[NaFran49]

@cebola5405

What I believe he wants to say with the music is this: Everytime people see terrible things happening like war, poverty, hunger, etc they say "how is that possible", "it doesn't make any sense". But if you think all of this in terms of money or profit (that those things bring to many people/nations) it does make "perfect sense".

[sandermatthijs]

@NaFran49

You've got a point, but my view is that he means history repeats itself over and over again..

[jaymoe310569]

miss pea pea can sing thats for sure.........luv it

[cyberlou33]

The chorist she's PP Arnold

[sefaroth]

this song still gives me chills

[zitam41]

absolutely love this song.....that man is GOD ;)

[wandam47]

Fantasticoooooooooooooooooooo <3

[johnyovhell]

muy buen tema

[labyonnette]

witrhout exception Roger stands alone in a universe of lyricists, noone can touch him for such accurate and touching words. what an understading of how the world is. thanks you Roger

[invectiveUK]

I like Roger, but weird choice of words ,if i was asked.

[sefaroth]

what can I say that hasn't been said: beautiful , perfect ! recording and audio should be upgraded to HD

[Thunderspaz]

she's got some set of lungs on her.

[bcgugg]

If only Roger would have stayed with Pink Floyd. His messages would get across much more easily. Now he puts out an album and the mainstream media say who. Everyoned knows who Pink Floyd is, No one knows who Roger Waters is.

[bigwrench01]

@bcgugg well your right pink floyd is well known, and that is why i and you know of him and we like him so much we get to his solo work. When people eventually get here they will get the message too.

[aussiekeith]

Roger for years has been writing songs with powerful messages yet still very few in our world really listen or do they??

I don`t think so as still the $ Rules the world and million`s are hungry !!!.

As Roger sings, Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense

Expressed in dollars and cents,

Pounds, shillings and pence

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense.

[xfilian1]

Very few songs move me to tears but this is one of them. It is amazing how a few words can do and mean so much. Thank you so fucking much Roger.

[woundedfreedom]

love it! "Roger in the man!

[luanis1]

geniale, delirante Roger<3

[westerntrev]

it all makes Perfect Sense!

[SILONAM1]

1971 ΤΑΡΑΤΣΑ ΣΕ ΜΟΝΟΚΑΤΟΙΚΙΑ ΗΜΟΥΝ 11 ΧΡΟΝΩΝ .....ΣΕ ΕΥΧΑΡΙΣΤΩ ....ΝΑΣΑΙ ΚΑΛΑ ΝΑ ΕΧΕΙΣ ΧΑΡΟΥΜΕΝΑ ΓΕΝΕΘΛΙΑ ROGER ΤΟ ΑΥΤΟΓΡΑΦΟ ΣΟΥ ΕΙΝΑΙ ΣΕ ΚΟΡΝΙΖΑ

[navychododraje]

@SILONAM1 ano,škoda že ti nerozumím...

[EuTuboSim2010]

most of people doesn´t want to see that makes perfect sence ,thats why!!

[underpantswedgy]

That is Harry Waters @ 0:36 - 0:43

He's Rogers son :-)

[sf1942]

wot a sexy voice he has,,,,

[Cheryi812]

Amused to Death: what a soaring, monumental recording. Probably the last album that really jolted my soul... and still does.

[aberdown]

Codepriest said it best.

Pink Floyd is a gift. Avail youself of it!

[naza704]

Extraordinario !!!!!

[marknl25266]

ITS a nice song

[attapattapie]

lyrics may seem strange eheister but will make sense to you one day. Rogers songs are deep and sometime have double meanings. final cut is a great example. listen over and over and will hit you one day how incredible this man is.

[Sevilea]

And the germans kill the jews and the Jews kill the Arabs and the Arabs kill the Hostages ... It all makes perfect sence expressed in $ and cents.

[redwhitch17]

Genius indeed..

[Rabbi1203]

oh my godness....simply a genius...

[rocklake101170]

The lyrics refer to young soldiers in the U.S. military being puppets to the government

[alltherestaretaken]

@rocklake101170 I'm not sure it's country specific... I think it's more general.. 

[codepriest]

how can you ever listen to pop music again?

[jaymoe310569]

awsome!!!!!!!!1

[boxtie]

Portland Oregon @ The Roseball, far better......simply awesome....PP must be getting on a bit.....she sang First Cut is the Deepest when ah was a youngun

[eheister2006]

nice song. stupid lyrics

[TheCanonrob]

tja the best there is

top music

[dio4ever]

I would like to live this day and hear this live performance.

Just amazing!

[salatfrau8]

das beste was ich je gehört und gesehen habe !!! danke!!!

[nospam671]

@chanper"... it all makes perfect sense... Sarcastic, yet true to this day. F'n cool. Or, F'n sad. I still don't know which.

[TheRaf888]

thanks for this song !!!!

[kimrafn]

The name of the backing vocal.... P.P: Arnold.

[ajnb1310]

anyone knows the name of roger's back vocal....if anyone knows please tell me

[peytonnn2323]

the man is such a genius

[Cheryi812]

Memory is a stranger... history is for fools.

[chenper]

"... it all makes perfect sense , expressed in DOLLARS AND CENTS , POUNDS , SHILLINGS AND PENCE... it all makes perfect sense !!!! .... "

[redwhitch17]

Killer song...I love Roger Waters..Genius..

[sohoboho88]

Seeing this live was the most amazing experience of my life

[DoCoCC]

@sohoboho88

agreed, i heard song for the first time in my life, and it was live in belgium.

totally blown away.

[slickwillywize]

die ne arricten

[redwhitch17]

Just blows my mind every time i here this song.

Roger Waters is amazing..

[arnosluismans]

This song, and What God Wants explain it all so extremely well.

[JeremyAlstar]

Dit liedje draaide op de begravenis van me oom :(

[oroedor]

The best.

Waters has the nuts to say it!

Loud and clear!

This is the message that we have to spread!

«It all makes perfect sense"!

[stateofsorry]

Damn Roger. Ever euphemizing...save your breath, wanderer. Save your breath and amuse yourself a little more.

[SkylarkStudios]

You are pathetic.

[stateofsorry]

It occurs to me that sarcasm is a concept sometimes difficult to convey (which is maybe not that big of a surprise). I'm sorry, SkylarkStudios, but you really didn't understand what I was saying. Roger is brilliant. As is this song. I would urge you to try and get at the heart of the word "euphemizing". Maybe David Bowie said it best: "It's the terror of knowing what this world is about". We're in a terribly sorry state of affairs. That's what's pathetic.

[SkylarkStudios]

I apologize, and I agree.

[stateofsorry]

No worries.

[Hulkman42]

Love this Video!

One of the best of all times.

It all makes perfect sense....

[ThePowerMovement]

This song is all too TRUE. It almost makes me want to cry...is this really our situation?

Unfortunately, yes...

[binitials]

The 'girl' is the wonderful PP Arnold, she's absolutely fantastic. Same type of voice as Ronnie Spector. She's worked with Ike and TIna and the Rolling Stones. She's a cult singer.

[onlyme2402]

na 6 jaar ben ik je nog niet vergeten...

en dat zal ik ook nooit...

CHRISJE R.I.P.

LOVE YOU XXX

[Sconz32]

That girl's got a hell of a voice.

[monicauk30]

@Sconz32: Yep, incredible pipes. Her name is P.P. Arnold.

[carlomure]

@Sconz32 why stupid?

[barnacora]

@Sconz32 She is P P Arnold -- famous for the song 'First Cut is the deepest' (of Cat Stevens) -- enjoy this one on youtube -- .../watch?v=oo__EIXzAco&featur­e=related

[woundedfreedom]

@Sconz32 I got back stage "& got a hug and a kiss from her,.. "Kool huh? ;)

[nzchopperr]

@Sconz32

PP Arnold I think

[DonSudia]

@Sconz32

The backup singers are awesome aren't they.

[arsesb]

Waters played this in Malta few years ago, it was fantastic. So was Arnold. Great, Great, Great.

[uglefisken]

The Germans killed the Jews,The Jews kills the Arabs, the Arabs kills the hostages and THAT is the news.... Is it any wonder that the monkey is confused....

Breath taking lyrics that is...

[adamtube2]

@uglefisken

Sums it up...

[Jesus1878]

Una sola palabra: IMPRESIONANTE

[Dragonoffor]

I first heard this song when i was five, and it one of the best songs ever written.

[LabRat6619]

PP Arnold is Awesome in this song, an excellent contrast to Rogers delphic tones!

[TheMagicsound]

wunderbar

[mtatrip]

i was there! eu estive la! roger waters live at rock in rio, portugal!!! the concert of my life!!!!

[GuitarMasterizer]

oh please tell me about it! I was only three years old when this happened! I wish I were there!

[simonecostasp]

FLOYD`S BRAIN!!!! GENIUS!!!

[Crzykjn]

I don't think he played this one at Summerfest 2 years ago. Great song and message. Gilmour didn't seem to go the political activist route with his career, but is just as good of an artist.

[sc0tt666]

joint + r waters = perfect sense lol

[gonzaklo]

Que genio, que genio!!!

Aún así hay gente que no llega a darse cuenta... :(

[funny1986]

Shivers...

[filipinoganjasmoker]

mownkey? is that even a word? lulz

[zitam41]

It is af fact that Roger Waters always delivers good music, but this, this is exceptionel, fantastic. The man is a genius...no one can say otherwise. He was good in Pink Floyd, but even better solo....i just love that man

[munghi]

happy birthday roger

[motley1235]

que bonita cacion verdad da dios

[pianoplayer1224]

i'm so close to tears EVERY single time!iously, this gotta be one of the beautifullest pieces of music in the world.

lyrically, this is also a real masterpiece of art!

[pianoplayer1224]

oh, that's an awfull lot of typoes there.. sorry!

[GtheMaddab]

when is he perfoming again

[BiggyT39]

the best way to feel this digital.. is BUY THE DVD money isnt importnant anymore.. :)

Pink Floyd 4 ever

[MrLoomboy]

Staggering!!!!!!

Possibly...no no ......the greatest rock performane of all time!!

[christinamaria36DKQ]

yes....its the best!! saw him two times live here in DK....total forever the greatest band

[redwhitch17]

Masterpiece....Just blows me away ever time...

[labitajojo]

PP F*cking Arnold, man.

Roger's possibly the greatest lyricist of all time. No one can give me chills like him only with the lyrics. Beautiful. Such a Genius. And I just love his voice too. Coming from his deepest inside.

[sniper71267]

most definatly a genius, and I love the voice of the chick.

[jamo2006]

what a genius....

[inclaudicable]

PIEL DE POLLO!!!

[chriswhitey01]

he is speaking of the American Military/Industrial complex that Eisenhauer predicted.

[dhafer5150]

masterpiece..... Waters man!!

[radioheadoors]

this is a fuckin masterpiece if you understand the lyrics

[sexmachine56]

La voz de la cantante es quasi perfecta, madre mia, que temazo

[tonymaster6]

la cantante eres PP Arnould y e surda ...perdona my espanol

[casperboca]

que tema alucinante!!!make my flay...

[cmimie22]

juste merveilleux

[5melis]

love this song

[luquet1]

Le plus grd de tous!!! i love rogers!

[eurobizon]

one of the best things made in the 20th century's music , the utmost in rock (however a decadent form of art), all my love and admiration

[naughtylicious555]

perfectt!!

[5rockstom]

BRILLIANT SONG rogers voice is not the best ive heard but i think thats original and GOOD

[sanazamiri]

o my god he is for ever

[J0nnan]

God I love his voice!

[mtatrip]

i was there in the front row, and damn how i feel good about being there this is just ..... speechlesss :D

[LeeJHooker]

That's 100 cool points fo you right there:) I wish I could have seen this concert!!

[Rickyzinho]

I was there.. But I was so damn stupid (14 years at this time).. I didnt recognize this masterpiece.

[karanatrv]

i jus love this rodger concert..... can i get the whole video online?

[Drummersleven]

Graham an exellent drummer!!!!!!

[DomRandy]

Just Perfect , no more words ( U Roger u're so so .... ) I liked it

[karrot101]

i filled up with tears each time i heard this live on the same line 'and that is news'

[studbolt77]

sounds like the album name when i read these comments "Amused to death" i am how about you love roger and the band remember radio chaos ? lol my mom had me listening to floyd and roger at a very young age and other bands that still thrive

heres a song you should look up if you like everyone knows lynyrd skynyrd look up was i right or wrong one of my favorites

[lemekid]

Brilliant. Everyone and everything was brilliant in this song. That lady's voice is exceptional for this version. Roger's voice was just perfect. Too good. Rock on everyone. God Bless.

[HolyDioDiver]

Just to let you know, that lady is PP Arnold, she did work with Pink Floyd as well, (and others).

[j6h9p]

shame the double act had to end

[zedrein18]

Wow, and here I thought that David was the one that brought the melodic element to the band.

[JDBeBiiiH]

is AMAZiiNG. ♥

[Thraikios]

I really liked to listen to this while in the army

[redwhitch17]

Is it any wonder that the monkeys confused...

100000*..great song.Roger Waters is AMAZING....

carnt you see...it all makes perfect sense....

[maharajwayne]

Intelectual massages.THANKS RW !

[aplha183]

Having seen Roger's "In the Flesh" show in 1999 and 2000, the "Radio K.A.O.S." in 1987 and "The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking" show in 1984. this video makes me sad. I find my sollice in his latest release "Ca Ira." He has lost his edge as a performer, but still is brilliant as a writer, producer and director. Hopefully if he ventures back into rock, he will turn his back on the audience and just be a conductor.

[thejourneyman123]

i saw him in 2007, that was one of mye best experience ever. i've been on 13 concert on 2 years... he has top 3 of concert, and top 2 as the best band ive been on

[agrymin003]

Alpha, what means SOLLICE.

Thanks.

[plattform5163]

Great song! My best concert experience!

[catafalco]

she is amazing...

[adieuropa]

IT all made perfect sense !

[1PINKFLOYD63]

it dont get any better than floyd, the feelings that are in the music are incredible... love it ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT

[thejourneyman123]

roger waters <3

come back to norway, you were fucking fantastic here, i wanna watch ya show once more =) =)

[HashFloyd]

a legend

[redwhitch17]

im so enjoying this song right now..Roger you are amazing.....

[amigosaurio]

Pero que BARBAROOOOO!!!!!! how is it posible that a so relaxing song can at the same time refill all your energy????? here is a clear example of the famous Mozart effect.

[ecca09]

Wonderful!

[taximack]

Roger is illuminated to the maximum, Is it any wonder the monkey's confused ???can't you see ,it all makes perfect sense

[cduff624]

why do all roger waters solo songs sound almost exactly alike?

[ellezeebub]

It's called a theme. The album, Amused to Death, was along the lines of a rock opera.

But I see where you are coming from ... when I don't much care for a particular style of music, it all sounds the same to me.

What I don't get is why you bother to listen to stuff you aren't much interested in, and then comment. Bored people are boring.

[Freebird1244]

such a wonderful song.

bravo Roger, bravo!

[semtex2you]

ahhhh, love ya. katie, cool. boba. here.hit me back

[11i300PL]

*** zapiera*** dech w piersiach

[Raflmon123]

This is my preacher!

[PdishmonkeyJJ]

ohh.. the sarcasm XD

amazing song

[nightmarejoe]

Richard Gere singing?lol.

[ADyingFaith]

He does look like Richard Gere doesnt he.

[SaturnProds]

one of the most beautiful songs in the world. my dad loved it.

[travelogue200]

Oh, and Katie Kissoon I love you!

[travelogue200]

Tears are falling down my face.

[AgentOrange93]

Amazing!!!

[redwhitch17]

Carnt you see,it all makes perfect sense,yeeeeeeeeaahhhhhhh.?????­?

[AaronMk91]

I wish Roger (or Dave) would come close enough so I could see them. The closest they'll probably come is Chicago.

[crazysalvatrucha]

Only Roger waters! original 100%

[gutamaral]

Como pode alguém juntar palavras e melodia com tanta genialidade? Amo tudo que Roger fez, faz ou fara.

[thankGodforDavidG]

Roger,what a"Rock Symphony"this is and how

uplifting to the soul. and you,the beautiful

vocalist in the center,when you lift your arm

up,and your voice fills the stage with power

and emotion,you are taking us to the higher

level of joy.and everybody in the band,BRAVO.

[jeanpaulfelix]

wow, You're so poetic. Well said. Roger is the greatest musician in history.

Long live socialism!!!

[cdresaw]

roger i love u man, 4 get the past " historys 4 fools " as u say,,,, get it together with gilmore man b4 its too late...............