Added: 2 years ago
From: gamespot
Views: 127,912
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (538)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This plays very well on an iPhone!

  • The OLD ONE was The BEST! Die alte Version war besser. Sie war in DEUTSCH!

  • Part 2!:-O Well yea he playd it, he might have playd it on hes old Channal darksydephil. i don't even remeber. but yea, i loved the character! i loved the music, i loved the art style, i loved everything!!!!:-D So this is a buy for me!

  • And now ''The Secret of Monkey Island Special Edition Collection'' is coming!

    It's a Disc whit Both 1 and 2. It's coming for the Xbox 360 and the PS3.

    Most lily for the PC to, but did not Bother to look that up.;-)

    They sayd ''HAHA you don't get it PS3''. now PS3 allredy have them on PSN and now on DISC. oh, on the Disc we get some extra stuff!:-D i'm going to buy it i think. i playd the demo of 2. and i'm a fan of DSP (DSPGaming) on YouT- and he playd it. Read part 2.

  • the older version is better.

  • loooooooom

  • MAKE GRIM FANDANGO 2 !!!!

  • Das Remake ist geil, nur die Steuerung ist wirklich mal Gay, also ich finde unten links gehört einfach "offnen" "schließen" "drücken" ect dahin

  • I have played Monkey Island and Loom in my childhood. Good old memories.

  • 12:00 listen

  • 12:00

  • this game is beautiful, they don't make games like these anymore! a shame!

  • Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy with the Havok engine (Force Unleashed 1 & 2) would be so awesome...

  • gotta love the music.... <3

  • can anyone show me how to drug the meat :((

  • @xitrumluubang Use yellow flower on meat.

  • they need to make a remake of crusador no remorse and no return

  • The walking looks so artificial in the Special Edition. He slides.

  • i love monkey island is watched my nan play this on the old PSone when i was 3 or 4 then began to play it good memories

  • I'm Guybrush Threepwood, mighty pirate!

  • I'm downloading this right now! :)

  • anyone remember zak mckrakken on the C64? took me forever to find the lighter on the airliner ..that game deserves a remaster so i can finally finish it ^^;

  • Do they have a mac version?

    

  • the scenery is pretty, but the new people look weird and their movement looks less natural. i like the idea of a re-recorded soundtrack, not that i have any complaints with the original.

  • man, what a great fucking perfect cool game.

  • The old game looks better.

  • @AWESOME90002 Yeah right and the original God of War games on PS3 look better than their PS3 HD Remake.

    Damn That was a good joke... or was it?

  • @aquapendulum looks same to me ps2 ones where hell gow1 had a glitch at some gates where i needed to reset my ps3 over 60 times in order to get trough and m ps2 and disc where brand new this glitch and many others where fixed they let the glitch with infinite orbs in tho for an odd reason -,-, mmm

  • Having attractive females do interviews with people for video games is pretty lame, come on, you're not fooling anyone, she was probably a toddler when this game was released and I doubt that she is half the gamer that most computer nerd males are.

  • @Frisbinator You, sir, are a weak, timid, untrustworthy homosexual.

  • @pandehigos LOL!!!!

  • I don't know who's responsible for it but they started with these "fluffy" clouds or the way the pirate in the SCUMM bar is drawn in the third game, I think. I'm certainly no graphics artist but I recognize a change in style from then and I don't like it. I also think that when they added the sound in game 3, it became a kids game. Game 1 & 2 are much more clever in dialogue.

  • Look! a three headed monkey!

  • thats how mi5 should have looked like...

    NO ONE wants 3d in monkey island... it just ruins the feel somehow

  • Please do this with Full Throttle!

  • How appropriate. You fight like a cow!

  • @mrRob789

    You fight like a dairy farmer!

  • this is one of the best things ever happened

  • yeah me too. I dont even think its nostalgia. I reckon the vector graphics look a bit too polished and clean. And of course these types of games are usually gritty and dirty, so pixels (or at least non-vector drawings), suit that more i think. Everything is done on illustrator these days (a vector graphics package). One good example of non-vector graphics is the google doodles or the backdrops from the original resident evil. Definitely more atmosphere and less like a Disney cartoon.

  • They need to do MI3 (and 4) in the style of MI1 and 2.

  • what a great news ill play this!

  • In other games graphic developement is something good of course.. but when it comes to adventure games like this, i (for some reason) prefer them basic and pixely.. like the old indiana jones games :)

  • also ich fand das original besser.

    bei soviel arbeit hätten sies also wirklich besser machen können. bin nicht überzeugt dass Ron Gilbert das als verbesserung des originals ansieht...

    wenn sie einen berater brauchen, helf ich ihnen gern.

  • hm, die grafik wurde aber schlecht umgesetzt.

    das alte Monkey Island ist wirklich besser.

    für soviel grafische arbeit hätten sies also wirklich besser machen können.

    bin mir ned wirklich sicher ob die macher des originals darauf stolz is...

  • I prefer the original ones...

  • Monkey Island 2 special edition was announced  :)

  • Nothing is like Monkey Island!MONKEY ISLAND RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • AGREED! Nothing beats MI! It's completely unique!

  • im waiting for #2!

  • Please come out for Wii!!!!

  • Hats down, people! Let's hope they not only make remakes of the classics but start making 'em again. ^^

  • from 1.3 Mb to 1,3 Gb O_O amazing

  • She should do a remake of all LucasFilm and LucasArts games!

  • Yep! (Maybe they can start with monkey island 2 or sam & max hit the road)

  • @Inshallaah just the first 2, and the 4th one (i didnt like the 3d jump) number 3 was... perfect

  • Great ob

    i´m fan of Monkey Island

  • Monkey Island!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!

  • Great adventure game ever! They should do the same with X Wing and Tie Fighter flying simulators and also with Loom!

  • great job guys! Monkey Island rules

  • the old versoin is better :D

  • So... will I be able to ask the pirate in the bar about LOOM(tm)?

  • Yes.

  • the monkey island 3 is best :)

  • 0:41 - *cry* The original Elain was damned more beautyful, I want her back! This one is just a caricature...

  • This special edition was 2.50 on steam a on monday

  • oh hell. DO WANT.

  • guybrush had no earring back in the old game.

  • Yes but most pirates had an golden earring. They wanted that the one who took it after their death felt responsible for a good burial.

  • i know.

    im just saying, that he didnt have an earring in the original game.

  • Looks good but the old one is way better for the people who played it back in the day, at least it does for me

  • LUCAS fucked the ART. Watch this amateur project and cry: watch?v=3bInZ7_y4Lw

    guybrush is a caricature and the way he walks is just crappy.

  • Nope.

  • I'd take this over some crappy MGS4 or Gears of War anyday. I've played the original Monkey Island about a million times, and now I'm considering buying this. And also Telltale's "Tales of Monkey Island".

    Fantastic work, LucasArts. I thought they would never revive the old adventure games. Now if they could make a Monkey Island 2, Day of the Tentacle or an Indiana Jones remix too...

  • You should. Tales is easily one of the best games this year, and is in the running (officially; people have voted) for best Monkey game.

  • Tales IS probably the best game this year, but that's mostly due to the fact that 2009 has been an extremely weak year in gaming.

    Tales is probably pretty good (I loved Telltales' Sam &Max-games) but I don't think it's better than MI or MI2. Just because it was voted that way on some poll doesn't make it true.

    Of course, I could be wrong and Tales would be the Best. Videogame. Ever.

  • i think they whould of just added the voices i love the graphic on the original

  • LOOK!! A THREE-HEADED MONKEY!!!

  • UNCLE! UNCLE!

  • lol

  • Seems pretty faithful to the original but i guess some people will always complain.

    Hopefully they pick up other titles too, i'd love to see a reimaged Day of the Tentacle or Monkey Island 2 (best one in my opinion).

  • Man, I remember Monkey Island from way back when. Guybrush lives!!!

    This new retro-classic look is cool and the interface is familiar to people who've played the original. From what it appears here, the game looks awesome. Thumbs up.

  • Idc if its not just like the original. Its still brings back memories.

  • guybrush seems out of place...kinda crappy. is this just coz its not the real version or what?

  • This game design is very much old fashion. I wish they'd made it an isometric like Dofus and Wakfu.

  • If that, then it wouldn't be as good as it was as a point-n-click adventure game. SoMI was one of the great classic adventure games of its time back then. The format of the game back then was what made it memorable, as well as a great story. Making it isometric would lose its flavor.

  • Yeah, it's flawed, but I'll take a flawed release of classic awesome over the usual mindless crap gaming gives us these days. Ron Gilbert made a masterpiece, and at its heart, this is still that masterpiece.

  • The hint system is actually pretty good idea as you don't get stuck. But the new interface sux, at least on pc...

  • the curse was my favourite. you couldn't make that one better.

  • Why did they do this...

    The old version looks funnier, had no "easy" way to get through (at least not that easy), aand had just more room for Imagination. That is like a remix of a good old song. And like that it is loosing its heart by doing so.

    Ok. It is not that bad looking. But with this "not this and not that"-Version it gets boring. And I want to see them trying out to combine the items by having this long taken, and so complicated, User Interface and by using a Gamepad!

    Grrr...No good.

  • The hints are stupid, but the art is amazing. I have the game from TellTale and it´s pretty awesome so far (the other one).

  • they should do this with number 2 and loom

  • @soberteddys OMG! I would LOVE to see them do this with Loom! It was already so cutting edge at the time with looks and audio, it's amazing to imagine what they could do now!

    Speaking of which, I can't help but wonder if the Loom guy is still in the Special Edition, in the Scumm Bar. LOL! :)

  • @soberteddys they have remake 2 is great

  • @soberteddys loom would be an amazing remake

  • @soberteddys number 2 is out! )I know this comment is 1year old)

  • Comment removed

  • NO SUBS!? wtf!!!!

  • But as he says, you can turn subs on in the menu.

  • Would have been cool to have the EGA version as well.

  • yea the original is obviously going to be better - one of the best games ever- maybe only second to MI2 :) However it's good to bring attention to the series, the more attention, and $, the more likely future games like it will be made

  • well the special edition has the original built in, you press a key and it switches to the original. although, i've played the SE and the original to the end, and i'd say the SE IS superior.

  • Original characters looks much better. New ones are strange...

  • Compare old and new Governor Elaine Marley. The first one looks more beautiful in close up scenes :).

  • yeah, the new one has more hmmm 'manly' features of her face... agh! :S

  • Slowest interview EVAH!

  • good thing they kept the original version accessible then, huh?

  • yes they need to do monkey 2. my only niggles with MI:SE, is guybrush hairdo and earring. Had they consulted gilbert I'm sure guybrush would be more charming. Also, the music, while nice, could've been done more towards original (f.i. forest theme). Maybe the musicians were to lousy in studying original. And they added the shipyard behind scum bar. The navigator heads eye needed fixing. And hint system is too giveaway. other than that its great.

  • Now all they need to do is release Monkey 2. I always hated Monkey Island because I played the fourth one and thought it was stupid as hell. But then I tried this out and I was suprised at how much I liked it. I'd love to play Monkey 2 on my xbox with the new look.

  • yeah the problem is that you can't find the original game anymore and it doesn't work with most current operating systems. This is a good thing, means I can actually go back and play the game and like they say, you can keep the game on the original content so it isn't really destroying the original game.

  • There is ScummVM, so its possible to play the original on many platforms without problems.

  • but why use scummvm? id say its worth it to get the special edition, i've played the original and the special edition to the end. and i'd have to say, the special edition is better!

  • Oh Yes!!! If Monkey Island 1 is being remade, hopefully 2 will aswell. Such great classics need to be released again onto nextgen consoles.

  • can't wait for grim fandango!

  • I absolutely loved the original Monkey Island games; part of what made them so great was the fact that you had to integrate your own imagination, rather than relying on CGI to fill in the blanks for you (which takes away more than it gives). It's a pity they used the voice of that guy again, as he's quite irritating. The sound of the narrator at 12:01 sounds VERY irritating too. Despite that, I can't wait to buy this and look forward to the Return of LeChuck (by far the best of the games). :-)

  • Blasphemy...

  • then don't... fucker

  • I agree. The original game for the original generation.

  • You're Right man! the original one remain the best!!!!!

  • only noobs and people doesn´t know what is good will buy this game the original performance is better as this

  • 7:38 is the reason why games suck nowadays.

  • So it sucks because it tells you exactly what you could easily find on the internet? This system is actually better than the walkthrough method, since it doesn't give you the answer straight off. It's not as if you have to use it.

  • 100%

    Modern Computer games are spoon fed and easy.

  • will monkey island 2 be remade

  • I guess it really depends on how well the first game sells.

  • in the and of secret of monkey island special edetion it says guybrush will return and that isn't what it sats on the original.

    i hope they make a monkey island 2 special edition

  • I wish Simon the Sorcerer was remade...

  • The intro totally faked me out and faked my friend out when he came over, I was like... um, k, i thought i payed for... OOOOO. And then my friend was like, o wow i can see they really improved it and rolled his eyes then i was like suck it bitch! haha

  • I managed to complete the game a couple of days ago and really enjoyed it. The graphics were really good and it was great to finally hear voices with the characters.

    The only times I had to use the 'F10' button were when I was transporting the grog in the mugs to free Otis and when I was in the rowboat trying to get from one end of Monkey Island to the other.

    I would love to see 'LeChuck's Revenge' remastered.

  • ningun otro juego lo supera

  • i'm playing it right now and what i find interesting is how they interpreted the old version by converting it to a new look. sometimes the characters fit very well sometimes they don't. all in all it's awesome to refresh the former feeling of that point'n click masterpiece. the only thing missing to me is the 8-bit sound.

    looking fwd for more remakes like zak or indie

  • hahaha i couldnt agree more.. i LOVED this game so much. i kept on switching from the old version to the new one by pressing F10 and comparing the old models to the new ones it just amazed me.. i kind of hoped that i would be able to hear the 8-bit sound if i switched to the old version but that didnt happen unfortunately.. great remake anyway..

  • rubber chicken with a pulley in the middle :D!!!

  • i dont like Guybrush hes hair :S

  • That moment when it mergest to the new graphics was awesome

  • They REALLY should remake Zak Mckraken

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • No need for that type of language. I downloaded it from Steam AFTER I BOUGHT IT and it will only work on my laptop.

  • No need for that kind of language, thank you very much. I downloaded the game AFTER I BOUGHT it and it won't work with my PC only my laptop.

  • I have just completed The Secret of Monkey Island on my iPod touch. It took me 8 hours and 44 minutes. Lucasarts done a great job redoing the game. It available in the appstore for £4.99 for iPhone and iPod touch also. Love what they did, swping 2 fingers across screen switches to classic. They gota do LeChuck's Revenge now and more! :) Good Job

  • Ahhhhhh!...

    The memories....

  • Just finished Secret of Monkey Island : SE on my iPod touch. Brilliant. Music is redone. The voice acting is awesome. All the art is redone and gorgeous, but you can go back and forth between classic and redone versions. Zero complaints. Three headed monkeys galore.

  • Anyone ever wonder why the second game is called "Monkey Island 2" when it should be "The Secret of Monkey Island 2"?

  • its called Curse of Monkey Island.

  • Nope that's the third game, some fan you are

  • Okay. I got mixed up. Big deal. sorry

  • 'Monkey Island 2' is 'LeChuck's Revenge'

  • OMG.

  • Oooh, I can't wait to meet Lemonhead™

  • what!!! is it not being made for the ps3???? they never mentioned it!!!

  • OMG OMG OMG OMG. my favorite game series OF ALL TIME is getting a remake! ITLL BE SO FUN!!!!!!

  • Just got this for £6.99 off steam last night,

    RECOMMEND TO EVERY 1.

    downloaded in 15 minutes and was playng 2 mins after the download.

    Absaloutly fantastic, great idea pulled of to perfection. The detail is quite incredible, the voices and art have added to the game so well and made it even more enjoyable.

    hopefully if this does well they will do TWO!

    People are talkin about the Guybrush design, I think its perfect personally, They've clearly taken all the designs and mixed it into one

  • I'm downloading mine now, can't wait to play it.! This gona be my first time playing it. Hopefully i don't get stuck and google the walkthrough. lol

  • Awsum, yeh see if u press H it gives u a hint, its horrible lol, so tempting but iv now managed to get some will pwer and not press it.

  • Comment removed

  • looks like they wanna make more money without realy make a new game thanks i dont like this i think its same problem with the sam n max series in new ugly 3d. i play the good old games its better

  • "Are there any penalties?"

    Yeah, she's not down with the having fun thing. Probably more at home with some hideously intense RTS war game title.

  • and for iPhone too !

  • do i really need 3ghz to run this game?

  • loved the original, love the remake(the art background is just <3) only thing im not so found of is Guybrush design

    no matter the case, Monkey Island rules, Adventure Games rules, and i hope that they will have a return :D

  • Agree the text part was one of my favorite moments in the game.

  • Wonder how i ever found the SCUMM bar without those hints in the original game...kids todays are clearly dumb ;-)

  • i wonder if there going to remake the other old monkey island games

  • classic monkey island forever

  • WTF did they do to Guybrush and the resolution of animation doesn't match the higher resolution art.

  • its nice but they should have made it like mi3, MI2 wasnt that good it had a random ending a remake of that would be nice aswell. But they really need to tell us what the secret of monkey island is its been many years now, we need to know.

  • The secret of Monkey Island is the imagination of a child ;)

    The originally intended story actually ends with MI2, Ron Gilbert left the team after that.

  • Im exited too, but wtf? :P

  • Release it PSN also...I'll buy it immediately! I bought the original version back in the days for my good old Amiga 500 !! It was about 4x 3.5" disks then....*sigh* I miss the good old days, so I'm really glad LucasArts made this Special Edition. I can't wait for other SE's to be released....Monkey 2, Day of the Tentacle, Sam&Max, The Dig, Full Throttle, Loom... so BUY this game and encourage LucasArts to make more SE's!!!!!!!! :)

  • this a hd remake of a fuckin classic Secert of Monkey Island